I Challenged Shelfy with the All-Time Phillies

[@Koogs46]

Thanks to Shelfy for playing me in this one! www.youtube.com/@ShelfyMLB

[@GBRO.FTBL04]

Koogs can you do more content creator 1v1s please

[@Rahh623]

Can you do the braves all time team vs daddy dimmu ?

[@matthewhenningervonada9914]

Umm... You said they had 8 titles? I thought they only had two?

[@adriansym]

@@GBRO.FTBL04its probably the giants with kyle

[@3IGP4PI]

Koogs I got a sweet Red Sox team if you want to use or play against!

[@Clubtropper1]

I wish this game had Jason Werth and Shane Victorino

[@TG-ld8hl]

Or, as my dad would call him, Vic Torino

[@maxrobinson4706]

they need to give werth men’s league power

[@kwels01]

My great grandfather played with Ashburn

[@TheBollywoodBandit]

Thought the Phillies had 2 WS titles (1980 vs the Royals and 2008 vs the Rays)

[@deluxz7598]

They do I’m not sure what he’s talking about I went to the comments to see if anyone else caught that

[@Philly_4_life]

They do I’m confused

[@aguy626]

I think he was talking abt how many times the phillies won the nlcs

[@Philly_4_life]

They won a bunch with the Philadelphia A’s

[@TheBollywoodBandit]

@@Philly_4_life theyre the oakland athletics. Mr.October's rookie year played with them their last year in Kansas City

[@ryansmith7850]

I'll go bold prediction and say Phillies land Hader. He really feels like the missing piece for them

[@MatveiMania39]

I Would Love Hader And Joc!

[@danieljoseph8344]

As a Phils fan that’s what I’m hoping especially since kimbrel left(THANK GOD HE LEFT). Alvarado wouldn’t be the everyday closer and Dominguez is still getting back to his former self. So getting Hader would be lovely

[@natehavlen848]

Rangers landing Hader

[@Votered42]

No shot lol

[@NickNoll-b4o]

@@danieljoseph8344Kimbrel was FINE for the Phillies until they overused him

[@DevonTorres-i8t]

Do one more with Kyle with the all time giants or whatever his fav team is

[@BB9AndRB]

Steve Bedrosian I (want) to be in the game, he fits for a few all time teams, Braves, Phillies, Giants, twins

[@Theguy70052]

Love ur vid koogs

[@edmintorres4470]

Love the vids!❤️

[@sharksfan2041]

I think Shelfy just used his god squad haha

[@WWJDAstro]

He did

[@GoeyVr]

I’m so happy I’m a phillies fan

[@captainelliot1123]

i love the way you did this team

[@mattyd28]

I’m a huge philles fan

[@shealynogara5165]

Yes the Phillies my favorite team😊😊

[@Weekly_baseball_shorts]

As I Phillies fan I can conform that the Phillies have 2 ws not 8

[@HPBazeballloverz]

Love the vids❤

[@Masecase100]

Bruh I’m from Philly they have two World Series wins 😃

[@SilasR-p3u]

Thank u kookgs I love the Phillies

[@gingerale6788]

Holy I’m so early. I just want to say that I love your vids and haven’t missed one since like 1847

[@Diablokoolaid]

Fire keep it up

[@oneshotsports-xi4zg]

Could you please do the all time nats? Love your content!

[@Tim3909-e8c]

Fun fact, my grandfather played with Mike Schmidt in college at Ohio University

[@GatsbyCioffi]

Is there a copyright reason as to why we don't have a Carlton card? Otherwise, what an oversight to just not have a top 2 lefty in the history of the sport, lol

[@R3APR47Gaming]

@koogs46 when you’re ready for the white Sox team build let me know. It’d be an honor to get absolutely shelled by you with my white Sox team build

[@NicholasFranzese]

For sure, I think you should do the cubs

[@GavinOlsen-ll1md]

When will you do an all-time Braves team?

[@TheRealPhillieFanatic]

I have a Phillies themed team right now and I have Finest Harper in left, Finest Turner in center, PS Castellanos in right WSMVP Schmidt at 3rd Retro finest Rollins at SS PS Stott at 2nd Snapshot Howard at first PS schwarber at DH and PS Realmuto at catcher. That’s the team I would use in an all time team because personally I play really well with all of them.

[@DanaShields-v7j]

chase utley at short kyle on the bench and stott at second btw i love the phills so i am thankful for you doing this.

[@michaelrobinson9515]

Next pls do the Astros you better win with “DR SMOOTH”

[@Lo_an]

WASUP KOOGS!!

[@ethankelley2417]

I would’ve swap ashburn for trea to cut down the lefties in the lineup and a guy for the bench I would like to see would be bohm

[@GOPHILS17]

I hope the Phil’s land hader and bellinger and then trade for trout

[@Carolbaciga]

I don’t owe you nothing

[@Carolbaciga]

I want Nicky two bags

[@Carolbaciga]

I’m the biggest Phillies fan

[@LeviGleichenhaus]

If Shane Victorino was in this game the flyin Hawaiian would have been one of the most perfect incognito cards

[@calebpayne7651]

Me personally I would’ve put Trea Turner on the team cause of how big the singing was

[@xXx_MakeAmericaGr8Again_xXx]

And replace Jimmy Rollins? Yeah no

[@calebpayne7651]

@@xXx_MakeAmericaGr8Again_xXx I was thinking maybe Ibanez, put Trea in center

[@Tanner2pt0hhGaming]

J-Roll to Utley to Howard. RIP Harry Kalas

[@ryannowacyk9056]

I liked the wheel he did last year

[@isaacmclaughlin5465]

Ur doing Bryce bad lolll

[@kurtzmann22]

The All-Time Marlins team is sneaky good when you play as them.

