[Leemujin Service] EP.116 aespa NINGNING | Thirsty, Be Natural, Paper Hearts, Breath

[@queenning28]

Ningning really understands that singing is not just about belting high notes. It's about vocal control and dynamics. It's about conveying emotions and telling a story. And she's a great storyteller. I hope she gets more opportunities to sing OST for K-dramas and C-dramas in the future.

[@chympui]

Amen... ♡´･ᴗ･`♡

[@karihyun]

LO DIJJSTEEEEE HERMOSAAAA Y DILOO MAS FUERTE PARA Q TODOSS PUEDAN ESCUCHAR EL FACTTITOOO Q DIJISTE EN ESTE COMMENT FR

[@_miuki117]

That’s why she’s the top main vocal in 4th gen😭😭💗💗💗

[@syahidanabilah4714]

Agree! And she actually has a kdrama ost with winter for Our Blues! Hope she gets more in future

[@insidemagicworld]

omg yes, thats why i think that her is the best singer of the aespa, the other one of the group only screams, while ning ning really sings

[@RoseFrance]

This is definitely the cleanest Lee Mujin Services episode I've ever watched. Every song she sang are all so perfectly done, every run, riffs, head, high or low notes, even the emotion portrayed are so perfect. Ningning is really massively talented, and look at her if you watch her sing, it's like she's just using 30-40% effort of singing in this episode, what more if we hear her 100% vocal power, this girl is scarily talented. Lots of potential to unlock. SM don't you ever waste Ningning!

[@celebnewschannel3072]

Episode 1 of lee mujin is also so perfect as this ..I love ningning and minnie from kpop industry

[@RoseFrance]

@@celebnewschannel3072 to think that they are look a like in some angles, the similarities are uncanny tho hahahaha plus both talented ❤️

[@OppaCesarock]

Ningning es la próxima Taeyeon vocalmente hablando tiene un potencial impresionante 😊

[@loretta_3843]

That's the thing about people like Ningning, they make things look easy!

[@NRam-ke6cs]

I could Watch Ningning ep and Liz from ive's ep 10 times a day. I always go back to these 2 videos.

[@waterdrop000]

Her voice is light, high, and bright. But for someone whos a soprano like her, the way she navigates her low notes is something unbelievable. It only shows that shes versatile and a well rounded vocalist, shes technically skilled, but at the sametime she has her own style that you'll know its her! Her range is such gem. The way she can do low, high mix, and head! Thats why in a choir, she can be either an alto, mezzo, or a soprano! And the way she can do riffs and runs as well!

[@hectormsk9463]

I am not a singer but yea5

[@slaystinn]

Her lower register is one of the strongest in SM. I would say hers is stronger than any SM female main vocalist except for Luna. It really is a fantastic asset of her vocals, and it's what makes her stand out to me.

[@lalapiee]

Yes!!! 🎉❤ she's a hidden gem

[@arwyuna7060]

That is what a singer should practice, and she did very well.

[@chympui]

Well said! She's brilliant! ʚ♡⃛ɞ(ू•ᴗ•ू❁)

[@visurvix]

Ningning is a master of vocal agility and switching between chest/mixed/head voices. I can’t believe she made this song sound so easy. She needs to sing more R&B and big ballads in the future. She is too versatile to only sing pop dance songs.

[@Ningning___]

Ningning's vocal tone and her voice control is crazy she's singing from her whole soul you can tell how much she like and know she can SING !!!!!! SM PLEASE DON'T DON'T HIDE HER TALENT FROM THE WORLD !!!

[@jisongprak882]

Ningning sings like Bada, dances like Luna and performs like Beyoncé. she's such an amazing artist, SM really bagged a gem when their staff decided to dm her.

[@chairmanrosethewisegentleman]

She deserved a solo debut after Aespa reaching their senior year.

[@CindyZhang-lt6ke]

她是她自己❤

[@naya_raaa]

that's why ningning is my bias🥹

[@linqque]

​@@chairmanrosethewisegentleman all of the members have their solo songs already, but idk if we gonna see it as release

[@fab6478]

AAHAHAHAHA PERFORM LIKE BEYONCÉ

[@naevisalaeri]

Ningning's low vocal tone supremacy

[@r.7475]

THIS!

