Lawyer says Alex Murdaugh never mentioned going to kennels on night of killing: full video

[@FancyNancy964]

Mr Crosbys testimony was so moving. He seems like a very decent and kind man.

[@KatJ3st]

The perfect foil for Alex's manipulations sadly

[@KatJ3st]

1qq

[@KimberlyBishh]

Not really though.. Alex didn't get away with much. You could say he didn't get away with anything.

[@janetscott5252]

You can see his disappointment and pain from all the terrible things in business Murdock had done, let alone the killings. He is sickened.

[@dfinite1111]

Agree.

[@horsegonewild]

The attorneys and friends of Alex who testified have shown more emotions and grief than Alex has.

[@cathyl2338]

I thought the exact same thing

[@jenniferpalsrok3857]

Totally disagree. Alec has been shook up at every witness. Rocking back and forth. This best friend seems fishy to me.

[@dougiesherwin9591]

@@jenniferpalsrok3857 Alec is rocking back and forth with fear. He's an arrogant lowlife, and going to spend the rest of his life in jail. Sucking black men off.

[@bamazing2731]

Alex was more fired up about being asked on the 911 call if he had a house or a mobile home…lol

[@louisesammons5644]

You mean fake emotions and grief!

[@skysk5469]

It’s comforting to see that there are so many trustworthy lawyers out there. This gentleman looks honest and forthcoming.

[@sloan_005]

Looks mean nothing, good grief. 🙄 If that were true prisons would be filled with only ugly people. ‘Trustworthy’ lawyers is pretty much an oxymoron. They sell their souls and twist everything. They are trained to do so.

[@makeupchick9544]

Or he was questioned by police, is therefore just giving the same testimony; not knowing it proves his buddy is a crooked liar who killed his wife and child.

[@_KaiRos-11]

U know what they say about lawyers… it’s not just one or some. They’re all that way besides maybe one or two maybe

[@sloan_005]

@@makeupchick9544 - Umm, he’s been questioned by more than the Police. He’s been an Attorney for decades, you don’t think he knows what he’s testifying to? 🙄

[@ZootZinBootZ]

Two lawyers competing for you to select thier services with... "One of us is always lying, the other is always telling the truth"

[@Changeiscoming47]

Sadly, these witnesses are far more devastated than Alex has ever been about the loss of his son. Litigators with 30-40 years of experience, who know how to control their emotions and feelings. It’s been more than a year and a half and their heartbreak is still fresh. Alex Murdaugh is a sociopath, narcissistic, cold blooded snake. God bless and be with all of these broken hearted souls 💔🙏🏻

[@14isoldenough]

God let em die. What kind of god does that?

[@Changeiscoming47]

@@14isoldenough Good question. I wish I had the answer.

[@jlowe8059]

He's a terrible person obviously, but I do think at some point he regretted it, and many of his tears may be legit. He just didn't have to balls to kill himself.

[@t.c.8212]

I hope the jury thinks so🤷‍♀️

[@dar44445]

@IsIt2024yet? You are 100% correct; my take, as well !!!

[@sooz9433]

Wow.. Mr. Crosby was very obviously devastated by the death of the Murdaughs. He comes across as a very good friend and an honest man and I think this was extremely difficult for him, to testify.

[@ambercombs5346]

Just remember he's a lawyer.

[@maryjemison1101]

@@ambercombs5346Amen

[@maryjemison1101]

@@EpiphAnniesexactly what she said

[@Len-jk4zi]

@@maryjemison1101 I think they'd like to know what that means in a literal sense for their own clarification.

[@murielodette2995]

mur-der mur-daugh. strange

[@leefromoakville3810]

The amount of pain that Alex Murdaugh caused so many people is hard to believe.

[@kapa4163]

I was thinking that. The community has been ripped apart. They’re feeling the pain of betrayal and death of his family.

[@janicescott7338]

Yes, the ripple effect. Just think how some of these gentlemen who were in AM law firm could of had a heart attack from the stress. Think what their wives even went through. The secretary’s and accountants. It’s all just tragic and horrible.

[@tinab3627]

Totally unbelievable

[@suejohnson3787]

People get corner they do desperate things

[@zoyalis1487]

He just reminds me of a privileged, arrogant, bully. I just wonder how many people were happy to see this happen to him. Not murdering his family & hurting people, but to be exposed for he who really is and knocked from his throne.

[@larrybrown9883]

The overwhelming consensus from Alex's colleagues was that he was really good with people and how to read them and to connect with them. In other words he was a master bullshitter and a manipulator of people. Two very strong and prominent traits of a narcissist and a Psychopath.

[@bonniecreighton4163]

🎯

[@patricktracy4371]

… attorneys

[@horsegonewild]

Bingo.

[@nbgilbert]

He was a good old boy just like they all were. Believe me all of them are suspicious. Who is friends with him was receiving benefits just like mr lafitte. And guess what? He’s not in prison even though he was convicted. These people make me sick!

[@Rnimgb115]

And lawyers😂😂😂

[@OthoDaFe]

A lawyer questioning a lawyer about a lawyer

[@JoGirl73]

Nicely done 😂

[@MissX905]

But only 1 of them turns out is a very very evil and crooked 1. Guess who.....

[@donnagarside8520]

And they all know each other

[@newt1834]

It gives a new meaning to justice 😅

[@dar44445]

#bravo👏

[@debnewpal4763]

Obviously Mr. Crosby cared more about Maggie and Paul than Alex ever did. His testimony brought me to tears.

[@letstalkcrypto532]

You are right……Maggie and Paul were sub human, dirty little red heads like Alex…….definitely in on the whole thing, right?..

[@chriscypret5365]

Alex was crying off ,on

[@cowdaddy4595]

Then you got conned.

[@TheKoolbraider]

@@chriscypret5365 Alex never shed a real tear.

[@h_williams1221]

@@chriscypret5365The head bobbing and smacking grated on me.

