【VY1V4】Fairytale,【カバー】

[@kyaami]

Thank you all for 2 million (?!) views!!

[@warfu_]

This thing is legendary now, congratulations

[@rivaldosilalahi7992]

Mantap gan

[@가나슈타르트]

매일같이 듣고 있습니다! 축하드려요:D

[@deswina1069]

Mantappu jiwa!!!

[@ataparag232]

congratulations!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ~ proud to be here since the release woooohh

[@επαγυηεςαγ]

SHE BREATHES!

[@bazooka-sharks-parker]

+κιmτσ クラウド (αγαησ) Miku ? Miku chan you're breathing ? are you alive marry me aready

[@επαγυηεςαγ]

It's not Miku...

[@bazooka-sharks-parker]

クラウドκιmτσ it kinda souns olike her ? i mean the point is i can marry a vocaloid now

[@επαγυηεςαγ]

Ye, that's so true.

[@velajuel_]

SHE BREATHES! SHE LIVES!!!!

[@steamlink4803]

It's been 7 years, and I've yet to find a vocaloid song that surpasses this one

[@annag1638]

Same 😭

[@animesenpai1163]

Only ones the comes close to me personally is Kyaami Near and Donor Song Then Suzie's Otomachi Una Cover of Unknown Mother Goose.

[@ethios8115]

I thought odds and ends is the best voca song until 2014. And then, this masterpiece appeared.

[@cameron82489]

I think this one, teo and palette are my 3 top

[@nolienn]

Right?? I still find myself thinking about this song

[@SirHamnet]

hOLY SHIT I LOST IT AT THE GROWL

[@zimju9667]

we all did

[@KevinBrooks_c]

Tears burst out every time

[@KANA_AI]

5年が経っても、未だにこの曲の調教を超えるボカロ曲はいない

[@___xxxx5956]

未だにこれが最強だと思ってます

[@四条ナワテ]

10年たっても追い抜かれてねえ 結局AI生成で別軸からボカロが追い抜かれるまで独走し続けたな

[@Backforyou777]

@@四条ナワテまじでわかる...😢

[@dacasman]

I can't get over how realistic this sounds. This if the first time Ive had a hard time telling vocaloid from real vocals. If I wasn't so familiar with vocaloid, I would have no idea this wasn't a real person singing.

[@pacipanpen2785]

If you think this is human, look at kyaami's End Of Rain cover! It's just...holsjagdhjshsvsbahsjsbxb ;)

[@largebaguette3507]

It actually isn't Vocaloid! It's from Utau! It's pretty much Vocaloid but with abetter voicebank and it's free!

[@nyuuronfly]

@Jimmy Fung they're talking about the End Of Rain cover, which was done with Utau.

[@WangleLine]

What the hell, I've been listening to this song for a loooong time and only realized it was a vocaloid after reading the comments today. Those growls give me huge chills

[@OtakuUnderground92]

Wait this isn’t a real person singing?!?!

[@natemantle5933]

So, as a trained musician myself (and with a particularly strong love of production/editing/mixing/mastering), I can see such a difference between this and other vocaloids ... and the main thing is that kyaami likely has some sort of understanding of how vocals work, and a very discerning ear (and patience!). Listen to the vibrato, and how it doesn't just move at one tempo or amplitude. Like a real singer, it starts a bit slower and wider, and tightens and gets faster near the end of the notes. This is just one example of something that a lot of other people who compose with vocaloids seem to not "get". Thanks for this. Really awesome work!

[@nchiakinqayyim]

YES, THIS IS WHAT I'M THINKING ALWAYS. Kyaami is one of the few vocaloid producers that know how to control vocaloid's voice technique because for me, some vocaloid tune too screeching and weird tempo that makes my ears ringing and unpleasant to hear. But Kyaami really one of the kind that knows how to use every voicebanks speciality to avoid weird note and off tempo.

[@namelessking111]

In other words, Kyaami is a damn prodigy when it comes to the vocaloid community. I don't know about the technical stuffs but just purely from listening to her songs and seeing how people praise her, i can just tell that she's really a cut above the rest~

[@jasonn6594]

It sounded so real I thought it was an actual singer

[@kawaiiotaku1599]

The syllables and changes between pitches are much more fluid too… this is amazing!