[@insidemagicworld]

in my opinion her high vocal tone is so good too, i miss so much because SM dont let her sing like that since savage :'(

[@athaya2992]

one of the best among female idols fr

[@ninjalina3]

I can't help but think of "Paper Hearts" in the context of how difficult being a foreign trainee and then idol has been for her. I remember seeing how close she was to her dad and now hearing her wish she said a proper goodbye to her Chinese schoolmates, I'm sure Ningning had to go through a lot even at her young age. Every note and emotion was crystal clear. I love how beautifully and artistically Ningning sings here, and I know every song well. The jazz-y vibes of "Be Natural" is so hard to pull off, it's so impressive! So much respect

[@spideyhamporker]

Are you also a singer?

[@urhypeboy]

7:55 The random noises she makes ❤

[@vixelscoffeehouse]

@@urhypeboy random noises??? u mean adlibs lmfao

[@yomomma4352]

@@vixelscoffeehouse…bruh click the timestamp then you’ll see the weird noises no one is talking abt adlibs😂

[@tatinmaria7392]

THIS is how a MAIN VOCALIST should be. Not just good with the high notes, but good with EVERYTHING. I really believe people don’t appreciate her vocals that much.

[@NRam-ke6cs]

Wdym ? Everyone loves her. She is one of the best along with Liz from Ive.

[@clipzed]

@@NRam-ke6csand Lily from nmixx! My 3 fav

[@Lunafreya_Nox]

How can ppl appreciate her vocals more when her group instead didn't bring much vocal power all she could do is sing mid song and mid style of songs... Well most 4th-5th gen kpop unlike 2nd and 3rd really appreciate they vocals more bcoz they flex that song on their music by singing BALLAD and RNB which AESPA and some 4th-5th rather like noise is easy pissy type of tone of music which add NOISE music to backup. .

[@kinanana6856]

⁠yap yap yap

[@cunt6743]

@@kinanana6856 you're so pathetic lmao

[@ongk9631]

닝닝이는 진짜 육각형멤임... 외국어 가사로 된 노래를 불러도 그 가사에 실리는 감정을 어지간한 모국어 가수보다 잘 이해하는걸 보면 키즈 들어갈정도로 재능도 출중했지만 노력도 그만큼 어마무시하게 하는게 느껴짐... +)여기서는 닝이의 보컬이 주 컨텐츠이니, 닝닝을 잘 몰랐단 분들이 다른 노래도 들어보고 싶으시다면 박화요비 그런일은 / 브리트니스피어스 toxic 찾아서 한번 들어보는걸 추천합니다!

[@wrenwu5674]

I really enjoy the moment when she singing Korean songs, to be honest it give me a feeling like she was growing in Korea, she’s absolutely a bilingual singer, smart girl with superb voice and talented language skills

[@SamTorres.]

​@LuellaGaetanii 🤔🧠💩

[@신나영-o9n]

@@wrenwu5674햬 하 ㅏㅓㅣ레ㅣㅠ 훞 ㅏㅍ 하포 ㅓ 4:40 4:40 ㅡ ㅑㅡ ㅡ

[@세르미스]

육각형에 6가지 능력이 먼가요?

[@하아-d1s]

​@@세르미스비주얼 실력 등 다 갖춰져있다는 뜻이예여

[@fromlu78]

에스파가 재조명되는 이유는 멤버들이 활동할수록 실력이 계속 는다는거임

[@pendulum6888]

이게 성장형 아이돌이지. ㄹ 들어가는 그 아이돌 말고 ㅋㅋㅋ

[@이나-i3u]

그래도 데뷔때부터 잘했는데 점점 더 잘해..

[@법규고양이]

릇은 ….

[@다은-w3k]

원래도 잘하는데 더 잘하려고 노력하는거 같아서 예쁨 ㅠㅠㅠ

[@noteasy11-b4o]

에스파는 나야 둘이 될순없어

[@rpkzq4651]

I love it when the vocalists from Idol Group realize that good vocal is not all about belting high notes, but also the dynamics, low register, head voice, other techniques AND the emotion when you deliver the song to listener. Because there are a lot of good vocalists - tech wise, but I couldn’t feel the emotion. So good job Ningning!

[@Kyeophee]

I might be biased but from all Lee Mujin’s show performace I sense that Ning Ning singing style is the most sophisticated among her peers. She sings like a real diva.

[@samonsquad]

I think you’re biased haha Wendy’s performance is an example of a diva performance. Ningning got vocals though

[@Kyeophee]

@@samonsquad if you think so, it’s ok 😊 Like Ning Ning said music is very subjective. So my taste is not the same as yours.

[@NRam-ke6cs]

Liz from Ive also was good.

[@samonsquad]

@@Kyeophee that I can agree with!

[@divaqueening1940]

were talking abt NINGNING only!

