紐約/倫敦街訪：你對香港反送中的看法是什麼？Do You Know About HK Anti-Extradition Protest │老外看香港│郝毅博 Ben Hedges│新唐人電視台

[@kengoy2001]

我知道有些人會用言論自有來說一些傷害人的話；但是你要記住，當你說出這句話被看到的同時就表示你已經接受了自由社會所給予你的言論自由，因為即便人們不喜歡、不認同，依舊給予你說出意見的言論自由，而這是那些只要不認同就直接禁止你的社會所不能給予的

[@locktar8723]

純喫茶 虚伪！你去那帮香港人面前说一句哪怕是中立的话，看那帮废青揍不揍你？真他妈好笑

[@無罪-r7u]

重新定義了中立呢

[@lilysmith6055]

所以为什么好多香港的视频在外网上被下架了呢，这又是哪门子言论自由

[@eric711229]

一點也沒錯!!! 沒有了自由，不管你喜歡不喜歡都再也不重要了，因為那所謂"偉大的領導"也不會管你想表達什麼，當他們說什麼就是什麼!! 即使你事業有成，也幫助了國家經濟發展，當黨要接管你的事業讓你退休時，你也只能乖乖退休…因為你的一切不是你的，是黨的……真是可悲!!!

[@anniexcat]

嗯嗯，借我引用_(:3」∠ )_

[@朵拉-b3r]

第二次看了還是淚流滿面，好想擁抱每個香港人，請別再傷害他們…

[@陈世美-r3q]

纯粹他妈胡扯，一败胡言，

[@彭-x3i]

香港加油~~~ 你們第一次遊行的時候，我看臉書新聞直播就開始哭了 難以想像身在現場的氛圍該有多可怕 看到半夜兩三點我才關掉 整晚都超低落 第一次覺得我們是一陣線的..... 第一次意識到台灣的好.....

[@李山风-y5q]

一个小女生也这么热衷政治，媒体有这么可信吗？

[@gcyeung1546]

Thank you for standing with Hong Kong. However, it is tragedic that the situation in HK becomes worse. More and more young protesters are found missing and reported to have suspicious suicide.

[@chongmc7208]

我是香港人，看完這片眼淚一直不自覺流下來！過百萬遊行我也自發行出去反對這個不聽民意政府，可惜最後這個政府還不承認自己有錯！真的痛心，在香港住了30多年，我愛香港這地方，所有香港人加油，抗爭係要時間的

[@yantony9039]

都去英国洗盘子🥏了

[@childish8355]

I am a Hongkonger and I am really proud of ourselves.No matter you are 10 years old or 80 years old,you can stand out and protest for the basic right we need.That really make me proud of ourselves.

[@hankwang2850]

I wish you have told the people on the street the truth. They just gave answers based on your own explanation.

[@LoveSeohyunShi]

Hank Wang Almost all videos on the hk issue doesn’t want to show everything that happened, the attacks on the police and vandalizing properties. Those people don’t care about hk, they just want to paint China in a bad light and on KZbin, they love videos like this while the ones supporting the Chinese got deleted or demonetized. Freedom of speech? Ya right, I only saw hypocrisy.

[@jessicayan7109]

Tell the fact, not one side of the story. How about showing them the pictures when the protesters bite off the police officers’ fingers, tried doing that in either the US or the UK, then lecture us about freedom and right!

[@13579water]

There are many other reports about Hong Kong on the Internet. After reading it, we will find that the video here is not objective.

[@mo3399]

身為台灣人˙˙我很心酸。 美麗香港逐漸的不見了。 天祐香港˙˙˙

[@精神裸奔]

想过是谁导致的吗

[@阿嬤的吃飽沒攻擊]

@@精神裸奔 中國共產黨（非所有中國人

[@谭九鼎-h8l]

@@阿嬤的吃飽沒攻擊 香港中文大学是谁破坏的？

[@阿嬤的吃飽沒攻擊]

@@谭九鼎-h8l 那你有想想這一切的導火線只是一群香港人要爭取他/她們的自由，而奪取這些自由的不就是中國共產黨嗎？

[@谭九鼎-h8l]

@@阿嬤的吃飽沒攻擊 那杀几个人放几次火也没什么问题吧，他们只是想争取自由啊，他们还只是孩子？

[@長大後當村長]

從沒出過籠子的鳥 總說飛翔是件怪事

[@rexwoolf8620]

Well said.

[@tsznokli9994]

很好的形容了內地的情況👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@铠豆豆]

也不想想英国殖民移民过那么多地方，新大陆中的美国，澳大利亚，新西兰就不说了，起初土著就没啥数量也死的快，说说原住民多的地方，非洲阿散蒂、达荷美、索科托、布干达等乱七八糟的很多地方，印度，缅甸，斯里兰卡，马来西亚，法国殖民的柬埔寨，老挝，越南，还有一大推北非西非国家，哪个国家自然资源比不上香港这个面积很小的地方，香港的优势来自哪里，为什么只有香港可以成为东方之珠，金融中心？缅甸越南怎么没成金融中心？

[@铠豆豆]

中国大陆清朝以后这段时间不管怎么穷酸，但貌似香港也是因为地缘政治因为香港有英国能从中国赚到钱的价值才能比很多殖民地更富有。瘦死的骆驼比马大，中国再怎么落后只开一个对外窗口，这个窗口就能挣大钱，中国稍微发展一下你们更富，当然那是在改革开放之前，世界变了，没有殖民地了，中国也敢开放不怕民族企业被完虐有底气了，与外界不需要通过香港了，也难怪香港回怀念殖民时期，不是因为那时比现在更富，而是那时完全比大陆更富。现实一点，世界不可能一直维持在中国很弱的时代，中国人一起去变得更好不好吗？香港还貌似一直有优惠政策呢

[@delideli8577]

翅膀都没有长出的鸟儿 总想着飞出自己的巢穴

[@jessiejin2521]

You are not telling the true story of this! You didn't the show the full picture

[@natalielai211]

He is not! He also did not explain the bill correctly!

[@descendant0fdragons]

Actually he did remain neutral as a laowei primary in China, he even speaks putonghua to let you mainlanders know what the big picture is beyond the great firewall of China. Instead of showing everday police brutality displayed by the imported police officers from mainland!!! He really just scratched the surface! He didn't show White shirt mainland Triads beating innocent in yuen long! He didn't show police officers framing protestors have weapons, caught on CCTV!!! He didn't show officers speaking MANDARIN to MANDARIN officers in HKPolice uniform!!! WTF are u guys dumb!!! If I use these tactics in any western country, expect a f*cking WW3!! But they dare use in HK!!!

[@lbilly8790]

@@唯真不破2020 昨天晚上示威者攻占香港机场，群殴内地深圳旅客，暴打并扣押环球时报记者。

[@mrshawndunn]

@@descendant0fdragons 美国间谍都要先学好中文才能来捣乱

[@descendant0fdragons]

@@mrshawndunn 大陸仔... Why would I want you to know what I say, You go back learn english!!! and your crap putonghua

[@bingong6809]

If you dont understand what's the bill is, please do some studies before you goto interview and explain to others.

[@naonaonao7701]

Bin Gong 真相了，这主持人问的问题，根本就是引导性的

[@ethanzu3119]

I think he really knows what the bill is, his Chinese is really good. He just wanted to induce the interviewees to say what he wants. This bill only applies to a part of serious offenders, not including political prisoners.

[@bingong6809]

@@ethanzu3119 good point

[@windbaek1416]

@@naonaonao7701 就是啊

[@西源-l2e]

NAONAO NAO 真相个jb 这主持人说的难道不是事实么 用事实引导有问题吗

[@lifeamanda2680]

每次看到这件事情 每次都是哭着看完的

[@CT-qh1sf]

life Amanda 还有台独势力捣乱香港 煽动香港年轻人情绪 黑暴打伤老弱妇孺 破坏公共设施 搞乱香港 所谓撑香港都是利用而已 台湾是想替代香港的金融业 只是在利用香港 在寰宇全世界节目里被一个美国人说破 台湾人英语不行 金融人才也寥寥 取代不了

[@jokerye877]

哭，都给我哭

[@王军-t5g]

@@CT-qh1sf chi na人…

[@啊门-k3d]

@@CT-qh1sf 不是台湾人做的啊而是中共啊

[@煉丹爐裡滑冰]

鼻酸

[@JasonLee-rh1xm]

You make a explanation first in your view and ask people what do they think. They draw a conclusion on your explanation. That's what you think. Not there's.

[@Momo4378-h1z]

Jason Lee yes I also agree with you.he didn't give a objective explanation

[@jp-nm5gm]

their

[@jeffkwok8833]

yeah, he has a good invention but bad execution

[@lawyermay9889]

Yes,I agree with you,this video didn't tell the truth,it's just a lie.

