龍鳳爭掛帥之爭帥 - 林家聲 汪明荃 阮兆輝 尹飛燕

[@chanmay2919]

聲哥唱做一流👍汪亞姐聽到你毛管棟

[@amyfung9274]

我同意

[@user-hs7tf5gl8q]

同意

[@mas-yb1jw]

聲哥一片好心，圓汪阿姐粵劇夢！

[@user-pi4kk5pn8i]

林家聲配陳好逑是一流的。👍👍👍👍

[@queeniechow3214]

林家聲功架風采不會忘懷

[@hooikwan1221]

多謝分享，萬分感激，非常難得一套折子戲，🤩😍👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👏👏👏👏👏👏👏💞💞💞🎉🎉

[@petercheung-pg2rv]

因近日網上熱議阿姐跟聲哥陳年紛爭，再细看本片，真係冇得講，２人一出場，比較之下更顯聲哥大老倌功架，無論舉手投足關目轉身，都顯示到聲哥要爭帥印的決心。细心欣賞比較，完全唔同级數，粵劇演員係要靠對眼做戲，唔係淨識得睩大對眼，要比觀眾從演員的靈魂之窗看出其內心，就算我童年時常跟祖母入荔園睇大戲啲演員都做到。尹飛燕出場唱幾句，已經有幾個不同關目表情，對男方的輕蔑譏諷，學星爺話齋，由內而外發出來，完美示範甚麽才是大戲。當然，如果係東華義演就無所謂啦，但组班開戲要觀眾買飛入場，當年仲要成200元一張飛，梗有要求。不過這片段好像是阿姐跟聲哥學了４個月戲後的歡樂今宵試演，無謂苛求。可是阿姐的唱腔多年來都冇法突破，妹腔唔似妹腔，京腔唔似京腔。其實自從粵劇出了個芳艷芬之後，全部花旦都要跟著轉腔，唔能夠再唱到好似上海妹、譚蘭卿那種吊高啜子的唱腔，徐仁心轉唔到便被芳姐取代。只要聽返仙姐早期唱腔便知分別。粵劇花旦唱腔跟其他地方戲曲不同，花旦唱腔要油潤、滋音，拉的時候聽来特到舒服，而且一聽便分得出芳艷芬、紅線女、李寶瑩、崔妙芝、冼劍麗、吴君麗、鳳凰女、陳好逑.......未能盡錄。

[@daisandra8572]

的確多謝版主播放林家聲劇目他配那個花旦都好睇好聽極有水準。 但如果花旦掉轉由尹飛燕做會更好得多多聲

[@Minniehon188]

多謝版主播放林家聲與汪明荃合作戲劇節目〈從未看過〉🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@alicecrom9048]

聲哥曲藝已達高峰，但阿姐也算中規中矩。很好看的表演！

[@raymondyeung2791]

Thanks for sharing well done good job.

[@user-ke6nc3sp5l]

林家聲

[@user-pi4kk5pn8i]

林家聲先生，永遠懷念他！👍👍👍👍🙏🙏🙏🙏🤩🤩🤩🤩

[@hooikwan1221]

永遠懷念一代宗師林家聲博士🙏🙏🙏

[@waichunlau5556]

😅

[@paulinechua276]

感谢分享👍👍👍❤️

[@cheangshukee]

真係好戏。谢谢。

[@raymondyeung2791]

Master Lam Ka Sing was amazing.

[@tungwong424]

當年唱功曳的，但做一流，又靚👍👍

[@chinmeilo9959]

吾覺得佢靚，就算靚又如何，「聲、色、藝」沒有「聲」與「藝」免強做落去，只得個殼，沒有靈魂，談不上藝術。

[@yinyang3936]

亞姐當年是电视火红，如果能虚心向声哥学习（以師礼相待）其在粤剧成就肯定比今天更勝！而声哥也可能欲借亞姐電視界名聲加強他及粵劇推廣；而最後聲哥只能回歸麗姐及球姐（因為李寶瑩當時要照顧羅家英、而且汪亞姐當年甚紅而且比麗姐球姐年輕近二十年也）。當年聲歌粵剧造藝正值巔峰、阿姐是錯失良機的！