[@z00merang18]

She's really one of the best vocalists in the 4th gen. Her voice is like an angel's. Sm made a good decision debuting her in aespa

[@AznIntegra521]

She made a good decision to join sm.

[@NRam-ke6cs]

Definitely one of the best. SM artists are usually very good singers. Ning ning and Liz are the top 2 best 4th gen female singers.

[@KhadaJhin04]

I feel like the reason why people undermine Ningning is because how silly a lot of the idols will look compared to the giant that is Ningning, like the difference is galaxies apart it's laughable, while some are struggling to hit the simplest of notes on their own songs, she's out here showcasing a crazy range and interpreting hard songs making them her own, not the first time SM idols are dismissed and osrracized for being too talented.

[@Ferrmatta]

닝닝 목소리에 역대 SM 여돌 보컬들의 향수가 다 담겨져 있네. 곡 중간중간에 바다, 유진 느낌부터 태연, 웬디까지 다 녹아있음. 그러면서도 자기 음색을 잃지 않는게 장점인 것 같음.

[@ivyeppi]

BE NATURAL IS SO GOOD

[@abelpehopu8175]

be natural is weird song in good means... love it so mucchh ❤❤❤❤

[@neoyya]

SM is proud because Ningning decided to accept the offer to become an idol in your company.Ningning has a very very good voice, like a voice that came straight from heaven

[@AznIntegra521]

To be fair anyone getting a dm through social media claiming to be sm and they want u in korea, would think its a scam.

[@parkchithung2672]

​@@AznIntegra521I won't even reply lol

[@maban1747]

Indeed, Ning Ning is a treasure!

[@ristocrats247]

​@@AznIntegra521true 😂

[@KhadaJhin04]

The reason why NingNing is this gen'e vocalist is because she is a well rounded singer, it's not just the high notes, it's her lower register, it's her feel for the songs, it's her sultry tone and how she manages to make it her song, whatever the song is.

[@queenning28]

Her vocal control and dynamics are crazy good. Singing is not just screaming high notes. It’s music and it’s art. Ningning is an artist.

[@KhadaJhin04]

@@queenning28 very true. This is what I've been trying to say but everyone keeps undermining her because kpopies don't understand screaming high notes isn't singing and that this is much harder.

[@이은수-q7i]

닝닝이는 노래도 잘 부르고 춤도 잘 추고 비주얼도 빼놓을 수 없고 사실상 에스파의 최고 올라운더임.. 음색도 너무 유니크함… 가사 전달력도 넘 좋고…

[@avaroseteague]

That paper hearts.. it hurts me.. ning's voice is so beautiful

[@葡萄柚柚柚-l6g]

I love that song too🥲🥲

[@fitzzaa_18]

ikrr

[@mypearlb5208]

How can someone sing so high but still sound so soothing and pleasant at the same time? Ningning, you're truly a GEM of KPOP.

[@baeeunho3096]

Ningning really proofing how main vocalist should be

[@r.7475]

SO TRUE!

[@laurawong1201]

Indeed She's the best ❤

[@gavinhuang4521]

Proving :)

[@KlaudiaJ]

Ningning's vocal technique is insane, she improvises so beautifully

[@synkcity]

I'm here again after watching karina and winter.

[@Lyn_o0o1]

real

[@visurvix]

as a Taeyeon biased, i'm so so so happy that Ning Ning chose "Breath" to perform. and her voice is too good that made me cry, thank you so much Ning Ning. T__T

[@akuhappy3246]

Ah, same here. Been a sone just because taeyeon sing if back in the days.

[@AznIntegra521]

Don’t forget Li Yin also sang this song

[@tamdiep5537]

It has been a while listening to this song, it originally sung by 2 great vocalists and now 2 other great vocalists cover it

[@jieunnnis]

닝아 너는 알까 너의 목소리는 누군가를 살게 한다는 거 노래해줘서 정말 고마워

[@linqque]

​@LuellaGaetaniii think you should delete yourself

[@ipeachyoumyluv]

Such a gem. SM should give Ningning more RnB songs esp which have mysterious and flirty vibe

[@nayeonblinkissy]

I think they will when she goes solo; it's ning's desire since day 1

[@katiacoelho912]

oh i knew ningning was good but i never knew she was THAT good, she has full control of her voice, you can tell she is so skilled and uses her voice very precisely and cleanly. I'm truly so much more appreciative of her now, she's truly incredible. She can put so much emotions in her voice will having a stable face. I was so captivated, it was truly a pleasure listening to her

[@nanaeri6392]

So glad Ningning didn't give up since SM Rookies. This show really showcased her talent in singing and why she deserve to be recognized.