[@fl0yeeyeah]

TOTALLY AGREE!

[@scorpio3901]

This is not an interview at all. A fair host won’t put things so subjectively. If foreign people really want know what is going on, please go check out yourselves and make your judgements. This video is not telling everything.

[@vivian9321]

From now on, we should support Scotland Independence, instead of putting the focus always on China

[@scorpio3901]

Vivian maybe the host should try to report Scotland stuff and we can see the way how he reports that

[@chorrrpu4422]

I am wondering why these western people are so hypocritical. I can promise we will definitely hear different points of view if these kind of thing just happened in US or UK. They basically know nothing about HK. Only thing they can do is to support those people without thinking. It looks so sweet but actually it is disgusting.

[@ylyr99]

Welcome back and thanks for this piece!!! Big hugs from HK~

[@shukyingao4856]

I am a Hong Kong person Thank you 🙏🏻

[@刘凯撒]

你為什麽不用中文，你不是中國人嗎？ 如果你承認你是中國人，那麽我祝福你。如果你認為你是香港人，那我只能祝福你做夠快樂

[@MsZuckar]

@@刘凯撒 on9

[@美美斯馬爾]

@@刘凯撒 你懂啥是Hong Kong嗎？？？懂英文嗎

[@casparyeung2978]

@@刘凯撒 中國人不能說英文嗎？🤔

[@nghuangngai]

@@刘凯撒 戇鳩鳩

[@guoyuanliu1965]

at least，you should tell the western people the whole story, and then ask your questions.

[@aasammiwu137]

刘国元 clearly he is just telling the part of the story....

[@汉人是你爹]

信息不对称加上双标，再说你觉得西方人真的关心香港吗？就好比纽约大暴乱的话我只会当看戏

[@廢青都是垃圾]

metoo

[@lihenry9052]

yes I agree with you people now see most are fake news they don't what is happening in the street

[@tanyann2700]

终于知道了中国建防火墙的原因，如此歪曲事实，煽动人心，做这种视频出来请问是为了博取眼球还是拍美国政府马屁呢？如果真是有理想、有情怀，为何要扭曲事实来煽动人心。还是长长心动动脑子吧。

[@skyeli474]

You didn't tell the whole truth. You just showed some of the pictures. Why don't you tell them what protesters did like paralyzing the traffic, hitting the elder and assaulting the police force?

[@Puppiesmaster]

report him

[@zacelliot8029]

If you search into the actual and FULLY unedited video clip, you will see that the elder guy from China snack off the protester's poster ... That's why the protester stood near the elder but never hit the old dude. News in China had edited out the part where the old guy smack the poster off the ground.

[@descendant0fdragons]

Shame Chinese citizens can only watch HALF of a NBA game while HK like the rest of the world can watch a Full NBA game. While I even have Cheer-leading and artist performance that only live spectator have, in USA they show commercials instead! Don't expect you see everything as a mainlander!!! Sorry

[@skyeli474]

Actually no one can see everything. When we watch CBA games on TV, we watch ads instead of cheerleading like Americans. This is how it works. Cheerleading isn't for broadcasting. Why do you use this for an example? I just don't get your point.

[@descendant0fdragons]

@@skyeli474 You will never get my point, only non-mainlanders and those jump over the wall, cause they are great athletes will know my point. Sorry

[@nodamemongoose8126]

Ben Hedges had wrongly explained the law to the people in US!!! He said : where they can send people to China to go to court in China. But the fact is that, Hong Kong can send people to foreign who had broken the law of the foreign countries who they escape to Hong Kong . Not only CHINA, but also the other FOREIGN COUNTRIES. PREJUDICE !!!

[@Thefreenebula]

Well, Hong Kong doesn’t have an extradition treaty with China. I don’t get why this is prejudice.

[@whz1991]

freenebula but US does have this kind of treaty with China. Now, you tell me is China controlling the US or what? Do ur homework before you talk

[@sunnyhon65]

@@whz1991 Under the said treaty, US still have the say on Extradition. But in the case of HK, Hong Kong administration has little say to reject an Extradition Order from China, even it is a wrong case.

[@wenyilunyc]

What are you trying to express? Quite confused

[@sunnyhon65]

@@wenyilunyc please refer back to that Thomas W said.

[@可笑的民主专政]

香港，我在这个该死的政治制度下不能亲自来支持你们，但万幸的是，我还能在网络上声援你们，加油！香港!

[@劉晞-f9s]

覺得經歷過古巴社會主義的先生 說到了這次香港會走上街頭的重點了 一直執著逃犯條例的中國人都該聽聽，其實讓香港人暴走的不是單單因為逃犯條例，逃犯條例只是個開端，真正讓香港人暴走的是，自由即將被剝奪的緊張害怕失望！ 對於從沒真正自由過的人 長期被管制控管的人，而言 失去自由是很無感的！ 但相反的對於一個習慣自由的人，而言 失去自由就是被剝奪人身， 被控制自由就是在被掠奪！ 希望，彼此能互相尊重體諒，設身處地的好好想想，如果今天是你 你會怎麼面對？ 彼此都沒有誰對誰錯，畢竟習慣有很大的差異，沒辦法比較，但同理心設身處地的想過後，就比較能彼此尊重彼此諒解了！ 要一個自由的人被管制，那就如同要讓他再歷經一次戒嚴時期，在這人人皆有知識、自由心證能力高漲的年代， 這是很不合理的管制，也是沒自由過的人無法體會的被掠奪感！

[@badgerhoney3003]

你的傻逼自由是用暴力消灭警察吗？

[@九九-v8k]

哦哦 支持你们的打砸自由，犯罪自由，香港罪犯天堂万岁！

[@snowhe1939]

可笑 自由就是阔以肆无忌惮的冲击政府部门，破坏公共财产？

[@pfcai]

你们可以离开啊，去给你们自由的地方，不要阻碍我们中华民族再次崛起。

[@劉晞-f9s]

何來的暴力滅警？ 現場直播你們看的到嗎？ 沒看到嗎？ 就說不是因為單單的 逃犯條例才暴走 是因為政府每每說話不算話， 試圖破壞香港原有的自由！ 這是事實， 每天都有150人客移居香港這就是中共的手段，試圖用人口影響當地的政治和綁架經濟綁架人民人身自由！ 如果今天是鄧小平才不會用那麼下流無恥的手段， 也不會像習大大那樣做事遮遮掩掩不正面回應，不夠坦蕩蕩正大光明，我個人很讚賞鄧小平，很欣賞當時的共產黨，但是習近平真的是一個草包，衝動無腦等著人家幫他收拾殘局，成事不足敗事有餘的小丑毀了共產制度的好放大了共產制度的缺點！ 再出現一位鄧小平定能打敗美國

[@chenchen6774]

The way you describe it already imposes your opinion on those people.

[@的人的]

Very biased interview

[@rizhaocai8451]

He is deliberately misleading the people. Son of a bitch.

[@rainbow8004]

这就是媒体传播的影响力，站在自己的立场上，施加具有极其强烈的主观意识，拉拢不明就里的路人。（比如影片中，港警在围栏后面用水喷拿着雨伞的抗议者，那是因为抗议者要冲击立法院吧？）

[@diskycn]

就在反送中事件发生不久之后，这个已经停了大半年的频道突然复活，标题中几个大字“新唐人電視台”，查了一下属于法轮功阵营。。。毫无疑问接下来的视频都将会是反华反共主题。

[@zacmtwood6149]

lalauya1111 轮子应该是最开心的

[@ariswen2929]

香港加油！我是台灣人，但是我看了真的也忍不住哭了！你們真的很勇敢，不要放棄希望，世界都看得到你們的努力

[@hungmax6812]

謝謝你！我愛台灣！守護着你們未被污染的净土！！！

[@hopesu3747]

