[HIGHLIGHT/ENG SUB] NewJeans' Hanni sheds tears during testimony at National Aseembly

[@annoyingcactus8862]

Actual bullying just happened to a member of riize named Seunghan, the amount of distress the boy must've felt with all the threats pasted on the funeral wreaths must've been so awful and yet SM still kicked him out

[@lynneloud8565]

Seunghan case is too sad 😭😭 I hate SM

[@aa-bz8jg]

there are too many toxic femcels in Korea. 😭

[@msrazal6668]

Sm should support their idols rather than just kicking them out even when they are wrongly accused

[@soullucy4198]

True but that's not workplace bullying...the case these politicians are looking at is specifically for workplace bullying

[@lisapang1943]

Buukying are from their crazed fans & haters. SM is not the bully.

[@zoesthetic]

South Korea and korean news outlets, are you not gonna do anything about a 21 y.o guy who received a 1000 funeral wreaths? Who was literally bullied out of the group? How many talented youth do you wanna lose because of this toxic culture? JUSTICE FOR SEUNGHAN To everyone saying that it isn't workplace bullying, SM released 2025 season greetings with 6 members today which would've been shot like a month ago. This means that they never planned to bring him back, "fans didn't want him" was an excuse. Also we saw SM employees on Blind being so openly against Seunghan's return and mocking his int'l fanbase. And we now know that funeral wreaths to a living person are illegal in Korea (thanks to armys) so SM could've easily removed them and sued those people but did they?

[@onetwothree8359]

so tell seunghan to appear and did like hani did and stand up for himself instead just say apologize . Hanni just brave to defend herself .need to learn from her be brave n if it makes u uncomfortable just stand up for yourself. maybe others idol cant do like hanni bcoz they afraid to paid sue or hate comments saying this idol overract .

[@vu4677]

Then tell him to speak up and stand up for himself?

[@Westerneve]

​@@onetwothree8359 wow she is asking justice for ignoring her😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Roseaannieloavv]

​@@onetwothree8359justice for what? Seunghan is not selfish like hanni. He just don't want to cause any damage to the members. And about hanni she just keep saying he igrore us, they ignore us. When their so called lovely mother said worse things about them. Lol

[@Hatsunegacha_club]

South Korea Made bullying above anti Japan thats make me sad because im Japanese homeever when i visit Korea they looked so weird at me ,maybe for me IM a fandom too for idol in Korea ,but totally i had feelings even i came from Japan i just want to had vacation in Korea like my bias did on their reality eps,i watch my bias only on their fanbase basically i become interested on their mv because they spread a lot of happiness IM so comfortable of they fan service is mood booster,i know theres a lot of people doesnt like my accsent but at least once i feel being treat better with all memories and song they made

[@marana.v]

Idk why I'm still surprised by South Korea's selective treatment. What about the bullying with Riize's SEUNGHAN? Also, the difference in ATTENTION given to this case and NCT's T**il just shocks me.

[@lujiesun6765]

The fact is in entertainment industry in SK, bullying is part of its culture that everybody is getting used to it. What brings Hanni to the congress is not bullying culture, but the power. These girls are famous and thus have authority to be listened, even with trivial things. Seunghan is not famous yet, hence no matter what happens to him, it will get ignored. Sad to say that but people don’t really care about bullying in idol industry.

[@ltk7309]

South Korea is known for their preferential treatment towards females. They don't believe in bullying among guys lmao. Every time a female idol talks about the slightest bit of bullying, everyone and even the parliament wants to be involved and help her out. But male idols don't receive the justice nor empathy they deserved lmao. So keep quiet. To date, South Korea has never been as enthusiastic to help out a guy in need of dire help from death threats and bullying.

[@shersxtrustx2864]

This is a hearing about workplace issues. Seunghan is a very regular case of cyberbullying and public humiliation in SK which SM could have sued for as he is not a commoner, but instead left him vulnerable for their “gain” without knowing now people want to boycott them. Sadly some things are harder to fix and this hearing only focuses on issues that have barely been addressed before due to coercion and could help improve the experience for new idols so they don’t receive bad treatment both inside (company) and outside (fans, public)

[@Lamia-z3g]

finally someone actually said it, i'm utterly shock at how jaeil's case went down so fast, like since the day they announced he was kicked out, the news did't even last a week i think... this is so sad, sunghan was so wronged, and now this whole thing with hybe.

[@tzuyu4902]

SEUNGHAN SHOULD REPORT bullying too

[@ltk7309]

South Korea don't care about male idols lol. South Korea is known for their preferential treatment towards females. They don't believe in bullying among guys lmao. Every time a female idol talks about the slightest bit of bullying, everyone and even the parliament wants to be involved and help her out. But male idols don't receive the justice nor empathy they deserved lmao. So keep quiet. To date, South Korea has never been as enthusiastic to help out a guy in need of dire help from death threats and bullying.

[@devillove9334]

Who is swung seunghan? And what's his story?

[@rv.effect]

​@@devillove9334seunghan is a member of riize. back in november 2023 he went on hiatus because his personal photos of him with his ex girlfriend and of him smoking from before he even debuted got leaked and the internet blew up about it and started bullying him. he finally returned after 10 months of hiatus, and he was in the group for barely 2 days when the company announced that he had 'left' the group

[@Cartoblate777]

SEUNGHAN derserves an apology. SEUNGHAN was the biggest victim of bullying

[@juyeu]

@@Cartoblate777 dont make this about someone else. everyone is sad about what seunghan is going through, but severe or light bullying, IT IS STILL CONSIDERED BULLYING HELLO?? you people LOVEEEE to defend companies and male idols, but the second a female idol speaks up, they suddenly have no rights to speak for themselves? do you eveb HEARRR YOURSELF HELLO???

[@lynneloud8565]

This!!! ​@@juyeu

[@nai2304]

@@juyeu What Hanni described was not bullying. Things like that happen everywhere. But if what she's saying is true she might have signs of depression. She might need healing time.

[@boratroop]

@@juyeu gurl shut up. everyone knows what happened in the national assembly was a drama played by hanni and directed by mhj so sit down. also don't you dare disrespect seunghan. national assembly is for real bullying issues not delusional ones.

[@juyeu]

@@nai2304 oh there you go again. as i said and will mention multiple times (clearly because some of you cant comprehend words at all) - light bullying or severe, it is still considered BULLYING. you think downplaying their success, trying to sabotage their plans, barely do anything to protect the members, making other artists ignore them (when in korea, it is very much known that they greet each other no matter what, after all it is still polite and professional in their work environment), its giving some signs u should look at. depression is something else, i dont know why you are trying to diagnose someone if you dont know what the person is actually going through! for fucks sake open your eyes and stop being such company Stans.

[@CCCP99]

I expected her to mention additional info about the harrassments and bullying she allegedly experienced at work but she only said what she also mentioned in their youtube live. Her presence at the assembly is a publicity stunt and a mockery of those ordinary workers who are harrased and mistreated at work but dont have platforms or opportunities to speak out. That is the same assembly who failed to address the incident about the 23 factory workers who were burned to death in a factory in Hwaseong this year

[@ashlee4063]

It was because she didn't experience those kind of bully.. Cause for her "not greeting back" is bully.. 😅😅 cause maybe she use to be greeted everytime.. she should address the real bully

[@T4zu.T]

Even though is not a “serious bullying” that everybody thinks it should to be a bullying case, it’s still bullying, and I know this because I was a victim of bullying and, first to ignore someone or to ask someone to ignore them, is actually bullying because you know that, this type of action is going to hurt the person, and you are still doing it because you are doing it with that intention, also to talk sh-t abt someone or a group of people on a app, that is like 100% posible that they can see their conversation and how much sh-t you talked is also bullying, because again…you are doing it with an intention to hurt that person, because that’s what you want to

[@rsingh2001]

KID MIND .. KIDDING THERE

[@none2428]

​@@ashlee4063but is it pleasant when even in your company people hate you..

[@juyeu]

use your brain for one thing. severe bullying or not, IT IS STILL BULLYING. you guys clearly have NO IDEA of what bullying even means if almost 1/3 the comments are disregarding someones BULLYING EXPERIENCE. STOP BEING COMPANY STANS THANK U.

[@ninvelasco]

I’m dumbfounded that this reached the national assembly.

[@alalehkamal6455]

Thats why research is important. This was an audit and I don't know the exact words but the topic given to the national assembly was regarding protection of workers in their workplace like kpop idols who aren't entirely considered workers under s.korean law, especially with the increase in foreign workers like hanni herself who is Australian Vietnamese

[@alalehkamal6455]

So this reaching the national assembly given the audit is completely relevant

[@ninvelasco]

@@alalehkamal6455 I respectfully disagree. The state audit is intended to address major national issues, scrutinize the implementation of government policies, and aid in legislation. This incident with Hanni is essentially an internal dispute with an entertainment agency. What does the state have to do with any of this? For government-funded projects, they should have a say on the management of workers. However, in this case, the state has no stake in privately-owned companies such as Ador and Hybe (unless there are criminal violations). They just used the artists for their own agenda.

[@midapita]

@@alalehkamal6455So i’m confused, if idols aren’t considered employees deserving protections then what are they under the law? just products? like are there no regulations whatsoever for people who work as idols?

[@monstafloppa871]

@@alalehkamal6455 Absolutely.

[@norhaniyahismael5804]

From now on, when someone ignores you or doesn't greet you in your workplace, just go to the National Assembly.

[@iluvquen]

Not you downplaying bullying

[@Estelle-wr8gx]

when i greet my boss they didn't greetings back they only walk 😂​@@247iove if my boss start talking to me i would be either get promoted or get problem lol

[@gumoa2866]

@@iluvquen Uhh no. The South Korean National Assembly and many other netizens clearly recognizes getting ignored as bullying 👆🤓. I think I should get to go to a National Assembly to because I was insulted, gossiped and actively excluded when I was at school. Oh, also include when I meet rude people in my everyday life. So sad isn't it. Why does Hanni get to go to National Assembly for getting ignored while I can't while I got gossiped, insulted and excluded.

[@Niliaz_chapter]

@@247ioveshe said it’s happened before

[@iluvquen]

@@gumoa2866 Do fr think becus of that one experience she's standing up?? It's just the tip of the iceberg. And if you use your brain you'd know that when you have signed contracts/nda's, there are sum things you can't talk about that'll damage the company. She even stated in the nj yt live that she's been experiencing the bullying since predebut and was in horrible situations bts that are uncomfortable to talk about. I'm convinced yall just hate Women. Smh

[@bloom6250]

She has the right idea (stopping the bullying and treating idols like humans) but given her situation of her supporting Min Heejin publicly is the reason why her point is not getting across

[@renren123451]

seems that the solution to prevent more workplace bullying is to reinstall a very special person who can do no wrong after attempting a coup, doing media play to damage other artists, being proud to have originated everything, being a good mother by providing the members luxury with the money given by the company, and talking shit about the girls in the chatroom with someone outside of the label and then the world will be at peace once again

[@nad0862]

That's not the point tho bullying is the point here regardless of the Min Heejin feud the girls should not have been targeted and bullied because of her actions, they are only kids trying to do their job !!!

[@tiffanykim2773]

Good

[@renren123451]

@@nad0862 may I ask is there more substantial evidence of it *reoccurring* other than being ignored? It is totally alright to feel upset! But is it targetted? The members happened to be in the same room when the staff said to probably their team to ignore them, to get back to what they were doing in the make-up room. The members happened to be passing by when they weren't greeted properly. How to exactly prevent or resolve that issue? Asking the staff to meet with the members' parents? Anyone who feels uncomfortable or threatened, should speak up and their feelings and experience are valid. She spoke about it in a livestream with the context of demanding the parent company to reinstall mhj. Not to allow the members to leave, not to sue, not to demand a compensation for what happened (again, what will be satisfying?). The demand is to reinstall someone they said who can protect them. Their words. Once again, what is the evidence of bullying reoccurring and being targetted to a point the environment becomes very unwelcoming of them? The members are open with who they support. It says about what or who they consider matter and worth speaking up about (well, who could that be in the past several months? Clue: not the juniors that mhj accused publicly for being similar and leave them to fend for themselves). We can come to the office and work after conflict but don't expect everyone to suddenly brush everything aside unless all sides acknowledge each other's part in the drift. Have we also considered that the staff, who are considered as workers by law, expressed their frustration and annoyance, them being under pressure bcs the situation that mhj caused? There are also staff who expressed their complaints working under mhj. Yet the hearing is only for? By the committee with what kind of track record when it comes to taking issues seriously? Invited by someone who is a fan of who?