[@queenning28]

It's just crazy how much SM didn't let her showcase her vocal skills until now. She is one of the most underused main vocals in Kpop I've ever seen.

[@blinkningbetterthanyourfav2107]

Fun fact she not use 40% 😂

[@NewCaledonia1987]

What are you talking about?

[@ibizamarquina793]

​@@NewCaledonia1987 she barely had any solo singing gigs, its always the korean members (not surprised the xenophobia sm and koreans are always like that) and to top it all off, even on her own group songs she barely have any lines, not even the high notes (again always the kr members) spicy is the perfect example. Cbars are boycotting the album so probably why they are giving her some gigs now.

[@NewCaledonia1987]

@@ibizamarquina793 you're funny you know that,being ridiculous. About the gigs,if the organizer wants other members,why would SM send Giselle?Dive studio wanted to cast Giselle,so SM sent her. I can say the same thing,why SM didn't send Ning Ning or Karina instead?think about that. About the high note,why would SM ask her to take that part when they have main singer and lead singer to do so? Chinese bar boycotting SM not because of this. Why do other not complaining about Giselle has more singing line than rap ones?think about that.....I am saying this not because I don't like her,I support 4 of them equally. They decide lines depend on the song. Which member would suit the song more. This happened not only to Aespa,but to every group. Don't make a problem out of nothing. This is very childish. Let's just focus on supporting the girls. Be positive you girl

[@ulfazakiyyah590]

​​@@NewCaledonia1987totally agree with u. If SM not showcase her vocal she didn't even exist for shining star ost lmao, aespa has 2 main vocal which are ningning and winter, and in my point of view ningning has the best technic of vocal and winter has the stable vocal, why winter got many highnote than ningning I think because her stable vocal and range event ningning also has large range of vocal but her voice is suit for adlibe than powerfull highnote (?) (not all of the highnote in all of their songs but a song that need powerfull highnote). Ningning's vocal is too soft and winter has the strong powerfull voice whichis suit for the highnote in almost every aespa's songs

[@aeling642]

What always stands out when listening to NingNing is her so obvious joy of singing and the confidence she has in her own abilities. She made me cry with Paper Heart.... Her tone is so clear and beautiful. It's such a privilege to listen to her.

[@AznIntegra521]

Well she did tell Mujin that singing makes her happy

[@MiguelAldanotes]

Think i FINALLY found an Aespa bias. The fact that she sang Paper Hearts solidifies it😅

[@queenning28]

Ningning always sounds like she's only using 30% of her singing skills. This world is not ready for when she releases her full vocal power. And I hope that day will come very soon❤‍🔥

[@aidan_luke]

You’re right. She’s still holding back and I don’t know why

[@Purr279]

@@aidan_lukeholding back how ?

[@doo9647]

Maybe she’s afraid to get vocal nodules

[@wintercrumbs6539]

Fr like she always control her voice

[@Purr279]

@@doo9647you’re not gonna get vocal nodules if u sing high notes 1 time per week…

[@visurvix]

i'm glad that SM let Ning Ning showing her supremacy skill

[@jaehanzip]

닝닝은 진짜 완벽한 KPOP 아이돌이라고 봄... kpop 그룹에 외국인 멤버 있는 거 조금 안 좋아하는 편인데, 닝닝은 한국어 발음은 물론 춤, 노래, 외모 모두 탑임. 안 좋아할 수가 없음...

[@네히-f2z]

잉 발음이 뭐가 좋단거야ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ지금 노래들으면서도 거슬리는데;

[@헤어린수]

@@네히-f2z레스따리 레스게 스따리~~~~ 미르꾸아뻬 쎄벼됴 나 수따리~~~~~

[@nkbzx]

​@@네히-f2z이게 거슬리면 문제 있는거 아닌가 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@jh-lo8li]

누구누구들과는 다르게 자기 노래에서는 발음 외국인 티 안나죠. 여기서 부른 노래도 며칠 더 주면 발음 티 안나게 연습해올듯. 모국어 아닌 곡 부륵 때 기본 자세죠. 한국에서 활동하려면 예의지.

[@님루머]

그정돈아닌데........

[@EchoesBlackSwan]

Her lower register in Paper Hearts was AMAZING.

