Laura Osnes - "If I Didn’t Believe in You" (Best of Pronoun Showdown)

[@JustSmile1987]

"He will not fail so you can be comfortable, Cathy.... He will not lose because you can't win." ........ The audience was dead quiet after that. That's the definition of impact.

[@misswaitressful]

wow, this is probably the most intense of that night..too hear this from cathy's perspective... laura got me in my feels :(

[@sydneyd05]

This song is so much more powerful than it already was even with just a few word changes.Laura Osnes is the best.

[@jabberwockyings]

what a dream would it be to see an off broadway run of tl5y with jeremy jordan returning as jamie and with laura as cathy!

[@phantomvideowatcher]

Absolutely stunning performance! Laura not only sang this beautifully but she really embodied the emotions of Cathy at this point in their marriage. 😭

[@Ummmmmmmm6no]

This is one of the best Pronoun Showdown songs. It gives such an amazing perspective.

[@DA-vw1hu]

Not what I expected when I read the title...so much better. I need this to be a mash up with Jeremy Jordan singing the original

[@maddietillem6778]

She made the song 500,000 times more meaningful by changing two words

[@KellyDurgan]

the trust between laura and ben is so deep that you can see it. well done to both of them!

[@e-linamarie]

wait i love how introspective this got

[@MaggotfilledFlesh]

Oh man the song is so damn powerful. The original song is great (I haven't watched the movie) and it's kinda refreshing to understand Cathy's side. Man, I love both of the songs. They are both as emotional, fantastic singing man.

[@truefairytales77]

Chills. Laura is amazing.

[@madisonburdette1025]

this song already hurt me by imagining how j would feel with someone saying all that to me, but DUDE the idea of cathy singing it to HERSELF i am SOBBING

[@ivyesque]

this is why I'm team Cathy, because Jamie was always manipulative

[@maddietillem6778]

exactly. Of course she has problems, but at least she's not manipulative

[@christophercobb249]

Yes, and he also gaslights her and takes advantage of her vulnerability. I find his character insufferable, though I LOVE the score.

[@katechan1010]

This is perfect!

[@TwiZtiD23Soul]

holy fuck i need a 5yrs prounoun swap like this -- see the other person's perspective that whole time

[@erinwhewell857]

I just adore this

[@kaitlynhanson865]

Wow I have chills

[@igorarnaud]

It's way more intense from her perspective. Wow. I'm speechless and I relate (that sucks)

[@theblackcat2792]

Wow ❤️

[@mochriademia]

Oh wow this is beautiful and painful to hear from Cathy’s perspective.

[@gabbybrown7190]

Does anybody have the lyrics to this version? I was thinking of making a cover of it.

[@jaymichelle8357]

🤧🙌🏽💕