[@greenbeagle13]

If I needed an attorney, THIS would be the man I would want. He seems more hurt about Paul and Maggie than Alex did. Very compassionate.

[@h_williams1221]

I agree wholeheartedly

[@lorettacaslin3641]

This attorney is breaking my heart. Such a genuine man.

[@samanthacurl2640]

Attorney and genuine?.. wake up

[@alwaysready4017]

@@samanthacurl2640 all a show.. lawyers are bottom feeders.

[@fisherlady408]

I was very impressed with this man as well. You can tell his heart was broken when talking about Paul especially!

[@Writingxx]

@@samanthacurl2640 🤡🤡🤡

[@Writingxx]

@@samanthacurl2640 🤡🤡🤡

[@JeffreySykes]

I have never seen a more cold, calculating stare of guilt than when Alex stares at Ronnie after he id'd Alex's voice on the cell phone video. A complete example of the eyes revealing the soul.

[@noradunn7196]

I'm not sure Alex has a soul.

[@jakebe4915]

Black demonic eyes...they exist among us normal folk

[@merced175]

“Tell me how you knew Paul” You can see the lawyer instantly gets choked up and has to avoid getting emotional. I can feel his pain.

[@theresecosgrove930]

Try feeling the pain of the terrified animals shot and STABBED to death on his precious property. Another greedy devil.

[@bizzyduffy873]

Very sad.. The pain thats caused is terrible. All over money.

[@kimlarso]

He’s just a good actor just like Alex….No way the Firm didn’t know what Alex was doing for decades! What it comes down to is Alex is taking one for the Team however, they all will be taking care of Alex financially such as his attorney fees & whatever he wants & can have in prison for 👉the rest of his life to keep his mouth shut!

[@carleenkinte8622]

That is what I think there is no way the other lawyers did not know what was going on they took up for Alex and I do believe he and Maggie where arguing that why he does not remember what was going on at dinner and other times times

[@bizzyduffy873]

@@carleenkinte8622 if you watched the trial you will get answers to your questions. Also after the lawyers discovered what was happening they hired a forensic auditor to do an internal investigation aswell as their own internal investigstion.

[@matthewpittsinger8354]

His entire testimony struck me as immediately sincere and honorable. The collateral damage of the defendant’s actions is shocking in its reach.

[@tikibar1169]

I found myself crying during his testimony. Betrayal by a friend or family member is difficult

[@unapologeticallyme7664]

Me too. He's wonderful

[@StilettoCutsQuick.]

Did you listen to the AM’s jailhouse phone calls. Not a sincere bone in that guys body. Such a difference listening to this man and AM.

[@whatareuthinking1]

AM I don't know if it's the drugs stress everything crumbling wow what an awful awful person

[@sandralybrand9425]

I've listened and he's now manipulating his youngest son. All he talks about on his calls is money and bragging about gambling on ballgames!

[@KimberlyBishh]

Total disbelief, shock.. and to the very core... Alex is a snake in the grass.

[@dfinite1111]

Bless this man. Mr Crosby seems like a man with integrity. He has also been seriously snowed, by AM. Been run through an emotional ringer, and challenged by a trusted friend, family friend, and “brotherly” colleague. Then to have to articulate it all, on the stand, in front of the whole court and the world. *shudder.

[@TheresaofTheWorld]

As AM!

[@TG-fn2ri]

Not to mention seeing the “bodily” fluids of a lady he considered a good friend and a young man who called him “Uncle Ronny.”

[@KimberlyBishh]

Yeah his little stutters here and there really hit me in the heart, this man shouldn't have had to feel any of this.. none of the good people around Alec Murder should have felt any of this.

[@Roselady7]

He does seem very passionate but also remember he’s a very good lawyer and they know what to say. He already knew how to answer these questions. He wouldn’t have answered those questions the way he did if he was not an atty. A friend would question why their friend took money. I would want to know if he was being threatened or what was going on? This was too clean! I’m not saying Alex is innocent but no one questioned where the money was? What happened to yearly reports. If my company invested money I would want to know where it was and the balance. You don’t trust anyone with that large amount of money.

[@phyllistouchstone7136]

@@Roselady7 I do not trust any attorney

[@attorneymazur]

Mr Crosby is so far the best human of the pool of witnesses. His emotional reaction puts a human face on otherwise bizarre story

[@ariadneschild8460]

It got me when he couldn't speak when asked about Paul, he really was like family to him. I don't think Mr Crosby will get over it.

[@celinagarzamollohan7453]

Omg me too like a baby

[@robertafierro5592]

Nothing is more Bizarre or Baffling than Casey Anthony and that whole mess..

[@justanothersmith6012]

@@ariadneschild8460 I have a feeling we’ll be hearing a lot more about Ronnie Crosby . As for his description of Paul, aside from the part where he describes Paul “hunting” wild hogs with hog dogs then killing them with a KNIFE, it’s very different from from what is already known about Paul, as a child then young adult. The word CRUEL was used , even as a young child , but the way Paul took pleasure in torturing and slaughtering wild hogs , putting dogs at risk of severe injury or death for the love of the sport, does give us a glimpse of what Paul was like.

[@ariadneschild8460]

@@justanothersmith6012 I'm not as bothered by the pig hunting bc it's normal in Australia due to their feral status. So many are up in arms about things irrelevant to the murder.

[@johnnyreddot]

Great lesson, when attorney gives testimony wait until question is asked, pause think about your answer and then give it. You see he’s a pro

[@ahnonemous8250]

Yes, definitely! the pause before answering also gives time for an objection on cross.

[@sherylbender9049]

Yes I agree. I can see shutter his mouth. Strange

[@Dhaneshwar9]

Skill..

[@unapologeticallyme7664]

Excellent

[@tonics7121]

What pure joy to listen to a prosecutor who moves logically, step by step, NOT leaving listeners to wonder what his point is.