[@yuh664]

Actually there are reason why alot of knetz still supporting new jeans meanwhile the others thought new jeans are just like fifty fifty aka go against the company. But since the debut of newjeans there already some problems, aka the CEO keep promising them to debut but keep postponed it to debuting other idols that the CEO made himself and the one that actually fighting for their debut and actually take care of them is MHJ, and that's why the NJ members can't really be sided with their company bcs the company never really cared abt them and only MHJ that kinda give the attention and help that they needed. Don't get me wrong, MHJ herself is a bad person, but NJ is also being used by her in a way. And NJ's reason of wanting her to comeback to the company is pretty understandable in a way? Bcs however noone actually wanted them on that company, and the one person that actually take care of them is gone. And even when they speak up abt them getting silent treatment on youtube, the company just need to deny it and the media just go against NJ again even tho hybe is known like to stir media up, so a fight against some teenager girls is nothing to them obvi. We actually do need the old big hit to comeback bcs hybe is just a company that's full of dramas

[@iagreewithyou3478]

"Respect" says the girl who was sideeyeing and smirking when the CEO was talking.

[@layloo5244]

Yall are doing too much

[@iagreewithyou3478]

@@layloo5244 How?

[@Teresahkp]

Coz that CEO was faking in public like she cares them lol

[@tauseefkhan7939]

Because she knew she was lying?)

[@RosangelNunez-ls6sl]

yall have that much hate in your blood really concerningg

[@mb6705]

Maybe Hanni should think that the feeling rises from when their former CEO accused other groups of copying them. If she can feel like that, how about the other girls being accused and bullied online because of her former CEO’s accusation?

[@jimcalatrava4136]

Being bullied or hated online by other people or someone you don't know is way more different than being bullied personally right in front of your face.😂 D*mb@s$.

[@GonBon1]

It’s not an accusation if it’s correct MHJ accused the company not the group she even specifically said Illit did nothing wrong

[@ketiponglalongchar6051]

Exactly Hanni the brave anti bullying girl didn’t even care when Illit and lesserafim were being bullied to death due to mhj and new jeans fans.

[@ketiponglalongchar6051]

@@GonBon1ur missing the point , go get some brain cells

[@m.mikrokosmos1736]

@@ketiponglalongchar6051 I mean is she a public defender for lesserafim and illit???? She is defending HERSELF here. What does she have to do for other girlgrps??? That’s hybe’s job…

[@shorthairsuperiority]

the fact that she spoke at the National Assembly ,shows how privileged she is. others actually getting bullied could NEVER!!!!!

[@GonBon1]

It’s not that they could never it’s that they don’t have the balls too, new jeans went on live and risked their careers for this moment, that’s not privileged that’s brave

[@nailaputrihanifa947]

And she is using her privilege right aka bringing up about others too, so no one would experience what she feels.

[@lynneloud8565]

So true they don’t even try to understand the main purpose of the assembly they are just mad that she got invited.

[@itzllz6270]

​​@@nailaputrihanifa947 then she should also mention about the employee who got s*xually har@ssed by her self proclaimed mother Min heejin ☺️ and we'll see.

[@nanao7412]

​@@nailaputrihanifa947 That's rich coming from a person who support MHJ that is clearly targeting and bullying another GG because they think they're copying NJ'S brand ?

[@NeerajKumar-ju2vg]

she said like them other artists should;t have to go through office bullying when their own ex ceo pretty perfect mhj is the one that bullies other groups

[@DUNGSTA]

Only. OK when they do it😂

[@rsingh2001]

CROCODILE TEARS ALL THE WAYYYY

[@p0p-p0p]

Huh, how did she bully other group? It's the other groups' management that she keep on pointing out that copies her creative work. Are y'all bots?

[@GonBon1]

@@rsingh2001hag army

[@GonBon1]

MHJ didn’t bully anyone she specifically said Illit did nothing wrong, it’s not her fault people don’t listen

[@forevermoa9378]

I think it’s good that she speaks up about injustice but it could have been handled differently by others. Bc the ex ceo being back is also an injustice to other idols. I’m just sad that it’s only New Jeans that speaks up and get the opportunity while other idols who have been through much worse don’t get the light of day. But I think Hani gives them light by representing everything she can to court. The problem seems to be big as many are involved. There were even evidence that couldn't be made public bc of how bad it was and contactal reasons

[@msqaengineer]

Because no idol complained it to government to take action. We bunnies tried hard to get justice and give her a platform to get justice. I want other idols who went through this type of bullying to come up and speak for themselves. Justice can be accessed when you raise your voice. Fandoms must if you idol is going through bullying and when the company is not taking action pls complain. Wonyoung and kang Daniel also took action for their bullying and cyber bullying and misinformation spread by KZbinr. If your idol got bullied and has evidence pls complain and raise awareness to the issue .

[@emilylee9894]

​@@msqaengineerThe only bullying seen here was that which Hanni committed against this new manager who has done nothing wrong. 🙄🤔🥱

[@riskyriskywikiwiki]

​@@emilylee9894this person litterally undermined and mocked her experience on camera she's litterally mentioned how its not just "ignoring" But the company has made it very clear that they hate the group also if your gonna say " They deserve tthey support mhj" First of all BSH LET them under mhj being well aware of her past endeavours. Second of all the first ignoring incidence was revealed even before they ever spoke out about supporting mhj ( during mhj's First press conference)

[@chenles]

@@emilylee9894”done nothing wrong” she’s the same ceo who covered up an employee’s death who’s the bad one here?

[@angelicaeclevia8566]

they can complain? it's not that hard.

[@kavr-ek7xt]

5:23 I really understand that she was hurt or bullied there ,no one should go through that in their work place,but her blunt way of saying that the CEO has not done anything speaks volumes,with the current situation of their grp and company ,it does not sit right at all

[@MarianNelms-id9ye]

She has been very rude from the onset when she DEMANDED CEO to be fired and MHJ reinstated as CEO. Was MHJ doing the talking? It sounds like it.

[@Hannie_meena]

this happened when Min Hee Jin was the CEO

[@Sweetdailycup]

@@MarianNelms-id9yedid you see the way she looked at the CEO Kim at the assembly, very disrespectful! I feel very bad for CEO Kim. Mhj and nj look like lunatics

[@nancyshiver9165]

Not speaking to someone is not bullying and it speaks volumes that they can only come up with that!

[@Teresahkp]

The CEO seems so FAKE lol She ain't even helping Hanni 100%

[@Jay-np3hx]

If getting the cold shoulder and ignored is bullying, then my wife bullies me every day.

[@hamu8482]

😂😂😂

[@ketiponglalongchar6051]

😂

[@ketiponglalongchar6051]

And Hanni the brave anti bullying girl didn’t even care when Illit and lesserafim were being bullied to death due to mhj and new jeans fans.

[@vee.3029]

Look at all these teenage girls who stan bgs show their misogyny to hann

[@Visibility-Invisibility]

@@Jay-np3hx 😂😂

[@amalhope2528]

I showed this to my lawyer cousin, he laughed so hard.

[@Princesssgay]

Let him laugh all he wants

[@minyoonkey5437]

I would too if I was in his place

[@ltk7309]

South Korea is known for their preferential treatment towards females. They don't believe in bullying among guys lmao. Every time a female idol talks about the slightest bit of bullying, everyone and even the parliament wants to be involved and help her out. But male idols don't receive the justice nor empathy they deserved lmao. So keep quiet. To date, South Korea has never been as enthusiastic to help out a guy in need of dire help from death threats and bullying.

[@Speaknowwww77]

@@minyoonkey5437that’s why momo sings like a dying goat

[@ning_exe]

​@@Speaknowwww77 at least twice aren't disbanding💋

[@Cartoblate777]

Not getting a "good morning" back is workplace bullying...... wah I feel bad for the people who ACTUALLY gets bullied in their workplace

[@MILK_LOVE_23.5]

She talk about that too of u watch it carefully

[@pasta-bv2in]

i hope u think again abt what u just wrote, they are all basically children!!! can u imagine what they actually might be going through, there is so much more to this entire fiasco than what we are seeing right now

[@amyw1715]

@@Cartoblate777 she never said she didn’t a good morning back, people really don’t listen do they… one day if a manager tells other colleagues to ignore you, hope you won’t change your mind and feel bad for yourself

[@lynneloud8565]

I don’t think that Hanni is really bad person that’s she would ignore Illit members so of course she greeted them but that manager who tells the members to ignore Hanni in front of her was completly direspectful she could have said it when Hanni left but still said it in front of her face and that’s not OK, if the situation was reversed and Newjeans manager had told the members to ignore Illit in front of them you guys would have thrown a lot a hate to Newjeans calling them evil and pittying Illit so please be fair

[@MILK_LOVE_23.5]

@@pasta-bv2in exactly she just turned 20 few days ago and we all know the amount of hate nwjns getting is so insane.

[@lindas5511]

This is so so sad and kind of silly. Maybe Hanni should think about this. The world is a difficult place if you think everything revolves around you and that everyone you meet has to treat you in a special way. Not everyone who meets you has to praise or even like you especially if they feel that they have been the target of hateful actions from those around you.

[@Nollugs5111]

What Hanni knows about REAL bullying?🙄🙄

[@none2428]

But it's bulling too? Or if bulling don't hurt you physically then it should be OK? Everyone cases should be speaking up..

[@GonBon1]

@@Nollugs5111bullying is bullying no matter how severe

[@aquaaria3489]

I hope you don’t get to have people behind your back bad mouthing you and telling others to ignore you… It’s like you haven’t heard sht she said.

[@bangtan4ami]

“maybe hanni should think about this” you aren’t in her position to know what she’s going through first hand… there’s a difference between just plainly not likely someone and actually disrespecting and mistreating them in work. she’s mentioned how they treat her and her group and that’s why she’s here today.

[@Alex-hf6vj]

Illit almost had a black ocean because of the drama MHJ started against them yet no one cares about the bullying done to them? Their group has minors too that share the same age as newjeans members but apparently being ignored is worse than openly being harassed everywhere like illit/LSF.

[@tripleSSupremacy]

Hanni has been my bias but from now on, she's no longer my bias because ILLIT (another fav group of mine) is getting hated because of her (and NJ). I love Hanni but she has made (and still making without regret) a lot of mistakes 1. willingly taking part as MHJ's puppet 2. embarrassing herself by complaining about workplace bullying and mistreatment at the parliament while she's merely ignored (but CCTV shows that ILLIT members did greet her) Sorry Hanni, I love you and I tried to forgive your actions but you're too much girl. You should reflect your own actions and get some education.

[@tripleSSupremacy]

Hanni... You are the first one among my biases who greatly disappoints me. Why are you hating ILLIT? They did no harm to you. In fact, they are the ones getting hated because of you. If you learn to be good to them in the future, I will re-accept you as my bias.

[@tripleSSupremacy]

Hanni is embarrassing herself by complaining about mistreatment while NJ will not get this far without HYBE's support and promotions (not siding with HYBE; they are an evil corporation but what Hanni complained is very wrong) I acknowledge Hanni can sing and dance. She's very pretty and lovable (until this) but apart from this she's nothing special (so does other NJ members) They get to the top of the charts, became top gg, get a lot of brand deals and became rich in a very undeserving way. In fact, NJ might even be one of the most overrated groups.

[@aquaaria3489]

I love how illiterate you all are… She kept mentioning a manager and other employees inciting other Hybe idols to ignore her. Now, y’all are hating on her because other stupid illiterate people on the internet are being cyber bullies. Something she has nothing to do with it as she kept calling out Hybe employees. Y’all are no different.

[@SomyaSharma-d2k]

​@@tripleSSupremacyyou were never her fan you people don't know a thing u don't care about anyone and illit your fav funny because getting black ocean is common gidle to twice every gg face it you cannot blame it to oppa loving fans who only attend to see boy groups without researching it go on and blame new jeans groups like gidle I've have received blackocean so either learn a lill about kpop korean fans then talk

[@cia0101581]

What did I just witness! You have to be kidding me - and the award goes to Hanni.

