Knuckles Approves Mainline Mario Games (My Opinion)

[@torterratortellini6641]

0:18 Knuckles does the Stamp BLJ.

[@scanchannel3259]

I like the fact you were confused about the first maker game but approved of the 2nd one.

[@MaliSona]

Yeah the first one diddnt really do it for me, but the second one- i couldnt get off it for a while

[@scanchannel3259]

@@MaliSona I don't blame you (I haven't played either but the 2nd seems like a lot of fun as i still watch smm2 videos from people like dgr.)

[@ThatoneFelicia]

Stop being everywhere bro lol

[@scanchannel3259]

@@ThatoneFelicia I didn't even know your subscribed to him.

[@ThatoneFelicia]

@@scanchannel3259 great minds watch alike

[@torterratortellini6641]

1:18 Yoshi Jumpscare.

[@CocoThunder568]

3D land getting excellent is the correct answer.

[@MaliSona]

@@CocoThunder568 Fr

[@Okeana_Aster]

True

[@BrandonRoyce-bj1ix]

It is so underrated

[@Alapaloozalover2000]

0:25 Phew! Thank goodness my favorite game was approved!

[@Mortimermilan]

0:18 my too

[@gameomer1855]

0:44 After that Knuckles went to buy more ink so he could approve New Super Mario Bros 2

[@JAYFORCE113]

I personally hate NSMB2

[@channel-pd2yn]

​@@JAYFORCE113good thing no one asked

[@Cupcakekyxn]

:(((

[@jadonrohan8892]

0:59 lol odyssey got so many approvements so did wonder

[@SonicAndMarioFan-ds6gq]

I Mean They're Really Good Games

[@Jordan_edits2009]

To be honest, Oddesy and Wonder are better games then other Mario games in my opinion.

[@ethancardona9203]

⁠@@Jordan_edits2009 odyssey wonder 3d world 64 galaxy 1&2>>>>>>>>>>

[@saltendo2177]

Because Odyssey and Wonder are the best of their respective series, at least to a big part of the Mario fanbase.

[@padydev094]

0:03 damn but this game its beautiful i love it!!

[@SuperNickoHarris]

0:25 the one that started it all for me. The music in the first half brings me back. I miss the old days.

[@courtemanche437]

Guys I think he liked Odyssey and Wonder

[@Mahdi12]

As someone who bought Super Mario Maker 3DS on launch and never owned a Wii U, idk what I would rank it tbh. But the concept of not letting me share levels is stupid.

[@straw_hat2011]

Look at you...LOOK AT YOU MARIO RUN!!!

[@MNM_1064]

Odyssey deserves that, indeed.

[@Sly88Frye]

That was short and sweet and awesome! I made one of my own for Johnny Depp movies and shows and video games and music videos because of well that's basically what my channel has become but it's a lot longer than this one because I included the additional details in his responses like the meme text at the end. Maybe would have gotten more views if I made it shorter like yours, but anyways this was awesome! I included some custom ones that I actually made myself for a few of the movies and also included Knuckles rage quitting his job based on certain ones and using footage I found of Sonic or Kirby taken over on some of the choices briefly

[@alanprpic5992]

Knuckles approves all sega games

[@supermario64949yP]

0:59 extremely mega super approved.🤣🤣

[@mariosololeveling]

so much work for him lmao

[@raphanderconph]

0:23 My favorite of Mario 3D game

[@Penguingamerfr]

The worst one

[@raphanderconph]

@@Penguingamerfr you mean super mario galaxy right?

[@Penguingamerfr]

@@raphanderconph no 64

[@cruznayara]

I love the fact you using Athletic Theme for this video, because is my favorite Mario music theme.

