Lawyer Abha Singh on Kolkata R*pe Case, CBI's Role & Misuse of Nirbhaya Fund | Karishma Mehta | Ep52

[@nidhimagon4469]

3 doctors male doctors and 1 female doctor who led her to the room are missing from the very day of the crime. Where are they....

[@vidulabavishi7501]

I am a gynecologist ,i have done L L M in Criminal Law. Very important message given by Abha Madam. I am inspired to become voice for the voiceless.

[@nishashah95]

What a powerful episode! Could feel the anger when she spoke about how we as a society failed the recent rape and murder victim in Kolkata 💔

[@Sereneee111]

​@@Invictus999-9 atleast they are raising their voice making people aware unlike you who's hating without any reason

[@silentwatch7643]

😢 Even CBi can be compromised. Looks like nobody is honest in India.

[@2009sanghi]

I agree with her . From the moment an FIR is filed to the punishment given by court should be done by a year. Justice delayed is justice denied

[@humansofbombay2801]

Indeed. 🙏🏻

[@HappyMarshrza]

That's why we all ready says these things cases for her parents,families and whtever so don't trust for their rules police,CBI and etc..they are not working in proper ways ,and they are need fr money and take charge more money only or and they might be just pretending to delay for justice but they just make money to do these and those things so that we are supporting you her parents families of Dr Muimita don't trust to them because they don't want to raise these case yours Daughter she hd rape murder like this kind she's not a human or what? she's non_Living thing or what? we're request you all the the peoples of Kolkata let's fight a violence to gt fr justice Dr.Muimita.why we are says these things you already known about Sushant Singh Rajput till now also He couldn't gt justice fr him !. therefore you just think are you believe for ours we are never trust fr these rules of police CBI and etc and also the peoples in kolkata don't trust

[@bahnisikhadutta7344]

Here in Kolkata, the Principal didn't even file an FIR on time! All the evidences were removed from the scene!!!

[@seetharamthammineni1302]

All the guys should wear bangles in Bengal, they failed to protect their sis moumota

[@nilanjanasengupta6910]

This channel itself is falsifying facts and declaring it was not a gangr*pe which is false.

[@soumo58]

Stop believing everything in social media...

[@prarthanapathak8100]

Exactly...

[@bak3310]

Hats off mam.Every woman should watch this.i feel all girls should educate from 8th std.onwards about law and order .All helpline numbers and rights of FIR should be a part of education system now and should be included in school books.Karate should be a must class from std.4.Abha mam is just outstanding

[@Also_Devika]

I feel it starts from Home, the kind of upbringing that you give to boys while they are growing up, teaching them to be more sensitive, more respectful towards women, teach men what women go through it needs to be taught well.

[@humansofbombay2801]

So true! 🙏🏻

[@accountchitty]

Verry true ...we boys or men should atleast learn from the incidents how brutal Male Gender is becoming.The Image of a "MALE" be it adult ,teen ,old or may be even a preteenager in future seems to switch to "BRUTE" .....the only way to stop this us to start at home ,if parents dnt know or not able to handle ,take councelling....from primary schools to colleges the primary activity must be this ,atleast weekly twice or daily is best .....now in comming generation,parents have to be more careful ...really afraid where is the world going .

[@Kaushani_Dey]

​@@Ra-rg1vk Don't just give up and make excuses instead you as a uncle should teach your nephew yourself if his parents are not doing the right thing.

[@accountchitty]

@@Soumyendug true

[@pamz122]

Everyone should watch this episode. Thank u mrs.singh for ur selfless work we need to speak up n b the voice to the voiceless..keep working n fight for justice for the voiceless. N thank u human of bombay for this needful n important potcast show.

[@parth3337]

Such a thorough , informative episode. Thank you Abha Singh Ma'am for being a voice of the voiceless

[@nityapraveen5082]

This is such an important conversation & use of the platform. Women can only make use of their rights when they know what they are

[@humansofbombay2801]

So true!

[@nityapraveen5082]

@@Invictus999-9maybe men don’t care about the law and continue to rape women…

[@nityapraveen5082]

@@Invictus999-9do you think that percentage of women with false claims is higher than the percentage of men abusing women?