[@theymakefunofmyname-qz4dq]

Give her an oscar already... what pure acting

[@ashlee4063]

I greeted my boss but he didn't greet me back.. should I also go to national assembly?? 😁

[@Enaeve_pop]

Oscar? She needs to disband

[@xoxo-zx2je]

​@@ashlee4063 sure you should. Lol

[@rsingh2001]

Award for the best actress 2024 goes to Min Hee-jin and Pham Hanni

[@lona234]

Honestly, I feel so bad for the new CEO. Imagine coming into a new position and needing to handle the tensions place from a former CEO. And in one of your artists' complaints, there is no evidence. I dont believe the new CEO told her to let it go because she doesn't believe her, but because an argument with baseless claims can not truly be rectified, it would all be a matter of hearsay. But even if the situation is true and the supposed manager of Illit told the girls to ignore her, would it not be valid considering Min Hee Jin at the time was publicly attacking Illit and Source Music. Im not trying to dismiss Hanni's claims but to bring an issue so trivial to such a high place (without evidence ). It honestly seems very unwise, almost as if these girls have become senseless puppets to someone else's plan 👀.

[@ketiponglalongchar6051]

Exactly

[@D10S.777]

The CEO herself admitted she couldve done more. You are funny.

[@lona234]

@@D10S.777 she only said this after seeing Hanni's reaction which honestly is a bit melodramatic

[@rftg1793]

Thank you for this!!!

[@lynneloud8565]

​@@D10S.777Fr like they didn’t even listen to the assembly they just want to hate Hanni

[@sakura0495]

TBH I'm more sad for Kim Joo Young. I mean, she's not the CEO at that time. So why didn't they raise it before MHJ was replaced when this already happened during her term. Why now? And what does Hanni want her to do when she tried her best to acquire the footage. Fist fight with the manager? Without proof? Gahd, it's too much drama. Fromis_9 can't even.... crying to gain sympathy..like their mom. But when the new CEO cried they accused her of making them look bad.

[@raisinmancereal]

Feel bad for the CEO who is cancelling Newjeans' planned future activities and clearly not supporting Ador's only artist. Again, too many odd comments in the comment section...

[@vantae1306]

@@raisinmancerealbut the question is why did they raise it after the ceo got replaced, Cuz clearly if hanni was much closer with mhj she would have told her directly

[@raisinmancereal]

@@vantae1306 It’s possible she did bring it up to MHJ, but MHJ was forced out, so how can she help?

[@sakura0495]

@@raisinmancereal cancelling? Are they even working if there is no MHJ? The ceo who’s cancelling newjeans is definitely MHJ.

[@sakura0495]

@@raisinmancereal mhj was removed august, they said the ignoring thing happened in june. The new ceo is only an internal director back then.

[@UmehChimdebelem-vm3rr]

BTS was bullied throughout their career,death wreaths were sent to suga recently and another death wreaths sent to riize idol but someone is crying because she was ignored..i bet all the people i ignore in my place of work would be suing me right now...please what is this world turning.

[@rush_xoxo]

Oh my God. Did Hanni ever say they shouldn't stand up for themselves. Those idols CHOSE to brush it off. And Idk if you guys are just to blinded to see that she mentioned THREE incidents and also stated that the reason she's here is because she does not want it to happen to any other person...???

[@nothingnothing6036]

@@rush_xoxo so, where is the evidences? Without evidences, this all is bla bla bla. The reason she's here is to gain sympathy from the public. She avoid from being to the court becuase she knows she gonna lose the case. So, she took advantage of Korean media outlets. Making up stories. Crocodile tears. Same like MHJ aka the professional scammer.

[@yjmiccheck5452]

shut uppp this is not about BTS

[@rush_xoxo]

@@yjmiccheck5452 REAL. Armies are the biggest attention seekers I've ever seen.

[@evajain430]

​@@yjmiccheck5452 it's totally not but that's a pretty good example as they're from the same company the point here is ppl have suffered worse than just being ignored and crying about it on national assembly or whatever it is they're just making a big deal out of it just a lil fame game

[@juuviyosramyeonz]

By no means am i undermining workplace mistreatment but issues regarding Taeil, Seunghan and the resurfaced burning sun scandal very much deserve to be addressed the same way just as seriously. MJH dug this pit and pushed NJ into it and the whole world knows it except NJ themselves. She burned bridges with everyone NJ could possibly reach out for help on purpose.

[@h33ki]

this is actually such a tone deaf comment because taeil’s situation is rape …. tf does that have to do with labor rights ? he is literally under investigation tf is the nation assembly going to do. what’s frustrating about people like you is that you comment on things you know nothing about. hanni wasn’t randomly summoned to this hearing. their korean fanbase for newjeans petitioned to this court with a 17 paged paper explaining their case and desire for newjeans & hybe to appear. the fans gave this opportunity to her! also, for you to bring up seunghan is ridiculous because he was kicked out 3 days ago ….. why would he or riize appear on this court when that shit just happened? stop using other mistreatment cases to downplay what newjeans is going through.

[@juuviyosramyeonz]

@@h33ki wow i never downplayed anything newjeans went through and only said other situations could have been taken just as seriously. I've always supported the girls and was only against MJH. Pretty sure you're against her too.

[@h33ki]

@@juuviyosramyeonz i’m siding with newjeans and recognize the sabotage & mistreatment they have caused since debut. any beef that mhj had with hybe should not have trickled down to the girls and honestly people like you don’t condemn them enough for it.

[@juuviyosramyeonz]

@@h33ki girl WHAT I've blatantly put out that I fully support the girls and I'm against MJH. If you reread my first comment I've said that MJH dug a pit for NJ on purpose and burned bridges with anyone they could seek help from when things go south. I don't wanna fight with you about this when we both share the same thoughts

[@h33ki]

*the mistreatment and sabotage HYBE has caused

[@crazysodan7934]

I really don't get it why they call it bullying when the actual bullying happens to seunghan.

[@ltk7309]

It's sad that most don't care about bullying when it happens to males. However, every time a female idol talks about the slightest bit of bullying, everyone and even the parliament wants to be involved and help her out. But male idols don't receive the justice nor empathy they deserved lmao. So keep quiet. To date, South Korea has never been as enthusiastic to help out a guy in need of dire help from death threats and bullying.

[@2020-l4y]

Holy shit you people are slow. He got kicked out of a group bc he was dating someone, something not allowed by his contract. Boo fucking hoo. You want people to talk about it? Tell him to go to nations government. Stop calling Hanni selfish when she’s not a pussy and is able to stand up for what is right and for her fellow members as well. This is a young girl calling out disrespectful and hateful behavior, literally under the definition of bullying, managers telling their group to ignore newjeans, being isolated. She’s standing up for herself and her group? Why can’t Seunghan do that? Why can’t Hanni? What you don’t realize is this is a sure fire way to change the way people respect idols rights, inadvertently helping Seunghan. Why you lot have to baby male idols so much, I don’t fucking know. This is a young girl standing up for herself, and all you can do is call her dramatic? Then what is Seunghan? Let me use your ideology: he knew what he was getting into when he became an idol, why did he get into a relationship? He knew as an idol people would be commenting on him as a public figure, so why should I feel bad for him? He brought it upon himself right? That’s how you people sound every time you put down Hanni for standing up herself and her group. I don’t see Seunghan up there? Why is everyone crying for him? Why is everyone demonizing Hanni? Is she supposed to stay quiet and get over it like every other idol? Is that why you’re upset? Because she’s actually saying something?

[@2020-l4y]

⁠@@ltk7309 Goo Hara? Sulli? Are you being serious right now with this statement? How about all of the sexual deepfakes being made of female idols that nobody wants to talk about? This is the first time we’ve ever actually seen a case like this taken to Korean government. So I don’t know why you’re acting like women have had some sort of upper hand for the longest time. As if Jennie, Lisa, Irene (who literally got bullied by bitter men on the internet for reading a feminist book), Hwasa, Kristin, Jihyo, Tzuyu, and more didn’t all experience bullying for their weight, beliefs, and outward appearance. When are women ever taken seriously? Why are you babying male idols so much? Truly explain. Why are you acting as if it’s always female idols that get to stand up for themselves? Maybe there’s a correlation with the fact that all you people do is hate on them. Boo fucking hoo.

[@haeringoyangi]

She literally explained how she’s also speaking out for other idols

[@crazysodan7934]

@haeringoyangi seunghan is not the same scenario as hers. Seunghan is bullied by his fans for dating. Totally different case.

[@danself34]

They should put she in a kdrama she acts well, there are others who are truly being bullied and no one is helping them, because actors like her..🙄😕

[@ketiponglalongchar6051]

Ikr. Hanni the brave anti bullying girl didn’t even care when Illit and lesserafim were being bullied to death due to mhj ans new jeans fans.

[@junyc_hi3196]

I agree that a lot of Kpop idols have faced worse things, but they have not been vocal about it openly and if it is brought up it’s usually already to late.. it’s already confirmed about mistreatment in the company multiple times and now these young girls openly speak about theirs to prevent it from worsening. Why speak Ill about these girl? :/

[@Niliaz_chapter]

they were going through a lot

[@Niliaz_chapter]

@@ketiponglalongchar6051they were dealing with things too their manager got exposed that can look bad for them that’s probably what they were thinking and they were probably groomed that can ruin a child

[@solonar87]

haha again comment from a bts trash fan , dont hide :D

[@shinagi6807]

This is so weird... did we just spend 7 minutes talking about not being given a hello back and for the company not kissing the floor they walk in after everything they have done???? And in the meantime, another kpop idol was bullied out of the group AGAIN! what the heck is this? The best part was the crying with no tears how she didn't mention that she brought this up when mhj was the ceo and nothing was done and that she was a director at the time, she just called her ceo. You know what don't worry hanni none of the artist from the past or the future will ever come up to talk about something like this ever, thanks for your sacrifice.... Honestly if I was to take to the court everyonr that didn't say hello back, dislike me or didn't praise me at work I don't know if they will be an end to it, it just makes you feel as if they have never experienced any hardshipd if this the reason why you take someone to the national assembly for and there is no way this is the case but honestly this whole New jeans mhj drama is becoming pathetic I don't wanna know anything else, is getting weird.

[@hansung5118]

Oh my god ur so stupid, did u miss the part where they were literally trying to sabotage their career?? And not greeting back or telling others to ignore them is first - SUPER disrespectful in korea and second, a very common form of bullying by those who have more power and third, absolute inhumane treatment. You seemingly can’t comprehend how much impact workplace bullying can have on someone, or even just people acting cold / hostile towards you. Especially in an industry like that, where they already go through SO much shit, and other idols do too, but they do it quietly because NO ONE ever speaks up, and that’s why it'll NEVER change bruhhh. These girls have no one to turn to so of course they’re gonna try whatever they can, be it a court appearance or whatever. It doesn’t matter if mhj is a bad person, she is the only one that actually helps them, be it out of her own greed or not💀💀💀

[@locomoco7141]

BULLYING IN A COMPANY BECOMES TOXIC. SHE JUST STATED WHAT HAPPENED TO HER WHICH WAS CLASSIC TOXIC BEHAVIOR BY ANOTHER GROUP'S MANAGER. IF YOU DON'T PUT A STOP TO THESE TYPES OF TOXIC BEHAVIOR NOBODY WILL WANT TO WORK FOR THAT COMPANY OR BE AROUND TOXIC PEOPLE. THINK ABOUT IT HOMIE

[@Truthshouldbetold25]

​​@@locomoco7141how funny.... her mother figure made other group helll,,, she did not find that bullying or absurd but someone prevent say hello to hanni.. Hanni found that bullying... Hybe is Corporation every person here pay mental or physical labor to earn fame and money dont compare it with family... Corporate world will never become your family... Educate your self dont comment like your idol who even does not know the real defination of bully

[@btsimagine7506]

Exactly

[@jiminpark-jl1cc]

That's the difference between she having self respect and dignity.... And you don't

[@DimiDayman]

MHJ has not done these young girls any favours she is manipulating and using them for her own gain, however bullying in a workplace is unacceptable

[@livinglife1442]

My God it's so embarrassing🥲

[@ltk7309]

South Korea is known for their preferential treatment towards females. They don't believe in bullying among guys lmao. Every time a female idol talks about the slightest bit of bullying, everyone and even the parliament wants to be involved and help her out. But male idols don't receive the justice nor empathy they deserved lmao. So keep quiet. To date, South Korea has never been as enthusiastic to help out a guy in need of dire help from death threats and bullying.