[@ApolloJustice-rs5ry]

I have only a few different opinions, like i for one enjoyed Mario lost levels, but it's so stupid, so i get the hate lol. Also, i happened to REALLY love SMM1, but for whatever reason, i REALLY don't like Mario Wonder. I guess it's probably because of the weird level gimmicks that apear once and never again, the game just overall annoys me for some reason. Anyway, great vid :)

[@MaliSona]

Yeah i get what u mean abt wonder, like it can def come across as smth unlikeable. I was a bit nervous at first but ended up loving it a lot, but ye i know what u mean, and thanks sm for watching :)

[@ApolloJustice-rs5ry]

@@MaliSona I guess 3D land was one of your favorites? For me it was basically a single player 3D world ¯⁠\⁠_⁠(⁠ツ⁠)⁠_⁠/⁠¯

[@MaliSona]

@@ApolloJustice-rs5ry 3d Land is def up there for me, i had loads of fun times with it, but i'd still say despite many childhood years with different mario games, odyssey still takes the cake idk why i love it sm

[@ApolloJustice-rs5ry]

@@MaliSona my favorite Is probably Galaxy. It has the best soundtrack in all of gaming, I will DIE on that hill.

[@MaliSona]

@@ApolloJustice-rs5ry now that is valid, now that u mention it, i 100% agree

[@qwert10k]

New super mario bros 2 was my childhood though 😢

[@TheEPICMarioBros2]

finally some 3D Land support

[@MaliSona]

ofc 3d land is so good fr (imo)

[@dexm795]

Oh my my thoughts exactly on SMB 3!

[@Foolbound282]

Looks like *someone* likes Odyssey

[@Backrooms_Francais]

The music is so nostalgic ! And also New super mario bros 2 is a good game but it's too easy.

[@thomasdaly4597]

SMB2 is approved damn you it’s an awesome game with a sweet ost

[@scorpionzero7872]

Nice list i completely agree with you.

[@egilbertson27]

Love how you wanted to approve NSMB2 but ran out of stamp ink 😂

[@egilbertson27]

Also respect for approving Galaxy 2, is epic :D

[@MaliSona]

@@egilbertson27 thanks sm for watching yeah lol i really wanted to like the game... but nahhh... and ya galaxy 2 is legendary

[@DivinePeas64]

Ah, someone who is also a really huge fan and greatly approved the Mario Galaxy games. You have based taste, my friend.

[@MaliSona]

I guess so, but what sets me apart is that i found the first mario rpg for the snes mid. Just an unpopular opinion

[@DivinePeas64]

Oh, Super Mario RPG for the SNES? I can see why, because of the OG having unpleasant graphics and janky controls. The remake is a huge improvement for it tho imo.

[@MaliSona]

​@@DivinePeas64oh mb, massive confusion i did mean the remake i only said snes because i wanted to classify it was that specific mario Game from the rpg series (like with the papers and mario and luigis) but completely forgot it has a distinctive name 😭. Yeah me finding the remake mid is an even more unpopular opinion lmao

[@hvjijc3246]

1:00 KIE STOP

[@SarahWestCrazyTaxiQueen]

Knuckles: Excellent Meme approved

[@EdenLovesDragonsForSomeReason]

Odyssey deserves ALL the approves

[@MaliSona]

@@EdenLovesDragonsForSomeReason fr i had to use the ultimate approval

[@Penguingamerfr]

Nope

[@EdenLovesDragonsForSomeReason]

@@Penguingamerfr Yep

[@AlfredoPuente8]

First Mario Maker is much better than the second, the menus are simpler and we had the amiibo costumes.

[@BlueTheCubeReturns]

Would be better if it still had Amiibo Costumes and Custom Themes

[@coinygaming2763]

Thank you for approving new super Mario bros u it’s my favorite Mario game

[@NeoDarkMarioFazbear]

Mario Advance >>> Mario Bros 2

[@MattatoChips64]

Same, I have so much nostalgia for the Mario advance series. Plus, the only thing it’s doing is adding better gameplay, and more content.

[@jpjasso2002]

Mario advance>>> Super mario bros 2 and classic mario bros

[@imnotuploading512]

I love how you gave Super Mario Odyssey a "Omega Explosion Approved".

[@bigshortstop1931]

Mario 64 DS? It may as well be a different game but it’s a whole lot of fun IMO

[@airbelum]

Video.... Approved 👍

[@josedirceubackes2024]

Knuckles approves super mario maker game styles 0:00 Super mario bros 0:07 Super mario bros 3 0:13 Super mario world 0:46 New super mario bros. U 0:48 Super mario 3D world

[@ChrisA5]

New Super Mario Bros. 2 wasn't even that bad. Especially the exclusive DLC being the best part.