[@moonchild1569]

The prosecution sucks!!! and I believe he is guilty

[@cbeverage18]

THIS!!!!! this is what I came looking for in the comments, I couldn't have said it better myself so I was searching!!!!

[@TG-fn2ri]

@@cbeverage18 Same. I play the videos to fall asleep because I have insomnia. Actually helps.

[@cbeverage18]

@@TG-fn2ri i do too! I was actually just falling asleep, so i turned it off... And now I'm suddenly awake again ☹️ time to start a new one!

[@suzymoroka297]

@@moonchild1569 you believe the prosecution is guilty??

[@myrnasherman4351]

He is such a soft spoken gentleman. His testimony is deeply sincere. My 💜 breaks for him

[@slix96]

Just when you think you have grasped what AM has done, more comes out. The fact that this man’s family had a relationship with the young woman who AMs son killed just adds to the devastation.

[@sueherb6482]

⁰

[@jannyjanjan2385]

Soooo creepy! All of it! I can’t believe humans can be so unthinking bad/evil! Alex is evil!

[@leahanderson30]

The whole family evil lack of a soul or sold their souls

[@suzymoroka297]

@@leahanderson30 Maggie was an enabler of the entitlement of these boys. I read somewhere that in her eyes, these boys could do no wrong

[@slix96]

@@leahanderson30 no I haven’t watched it. I love documentaries so I definitely will watch

[@greeneyedsoutherngirl6468]

Just think if Paul hadn’t of taken those videos-he’s literally telling everyone his dad did it from those videos. 😔

[@brettlawson9488]

Most damning evidence against him

[@manyenaa6301]

Alec thought he committed the perfect crime! He intentionally used two different weapons to secure reasonable doubt, if needed. But how difficult is it for an avid hunter to carry a rifle on his shoulder while shooting another weapon?? For all of his meticulous planning he couldn't account for the human variable...Paul talking to his friend on the phone & then recording the dog Cash!

[@Terri1976]

The Lord works in mysterious ways. When I heard AM talking about his son cellphone during 911 call I was shocked that this would be his focus. I understand now why...

[@bg3409]

@@manyenaa6301 💯

[@tektako]

@@manyenaa6301 you haven’t watched Rambo have you?

[@goingaboutmyfathersbusines4359]

I really enjoyed this man's testimony. He is believable and sincere..he is one of the best witnesses so far..

[@PrettyGoodLookin]

I see acting. I see a fake personality.

[@jenniferpalsrok3857]

Me too. Best friend is Fake fake fake and guilty of something

[@angelaholmes717]

Does anyone else wonder if Alex had anything to do with his father's death?

[@mathewgladden8914]

@@PrettyGoodLookin seriously lolol people are so gullible

[@jancrawford9318]

@@PrettyGoodLookinYou nailed it! I wouldn’t trust him as far as I could spit!!! 😂

[@merryhunt9153]

This is so sad. Everybody talks about how Paul was spoiled, entitled, and responsible for Mallory's death, but this man remembers him as a longtime friend and a buddy to his own son, and he weeps.

[@shirleydrake1602]

This man’s children were considered equals, or nearly so, by Paul and possibly Maggie. Alec doesn’t consider anyone to be HIS equal. Everyone was there to meet his personal needs.

[@laurahoward5426]

When the going is good, it's easy to ride the gravy train...when the gravy train derails, everyone suffers

[@noradunn7196]

It was said that Paul was not the favorite with his father nor his mother. It's sad he didn't have the chance to become a better person. If his father killed him, which I believe he did, he knew it. That is a terrible way to die.

[@kimberlymason7080]

I am sure both sides of Paul were there. When someone has a drinking problem, they can change in behavior. as with all teens and kids in their early twenties, they show a different face to their friends than adults - I know I did.

[@TheTaxburden]

Let's be real, he wasn't the only one drinking that night. They all had been. Accidents happen. Not like he did it on purpose. People see a family with money and automatically think they're entitled snobs without knowing them at all.

[@outoftime7740]

Thank you Ronnie, you are my favorite witness so far. You were genuine and true. You also broke my heart, when you spoke about Paul. You are a good man.

[@donmoore7785]

How sure are you? 100% sure. Guilty, guilty, guilty.

[@mjz16]

No way a lawyer and a friend would say 100% if there was tiniest chance it wasn’t.

[@chasityyoung815]

Where I come from if a double homicide occurred, NOBODY would be allowed onto the property, especially while the bodies were still there.

[@LScholten]

Shows what entitlement and money gets you.

[@Loverofnature76]

The entire crime scene was compromised,

[@cbeverage18]

But this ain't where you come from. It was testified when Mallory Beach died they waived alex right on thru the crime scene tape.

[@chasityyoung815]

@@cbeverage18 yes! That also blew my mind!!

[@Loverofnature76]

@@cbeverage18 omg , I didn't know that 😳

[@elizaleroux9173]

I actually felt his pain talking about Paul. This whole case is affecting so many people not just the accused.

[@kelley695]

Agree. I mean look at all of us just watching the trial. I’ve cried COUNTLESS times. ESPECIALLY when Paul & Maggie’s injuries are explained. I didn’t even know these people and I’m sick, and devastated. I can’t begin to imagine the pain their friends and family are feeling. 😢

[@sandcastle1417]

Paul was a verified peace of sh*t though...If your daughter, sister, mother was killed on that boat you'd be thinking real differently about him.

[@HappyEverElle]

This is heartbreaking. I feel so sad for all the people who were deceived by the defendant. This witness obviously cared very deeply for the defendant and his family. 😞💔

[@Mewse1203]

Watching him go from a serious professional to choked up is heartbreaking

[@albybrava]

Eulogizing a boy that beat up and publicly humiliated his girlfriend, kill an innocent girl and then smile about it to the police. Nice people.

[@jasontisdale5172]

What would you rather him do felicia? Pee on the boys grave? Your moms a hoe but she’s still your mom.

