Judge Rip You Apart, Fake Report by Doc

[@LawChakra]

The peculiar thing about this hearing is that theHon'ble judge knows in detail many facts about medical field. This is so nice to see. Pranam to the hon'ble Judge from @lawchakra

[@abinv1972]

Judges are practicing like doctors

[@krishnamurthyasjois8616]

Brilliant

[@nainitalism]

its is his thought process that is relevant. Never assume. When you do its a case of " ass of you and me "

[@lakshmisree4063]

Preoccupied

[@samfightss]

Judge does not know medical facts he is just pretending that he knows everything. 1) The term primi gravida means first pregnancy. And he is saying that the doctor should mention fetus in uterus. Primi gravida itself means first pregnancy and pregnancy means fetus in uterus. 2) there is no protocol to send histopathological sample for bite marks of skin. The government and court should send guidelines to implement such practice to textbook of medical students. There are many such things that are not implemented in medical education. This pocket is because the education board have not set proper guidelines. The doctor report is not nefarious in any way.

[@AthishaySimon]

I’m a doctor and I’m impressed by the amount of medical knowledge the judge is having. He’s using medical jargon as if so accustomed to it. Impressive.

[@harbat4934]

he was a general physician.

[@RMw1252]

He even knows haemotoxic or neurotoxic...

[@Abram-kb3ux]

Judges are familiar with these, a seasoned police officer also knows these things. They have to read all these things.

[@utkarshk22]

Judges are taught about forensic during thier training. Plus since he is a High Court Judge he might have seen various cases of poisoning and snake bite.

[@muroogle]

they read postmortem reports, dna test reports, insurance reports day in and day out

[@adnanhimaloy3665]

When u wanted to be a Doctor but your parents forced you to be a Judge 😆

[@lunalisapotsangbam5194]

😂😂 but so impressed!! The forensic doc must be thinking where he has come!!!

[@adnanhimaloy3665]

@@lunalisapotsangbam5194, He had thought that he could feed whatever he wanted to the Judge bcz of the difference of backgrounds. Little did he know that he was wrong...

[@shivankrastogi2591]

Really,The judge is no less than a forensic expert.

[@ranvijaysingh5465]

Well said 😂😂

[@KishoreKumar-hm8uh]

On the other hand you want to be a business guy but your parents forced you to become a doctor😂

[@msh3536]

These kind of Judges are gems of the judiciary.

[@MrELus1ve]

Many such judges are there in MP

[@gijoe678]

For those wondering, judge's name is Atul Sreedharan. He was recently transferred to the J&K high court.

[@abishekraja]

much needeed

[@awakeningcalls9567]

Thanks So much to learn from him

[@aryanwankhede6102]

Thanks man, I was looking for it everywhere

[@Subuhi61]

What a fantastic flow of reason by the judge leaving the forensic doctor breathless and shocked😂

[@DarthV27]

Doctor be like, “Yeh toh external viva se bhi khatarnaak hai”.

[@pikingd8840]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@bharatchhanga3640]

😂😂

[@asg1183]

Hahaha.. real life external viva.

[@Gary-wp1wt]

😅😅

[@Jackie_Chan-w2m]

😂😂😂😂

[@PoliticalMatter]

Highly informed judge. These are the people who are backbone of the judiciary.

[@doctorpanigrahi9975]

I trained him.

[@vivaindian]

And silently provide best in support to our faith in judiciary and system.

[@sumitnegi1843]

Woahh , surprised to see judge knowing so much about medical field

[@LeadLifeWithEaseNow]

He is an experienced judge..... he has dealt with many such cases

[@NikhilDixitMusic]

Even lawyers know. You should read Modi’s Medical Jurisprudence.

[@akshaydeora5182]

Me too

[@krishnagattani3809]

Judges are next to god they know everything

[@abhishekthakur5702]

They read the petition before the proceedings and there are also young law graduates who are employed on contractual basis for reaserch work.

[@ashutoshbaloni7688]

Wow..this is called justice in 5 minutes. He has such warmth and empathy yet in depth analysis and logical deduction in him. Sound knowledge of medical sciences as well.