[@Austar7]

I agree with all those, but I honestly really like Mario 2 (USA).

[@oliverrubio6647]

Ok, I’m offended from New Super Mario Bros. 2. It is literally the first Mario game I’ve played and remains as my favorite one

[@Crimson-BH16]

I love mario galaxy 1 & 2 as well

[@humble5287]

Great video also I have a question why do you hate super mario run?? I can see it here 0:54

[@MaliSona]

@@humble5287 so i dont hate it in general but the fact that its a mainline mario game, comparing it to like mario bros 3 and galaxy, i hate it as a mainline yeah. Its alright by itself but mainlins? Nahhhhh

[@saltendo2177]

I mean, it's good as a mobile game once you get past the paywall, but it's Mario U as an autorunner.

[@ReneeWilliams-s5n]

Kevin Fork

[@jennifergranados8660]

The Mario odyssey one made me laughing

[@Ababakau123]

Am I the only one wondering if Knuckles actually says MEME ☠️

[@1530Shresh]

0:35 got approved. It's the first video game I ever played and is my favorite for a whole list of reasons Edit: Holy crap it's not even been 15 min and I already got the comment liked by the creator of this masterpiece of a video

[@PinkGoldPeach23105]

I'm the only person who thinks NSMB DS is the best 2D mario game (haven't played wonder yet)

[@milhanebenzaid9001]

my top 10 favorite super mario games : 10.Super Mario Bros 2 9.Bowser's Fury 8.Super Mario Sunshine 7.Super Mario Bros 6.Super Mario Bros 3 5.Super Mario Galaxy 2 4.Super Mario World 3.Super Mario Odyssey 2.Super Mario 64 1.Super Mario Galaxy

[@miraclemachineakanotfry]

i think this guy likes mario

[@MaliSona]

Yes, no, maybe so

[@Jesus_is_the_addiction8960]

Super Mario world is excellent meme approved? That should’ve got more approves than super Mario bros 3

[@make04]

Good BUT... There is some no mainline game: -Mario Maker 1 & 2, they Are building games. -Bowser Fury is Part of 3D World on Switch not full game. -NSMBU Deluxe is 98% same than Original. -Super Mario Run I don't count, Because It's mobile game.

[@armandoguzmannieves5472]

Nintendo treats the Makers & Run as part of the mainline series.

[@theoci4]

literally all of them except mario run is mainline, mario maker 1 and 2 have story modes

[@saltendo2177]

Nintendo counts Mario Run as mainline, Mario Maker 1 and 2 have an elaborate enough storyline to be considered. I think Mario U DX is also considered mainline for some reason, but it's better to include it since that's the version of Mario U that more people played.

[@D4rked_03]

facts

[@MisterCuervo74]

Super Mario Odyssey vs Sonic Frontiers 👀

[@MaliSona]

Oh anyday mario odessy, as someone whos played both games (havent completrly finished frontiers i just genuinly diddnt like it at all), imo its oddessy winning twice over

[@kubustumor69420]

No! I like the 420 at you sub-counter.

[@GameGearGabe]

My personal ranking Smb: I dunno Smbll: Look at you! You who were once so proud! Smb2: Excellent argument. Approved! Sml: Approved. Smb3: I dunno Smw: Approved without hesitation! Sml2: Approved a hundred times. Smw2: Approved a hundred times. Smrpg: Approved a hundred times. Sm64: Approved a hundred times. Sms: Approved a hundred times. Nsmb: Approved Smg: I dunno NsmbWII: I dunno Nsmb2: I dunno NsmbU: No! It's now illegal to use your meme! NslU: I dunno Smo: Approved a hundred times. Smrpgr: Approved a hundred times. Smbw: Approved.

[@saltendo2177]

What do you have against U that doesn't apply to Wii?

[@GameGearGabe]

@@saltendo2177 The bosses are pathetic

[@saltendo2177]

@@GameGearGabe That's it? They were ok to me.

[@islandplace7235]

I agree with all, but US mario 2 is a banger.

[@Jordan_edits2009]

W for approving Mario oddessy a lot of times. That game is pretty good.