[@ZeryaZayci]

I don’t think so for me your are embarrassing

[@DearlyBeloved652]

But she openly supported Min Heejin's bullying of idols, even her own parents publicly bullied idols and Hybe employees and she didn't try to ask her own fandom to stop the bullying they are known for because it all benefits her. The hypocrisy and entitlement she shows is alarming and the tears are straight out of Min Heejin's guide for media manipulation. She just made her acting debut and chastised the CEO for not having enough evidence to legally punish an employee to her satisfaction. The entitlement is real. Where is the evidence of bullying at Hybe? She was called for that and gave nothing. If it was for all of kpop, they should have called other idols who actually experienced bullying. But they would include the victims of Min Heejin who Hanni supports and her fandom, so this was supposed to be about Hybe alone, but no one ever thinks they should present actual evidence against them. They just make accusations and cry for the camera to save Min Heejin and the group after breaking contract and blackmailing the company. EDIT: Getting all my replies deleted shows who is getting paid to troll comments and for who. Smh

[@rftg1793]

The stickers on their laptops said everything we need to know… everything was totally biased

[@koalakoalakoo]

what? How did Min Heejin bullied other idols? Her own parents bullied other idols and employees? Where did that come from? Can I have the source or proof of where that happened?

[@kanch0]

Spreading lies here, I see

[@itzllz6270]

Lmfao Ikr? And the 2 idiots in this comment section got groomed by min heejin as well I see. Congrats pixels.

[@raisinmancereal]

Good to see more HYBE trolls in the comment section. Hope you get a raise with that amazing comment.

[@ronintiger]

Guys today a stranger on the street didn’t greet me back after I said Good Morning. I am thinking of going to Washington DC and reporting this issue to President Biden at Congress. Wish me luck!

[@ken2063]

Wow, the level of disrespect. What is the world coming to?? Sue him or her for millions Queen!! 😆

[@aquaaria3489]

No, it should go like this. You’re going to work and you greet your colleagues, but they don’t greet you back because other colleagues have told them not to great you. It happens again and again, and now you’re completely isolated and have no one to talk to. There, fixed it for you.

[@ken2063]

@@aquaaria3489 1. They are not colleagues. Two different labels. 2. They did greet back apparently in one encounter they ever had ever. 3. There's no proof or evidence that happening again and again. Because they didn't cross paths. 4. Boohoo cry me a river. You didn't say " hi " back. 😭

[@ronintiger]

@@aquaaria3489 its sarcasm cause this is stupid bro

[@Nchallah-u6z]

@@ken2063greetings mean something completely different in Korea. Also, they erased the evidence but oddly have 8 seconds of the first encounter when nothing happened. That ability to erase evidence and lie is an even bigger indicator of the deep systemic problems in Korean corporations.

[@jarinashakya5760]

and here some are crying on nation tv and audit for ""IGNORE HER "" word...WOW......

[@amyw1715]

In the work place yes. It’s workplace harassment, people loose their jobs for harassment, what world do u live in…

[@amyw1715]

You a teen or pre teen keyboard warrior that has never worked before ?

[@voulniz]

she did great. nobody cares about your opinion 🤍.

[@jarinashakya5760]

@@amyw1715 world where i know what real harassment means .. Harassment is what Suga went through for his DUI case by k Media.. Harassment is what Seunghan has to face with funeral wreaths... Harassment is what 23 employee were burn alive and haven't got justice.... Your so called princess idol was just ignore..even that was true or not who knows..you ppl just like to listen their side not other side..u ppl are dead case

[@jarinashakya5760]

@@voulniz so great that she cant even speak properly....

[@evangelinedatuin2919]

You’ve got to be kidding me. She’s wasting peoples time telling them that she felt bullied because some ONE didn’t acknowledge her yet there’s literally a young man being bullied by PEOPLE to leave his group. I hope these politicians know the real difference of bullying.

[@columbinarina]

she said this isn’t a first time occurrence, are you deaf?

[@skmarjanrashid4891]

@Justice_oc2sj Frrr finally who have some sense

[@koreanbrian]

this is not just about herself or the group, but also other artists among all the korean companies, who are either freelancers and contracted. this actually has been a problem for awhile and she spoke for all of them. Which is over 8 million people in south korea. So whatever you are saying, ‘this is wasting money’ grow up and see further. Hybe literally said artists are not employees. WHICH MEANS whoever support, this can happen to your stan as well.

[@hahanyameow]

newjeans is getting sabotaged, their comeback got cancelled, their collaborations are postponed etc. You're only focusing on one thing and don't even bother searching whatever the fuck HYBE is doing to them that is ruining their career. Other fandoms are bullying them and even went as far to being racist, slvtshaming, and saying all negative stuff to Hanni. If that doesn't count as bullying then you're not only IGNORANT but you're don't know anything. The only one wasting people's time is YOUR AHH for wasting your mom's time in labor to give birth to a illiterate weirdo like you, go apologize to your mom 🖕

[@Khiet2n]

@@evangelinedatuin2919 Are you suggesting beating people up in order to qualify for a bullying? Do you like to work in an unfriendly and hostile environment everyday?

[@tiffanykim2773]

Min Heejin taught Hanni well 😮

[@Agust.d.6969]

Very well !!!

[@carediva101]

Just like their stage mother

[@Agust.d.6969]

@@carediva101 wow😅😹

[@solonar87]

haha again comment from a bts trash fan , dont hide :D

[@Agust.d.6969]

@@solonar87 Hey , It's our personal opinion.So don't talk trash things. 👆👆👆 We only talk about the things that's going . We haven't talk or nor used bad words about newjeans. It's about their ( ex) CEO

[@KaibaCoperationX]

I don't know why some of the peoples will said she faked it or it's not a serious matter. It took a lot of courage to stand up for it. She knew if she stand up for it she can bid farewell to her entire career yet she do it anywhere. So atleast show some respect for her.

[@ShahnazSiddiqui-hg9qy]

The whole country is brainwashed and obsessed with this grp. And that's why they are getting too much brave and the dramas are never ending

[@bangtan4ami]

“drama” and it’s an idol coming out about bullying, many idols never do that that’s why they end up committing because of harsh pent up feelings

[@kanisweetie..]

Real fact is everyone jealous about BTS and hype 🤷.....end of the day haters gonna hate players gonna play 🤷

[@bangtan4ami]

@@kanisweetie.. this has nothing to do with bts tho…stop dragging the tans into this and setting them up

[@kanisweetie..]

@@bangtan4ami omo i am also army i mean every group and politicians some company jealous about BTS chill yar ....no one important to me other than BTS 🤦

[@Agent007_Ot7forever]

what u r expecting cause of them 2 groups are getting massive hate whats abt them huh?? Still these girls wants that mhj ig they r not kids anymore even jungkook from bts speaks for them but what they did i mean they choose mhj over their carrer ..we r not saying that she isnt getting bullied [well ignoring is not bulling but ok its ok] but just cause of their ceo those groups are suffering and all of them belongs from rich families there parents are already f...king up i mean literally no one was hating them even we all were thinking they dont deserve this all shit but what the hell they did bruhhh dying for that mhj like they dont know what she is doing

[@Multi_diamond]

This incident happened in June, when MHJ was still the CEO and ms Kim here was an ED (or sth like that). Hanni, taking into consideration her personality & close bond with the former CEO, probably told MHJ about this incident already but we didnt hear a thing from her nor how she resolved this incident. If MHJ (CEO) couldnt do anything bc of the lack of evidence, how does she expect an executive director or position to resolve it? If MHJ did really love NJ, she would have raised hell just to get justice for the girls, but now, a few months past she suddenly & conveniently remember about this incident and persuade NJ to talk about it. This case has been closed bc of lack of evidence in the past but they just had to bring it up again for shock value and bc they had no further argument. This assembly is proof, since out all the supposed "mistreatment" they faced, this incident which involves another idol group (and caused an uproar amongst netizens & fans) got attention. Not to mention Hanni (not in this 7 min vid) made a lot of statements based on her feelings alone, like "i feel like the company hates us bc we're different from the start/debut", not concrete facts. But what's the verdict or whatever response the assembly is gonna give here? Are they gonna pass a law banning "ignoring your colleague no matter how bad they are"? Im curious.

[@Mondscheinelfe]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oXioaauYjqqMms0si=L7DKvf9QPhOY1knS

[@이진-f2f]

김주영 씨는 이 사건이 일어난 당시에도, 지금도 하이브의 최고인사책임자(CHRO) 입니다. 이 일은 하이브 산하 레이블인 어도어 소속의 하니와, 하이브 산하 타 레이블 소속의 매니저 사이에서 일어난 일입니다. 따라서 그 당시에도, 지금도 김주영씨는 하이브의 최고인사책임자(CHRO)로서 이 일의 적임자이고 해결할 의무가 있습니다. 어도어의 새 CEO로 취임한 후 갑자기 요청한 것이 아니고, 하니는 과거 사건이 일어났을 때도 하이브의 CHRO인 김주영씨에게 도움을 요청했다. 지금 김주영씨는 어도어의 CEO이면서 하이브의 CHRO직을 겸직하고 있는 상태이기 때문에, 하이브의 CHRO로서 일해야 합니다. (하니가 겪은)누군가를 무시하라고 지시하는 것은 이미 한국 노동법상 불법입니다 (한국 근로기준법 제76조의 2와, 한국 고용노동부의 직장 내 괴롭힘 예방·대응 매뉴얼을 따르면). 다만 k팝 아티스트는 한국 근로기준법에서 규정하는 근로자가 아니라서 노동자임에도 노동법의 보호를 받지 못하는 상황이고, 이에 따라 '노동법에 보호받지 못하는 노동자'를 다룬 이번 국정감사에서 하니를 참고인으로 부른 것입니다.

[@Multi_diamond]

@@이진-f2f ok, i get that, it answered like maybe 1.5-2 of my points. But my points still stand that mhj didnt say a word of it bc of the lack of evidence until she had no other arguments & had to use an influential girl group member (bc fans will blindly believe the idol) when things has already been solved/closed in the past. "I believe she didnt use all the means necessary to help me" (or sth similar) is wild bc it's speculation & personal belief, it's biased based on her own feelings, again, lack of evidence but she was very confident in that statement, further incriminating ceo kim. Whereas ceo kim claimed that she believed she had used all the means in her power, her statement is also personal belief but it's not definite nor as arrogant as hanni's. It's basically he says she says where both sides have different stories and no definite proof on hanni's side. And if u could pls state the content of the law, it'd be helpful to me to further understand what's it like in korea. Also, i heard some people scoffed at ceo kim for saying that idols arent protected under the same law protecting labor rights as ordinary workers (or that idols arent included in that law, like u said). So there's that. 🤷‍♀️ Also, completely irrelevant question but is part of the reason why idols arent included in the law bc some of them are minors & arent of legal age yet? Idk, just a thought.

[@이진-f2f]

​@@Multi_diamond 하니가 최선을 다했다고 느끼지 못하는 이유) 아마도 하니는 cctv 영상 확보의 문제와 관련해 하이브측이 cctv영상을 "무시하라는 부분을 제외하고" 편집해 보관했기 때문에 최선을 다했다고 믿기 힘든 것으로 보입니다 (또한 이렇게 증거영상이 편집되어 보관된 이유에 대해서도 말이 바뀌었습니다 : 직원이 삭제 후 퇴사했다 -> 무시하라고 지시한 부분이 기간만료로 인한 삭제되었다). 노동법에 대해서 ) ​한국 근로기준법 제76조의2(직장 내 괴롭힘의 금지)에는 사용자 또는 근로자는 직장에서의 지위 또는 관계 등의 우위를 이용해 업무상 적정범위를 넘어 신체·정신적 고통을 주거나 근무환경을 악화시키는 행위를 해서는 안 된다고 규정합니다. 직장내 괴롭힘 관련 기관은 뉴진스 하니의 인사를 “무시하라고 지시"한 타 매니저의 행위가 ‘업무상 적정범위’를 벗어났다고 해석하였습니다. 한국 고용노동부의 ‘직장 내 괴롭힘 예방·대응 매뉴얼’을 보면 업무상 적정범위를 넘어선 상황에 대해 집단 따돌림, 업무 수행 과정에서 의도적 "무시"·배제 등 행위라고 열거합니다. 누군가를 무시하라고 지시하는 것은 분명히 한국에서 노동법상 직장내 괴롭힘에 해당하여 처벌할 수 있는 행위입니다 아이돌이 노동법에 포함되지 않는 이유) k팝 아이돌들은 노동자이지만 소속사와 용역계약을 해서 한국 근로기준법에서 규정하는 근로자에 해당하지 않기 때문에 노동법에 의해 보호받지 못하는 상황입니다. 이에 대해 "노동법에 의해 보호받지 못하는 노동자"를 다루는 저 국정감사에 불려나가게 된 것입니다. 저는 하니의 참석을 계기로 회사에 소속된 K팝 아티스트들, 프리랜서들이 노동자로서 인정받고 노동법에 의해 보호받을 수 있도록 법안이 개정되길 바랍니다(그렇게 된다면 모든 k팝 아이돌들이 노동자들이 노동법에 의해 보호받을 수 있을 것입니다).