#知道你们为什么会失败吗？# 一，你们只有革命的口号，却没有为革命去死的勇气，自古以来每一次革命的成功都是要用血海换的，国安法一出四处逃散，你们比死更重要的价值呢？几百万人上街头都视死如归了吗? 这算不上革命，更没有强大的信念。 二，你们的理由想法和作为没有得到大部分的人的认同，两三百万人听起来很多，但不用说中国14亿人，连香港的一半都没有，凭什么认为你们的想法代表了正义？正义的一方通常一呼百应，你们自诩向往自由，却容不下不同的声音，暴力事件层出不穷，想学中共？中共镇压弱小的你们，你们镇压弱小的反对者？ 回到反送中事件的本身，完全没有正当性，暴露的只有打着自由幌子骨子里的极度自私和虚伪，中共本来可以不需要通过送中条例，这么多年23条因为你们的阻挠迟迟不定，罪恶发生了，因为没有法律的限制，罪犯竟然可以逍遥法外，你们是自由了，对受害者本身呢？难道你的自由是建立在国家和法律之上？？极致可笑的利己主义们，收起你们义愤填膺，好像你们失败了香港就完了，不会的，午夜梦回问问自己的内心，你们这么做真的是为香港好吗？其实从始至终，大部分人都是棋子，被有心人一撺弄心里的激情和热血就出来了，其实就算胜利了，也只是小部分人都到了政治和金钱利益，你们生活也不会因此有改变。失败了，这一小部分人成了你们心中的英雄。无论怎样，他们也不亏。你们却连之前的自由都没有了。 我也反思，其实一国两制并不是一个好的制度，任何一种体制会存在很多弊端。中共既然在历史的洪流中依然坚挺，必然有道理，人民要沉下心有智慧的过好每一天。这位台湾朋友，你都哭了也是挺感性的，你觉得他们勇敢，但当今台湾人民连这份勇气的一半都没有，在我看来你们的自由还赶不上香港，现在的政府不是让你们吃莱猪核食了吗？只剩下一人一票选个自己都做不了主的候选人当总统吧，未来台湾命运怎么样不好说加油吧，有些话不吐不快，完毕。

[@Moch24]

每次都忍不住流泪

[@jiaxinna5803]

The way you interviewed those ppl is ridiculous. You didn't really explain the real background of the event. What you did is telling those ppl what you want them to know to trigger the answers you wanna hear.

[@workisimpossibletowork7415]

Shame on this journalist. Why don't report the students HongKong beat mainland Chinese people in the airport?

[@东东东东东-d2r]

Please restore the truth and let people see the whole thing instead of leading them. Do you even know the basic rules of asking objecrive questions???

[@jianwang3421]

Dongxin Li 谁给我翻译一下

[@arthursmith8676]

不知道啊，一堆华人在那里说英文。（好吧实际上他们说是大伙儿没有认真阅读法律）

[@ngutlesegyzehnelf605]

真相是中共为暴政，习近平独裁，中共大陆无法制。

[@godblesstheworldwearehuman3331]

这个家伙是个台独，不公正的报道中国的新闻，制造仇恨，断章取义让全世界恨中国。

[@yingmoaizi327]

Ngutleseg Yzehnelf 然后这个世界上出翔了你这样的傻逼

[@lyricsmeaning1061]

"We stop being ourselves when we stop standing up for the things that matter."

[@bun7123]

I don't understand why everybody is being moved by themselves, but no body care about these articles of law which is the cause of the event. I read them carefully, and I don't think there is anything wrong. They are well-concrolled. No body is gonna be caught because of religion, politics and economy. The person who decide if you can be sent is HongKong's judge. That means you can keep doing smuggling，money laundering and abusiving the government which really makes you happy. If you can't trust the judge and the governing party which you vote for，will the laws matter?This is ridiculous. People can easily find something is wrong by just think for a while. However, they prefer to listen to the media with bias. Yes, Chinese politicians are false，just like other politicians from all over the world. But, it doesn't mean that you can abuse your rights，damage legislative council voilently. Are you thinking you are fighting for the democracy and legality？ Or, maybe the opposite. July 1, 2019. A very dark day of legality.

[@kittywong6983]

@tim tang why don't you think about who make us do all this

[@kittywong6983]

@@bun7123 we opposed because we do not trust the system in China. They can accused you with crime that you did not committed and we have already seen that. Thr judge cannot decide whether the suspect committed the crime but only ensure the case has fulfilled all criteria to extradict that person. I would love to trust the legislative Council as well, but the fact that it is dominate by pan democratic simply they control the functional group. When the legislative councile cannot represent our view, government not listening to people, how are we going to change the law? China government promise us universal suffrage in 1997, and she is the one not keeping promises.

[@bun7123]

@@kittywong6983 You absolutely can fight for your freedom, but maybe sometimes overdoing would make things go worse. Please respect the people who work for your freedom. Without the police officer, how can you protect your democracy?

[@kittywong6983]

@@bun7123 I respect the police and I absolutely understand sometime it not up to them to decide what they can do. Therefore we should set up an independent investigation to understand the entire things and find out who should be responsible. But it is also true that some police are using more violence than they should and violate the regulation.

[@loveavril1022]

隔一陣子在看，我看了之後好難過喔! 尤其曾經享有法治之後再被剝奪是比從未擁有過自由更痛苦的事!幸運我在台灣出生長大! 祝福每個香港朋友! 加油 那位Julian先生講的真的好好!真的了解中共的手段!

[@cheaiji]

真的想有人给大陆空投武器，真的受够了。空投武器让我们自己解决问题根源！！

[@blockedbyCCP]

@@cheaiji 你是一個清醒的人🥹 很感謝還有你們

[@weidu-wt1mt]

反送中？罪犯犯法不应该受到惩罚？逍遥法外？这是对大陆法律的固有偏见，香港人这种偏见害了自己，井底之蛙。

[@janyip8668]

我是中国人，但是我想说，香港人加油，注意安全。

[@boblewis5359]

Thank you!

[@zzy6159]

fuck you！

[@mssiuwhite]

Thank you

[@祭央又-d7e]

yip jan kzbin.info/www/bejne/rpjWm4iQhJ6sas0是要注意安全，暴徒无所不在

[@janyip8668]

@@雷志刚-z1x 你这种人，真低B，我说什么了？630是不是也游行了？有暴动吗？不能叫他们加油？还一个太平的香港？

[@강지산-t7q]

i don’t think he interviewed people in a good way

[@berroyang5640]

강지산 me too

[@MaveFAGA]

How to say ?

[@wi1118]

Faga He didn't mention If a Hong Kong person returns to Hong Kong after killing someone in mainland China or Taiwan, he will not be sentenced.

[@p35682477]

wade wade It was just an excuse. Taiwan government have already said that even the bill is passed, they still would not accept the extradition because they do not trust the Chinese government.

[@zizhengwang7207]

강지산 exactly, he’s teaching us how to lead misunderstanding and biases: tell them a real thing that is happening, interpret it with wrong examples to lead misunderstanding and then ask them questions to lead further thinking with a wrong premise 👍

[@lumartin6993]

I am not a CCP supporter. But your interview is full of misleading and prejudice.

[@yi99812]

Exactly! Why don’t u show the crowd what the rioters have done huh?! Spreading misleading n twisted views is totally despicable !!!

[@Jadgtiger1ww]

Vivian Lois Yet there’s no denying that the crowd did have committed something wrong, It’s suppressed by the CCPs high-handed measures that the whole chains of irrational behaviors happened spontaneously. Moreover, the recent reports have revealed that the policemen just dressed them up as the protesters and did something disgusting illegal things, then framed the cases against the protesters. In no circumstances, I think the CCP government shouldn’t adapt like violent-oriented means to deal the problems; the entire means were no so much alleviate the tense atmosphere as posed a vicious circle to the public.

[@zgx8181]

@Boom Boom You CCP 要不你表演个自焚，会不会

[@xiaerliu6274]

@Boom Boom You CCP kzbin.info/www/bejne/bWGmgoaoZ6mHgdE

[@xiaerliu6274]

@@Jadgtiger1ww kzbin.info/www/bejne/bWGmgoaoZ6mHgdGcttps://kzbin.info/www/bejne/bWGmgoaoZ6mHgdE They create chaos in Hong Kong

[@WEIHSIAO]

香港人，加油。為你們祈禱。

[@可刘-y7h]

港督是选出来的吗

[@Fish-go9si]

現在不知道該怎麼辦

[@-graceey-8964]

香...香港人沒甚麼希望了....

[@bllok3885]

I am also very supportive of the independence of Ireland, Scotland and Wales.

[@WethDeath]

I am also very supportive of the independence of New York, Washington DC, Ottawa, Berlin and London. As I am a Hong Kong citizen, no one out of Hong Kong should try to control and disturb our will, I am Hong Konger but also a Chinese. I love Hong Kong, and also I love China, which western newspapers won't told

[@kenjane209]

Alex Li 👍I agree with you，and I know the truth

[@user-xu2qd2bn1g]

😂😂😂

[@roccodea4934]

Scotland was given the chance to separate through a referendum in 2014. We're Hongkongers given that chance too?

[@darylcroft4214]

@@WethDeath no you’re not a Hong Konger, fake.

[@mingzhu9613]

Even if you have a conclusion and an answer, why do you have to ask someone else?

[@xandertsai8069]

Yes, but he needs upload video to make a living, and it's obvious that taiwan people will love such a video.

[@nativeng]

This is not justified! Don’t be biased because you don’t know the whole thing! And how you explain the law which is also not 100% explained!