[@linasouza6771]

THE WORLD NEED THESE KIND OF LEARNED JUDGES

[@arundev1]

After watching these sessions, I can now understand. Why is our court so close to people

[@LawChakra]

They are and people have wrong perception about courts

[@abhaydeomishra9595]

The judge is very detailed and good in his questions.

[@arpshkl]

Knowledge is the key. The judge's argument shows his level of education.

[@jimiz]

Wooow respect to the judge!!!!

[@LawChakra]

Indeed, We need such Judges.

[@subhojitghosh8041]

The judge is more of a doctor than the real doctor 😅

[@albertjohn2735]

Blessing n powers of GOD TO HIM

[@meenakuraseruthu11]

Lol

[@jvsuryanarayana]

My deep Namaskarams to the Hon'ble judge.

[@SuperCptblood]

My god! I never thought how much difference a great Judge can make. Absolutely stunning Judge Saab. The command on language, knowledge of medical field...I doubt whether the culprits will get away here. India needs at least a hundred similar super man Judges. God bless you sir. Keep it up.

[@ranvijaysingh8924]

That's type of personality a judge should possess. Great respect sir 🙏🙏

[@kranthikiranful]

Being a Medical Doctor, I would say Hon'ble Judge is on Right Points.. it's an example of Medical negligence,but it is also important for public to know that Forensic laboratories are low in our country and in many assault/ poisoning cases , MLC is not done which is mandatory...

[@nanditam8021]

He should never have given a definitive opinion... it should have been provisional to be correlated with forensic lab reports...

[@manomano2524]

As I worked in forensic medicine department, he never should comes into conclusion even if he is confident without visceral and histopathology reports. It's not his problem on getting histopathological and visceral reports it's police headache.

[@Subuhi61]

Always thought Indian judges are pompous, verbose, arrogant, poorly read , weak in faculties of logic & reasoning and with doubtful integrity standards. But this one judge belies all such ideas. Complete respect and best of wishes to him! May we have more such judges in our courts. 😊

[@JinSakai_Kuroudo]

That’s because you don’t have an education in critical reasoning. They are there to make sure the evidence presented and the logic of the lawyers are sound, otherwise anyone will say anything and they’ll have to be live it. If you get your idea of judges form movies and tv like most Indians do please don’t. A lawyer will try every possible tactic to defend his client its the judge’s job to make sure it stands in court. This is why not every monkey can become a judge and not everyone can’t understand what he does

[@neelj5155]

Are you the same or your family have these kinds of people?

[@NishantShyamGoutam]

@Suresh Bharadwaj Exactly Hope that such exceptions become the norm

[@kevivtawar7716]

Lemme tell you most judges are very well read and competent.

[@tresconik]

Not at all.. HC judges are very competent.

[@thevoicerapstar]

I never knew judges with such medical knowledge existed. Thankgod for such people.

[@kevivtawar7716]

It is a result of practicing criminal law with passion all your life as an advocate. As almost all HC and SC justices are former advocates. In advocacy you are expected to be master of almost all trades be it Medicine, corporate, white collar crimes, company law so on and so forth.

[@giridhar3nr]

I'm a doctor and i can say that this judge has very good knowledge about forensic medicine. The forensic expert is not answering properly

[@jasleensingh1491]

One of the finest and best judge in the indian judiciary

[@62133004]

WOOW... I appreciate the command over english language the judge has as well as the subject knowledge - forensic sciences... these are the kind of people we would luv to see as judges and would luv to hear them...

[@mkrchowdari9901]

This took my respect for judges through the roof. They are the highest chair holders and get there through knowledge, not politics

[@rationalbeliever4789]

Being a doctor I am assuming what happened.... Actually in Govt Hospitals these PostMortem are not done by Assistant Professor(which is their duty).. Usually Ward Boys or Compounders or let's say Jr Residents perform post mortem and write the name of Assistant Professor. So basically Assistant doesn't even know anything. And what us the name of the Hon'able Judge?

[@lunalisapotsangbam5194]

It seems that's the exact case,! The Asst prof seemed lost. He seemed to have just signed!