[@hooikwan1221]

聲哥當年和亞姐合作是覺得亞姐係有心學習又因亞姐也是有一定的號召力，望能吸引更多人欣賞粵劇，聲哥的號召力當然不需要阿姐為佢爭取名器

[@user-Q-HK]

我覺得汪明荃事事追求完美 當年都係有心做好件事 但貴為電視台一姐 加上當時可能未太了解粤劇行文化 係好講求排資論輩 响排練期間因巨大壓力先向大老倌發脾氣 可惜今次發脾氣非同小可 引起軒然大波 我覺得阿姐自己都知道理虧 但係事情已經無法挽回 加上當年40歲依然氣焰強勁 所以未識撲火 三十幾年佢自己做花旦 應該好了解大戲行規矩 佢亦已75歲高齡 大老倌亦已作古人 一切都過去了 我覺得佢初期做八和主席 一來係呢個豬頭骨位無人願做 二來係八和班老前輩想睇下佢點死 點知汪明荃做大戲5係好得 做主席就好掂 可能佢亦想為自已爭番口氣 人地睇死佢5得 佢就偏偏要得 睇左佢做電視幾十年 多多少少都睇得出佢性格 越多人彈佢唱歌5得 佢越要唱 話佢唱王菲首歌似唱大戲 佢更加唱多幾次 佢自已亦知自已事 所以上親台 即使只係做嘉賓都落足本 打扮到最靚 因為佢知道咩叫明星 歌5得 起碼要似番個大明星 光鮮亮麗

[@user-rg4yb3iu5b]

@@hooikwan1221 香港粤剧如果没有阿姐这样的领导力就凭那些男人那么粤剧也不会有今天的成就，看看阿姐做八合会主席那些男人是怎么扯后腿的。

[@sky-uw6cl]

強強相遇, 不難聽過老戲行習慣, 我唔肯定背後聲哥有冇擺起老倌架子 同一句可以是禮貌交流, 也可以是”直不甩”擺前輩款(講實話但冇禮貌唔係大晒), 以現代角度非常落後, 連教小朋友也不會接受

[@linma6505]

It is great to see Lisa Cantonese Opera performance , which I never seen . She is a marvelous lady ! Thank you for uploading and sharing high-definition full screen . It is awesome !

[@sky-uw6cl]

She looks perfectly charming in all performance & talented all rounded, while sometimes denounced her voice by netizens, to me she sings beautifully

[@poupouwahfu9552]

阿姐吾係紅衭子出生，唱時代曲都吾夠氣，

[@bronsonlkm5875]

Fantastic moment while watching n listening to this Fantasy video! Sounds good n light, brilliant melody songs, delightful singing n great voice singers. Awesome opera show!💖🎶🤔

[@TomTom-og3tv]

阿姐同家英哥的死症😶‍🌫️😶‍🌫️ 就是聲綫單薄！ 尤其是汪明荃加上中氣不足 能在梨園舞臺立足 只憑電視上 得來的‘’名氣‘’兩字🙈🙈🙈

[@unlenglou7844]

說得正確中肯，呢兩個人如果唔係用名氣人氣搭夠，唱造不佳，一早俾有實力資深老倌踢出梨園👎👎

[@TomTom-og3tv]

@@unlenglou7844 不過阿姐能辦事👜, 為梨園做了不小功德💰☕🫖, 這是肯定的✌️人心團結萬事成🏆加油🙏

[@TomTom-og3tv]

@@unlenglou7844 羽佳也仙遊了！ 今天大陸粤劇步向歌劇化, 梨園承傳也要講運啊！政治氣勢才是王道！！

[@yywongable]

汪唱粤曲真不敢……領教

[@koontunglee4879]

認同

[@user-rg4yb3iu5b]

真正懂粤曲的到底有多少人。

[@laimengchoy1445]

到底是电视演员出身，当年很红。粤剧是後来兴趣，能唱就不錯了，不如你來唱😂

[@LittlelionDragon]