[@NachoManWithThePlan]

its funny how the only one that wasnt approved at all was a game only available for mobile

[@OrbitalFrog_]

Obviously goated, using a Mario 3D land song. (Even if it’s technically a Mario 3 song)

[@alexsgaming1729]

Sega rating all the Mario games

[@maskay]

3d land is so underrated

[@MaliSona]

Frrrr

[@j-m0n3y89]

Bro just casually skipped super Mario 64 DS 😢

[@AmNaZaaa]

It's funny I agree with most of it actually

[@MaliSona]

Thanks for watching👍

[@breezygamesss]

What about super mario RPG legend of the seven stars? These are accurate

[@mikebro4220]

3d world is da best game ever AND YOU CANNOT CHANGE MY MIND

[@MaliSona]

Dont think anyones gonna change ur mind its a valid opinion, i dont agree but def a valid opinion

[@BaconNoobGaming]

3D land my favorite 3D Mario game

[@MaliSona]

@@BaconNoobGaming valid, that Game is so cool. Ik people call it basic but me personally, i love it

[@BaconNoobGaming]

@@MaliSona same it has mechanics that are enjoyable like the cannon

[@Kameron347]

64 DS?

[@iLoveBread260]

Mario Maker was great! What are you on about, its one of the only good Mario games on the Wii U

[@MaliSona]

For me it just diddnt hit that well..

[@ForestCityKitty]

Super Mario 64 is the best 🔥

[@sansthecritic2093]

Forgot 64 DS

[@MaliSona]

@@sansthecritic2093 i was going off the official nintendo mainline mario timeline, and i diddnt really consider it mainline but tbh i'd rate it a solid "Excellent! Approved!"

[@Nathan74357]

“Look at you. You were once so proud. Don’t come back and never return.”

[@MaliSona]

No 64 ds is goood (sure the controls are a lil off) but its funn :O

[@alexanderthegreat-mx5zu]

​@@MaliSonaIt is a mainline and you can play it on a 3ds or wii u which fixes the controls.

[@TheEPICMarioBros2]

@@alexanderthegreat-mx5zu it dosent, the game was programmed to function with a d-pad, it still has 8-directional movement, you'd need a patch for analog movement

[@darkrage5758]

Guess the OG Mario 2/lost levels was to hard for you 😂

[@FanimationStudios-2007]

I get the feeling you like Mario Odyssey a lot.

[@Noname20238]

I feel like its a little too generic for me but its still pretty good.

[@TicTacToeCraft]

​@@Noname20238 How is it generic when it has the most unique set pieces of any mainline Mario game?

[@MoxxySlashSerialN]

HOW? HOW? SUPER MARIO MAKER IS ONE OF THE GREATEST MARIO GAME EVER HOW COULD YOU BE SO CRUEL? wait i reformulate the word HOW COULD "KNUCKLES" BE SO CRUEL?

[@MaliSona]

@@MoxxySlashSerialN ig he just thought it was eh idk he be like that

[@Hudson-o3o]

You forgot 3d All-Stars

[@MaliSona]

Ah yeah. Well i did rank 64 sunshine and galaxy so im sure its fine. But i'd rate that very high

[@malik_931]

0:54 super Mario run isn't even that bad

[@MaliSona]

@@malik_931 yeah it isnt, but the fact that its listed as mainline mario?? Dosnt compare well

[@malik_931]

@@MaliSona are you saying its trash just Because its a mainline Mario game but its very different from the orther ones ?

[@saltendo2177]

​@malik_931 As a mainline Mario game, it is not as good as the others. As a spinoff? That will give it an accurate rating.

[@BlueTheCubeReturns]

Super Mario Bros 3 is the best NES Game ever, it actually feels like New Super Mario Bros U but retro.

[@saltendo2177]

As NSMBU was my first ever videogame, I have to agree with this. Mario 3 is the best classic Mario title, at the very least on the NES.

[@PixelPabee]

truely. a good opinion.

[@minhnhathoanhap4813]

Bro u forgot luigi mansion games

[@MaliSona]

@@minhnhathoanhap4813 They're not mainline mario games

[@Pablo.673]

I like NSMB 2 tbh

[@AxolotlC]

Why was Mario Land 1 “No time to read the list, approved!”? It only has 12 levels.