[@ashoknajan]

It’s not like that brother plz don’t give such views without actually knowing the facts

[@ashoknajan]

You yourself is a doctor and you know dissection is done by workers and observed by mbbs or md forensic medicine doctor.

[@ashoknajan]

By negligence he must have missed the pregnancy findings… may be he ha written the rom report after some gap between pm and writing

[@csk8981]

Thing is viscera is sent for histopathology in all cases , blood is sent to toxicology but how many times sample reaches lab or the proper handling of samples is done .? . I have worked in casualty for years sent n number of samples of blood for alcohol but none of the reports come back .. important thing even doctor does all the work ,documentation is very poor in government hospitals .all the responsibilities come back to him .

[@laxmikumarkayyarsubraya2222]

I am so impressed.His lordship is so incisive in his questions yet balanced. Knows the subject what is hearing.Such gentlemen sitting in the bench gives common people like us a hope that law of the land will prevail

[@vivaindian]

Experience speaks. It's clearly visible that honourable judge passed through these types of cheap cheating and he does knew where is the mistake. Love it the way he analysis it.

[@meerarana7399]

Judge sahab ne to apne logic se doctor aur lawyer ka post-mortem kar dala😮

[@Bunuuuuuu]

Sign of greatness at the end he is telling that there are others who has more knowledge than him.....just see. How down to earth this person is

[@nandhivvarman355]

A good practising lawyer makes a good Judge.

[@LawChakra]

Agreed

[@sundarsundar3157]

....nandhi... But many of such practising Advocates are very reluctant to become a Judge for various reasons. I worked for some years as a Stenographer ( by the by I am a high speed Stenographer with 150 wpm in English Shorthand and 75 wpm in typing) in Law Firms after my retirement from Government and they paid me well and treated me well. During that period I came across some Advocates who were unwilling to take up High Court Judgeship and politely refused at the initial hinting of the proposition from THE TOP. By casual talk with such knowledgeable people when chance occurred to me in Events , I understood their side. People see things in different ways. But efforts must be made to roap in such people in the interest of Justice and Judiciary as a whole.

[@nandhivvarman355]

@@sundarsundar3157 so nice of you to share this. Thanks

[@prakhar1623]

It's not surprising that the Justice has a deep knowledge of the medico-legal aspects. As someone who has been in the Courts a few times, they're a matter of discussion pretty much everyday. Our judges indeed are a treasury of a lot of knowledge.

[@kalaalex1]

Highly impressive, the Hon'ble Judge has done an indepth analysis and has used medical jargons and terms as thorough knowledge is imbibed in his own Investigation. Salutes for you Honorable Judge a million times. We trust the Judiciary ❤ Jai hind

[@dondelhii3663]

The Justice Sir truly ripped him apart and hopefully, the deceased will get the Justice after the detailed investigation is carried out by CBI, a premiere investigating agency.

[@aniukumarrr]

We need more Judges like you sir, hats off!

[@lazyidealist]

Judges like these are an asset to our nation. They must be preserved at all costs.

[@pratyush487]

We need a lot more of these judges who can be really instrumental in justice delivery. Very impressive.

[@arasikeremukesh1692]

These kind of judges are the ones saving democracy. salute to his knowledge

[@whatstalk8848]

Judge be like: iam the Dean of medical college😂

[@ThunderForce_Automotive]

Proud to see such a moments, honourable Atul Sir. People like you are our hope for fair judgements. You are an great example of supreme justice. God Bless You Sir

[@wilsonsolomon48]

Just one word for such learned n hon'ble JUDGE: MINDBLOWING

[@krishnaprassad4232]

Hatsoff to the Learned Judge !!!!! Awesome and highly mature, professional!!!!!

[@DHAVAL1982]

Salute to the Hon. Judge... Jay Hind Sir! Jo kaam Investigation Officer ka tha woh kaam yah respected Hon. Judge kar rahe hai...❤

[@krishna-zr8wn]

Judge ne toh Bhai kya intelligence aur calm composure dikhaya. Salute. He is not even shouting, letting the other guy speak. He is hitting him with intellect.

[@4ugmg]

Knowledge + Power are a deadly combination!! It's a divine thing and can only come from God almighty...