兩個人唱歌都很好聽

[@meekingtong2887]

多謝晒，真係未睇過

[@longfu1431]

應該是歡樂滿東華。

[@eddiechow3977]

粵劇冇得速成

[@unlenglou7844]

正確，台上一分鐘，台下十年功，想借自己名氣一夜成名？華光先師都保你唔住。

[@user-sv5gv5gv1f]

阿姐唱粤曲好像唱时代曲，没有粤曲味道

[@kwokpiuleung9841]

當時阿姐應該下個一番功夫!😊

[@Minniehon188]

懇請多播出林汪劇目❣️🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@puishanng7723]

林家聲同汪明荃譚炳文做粵劇未看過

[@kamho7617]

f 你估阿姐蠢呀 他也借助聲哥當時在粵劇界也是一哥地位，她想錯了，以為個個喺英哥呀

[@user-rg4yb3iu5b]

阿姐唱的真是好，香港粤剧如果没有阿姐这样的领导力就凭那些男人那么粤剧也不会有今天的成就。

[@rolljollanniieex]

😂😂

[@chinmeilo9959]

拍汪汪姐馬屁，「踏低别人抬高自己」，低招！

[@tungwong424]

其實汪明荃，真的好叻女💯💯👍👍

[@juneeng1652]

汪阿姐唔唱 !😛

[@yuenwahauyeung3052]

亞姐太好勝了 以為樣樣都得。

[@chansewpingmariachanchan7675]

Excellent. !

[@kwaikeunglui2251]

普通一個梅香也好過亚姐

[@waichingyu5380]

我很佩服汪明荃！扮相一流！人人都有初階！

[@mamasun2557]

汪亞姐👍👍👍！

[@paktang8333]

汪明荃畢竟不是唱粵曲家,連基本唱腔音韻也沒有.雖知粵曲不是一朝一夕能學成,沒有十年八載苦功難成大器.

[@derektrotter3053]

阿姐當年身手真係「硬朗」！😂

[@darnaychan5461]

汪明荃唱粵曲，不唱也罷！

[@andrewwong8118]

眾人中，啊姐真係差很多，真的不懂唱大戲！連炳哥比她好。

[@sky-uw6cl]

阿姐很美, 八和主席做實事不是掛名只靠名氣, 以當時新人來說關目身段做手都做得很稱職

[@alicecrom9048]

Lisa is an excellent actress !!!👍👍👍

[@malai857]

亞姐花旦扮相很美，不是粤劇功底，拍聲一定比下去，唱粤曲發口不同流行曲

[@liewkaisun6850]

....she thought that migrating pre recorded tv series to the " live " big stage acting would be as easy as saying " ABC "....needless to say, her Legend of White Snake project was a flop...as she is nit from the " school of red pants" mean that she has not received the basic necessary skill training as a huadan performer from young.......I would appreciate if someone could let me know who is her Sifu....for we all know that in the life of Cantonese opera actors n actresses, LINEAGE is so very important just as in the pugilistic world of " jiang hu" that we see in the kungfu movies aiithnd tv series ...OR maybe Ms Liza taught herself by resorting to self-help books n recordings of famous n successful actors n actresses....in which case Ms LWang would have the distinction of being HongKong's First DIY Cantonese huadan.....three cheers for her.....!!! Watching this video we all would agree that it was such a mismatch....our legendary Sing Kor was so magnanimous to consent to team up with a half-baked performer with little skills n a squeaky voice at best...

[@marianaleung1818]

难能可贵，惊喜。

[@mamasun2557]

名氣啊！

[@kenbenny6689]

當年 " 麗莎...汪亞姐 "，因要突破自己，所以玩廣東大戲，記得當時她說過，如果呢台戲成功的話，會邀請 " 寶珠姐 " 復出做第二台戲，可惜惨敗收場。 但係皇天不負有心人，响2004年全體八和弟子，合力每位演出一場 " 帝女花 "，到最後一場 " 香夭 "，終於得償如願；跟 " 寶珠姐 " 合拍演出。

[@chinmeilo9959]