[@malaconway2645]

​@@Invictus999-9Yes, works both ways, but women are victims far more often..... The statistics are there.

[@nilanjanasengupta6910]

No it isnt. The title of the video declares the culprit was one man while the original autopsy proved otherwise. She was a strong woman sleeping in a relatively public area, one man coulf not have subdued her and broken so many bones. There were multiple men.

[@mashkoorsabaab6733]

Honestly speaking, this is not one man involvement in such heinous crime.Where are the others?Are they backed by political support?

[@ushamenon6975]

you are so right dear viewer ...a single individual could not have restrained the doctor to such an extent unless she was made to loose conscious ness.The Tmc spokes persons have started to say to the media '' go and pose all questions to the CBI''

[@rajeniyannah1341]

Greetings from South Africa. Very powerful message. Following the Abhaya incident for the past 2 weeks and listening to all the News channels and these experts like Abha Singh, it's evidently clear that there is so much of inefficiencies in the policing system. I wish for the sake of Abhaya's parents they get the justice they deserve. Keep up the fight! Following!

[@shreyapaul3822]

Loved d caption..."Power is not to show off ,It is to make use of it..."

[@s_s8489]

The moment she said Sushant was not murdered...this woman lost all credibility for me! Im glad i saved 1:15:52 of my precious time! God knows where these people come from!? Everybody had an agenda, she says! Even the forensic experts who are not from India said how he was murdered! What agenda they had!? 😡

[@nidhimagon4469]

Abha Singh lawyer does she has any connection with Rathore (IG) accused in Ruchika Girotra case

[@abhishekdsl]

Same here. I was going through other comments and wondering why people are praising her when she's speaking complete bullshit. CBI will report only what its political masters will ask it to report. I am completely pissed off with her theory that only one person was involved in the Kolkata murder case.

[@radhikaraja8875]

Agree ..even I feel she has an agenda... Is she so dumb to say that it was only one person who raped..Sandip Roy seems to be a scapegoat.. the real culprits are being protected

[@radhikaraja8875]

She never mentioned about Shahjanh Sheik and sandesh khali....these type of NGO activists ( most of them)..are the real reason that real culprits get away and some innocents get trapped..Like in Kathua case it was quite evident that innocent scool teacher was falsely indicted and his two sons were named as culprits. Mehbooba mufti had concocted that story.. Everyone must read the book of ms Madhu Kiswar "The Kathua girl"..to know the truth...

[@sumonadey4837]

SSR did suicide . Celebrities can have mental issues and depression. DIGEST IT .

[@shaunbird8051]

Very good interview. Thanks. Definitely many people can benefit from this talk.

[@user-wc4li6qz3k]

This is one of the best and most informative videos i have ever watched. Thank you for posting this and making general public aware about their rights.

[@anupriyaakhade1526]

This conversation was such an eye opener 💯

[@humansofbombay2801]

Thank you for watching! 🙏🏻

[@sutapaprasad5472]

This is one video every right thinking person, male or female should watch. There is so much info about relevant topics. Kudos to the channel and respect to this amazing woman Ms. Abha Singh!

[@ushamenon6975]

Sushant singh Rajput's case was also not given a fair hearing. The mumbai police and other influential politicians were involved in protecting the perpetrators... Disha Salian's murder also remain unsolved

[@pauldaswani7637]

He was a good actor feel sorry for him it is hard to get justification in India even his parents we killed trying to find out about there son god knows when our India will change

[@SuperShinigamiKnight]

Everything she says is so correct, so true, so spot-on. From time immemorial, women have been regarded as a tool to be used, to be immortalized as a goddess, as a life-giving mother, as a beautiful creation, again as well as to be taken as a doormat, to be commented upon, lectured to, advised ........ And on and on and on.. the day this stops and a woman is regarded just as a living being living for herself ... That day our society will probably change

[@sharmistharai5518]

Very informative & knowledgeable! Everyone must watch it ! Inspired to work for voiceless !