[@abhinav_posts]

Glad that the judge did his study before hand. We need more judges like him. Judges like him give us the hope of justice. Thank You.

[@vijaykrishnamenon]

Mind blowing ... hope we have a lot more judges of such knowledge and conviction. Jai hind

[@sudhirmundkur5449]

What a fantastically knowledgeable Judge! And blunt too, as the case required. Referred ut to CBI without any hesitation. Brilliant! We need mire such Judges in all our courts.

[@syedkhader2052]

Waah, you are absolutely safeguard the justice, your service is simply superb, those who are criminals should be punish severely 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@SARajanGenesis]

Salute you sir . Gem of an Indian judiciary. May God bless the Righteous because he stands with the righteous

[@AdarshKumar-vk9cz]

Proud of Indian Judges who have such command and knowledge of the field they are judging! Kudos Honorable Judge!

[@druvakumar5383]

This judge can crack NEET & USMLE in his sleep. As a medical professional I'm very much impressed and salute your knowledge on medical sciences Mr.Justice👍

[@vp1132]

Judge sir ko pranaam.. 👏👏👏👏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@muraleedharanpaloran1712]

A Judge like this are becoming rare. BTW, what was the PP doing when getting expert opinion from his witness. Kudos to the honourable Judge who went beyond his call of duty 👏

[@stingable]

This is how knowledgeable all the judges are expected to be , Knowledge is POWER

[@mj1nc]

Taking a bow your Lordship!!! India seems to be still safe bcoz of people like you!!!!

[@pramodkumarkushwaha4169]

I did my internship under him...sir ka transfer av J&K HC me ho gya hai....HON’BLE JUSTICE SHRI ATUL SHREEDHARAN

[@LawChakra]

Thank you

[@bluelords9813]

Sir, hats off, country needs people like you, so much corruption, common people has no belief in justice, I’m shamed what is going on in this country Proud of you sir

[@danielbusi]

these fellows thought they can get away with any kind of report they produce before the court and they got stuck with the right judge who has proper knowledge about medical science and this Honble judge vocabulary and english and his voice vibration definitely itimidate anyone who tries to take courts for granted...wow!! first time I felt so good coming across this video in my recommendations....

[@DeepakSharma-sp8cr]

Time has come that in India we should have separate Judges for Economic, Murder, Medical etc and micro specialisation for Police, Judges at least. Law needs to be more stringent and punishment equal to USA laws this will not require any money to do it

[@432fi]

Don't underestimate a judge in the court and think u can mislead him.he can absolutely rip you apart

[@bivekghosh9766]

What a knowledge 😮. Impressed As well as I'm feeling shame for this DOC

[@TheMANDOLINLOVER]

Hatsoff Judge saab!!!! Amazing command .

[@thestriker269]

The people who are saying that the judge knows about medical field ,the matter of fact is that district judges do hear a lot of cases each and every day related to medicolegal issues and negligence that's why they know what ,how and where to look and ask.indeed many judges do have a very methodical and sound knowledge about many medical cases,issues. Snake bite,pregnancy related deaths,poisoning deaths ,suspected homicides, suicides etc.

[@satyanarayanareddy6074]

How judges know this much knowledge wonderful

[@dr.m.w.samuelpaul]

Honorable Justice ⚖ and his knowledge is astonishing. 👏

[@dawawangdi5358]

Judge shaib asked very excellent question to doc. Law of Land is Supreme than any citizen and politician. Namaste

[@dsvikas]

I am really proud of the judge. He is so much knowledgeable. Such pointed questions and analysis by a judge increases your faith in judiciary. Kudos to the judge.

[@RS-df2gr]

Salute to the Judge, such an erudite person with eloquence and an ability to assimilate so many facts!! Thanks 🙏.

[@mohammedibrahim1327]

Excellent to see a judge who is having a brilliant knowledge of medical field.

[@spoofmy284]

Everything was perfectly planned...but then OG arrived..!!🔥🔥🔥

[@kumarswamy19]

Kudos to Judge for ripping apart the doc for his incompetent doctor. Great!

[@ck3289]

He gave definitive instead of provisional, judge was right !