[@wendyhannan2454]

I understand what your saying here.

[@sammisung3914]

This man is devastated his “friend” did this. Traumatized. 😢

[@BK-uf6qr]

Criminals these days don’t always look like criminals. It’s a different world. People you considered friends aren’t always what one thinks.

[@margopack6343]

I would feel so betrayed if my best friend did this to me, just heartbreaking.

[@jackiek412]

He will be impacted by this for the rest of his life. I hope he is seeking counseling.

[@M.ds87]

@@BK-uf6qrmy guy... It's always been that way, you just were prejudicial. Welcome to the fold, where there are no good or bad people, only people doing good or bad things... Where everyone is a criminal one way or another. Our entire existence and social structure is inherently built upon harming one another for our own gain. It doesn't have to be a zero sum game, but it's hard to change such rigid rules of millenia. By the way, I was in prison with blue and white collar criminals alike. The guys from better financial backgrounds usually had more of these insane and drastic charges and stories. Ironically enough, because of people who didn't think they looked like a bad guy or a criminal. Just like Alex , they were skilled at the art of seduction and bullshit. So when the levee finally breaks , it breaks in spectacular fashion. The guys you think look like criminals typically didn't start that way, they just had a gradual increase in their crimes and severity - typically STARTING innocently enough because of a warped world view that allowed them to take riskier and riskier indulgences for the sake of survival or pleasure. As crazy as this case is, it's nothing new. One of the guys that stands out to me best is the regional flight traffic controller of the FAA for the entire Midwest region. He snapped one night and took a 30-30 and blew his wife's legs clean off. Ironically enough, again, they were arguing over money... Everyone wants more more more. He'd have gotten less time if she'd actually died too. Count your blessings folks, and open your mind a bit as to your own preconceived notions and your own ego and humility. We are all just walking different paths to the same places.

[@amandapayton5214]

Well said, sir. We have ALL done things we are not proud of or could be in jail for, just not all are caught. We do not end up in the same place, most do end up 6ft deep but some will go with Jesus and the rest go to the lake of fire. It is our given free will to repent for our sins, as a sin is a sin and looked at as the same level even though murder is the most horrible, I believe, but so is lying and cheating. We can all choose to turn our lives around, come to repent and go to Jesus, and be better people that we need to be. We all need to realize, we are human, we make mistakes, be nice and lend out a hand to lift other off of their feet when they fall, it is not "if" it's "when" we fall that we need the most help. I pray all these people involved get the rightful healing they deserve! God bless you sir and all the others reading this and going through something no one knows about, the light will still shine!

[@tmtm5595]

Heartbreaking to hear him describe Paul. Only a killer couldn't have watched someone talk so well about his own son.

[@maryloukauffman3551]

You

[@maryloukauffman3551]

P

[@iTammy]

Huh?

[@KimberlyBishh]

Yup!

[@Tattiehoker]

They were all killers!

[@amandawalden6319]

It's heartbreaking to listen to this man talk about Paul... Paul's own father doesn't even show any emotion!!

[@JoanneMomsen]

On a technical note: Every time I watch a witness taking the stand in this case, it bothers me that almost all of them have to bend forward to speak into the microphone. My question is: can't the microphone be adjusted so that they can just focus on the content of their answers rather than also think about being audible over the microphone?

[@Terri1976]

I know right!!!

[@smileeysface]

It can't be adjusted much at all. This is the worst witness stand I've ever seen. The chair looks terribly uncomfortable, and the witnesses look uncomfortable. Meanwhile, the judge's chair is about a $500 chair. (I like the judge btw)

[@rvthereyet4553]

@@smileeysface The judge's chair cost several thousand I'm sure. The poor color choice irks me for some reason, it doesn't fit the room.

[@smileeysface]

@RV there yet? I don't know how much the city actually paid for it, but Emily D Baker channel has a link to what is supposed to be the same chair for $500. I just think if it wasn't obvious to them before, it should be now they need to do some shopping. Maybe they should start a gofundme, and Tinsley can donate enough to cover it. He did say it was uncomfortable.

[@rvthereyet4553]

@@smileeysface Yes everyone looks very uncomfortable and at an odd angle.

[@cdelane3335]

People knew this man for decades and never really knew who he really was. So this questioning of him be loving husband and father doesn't hold up well.

[@Myannasmagic1983]

Absolutely! And so many still don't get this

[@Oldfarmlady]

Ya I don't know if I completely buy it. Maybe they didn't know all the details, but they had to know something was off. They probably choose to look the other way considering the money he was bringing in and his family name.

[@suejohnson3787]

Yea..does anybody really know anybody ? ..

[@darlingkelly100]

@@suejohnson3787 my thoughts exactly

[@leahanderson30]

I said that people only said that probably because he told them to or because that’s what they showed people outside but didn’t allow them to see them behind closed doors people only sho you what they want you to see

[@RikodiusRex]

Listening to these attorneys get up there and cry genuine tears is pretty humanizing for a lawyer. I actually like these lawyers a lot for how vulnerable they have to be in public. I know that is hard. ❤️

[@shirleydrake1602]

Would the witnesses not need to express grief and sorrow after finding one of the partners was misappropriating funds from trust funds administered by their firm. That’s quite an offense for a attorney.

[@iffyangel3380]

This testimony is so important, so sad and you can see him struggling with the pain he is going through.

[@dianayount2122]

He seems more genuinely distraught than Alex

[@ohioh111b111y]

he really does. He seems almost traumatized by doing what he knows he MUST do / say.

[@kimberlylowe646]

Man, Alex caused so much pain for so many. He was so lucky to have all those good people in his life who loved & cared for him. Greed is an evil thing. He crushed their hearts & souls. #JusticeFor Maggie&Paul

[@patgal2359]

also their skulls and brains

[@dr.barrycohn5461]

He sure screwed people's lives.

[@OOceaneyess]

This poor man showing more REAL emotions of grief for Paul than Alex had.