[@gyoulie4565]

SM singers are always rich in singing techniques which I can’t find it in other companies, they always amazes me

[@akuhappy3246]

Agree

[@mo9-j7p]

닝아 댓글 보고잇어? 데뷔초부터 나의 원픽이엿던 닝아 처음에도 너무 예뻤지만 갈수록 더더욱 예뻐지는 닝아~~ 에스파의 자랑 에스파의 메보 얼굴천재 닝이줘 사랑해 항상 고마워 에스파로 활동해줘서~~

[@bedro6607]

오브이알 적당히

[@queenning28]

Mujin genuinely looks so happy to see Ningning and acts like a shy fanboy which is so cute. Ningning is the brightest star of our generation and I just love see her getting the recognition and appreciation that she deserves.

[@user-ci7pd5yr9j]

닝닝은 진짜 볼수록 대단한게 외국인인데도 데뷔할 때부터 계속 노래할 때만큼은 외국인 억양이 아예 티가 안 남 말할 때 한국어도 잘하지만 노래할 때 그 가사를 더 쫀득하게 살리는건 또 다른 문젠데 그걸 외국인 멤버가 이렇게 수준급으로 해낸다는 건 타고난 재능과 엄청난 노력의 결과임

[@jc-pn3ke]

Ningning’s low notes is really impressive

[@queenning28]

There is NO ONE in Kpop who can sing like Ningning does. She is very talented in R&B and jazz music. Truly one of a kind.

[@BEcauseILoveYooh]

Wendy

[@anya0717]

i mean wheein from mamamoo literally exists. but yeah ningning is also good.

[@lovescience3]

​@@BEcauseILoveYoohreal, but ningning Good too

[@BEcauseILoveYooh]

@@lovescience3 didn't say she wasn't but op said no one in kpop can sing R&D/Jazz

[@dakikotissururiyah6327]

bada?

[@kgwnkgwn]

닝닝은 에스파의 팔각형 보석임 점점 빛을 발휘하는 것 같아서 마음좋다 + 닝닝이 노래랑 비주얼은 말할것도 없고 춤도 진짜 잘춤 동작 하나하나 빠짐없이 잘 표현하는 멤버임 닝닝 춤추는거 보면 정말 알차다고 표현할수밖에 없음.. 춤추면서 표정도 잘씀 그리고 성격 털털하고 재치있고 말도 따뜻하게 잘하고 사람이 단단한게 느껴짐 닝이 알면 알수록 빠져들어서 요즘 에스파 최애임 닝닝이 진짜 너무 사랑함… 우리 닝이가 많은 사람들에게 오래도록 사랑받길

[@porvw6293]

숨은 보석은 진짜 맞늨 말이에요~ 에셈은 닝이 자주 숨기니까 🙂

[@kgwnkgwn]

@@porvw6293 여러 컨텐츠 많이 나왔으면 좋겠어요 예능도 분명히 잘 할 것 같은데 에스엠은 정신 좀 차려야됨

[@kgwnkgwn]

@@porvw6293 닝닝이 하고싶은거 다 하게 해줬으면 🙂

[@tala4947]

ningning has always been the best vocalist of the group since debut.

[@kgwnkgwn]

@@콩-n9k 가정교육을 어떻게 받았길래 악플을 달고다님? 루저인생 ㄹㅈㄷ

[@here_Tan]

謝謝邀請寧寧來⋯讓更多人了解寧寧對於多方面的歌曲詮釋都是如此細膩⋯寧寧很小就到韓國發展，很努力的學習韓語，不論發音，還是音準與整體詮釋都是完美的，寧寧在音樂上從不馬虎包含舞蹈每次都盡心的表演，不會替自己找任何藉口，如果不是之前的雜誌採訪我們都不知道她有一隻眼睛幾乎看不到，因為在舞臺上看不到任何缺失⋯⋯就知道寧多麼用心~寧寧不知道妳會不會看到這篇留言⋯⋯妳真的做到了專心做好一件事⋯不負歌迷的期待⋯會一直支持妳~(她不止可愛不止漂亮她很會跳舞也很會唱⋯看似迷糊但其實邏輯清晰.個性好與世無爭、也很幽默。希望希望韓國人可以多多愛她❤)

[@Frig84]

I love the fact we are still seeing Ningning being her quirky self even though she is blowing everyone away with her vocals. Don't change girl!!

[@jh-lo8li]

웬디 저 나이때가 보임. 노래 스타일이 비슷하기보다는 노래하는걸 좋아하고 사랑하는게 보임. 잘하고 싶은 욕심도 있고. 데뷔하고 나서도 노래가 꾸준히 느는 것도 그렇고. 꾸준히 좋아하고 늘다보면 어느날 웬디처럼 뭔가 틀을 깨고 득음 해오는 날이 있을듯.. 노래하는거 좋아하는 모습이 사랑 스러워서 그모습 그대로 계속 노래해줬으면.

