Cinemare Sins: Everything Wrong With The Gift of the Maud Pie

[@ImminDragon]

No sin for the fact that Pinkie owns multiple canons and only gave up the one she brought on this trip? Heck, she has so many that she was able to hide canons around Twilight's castle and forget where they were!

[@mettapeachhead2076]

Ikr

[@Figgy_Jub]

Maybe it's her OG cannon, the first of anything is always special.

[@rengie-feather8]

My thoughts exactly

[@King_Of_Arkham626]

That's why she can't use them anymore.

[@LannyLeArtist]

@@Figgy_Jub yea

[@the-hashtag-girl]

Every member of the pie family has a sense and pinkie sense is the ultimate sense.

Limestone can sense when somepony touches Holder's Boulder.

[@BNuts]

Makes sense,

[@the-hashtag-girl]

@ Lol

[@sylviemiaffo4548]

Maud can sense where rocks need to be hit in order to be broken

Marble can sense social anxiety.

[@HossSwayerpr]

Maud knew all this time, but kept to herself like her usual low key self 😁

[@H.R.D.J]

*can we talk about the fact that is says this comment came out 3 days ago*

[@elijahsytland7441]

@@H.R.D.J ikr

[@GT_Walker]

@@H.R.D.J Patrons get early access.

[@joshuaareta2001]

Probably Maud sense

[@theberrby6836]

Yeah

[@TheCommenterDragon]

This episode definitely had some funny moments, like when Rarity imitated Pinkie Pie, when Maud quote unquote "broke" Rarity into telling her about Pinkie's cannon, and when Maud pulled the same tactic on that stallion.XD

[@joshuaareta2001]

Maud's thousand death stares. Works everytime.

[@nicknackpaddywacks]

"Ready, Maud?" "No." SHWJKDBDJS THE VIDEO DIDN'T EVEN START YET AND I LOST ALL COMPOSURE

[@benleymathew3853]

Should have also added the fact that Pinkie Pie knows how to haggle ponies, since she's done it in the episode "Putting Your Hoof Down", but fails to implement that when trading the party cannon for the rock pouch in the beginning. I love the episode anyways!

[@JCBro-yg8vd]

3:48-3:58 She could also probably stitch a pouch similar to the one Pinkie wants and could do so free of charge. Rarity's entire inclusion in this episode creates a plot hole that could easily be resolved if you just wrote her out.

[@kyuubinaruto17]

I don't find that a plot hole. Rarity may have the skill to make a similar pouch, sure, but not the time. They're out and about in another town and she's got her own agenda. But putting that aside, as she can always look for her new store location another day, was she just supposed to bail on Pinkie and Maud, take a train back home, spend however long it takes to make another pouch, then take another train back and somehow find the two of them? All without Maud wondering where she went for 2 or 3+ hours? That seems a bit excessive.

[@JCBro-yg8vd]

@@kyuubinaruto17 I'm sure she could improvise.

[@timwoods2852]

@@kyuubinaruto17 She literally made a dress out of a stage curtain in two seconds. And there's probably a dozen or more fabric stores in a big city like Manehattan. All she'd have to do is excuse herself for an hour, agree to meet them at the next location, and grab the materials she needed and whip them together, 20-30min job tops.

[@CyberWarezz05]

@@timwoods2852 I think the point of the episode was for Pinkie to give Maud a personal and meaningful gift.What was the point for her to say"Rarity, make this pouch for Maud"?.Think of the Princess and the frog, for example:Tiana's friend had a lot of money and she could gave her enough to buy a restaurant, but Tiana did not want to.

[@timwoods2852]

@@CyberWarezz05 Somebody's gotta make the pouch. How much more meaningful to get a close friend to make it? And she could still pay for it or find some other way to compensate Rarity. Tiana still accepted her paycheck for making sweets that her friend and her dad liked.

[@elizabethrose644]

I’m pretty sure Maud smiles once in every episode centered around her

[@bandicootsauce4569]

LittleShy: "Derpy is best pony." Maud: "Hold my rocks."

[@emilyplaysgamesstuwe5801]

Derpy is still the best pony

[@FlynnMLP]

Are you confused how I was able to comment before the video was even published? Let me tell you my secret: Flynn sense.

[@caitlin_a]

Wow

[@saggysackofpotatoes1351]

wh-

[@BNuts]

And here I thought it was because you were a Patron. Silly me.