[@connordoesexist1807]

even slight pitch rise at the end of words and runs, and slight pitch lows at the start of words and runs, that makes the pitch transition very fluid and human-like

[@KaitoILoveIceScream]

Oh my God that growl

[@riooceo4171]

your still alive i see :p

[@KaitoILoveIceScream]

I have died for a while, but I am back~

[@riooceo4171]

lol

[@ASHERUISE]

+Raito Kun (Ratio) Fucking intense.

[@exzobree9158]

Grrrrowl.

[@Sutidamuskun]

0:40 3:20 Warning, your mind will explode, you will cry tears of joy

[@artema.]

Oh shit the growl function

[@Kirious]

Suti~Tooti YEP

[@KevinBrooks_c]

absolutely

[@amylu266]

That riff tho

[@onebigmood9632]

He growls and it makes it feel so real

[@HazeEmry]

In 2 more months this will be a decade old. How time flies

[@기사타]

진짜 명곡에 명조교긴 한가보다 이 커버가 나온 뒤로 조교든 커버든 이것보다 더 한게 아직도 없는걸 보면.. 심지어 원곡초월임

[@돗-i5c]

9년이나 지났는데 아직도 이것만한 보카로 조교 없다 최고

[@MonoJelly]

Even almost a year later after hearing this, I still get insane chills every time I hear that growl. Serious props to kyaami like oh my god

[@nyooang]

+MonoJelly I know right I still can't get over how amazing this is ;;

[@bobbieproductions4491]

+MonoJelly Me too. The chills are real.

[@user-ld5wy3er3x]

yeah like, this cover is now a classic among the vocaloid/utau fandom

[@kan9476]

I thought I was the only one

[@alishademan5452]

that's true

[@juanmagg5909]

I hope those 5 seconds between 0:40 and 0:45 really draw a line that all vocaloids could follow in a near future... it sounds SO realistic, the breathing, the growling, it really add feelings to this song like a real human would do.

[@reimuhkrei]

kyaami release all vy1 voice capabilities.. :3

[@enriquecampos212]

Like a real singer. But it actually sounds decent.

[@김하늘-t7r]

이게...5년 됐구나...,ㅅㅂ...믿을 수가 없네 진짜

[@오늘저녁-j4p]

하 고등학생때 듣던 노래가 진짜 벌써 5 년이라니~

[@modforge]

이제 10년 가까이됨 ㅋㅋ

[@rcoon0708]

이제 10년입니다..

[@w00nae]

V5가 나온 지금까지 이 조교를 뛰어넘는 곡은 없는듯.. 진짜 숨소리랑 목소리 긁는거랑.. 너무 완벽함 보컬로이드가 아니라 진짜 감정을 실어서 노래하는 사람같음

[@힘내세요]

숨소리가 진짜 미쳤음

[@야니들진짜너무한다]

저는 살면서 들었던 보카로 노래들 중에서 이게 제일 사람같았어요....첨들었을때 기계인거 몰랐을 정도로ㄷㄷㄷ

[@겁이나서시작조차안해]

아직까지도 주기적으로 들어줘야함 ㅠㅠㅠ 진짜 레전드

[@familykwon219]

사람이 부른거 아님?

[@박세림-v9o]

@@familykwon219 보컬 전부 기계임

[@나타샤-f5s]

새하얀 채 지냈던 시절로는 돌아갈 수 없다고 했는데, 하얀색만큼 물들기 쉬운 색이 없으니 돌아보지 말라는 말은 헤어졌지만 지금도 사랑했던 그때처럼 사랑하고 있다는 의미... ㅠㅠ 옛날이야기의 뒷이야기가 있고 그걸 들어두라는 것도 다시 시작하고 싶다는 의미 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 가사가 진짜 너무 서정적이고 가슴 아픔....

[@lukmansutanto1882]

Its 2020, but still this cover is still on top of the list for me.