[@PETITROSE-fr7qn]

​@@Multi_diamond그때 당시 대표이사가 민희진이었지만 씨시티비의 일부만 남겨놓고 삭제되도록 한 건 하이브 보안팀입니다.

[@HermoineG04]

Nah. Them bringing other girl groups down is what’s bullying. Not this. 😂😂😂 such a comedian

[@junyc_hi3196]

Newjeans themselves didn’t do that though, it is the fans that do and let’s not forget that Hybe is the one that mentioned Illit.

[@pao94]

​@@junyc_hi3196mhj mensiono a illit y esta chicas no tuvieron ningún problema en escribir plagio en su ig cuando mhj dijo que illit le copia newjeans, estas chicas de newjeans son parte del problema al igual que su ex ceo

[@quadling3521]

No, out here in the real world where people have jobs, this is a pretty clear example of workplace bullying, retaliation and a hostile work environment. That’s why Hybe worked so hard to deny it happened. That’s why she’s been asked to speak at this committee on labour conditions by the government. It is her employer and other employees bullying her, not the gp or fans of other groups like in ILLIT and LSFM’s cases (and like what you are doing now.)

[@wademyler9167]

New jeans didn't do that. They clearly wanted to be friends with Illit

[@tiffanykim2773]

​@@quadling3521she wasn't bullied.

[@HaiderAli_371]

The real gace of hybe has bow been revealed guys! The company had a document which was named weekly kpop idustry report or smth and they wrote comments about kpop idols from other agenices (minors as well) calling them "ugly" "short" etc

[@Freshbeats13]

It looks like the actual person who is being bullied is CEO

[@beethao9380]

no

[@kayCee78689]

Seriously this is what entitlement n arrogance looks like.. what is she crying about.. a staff member ignoring her.. like how can she even stand there n create a drama out of that.. especially in the light of recent events.. in that case I think Seunghan should start a protest n m sure a lot of ppl will support him like they should.. coz what happened to him is highly UNFAIR n UNREASONABLE.. not these drama queens..

[@jinndiaz3752]

She's just giving an example. She's not doing this for herself. She's doing this for all idols. instead of bashing her cause you think her grievances are minor start supporting her. Her complaints & concerns are valid.

[@kayCee78689]

@@jinndiaz3752 lol.. u must be a fan to be this blind.. SHE IS DOING EVERYTHING FOR HERSELF..the way she spoke.. smile n tears n acting so high n mighty.. she definitely took some acting classes! Being ignored is not a big thing.. her concerns are minor.. they lived luxuriously, enjoyed all the perks n brands and now doing all the drama!

[@momo9279]

the word the staff member used wasnt "ignore" there is no exact translation to it in English, but its something like "ignore" but in a belittling and humiliating way. and this is just one example. and yes i do agree that Seunghan is receiving an abnormal amount of hate for stupid reasons by delulu fans, but u shouldn't use that as a way to belittle someone elses problems. this is the first time an idol is standing up for themselves against a HUGE company and we should stand with them...because if we show her support and she wins than maybe she can set an example for idols that are being treated the same way if not worse (example: seunghan) to stand up for themselves too. remember: always be on the idols side not a multi-billion company who doesnt care about its artists physical and mental health (example enhypen) and using them as cash grab

[@tanaompu2770]

He should get a chance but don’t say about hanni like that She felt overwhelmed and it’s very new for her the environment she faced today She got the chance and she grab the chance If there was someone else instead of hanni he/she might not cry or cry too It depends on the person too how they would react either they will control their tears,either they would confidently deliver their part or might burst out crying We can’t say She said her part which she was supposed to say and lastly resquested a well maintained relationship between the idols and the companies and for the trainees too She spoke for the Idols

[@snenners123]

Your reaction and judgemental attitude is the exact reason why people don't voice their concerns regarding bullying in the work place or other serious issues like rape for that matter. There is nothing arrogant or entitled about wanting the work place bullying to stop..not just for herself, but for current or future idols.

[@aprilforgue]

Why would they even give her the time of day. This is so funny how can anyone take this seriously. This is why the rest of the world is never going to understand about K-pop and SK.

[@ltk7309]

South Korea is known for their preferential treatment towards females. They don't believe in bullying among guys lmao. Every time a female idol talks about the slightest bit of bullying, everyone and even the parliament wants to be involved and help her out. But male idols don't receive the justice nor empathy they deserved lmao. So keep quiet. To date, South Korea has never been as enthusiastic to help out a guy in need of dire help from death threats and bullying.

[@shersxtrustx2864]

She is speaking up for many. Many artists respect her even more and are even promoting NJ even more due to her bravery which many others weren’t unable of doing

[@aprilforgue]

@shersxtrustx2864 she is a child having a tantrum. No one in their right mind would take this seriously.

[@shersxtrustx2864]

@@aprilforgue I agree MHJ is making her look even more immature, but there is lots of abuse inside Kpop companies and many are glad someone spoke up. Sadly it sounds stupid due to not much evidence (though it’s still very childish for a company to not act accordingly) and it not getting to a point where their mental health lingers because of it, compared to other idols who’ve gone through worse. Remember it’s not the measure of how big or how little, companies should act formal regardless and some artists still feel unable to talk about what they went/are going through and they appreciate someone got the strength to

[@aprilforgue]

@shersxtrustx2864 this just downplays real abuse because this is not it.

[@sabrin8980]

Actually, I know seunghan deserves justice, and yeah, I hope everything goes well for briize and especially to all riize member they went through a lot in their rookie times but hanni can't do anything with it like she is not the one who started the hate right ?!?! So why saying stuff that may hurt others like there is difference between the two cases seunghan one is because of his own consequence which he did in the past ( I am not hating on him) he was just living his life as any teenage would do it's not sth that he the only one who did in this world right But hanni case is different she speaked not only for herself also for her junior she was speaking about her mistreatment and what's wrong in it she revealed the truth about the industry and that's it. she is a brave girl. I admire her and to all BRIIZE AND RIIZE MEMBER. And i hope everything return as it was, and seunghan returns back and riize be ot7 forever just stop comparing one mistreatment with other let's support both to strengthen our voice

[@rush_xoxo]

EXACTLYYY

[@winter215]

OMLLLL THATS WHAT I AM TRYING TO EXPLAIN IN EVERY DAMNED COMMENT SECTION, ILYYYY

[@apartheid84]

Hanni lies, that's why you see comments against him. This is not about a young woman who fights for the rights of idols to be treated with respect in their companies, but about a group of girls who have been treated like princesses by their company and who do not want to let go of the person who has done the impossible to destroy that same company, ruining in the process the lives of trainees and idols from other Hybe labels. NJ from the beginning supported MHJ despite the evidence against them, that is why they have no right to talk about bullying when they are the cause of others' pain

[@apartheid84]

Hanni lies because the events occurred while he was CEO MHJ. At a time when there was also workplace/sexual harassment towards an ADOR employee that MHJ herself dismissed her case and blamed the current CEO for the events.

[@sabrin8980]

@@apartheid84 how do you know she is lying and not that women

[@Estelle-wr8gx]

The example of media play talking only then crying to gain sympathy like their mother. if you really gettin bullying then show proof girl. which kind of bullying happened no one would go outside then cry outside calling someone bully without proof you gonna get sued instead 😅 best luck for you, you ruined yourself

[@minarai9156]

Exactly they just want mhj back nothing else

[@jasperherr8694]

My lord, if this is bullying, I think those boomers in my company should be sued. Girl, you need to man up, this is working and adult life yo. Not everyone needs to greet you back in life. What a joke.

[@acidicrain3104]

I don’t think it’s just greeting. It’s the psychological toll on someone when people don’t acknowledge them. Undermining them and not seeing their full potential. Not protecting them when something happens to the team or the company or whatever. Nobody needs to be in a work environment like that, everyone needs to be safe and not feel belittled by others. Ofc that is very idealistic but at least some human decency and not the constant belittling.

[@Nchallah-u6z]

Greeting is a more valued cultural etiquette in Korea than other cultures. It has much more meaning than “hi.”

[@jgarcia237]

@@acidicrain3104you are wasting your time talking go this bots, its all copy paste statement from other videos.

[@MaxFurry-u3x]

@@acidicrain3104 that’s how life is , if that’s the case then every employee from workplace should go to court .

[@solonar87]

haha again comment from a bts trash fan , dont hide :D

[@mischa6688]

She has never experienced how difficult it is outside their popularity. I like some of their songs but this is not worth it in National Assembly.

[@PETITROSE-fr7qn]

너는 케이팝의 연습생 때 생활이 얼마나 혹독한지 모르죠? 하니 또한 일반인이었던 때가 있었고 연예인이라는 직업은 높은 경쟁률을 뚫고 그녀의 순수한 노력으로 얻은 자리입니다. 하니도 인기 없으면 얼마나 힘들지 알고 있어요. 하지만 중요한 건 하니가 굳이 불이익을 참을 필요는 없다는 것입니다.😊

[@mischa6688]

@@PETITROSE-fr7qn of course I know how difficult their training are but that’s beside the point. Let’s stick to the issue here. So many other big issues and crimes that are worth National Assembly rather than this company issue that Hybe and Ador should settle on.

[@maemae3982]

I am working in foreign country and my co workers didn’t greet me back when I greeted them.Maybe they are bullying me

[@Teresahkp]

That's not What she's referring too. Know the difference lol

[@roshnnii]

"You should also appeal to the national assembly"

[@salvat60]

😅😅😅😅

[@Essie-d6l]

Does it even seem like bullying it just ignoring that means that manager don't like you don't try to get close to people who don't like you and ignore you

[@salvat60]

The national assembly have more important duties to do, that listen an infant get disturb because someone said to ignore her, image how much money they are spending in this market gossip and hallway gossip😅😅😅

[@6tribes]

working hard to leave ADOR without a penalty

[@ketiponglalongchar6051]

Ikr. Hanni the brave anti bullying girl didn’t even care when Illit and lesserafim were being bullied to death due to mhj ans new jeans fans.

[@lynneloud8565]

And to erase workplace bullying in the Idol industry

[@6tribes]

@@ketiponglalongchar6051 maybe have a convo with MHJ andhow she dragged other young girl groups and made their lives miserable. Their Japan trip was not a success it didn't make any money

[@solonar87]

haha again comment from a bts trash fan , dont hide :D

[@6tribes]

@@solonar87 ok troll fighting a losing battle

[@kanisweetie..]

This girl need to debut as a actress 😂😂😂

[@solonar87]

haha again comment from a bts trash fan , dont hide :D

[@kanisweetie..]

@@solonar87 senseless fandom award goes to ungrateful fans like their idols 😂...i am laughing at u poor people's 🤣🤣

[@solonar87]

@@kanisweetie.. BTS trash should teach their fans how to behave more politely on social media

[@rathodlalita4926]

​@@solonar87 Bot

[@ltk7309]

South Korea is known for their preferential treatment towards females. They don't believe in bullying among guys lmao. Every time a female idol talks about the slightest bit of bullying, everyone and even the parliament wants to be involved and help her out. But male idols don't receive the justice nor empathy they deserved lmao. So keep quiet. To date, South Korea has never been as enthusiastic to help out a guy in need of dire help from death threats and bullying.

[@nattiebee]

Good on her for speaking up but what she had to say was a waste of time. The only “new” incidents brought up had no evidence, we just have to take her word for it? Also, posting on blind is not WORKPLACE bullying. She lost the plot and made everything only about new jeans.

[@charstar386]

Her side eyeing and smirking while the CEO was talking is so disrespectful. This girl is not innocent, and she knows exactly what she’s doing. She’s min hee Jin’s evil mini me.

[@Niliaz_chapter]

Girl where

[@MFFGAMING99]

From 5:20 see hanni's eye movement while speaking 🗣️ ​@@Niliaz_chapter

[@MFFGAMING99]

​@@Niliaz_chapter 5:20

[@anushreedas8543]

​@@MFFGAMING99bruh you call that sideeyeing or smirking. She's looking at the court.