[@lzqlzq6749]

我永远支持你们捍卫自己的自由 来自广西

[@tomzion138]

隻持hk 來自福建 抵抗暴利條子

[@dorcasl8061]

lzq lzq 我也永远支持你们！来自中国大陆重庆 Carry on HK！❤️

[@成-赤色燎燃]

@@tomzion138 一个个装BI 看看你打的是繁体字就知道你不是福建的

[@唐浩-x9v]

@@nantococy8597 来自你mb四川

[@唐浩-x9v]

@@dorcasl8061 我信你个鬼

[@youtoohuang407]

I think England should make Scotland and Northern Ireland independent, and the people should also fight for independence and freedom

[@andrewtong4491]

The people in Scotland has chosen to stay in United Kingdom by THEMSELVES through VOTING! Ohhhhh, is VOTING a new term for you? Citizen of PRC?

[@youtoohuang407]

​@@andrewtong4491 British voted to leave EU, but many of them didn't know what is EU, is that voting you mean? Actually, the policy of your country is also very good for you, we should respect each other.

[@user-hongkongnews]

but this activity in hongkong has nothing to do with independence lol

[@eunicec9282]

youtoo huang lol you don’t even know what’s the hk people marching for and you just related it to independence

[@jinniwind]

Andrew Tong should california start a vote to leave US then? There’s gotta be a line drawn somewhere. For taiwan, i kinda see it, and for HK? No! It was always part of china and there was never even a dispute, British just “rented” it for 100years and even they dont deny it. So you bringing up the vote is really irrelevant, you dont get to vote on HK independence, sorry mate.

[@dorischen6271]

看到哭我的天 香港加油 台灣人也不要自我放棄

[@陈世美-r3q]

你别狗叫了

[@farinifc]

Why the host telling assumptional questions to get people's feedback ? May I ask the host of this program: have you read the Hong Kong extradition law ?

[@ycliu5483]

pExactly, he is misleading the interviewees. Obviously, political and religious criminals are explicitly excluded in this extradition agreement. This is for pure criminal such as murder, but he ingores this and manage to have people to say what he wants. He is just a biased hater and get some biased interviewees. Also, how can you tell the very few people you interviewed can represent the Hongkong people rather the mob protesting on street? What a funny and stupid video.

[@kramon4607]

@@ycliu5483 hong kong have over million people protest and they only have 7million people.excluding child and old people almost every hong kong people support this protest. Extradition agreement is a challege of hong kong own law. This means china will step by step interrupt hong kong. Hong kong will not be hong kong anyone. You know hong kong government is directly order by china. This Hong Kong will become dictatorship instead of democracy. Please listen to hong kong people. Help hong kong!!!

[@jinjiang3875]

its eys are blind

[@DONGDAQIAO]

You're exactly right,

[@ycliu5483]

@@kramon4607 Your are making a logical argument, and so I would like to reply. Thank you. But to be honest, your so called "million" people does not make much sense. Hongkong has a long history of street protesting many things. Some people even survive (make money) on protesting the mainland goverment, some innocent people are very easy to be mislead, and some protesters are just mobs. So, the component of this million people is quite questionable. As for the challenge of Hongkong's independence, at least this extradition agreement is not. As I said, political and religious criminals are explicitly excluded and your so called "step by step" argument is more of an unnwarranted charges that can be imposed on any goverment policy. Even in the future, your concern happens, Hongkong can protest seriously and that will be more reasonable. As for lsitening to Hongkong, I do have many Hongkong colleagues in U.S. with independent thinking and they do not like this protest. Even some "ABC" friends are not supportive on this protest. The reason the voice of protester sounds louder is becasue: 1. the extradition agreement supporter in Hongkong do not have much time to speak publicly because they are working and have their own thoughts; 2. the protesters usually kidnap people's opinion and will attack the people not agree with them; 3.some western media like this video are trying to mislead the public to realise their political purpose. Anyway, thank for your logical reply and I do believe the guy who wants Hongkong to be better is the China's mainland not the other countries such as UK.

[@Jen-xd2dt]

I cried ... thank you for standing with HK!!!

[@echomeng7487]

You explained the case to those interviewed with your bias! leading ppl to say something you want them to say. Thats a shame!

[@errilyn8300]

雖然我撐香港人但是我希望主持人能夠講清楚事件經過

[@zhangalvin891]

酸酸 你们真是被英国殖民习惯了

[@girlandhercomputer7204]

@酸酸 我认可你们应有言论的自由，但别人不认可也不需要暗示他人没有在思考，相反，港独那种（没有说你）“我们这里是地狱，百万香港人都要进来，大陆也要进来，全世界都要来”的想法，才是黑洞一样的可怕，抱歉，我们才不羡慕这种不理智的自由

[@jiayin4444]

@酸酸 你也是啊，有脑子不用以讹传讹，在你看来，暴动没有错，躺在地上流着鲜血的警察有错，他们有血有肉，有家庭有父母，面对你们这帮所谓的手无寸铁的垃圾不能还手，现在被打成这样，凭什么。内地人比较维护军人，在你们这貌似就是谁嘴巴厉害谁就是弱势群体，可悲

[@LawrenceTse]

@@jiayin4444 不如咁啊 你係以警察角度睇被打 有冇睇過市民角度睇下警察做法 睇完再發表偉論

[@LawrenceTse]

@@zhangalvin891 你是說我們要馬上被中共統治嗎?這樣當初小平叔說了等於白說 這樣一開始一國一制就好啦 說什麼一國兩制

[@jazminp3909]

shame on you speaking so good in chinese, but your view is sooooo disappointed.

[@leegiulio9538]

so am i.

[@raystudiocn]

He just showed the half he wanted

[@richardbaldwin1679]

Jazmin P son of bitch

[@descendant0fdragons]

Actually he did remain neutral as a laowei primary in China, he even speaks putonghua to let you mainlanders know what the big picture is beyond the great firewall of China. Instead of showing everday police brutality displayed by the imported police officers from mainland!!! He really just scratched the surface! He didn't show White shirt mainland Triads beating innocent in yuen long! He didn't show police officers framing protestors have weapons, caught on CCTV!!! He didn't show officers speaking MANDARIN to MANDARIN officers in HKPolice uniform!!! WTF are u guys dumb!!! If I use these tactics in any western country, expect a f*cking WW3!! But they dare use in HK!!!

[@brianyu5966]

descendant0fdragons if you start such riots in a western country, i bet you won’t have the chance to see WW3, or any war whatsoever.

[@kitty52342]

Im so proud of myself just bc I am HongKonger and being one of them in this generation.世界各地的人與我們同在🙏🏻香港人加油 香港人反抗 光復香港 時代革命 五大訴求 缺一不可‼️團結的香港人精神造就了今日的香港

[@梁生-f5e]

结果光复啦吗年轻人，总是以为自己可以拯救别人，不如现实去帮助那些身边需要帮助的人

[@jjjho]

Not knowing the whole story and twisting the situation and misleading people... This is very not professional.

[@JCbowieee]

John Ho this idiot literally showed police spraying tear gas into the crowed and ask interviewee ‘they are spraying tear gas, what do you think about this?’ WTF does he expect anyone to say ‘ohh wow that’s so interesting I like watching that’. Stupid.

[@peterleung1328]

The interview is biased without explaining the detail of the Bill amendment of extradition, IT IS A UNPROFESSIONAL INTERVIEW

[@vivian9321]

From now on, we should support Scotland Independence, instead of putting the focus always on China

[@chenghotung]

maybe they already knew the news ?

[@CollegeRodent]

You only need a treaty between two governments, not any new legislation, for extradition. As a matter of fact, there is an extradition treaty between Hong Kong and the U.S. Who is biased here? Fuck the Chinese communists.

[@marjezhang7600]

yes that's right

[@teczdn]

U need to show a whole pic of what happened. Maintain neutrality. Also welcome to China to see what is real like.

[@shoranliu8482]

Danni Zhang 这就是反华媒体

[@teczdn]

刘翛然 你名字中间的字念啥😂

[@shoranliu8482]

Danni Zhang xiao 第一声，哈哈哈

[@descendant0fdragons]

Actually he did remain neutral as a laowei primary in China, he even speaks putonghua to let you mainlanders know what the big picture is beyond the great firewall of China. Instead of showing everday police brutality displayed by the imported police officers from mainland!!! He really just scratched the surface! He didn't show White shirt mainland Triads beating innocent in yuen long! He didn't show police officers framing protestors have weapons, caught on CCTV!!! He didn't show officers speaking MANDARIN to MANDARIN officers in HKPolice uniform!!! WTF are u guys dumb!!! If I use these tactics in any western country, expect a f*cking WW3!! But they dare use in HK!!!

[@pred1012]

killing off people? eating dogs? Chinese ain't no shit. Fuck off

[@3cuprabbit]

香港加油😢台灣支持你們！

[@yap8845]

@挂个号 別翻墻出來留言 祝你得武漢肺炎 不送:)

[@郭七-r5d]

台湾佬准备接收大批香港反中者！

[@leileichen1901]

You didn't told them whole thing.