[@anantkaushik5822]

So important to know the laws of the land. 🙏🏻

[@humansofbombay2801]

Absolutely! 🙏🏻

[@ritumukundan2280]

Kudos to Abha Singh ! She is brilliant and such a great force on the side of the voiceless. Most impressed and touched by her sincerity and her efforts to protect the law and protect victims. Speak up as she says. God gave us a voice. Don’t be afraid.

[@AryaMoney-hm7bz]

A much needed conversation 🥺

[@humansofbombay2801]

Absolutely! 🙏🏻

[@rperry6835]

The Doctor in West Bengal who is sexually abused and brutality that inflicted on her that night at work. Serving humanity. She is also a professional, I say an intelligent women who burnt candle late night to achieved her doctor's degree. Parents worked hard to pay her tuition fees. The whole world is shaken.

[@soumyarao8150]

So sad to see no1 is calling it a gang rape and everyone is blaming that scapegoat and protecting the real culprits, including relative of ex- Minister!

[@soumo58]

Sherlock Homes in this case nothing is more conclusive than the PMR and PMR done in the presence of junior doctors , dm and videographers.

[@AA_RFF]

Stop believing everything shared in social media. There's no forensic evidence that it's a case of gang rape. Court can't act on public sentiments!!

[@soumyarao8150]

@soumo58 The Drs only claimed gangr@pe early on. DNA report, nail clippings would nail the culprits but these are missing, no1 is bothered.

[@radhikaraja8875]

Totally agree with you ..this lady is talking with some agenda which is obvious...She never once blamed Mamata govt of trampling with the evidences by her goons.. She never mentioned about sandesh khali ..but she mentions about Kathua.. Also she never talks about why the so called juvenile in Nirbhaya case was let off in 3years and was pamperd by Delhi CM and TN govt..( rehabilitaed by them by giving money) Whereas in Kathua case the headmaster and the two boys who were framed ..( read Madhu Kishwars Book "the girl from Kathua" to know the facts)

[@socraticdialogue29.]

Thank you for a very informative and enlightening discussion. Kudos to Humans of Bombay

[@udipaabridge680]

So much gratitude humans of Bombay for bringing her up and lighting on so many things that normally go unsaid. Thanks ma'am ❤

[@nainamahtani2860]

This education of teaching boys in school to respect all girls women in college from kg to graduation and should be a compulsory subject in schools

[@sheilakrish1]

What about in homes...the father, husband , son brother should be seen to be respecting the women..household men are the role models for growing children

[@neelamagarwal4291]

Very informative Podcast, thanks 🙏

[@humansofbombay2801]

Thank you for watching! 🙏🏻

[@devraashi1449]

Chills down my spine!

[@humansofbombay2801]

Indeed.

[@Randomest_Stories]

I want to understand why an FIR can't be lodged online by every citizen and they can then join it with physical FIR at the police station. A simple audit every month or quarter will tell u how many FIRs were matched to a physical FIR. If not....enquire and punish where it is seen Physical police refused to do an FIR

[@akhilasanjeev7735]

You are very right, ma'am. CBI failed to investigate the Sushanth case

[@roscioocasio4385]

Greetings Ms. Mehta! I enjoyed your candid and informative conversation with Lawyer Abha Singh. I agreed with the sentiments of both of you. Here in the U.S., the corporate world favors the men. The burden of proof is on the victim. Generally speaking, the hospitals should have the security of "high-end" hotels; where anyone at anytime can be seen at any area of the building. I feel the medical personnel, reporters, and other individuals in careers that could possibly put their lives in jeopardy, should have personal "spy" cameras (because of their miniature size) as part of their apparel. These cameras would need to be setup to transmit off-site to a home network or other secure computer the individual or their families could access should something happen. Since both of our countries have similar problems, cases like this, should have an independent inspector, whose team means business; and can't be corrupted. My most sincere and heartfelt condolences to the late Jr. Dr's family! Peace and Blessings! Namasté! 🕉️🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🕉️❤️❤️❤️💐🕉️

[@humansofbombay2801]

Thank you for watching and sharing your thoughts! 🙏🏻

[@Indianlegalprofessional]

Not only mothers but the fathers also have responsibilities to teach their son. Men should stop talking loose talks about women. Men and women both jointly have responsibilities towards society.