[@Niliaz_chapter]

@@MFFGAMING99 how was that a smirk

[@zzzmisun]

Again, Drama with with NewJeans and MHJ will never end... Its beginning to be a total publicity stunt...

[@bangtan4ami]

1 neuron in that head of yours ..

[@zzzmisun]

@bangtan4ami I didn't ask you to Bully me!!! Do you own KZbin!!!! HELL NOOOOOOOOOOO!!!! DO YOU KNOW WHAT EXPRESSING OF FREEDON OF SPEECH IS!!!! GO BACK TO SCHOOL AND EDUCATE YOURSELF BEFORE YOU MAKE an IDIOT OF YOURSELF!!!!

[@zzzmisun]

@bangtan4ami Freedom of speech, freedom of opinion.... Better than no neuron to think everyone has a right to express their opinion!!!

[@ltk7309]

South Korea is known for their preferential treatment towards females. They don't believe in bullying among guys lmao. Every time a female idol talks about the slightest bit of bullying, everyone and even the parliament wants to be involved and help her out. But male idols don't receive the justice nor empathy they deserved lmao. So keep quiet. To date, South Korea has never been as enthusiastic to help out a guy in need of dire help from death threats and bullying.

[@carentupaz1546]

this girl only shows that South Korea is full of drama, it justifies their K-drama........

[@Sud__524]

Their predebut videos got leaked and their private information as well

[@carentupaz1546]

@@Sud__524 its their so called mama doing ... she was the one who leaked their info... and fyi their group is not the only one who got into this mess that their so called mama created

[@nothingnothing6036]

​​@@Sud__524well, thats what MHJ doing behind NJ's back. Selling her kids😂😂😂 If she can betray HYBE (leak HYBE confidential info to rivals), she also can do the same to NJ.

[@agamyagupta3945]

girl i get it but this aint bullying

[@zoeybrielle9567]

she said she had a lot of proof? why not show it directly on the assembly? wheres the proof?

[@trea477]

Exactly I really hate it when people do this . U are called to present evidence , the opportunity is right there still they wanna threaten n drag this issue

[@solonar87]

haha again comment from a bts trash fan , dont hide :D

[@ylimez17]

@@solonar87newjeans bot fan is here

[@solonar87]

@@ylimez17 Who is this guy? Have you ever seen a bot reply to your stupid comments?

[@iamarmytinyctzentheb]

so in Korea its mandatory to be greeted 24/7 and not ignored. Its a crimanl offence to ignore a person😂😂😂😂😂😂. idols are out there being harassed by fans and unaliving themselves and this lady wt her minions are out here crying for no reason 😅😂😂. how weird are these pple 🙄

[@ZeryaZayci]

Imagine embarrassing yourself she said three other stories to dummy

[@zeyv4551]

Hanni took the HMJ 101 class: How to Gain Sympathy.

[@allya8234]

I love NJ but going to national assembly just because someone didn't say hi to you it's just messed up There are people in work places, school who are seriously bullied and who suffer immensely from situations like that but this it's not the case and it shouldn't be it's a slap on the face for people who were seriously bullied

[@pornesian7parapio]

if you've done drama and caused problems, you should at least think about the consequences. Being ignored isn't really a big deal. You have to be big and mature if you want to get into adult problems. And why did they send Hanni in the first place if they had 3 other native speakers who could explain everything better?

[@TahelEzra-f7d]

Soojin was the biggest victim of this industry.. Her case cannot be fixed anymore. But for the young and new artists- protect them please!! Seunghan of riize deserves apologies!! Hanni you are so brave!! I love you with alll of my heart and remember that you have true fans who will and already support you and all newjeans members forever!!❤

[@fyahstatah6298]

Imagine not being said hi to or not being congratulated and thinking "that's a case of workplace bullying" and then doing this. This is a case of being soft. I understand hannis frustrations but this is nothing to cry about. Workplace bullying happens on a much larger scale than anything she has been though i can guarantee you. I'm a construction worker and if the worst thing to happen to me was not being congratulated or not being properly greeted i would be delighted.

[@myki16]

I’m a fan of newjeans but I think hanni is going way over the top here.

[@whimsych3ry]

HELP FOR SOME REASON THIS REMINDS ME OF AMBER HEARD LMOAAA

[@jazzy4164]

My dog stepped on a beeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[@ltk7309]

South Korea is known for their preferential treatment towards females. They don't believe in bullying among guys lmao. Every time a female idol talks about the slightest bit of bullying, everyone and even the parliament wants to be involved and help her out. But male idols don't receive the justice nor empathy they deserved lmao. So keep quiet. To date, South Korea has never been as enthusiastic to help out a guy in need of dire help from death threats and bullying.

[@92nelena]

It is like complaining my Dean/CEO refused to greet me while am still an intern

[@kidjewel1468]

😒😒I guess we are all going to be doing that soon.

[@julianasilva6946]

this type of thing is taken seriously in SK. they even analyze the angle people bow to say if they are being respectful enough. and she was not talking about the CEO. she said the manager of a group did that. also, she is not an intern. she is part of the main girl group in the company.

[@ackerman7317]

According to sk laws not greeting someone is legally considered workplace harassment, however k pop idols are not protected under this law because they are not come under the workers and there are apprx 8 billion service providers who do not come under this law, hence Hanni speaking on this can lead to reformation of korean labour laws

[@92nelena]

@@julianasilva6946 She also said Bang si Hyuk ignored them. They are the members of A girl group THEY recruited. Basically the girls work FOR the company. Comparatively, being a recent girl group, they are on the level of interns, compared to Bang Si Hyuk. They should know their places. This is typical princess treatment. It seems like it got to their heads once they became really famous. They need to know they became famous because of the company they work for. They cannot be going around complaining that their seniors and superiors are not greeting them. I also know the hierarchy system is taken seriously in SK. Based on that, these girls need be more humble and down to earth.

[@gia42472]

​@@92nelenaif someone works for someone else, does that give them right to exploit others? Get your head checked to a nearest psychiatrist.

[@zozigwabeni5249]

I don't know, they are still so young but it's common in workplaces to be ignored, especially if I'm a rookie. I understand and hear her complaint but to really take it all the way to the National Assembly and still clearly be on the groomers (MHJ) side is crazy. Hybe and mhj should just leaves these girls alone because they are so sensitive and entitled but can't seem to stop defending their predator ceo

[@blancpaincollector]

What a brave girl. Let's support Hanni!!!

[@sandralovecchio7530]

So this is about a girl shedding tears and lying? I saw maybe one tear. Let’s not forget this is all about MHJ and her wanting the CEO position because of the money it came with which she lost. What a waste of taxpayers money.

[@solonar87]

haha again comment from a bts trash fan , dont hide :D

[@nanak2531]

Are you kidding me, video doesn't support claim plus why is she not addressing the bullying and harassment from her, MHJ and fandom at their direction. That is real bullying

[@nikkonikkoni8264]

Sorry....but is this a joke???🙄 like she has not witnessed what workplace bullying actually looks like. Workplace bullying is when someone "constantly picks on someone", "deliberately overloads them work", "make sure that they're always the last person to leave the office", "make them run errands for you", "snitch about them to your higher ups even when haven't done anything wrong"....and in extreme cases "using physical violence against them"......her definition of "workplace bullying" literally discredits the actual victims undergoing bullying/harrassment at work.. MHJ taught her well😏😏 it's like she knows how to cry on cue...😂😂

[@ltk7309]

South Korea is known for their preferential treatment towards females. They don't believe in bullying among guys lmao. Every time a female idol talks about the slightest bit of bullying, everyone and even the parliament wants to be involved and help her out. But male idols don't receive the justice nor empathy they deserved lmao. So keep quiet. To date, South Korea has never been as enthusiastic to help out a guy in need of dire help from death threats and bullying.

[@shazaza1]

The definition of bullying is the repetitive use of strength or power to frighten or hurt weaker people. Where the relationship involves an imbalance of power. Hanni - a rich senior idol who lives in a luxury apartment, is taken around by drivers and attended to by staff - complained that after getting her hair and makeup done, Illit's manager - a junior employee earning substantially less, not provided with luxury accommodation or transportation - told a member of Illit "ignore her" (allegedly). And Hanni and parents demanded the company to summon the junior employee and interrogate them. The imbalance of power in this relationship and who the real bully is, is clear. Her smirks and glares at Ador's CEO were disrespectful, a real "mini Min Hee Jin" - like mother like daughter. Even if the manager did say "ignore her", with all the accusations and smearing that MHJ has done against so many groups including Illit, it would seem an attempt to protect the junior idol. I imagine everyone at the company is walking on eggshells around MHJ and NJ (if they ever show up), and the environment must be toxic. The National Assembly was a farce. A politician had NJ bunny stickers on his computer, others took photos of Hanni arriving, and the CEO of Hanwha Ocean - called for a hearing of workers' deaths - was smiling and taking selfies with Hanni. Utterly disgraceful.

[@begait_1297]

Hahahah, this makes me laugh. They keep gaining attention to these issues for so long, but the school bullying they never give attention to... Why would they go in these matters to and never ever in school violence?.???

[@TrinhNguyen-sh4fj]

I wonder the same things.

[@꿈빛나래]

한국 정부가 학교폭력 문제를 신경쓰지 않는다고 누가 그래? 학교폭력 특별법이 있다는 건 알고 있냐? 뉴스를 제대로 찾아보고 말해ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 유튜브 영상이나 드라마만 보고 떠들지 말고 이 외국인들아 아오;

[@Talent_more_than_popularity]

We are not as stupid as the Koreans, look at the statistics, congratulations, you are in FIRST place in bullying at school, in First place in suicides. We don't listen to politicians' excuses, we look at statistics

[@SanatombiLeichombam]

Yeah yeah school bullying is a big issue...I think

[@0Quackers]

Honestly, whats so sad about the majority of these comments is most of these people are comparing bullying on the degree or severity which is not helpful at all as all forms of bullying are harmful. Instead of uniting together on a humanity level to combat bullying, you turn on Hanni to have someone to blame and use as a scapegoat. Blinded by trying to determine whose case is more severe, the ignorant people in these comments miss the point that Hanni decided to take a step forward in diminishing workplace bullying and toxicity. Regardless, knowing she was going to be faced with large public opinion, Hanni used her power to speak up on bullying within the idol industry and that's a very brave thing to do. I find it ironic that under a video where the premise is anti-bullying, the people in these comments pursue to bully Hanni for speaking up. Whether you like it or not, Hanni did what she thought was right and hopefully this can be the beginning for more artists to speak out on workplace bullying.

[@Mondscheinelfe]

THANK YOU! Every human and idol should be able to speak up to ANY mistreatment. Her doing this will set a precedent and hopefully give idols more power and strength to defend themselves against any mistreatment!

[@0Quackers]

@@Mondscheinelfe Thank you for spreading your positivity. I wish there was more people like you in this world

[@Mondscheinelfe]

@@0Quackers i also very appreciate you

[@ilauliu]

exactly

[@MusicLover-u2j]

But there is not even one instance that Hanni or anyone from Newjeans have pointed out that equals to bullying or workplace harassment. Someone saying ignore her is not harassment. Infact you will also ignore someone who is bringing hate to you. I don't know how old you are but ignoring someone at workplace is quite common and infact your manager will tell you to ignore people who are negative towards you. That's also how in life you go about in general. For your own sanity you ignore things or people who bring negativity.

[@inlovewithyibo7713]

She's so brave showing up with no actual evidence to back up her claims. But her doing this might help others with actual real bullying problems come out and do this. What she's experiencing is called a culture shock. I wouldn't go that far in calling it bullying... these young girls are being so sheltered... they need to reconsider going back to school so they could learn about the real world because this is real concerning how much they are focusing so much on someone not greeting them back or being purposely ignored. Grow some thick skin and let it roll off you. When she said bullying I was thinking T-ARA kind of bullying.

[@tanzilsalekin7633]

What an assumption you are making about her whole life to try to prove your point. She’s literally said she has evidence of the security people lying about why they don’t have that footage. Yes there are people who deal with worse things, especially in the Korean entertainment business. But no one deserves to be disrespected and suppressed in the workplace by employees and their CEO. Stop trying to gaslight this girl for calling out her companies BS.