[@descendant0fdragons]

Right!!! AGREE He forgot that Carrie Lam lapdog of Xi the Pooh. Insist on using the term Bill is Dead while the right Legal term is Bill MUST BE WITHDRAWN!!! Bcos she is afraid of Uncle WINNIE THE POOH!!!

[@descendant0fdragons]

And now finally on 9-4 she finally submits to bill is withdrawn! WHY, so late? WHY NOW, WHY must there be eight lifes or more lost before, you finally quits playing word games?? it is TOO late!

[@wd159]

This video is from two months ago tho

[@calvinng1995]

Lily Chen then you can try to explain please

[@kimkoay7007]

Hi,do you really shown the fair interview? If you do not do your homework,don't make such interview.

[@bradfordli9119]

the interviewer didn't show people how the “protesters” attacked police and damaged public buildings.

[@zizhengwang7207]

Well, I learn how to lead misunderstanding and piss people from this guy: tell them a real thing that is happening, interpret it with wrong examples to lead misunderstanding and then ask them questions to lead further thinking with a wrong premise 👍 I’m glade to see that so many people believe it. It’s so easy to fool people on social medias.

[@huangyu-mingart]

It’s not a fair interview.

[@terrywang9493]

Beau H yes, CCTV is “really” fair

[@mikemountain7630]

This channel is run by same group of people that runs China uncensored

[@無語-v9f]

我強力支持蘇格蘭及巴賽隆那獨立。

[@huancheng2099]

holahola 贸易战再打五年，加州就快独立了

[@whl103]

@holahola 你只是一個低能的奴隷及奴才，你太無知次可悲

[@nyugraduate]

@@whl103 傻逼

[@jackng2136]

@@whl103 用我们大陆人的说法“你就是一个‘索嗨’ ”

[@开箱达人史达格]

支持，应该北爱尔兰，威尔士，苏格兰，英格兰独立，支持美国加州独立，支持美国所有州独立。

[@abcde0122]

If only i can thank each and everyone of them in person ... thank you all so much for the continuous support. Its a very hard and steep battle to fight... against an all-powerful government ... a tyranny. We will always stand together and stick to our beliefs.. because beliefs are bulletproof, no matter how hard they are being struck. Thank you Laowai’s Team, ps you speak Chinese even better than me haha

[@donalddakota2591]

Please do your research before telling ppl what is going on and doing interviews. This is such an unprofessional and biased video.

[@ltl5202]

Thank you to all of you showing support to us in Hong Kong. It is really tough here, but I am still proud to be a HongKonger!

[@liang2201]

Cover your face.

[@Arthur9306]

how is your life in 劏房(cage)?

[@ltl5202]

Arthur Nie thank you for your care to me, but I am not living in cage house and pretty sure that I have good living here. It is not necessary for you to worry😊

[@Arthur9306]

@@ltl5202Good for you, anyway, I'm pretty sure most of you guys living in cage houses, keep going, keep protesting, keep your ass in jail.

[@莱胆]

Good for you guys to ruin hongkong. Keep up the good woek. Can wait to see its doom.

[@phelia1121]

好久不見了～ 一直都很喜歡你們關於時事的報導，真開心看見你回來，郝毅博似乎瘦了不少，希望你保重身體！ 這影片看完眼眶都濕了，我是台灣人，香港加油！

[@hungmax6812]

謝謝你！我愛台灣！守護着你們未被污染的净土！！！

[@万某某-d5i]

我還沒去過台灣！😂😂

[@SimonSimon-qz6lt]

小心被擄回大陸判尋釁滋事罪，不知道关在那𥚃，家人不得見，審訊不公開，不用找律師，只是陪襯，我說你有罪，你便是有罪

[@James-we6nl]

拜托你去请求你的蔡英文总统宣布中华民国给予香港特区独立 好不好？谢谢🙏

[@zhoukaiqian709]

phelia1121 别忘了，怎么样，台湾永远是大陆的一部分，OK？

[@lifeamanda2680]

来自大陆人的心声 香港加油💪🏻发自内心祝福你们 荣光香港

[@ybe1025]

Thank you Ben 💓 加油💪香港人🇭🇰❤️ 一陣見🌻 就算失望也不能絕望

[@matotoTomato]

丢香港人的脸。

[@天天美食-u2w]

返回食屎

[@matotoTomato]

你先反回吃屎吧，傻逼

[@fluentjesse]

Idea: You can also interview Chinese people to see what their reaction is when seeing the unskewed truth.

[@kk9955888]

哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈

[@陳彥廷-Taiwan]

@@miyayu3768 這話你自己說你真的信嗎

[@magiheaven-revelation12]

陳彥廷 這班世界級民主政棍在推NWO你不知道嗎？You are so ignorant of their agenda.

[@陳彥廷-Taiwan]

@@magiheaven-revelation12 你知道陰謀論絕對不是民主的嗎

[@herrwen8542]

@@陳彥廷-Taiwan 所以我们翻墙看看外面的世界，兼听则明，看完墙外的世界才明白那道墙一定程度上保护了中国人，但是大部分中国人都知道看新闻联播，看那些一昧正面的报道，也就只是看看，大家都持保留意见的态度，也不会尽信，辩证的看问题或许是马克思带给中国人最有意义的东西。

[@zizhengwang7207]

Well, I learn how to lead misunderstanding from this guy: tell them a real thing that is happening, interpret it with wrong examples to lead misunderstanding and then ask them questions to lead further thinking with a wrong premise 👍 I’m glade to see that so many people believe it. It’s so easy to fool people on social medias.

[@planckzhang3423]

You are so damn right

[@quintusqiao725]

Zizheng Wang I think medias have deep influence on the public’s cognition,whether they or we.What do you think about it?

[@zizhengwang7207]

Quintus Qiao it’s true. Never never trust the media. There are two kindda medias. One never tells the whole truth. Another one never tells the truth. Under the gov-controlled media system, media will save face for gov but concern more abt social impact of the contents. Under free press system, media only serve their audience (market) and always take advantage of our bias and prejudice.

[@quintusqiao725]

Zizheng Wang I can't agree anymore.Sometimes,I think maybe we can neutralize the two to find the truth. : ) By the way,you are from China,right?

[@WoodyChens]

So what was the other side of the story? Just curious

[@gamerh7218]

屌～～原來外國人咁支持我地香港～～看到哭爆了！！

[@chenxifeng9078]

when u carry a result to do ur interview and just ask wether people agree with ur point，it's not fair and it's not a real interview. Objective is the premise of interviewing rather than bringing people into your point of view. Of course I know that this is your purpose.

[@AndrewTsui-rg3bt]

This interviewer is bias, he should show the violence that caused by the mob, not just show the peaceful marchers. manipulative!!

[@jiaweiguo8023]

They didn’t know anything, Thats not easy to explain the whole situation! Stop agitating others.

[@ritayang3542]

why u didn't give them watch the video people throw the bricks and iron sticks to the police? i am shame on u. u r so unneutral

[@descendant0fdragons]

Actually he did remain neutral as a laowei primary in China, he even speaks putonghua to let you mainlanders know what the big picture is beyond the great firewall of China. Instead of showing everday police brutality displayed by the imported police officers from mainland!!! He really just scratched the surface! He didn't show White shirt mainland Triads beating innocent in yuen long! He didn't show police officers framing protestors have weapons, caught on CCTV!!! He didn't show officers speaking MANDARIN to MANDARIN officers in HKPolice uniform!!! WTF are u guys dumb!!! If I use these tactics in any western country, expect a f*cking WW3!! But they dare use in HK!!!

[@capella3368]

This video is in June

[@damaomiX]

你去过香港？

[@descendant0fdragons]

@@damaomiX 你去过香港 why does that matter?

[@descendant0fdragons]

@@mia_hqy I think you do not know because China won't show you that the other 6.8 millions, these are grandpa, grandma, restaurant owners, lawyers medical staffs civil servants says they support the protesters. They give them water, meals, legal advice and medical attention. HKpolice??? citizens lost trust in police!!! what NEWS you watching!!! if that news is not from HK with moving display YOU ARE MISLEAD. OUT

[@kayindai4017]

Freedom Stand with Hongkong Fighting We already lost a lot Five demands no one less

[@TheMypurpleflower4u]

I am from Malaysia.I think Westerners shouldn't interfere with China internal affairs.