[@PKL789]

Who leaves without telling your spouse where you are going at 9:00 pm?

[@dianealarcon8304]

Especially, if you asked your wife to drive out to the house, and go w/you to the hospital.

[@athenavan2242]

@@dianealarcon8304 exactly that late in the evening, most hospitals have visiting hours, but I guess when you Alex those rules wouldnt apply.

[@salutsoleil3682]

Was there any evidence that he went to the hospital that night?

[@cathyl2338]

@@salutsoleil3682 I think it was earlier in the evening he’d gone.

[@terryschwartz5254]

me

[@jeanyale5599]

Amazing. The son he kill3d is the one who will put him behind bars for their murders with that video. Alex wasn't thinking when his son was video taping about the dog. This is incredible and damaging evidence against Alex. This was meant to happen this way.

[@jasontisdale5172]

No way that one video is enough evidence for first degree murder. The prosecution has no evidence.

[@lindakaufmann9099]

I think that’s why he tried to get the Sons phone and probably couldn’t get it open and that’s why he said it there and said it fell out of his pocket

[@abc-wv4in]

@@lindakaufmann9099 I don't think he knew Paul had made the video. He would have destroyed the phone if he had known. Thank goodness for those two dogs!

[@senzubean27]

damn I teared up listening to him talk about knowing Paul. Everything is pointing towards Alex, not away, but even without the murder charges, its clear that Alex was a deceptive manipulator of the highest order.

[@mariagabrielle6383]

RICO Act all day long

[@Treny5000]

Nepotism

[@tektako]

Nevermind homicide, he should be locked up for any one of the shitty things he’s done over a lifetime.

[@marthadavidson4441]

Love Mr Waters-sensitive and very humane

[@lauramatterazzo7670]

This witness was clearly devasted. My heart went out to him.

[@joycetipton3811]

I don’t understand how he can even sit there and listen to all the people he betrayed.

[@tommymyers3183]

Whats he supposed to do, leave?

[@miab82]

I know exactly what you mean. And, no not that he can just get up and leave (obviously 🙄) But to sit there and hear literally everything come out that what he thought would go with him to the grave. The level of embarrassment has to be unbelievable 😬

[@jenniferbailey5914]

He can’t go anywhere but a narcissist does not have empathy. The only time he rocks himself to self sooth is when he is wounded. He does not care for others. He disgusts me!

[@LorJuT]

Crying like a baby…silly fool. no one don’t know your story Alec

[@joycetipton3811]

I know he can’t leave idiots but to sit there and look all those people in the face like nothing happened and to the people he consider friends. He has to have a stone cold heart.

[@kellycregeen1393]

MR CROSBY SEEMS LIKE A GREAT FAMILY FRIEND,COWORKER!!!!!HE REALLY LOVED PAUL LIKE A SON

[@islanderbyrd1881]

If Crosby had watched the video of Paul at the dock (after Mallory was missing, dead) he would have seen the real Paul Murdaugh. In the ambulance, Paul was blaming others, even though he refused to give up piloting the boat. 3 witnesses reported Paul was the driver of the boat.

[@MyWildhaber]

I felt his pain talking about Paul. His son must be devastated too 😢

[@Lisa-dd6gm]

Same thought 😢so sad and for his son being his friend.. what a loss 😢

[@Lisa-dd6gm]

Very emotional testimony 😢 big loss 😢 Justice for Maggy & Paul

[@deolindaramada4166]

This Attorney loved his son more than his father it really broke my heart how can he be so cold 👿

[@linds1571]

What attorney ?

[@JanJan-Y4d-6dx]

@@linds1571 referring to the lawyer on the stand as an attorney I believe

[@ashleymorris8705]

Oh, yes. it seems he cared for Paul a lot more than he did for Alex

[@cigar_fanatic_721]

As a European, I will never understand how it is possible to be surrounded by so many guns in America. Finally start regulating it and you won't have these problems.

[@dirkdigler5190]

SHALL NOT be INFRINGED

[@unapologeticallyme7664]

I love this lawyer. Bless his heart ❤️ What a great guy.

[@nishamack586]

My husband and his brothers inherited a church from their late father. It took about 2 years before the other brothers realized that one had swindled 60 thousand dollars from the church account. This particular brother is charming, generous, larger than life personality! Their late father always sheltered the one brother from his financial failures, he even had accounts he used after their fathers death( in the dead father's name) It's not hard to see how Alec's partners could be blinded for a while, but eventually they knew what he was! I believe sooner than they are now publicly claiming!

[@ashleymorris8705]

Wow 😮

[@tiffanygipson]

Of course they probably had an idea but these ppl probably had to put the pieces together before confronting him honestly

[@abc-wv4in]

How does a person "inherit a church"? Did he inherit the building the church leased, maybe? A church doesn't "belong" to any one person, or at least no church I've ever known. Notwithstanding, for someone in a church to steal is especially evil.

[@nishamack586]

@@abc-wv4in Their father founded that church in 1969. Yes, they own the building. There are generations of family members that still attend to this day. A church is still a business, bills still have to be paid. Yes, someone owns the church. Lol

[@cpatient3564]

This friend/law partner knew four ppl (Mallory, Gloria, Maggie, Paul) who died all surrounding Alec. No wonder everyone seems fearful testifying.

[@sanna7509]

And Buster's supposed gay lover who died of a hit and run that didn't fit a hit and run description

[@lucyElaine5656]

After hearing the testimony I wonder, if the housekeeper really was tripped by a dog????

[@zoyalis1487]

@@lucyElaine5656 I always thought Paul & his mom helped Alex with that. The 9-1-1 call was so disturbing. I didn't hear urgency and Paul continuously sounded as if he was aggravated with the dispatcher on the phone. I remember thinking she wasn't dead yet, and they needed that to happen before the EMT's arrived. Isn't it ironic the maid tried over a dog and died, them the wife and son dies in the dog kennels area. Faking his attempted murder/suicide Alex was shot (grazed) in the head, Paul brains were blown out, and the wife faired no better. Alex murder methods didn't seem to switch up much.