[@myaedentty149]

Lee Mujin when Ningning tell a reason she chose 'Breath', "Please feel free to shed tears at any time!" But Ningning just giggling and even sing successfully without tears. Meanwhile me: Crying alone in my room 😭

[@kbbhjv806]

Trueee😭😭😭😭😭

[@xiumina-yd7su]

The emotion in Ningning's song makes me cry.

[@danlee88]

Be natural 완전 미쳤다 역시 바다언니가 인정하는 닝닝이 믿고보지요

[@오연채널봐]

↑🌌

[@Chris-qm3og]

Ningning sings so easily and soft just let people forget how hard these songs are😢

[@queenning28]

I'm not surprised that Ningning's biggest inspiration is Beyoncé. Her stage presence always reminds me of Beyoncé for some reasons. She is a queen on stage👑

[@samanthakim5035]

A person tend to mimic what he/she admire.

[@fab6478]

where did she say that

[@a_mystical_potato4325]

@@fab6478 16:51-17:16

[@owlinlin9134]

i like how she confidently admitted that she is naturally gifted

[@user-uidsnh]

I so strongly believe that she was born to sing

[@Ireneisbae]

Ningning had a purpose since the day she was born.

[@aerichan-_0]

무엇보다도 곡 이해도가 진짜 높은거같음

[@mjmj0828]

ㄹㅇ 외국인이 저 정도로 이해하고 부르는 거 정말 대단……

[@jjun_6221]

닝닝은 명실상부한 4세대의 에이스다

[@alyanacuanico864]

4th Generation Best Vocalist ❤️‍🔥

[@lalapiee]

Exactly !!!!! 🎉

[@danissegomez7953]

best main vocal to be specific❤

[@john-g5m8p]

I'm not surprised when she says they signed her right away, this girl can sing! Ningning has the best low register of the 4th generation, she is the Seulgi of this generation! She has a very professional vision of things and she is intelligent. She is not in the competition and in the vocal demonstration, she sings, and it is very clean and very musical. As for his stage presence and his performances... it's high level! They found a great gem at SM!

[@msshadow916]

Ningning is not the type who easily cries in front of the camera, so she expresses and conveys her emotions through her angel voice and the songs she chose

[@Big__Sister]

Ning Ning is so cute. She is happiest when singing. Go girl!

[@lillil9997]

데뷔 초에 에스파 립싱크한다고 할 때 닝닝이 에스파 라이브 해요!하고 억울해 했던 게 생각난다. 정말 자신있고 좋아하는 일을 자부심을 갖고 하는데 립싱크 논란이 얼마나 속상했을까ㅠ

[@august_shin2618]

그니까요

[@zyzabc5368]

her head voice tone is so so so so beautifullll

[@heyyou2834]

닝닝 진짜 잘한다ㅜㅜ 에스파에서도 너무 잘하고 있지만. 솔로 아티스트로서의 닝닝도 너무 기대된다. 닝닝 솔로앨범 꼭 기다릴게! SM대선배님들 SES노래를 부르고, 샤이니 종현이 노래를 부르다니ㅠㅠ 진짜 더 감동이다ㅠㅠ 이렇게 타국에 와서 kpop가수로 활동하는 모습 너무 예쁘고 사랑스럽다ㅠ 오래오래 에스파로 함께해줘!!! 닝닝을 응원하는 너무나 많은 마이들이 있다는거 잊지말구~~~

[@메디-w6i]

닝닝은 스킬도 너무 좋은데 목소리 자체에 깊이가 있어서 너무 좋음…타고나길 노래 잘하는…

[@blueming3504]

NingNing and Mujin should have an OST together, their voice suits so well!!!!

[@inadraodwikaaudry916]

Yapss i hoping too

[@eumeueu]

근데 사실 에스파한테 다들 “성장형“이라고들 하지만 에스파는 처음부터 잘했음..ㅋㅋ SM이 신입이라 라이브를 별로 안시키고 하필 데뷔 시기가 코로나 팬데믹 때라 관객들 앞에서 라이브도 별로 못해본 상태로 코첼라 가서 그랬지… 이제라도 대중들한테 이미지 각인 시켜서 다행

[@edyy-yb5pc]

우리 막닝이 어린나이에 한국에 와줘서, 어려운 연습생 생활 잘 견디고 에스파로 데뷔해줘서 너무 고마워!!!! 오래오래 한국에서 노래해줘

[@queenning28]

Finally Ningning is here! I've been waiting for three years!