[@IbrahimGuhaan]

Absolutely

[@Athirahindustani]

The moment she took Bilkis Bano case , I knew her agenda 🤮

[@bilkisjutha2462]

@@Athirahindustani what do you mean? What is her agenda?

[@maheshsikka4376]

This discussion was the need of the hour! Thanks for bringing this out

[@humansofbombay2801]

Thank you for watching! 🙏🏻

[@bilkisjutha2462]

This discussion was so informative and shocking at how pervasive this mistreatment of women and minors really is in India. There is definitely a failure at all levels of society and government if it is this pervasive. The words of Ms. Abha Singh that "we are only self absorbed and self centered and we are not concerned about others. If something wrong is happening we are scared. Let us not be fearful." Such true words and insight need to be echoed by everyone so as to help make the changes that are required not only in India or Indian society but globally because these issues are relevant everyone just in different degrees of pervasiveness.

[@humansofbombay2801]

🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@Athirahindustani]

They wouldnt talk abt abuse of men , boys etc .

[@udipaabridge680]

So much gratitude Abha Singh Ma'am

[@fatemaplumber4368]

What a powerful episode!

[@humansofbombay2801]

Thank you for watching! 🙏🏻

[@malaconway2645]

Thank you, Ms Mehta. Great show. Everything is so well explained by Ms Singh.

[@satwantdhanda8450]

Wonderful interview, I fully appreciate your knowledge and courage.

[@janakisreenivas]

Wonderful conversation and get to know so many things we still don't know

[@Randomest_Stories]

Its terrifying. How are we functioning as a nation 😢.

[@socraticdialogue29.]

I am watching from Canada, we have our problems in our nation as well, but nothing of this level of corruption and incompetence.

[@ChandrakanwarNaruka]

Thank you so much for such an insightful conversation🙏🙏

[@balajiedjeengaph3761]

Wow ... such a great conversation...No words but i really appreciate this beautiful lady for this podcast but such a great speaker Mrs Singh ..God will be with you no harm will be against you or anyone who fought for the voiceless peoples.... 👍💯💯💯💯💯💯🫶

[@payalchopra1095]

Absolutely loved the podcast. So relevant ! In fact it’s the need of the hour ! Thankful to Humans of Bombay for having invited Advocate Abha ji to share the recommendations. This was so good ! Abha ji is brilliant and inspiring…hope people in power take her advise…do needed to make our country a better place !

[@GULSHANGILL-t5v]

Justice for kolkata Dr Beti May God comfort and bless the family of this daughter .CBI is doing a very good job, I have full confidence that justice will be done.It's crucial to remember that heavy sedation can completely inhibit a person's ability to any sounds. This has serious implications, particularly when the victim has sustained severe injuries. It's imperative for professionals to intervene promptly in such cases.

[@anjanabhaduri1241]

oh!-- Hat's off- very bold Lady.!, .. (Thank you, Ma'am, for so much information)!

[@shantaborkar3372]

wat a strong interview. came to know about some important laws/rules v must know as citizens. i think its important for every individual of our country to know these important rights. if everybody is taught them in school/college i think life should b more stress free..less corrupt..more awareness nd accountable. jabbardast podcast this

[@kamalbrar7577]

Yes you both were very transparent and strong voice command Salute you both Bring this programmes with videos regularly.... In UK Police do name shame in news...

[@artidhuparh8877]

A very well explained summary. Abhaji is too good.

[@jayashreeswaminathan4634]

Very enlightening. A big thank you.

[@filmyfatafatIndia]

I request that make podcasts in Hindi as well because maximum people should be reached out with these kind of podcasts

[@satyanarayanaguda4848]

The inhuman layers that actively connived and did the brutally heinous crime: 1.Ministry & top Men 2. Health authority 3. Principal & his coterie 4. His low level confidants (could be doctors and other staff 5. Mad manic Roy 6. (one or two last grade staff plus some top police under orders from top)

[@aryamansingh8278]

Points made by ma'am in the video are valid and we must ponder upon them.