汪汪姐在各大老倌羣中很特出，與眾不同，吾知佢拜誰為師？可能是無師自通。

[@yuenwahauyeung3052]

當年佢拜梁素琴為師。

[@yeepinglo5304]

樓主可否加大字幕，雖然好精彩，但媽媽都聽不明白，十分可惜

[@lowong1781]

汪明荃未達粤劇水平

[@kettylee1742]

實在太差

[@springsummer7900]

唱時代曲

[@liewkaisun6850]

You are so right....Ms Liza Wang is just an impostor....a tv series actress trying her luck to be an opera star...with no training n no skills she is a dismal failure and a total embarrassment to the Cantonese opera loving fraternity...a great pretender...

[@glorialaw3998]

每一位演员都有最初级时后若干年后才有今天，拿一个大老官同初哥比太唔公平。

[@LoveToBeFree8135]

林汪配，失策。

[@ssiu100]

還未擘網巾之時

[@shirleyc9038]

點解係汪明荃？

[@yongo2988]

)

[@lamlam4388]

汪明荃不是粤劇的

[@longfu1431]

又不是帶孝。為何身掛白球呢？

[@cantonesesing9234]

胸前球不同於頭頂球，非喪事也可用白色。如劉備過江超親，趙子龍亦是掛白球。

[@longfu1431]

@@cantonesesing9234 白球不是應配白色大扣嗎，趙云傳統是勻扣，周瑜是粉紅扣，不是嗎，請前輩指教。😊

[@waipingcheung4730]

孤陋寡聞,無論什麼顏色,自己喜好,又何必計較,結婚有人用紅色,有人用白色,唔通辦喪事咩,請尊重中國文化傳統,雞蛋裡面了骨頭,

[@tungwong424]

你地去學唱粤曲初時都一樣呀，唔好話人嗱，你又人咁靚咩

[@hooikwan1221]

同意！亞姐花旦扮相的確很靚，我都相當佩服佢學習嘅毅力，但可惜佢捉咗鹿都唔識脫角，白白失卻跟名師學習的機緣，如當年佢不是太驕傲，今時的粵劇藝術可能會令有改觀的一面。

[@amyfung9274]

先天不足,没有天份,什麼師父也沒用.

[@liewkaisun6850]

Ms Liza Wang is a small screen actress parading and promoting herself as a Cantinese opera huadan....at best she is a half baked huadan without the necessary basic skills n voice training to perform on stage...the elderly generation will remember her foray into stage acting decades ago when she and famed legendary Canto-pop singer Mr Roman Tam staged The Legend of White Shake ...we all know very well that Roman Tam was trained in Cantonese opera since young in the mainland beforehand going over to HKong n could handle the demands of the role....but not Ms Wang....she thought that migrating from small screen (TV acting

[@sammyluc9742]

Koiu

[@kianhonglam2360]

难得汪亚姐有天份能做到外行人有7O多分，难得

[@analei1939]

汪明荃唱得真難聽，口白又不能

[@glorialaw3998]

假的我叫你个头戴住咁多野我想你企不起身仲 叫你做手和唱，弹人你就巴闭

[@mzee5409]

Miss Wong is not qualified to sing Cantonese opera.

[@wilsonwong2984]

阿姐做都可以, 唱就有D時代曲感, 炳門聲都幾靚但冇力水.

[@longfu1431]

炳文哥唱咗好耐粵曲喇，佢有錄碟，我也唱過，講西施嘅，曲名忘記了。

[@wilsonwong2984]

@@longfu1431 我知, 佢唱粵曲就唔及粵時代曲了, 始終發聲方法有唔同, 粵曲系講味為主.

[@andrewtam3185]

@@wilsonwong2984 agreed

[@andrewtam3185]

唱就有D時代曲感..... yes lol 冇力水.味

[@jonathanhos6031]

Wilson Wong 非常贊成你講，汪明荃根本唔識唱粵曲！

[@user-rg4yb3iu5b]

香港粤剧如果没有阿姐这样的领导力就凭那些男人那么粤剧也不会有今天的成就，看看阿姐做八合会主席那些男人是怎么扯后腿的。