[@reimuhkrei]

Kwkwkwkwk samaa :v pokoknya best lah vy1

[@dchen8874]

ayyy

[@mja6378]

2022 and same

[@kkojii_]

@@reimuhkrei sama -error juga bagus

[@reimuhkrei]

@@kkojii_ yap

[@오쌤-i9h]

정말 찾고싶었는데 제목도 몰라서 몇년 간 듣지 못했던 곡이 갑자기 내 알고리즘에 들어왔다. 왜인지는 모르겠지만 너무 좋다.

[@drowningblue]

Growl would sound good in a song like Error.

[@mc.myerss]

This needs to exist now

[@MonoJelly]

I was exactly thinking that the first time I heard the growl!! It's perfect for Error.

[@lXhikito]

Thanks for that fabulous idea, thank you, seriously.

[@bakeryssoul]

DrowningBlue only if it's used well tho. I've heard a lot of covers in which they overused the growl parameter and it just ruined the whole thing

[@Froggiefairy]

YES!!

[@Zarastroika]

I think VY1 is *seriously* underrated· VY2 as well· I mean, these two *really* deserves more caring from the producers and fandom· Just because they're "anonymous" and "doesn't show their faces" as the others doesn't justify why people seems to don't care at all about them·

[@alexwilliamson6951]

+Zarastroika Not that this comment really needs a reply, but I agree. I also see complaints the VY1 sounds like Rin Kagamine. Not that it necessarily matters much, because both voices are beautiful. I'm just hoping for a VY2 V4, or at least the possible VY4 will be an English version of "him." In my opinion, I actually don't even know why they aren't popular. I mean, I can't figure out the reason why.

[@Zarastroika]

+Indigo Williamson Yeah! Totally~ That says a lot about most fans: That if they doesn't have a pretty face and/or have no design, most people are likely to ignore them· For most it seems that looks are more relevant than voices· ;-; How ironic· From the roots, that's what VOCALOID was supposed to be, to focus: Voice·

[@alexwilliamson6951]

Zarastroika A lot of people like the designs! I do as well, but people overlook the sword and hairpin. Not to mention they're both really cool designs of a sword and hairpin. Also, the pink. People overlook the pink, for example VY2 because it's a male vocal. So they're like, "Oh, well, it's probably feminine or something weird." It depends on the person. I mean weird as in not a "normal" or "realistic" male vocal. And you're right, ironically we're talking about the designs, not the voice. People complain about Piko's design, but listen to the voice! The design might be cool or not, but the voice is good! (when in the right hands)

[@Zarastroika]

Indigo Williamson I did not say that I don't like them, I meant that for many people they gives more attention to looks than voices· Like, see Miku· Her voice is nice · when it's used properly, sadly it's not the case with most songs · but the VYs are more professional, if you know what I mean· But see how many millions of views Miku songs got that both VYs couldn't even get close· In fact, pretty ponytails catches much more buzz than professional singing and mellower songs· I'm pretty sure if Miku didn't got her looks, she would be much less popular·

[@alexwilliamson6951]

Zarastroika Did I say that you didn't! Oh, my gosh, that's not what I meant at all! I'm sorry! I meant that it's just how people judge by looks, but I guess that's how a lot of the world goes. I see what you mean. I'm thinking it like how when a VOCALOID cover a song like, I don't know, a JB song, fans love it (the few fans that actually listen). I think the twin tail part just caught on, and as a younger girl--as compared to MEIKO or KAITO--more people became interested. I've noticed some people like it less when Miku doesn't have her ponytails, or when her hair is cut for certain songs or MMD models. It's just become her trademark, and people like it.

[@20051106ing]

갑자기 오랜만에 듣고싶어서 왔다. 이 노래를 하루종일 들었던게 얼마 안된거 같은데 벌써 5년이 지났네..