[@humansofbombay2801]

Absolutely! 🙏🏻

[@balmindarsingh6182]

The Principal must be also investigated as he is also responsible for this incident as he act is arbitrary. He must be investigated for unexplained wealth n leaving beyond his means. We want justice for the family, girls n women

[@roopamp8304]

Good interviewer. ❤❤

[@ratnade6073]

Excellent interviww.. very informative.

[@MINOTIK9]

Thank you for this Interview.

[@vedikanarsaria8843]

So heartbreaking.

[@humansofbombay2801]

🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@srilata2070]

If women stood by one another, things could be so much better. I've encountered situations that felt absolutely crazy, where women were left feeling helpless and victimized. Imagine a well-established neighbour brazenly standing naked in front of a divorcee living with her parents. If the divorcee dared to speak out, her envious woman neighbour would lash out at her. In another instance, an HR head blamed a female employee for reporting misconduct by her male boss. And the way these cases are resolved? A group of women leaders gathers, but it's the male HR head who leads the discussion and decides the outcome-another mockery of justice. I can completely understand how Abha Singh navigates through all these cases. She'll need many of us women to support her. Women endure torture and harassment at every level, even from their own parents, siblings, and certainly from in-laws. They're often pressured to remain silent, fearing that speaking out could cost them the very roof over their heads. The whole system of marrying daughters and making them vulnerable first in the hands of in laws then making her a helpless mother has to change. Women deserve freedom, even from the control and dictatorship of their own parents. We need to first give voices to the many mute women out there who remain victims their entire life.

[@zareentaj7654]

Very logical and mind boggling session!

[@bhagvatiramakrishnan5033]

Please,please hold workshops and bring awareness amongst young school boys for their mental health and bring about respect for women!!

[@sumitasanyal5287]

Thanks a ton Human of Bombay team for this wonderful episode. One request on behalf of all women, kindly make more and more such informative videos ( specially focusing on the laws for women) so that women of India can really get correctly informed. Because most women in our country are ignorant and they are forced to stay ignorant. Its a request to all women podcasters to come up with such discussions. Its really the need of the hour. We really need to sensitize these topics.

[@santhipravin9615]

Mam great information. Much appreciated for awareness about the various laws.

[@GirijaDD]

Thank you for letting us know several laws that can give us support.

[@akhilasanjeev7735]

So much information given by you ma'am.

[@DineshMSachdev]

Eye opener knowledge. Thanks humans of Bombay and alpha mam..Alpha mam ..u r inspirational

[@sodhamrinkal_28]

Each and every word spoken by this woman makes me feel so powerful she's so strong 💪🏻

[@sentamartins2618]

Much needed knowledge 💯

[@humansofbombay2801]

🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@GirijaDD]

It seems the doctor did not go to seminar room by herself. She was sent there by her colleague after a quarrel. The rapists were sent there. Others were told that work was going on there. So no one went there or hear the screams. It was a conspiracy.

[@bandanarajbongshi8668]

Awesome show! First time I am viewing your program.

[@NatashaSingh-xz3qs]

Sandip Ghosh still hasn't been arrested by the CBI.

[@saritafurtado9556]

Exactly. When was the last time CBI solved a big case. Shushant singh, Neet, etc...

[@mikes4348]

If legal professionals become honest, they have the power to change society.

[@socraticdialogue29.]

The onus is on each member of society to hold legal professionals accountable. This is what is called democracy.

[@mikes4348]

@@socraticdialogue29. Democracy is a system of government by the whole population or all the eligible members of a state, typically through elected representatives. In a country where most people are poor, their votes can be bought for a few thousand rupees. Do you expect them to hold anyone accountable?