[@ココファーム8o8]

The deletion of cctv should be properly investigated. In the first place, it was the time when Hani checked, but in June, when his parents protested. The 13th is within the 16th, which is half of the 30 days of the cctv expiration period. But the problem is that the 50-minute video containing only an 8-second greeting video of greeting Hani was deleted. My parents protested on June 20th, and this is also before the expiration date of cctv. My parents kept protesting until September. When I showed the video on August 13th, I showed a completely different video of Hani + Daniel + manager together, not when I was alone. And in the state audit, he lied that there was an 8-second half, but the second half was gone because cctv expired. And he said he couldn't appeal strongly because he was the manager of another company. Kim Joo-young himself is still the chief human resources officer of Hive. Is the chief human resources officer in a position where he can't say anything about such a dispute? It's something the world will laugh at.

[@Hii_Miraa12]

How can you call it culture shock when the rest of her team members aND company had a problem with it and sent her here?? They’re all Korean too lol

[@inlovewithyibo7713]

@Hii_Miraa12 Well, I think its funny they sent Hanni, a foreigner, to speak. I don't think you understand what culture shock means. It sounds tactful they sent her since a non-Korean addressing workplace issues could be viewed differently. Probably with more leniency or understanding if she unintentionally offends someone. It's easier to call it misunderstandings or cultural differences if her testifying backfires. So no. I don't really think Hanni actually knows what the problem is because she wasn't raised in the Korean culture. She's just being told what to do.

[@inlovewithyibo7713]

@tanzilsalekin7633 Gaslighting involves manipulating someone into doubting their own reality or experiences. I was merely providing my opinion. If anyone is gaslighting, it's whoever made her show up to testify. Just to be clear, I wasn’t trying to dismiss Hanni’s experience. Workplace issues in the entertainment industry are serious, and speaking up matters. But this is the real world. My point was that without any actual evidence, her showing up without solid proof weakens the argument and makes it harder to take action. Did she bring this alledged evidence to the Korea National Assembly? If she did, great! My opinion can be disregarded then! That will help her claims and assist to move for a policy change. But if she hadn't brought anything supporting her claims and yet she was still wielding that statement about having this alledged evidence in front of the National Assembly?? This isnt childs play. Who tf does she think she is? To me, that just sounds like a threat was made. That's why I called her brave. Her testifying in front of the Korea National Assembly, which is Congress in the U.S. for me, they were all being nice and I wondered if it was because she's a foreigner.

[@xxgg3407]

#HANNIPLEASEGROWUP 😢

[@CCc-nr1xv]

If this is the reason to call a National Assembly Hearing then how about the extreme bullying for SEUNGHANS CASE???? This is nothing compared to death threats she got such a big opportunity a big platform to talk about and she pulls this ?

[@minarai9156]

Exactly poor seunghans

[@OtakuMedia-n2z]

OMG crocodile tears. I didn't knew she was so good at acting 😂

[@sphouse.storevn]

bts kid fan crying hahaha

[@OtakuMedia-n2z]

​@@sphouse.storevnbrain-dead bunnies 😅

[@OtakuMedia-n2z]

​@@sphouse.storevnyour girl group career is over 😂😊

[@sphouse.storevn]

@@OtakuMedia-n2z cry louder

[@wasekaislam4450]

​@@sphouse.storevnNewpanties uncle fan crying hahaha

[@dionneransome839]

It's weird that this girl keeps changing her story. And bullying is more than just ignoring someone. And again, she accused Seventeen of disrespecting her, when they didn't. Too many lies being told and these New Jean girls need to stop trying to be "privileged". Hard work equals success. If you want out of your contract pay the money, move on. Stop trying to win sympathy and get to work. Like your fellow idols. Remember, BTS went through trials and tribulations and were ignored by their seniors of all 3 major companies, but they kept working and look at them now.

[@bluehourtarot]

@@dionneransome839 Yep, she just didn’t understand Korean enough but was quick to point the finger.

[@FifthGate]

Australian K-pop idol and Gucci ambassador Hanni Pham ($3.8 million take-home last year, wearing an outfit that retails for approximately $12,000) "cries" at the National Assembly about supposedly being ignored by idols leaving the salon where she was having her hair professionally styled. This, despite the same idols giving her a 90-degree bows upon entering the salon and seeing her. She showed she isn't proficient in Korean, understanding only just over half of the questions asked of her by subcommittee members, and yet we're supposed to believe she heard "ignore her" from an employee who makes less than 1% of what she made last year, as the employee was passing by her to exit the salon. Sure, Jan.

[@bluehourtarot]

@@FifthGateWell said. Put this in the man comments so everyone sees it. Good points to make.

[@Department_of_Justice]

They aren't victims of MHJ here, they are accomplices.

[@purplerainpurplerainprince5702]

@@FifthGate😂

[@jopay0613.7]

She was not bullied. She is the BULLY. This politicians seriously is the total joke.

[@fleurpisano4563]

That girl IS the bully. So disrespecful to her seniors

[@ltk7309]

South Korea is known for their preferential treatment towards females. They don't believe in bullying among guys lmao. Every time a female idol talks about the slightest bit of bullying, everyone and even the parliament wants to be involved and help her out. But male idols don't receive the justice nor empathy they deserved lmao. So keep quiet. To date, South Korea has never been as enthusiastic to help out a guy in need of dire help from death threats and bullying.

[@shersxtrustx2864]

Her seniors are extremely grateful. Only the perpetrators aren’t for being exposed

[@jenk2351]

What is wrong with the comments here?? There’s so much hate for this girl who’s speaking up about her experiences. Just because there’s other “worse” bullying doesn’t mean her experience is not valid.

[@Eot04]

SOS CONSIENTE???? Ella está ahí solo porque alguien no la saludo mientras que otro chico recibe amenazas de muerte!!! Que está mal contigo??? WTF

[@Teresahkp]

​@@Eot04she ain't talking about the ignored greetings. She feel sad on how they got ignored by those Big Persons in the company without them doing nothing wrong

[@Gabiwi_]

@@Eot04 Oye calmate, nadie esta diciendo que su experiencia es la peor, esta diciendo que no porque sea mejor que la de otro artista la haga menos válida. AMBAS COSAS ES BULLYING.

[@shusokuconvergence955]

@@Teresahkpagree, and which happened before the public falling out with Min Hee Jin.

[@christineforno2457]

@@Eot04she s talking about bully culture using an example of her own. Should thank her for standing up to them, for her and for every body else. It doesn’t matter what experience small or big, bully exists and something needs to get done to set example for others.

[@egg-jj4qr]

y’all do realize shes speaking on the behalf of all kpop idols right? including seunghan?

[@star2like261]

No she’s not. She’s talking about her people not saying hello to her not about fans controlling artist and acting crazy! Sending wreath’s to a young man because he dearer to have a girlfriend. Didn’t hear her speak about others artists pressure just her own, sadly.

[@egg-jj4qr]

@@star2like261 Yes, workplace harassment and companies prioritizing profit over idol’s mental health. Sounds abt right to me? I’m not talking abt her literally speaking abt OTHER kpop idols, i’m talking abt how her speaking out abt her OWN experience AS a kpop idol: what will be changed in the industry after this conference. I wholeheartedly agree with legal action coming out of Seunghan being literally BULLIED out of RIIZE. Idk how Hanni was supposed to SPECIFICALLY bring this up at the National Assembly, but a platform should be offered to the RIIZE members and Seunghan for sure. It sounds like Newjeans and RIIZE and basically all groups should have protections in place for idols! Which is the goal of Hanni being at the National Assembly :))

[@star2like261]

@@egg-jj4qr thank you for your clear explanation, it’s appreciated. I think it’s a real shame that she was given the mic to speak on this issue, as I truly believe there are voices that are more worthy to speak on the topic. Sadly her experience makes the notion of actual bullying seem pitiful. I certainly agree that more needs to be done. I was dumbfounded by the wreath situation. At no point yet that I’ve seen has anyone condemned it. I hope the companies will track the senders and bring charges, setting a precedent for bullying!!

[@Estelle-wr8gx]

Nah she isn't talking about seunghan don't do it dirty. seunghan got forced leave because sm allowed bullying take place in sm , sm Stan is crazy they even sending flowers wreaths for suga acting like they're army.

[@Estelle-wr8gx]

​@@egg-jj4qr hanni goal seems leaving hybe without paying contract for 300billions

[@Kpopstan4ever_stanNCT]

Okay so one she didn't add any new info or context about this bullying, she's stating the same that she stated in the live, second of all she doesn't have evidence thats she was bullied in the first place, she keeps mentioning it but i don't see any witnesses or CCTV footage that can prove it, another thing when she said that HYBE was trying to downplay them, why would HYBE try to downplay one of their most popular groups, if anything they would be promoting them even more, also when she mentions that she doesn't want any of her juniors or seniors to go through this experience, it make mes think did she not realize that her words caused some of her fellow groups to get heavily bullied online and accuse, but did they come out to a national assembly for it? At this point this seems like a publicity stunt, this whole issue could have been solved internally.

[@ken2063]

You NewJeans fans better bow in 90 degrees Korean style when you see Hanni or any NewJeans members otherwise they'll take you to court. 😅 Any sign of disrespect will NOT be tolerated cuz they're NEWJEANS !!@! And they'll cry !!! btw Good acting Hanni lol

[@Niliaz_chapter]

You’re over exaggerating it’s like saying someone has to wave and come up close to my face or I’ll get sad no it’s not just about bowing but also how the manager responded rewatch the video and actually listen tf

[@Idontknowleeknow]

If any of my school mate ignores me when I smiled at them i never smiles at them after that and it's same mhj played with other groups reputation and she thinking everyone will give her princess treatment And the crying lmfao same like her mother

[@ayomideyusuf859]

Like you get, newjeans and their fans needs a reality check

[@Idontknowleeknow]

@@ayomideyusuf859 yeah

[@al1207]

This girl knows nothing about bullying. That one case she’s bringing up every time means she considers it the hardest one. But it’s really nothing. So what were other cases? 😅

[@jimcalatrava4136]

So, what is bullying? Employees are instructed to ignore or make another employee invisible or not existing, cursing and downplaying their group. So, what do you call these?😂 D*mb@s$.

[@truusvanroekel-se7pl]

It's a sign that Hybe is a good company. They couldn't find real bullying evidence. Shame on them dragging the death of that employee into this MJH mess.

[@savokisan]

I agree that by asking artist to ignore her is consider very rude especially since no matter what she is hybe artist. Yes they may come from different sub companies, they are still one hybe family. And being a fellow manager, that staff shouldn't have no consideration of another artist feeling But at the same time, I feel that she really escalate too much by going to a court case. At the moment no matter what happen, NJ isn't going well and her going to court is making things worse.

[@kholidams]

Yes i love new jeans and the music and that incident definitely it is not abuse Level

[@tejaswijetti7924]

They said there are so many incidents of others bullying them, but it seems only this "ignore her" thing is the only kind of bullying incident they have and she thinking its bullying and on blind some employees of hybe talking about their japan sales badly....i mean i don't think these come under bullying, surely for teenagers these things hurt, but its not that serious there are so many serious matters to look into but still korean govt choose this????? Their japan sales didn't make 1 million and hybe gave the info to the media as it's the company's duty not to let out false information, where as the japan sales were around 40 to 50 k sales.....they may be talking about that but still So many members talk about bts badly and one of the SM employee scammed jimin, and the media portrayed yoongis incident as if it's a burning scandal issue.....i think even though bts is at great heights the antis and the korean govt is doing nothing to protect our boys too....but i am proud that my boys never played a victim card and fought and still fighting.

[@ketiponglalongchar6051]

Ikr. And Hanni the brave anti bullying girl didn’t even care when Illit and lesserafim were being bullied to death due to mhj ans new jeans fans.

[@vee.3029]

Look at all these teenage girls who stan bgs show their misogyny to hanni

[@lynneloud8565]

But she also revealed other things at the assembly why are guys only talking about this greeting thing ?

[@lynneloud8565]

​@@ketiponglalongchar6051How the fuck Lesserafim hate is related to Newjeans? They were litterally hate because of their disastrous performance at Coachella 2024 and their poor live vocals during their encores( especially Sakura )even since antifragile era, Yujin had a collab with a problematic artist called Max and she was also spotted drinking Starbucks PUBLICLY during the boycott which cause many backclashs They were also hated for their song 'Smart' because it was similar to tyla WATER and the revelant outfit Eunchae wore + they received backclahs for their new song "Crazy" because people though that the song was not required any vocals abilities and that Hybe them the song to hide their bad vocals. Now did Newjeans told them to not take those vocals class serously ?