[@MusiicRoolz]

I THOUGHT THIS WAS A REAL SINGER AND THEN SOMEONE WAS LIKE NO ITS VOCALOID?? EHHH

[@mariammohammad50]

it's a utau though..? so I guess there's a real singer behind the screen with a changed voice or whatever that is xD

[@mariammohammad50]

it's a utau though..? so I guess there's a real singer behind the screen with a changed voice or whatever that is xD

[@mariammohammad50]

But.. idk xD I heard this song because akidearest said it's a utau .. so .. sorry if I'm wrong cx *****​ maybe I listened to something else

[@40ounces]

+Mariam Mohammad aki corrected herself in the description and said this was a vocaloid

[@dimmerlights]

Lesson learned: don't trust akidearest

[@muhdzulirfan483]

almost a decade and still a banger.....hope this song will be an eternity of an enlightenment for the next generations.....

[@yuunakosaka8199]

ボーカロイドが歌ってる中でこの曲の声が一番ぐっときた。

[@spicysandwich8943]

Nearly a decade later and this is still some of the best tuning I've ever heard

[@KHS-b2y]

보컬로이드 원픽곡. 집중해서 듣다보면 히사시부리네 부분에서 영상이랑 분위기가 진짜 너무 절묘해서 터져버림

[@jellidrops]

Vy1 and Vy2 are my favorite vocaloids. Even if they don't really have a Sprite (Well, I guess they do now but... Whatever), they sound so real and pretty. Also, you can hear them breath. It just makes them sound more human! I know a lot of people like Vocaloid because it "surpasses" the voice of a human, but a Vocaloid's voice comes from a human. Vy1 and Vy2 just sound so perfect, and their vibrato is great too! I just love them and I wish people would notice them more! Miku and the other get too much attention for their sprites.

[@jellidrops]

ALSO! I'm not trying to hate on Miku and the others! In fact, Rin and Len are my second favorites! I'm just saying that they are more popular because of their Sprites and because they were first. Actually, not even! MEIKO actually came first, but she's not nearly as popular as Miku, it's really just the sprites. People should be focusing on the voice, and these two have amazing voices.

[@riceman541]

Janex they still don't have sprites yet tho

[@azuregraffiti]

every Vocaloid has breaths... you get them as .wav files most just dont feel like adding them... Also Meiko had no -what you call- a Sprite (they are called avatars; Sprites are what you use in video games for example Mario in Super Mario World is a sprite) from the beginning, that was just a package design and never intended to reflect the persona of the vocaloid. the first one to do that was Sweet Ann, who was released I think a couple days prior.

[@imnyon332]

ME TOO ! I'M FEEL SO LONELY THAT MY FRIENDS DON'T LIKE VOCALOIDS...... I LOVE VY2, VY1 AND THOSE UNPOPULAR VOCAL UTAU SO MUCH BUT NOBODY KNOW. QAQ

[@iantune]

its because of the godly tuning of cillia and not their voice.

[@dezzydream]

Kyaami is officially the goddess of VY1V4.

[@betelgeuse5171]

More like the goddess of tuning

[@2yokun]

8년이 지나도 레전드... 여전히 최고의 커버입니다

[@힘내세요]

이걸 넘을 곡이 없는듯

[@nowimuniversitystudent]

보컬로이드 2012-2014년 때까지만 엄청 좋아하고 그 이후는 몇 년에 한 번씩 생각나는 곡 몇 개 듣는 정도? 근데 이건 진짜 계속 생각남… 처음 들었을 때 충격이 개세서 ㅜㅜ 뭔가 특유의 씹덕스러운 일러도 아니고 가사나 멜로디나 그냥 최고임

[@furikyu]

나왔을 당시에 들었을 때도 소름 돋았는데, 여전히 지르는 파트에서 소름이 돋을 정도로 좋네.... 오랜만에 들어도 역시 명곡은 명곡

[@마미-g6g]

진짜 이 노래를 뛰어넘을 조교가없네 ㄷㄷ..