[@harshabiliangady3211]

WOW hats off to the Honorable Judge. He is so so knowledgeable.

[@ramayyacv8275]

A great judge I adore such judges

[@neoyamaha]

This is the judgr we want and need. Great work Shri atul

[@mahaguru58]

I am so impressed by the learned Honorable Judge's medical knowledge and ability to counter the doctor's report which had so many inconsistencies! Kudos to the Honorable Judge! 😍👏👏👏👏👏

[@sunilkumara2368]

8:34 with that nod, he kind of accepted that he's under pressure.

[@lyngyps3364]

More power and strength to such kind of Judge ❤❤❤❤

[@Robylazarus]

Brilliant Judge and wonder full channel, subscribed.... Thanks for sharing this...

[@vishwanathtripathi2335]

काश ऐसे जज हर अदालत में हों और ऐसे न्यायाधीश को शत शत नमन करते हैं और ऐसे भ्रष्टाचारी डॉ सहित बचाव पक्ष के वकील साहब के कृत्य की भर्त्सना करते हैं जय भारत वंदेमातरम सहित

[@teeny2024]

The Brilliant Hon. Judge has blown holes into this fake death report given by this crook, unethical, shameless medico. They should not spare him he is an accomplice to murder n should b punished accordingly. Same punishment for murder i.e. no leniency so the poor dead woman n the foetus get justice. It's not negligence it's deliberate in intent. It should b treated as a double murder. JAI HIND. VANDE MAATARAM.

[@MOHAMMEDIQBAL100]

Excellent English. Wide medical knowledge. Kudos to the Honourable Judge.

[@santanubora4302]

Amazing judge these people should become leaders of the country🙏

[@nicyhere]

another gem of a judge

[@jimmydavda5908]

Hatts off to this judge for his knowledge 😊

[@sabygeorge5615]

Wow Hats off God bless people like you India is proud

[@furqanmirza1346]

One of the best videos on law chakra

[@VS-ij3lv]

🤣😂🤣😅 Doc and Lawyers,be like..🤦‍♂️.. Fantastic Doctor Judge 🙏🙏

[@chandankumar-lv7jc]

Great knowledge, not only in legal field but also in medical field🙌🏼 what a Command over language!! Wow, You are an epitome of Judge, sir. 👨‍⚖️✊

[@Awaj9]

Kolkata needs This hon'ble justice sir 🙏🏻💪🏻💪🏻

[@alertforfalsecase2299]

Salute Judge Saheb from Heart

[@mohammadazazkhan2771]

Relex guys Respected judge is a very good and close friend of Dr. Saluke (senior forensic dr,expert and scientist in CID)

[@Ramakrishnan-Ramaiah]

Respects to Honourable Judge for his deep understanding of the subject and right observations

[@usharani-sl2th]

He is brilliant and loads of respect to him.Hatsoff sir

[@HarishKumar-id6xz]

It Seems this Judge is having an mbbs and forensic science degree .. we need these kind of people in our entire system..not the power hungry UPSE Babu type( with no technical) or culture.

[@BOS-v2x]

You can neither become a babu nor a judge 😂

[@HarishKumar-id6xz]

@@BOS-v2x Really.... SELF CERTIFIED SO CALLED Shameless BOSSSSSS...

[@akshatsharma2064]

Judges study from a book named Medical Jurisprudence and Toxicology by JP Modi so that they can handle such technicalities and doctors won't be able to fool the court.

[@HarishKumar-id6xz]

@@akshatsharma2064 is it .. I don't know about that.. thanks for the information bro.

[@pranavtiwarixiia1098]

​@बम्बई वाले भईया जी For you everyone who doesn't learn or study the aforementioned discipline is uncultured. Why ? Not every case revolves around Engineering or medicine. Other individuals are equally good in their respective fields or deserve being judge as per their capacity even if they are from non science background.

[@kprabhakar975]

Honorable Judge sir is so knowledgeable that the doctor could not explain. Thank you sir.

[@shahiedshahied8770]

He knew the subject so well so only he is questioning doctor... Awesome we need this type of qualified judges

[@masterchefkitchen9986]

Hats off to the learnt judge salute you sir