[@ilovecats0406]

The clown of the year award goes to NJ and especially Hanni XD Why is she lying that the security just let her look through the security footage for this kind of dumb reason, at least try to make sense... What the Ceo said was completely normal and supposedly this actually happened while MHJ was the CEO but somehow they changed it that it happened now to belittle the new CEO... Also, her saying that she recorded the meeting sounds like something that is an illegal thing to do without notifying people present. Lastly, boo hoo rich girl got ignored by the victims of her bullying, and her ego got bruised so bad XD Hanni: "I don't think the CEO did everything she could to protect us" Did she expect her to beat them up or fire them for not saying hello to her? Girl is on another level of delulu... I feel so bad for the CEO for being put through this clownery...

[@user-sd6nw1jn9s]

The only real delulu here is you. Just your average everday bts ball rider with a serious case of anti-NWJNs derangement syndrome 😂

[@ilovecats0406]

@@user-sd6nw1jn9s Where did I ever mention BTS? I guess you are just average low intellect NJ fan, that blames BTS for everything instead of actually using critical thinking. Sorry I forgot that the whole tokis fandom lacks any kind of brain activity and are only able to obsess over (some underage) brats XDD I guess I should expect that when NJ fans are either creepy old men or children...

[@pastafreak5362]

Don't worry about the hate comments my girl u have to stay strong. only u guys know what u are going through. I feel so bad u have to go through all this. Don't give a fuck about the haters who have the audacity to troll u knowing nothing.#Newjeansforever

[@bangtan4ami]

yall in the comments don’t understand what workplace bullying is..workplace bullying is common and it happens everyday in the work place. the first things that common in bullying is isolation, she said that the staff said to “ignore her” and “don’t pay attention to her”. and even if this seems like a “minor” case to some of you, you aren’t in her position to know what she’s experiencing firsthand. i’m glad she spoke up because most idols just ignore the bullying and choose not to speak up about how it affects them and how it needs to be stopped, that’s the reason most idols are always depressed and even worse they end up committing. hanni speaking up can encourage other idols to do so as well, putting workplace bullying out in the spotlight and revealing what happens under closed doors. jeez you people lack all sorts of empathy

[@beany1944]

Victimhood, isn't this the mentality and speciality these days. Someone look at you funy and you become a victim, no one greets you, and you get butthurt and are a victim, you get ignored and you get butthurt again and play a victim. Get over yourself.

[@charityMokami-zk9gv]

Then are you gonna force people to like you at your workplace?no you ain't gonna do that,and her by saying this it will only increase what she is going through under hybe right now I don't support what is going on right now but I hope what's best for them and even if this is solved to the public but behind doors no one I mean no one after this is gonna be polite to them

[@bangtan4ami]

@@charityMokami-zk9gv there’s a difference between simply not liking someone and mistreating someone because you don’t like them. and the staff may hate her more but what can she do? stay quiet and let it progress, speaking out was one of the best things she could’ve done.

[@charityMokami-zk9gv]

@@bangtan4ami and you think it will change?? Nothing is gonna change especially now, am just feeling sorry for the girls this is something that happened to my sis and she had to quit her job

[@bangtan4ami]

@@charityMokami-zk9gv so because you think it “may not change” is just a reason to give up and accept the bullying? no way. i’m sorry that happened to your sister but giving up should never be an option, especially for something like this. the “never changing” mindset is what will make things like this NEVER change. we wouldn’t have this freedom we have today if our ancestors gave up and believed things would never change

[@TheShiloh1991]

Hanni is Australian and in Australia, not treating people with respect at this level can be considered as workplace bullying. Being continuously ignored in the workplace can put so much stress on the person and eventually their mental health, which is taken extremely seriously in Australia. Unfortunately, coming from Asian countries, I can say that we tend not to take such matters seriously enough. She's speaking her truth from her perspective and it's up to the assembly to review to determine the severity of the issue. There's nothing wrong with that. Does she have to suffer an intense level of bullying (physical abuse, yelling, etc) to be considered as being bullied? I don't think so.

[@sounasrasou3170]

Her workplace is not in Australia, so

[@Vampirewholovesgarlic]

@@sounasrasou3170 lol

[@유진-t4w7t]

Why Hani participated in the national audit) in relation to South Korea's labor laws. That national audit was about workers who are not protected by labor laws. Currently, K-pop artists in South Korea are not protected by labor laws because they are contracted as a service to their management companies, even though they are workers (labor laws only recognize workers if they have a labor contract). Hanni's participation in the national audit could lead to better treatment of K-pop artists, trainees, and other freelancers. This is an important issue for South Korea's labor system.

[@nganvuong7210]

Is she speaking up for the sake of Kpop idols, or for herself and MHJ? If she really cares about other idols that much then she should have stopped her ex-CEO from bullying other groups.

[@madysonclaeys6934]

I think it will lead to that but I don’t think that was the reason she did this. If there was actual harassment it would make sense but I feel this is just a publicity stunt to help MHJ. There was nothing much the new ceo could have done 😅. On top of that it’s kind of a slap in the face to other idols who actually are hurting due to MHJ mentioning them which she didn’t even have to mention MHJ did that purposely knowing they would get attacked. She is not stupid. The fact that Hanni knows this is kinda sad when she mentions so other idols don’t have to go through this…when the other idols are getting much worse than just being ignored 🤦🏽‍♀️. Idk I think it’s a step for other idols but her reasoning is not actually for other idols in my opinion it’s for herself and MHJ and to try to get MHJ back by trying to get rid of the new ceo and doing anything possible to do so…

[@DaisyDee5610]

@@nganvuong7210exactly. LSF and ILLIT needs to take the stand too.

[@alkim1519]

Eso es una justificación para dar credibilidad a esa señorita?? Están ustedes justificando algo que no comenzó con esa finalidad si no con otra muy distinta. Lo saben ustedes y lo sabemos todos los que tengamos dos dedos de frente o más de dos neuronas conectadas. Se están poniendo los puntos y la venda en una herida que se ha provocado con otra finalidad.

[@aquaaria3489]

@@nganvuong7210 Because the main subject is the workplace bullying that happened to her. She cannot really talk about what other groups have went to because that’s not for her to do. If MHJ has to be brought up here, then groups like Illit and LSF have to step up too.

[@vivianamaugo6555]

Is it that the National Assembly of Korea does not have any serious pending issues, then deal with the high suicide rate in your country.. you are having a hearing over what?? Min Hee Jin and Hanni (New jeans)!! 😂😂😂😂😂

[@Estelle-wr8gx]

They must be have something but famous person more important that normal workers who died

[@bananapie2483]

National Assemblies must deal with any legal issue they are given, regardless of the severity of the issue. If Hanni wants to take this case to the court she must be able to

[@minarai9156]

Now days korean national assembly only give important for popularity my gosh😂😂

[@WalterGoodman120]

Hallelujah!!! I'm favored and blessed with $60,000 every week! Now I can afford anything and also support the work of God and the church.

[@Deborah-d3j]

This is what ROSE M Elaine does, she has changed my life.

[@RobertDorsey-m7k]

After raising up to 60k trading with her, I bought a new house and car here in the US and also paid for my son's (James) surgery. Glory to God.shalom.

[@JoshuaBrockJerry]

Wow that's huge, how do you make that much monthly?

[@AP-fi2di]

Stupid trolls with multiple fake accounts 😂😂😂

[@MadelineR.Blanchard]

Yeah Mrs Rose M Elaine is a very committed and effective stock broker; in addition to managing my stock portfolio, she reinvests in many financial markets and generates money even when there are widespread losses.

[@sarendipity5926]

It’s a shame that this is the case getting the most media attention, not the fact that five workers passed away at the Hanwha Ocean work sites this year alone due to the lack of proper safety measures (and Hanni took a smiling selfie with their CEO)

[@10CIIC]

I will always support newjeans ❤

[@mona.cabocmona303]

We were told by MHJ that ''brainless''...girls idols... Hanni seems, to learn the art of manipulation from her mentor MHJ. And ''I'm aware that laws cannot resolve every problem that exist''...wow I'm impressed, she looks like she made rehearsals before and had a strategy too. First of all, Hanni brought Bang Pd in discussion about how another gg and their manager ''bullied'' her by ignoring her. So, it happened before at a higher level but now, she couldn't stand still anymore. Secondly she mentioned the discussion between the HYBE PR staff and the former reporter that inflated the NJ sales in Japan with approximately... 960.000 copies. And people discussion on that matter is bad-mouthing NJ? Thirdly the actual CEO of ADOR doesn't care and support NJ idols, because when she was a PR director under MHJ management!!?, the PR director didn't solved the case in Hanni's favor? The ''bullying'' incident was in June or earlier, how come is involved Hanni's distress of MHJ being removed without notice in 28 of August in all the story, that the actual CEO don't care about NJ idols? I think that the public was mislead by MHJ. Hanni doesn't seem to be brainless at all. If she connected in her speech all the incidents that happened in the last 6 months, with Bang Pd courage of not saying ''hi'' to her two years ago. That young woman/idol knows where to bring the discussions. I also think that the marketing company/consultant behind MHJ is involved and is orchestrating all of this tragicomedy. Maybe HYBE should search for one too.

[@CC-xx3wx]

yup hybe should hire another PR/marketing team to handle the current situation. they are so passive and weak so far

[@Hurryhurr]

For international fans. The topic of this audit was not "Ignore cases." It was "workers outside the labor law." Currently, there are 8.5 million people in Korea who are not protected by the labor law, such as contract workers and freelancers. The issue has been discussed all along, but it has received little attention from society. However, Hanni's appearance in the National Assembly has earned her the attention of society. It is for this reason that lawmakers thank Hani for coming out. Hanni understood this well and attended the National Assembly inspection. She said, "I don't want my seniors and juniors to go through this." because she didn't come out to solve her own problems. Regardless of the high or low income, it's the same that idols are not protected by labor laws. And the national audit revealed a cover-up case in which a Hive employee died from overwork while working in the office around September 2022. Therefore, it can be seen as lawmakers protecting workers and auditing several industries, including Hive, through these matters.

[@Hurryhurr]

For your information, idols in Korea are not workers. They are special employment workers who have contracted with their agencies.

[@sakurakou2009]

​@@HurryhurrWhat is the difference?

[@alkim1519]

Los Armys internacionales parecemos idiotas?? ¿Donde están como testigos los chicos que recibieron la supuesta orden de no saludar a esta señorita?? Porque no se olvide que esos chicos son testigos de primer orden. ¿Por qué no son convocados para dar su testimonio?? Surrealista del todo.

[@rensomusni8419]

@@alkim1519 I believe it's to keep their identity hidden to avoid getting hate from the internet so they didn't attend or not allowed to attend as witnesses since even Hanni herself refused to specify their names showing that she still respects them and still wants to protect their privacy

[@Hurryhurr]

@@sakurakou2009 This was translated into a translator. The official name of a specially hired worker is "special type worker," which refers to a person who provides labor services through a consignment contract for work, etc., not an employment contract, and receives payment in the form of commissions, etc. ▲ insurance planner ▲ chauffeur ▲ workbook teacher, etc. They work in the same situation as workers, but most of them cannot be guaranteed the rights of workers under the labor law.This is because it is not 'employed' by a labor contract, but is a 'self-employed' in form. Specialized workers contract with companies and are managed and monitored by companies, but are discriminated against because they are not contracted under a 'labor contract'. Special employment workers are not covered by industrial accident insurance depending on their occupation type. As of July 2021, only 3 out of 10 special employment workers are eligible to join. Since the labor contract is not written, the basic rights specified in the labor contract, ▲ vacation ▲ annual ▲ working hours, etc., cannot be guaranteed. Profits are unstable because they do not receive a certain wage every month from their employers. The Labor Union and Labor Relations Act, which can create and negotiate labor unions, also does not apply.

[@jasminirauch4322]

so not beeing greeted back is bullying now, court value. You have to work up relationships at work over time like anybody else. Grow up. Gosh this is so embarassing.

[@tripleSSupremacy]

True

[@tripleSSupremacy]

Please Hanni, my love Why are you embarrassing yourself 😭

[@ltk7309]

South Korea is known for their preferential treatment towards females. They don't believe in bullying among guys lmao. Every time a female idol talks about the slightest bit of bullying, everyone and even the parliament wants to be involved and help her out. But male idols don't receive the justice nor empathy they deserved lmao. So keep quiet. To date, South Korea has never been as enthusiastic to help out a guy in need of dire help from death threats and bullying.

[@ZeryaZayci]

@@tripleSSupremacyshe is talking about her problems and not talking about embarrassing yourself you embarrassed yourself and not her

[@beethao9380]

you're embarrassing. gosh.