[@memo9]

that growl is fucking amazing omg marry me

[@memo9]

yea i meant kyaami lmao

[@Jennacraa]

omfg ikr i would give up my life savings for kyaami

[@user-xh5fg8tl9z]

ボカロの無限の可能性を感じますね(´・ω・｀)

[@pecco4462]

もはや人間 どうしたらこんな調教できるんだ…ほんとcilliaさん何者…好きです

[@ユックリミケさま-x5l]

ぷにわさ すみません。このコメント読むまで歌い手さんが歌ってるのかと思ってました… すご…

[@rikelle7718]

몇년째 다시 들어도 기계에 감정이 있는거 같다니까

[@nolienn]

Kyaami, it’s been 7 years, and I still believe you’re a genius

[@mizuhon.7145]

あの日みたいな朝靄がかかる 足がもつれては、手を取った 解けない魔法のような御伽話覚えてる？ 続きがまだ…うん、また話すね 暗い海に浮かぶ二人が　寂しくないように 神様がきっと少しだけきっと　許した時間 重なり合う星のモノグラムに応えて あなたが来てるんだ　声を張り上げて軌道上の先へ あなただけの輝きに憧れ続けてたの 真っ白なまま過ごしたあの頃には戻れないのに 別れの刻はすぐにやってきて 話したかったことも半分くらいで 「せわしない日だね。」って笑い合う二人は 再会の環に思いを馳せた 時の魔力が変えた　枝垂れ桜の遊歩道も　心も 気付いてしまっても振り向かないでね 白ほど染まりやすい色はないの 一人では輝けない私からね 御伽話の続きがあるの　聞いておいて 久しぶりね 重なり合う鼓動が命の瞬きを教えてくれてる 誰の愛を受けても消えないでしょう あと数秒で離れていく星を見送るなら 例え何千年経っても会えるから　そういう話よ 約束ね 約束ね

[@TAKANSHOU]

澪千影 ありです！

[@rynrineru]

I lost it at 0:42 it was epic

[@sinqsliva4812]

+Ryusaki Hatsue ikr?! it sounded like a real person would

[@zrel7019]

+Ryusaki Hatsue Rip feels

[@aemiko8726]

HAVE YOU HEARD 3:22 THAT SHITE TOOK THE CAKE OML

[@Mintchip24681]

To this day, still the absolute best use of VY1V4 I've ever heard ;w;

[@mkt1194]

喉から声でてるわ…ここまで感情を表現できるって本当にすごいな 何回聞いてもグロウに感動する

[@syntheticvocalist-p472]

...what....

[@HazeEmry]

December 19 this turns 10. I'm setting a reminder for then to celebrate 10 years of this amazing song

[@DonnChandaisuki]

조교 개잘했네 지금봐도

[@smm-q6x]

하 초딩 때 데이터도 없던 때 영상 저장해서 학원 오고 가는 길에 맨날 들었던 거 생각나네... 지금 거의 7년이 지났는데 초딩 때 이후로 내 기억 속에서 사라졌다가 지금 어쩌다가 다시 들었는데 하 진짜 해석 가사는 기억도 안 나는데 일본어 가사는 다 따라할 수 있는 거 보고 진짜 소름이 돋았다 게다가 지금 들어도 띵곡이고 지금 들어도 보컬로이드 같다기보다 여전히 사람이 부른 것 같이 자연스러움... 결론은 진짜 띵곡 ㅠㅠ

[@franciscanel4170]

Listens to the song 0:40 *chokes on saliva*

[@A-To]

i replay that part many times... can't believe vocaloids capable to bring out such natural humanly voice.

[@Ritsuuki]

+Tonrasumange Andi found you! hahaha

[@A-To]

Ritsuuki Glad to find u here :D

[@ariabellagaming1904]

francisca nel THAT SCREECH AND GRAVEL MADE ME LOSE IT!

[@iwayanbagus2271]

i got chill lol

[@user-zi8jq3ir7h]

重なり合うで高評価ｂ　ほんとビックリした

[@AnyaF-y7p]

Even with the emergence of vocaloid ai this has aged so well! I always come back to it

[@queue7708]

몆년이 지났어도 처음 들었을때의 전율과 소름을 잊을 수 없다

[@bear-haribo]

ㄹㅇ ㅆㅇㅈ

[@nogiyu]

ㄹㅇ ㅆㅇㅈ

[@꺽지-s9b]

왜 이 띵곡이 스포티파이에 없는거냐

[@광견-z4i]

지금 들어도 소름

[@kangdo-z4h]

처음 듣고 이게 사람이 아니라고...? 하면서 혼란왔었는데

[@_milcha]

헐 와 우연히 봤는데 너무 신기해요 초반에 내지르는 부분 진짜 사람같아서 놀라서 5번이나 연달아 돌려들었네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 게다가 멍때리고 들으면 순간순간 그냥 사람같았다가 기계소리가 살짝 들리는거로 아 맞다 이거 보컬로이드였지 이러고 있어요.....