[@nozekangbae9427]

GURL YOURE COMMENTING EVERYWHERE HAHAHAHAH

[@dianalazaru]

Paper Hearts by Tori Kelly is such a high bar, and you need very good control of your voice to sing it well, but NingNing did a fantastic job! WOW! very well done!

[@nayistan]

Ningning's voice = Heaven

[@cosmosintheair5692]

The little noises she makes after every song! 😭😭

[@unsramee9834]

I love that she's being herself 🥰

[@bjabbi7328]

I know so cute our maknae is shy everytime she gets complimented

[@zym-w1s]

Soooooo cute🥺

[@whocares7974]

She's so cute 😭😭

[@user-andjebdyu]

It’s the exact same noises she made after her solo cover of something like that on it’s live😭👏🏻

[@PlanetOsage]

my personal favorite kpop vocalist of all time. she has so much power in her voice while also sounding like a soft angel at the same time. truly amazing.

[@쿠기꾸기]

닝닝이 그동안 얼마나 열심히 살았는지 알 수 있었음.... 진짜 꾸준히 노력했구나... 지금 미모도 미쳤고... 뭐 하나도 놓질않네

[@SHEESS-v7m]

SM idols who were recruited under the LEE SOMAN era really had extraordinary visual quality and their vocals were the main characteristic

[@icemeow10]

목소리가 오로라빛 나는 물방울같음... 너무 좋다 닝이줘

[@쀼-l5v]

ㅇㅈ.. 목소리가 먼가 쵹촉해💦

[@geesezhuang9465]

She is literally a real singer who can perform with perfect emotional and technical expression.

[@yxiannahlim126]

A beautiful lady with a very beautiful voice!!

[@alinsofan501]

Harbin Princess NingSlay!

[@dxyyzz]

the way ningning hitting every note is soo satisfying to listen

[@ddddddddeonghwa7378]

IF I HAD A VOICE LIKE NINGNING, I WOULD NEVER SHUT UP

[@nx21023]

닝닝아 댓글 보고있지!!! 목소리가 너무 아름답고 단단하기도 하고 감성도 훌륭해. 앞으로도 이렇게 자주자주 노래 불러주길 바래!!! 어린나이에 한국에 와서 이렇게 멋진 가수가 된거 너무나 대단하다고 생각해 앞으로도 너의 앞날을 기대하고 응원할게!

[@winteringtime]

It's really crazy to have Ningning and Winter in the same group

[@dollyoo6204]

This is craazy if you think about it, she sounds so good live. Her technique is just superb.

[@tempthit]

닝닝이는 발성이 단단한데 목소리는 참 맑아서 듣기가 너무 좋다.

[@moonlover6782]

be natural이 너무 좋아서 미치겠다... 생각한 것보다 훨씬 잘 어울려...

[@서리-s1x]

ㄹㅇ be natural ㅁㅊ

[@alittlejingga9208]

Ning2 really bada's daughter.

[@Unknownandbyes]

Does your fingers hurt to write down Ningning's full name ?

[@nayeonblinkissy]

Bada's granddaughter; xiah junsu and zhang liyin's daughter

[@AznIntegra521]

@@nayeonblinkissyi get what u mean but Ningning literally has been called Bada’s daughter since debut

[@little_N_mixx]

​@@AznIntegra521she kinda look like her too

[@moraeine]

@@Unknownandbyeslol ning2 is cute❤

[@renedelrio5003]

Ningning carrying the torch of "Superb SM Vocalist" so well. Chef's Kiss 👌🏻👌🏻💯💯

[@bwobluu]

Her song choices and vocal is insanely good. Her vocal is soothing and cool at the same time its insane. As a MY since debut days, cant say any affection for her fell off one bit since day one. Always been such a good vocalist 😌

[@Pokjinler]

우리 하얼빈 소녀 닝닝, 사기꾼인즐 알았던 SM캐스팅에 선뜻 응해줘서 고마워. 이제 에스파 닝닝으로 전세계 사람들에게 정말 큰 감동을 주고 있어. 닝닝의 노래를 들으면 마치 스케일이 큰 영화를 극장에서 보는것처럼 목소리가 영상이 되어 촤악 펼쳐져서 노래 속으로 빨려들어가게 돼. 이렇게 놀라운 경험을 선물해줘서 정말 고마워❤ 앞으로 닝닝이 보여줄 노래, 음악, 새로운 시도들 설레는 마음으로 기대하고, 응원할께. 콘서트 고대하고 있어. 사랑하는 마이가❤

[@thankimda]

넘 댓이 예쁘다

[@maban1747]

Scammer? The relationship between the company and employees is that you provide me with a platform, and I create value for you. Ning Ning is definitely a sincere employee.