[@neokoroshi]

Lol. This dude really master in distortion and even greater than our bossku... 🤣

[@Ivan0116]

This interview is total bs, the interviewer did not stay nuetral and misleading people

[@Yy0085]

Daa Jun Tee The interviewer might be giving a slightly biased report that he didn’t show the whole picture of the demonstrations in hk.(like protestors attacking he cops) *but Plz* be reminded that the protestors were trying to *defend themselves* from harm, such as baton, walloping, let alone the tear gas. And the news have shown that it was the police who initiated the fight, who provoked violence, who paved way to chaos. And the protestors, they might be a bit radical u may say, like damaging public property. But all these were attributed to the irresponsible attitude of the chief executive!!! There were 2 million people took to streets, striving for freedom on 16/6, and guess what? The government neglected their requests, and that’s why protestors had to turn aggressive in order to get the government sit up and listen to the citizens. The interviewer could be impartial, but he couldn’t pocket his conscience. As neither the government nor the police are truly serving the people.

[@Ivan0116]

@@Yy0085 the news i've been reading is that the protest started due to the extradition law imposed by china to send criminals that can escape under the loop hole to face justice in china. This whole drama started because a man in hong kong went to taiwan and kill his pregnant girlfriend and escape back to hong kong. Without the extradition law, the justice department could not prosecute the man. Then the western media started to demonize the extradition law accusing it will harm freedom and democracy. If you look closely, more and more videos now are exposing those rioters violent conducts and bullying innocent civilians into agreeing into their ideas. That is not democracy, that is forcefully imposing an idea into a person. If this was happening in western world, it would be called terrorisim instead of protest.

[@Ivan0116]

@@Yy0085 dont get me wrong, im not saying that protest is wrong and unlawful, it is their right to protest peacefully and deliver their message to the government. But violent protest will not do good to their democracy and society. After more and more videos surfaced about those black shirt protester vandlising and bullying it became obvious that these so called peaceful protest reported by western media was so bs. These videos i.e kzbin.info/www/bejne/pKvRkpKZfteWqMU It shows how dangerous these protest could escalate into.

[@Yy0085]

Daa Jun Tee I’m glad that u r very rational. And I’m a Hongkonger and I understand the background of all these extradition-law-related issues and there must be something fishy going on. The mainland is sneakily trying to take control over hk’s judicial power which is utterly absurd---they are instilling their communist ideas and patriotism into every citizen. And if this happens in the western world, it will be regarded as white terror. I understand violence is intolerant. But u must see the truth behind the scene. The police and the government were the ones who suppressed the protest with weapons. “Rioters” are only normal citizens with umbrellas, cardboard shields, bricks; while the cops are fully geared, with strong helmets, pepper spray, batons etc. Perhaps it’s more obvious that the so called police officers are a bunch of bs. In many western countries, like Ukraine, If u want a successful revolution, you have to fight for democracy at the expense of social stability. Don’t get me wrong, but the radical movement was 100% propelled by the irresponsible government. Nobody wants chaos in their hometown, so do I, but this is our only way to express our discontent. We got no choice...

[@gloriayuelinjiang7416]

@@Yy0085 My friend, no one thinks Ukraine had a successful revolution. They became the poorest country in Europe after 2014 revolution, income level and GDP dropped drastically. www.ceicdata.com/en/indicator/ukraine/annual-household-income-per-capita You need to read more on color revolution, what happened in Libya, Abrab Spring, Iraq. I would hate to see Hong Kong turn into any of these countries and I don't think you want that either.

[@謝金銓]

真的好久不見 希望能夠常常發片👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@Aid544]

香港人一定要坚持住防线，中共的邪恶你是无法想象的，作为大陆人有切身体会，都是敢怒不敢言

[@陈宇轩-o8p]

傻子一个

[@xiongzhou2757]

装尼玛呢，一个香港人装大陆人

[@zhanhuju9043]

傻逼

[@gabrielho6021]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gYTOi2avequEqdk

[@LYJ0207]

xs，装啥呢哈哈哈哈

[@ptingdaisy]

This reporter has been using very subjective language to guide the people interviewed, and the videos that are shown to them are partial fragments. Ben should show them what happened before these videos, let them see why there is a police counterattack, because these "innocent people" attacked the police firstly.

[@vivian9321]

From now on, we should support Scotland Independence, instead of putting the focus always on China

[@helenlee6816]

I'm on Hong Kong's side but I think you're somewhat imposing your own opinions

[@reinne6719]

我來自台灣，香港的朋友們加油

[@陈宇轩-o8p]

中国台湾，中国香港！

[@Nomgd]

@@陈宇轩-o8p 人哋台灣同香港關你撚事

[@SussyBabbabQ]

@@Nomgd 人哋冇文化，歷史差到碌柒，臺灣不是中國的有讀過書啲都知道，中英聯合聲明都變成一件歷史文化，可見中國的諾言一毫不值

[@akayankee8841]

@@陈宇轩-o8p 傻逼

[@specialkelly_tae4016]

Thank you very very much 🙏🏻As a hongkonger This video touched deeply in my heart! thank you all of your blessing and support !thank you so so much !We are not alone 🇭🇰🌍

[@jackjin7106]

煞笔港独。吔屎啦。西方那么好。麻烦离开中国的土地。谢谢

[@miyayu3768]

主持人首先洗脑，让他们相信，中国政府做坏事然后问他们的意见，大多数采访者甚至不知道发生了什么或整个情况。多么棒的面试！做得好！

[@fatfat9843]

I dont think one third of Hong Kong people are being misled and the foreigners have their critical thinking , not like you guys, so called Chinese, only say you love China but never dare to speak out the problems in China. This is real disgusting.

[@星星-x4u]

牧羊犬滚去西方吧，西方媒体说什么都对。

[@amandachen9597]

You didn't inform people of what happened, you imposed your opinions already. Just unsubscribed, very disappointed

[@丑拒]

我在想为什么国外的人都记得64天安门，国内的人都忘了

[@corn5276]

你們那百度又搜不到六四..

[@張先生-i6h]

國內只會說 這是外國勢力操控年輕人

[@last6114]

信息审查的影響遠比想象的深遠

[@Machiiiiiiii]

國內網查不到的

[@graciesong9495]

其实六四也是充满着一些谎言和不实报道去抹黑中国

[@baponsnal2659]

We are with you Hong Kong

[@vincentqianghe9702]

Tbh, I believe you explained the case to those interviewed with your bias.. leading ppl to say something you want them to say...

[@razxu1553]

I totally agree with you !

[@averyman5103]

If misleading people against China is what you are focusing on, don't speak Chinese!

[@descendant0fdragons]

If you are misleading ppl against Hong Kong citizens beaten by mainland instructed police don't speak English!

[@averyman5103]

@@descendant0fdragons Who is misleading? God knows, and time will tell, local residents will tell, rather than the biased media.

[@descendant0fdragons]

@@averyman5103 Who is misleading? God won't know because CCP sensors the sh!t out of ppl that even Prophet Muhammed, Jesus, and Buddha can't report to God! Only rational people, like me know, and ignorant people like you don't know.

[@averyman5103]

@@descendant0fdragons OMG, it seems like you are the saver of the Chinese people living in hell. I would suggest you apply for the Nobel Peace Prize. Come on idiot, you can make it!

[@descendant0fdragons]

@@averyman5103 I won't save rotten souls beyond repair like you!!!

[@钢蛋-s4b]