[@shreehazel92]

This might sound very drastic, but the police need better training so that they don't victim shame. Every company, every govt. office, every college should have mandatory courses on "no sexual harassment" kind of courses and if they fail those courses, they don't get their license/degree/ position. Every school should have "value education/ moral science courses", and board exams should have mandatory "human ethics" courses, failing which does not let you have your school certificate. Every position that lets you have money, success, or a livelihood, should have a "human ethics" license/clearance. And they should need to be renewed every year so that good human behavior is ingrained in people's minds without any other choices available. Like a ration card/adhar card, every unemployed person should need to have a mandatory "human ethics and behavior" card renewed every year. Failure to pass should cut off access to basic necessities. And this should be obtained through non-human interactions, e.g. some online or digitized methods, so that nobody can tamper with results. Unless it comes to the level of people's own lives, people don't understand.

[@annajacinta1200]

Youth,mid age,oldies can 't change but young parents pls teach yr sons to respect girls and women from the time kids understand,faith and fear God and let them know God is watchng every acton,perhaps that helps to a better socety. Sons dont deserve to be treated greater but a good son will bring good society and families. Children learn from seeing and good or bad,they follow. Change for better and girls dont trust any man or anybody....your body is yours dont be naive be strong and smart.

[@drkaymd]

Thank you for putting it out there

[@humansofbombay2801]

🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@dipanjanrakshit7671]

According to CBI findings, the modification order of that bathroom which was just beside the claimed crime scene, was passed by the former principal Sandip Ghosh just a day after the case happened on 10th August 2024. Literally those who are non-resident of West Bengal, can't understand our situation currently. Only the people of Bengal can understand the situation of the crisis of humanity, we are facing because of our present Government.

[@sandy10442]

Abba Singh speaks so rightly! I agree totally with her

[@thingxang-yahgangsmy1995]

Very interesting interview. Both are fantastic

[@easypeasyenglish1331]

Fathers have to behave in the right manner!!!! Growing boys imitate their fathers.....he sees his father as a role model.....if the father is patriarchal, he too will be so..... speaking from personal experience.....as a mother, I have tried my best....

[@Fs_Ccoldd]

"Such a high quality knowledge "." Truth Dares".👍🏻 Defend yourself at all times and all cost.

[@priyagrover9253]

Hats of ma'am, require guts to say the TRUTH. HOPEING U WERE APOLITICAL.

[@shobanasamduth1818]

I can imagine what she went thru the pain 😢 bones broke eyes bleeding omg 😢very.....

[@eraranee7182]

Is he alone? Dnt think so

[@Athirahindustani]

Tell the judges to work like adults nd not vacation like school children 😡

[@ritadatta6197]

Salute..Abha ji

[@shanthishyju3344]

Basics of law and rights of citizens should be taught from primary school as a mandatory subject. We citizens have zero knowledge of our rights. Govts can invest in training retired citizens or housewives etc to work as educators of common man in establishing understanding of basic law and rights. Also, govt forces should be reeducated to establish trust among people. Big tasks ahead, but necessary ones.

[@Athirahindustani]

Mumtaz begum is the health nd home minister of her state . Why talk abt country’ GDP , chandrayaan mission ? Your agend is clear .

[@pradeepullanat]

Almost true… need action from Concerned authority to establish as law. Hope for the best.

[@Athirahindustani]

Bilkis Bano filed multiple FIRS .Initially she repirted no rape nd then she said she was not sure nd finally she was raped ( thanks to Teesta Seetalvad ) 🤮

[@Nepali-BengaliSpeakingLady]

I don’t believe this is modern India 🇮🇳 what a shameful act what a disgrace it. System failed India 😢

[@Athirahindustani]

Bilkis Bano ???? How many FIRs were given by her ? 😂Thanks to Teesta setekvad

[@arpithagowda1558]

In odisha, an army officer and his fiancee were assaulted for demanding to write an FIR!! How can an ordinary person hope for justice!

[@Saraswati.MSarasa]

Thanks for again 🇮🇳 Mam ❤

[@gosinglimicmie5396]

Mothers who protect their boys should also be jailed

[@HussainaNoordeen]

Excellent point. The principal should have filed FIR. And worst of all he was promoted not brought into justice.

[@vijayrchandran]

Feels rotten to the core. We as a society has to take the blame too. We find one excuse or the other.

[@Athirahindustani]

Tareek pe tarrekh is becos judges go on summer , winter vacation like school children . Shame on them 🤮