[@Joebizness.]

man revisiting this is nostalgic as heck, doesn't even feel like 8 years has gone by since I listened to this. Time Surely flies!

[@고구마-n7j]

어렸을땐 노래만 들어서 몰랐는데 PV 슬프다.. 제대로 왼손에 반지 끼라고 할때 노래하고 분위기 너무 잘 어울려서 소름돋음

[@justlikelemonjuice]

0:41 がなりに気を取られがちだけど、ここ息を吸う感じも再現してて好き

[@ryshichuan5376]

中学生の頃に聞いて思わず泣いた1曲。飽き性な私がずっと聴いてるぐらい大好きな曲です。

[@데우스-s2n]

어느새 잊어버린 곡이지만 다즈비님의 커버곡 알림을 보고 떠올라, 충격을 받고 바로 뛰어왔습니다. 비록 처음으로 접한 건 티비플 영상이였지만 제가 이 곡을 잊었다는 것에 대해서 적잖은 충격을 받았습니다... 마치 어린시절 제가 겪었던 것들을 눈치채지 못한 새에 버리고 온듯한 느낌이 들어 순간 멍때리고 말았습니다. 다시 접한 만큼, 두 번은 곡을 잊고 싶지 않습니다.

[@jjongjjong12]

기계음때문에 보컬로이드 원래 잘 안 들었는데 이 노래는 어릴 때부터 계속 듣는 중ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ또 와버렸다...

[@나나-g5n3f]

과하지 않고 담백하면서도 중간중간 질러주는 맛이 정말 세련된 것 같음. 덤덤하게 불러서 더 벅차오르는 느낌. 지금 보니깐 이 커버 말고도 음악의 악기 사운드나 가사나 뮤비도 시대를 앞서나간 세련됨을 갖추고 있는 것 같다.

[@Jirai]

Is this even vocaloid?! This is soooo amazing!! Can't wait to get my hands on them argggghh

[@lunisenlilja]

Jacen’s gaming channel It's a vocaloid. VY1 is a Vocaloid

[@frankieloinandgroin]

Jacen’s gaming channel Did you even see what she put for VY1’s desc.?

[@frankieloinandgroin]

Jacen’s gaming channel I should’ve said did you even see the top comment on that video? She literally explains, sorry guys I made a mistake. Y’know unless you saw the video exactly 2 years ago before she even made that comment.

[@frankieloinandgroin]

Jacen’s gaming channel You said you were gonna comment that fairytale was a vocaloid song when it first came out?

[@frankieloinandgroin]

Jacen’s gaming channel Why would you have restated what she said if you already saw the comment? That’s pointless.

[@T_Y_Track]

사람을 뛰어넘음 진짜… 이게 9년전이라니

[@kira0loka]

OMGSH im in love with this song! ;/////;

[@gc99099]

buzzg 원곡은 지르는 부분이 없어서 오히려 슴슴하고 료헤이 우타이테 버전은 긁으면서 지르는게 좋지만 랩때문에 조금 짜치는데 그 두개를 미친듯한 조교로 퀄리티가 엄청나게 섞어버렸으니 몇년이 지나도 질리지가 않는듯

[@IkeanerReborn]

three hundred years later and this still gives me goosebumps in the final chorus, it's a crime I can't listen to these on spotify really

[@Starsandstardust]

i'm impressed more about the fact that op made this song ONE DAY after this vocaloid's release. like damn

[@tsukiru-san1786]