[@Nei_its_me]

@@maban1747그말이 아니에요. sm 캐스팅 담당자가 처음 다가왔을때 사기꾼같아보여서 닝닝이가 따라갈지 안따라갈지 고민했다는 뜻입니다!

[@user-ny3bq1]

닝이가 없었으면 에스파 노래들이 듣기 편하진 않았을 것 같음. 너무 듣기좋고 부드러운 목소리 ㅜㅜ 가창력까지 최고야!!

[@insidemagicworld]

finally the best vocalist of aespa having her time to shine!!!!!

[@mixxahs]

데뷔초부터 닝닝을 파왔던 사람으로써,, 닝닝 음색은 진짜 국보급으로 부드러운데다가 음역대는 저음에서 고음까지 되게 넓고 또 기교는 기가막힘,,, 닝닝 진짜 좀 더 연차 쌓고 솔로곡 내면 자지러질듯😭😭

[@idkphw2189]

맞아요. 저도 동감입니다😮😮😮😮

[@geniepang3997]

11:58 하프가 인간으로 태어나면 닝닝 아닐까요. 첫소절에 악기소리인줄알고 진짜 깜짝놀라서 몇번이고 다시 들었어요 닝닝 너무아름다워라ㅠㅠ 이번 앨범을 계기로 에스파 앨범 역주행중 ..

[@JangggouJin]

닝닝은 진짜 저 청순 스타일링이 신의 한 수다 메이크업도 그렇고 청순하면서 과즙상 약간 조이 느낌으로 바뀌니까 그냥 사람이 180도 바뀜 원래도 이뻤는데 진짜 지금은 여신임ㅠㅠ 저 외모에 아련하고 청아한 음색은 진짜 사기 아니냐고😭😭

[@sabiaakthar1613]

7:37 goosebumps the way she sings it is soo refreshing

[@Cfghjs]

닝닝 정석미인이야 전형적인 고양이상에 타멤에는 없는 홀리는 눈빛에 섹시하고 귀엽고 예쁜데 거기다 웃기기까지 함 보면 볼수록 알면 알수록 매력이 무한한 사람 노래도 정말 잘하고 춤도 정말 잘춤 진짜 재능많은 보석같은 멤버임 많은 사람들이 알아줬음 좋겠다 닝닝아 정말 응원해!

[@쀼-l5v]

캬 홀리는 눈빛 ❤

[@oev5494]

닝닝 음색의 최대 장점은 솔로로 여러 곡을 불러도 질리거나 부담스럽지않다는 거인 듯 ㅠㅠ 스킬도 다양하고 음역대도 넓고 무엇보다 베이스 음색이 엄청 부드럽다 😖

[@헬창헬창-b2v]

듣기 너무 편안한 음색인듯 기분 좋아짐

[@tohm4549]

닝이 진짜 잘함.. 정말정말 잘함.. 올라운더 아기디바 아기바다 명창 닝이줘 많이 알아줬으면!

[@webarebears08]

This is my favorite Lee Mujin ever. Every cover was better than the last, and I got to see Ning Ning sing in such different ways than I have before. She truly is an extremely versitle artist who shows herself to be dedicated to her craft. I'm going to be listening to this everyday to relax because she's just that good at her job. No wonder she's my bias; whenever someone doubts her singing skill, I'm going to show them this video ❤ ugh it's insane how much she shines with her voice my vocal inspiration for real

[@fleuressante]

NINGNING BEST 4TH GEN VOCALIST NO ONE IS ON HER LEVEL 😭🫶🏻

[@bumuckpar]

목소리 참 청아하고 아름답고 기교까지 완벽한 이 보컬을 섭외해준 에스엠에게 백만번 절하겠음..... 진짜 너무 잘해.....................

[@ManniChan]

지금의 아이돌은 모두 낭송식으로 노래를 부르거나, 음색이 기술보다 크고, 감정을 전달할 수 있는 사람은 정말 매우 적어요. 여러분이 ningning을 소중히 여기고 사랑하기를 바랍니다.

[@VictorHugo-qh3sk]

Are we hearing Ningning during Paper Hearts?! One of my favourite english cover from her. And that Breath cover is just TOO GEWD!! The harmonization is insane!!!