[@suejohnson3787]

@@sanna7509 sii buster is gay..? Well no suprise

[@BlackStump172]

Don’t forget Morgan , Paul’s girlfriend , who survived a car accident . No doubt a warning to keep her mouth closed .

[@elskid206]

I was thrilled to hear a person speak in such measured tones, with such accuracy and thoughtfulness. Our society at large seems unable to communicate anymore. With hundreds of, "like... you know" peppering sentences, non-stop f-bombs, half sentences topped off with continual, "you know what I mean?". I am forever saying, "no I don't". Why should I hear half a dozen partial sentences, three dozen f-bombs and agree that a communication has taken place when it hasn't.

[@ruthegan8524]

Amen.

[@chairlesnicol672]

Even pres Biden does that. " No I really mean that" !/or Anderson Cooper" "I mean" etcl lol

[@KimK-cd3oe]

Alex drove me mad during the police car interviews in not finishing his answers

[@katewilson9691]

You are not alone. I was trying to pack for a trip as I have the week off, but I was drawn to the sweet and gentle nature of this man. He reminded me so much of my dear brother who has Alzheimer's disease. The witness was obviously devastated and wore his heart on his shirt sleeve. I guess we really don't know those we love as well as we think we do. Such a breach of trust and such a loss will always tear at his heart and memories. Poor guy. This is such a complex case, and there are so many excellent witnesses. Who knows where it will all end. A. Murdoch's face has such a flat affect. I wonder what he is thinking. His best friend was torn with grief and he is a blank page. Grief? Denial? Suppression of emotions?

[@lisas2538]

Alex is a sociopath.

[@shirleydrake1602]

Opiate users have a flattened affect. But I truly doubt the truth, as he states it , regarding his reported level of use. It seems clinically impossible to me.

[@sotelo4evr]

@@shirleydrake1602and you know this how?

[@laurahoward5426]

N9 feelings at all, just cold, dead shark eyes

[@laurahoward5426]

@@shirleydrake1602 Google how many opiates addicts can take....100s a day

[@chasityyoung815]

It's so strange to me that so many intelligent people were duped. Not only once, but many times.

[@kapa4163]

It’s called wilful blindness. They didn’t want to see.

[@janicescott7338]

Me too and that is why I think possibly AM may have been a fairly nice guy at one time. I know it’s hard to believe I know but how could of he of had these long time friends of integrity that trusted him! He may of gone down hill steadily after getting on drugs?

[@rebecca3205]

@@janicescott7338 As long as a narcissist / sociopath is being admired and getting his way or he's attempting to manipulate people, he can be the epitome of charming and agreeable. But when you say "no" to one, he can turn absolutely nasty and vicious.

[@MissX905]

AM had a lot of clients I guess so $$$ was coming in and his father and grandfather and on down the line we big and powerful men in the area they say.

[@janicescott7338]

@@rebecca3205 I’m afraid you are correct! Just don’t cross them.

[@HeatherRose2023]

AM immediately called his law firm partners to run over to the crime scene knowing it would create chaos, confusion and contamination. It was a pre-meditated attempt on AM’s part to destroy evidence. An innocent person, especially a person who has worked in any type of legal investigation, would know to preserve the integrity of the crime scene in order to find the killers. Tire tracks are particularly important in this case, and Alex knew that. What better way to eliminate that evidence than to invite people in to drive over it?

[@simka6858]

Good observation

[@bsrk3170]

Remind you of John and Patsy Ramsey?

[@rondafindley-ie9zs]

As Attorneys they should have known better than to contaminate the crime scene.

[@marvinabigby5509]

Mr Cosby is still mourning Pails death and the friendship he thought he had with Alec

[@dianegroves1141]

The pain is written all over his face. To be played like this must have hurt like hell when this all came out! Time has passed since this happened, but many are still affected by his crimes.

[@lesliewoodhull5383]

This man, Mr Crosby, is a very good and very kind man. Even after all this time he still tears up about Paul and you can tell that he loved him like a son. So sorry for all of the pain that AM has caused all these people.

[@jackiek412]

This man is as genuine as they come.

[@ZZ-yw5sh]

The most important thing Crosby said in his testimony was that he definitely identified Alex Murdaugh speaking in the video that Paul had posted…proving Alex is lying.

[@robertgray8377]

Why doesn't AM just admit what he did????? Just to arrogant I would guess. The boat crash was the final nail in AM's deceit.

[@jannyjanjan2385]

He loves himself too much

[@Susan42375]

All the body language experts say he’s guilty as sin. No signs of true grief or horror.

[@justmyopinion7636]

😂 this guy is a hoot. He looks so serious and then when asked about his reaction to Alex wanting to hide fees because of the boat case, he said “oh fu*#ck, no we’re not!” Love him.

[@Babygottaeat249]

hia face at @35:07 when he acknowledges that he is probably going to have to hear the snapchat video that basically 100% confirms he was at the kennels is kind of heartbreaking. Like he knows he has to do it. But it's such a betrayal as a friend as a family member as a partner to have the evidence to prove that he was at the scene of the crime minutes before it happened..

[@katherinechadwick828]

Yes! This poor, sweet man. I cannot imagine. Just awful.

[@retiredmom9049]

Thought the same thing. You could tell he didn’t want to have to listen to that video.

[@janevangelov364]

He closes his eyes briefly and shakes his head, a No, I don't want to listen to this

[@bflynn1985]

And then AM glares at him after he testifies that was his voice.

[@billyellis3509]

Its amazing that a man would screw over so many people that cared for him .. And now it seems he did do away with his very own family members.

[@lindaross783]

Allegedly

[@billyellis3509]

@@lindaross783 Criminals will do anything for money ,there's know allegedly about that . That's facts . This man has been a criminal for a long time . After hearing his voice on the recording at around the time of the deaths and him denying he was their . Guilty .