[@BNuts]

@KevonThe2nd No no, Silly Filly is someone else.

[@jjafs1008]

Woah-

[@Thegr8MC]

MAUD'S SMILE IS PURE AND PRECIOUS AND I WOULD DO ANYTHING TO PROTECC!!!

[@joshuaareta2001]

I think we're the ones who need protecting. As soon as a meteor heads towards earth we will call on maud so she can smash it to pieces

[@FamusJamus]

2:52 "Where is your canon?" In my head.

[@batsnghostz]

Love how your editing has gotten better and better while cinema sins is just the same and shitty. you’re hilarious and amazing

[@archtansterpg4246]

4:55 You just can't get enough of that face, can you, Littleshy?

[@1Milly1]

I miss the old sin counter sound

[@adamk-paxlogan7330Sucks]

fake fan

[@LandOfTheEnigma]

@@adamk-paxlogan7330Sucks wdym

[@timwoods2852]

Preach!

[@cardboard8073]

@@adamk-paxlogan7330Sucks uhhhhhhhhh, what?

[@earlybyrdy]

*ding

[@kristenarvoy2776]

It’s not a smile, it’s clearly just a smirk

[@outtagoodnamesdangit]

Can't believe I never noticed that "hand-stitched" line. The Lyra joke on top of it, though? (chef's kiss) That's the good stuff! Happy New Year, man!

[@cradiculous]

That was a perfect use of the long-absent "theme" sin

[@Portableholefromthefuture]

Rarity could’ve just sewed a rock pouch and given it to pinkie for maud’s gift

[@killertruth186]

They had forgot to mention that Rarity and Maud had one thing in common. Is that they find of what kinds of rocks they're looking for.

[@privateinvestigatorrick7406]

*_"Doest one ev'r questioneth how one can loseth their metaph'rical canon and yet still has't the ability to breaketh a mure in the 4th dimension and then loseth their actual cannon only the regain t once m're?"_*

[@privateinvestigatorrick7406]

*_"i guesseth what i cullionly to sayeth is gaze this video: _**_kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z5ytgniwgM2HaJKT**_"_*

[@joshuaareta2001]

Princess luna is that you?

[@privateinvestigatorrick7406]

@@joshuaareta2001 *_" !ytinrete fo lla rof retsam dna drol wen ruoy em llac nac uoy tuB !lliB s'emaN"_*

[@82dorrin]

What I took away from this episode. Grabbing cops is A-Okay! So is repeatedly firing guns in major cities!

[@privateinvestigatorrick7406]

@@82dorrin -I wanna make a joke but- oof

[@StainedGlassLamp]

As someone who has been to NYC multiple times and has gone up the Statue of Liberty, I can confirm no pedestrian pays attention to other pedestrians not in their party unless they're really REALLY weird. No one cares how loud you are on the streets, and the Statue is INCREDIBLY crowded. Especially the fucking ferries to get to and from there.

[@PixarShark]

“Eternal hoof washing.” ...................well......if you’ve been doing your part for the last 9/10 months, then basically......

[@dogman15]

This almost is sort of like a Christmas video, since "Gift of the Maud Pie" is a pun on "Gift of the Magi". Also, for the bonus round, I think you could have had a "+1", "+2" and so on thing for the cannon blasts, and then added it in at the end to the total.

[@emilyrivas7821]

He did

[@JettLockette]

4:14 Can we add 1 bonus sun for this nightmarish face?

[@beyondtherealmsofdeath]

I was so worried after this episode until the next Maud episode because I thought Maud left Boulder in the bag.

[@Squishy771]

2:14 the cheese wheel in the pile is probably a callback to cheese sandwich as well (if that episode was before this one)

[@lucarioriolu7651]

1:46 it's back!

[@UnusedRebrand72829]

Plot Twist : Maud saw the production of this episode and that's how she knew what was going on, but chose not to say it for the sake of the episode length

[@evelyngregg4666]

My day has just increased exponentially in awesomeness. (I used a big word...praise me.)

[@Redfork2000]

I always enjoy seeing a rich vocabulary, so have some praise!

[@evelyngregg4666]

@@Redfork2000 * sniff * thank you. I shall cherish this small bit of praise for the rest of my life.

[@FuzzyStripetail]

It would probably be so much easier to wrap your head around the prior to sunset Pinkie and Maud present swapping at sunset tradition once you witnessed Rarity merging her wrong end filed forelegs into one.