太多人不知道什么叫政府，什么叫国家。国家是你我脚下的这片土地，它已经有了几千年。政府只是管理这片土地的那个组织，它根本就不是国家。 清政府灭亡了，但是这个国家还在；北洋政府灭亡了，但是这个国家还在。我很爱国，但是我不会爱清政府和北洋政府。这么浅显的道理，为什么那么多人不懂呢？ 他手握枪炮，你拿个菜刀就算凶器； 他左拥右抱，你嫖个妓女就算流氓； 他钞票成吨，你摆个摊位就算违法； 他豪宅无数，你搭个窝棚还要被强拆……我就不明白，他一个当仆人的，怎么这么牛逼？！ 美国《独立宣言》讲的不是群体、国家，甚至没有讲民主，讲的只是三大权利：生命的权利，自由的权利ù，追求幸福的权利，这三大权利都是个人的权利，不是哪个群体的权力、国家的权力，这样的文化，才能真正使一个国家强大。美国的强大不是军事、经济、国土的强大，是思想的强大。 亡国是个伪命题，国是个不动产，只能亡统治者。古人说国破山河在。庄园烧尽有枯井。就是说这个道理。外夷入侵，走了，国人重整河山。日寇来了，走了，大好河山还在。不过现在这个古人也没料到。空气脏了，水脏了，山河石油、矿产、煤炭……挖空卖了，卖的人带钱移民外国走了，这真是国破山河无啊！ 七十年代中学毕业后，国人脑袋都装满了如下内容：李鸿章丧权辱国，义和团保家卫国，蒋介石只会摘桃子，地主个个是周扒皮，旧社会暗无天日。有人评价这种人就是一个中国傻逼的标准配置。你要是跟他说：你特么多看几本书，动点脑子再说话。他立马眼珠一翻：你也是汉奸！ 祖国，政府，党派是三个概念。 1，祖国是为民众而存在的。,2，政府，是暂时获得管理权的物业公司，是为人民服务的。政府不是用来爱的，是被人们使用，监督和选举的。 ,3，党派，只是党员的组织，和非党人士没有任何关系。 爱国，毫无疑问。爱国就是爱自己，爱自己更是爱国。 不要说政治和你无关，除非你打算像猪一样的活着，否则政治会随时来找你的麻烦；不要说民主不能当饭吃，没有约束的权力随时会让你没有饭吃；不要说他人的苦难和你无关，这种苦难随时会降临到你身上！ 一个社会有三大底线行业：1、教育，2、医疗，3、法律。无论社会多么不堪，只要教育优秀公平，底层就会有上升希望；只要医疗不黑暗堕落，生命就会得到起码的尊重；只要法律秉持正义，社会不良现象就能被压缩到最小……如果三大底线全部洞穿！这个社会就是地狱！ 一个国家奴才多不多，只要看媒体对领导赞美有多少就知道了。一个国家奴隶多不多，只要看民众遇到不公正有多少人沉默就知道了。一个国家自由不自由，只要看有多少敏感词就知道了。一个国家有没有尊严，只要看人们怎么样对待弱者就知道了。一个国家有没有未来，只要看孩子读什么书就知道了。 小人都想扮成君子，可见君子是受人尊重的；荡妇也想装成淑女，可见淑女是受人喜爱的；懦夫也想有勇士的行为，可见勇士是受人尊崇的；连专制的朝鲜都想炫耀自己是民主，可见民主一定是个好东西。 中国的教育不是启迪人思考，而是规定“你必须这么想”。不是教人如何分析问题，而是规定“这就是答案”。这种教育的结果，是让人缺乏独立思考，容易思想统一，从而便于驾驭，但却聚天下英才而毁之。无良学者到处都有，但数量如此之众，就是制度问题。资中筠先生说得好：中国教育不改变，人种会退化。一个国家的钱不用在教育上将来必定会用在监狱上。 装睡的国民。你永远唤不醒。 随波逐流才是主流，你的泉水再清澈也只是支流。 绝大部份国人关心的只是自己的得失和荣辱，他们不能称得上是好人，也不能称得上是坏人，他们只是庸庸碌碌活着的人 中国的教育体制培养出来的人大都是精致的利己主义的人，凡是对自己有利的事情必定趋之若鹜，烦恼是对自己没好处的事情必定避之唯恐不及。 这样的民族从根本上来说是没有进步的，也永远脱离不了奴役的思想，这世界上凡是进步的国家和民族，必定伴随着民众的觉醒和思想的先进，也惟有一个个人的思想的进步才能造就先进的制度和国家。我并不是五毛口中的美分和轮子汉奸，我一个小小的墙内草民没有啥能量去搞分裂更没资格去卖国所以别太抬举我了。我生在这片土地、生在这个时代，老人们说你是没经历过吃不上饭的年代没经历过文革对比过去你看看祖国现在的强大和改变你太不知足啦，表面看老一辈人民是被整怕了穷怕了饿怕了，能吃饱饭就是他们最大的向往和追求对于精神层次的追求基本是0什么自由民主什么司法独立公正，吃饱肚子厄运只要不降临到自己头上就行。这可以理解为时代造就了他们的意识形态和思想。党的意志大于一切嘛。但是对于我们现一代的人来说，从小也被灌输着同样的思想和教育，可我们并没有切身经历过那些残酷的时代。所以意识形态和价值观还是有所不同、对于好与坏真与假我们会有常识判断力对于违反道德与逻辑的事会抱有疑问，有追求真相的心，而不是无脑的盲从，在国内我看到太多太多匪夷所思的事情发生，当一次一次刷新着我的认知颠覆着我的三观，我会陷入迷茫的思考。是我太较真了吗？ 我不是当权者，所以我只会站在我自己、一个草民的角度去思考，五毛粉红们总搬一些大道理来给我扣帽子，来给当权者的错误和罪行开脱，诸如管理一个14亿人口的大国如何如何换那个政党有这个魄力和能力，为了国家稳定人民作出点牺牲怎么啦，管理这么大一个国家容易吗？贪点钱养几个情妇享受特权咋啦不应该吗，美国民主不照样腐败还有枪击事件，你不愿意呆滚啊、你要是当权者不见得你比他们好到哪去。你穷是你不努力，你没上进心你自甘堕落，你就是见不得别人比你好，你的脑子有问题心理太阴暗，国家要是乱了会被国外势力奴役到时候你活的猪狗不如等等。这些言语有温和的诱导、有危言的恐吓、有肮脏侮辱、看似说的头头是道但是每句话都经不起逻辑的推敲。 我在国内生活水平还算不错，那又有人说那你是吃饱了没事干？写这些东西是想反动？也许站在那些无脑爱国人士的角度我的确是吧，在这个独裁体制下我一个草民看到了太多太多、和我有一样诉求的人们的挣扎和无奈，被人视为异类，被孤立边缘化。这些大多和我一样吧当看到了美国和其他民主国家人民和我们的差距。追求进步、向往美好、向往自由有错吗？民主是不能当饭吃、但是独裁让你吃屎，你就得吃、还会告诉你不是他们照着，屎你都没得吃。人常说人的命天注定三分天注定七分靠打拼。但是我看到的现实却是9分天注定1分靠打拼。那些权贵掌握着大部分的社会资源。一个老百姓你拿什么去跟他们争？ 在这种社会氛围里草民活着的支点是梦，是那个宣传了70年的所谓中国梦。醒来的代价就是你的认知和良知让你看到真相后的痛苦和无力，最近中美贸易战让我的心很乱，一个思想希望美国能加大对中国制裁力度这样会让中共集权统治带来很大的压力，可另一方面当贸易战的火焰蔓延到人民的身上时物价上涨，失业率增高，人民活得越来越辛苦还要被强行灌输着爱国饿肚子抗美民粹主义思想。我很心疼人民。更恨这个恶魔一样的政权编织着各种谎言来欺骗人民的暴政。6.12香港让我看到这里有百万勇敢的人民为自由民主不惧强权抗争。他们的勇敢深深的感染到了和我一样千千万万大陆的人民。我虽然没办法上街去支援你们但是我会尽力的做我能做到的，在这个封闭墙内把香港人民的意志和精神传播给我身边每一个向往自由的人。香港的时局看似简单但是我总觉得水太深了并不是阴谋论，不管这次抗议人民背后有着怎么样的博弈人民是否是博弈的筹码，日后真相都会浮出，现在我是无条件支持香港同胞们。🙏🙏 如果你问我爱国吗，我可以摸着良心告诉你，我很爱国，更爱和我一样的炎黄同胞们。恰恰是因为我爱我才讲这些，我真心希望我们，我们的后代子孙能有尊严生活在这片土地上。而不只是活着而已。给翻墙出来的朋友推荐温和系列自媒（江峰时刻，匡正被篡改的历史唤醒人们的良知绘声绘色的历史故事影射现实）（文昭谈古论今纠正被中共扭曲的逻辑和普世价值，让大脑更理性的思考问题）（天亮时分分享章公深厚的国学造诣对当下时事的判断和解读）（萧茗看世界”有可以采访美国政要的优势第一时间掌握一手资料）小民之心、吴建民、陈破空、万维、明镜、新唐人 老黑公民 黄河边观察 邱家军 老北京茶馆。有漏掉的大家留言补充 反共我认为不能只是一句口号和一腔怒火。而是要理性，用你的智慧去感染去启发唤醒身边人line号码1020012571有群

[@TheAoiki]

政府不等於國家，但政府往往會綁架國家和人民。

[@darrenhsu862]

凡是說問心無愧不怕有人說嘴，共產黨就是害怕被對任何國家政權比較，所以封鎖人民比較的機會，也就是越來越難攀的防火牆。中國從來都不講法治，而是人治，只要位高權重的官犯任何明文法條都不會被依法送辦；只要有一點嫌疑的追求自由之人就會被定罪，哪怕沒被定罪被"審問"的時間都遠遠超過法律所允許的。我不反對絕對的制度，而是反對絕對的權力。絕對的制度就是不會針對任何一個人，天子犯法與庶民同罪，哪怕污了一毛錢都會被定重罪，而不是無限上綱的權力，導致某些人不論什麼樣犯的罪刑都是"清白"的。

[@darrenhsu862]

@@faifai356 有時候也是被迫選擇的，只要挺身而出就會被逮捕的話，多數人還是寧可保持現狀。但是想想一個人就能讓共產黨這麼畏懼，如果是一萬、十萬、百萬甚至千萬人呢?可惜現在黨的教育讓別人以為支持黨就是在守護國家，殊不知這才是真正造成極端的幫兇。

[@Adlay568]