[@donnameans1030]

I think he stole money but I donot think her killed his wife and son! I just dont

[@louisewright8769]

Alex is giving him the death glare at this guy on the stand he is fortunate he is not a family member !!

[@SmushyMcMushy]

The blatant glares seem a bit inappropriate for a defendant. Alex is such a disgrace

[@SLYDIT]

How the FK was he allowed to be on the property of a double murder just 2 hours after it happened??? I mean......seriously???

[@dianeaustin2414]

Small Town in South Carolina, maybe???

[@tommymyers3183]

It's a 2000 acre sprawling estate.

[@SSteeleify]

Which ironically happened to be a guy Alec stole a lot of money from and had more motive for murder then Alec. Returning to the scene of the crime?

[@tennesseestephani1353]

He’s a Murdaugh

[@SLYDIT]

@@tommymyers3183 nobody should have been let on to the property. His friends were in the house before it was even searched....wtf

[@joanneb3935]

It's so sad to see all these people totally crushed by this. What a tragedy that has probably impacted hundreds of people.

[@lovelylyrics1687]

Broke my heart listening to this man. I can't even elaborate except to say it brought me to tears. What an absolute rare treasure to have a friend like this man. You couldn't ask for a better blessing . Paul died a wealthy man. And no I'm not talking about money.

[@kelley695]

Right? We’re all crying watching & listening, yet Alex hasn’t shed ONE tear.

[@lovelylyrics1687]

@@kelley695 he looks upset I don't know he's a weird person

[@JPop1240]

I think Paul was just hitting the tip of the iceberg on a lifetime of trouble because of alcoholism.

[@feanorian21maglor38]

@@kelley695 He's such an obvious psychopath. If he ever shed a tear, it'd be for his narcissistic self.

[@SunshinesART]

This man is one of the kindest gentlemen that I know personally. He has a heart of gold. Breaks my heart to see him like this. He is shattered. He is not your typical lawyer stereotype. He is who he is on the stand.

[@judyscott9733]

This poor guy is suffering so much.

[@joelrudzinski6829]

There goes Alex again putting his head down when the evidence came out trying to push out some tears like every inmate I use to supervise trying to bring some pity for the incident that they caused.

[@TG-fn2ri]

His face gets really red too, which makes me think he’s holding his breath so people will think it is from crying

[@islanderbyrd1881]

I agree Joel, duping people has been Alex's entire way of living life.

[@optoms1178]

The amount of pain, disappointment and hurt that Alex caused is evident on this man's face...

[@AmandaBooBerry]

Wow. I can't even remember seeing such a straightforward and unimpeachable witness! His evident pain was hard to watch.😞

[@lynnegackstetter2779]

Ronnie Crosby seems like such a good man. His family should be proud of him.

[@cuthbert2546]

The utter sense of betrayal this man and others felt must be overwhelming.

[@MacSwan]

A man who had so much of everything, not just wealth but people who cared and he trampled on it, just threw it away.

[@914sandi]

I'm so sorry for this man. 😞 I hope he finds peace inn is heart again.

[@bethwhite3936]

Why is it that you ppl can’t spell correctly? If you make an fn comments😢,make sure it’s spelled correctly 🙄🤦‍♀️😂

[@Tattiehoker]

Why?? He didn't lose any Family members, he's manipulating the Jury

[@ashleymorris8705]

Me too ♥️

[@mariahenrich9602]

I think he said he's moved past the anger which is most of his healing. Good for him.

[@Shadowfax0113]

@@Tattiehokeridiot

[@sqrd3536]

That look of disgust on AM's when being identified, you can't miss it. A man who single handedly wiped out his family's future. Epitome of evil betrayal.

[@marshadavies8440]

He's got some very ugly& smartarse looks!

[@happyinparis]

My heart goes out to this man. He has a kind heart. He's devastated.

[@marvinabigby5509]

It had to be so embarrassing for Randy being called to that emergency meeting about Alec stealing

[@lisabowden402]

Or head have known. I feel like someone had to have known something for it to go for 11 years

[@greeneyedsoutherngirl6468]

If he had known that would be really stupid…..he was a partner, he was being stolen from as well.

[@dianealarcon8304]

@Lisa Bowden I wonder, if his brother or father knew. I really can’t see how they were in on it, only becuz by now, I think, the CFO would have ratted them all out, including the Feds. I can’t wait for his next trial, to hear what his brother has to say about the 99 counts of financial fraud,…

[@janicescott7338]

I know and so glad he didn’t try to make any excuses. We can only imagine how worried Randy had been.

[@lisabowden402]

@@janicescott7338 I have seen John Marvin at the trial , but has Randy been there?

[@cindywoodburn3068]

I have always thought it strange that when the 911 call came in about Gloria’s trip and fall incident, I never heard any noise of dogs.

[@lawdog323]

Exactly

[@amynadine9669]

Oh that’s right!!

[@MrsBooklover55]

The kennel was quite aways from the house.

[@ap1753]

Or any emotion aside from impatience

[@unapologeticallyme7664]

@@MrsBooklover55 They had three inside dogs

[@Harley57]

This man helped raise Paul, knew him all his life. IMO he feels like he has lost a child of his own. He has shed more tears than Alex.

[@astrialindah2773]

I mean really? You literally have no idea how many tears Alex has shed..... Only what a very few minutes of videos shows you....🧐

[@onwardsandupwards7397]

What stuns me is that no one, not one lawyer, not a friend, not a family member, ever stood up and confronted Alex Murdaugh (or even his out of control son, Paul) about their anti-social behavior and all the tragedy that unfolded because no one seemed to acknowledge outwardly truth.

[@maliamarin5718]

so heartbreaking you can tell he cared deeply for Paul! he was more then a kid who caused a wreck even though that was aweful! He was also a human being who was good with kids.