[@lulijouduss1634]

1:58 behold the mighty twicane

[@Sollace]

2:24 "Rocktorate" *ding*

[@joshuaareta2001]

i gotta admit with keanu on Maud she is breath taking. Wait. She smiled? This is an outrage!

[@buttercupkat]

3:01 He's a husk of a pony.

[@LunaBrony]

Awesome video and Happy New Year!!

[@IcefireToken]

I love how you keep calling starlight random things in the beginning

[@matthewcenteno5515]

love the new format!

[@azurefang1220]

The better question is where did Pinkie buy the Maud wrapping paper?

[@joshuaareta2001]

Well. She can summon almost anything out of existence. Its Pinkie pie. As littleshy said "If you question her, you will implode"

[@kalborge6635]

these are still gold every time keep up the fabulous work

[@NikoSource]

I love these types of videos! Well done! 😁💜

[@toeandshoe400]

I don't know what i'm doing watching this video at 4:55am but its all worth it in the end.

[@FanSeitz]

Love how you fit a Keanu meme in at the end.

[@lanfour4444]

4:38 Sentence: Eternal 2020

[@ElFreakinCid]

I'm a bit sad my favourite moment wasn't highlighted: Maud pulling an epic Sans maneuver to keep the scam artist pony from leaving with the party cannon.

[@powerpup97]

It really does take you a long time to make these!

[@crimsonxmoonlight9181]

THAT RARITY SCREENSHOT GETS ME EVERYTIME-

[@miinus5898]

I’m excited for these every month

[@Iron_10]

The fact rarity never offers to make a pouch for pinkie

[@Werefangx]

"If someone is so obessed with one thing its almost too easy to shop for them" Me: well what do you get a rock lover? Another rock? Me *thinks back to the rock tumbler my dad has and is now very disappointed that instead of a machine that can make any rocks polished colorful and beautiful hasbro went with a pouch"

[@ramirez9317]

This is the Best Gift Ever

[@FrenchRarity]

Always love those bonus clips at the end.

[@TheSimba86]

The perfect thing to watch on new years !

[@leahsmith1141]

Happy New Year everybody!

[@SonicJrandSarah]

You know, this episode could have been a take on Gift of the Magi, where not only does Pinkie trade her party cannon to get Maud a gift, but Maud also trades her rock to get Pinkie a gift. Like, maybe there is an instance where Maud isn't able to buy Pinkie some new confetti because the store she needs to buy it from is closed and instead sees some pony else with some who agrees to take Maud's rock in exchange. I can't believe I didn't think of that possibility when this episode first aired, but it would be interesting.

[@PhantomAarantula]

I don't know how much value a pebble would hold.

[@SonicJrandSarah]

@@PhantomAarantula Maybe there are some ponies who like rocks.

[@tonedeafbard7021]

Happy New Year!

[@chocolatelovereeek6745]

Yaaay new video this is the highlight of my day 😀😀

[@PhantomAarantula]

As odd as it is that Rarity is a seamstress who could easily solve this episode's conflict, I think this episode could have been drastically better if Pinkie tried to sew a rock pouch for Maud instead and Pinkie rejected an offer Rarity made seeing her desperate to drum up a gift since it'd be more hollow if not from her own sister. Would have made the moral a lot stronger, too.

[@conduite6721]

Unrelated but your editing is amazing

[@eetuthereindeer6671]

I already watched all episodes of my little pony so this is the only way of new mlp content for me. At least these videos are masterpiece perfects every time

[@joshblackwell8632]

Maud & Pinkie are two of the best ponies start the new year with.

[@otakutoongamer5616]

0:39 Suri Polomane is onscreen, her existence itself is a sin

[@eetuthereindeer6671]

3:30 i feel bad for the people who had to translate this. I dont even remember what pinkie said when i watched this in not english but it certainly wasn't that

[@Lucios1995]

I feel that way about puns as well

[@monicaedits]

The show isn’t originally in English?

[@Pinkie-Dash]

@@monicaedits clearly it's shown in other countries, meaning it's in diff languages :/

[@blazing_firez]

3:08 i had this toy and i loved it but it got lost and i was really upset bc pinkie

[@novalightfim]

So are Manehattan and Appleloosa the only places in all of Equestria with an active police force?