[@Pixelated216]

Bro please do the all time mets

[@Tate-4561]

What’s up kooooooogsss!!!! ❤⚾️❤

[@Jollybob54]

Brad Lidge, baseball bits

[@bfrashine]

All-time Mets!!!

[@isaacmclaughlin5465]

Go Phillies !

[@felixwentz5095]

Rhys Hoskins over Ibanez in the LF love his swing

[@shealynogara5165]

Bro said the Phillies have 8 World Series ring💀💀💀💀

[@SiimplyJW]

Koogs plz use the Red Sox we desperately need anything after the Yankees got Soto

[@clpzwings125]

I would just put Trea Turner in CF and putt-putt on the bench for Bryson Stott. I would put Schwarber in left and put Ryan Howard at DH and move Chase Utley to first the move Stott to second.

[@6FTDJ]

putting kyle in left is illegal

[@seththibeau1286]

goat

[@tiyeutley42]

You should have them do their own version of their favorite team! Instead of you having all time Phillies vs a god squad

[@EliHuffman692]

Do the all time cards

[@BennyintheBoothPodcast]

There is a 99 Mariners Finest Raul Ibanez

[@Theguy70052]

Can I play for ur next all time team

[@Tank_prodz14]

I have Roy holli P5

[@SadEditzz.]

Day: 77 of asking Koogs to make a video about Joely Rodriguez

[@rebornk9195]

I thought it should have been Phillys vs Phillys

[@BenSten15]

You should have threw Andrew Mccutchen in right

[@602jv]

Craig Kimbrel Philly legend 🔥🐍

[@Strattbatt]

Nice

[@Solis_was_taken]

I wish Pete rose was in the game

[@ironmorangaming6529]

Under 10 minutes gang. 👇

[@aaH3nry]

Team Record 1. Rangers L (0,1) 2. D backs L (0,2) 3. Angels W (1,2) 4. Dodgers W (2,2) 5. Guardians W (3,2) 6. Phillies W (4,2)

[@JamesPort-u5d]

Heck naaaa

[@TheBeastlyCHAMP]

5 minute Gang

[@jwlionsnotsheep4763]

Day2 of asking for all time yankees

[@arrow_07_]

Shelfy fly eagles fly?

[@matthewhenningervonada9914]

In case you care 1915- Lose to red sox in 6? games 1950- Get swept by Yankees. 1961- has a losing streak of 24 games, longest ever. 1964- blows a 6.5 game lead with 12 games to go. 1980- wins first ring. 1983- Loses To Baltimore in 5. 1993- Loses to Blue jays in 6. 2008- Wins again. 2009- Loses to Yankees in 6. Also around this time they lose 10,000th game. 2022- Loses to Cheetos.

[@Mcwhopper7404]

First

[@nerfdagreat2001]

Nope

[@Strattbatt]

@@nerfdagreat2001he is It doesn’t matter who’s first tho

[@nerfdagreat2001]

I know@@Strattbatt

[@firefighter218]

Should've started finest Trea in center and use JT captain and sub him for schwarber as catcher and put nick castellianos in left. then harper in left

[@HhSs-w2d]

08

[@CarterJames-xt2ew]

I mean they could go for him because they lost Kimbrel

[@lukec6d9]

Does anyone else think citizens bank park is cool as fuck

[@TheBurroughs365]

Phillies only have 2 world series

[@Jeterfan906]

The 2022 Phillies were so terrible defensively that it’s actually good for baseball that they didn’t win lol

[@PhilliesND5]

Koogs... the intro is straight up wrong. The Phillies have only been to the World Series 8 times (1915, 1950, 1980, 1983, 1993, 2008, 2009, 2022) and won twice (1980, 2008). I wish yours was right, though

[@xXx_MakeAmericaGr8Again_xXx]

I’m not an expert but maybe there was just championships instead of WS. I’m new to baseball so idk if the WS was always around.

[@jennifernichols2514]

Go Braves! F Harper

[@jack_spon]

this game is so dead but hopefully show 24 news in the next 2 months

[@thewifflebros7628]

FIRST COMMENT LOVE THE VIDS

[@nerfdagreat2001]

Nope

[@Mr.Baseball_the_III]

Nope

[@bboponyoutube]

Letsss goooo

[@kenm3788]

Yoyoyoyoyoyoyooyyoyooyo can I be in a video

[@LCDC0712]

I disagree with that squad by a mile bro what are you doing Richie ashburn has a way better card than the incongnito one and Raul Ibanez has his S5 TA card and you don’t need a pitching captain for the Phillies that staff is already koogs do better bro

[@pokeleomax1263]

Hi first comment