我很認真的全看完了。 如果你真的是中國人，很高興看到不是所有人都沒有理智的一昧支持共產黨政權的所有決定。 或許我們無法在以行動支持對的事，在行動中反對錯誤，但是我們的理念是為了我們自認為的正義。而此時此刻，反對那些東西即是我們共同的正義。 沒有人會承認他做的事是為利,為益,為己的，甚至還會因此將聲音放大來蓋過反對的聲音。也因此我們必須更加努力去反抗，不是呆呆的坐著等他來出招。反抗，也不一定要使用暴力手段。 到了某個時候，或許我們真的會成為敵人。這絕對是所有情況中最不為人樂見的。 川、習、韓...，這些人若是不再有那麼強烈的權利慾望，世界/國家大概也能和平些。

[@fu9762]

說得好,讚,好難得可以看到有自己獨立思考的中國人,超級讚~

[@李浩宇-i6p]

well, there is one condition in the law that the hongkong government intended to make. That is, only the criminals did crimes in the mainland of China and are going to be judged in jail for more than 7 years by the hongkong's law can be sent back to the mainland. pls remember, it's for the criminals who did crimes in mainland and the crimes are both judged guilty by the laws from the mainland and hongkong. SHOW THEM THE TRUTH, DONT TELL LIES, OR, SHUT UP

[@aaeett1999]

李浩宇 I mean at this point, it’s not going to be hard for China to add on penalties/jail time to a person’s charge if they really want to bring anyone back to China, and once the person is in China there’s no coming back, unless the government willing release the individual. Even without the extradition bill established, the government has already ‘kidnapped’ people from essentially the central of Hong Kong. See 铜锣湾书店 for more info.

[@LiLi-rn4jm]

看到你們團隊回來了很開心！但想到上次毅博太太家裡的事情還是不禁替你們擔心，謝謝你們的報導，但更要保護好家人啊！

[@tsusuankueh328]

老女人滾蛋！這節目才多久 一堆人說自己是多老觀眾 騙誰？

[@Meijyu112]

原來看到哭的不只我一人嗚嗚，香港加油！

[@alessandro-9708]

出过几次笼子的鸟 总说自己看见了全世界-------似乎很奇怪？ ------（欧洲170万华人）

[@alessandro-9708]

p n 显然你没懂，而且我也没想代表其他人。🙂

[@monapeng4618]

Alessandro - 哈哈哈哈对话有点可爱

[@jinzhengwei2654]

没有中国 民族 同胞你在外面什么都不是

[@yygqqq5077]

@@rosinaxia 那叫人心叵测。。。

[@Moch24]

加油，香港！山东人支持你

[@sharlanechui]

謝謝

[@xiyuwang85]

Sorry, I think your program is a international program, do the basic investigation and explanation is the most basic things. Do you think you did it? Could you pls read the rules again? it's the same meaning as your explanation?

[@ethan6395]

其實也蠻想聽聽法國人的想法，我想如果他們的政府這樣搞，人民會把政府滅了

[@EATing666]

法国黄背心运动你怎么看

[@fengshui....]

你没看过法国的黄马甲是怎么被法国的警察打残的吗？

[@lordschu6938]

這似乎在歷史上多次的發生XD

[@gadzooks429]

可见哪些人对国外制度和现实的一无所知，盲目崇拜，觉得国外就是对的，人民就是厉害

[@gadzooks429]

真逗，羡慕法国人民。工会和罢工是法国人民的家常便饭。全球化的今天，你罢工抗议，饭碗就流向其它国家。香港人总讲自己这二十年倒退了，从来不说是大陆强大了，香港曾经的角色被取代了。全世界从英国脱离出来的殖民地里，估计就香港最念旧主。被英国人抛弃，甩下，欺负的旧历史，这帮二十岁的从来没体会过。只知道抱怨，搞乱了香港更怨大陆。而那些没有未来的人，破罐子破摔，绑架了香港一起摔。

[@施正堤]

Already u lead them to answer what u want to hear. So whats the meaning for your report

[@rivernine1303]

我收到大家的鼓勵了，又有氣力繼續上路了，為自由而戰! Fight for Freedom!

[@anlhkt2041]

你真的是游行者啊？

[@aplise]

@@cengho4872 香港黑警是一班專抓少女的懦夫

[@f12536145]

保重!!! 加油!!! 祝你們平安，祝你們心願得償!!!!

[@sekiro875]

香港现在社会瘫痪，人心惶惶就是你们要的自由？

[@SunhawkMiller]

Welcome back, Ben!!　Miss you so much!!

[@SunhawkMiller]

@@xianglongma2274 我跟Ben是好朋友，關你啥事？

[@xianglongma2274]

@@sieggehortjetztmir208 香港是中国的，中国政府的，你不愿意就滚回洋爸爸那里去，不要来祸害香港

[@raymangala6976]

I admire ur capability to distort whole thing... God bless u...

[@hugochow6028]

在這裡第一次留言，在看這段影片時不禁令我感到感動，見到這樣多的人支持我們，但政府至今仍沒有回應香港人的訴求，在昨天又有一位烈士去世了，已經是第二位了，如果政府之後也沒有作出任何承諾，這種以死明志的行為不會停止，這是我們最不想看見的。 所以各位香港人,聽日71維園見! 希望今次遊行會超過300萬人🙏🏻

[@何足道哉道哉]

想到大伙成功筹得近700万港元，在全球多份报章刊登公开信，呼吁出席G20峰会的领袖，关注香港“送中条例”的争议，结果特朗普和媒体居然提不提一下，白天倒还好，一到晚上就抑制不住自己的感情，一个人躲在被子里偷偷笑出声来。

[@LCh-dn7nk]

Hugo Chow 加油！請在香港的各位遊行時多注意安全，面對蠻橫的中共，一定要先保護好自己，這是長期抗戰，加油

[@Anton-rc6pt]

又有一位烈士了……

[@hugochow6028]

Anthony T 好心疼🤦🏻‍♂️

[@karylam8206]

香港人加油!fighting

[@Lulupufstudio]

I believe you explained the case to those interviewed with your bias.. leading ppl to say something you want them to say...

[@安德雷阿斯]

好久不見郝毅博了 祝你平安健康

[@韦朗]

没死，遗憾

[@jakesze96]

You already told the passengers to answer in your way, they just gave you conclusion as you want

[@wendycheng1710]

This guy is enticing people to give him the responses he wants.

[@jezzihuang1254]

yes, you are right, damn right

[@Davi-jx9de]

so true, the question he asked and how he explain "his view of the situation" are so biased....

[@huffleparis_chao4021]

Exactly!!!

[@junjiecai5739]

Yes exactly

[@焦凡-r6e]

Yes he is not objective!

[@junyiliu6432]

How can you do a sort of interview by asking leading question and showing a side of view? This video can only fool fools

[@yeapwaikit2778]

Junyi Liu misleading the people

[@kevin76517651]

Thank you, thank you very much for who supporting hong kong. It's touching.

[@8343656]

感覺這次中共這次打算長期抗戰，在一段時間以後沒人在關住時在火速通過 希望這個頻道持續關住這個議題，間接監督中共政府守護香港的民主 最後天佑香港，世界與你們同在

[@unclebuzheng7160]

额，中共都没当回事好不，我们其实在看热闹，本来跟我们也没多大关系！这个事，说白了，是香港人自己的事，高度自治么，自己处理去，处理不明白，就等着一国一制把！香港闹的越厉害，广州澳门发展的越好越快！

[@習近平小熊維尼]

歪叔说电影Uncle Bu Zheng 這件事是中共惹起的，你剛也說了，香港高度自治

[@unclebuzheng7160]

@@習近平小熊維尼 这件事怎么成中共引起的了？中共干啥了？提出这个条例的是你们香港自己的政府好吧

[@習近平小熊維尼]

歪叔说电影Uncle Bu Zheng 特首是中共指派的，並不是人民選的，有腦的人都知道是習維尼搞的鬼

[@yyt4915]

歐冠辰 请问 97之前香港每一届都是女皇指派的 香港人也没选过 你怎么看

[@竹棚竹棚-b9b]

我是香港人多謝外邊國人 支持青年抗爭 更多謝(I)人,我也是廣西人。

[@雪落下]

廣西容不下您這尊大佛，可別再提廣西了，丟臉

[@dorischeung1573]

Thank you for supporting us. We’ll fight for our freedom :) I’m so touched and feeling supportive after watching this video. This is the tough time for Hong Konger especially reading the news everyday. I feel so sad of the hk situation now. hope the gov can listen what we strive for and HK can pass through this hard time

[@liang2201]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gYTOi2avequEqdk Hi Chinese, would you mind watch one more?

[@Arthur9306]

you all live in 劏房(cage) and wanna freedom? it is A freaking joke, man, really makes me laugh