[@marshmallowmountains4636]

I like how your editing and quality get better, unlike the original inspiration for your series...

[@SableWolfAngel]

Fanfiction titled "Maud's Rock Nose Candy" incoming (from out the back door of the shady rock pouch store).

[@fayil23]

omg since when have you been verified 🥺🥺🥺 im so happy for you dude

[@anonamouse5917]

I consume SOULS !

[@maxc5043]

Does this mean that marble and limestone and the parents have sixth senses of their own named after them

[@Beyondthe5thPanel]

An even better Fun Fact, the late great pianist comedian Victor Borge made the 5-ever joke popular with his inflationary language act. Never knew it was a meme, but they probably also got it from Victor

[@ellahastommy4298]

Love your video!

I think it's a sin that pinkie has made Maud smile on screen only once and in a different episode Starlight makes her smile twice

[@RenTran1]

4:22 I will be waiting for it.

[@slouchyllamagaming830]

Out with wings sin in with sin-light sin haha it’s funny cuz sin joke

[@skumpkin5191]

Something about the sentence "Pinkie firing a gun in Manehatten" is funnier beyond belief

[@sarasamaletdin4574]

This is pretty seasonal episode with the gift giving! Shame we never saw Pinkie in similar episodes with the other two sisters.

[@YoursTrulyThe1Pony]

I haven't done a mlp everything wrong with in while but someday I'll get back to it again

[@SteevLaw6]

After all this time I'm still salty we never got a PSSSD with Limestone or Marble. Thanks a lot, yada yada empty threat.

[@gacha4life824]

Happy New Year Little Shy!

[@82dorrin]

1:32 If Pinkie were Black, she would have been dead...

[@Oggie_rumperoo]

✋🤨📸

[@msgiantx1925]

Every time i see that freeze frame of rarity i start dying, i cant XDDDD

[@eimanb3887]

This came out 12 seconds ago but 3 days ago people commented😂

[@tonedeafbard7021]

I think they’re the patrons.

[@HenBasketFireAlarms]

@@tonedeafbard7021 Yup

[@eimanb3887]

@@tonedeafbard7021 yep

[@WeirdWonderful]

To be fair, with Pinkie being, well, Pinkie, Maud probably learned a long time ago to stop questioning anything she does.

[@forwhomthetacobelltolls]

1:18 ooklay in the agbay

[@joshuaareta2001]

I think you mean "Ooklay inay ethay agbay"

[@forwhomthetacobelltolls]

@@joshuaareta2001 it's a monsters inc ref

[@joshuaareta2001]

@@forwhomthetacobelltolls yeah i know i just wanna correct it

[@Pirate-Scorcher-1998]

Happy new year everyone

[@bloodrunsclear]

I do like the idea Twilight got the Twi-cane...and just sold it to a random street vendor

[@Lucios1995]

3:05 Expectation 3:07 Reality I had no clue "5ever" was a meme

[@daviddyer3543]

Pie Sister and Rarity fun! Also, Rarity gets to be a ball as well!

[@Lans32485]

Maude not questioning stuff Pinkie does isn't a sin. After all, if "it's Pinkie" is the answer for Pinkie related questions for regular people, it's definitely the answer for someone who grew up with her.

[@jschaeffer3440]

A sin for the fact that pinky could’ve asked rarity to make the exact same pouch

[@gugalldiznii383]

lmao the 'quote' in the description

[@Squishy771]

1:27 the fact that there isn’t a nightmare fuel sin is sin enough for me *ding*

[@marcyram]

Happy new year Littleshy!

[@Genmmay]

The faces ponies makes is already a sin-

[@trentpenner429]

Elizabeth Afton dabing? *SIN*

[@Genmmay]

@@trentpenner429 I forgot to change my profile pic-

[@alicewilloughby4318]

2:54 - The pony with the pouch isn't smoking, so why can't I shake the feeling that any pouch he's carried around for a while will smell of stale cigarette smoke?? 3:37 - I'm willing to bet this grew out of Victor Borga's "Inflationary Language Game", where any word that had a syllable that sounded like a number had to be pronounced with the next highest number. It's a twoderful game!

[@PKMNwww411_MkII]

35 + 8 sins. That's more than 42.

[@chrouu]

I’ve been gone for so long I’m not used to the new sin counter

[@dincjfs]

YAY CINEMARE SINS IS BACK

[@elrien591]

The pie family is the secret chaos magic family.