[@kareenwatson6084]

Thanks lord that I have learnt to be content with what I have . Thanks that I am never bothered by the things that others have.

[@May13Tiffanyyy]

I know someone name Kareen Watson.

[@islanderbyrd1881]

"MONEY IS THE ROOT OF ALL EVIL". Especially when it is stolen & embezzled from others.

[@romaworks8248]

Alex seems totally remorseless. He is a scary man. Hope he gets true justice, if not in this world, in the next.

[@cynthiashaw45]

Justice is now or never. Justice delayed is justice denied

[@mjz16]

He didn’t expect Paul to be recording.

[@donna-leeking9014]

That was so emotionally gruelling for this witness💔

[@sweetlady22]

It is interesting that the people who knew Maggie and Paul were much more upset over their deaths than Alec and some of the rest of the family

[@the5thYearSeniors]

Should have called the boat case the Mallory case. Missed a good opportunity to pound the real issue with that

[@cdelane3335]

He knows that's him on the video talking he gets visibly upset every time he hears it. This is big, 2 people now have said that's Alex voice in the snapchat video.

[@johnengland8619]

That's how they are going to pin it on him.

[@johnengland8619]

@Brianna Cartwright yy but they still need to find more evidence. Theft is not a reason to murder. If you think he killed them to try and get out of legal liability that's out there

[@GoldSkye]

@@johnengland8619hat man is a crackhead sir. And he has the decision making skills of one. He’s used to being able to manipulate and scam people to cover his ass. He’s been playing kicking the can of financial ruin for a long long time and he’s thinking what he always does… I just need a little more time to finagle this. Except for the first time in his life, times up. Desperate, drug addled minds do desperate drug addled things 😅

[@missyette]

3 people now stated on the stand that it's his voice

[@christie6488]

That’s not the Snapchat video. That’s a regular video that Paul was supposed to send after he took it, but it never got sent.

[@markwest1963]

This guy shows more emotion than Alex

[@HedonicMedia]

You must not be watching much of the trial. Alex has broke down and cried waterfalls a handful times.

[@violabiggar9678]

@@HedonicMedia I never saw a tear, but I saw the tissues were used many times The tears you saw was pity for himself!

[@markwest1963]

@@HedonicMedia not convincingly

[@AuroraAnderson1]

@@HedonicMediayeah it’s fake NO TEARS

[@cglenn1457]

This poor man is more devastated over the loss of Paul than Paul's own father is. Alex thinks rocking back and forth shows grief? No, it displays attention-seeking, dramatic tendencies.

[@Tattiehoker]

It's a habit!

[@debbieriddle9429]

My heart goes out to this man. Genuine. Loved this family.He will Never un-see this tragedy. I lost a Sister...her killer never found. It plays over and over in the mind. My heart goes out to Anyone who has had to live this.

[@melissaorellana6951]

I’m so sorry. Unimaginable. Hope you get justice for your sister some day. Peace be with you 🌸

[@debbieriddle9429]

@@melissaorellana6951 Thank you Melissa, I appreciate that.

[@TedBackus]

i was an active opiate addict for over 20yrs, and as many people know it consumes large amounts of cash, but even if you buy the most expensive pills , there is no way this man was out of money. a heavy pill user might use 3-5 30mg oxy's /day. unless youre buying them on the street one at a time, you will pay .50c /Mg. so 30mg = $15. thats $15x3-5 pills/day. so $45- $75 /day in drug cost. Thats $27,000 /Year a heavy user would spend on the most expensive opiates......there is NO way this man, with his income, had financial issues stemming from drug use, its impossible, because $30k/year to him is a rounding error. im sure it made his behavior erratic, and was a driving factor in his ridiculous choice to kill his family, but his drug use wasnt why he was stealing money, he did that to avoid settlement payouts.

[@Gapeachy3000]

I’m in Atlanta and my aunt is a long time opiate user both from doctors prescription and off the street when she can’t get her prescription filled…she’s been paying 50$ a pill, no matter if she buys 1 or 10, from many different dealers…not an isolated incident

[@kerrylewisRN]

I agree with you, he didn’t have drug addiction. He’d be a mess with withdrawal symptoms

[@claycollins8973]

I was a heavy opiate addict for roughly a decade, there's no way Alex was paying $50 per pill or full price $30 for a 30, I agree with the sentiment that $50k per week is absurd to even suggest.

[@billcollins1614]

"I'm 100% sure that's whose voices are on that audio" Fork. Done!!

[@lexooo]

That along with Paul’s friends testimony too. He testified he was 100% sure it was Alex too. Both such damning testimonies.

[@OneBadAssMoMo]

@@lexooo I didn't put much stock in the friends testimony on it.... at the time I thought that Paul was speaking to the dog, like we all speak to dogs....in a goofy tone, and then, turned his head maybe and said "it's a chicken"..... this time though, I thought I heard Alec. Clearly.

[@lexooo]

@@OneBadAssMoMo totally get what your saying but Pauls friend said he thought he heard him over the phone at the time but was 100% sure he heard him in the video

[@bizzmoneyb]

lies! Paul was talking to his friend on his cell phone in the Kennel & was recording a video to text to his friend. the friend heard Alex's voice on the call, and in the video, seen after because he didnt send it before he was killed. Alex was there.

[@llamamama2910]

No follow up video ever came, just the Snapchat but yes two people had identified Alex’s voice.

[@sharae926]

@@llamamama2910 the police had Paul’s phone & showed the follow up video to his friend during questioning. Alex was heard in the background again.

[@jkstubbington]

Unbelievable to hear the defense attorney ask something to be “killed” off the screen. So tone deaf.

[@BigBangvsBigPulsealiensufoNYC]

Three law firms representing one client. Each paid $900,000. Experts and investigators paid $500,000, hospital fees $1,5 million. Total $4.7 million off the top. Client received $800,000. Who is the criminal.

[@HeatherRose2023]

Why are three law firms representing one client?