If you're in singing along here: ano hi mitai na asamoya gakakaru ashi ga mo tsurete wa, te wo totta tokenai mahou no youna otogi banashi oboeteru? tsuzuki gama da…un, mata hanasu ne kurai umi ni ukabu futari ga sabishiku nai youni kamisama ga kitto sukoshi dake kitto yurushita jikan kasanari au hoshi no monoguramu ni kotaete anata ga kiterunda koe wo hari agete kidou jou no saki e anata dake no kagayaki ni akogare tsuzuketeta no masshiro na mama sugoshita ano koro ni wa modorenai noni wakare no toki wa sugu ni yatte kite hanashi takatta koto mo hanbun kurai de 「sewa shinai hi da ne.」tte warai au futari wa saikai no wa ni omoi wo haseta toki no maryoku ga kaeta shidare zakura no yuu hodou mo kokoro mo kizuite shimatte mo furi mukanai de ne shiro hodo somari yasui iro wa nai no hitori de wa kagayake nai watashi kara ne otogi banashi no tsuzuki ga aru no kiite oite hisashi buri ne kasanari au kodou ga inochi no mabataki wo oshiete kureteru dare no ai wo ukete mo kienai deshou ato suubyou de hanarete iku hoshi wo mio kuru nara tatoe nanzen nen tatte mo aeru kara sou iu hanashi yo yakusoku ne yakusoku ne

[@Siki_kurumi]

もう4年も経ったのか……実感湧かないなあ…ずっと聴いてるし…

[@bluejayperegrine]

THE GROW L S ARE FUCKING FANTASTIC HOLY SHIT

[@shu-kun0906]

がなるのほんとに好き

[@BohyunChung]

갑자기 생각나서 왔는데 진짜 눈물날것같음 너무 좋다 ㅠ

[@PARK-b7k]

ㅇㅈㅇㅈ ㅠㅠㅜ

[@theloganroe]

I literally get chills everytime I hear this. Its a shame its not on spotify

[@모선-b6x]

僕の学生時代を一緒に過ごした歌です。 作ってくださってありがとうございます。歌に感動からかですか。 少し涙が出ます。

[@3honeymoon]

이 노래 알고 들은지는 꽤 됐는데.. 보컬로이드쪽은 거의 문외한이라 이게 보컬로이드곡인거 안지 얼마 안됐을 정도로 너무 자연스럽다ㄷㄷ 단지 기계음일 뿐인데 감정이 고스란히 느껴지는게 정말 신기하네요..

[@miharuhareta1900]

3:17 ここからラスサビにかけて、寂しいとか悲しいとかの類の感情が込み上げてくる 凄すぎる

[@gedwed6715]

저때 특이점이 왔구나 생각했는데 이제서야 Suno AI 같은걸로 티가 나기 시작함.. 몇년을 앞서가셨던겨..

[@furmir11]

몇 년째 듣지만 목 긁는 소리가 진짜 레전드임... 매번 여기서 소름 돋아

[@uumuu]

0:39 not gonna lie I got chills as she took a breath and came alive even if just for a second

[@Goku16]

9 years later, still one of my favourite music pieces. Gives me such strong feelings every time, simply by the way it is arranged. You're really so damn good at this ❤

[@재수생-v9c]

Dk tlqkf 가사까지 ㅁㅊ 것 같애 아무것도 모른 채 지냈던 그 시절로는 돌아갈 수 없는데 초딩 때 들었던 걸 지금 다시 듣고 가사 보면서 눈물 개터짐 씹

[@AFreezer]

Still getting the same chills even after years. Especially when I heard that growl.

[@user-vd6cu2vt8x]

어릴 때도 이 노래 듣고 울었는데 여전히 들으면 울게 되네요 성인이 되어도 그때처럼 헤매고 다시 돌아갈 수 없는 어릴 때가 그립기도 하지만 노래 덕분에 변치않는 제 모습을 다시 찾았어요 고마워요

[@중혁유-h5z]

진짜 한동안 잊고있었던 곡인데 오랜만에 들으니까 좋다

[@caramelatte5477]

5 years after and I still cant believe that growl.