[@Barnabharts]

I agree wit super Mario 64

[@AllTheNamesIgotAreDumb]

0:54 hey I love mario run! Why?

[@MaliSona]

@@AllTheNamesIgotAreDumb nintendo clasifies it as a mainline mario. I just dont really think that should be the case

[@AllTheNamesIgotAreDumb]

@@MaliSona OK Your opinion counts

[@ShundoClodsire]

Here's my opinion on SMB Wonder. It went way too far with trying new things. It's good to try new things but they did it to the point where it didn't feel like a Mario game in some areas. Also -100 aura for not offering my control style (Y to dash and A to jump)

[@saltendo2177]

Y to dash and A to jump is a monstrosity to play with. How do you not touch the X and B buttons? Also, I say it's pretty fair on Nintendo's part to go all out because Mario Wonder uses a lot of things that would have been in Mario U if it weren't for the corporate era, and fans were hating on 2 and U for that reason. Maybe the next game they can chill with the new additions, but Nintendo's working hard to reach sort of a middle ground in the Switch era.

[@sonicmariopvz2365]

You forgot about super Mario 64 ds

[@MaliSona]

I followed nintendo's official mario game timeline, it isnt mainline

[@FunnyBluethecooll]

I seen this episode of sonic boom and its realy good 😊 Meme aproved ! No time to read a list aprove No

[@MarioFan-xq6jo]

I think you forgot Super Mario 64 DS from 2004!

[@MaliSona]

Yeah i did mb :')

[@MarioFan-xq6jo]

Since you’re here and all, dare I ask that you disapprove of Super Mario Bros.: The Lost Levels because it was deemed, “too difficult”?

[@MaliSona]

@@MarioFan-xq6jo oh not really i kind of just.. for some reason diddnt like the way it felt to play ik it seems like a goofy reason

[@Amine-uj6tj]

NO I LOVE MARIO RUN

[@MaliSona]

@@Amine-uj6tj its ok, but not mainline mario material

[@PenGelatinandDonutFan17]

What’s wrong with Super Mario Run?

[@MaliSona]

As a mainline mario game, compared to the greats like galaxy, its not the best.. like idk even know how its mainline

[@nolovequan26]

I loved New Super Mario Bros. Wii since I was 7🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩

[@MaliSona]

Valid! its a great game!

[@nolovequan26]

@@MaliSona Yeah bro! I got the Wii and the game on my birthday years ago

[@thomasgriffiths768]

I loved the ds one

[@antoniosaavedra8753]

me encanta super mario bros wii melo juge miles de veses y me se todos los niveles y mundos😊

[@Anty_MK]

No mariokart?

[@MaliSona]

@@Anty_MK not mainline mario

[@BrandonRoyce-bj1ix]

Super Mario 3D World is the best mario game imo

[@MaliSona]

Valid

[@saltendo2177]

It's pretty high up there.

[@Heisenberg-bb5fq]

Good opinions

[@MaliSona]

Thank u sm 👍

[@Nilsontargino]

O engraçado é que mario não tem jogos principais ruins enquanto as spin offs tem poucos jogos ruins

[@Jekino07]

New super Mario bros 2 deserved something better, but Nintendo did not execute it in the best way

[@MaliSona]

yeah i'd have to agree it had sm potential. diddnt go so well

[@youyououmf8200]

To me, zvery mario gamesw even not mainlines, are amazing

[@MadMax-ii8gq]

What makes Super Mario Maker 2 that much better than the first?

[@MaliSona]

For me it was kind of just the extra modes and more things to build with, but honestly for some reason it just felt more fun to play imo.

[@Soniquizito]

it's basically the same game with more modes, items, forms of creation and many more improvements... in other words = Mario Maker. but better.

[@saltendo2177]

The variety of new items included to use, the 3D World game style, the maker interface overhaul, World Map Maker, play as four different characters, the Koopalings are added, the Frog Suit, the P Balloon, The Acorn Suit, etc.

[@codezero7981]

no Mario Sunshine? 😅

[@MaliSona]

@@codezero7981 i gave it an "excellent! Approved!"

[@raphanderconph]

0:49 And 3D LAND?

[@jadonrohan8892]

Right here 0:35

[@raphanderconph]

Mentiroso ​@@jadonrohan8892