[@TripleGatan]

Same, it's incredible

[@KianeChulaKing]

I'm crying Vocaloid 4 is incredible so far, so much more organic sounding and emotional and I am legitimately crying shit I'm way over my head with how obsessed I am over Vocaloids

[@小野寺睦-n3u]

一番初めの「かさなりあう」の「な」が好き

[@こね-m2e]

重なりの〝な〟が鳥肌

[@purplejewls7443]

this song is a feat of modern technology

[@chimpark7504]

well said ;A;

[@_Rhatsody]

I can already hear the annoying covers with people overusing the growl

[@_Rhatsody]

Naruto Uzumaki rrrrrraaawwwrr. It only sounds good when hakaine Maiko does it lol

[@matias0007h]

Zephyr - P Hakaine Maiko V4 dream :X

[@_Rhatsody]

Matúš Horváth exactly. My vocaloid wet dream.

[@matias0007h]

Zephyr - P after Macne fail it wloud be nice...

[@_Rhatsody]

Matúš Horváth I wouldn't call it failure. I love Nana and all her imperfections

[@chRl-fv8oc]

아 스포티파이에 추가좀해랔제발

[@イチロー-l8y]

何回聞いてもサビの鳥肌やばい

[@마치-f6w]

초딩때 봤던건데 그때 충격받아서 성인된 지금까지 기억하고 오랜만에 다시 듣네 여전히 좋다..

[@juanmagg5909]

A bit more than a year has passed and I still cant find other song that uses a growling like this one

[@폴짝뛰기유단자-u1m]

0:42 오져따..

[@飛鳥-t4x]

無性に聴きたくなる

[@giny0317]

ㅜㅜㅜㅜ이거 들을때마다 노래도 너무좋고 조교도 너무 잘됐구...넘좋다ㅜㅜ♡♡

[@27분의우메보시]

아띠 ㅇㅈ 기계음도 많이없어요

[@cat12345763]

ano hi mitai na asamoya gakakaru ashi ga mo tsurete wa, te wo totta tokenai mahou no youna otogi banashi oboeteru? tsuzuki gama da…un, mata hanasu ne kurai umi ni ukabu futari ga sabishiku nai youni kamisama ga kitto sukoshi dake kitto yurushita jikan kasanari au hoshi no monoguramu ni kotaete anata ga kiterunda koe wo hari agete kidou jou no saki e anata dake no kagayaki ni akogare tsuzuketeta no masshiro na mama sugoshita ano koro ni wa modorenai noni wakare no toki wa sugu ni yatte kite hanashi takatta koto mo hanbun kurai de 「sewa shinai hi da ne.」tte warai au futari wa saikai no wa ni omoi wo haseta toki no maryoku ga kaeta shidare zakura no yuu hodou mo kokoro mo kizuite shimatte mo furi mukanai de ne shiro hodo somari yasui iro wa nai no hitori de wa kagayake nai watashi kara ne otogi banashi no tsuzuki ga aru no kiite oite hisashi buri ne kasanari au kodou ga inochi no mabataki wo oshiete kureteru dare no ai wo ukete mo kienai deshou ato suubyou de hanarete iku hoshi wo mio kuru nara tatoe nanzen nen tatte mo aeru kara sou iu hanashi yo yakusoku ne yakusoku ne You're welcome.

[@Kitadayo]

I cannot believe that it has been more than 8 years since I first heard this cover... Time flies by, I still love this one!

[@YuutsushiToshiro]

GODNESS.

[@DarkKudoh]

Sabía que te vería por aquí xD

[@〆サバ-w6c]

これ本当好き

[@kim-sx7sn]

보컬로이드임에도 불구하고 진짜 들을때마다 그 감정 때문에 울컥하게 되네...

[@힘내세요]

매번 엉엉 움

[@J슈아]

오랜만에 다시 들어도 정말 좋은 노래야... 가사 보면서 따라부르는데 왜 눈물이 나는지

[@piia1917]

"Oh yeah, the harmonies might sound kinda bad so sorry about that AHAH.... " WHAT DO YOU MEAN BY BAD? This is heavenly~!