LIVE: Boyfriend Cop Murder Trial - MA v. Karen Read - Day 19

[@KatieDeluxe]

The precise and sterile manner in which the state police forensic person treated the evidence she collected just highlights what a horrible job the canton pd did in contrast to how they collected evidence.

[@StephanieRae99]

Why does the judge sound so put out? She has a really bad attitude.

[@SAMMYBAMBAM24]

Because the defense is badgering, making remarks, using trickery, asking same question after question. Her courtroom her show..

[@yogabee2222]

She's easily annoyed

[@louise2257]

Because she’s compromised! She knows at least one of the witnesses for the commonwealth

[@gracie1598]

They're all from the same small community. Watch the court recorder's expressions when she interacts with Lally and eye contact with a few of the witnesses. They all know each other and cross paths related to their employment.

[@gracie1598]

​@@SAMMYBAMBAM24Defense is doing their job.

[@justmyopinion7636]

The work that these defense attorneys are doing is worth a million bucks. So detailed. So dedicated.

[@ohtobeasuriel]

I worked collision repair for years. That damage (except maybe the tail lamp) is not from a human body lol

[@truecrime98]

Why would a judge not want the jury to know who signed the chain of custody report? Why would she want that hidden?? Hmmmm we all know why!!!

[@cyndilagasse991]

i think because proctor had his clothes for weeks before entering them into evidence

[@melissa74066]

I have never heard a judge huff and puff so much under her breath. She sounds like she is soooo bored

[@taiprichard2312]

She's probably hangover lol

[@khadijamohammed-p6z]

If Karen hit him in the road, how did all the glass land on the lawn?

[@Pammerrigan]

Surprised the broken glass wasn't found in the trunk of Karen's car or the glove box.

[@lisadavie5282]

Quantum Physics and Reality Knows this didn't Happen

[@kinessa26]

And the body honestly he was found all the way in the middle of the lawn by the flag I just don’t understand. The car had to be flying for him to land there. *(Oh so they’re saying he was dragged somehow- so she had to drive onto the lawn where there would be some tire tracks since snow wasn’t that bad yet😮)* Also if she did do this why bring her girlfriends to find him why not just go by yourself or stay home and call the cops saying he never came home. And I don’t get the motive for whoever did this. Seems like everybody loved him. And although no one really liked Karen it doesn’t mean she’s a murderer. Very interesting/perplexing case

[@lynnmendoza2254]

Why couldn’t the name of the chain of custody form from the lab be revealed? VERY INTERESTING AND ODD!!

[@janeferguson4455]

I have heard that it wasn't a CLEAN chain of custody of evidence , SO, they can't use it !

[@200shoegirl]

I was thinking the same thing!!

[@mandyohlin6886]

It was, the lab just did not have the chain of custody before the lab received it .. because they don't have anything to do with stuff before it gets to them

[@JB-bm1to]

@@mandyohlin6886COC is supposed to start at the crime scene and track all the way through to transport and the lab. It doesn’t just magically appear at the lab with no paperwork and the tech is like “oh cool I’ll just start taking this seriously right now and believe that you guys did your own form, that has nothing to do with us before I sign off on this”

[@JB-bm1to]

@@mandyohlin6886IF the evidence did not have proper COC before being received by the lab, then COC is considered broken.

[@jagglenut]

The judge and her “you really need to keep your voice up” is so annoying. Fix the courts PA system it sounds fine

[@yogabee2222]

She's huffy 😮

[@svetlanastojanoska7185]

Not sure if its the speakers or just that this prosecutor mumbles so much its so hard to understand what he's saying

[@musicvarietyclips]

Also like if it’s so flipping hot in there maybe close the blinds and block the sun?

[@johnmartyn9018]

@@yogabee2222she really has an unpleasant way about her!

[@janeferguson4455]

I have trouble hearing at all, sometimes !

[@tobydean7097]

They don’t take photos when they find evidence before they pick it up??? 🤔🤔🤔😬

[@lisadavie5282]

Or Number It. NOTHING! It was Clearly Planted by Them!

[@JK-jj9ko]

why dose lally always sound like he is sitting in the bathroom talking through the toilet door to the witnesses ?

[@jacquelinefriedhof242]

😂

[@dianesweat6015]

😂

[@foobarrel9046]

Lally is weak and unmotivated, too lazy to speak clearly, he mumbles lethargically at his shoes.

[@lisadavie5282]

Cuz he had an McCAlbert salad toss for Lunch and he needs to Take a Higgins

[@KickRocks-me7hh]

Because he's a nonce

[@louise2257]

Every time the judge says Mr Lally, it sounds like she’s saying Miss Delally 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@lynnnichols2847]

Also, Mr. Yanetti comes out sounding like "Miss Geonettie" 😂

[@jdaddyco]

Now I can't hear anything else when she says it! 😂

[@jacquelinefriedhof242]

“We CAHNT hear you Miss Dalally”

[@rotten-saved-wretch5048]

The judge keeps asking is there an objection Mr Lally? The time he says yes she says sustained to both. This trial is a disgrace!

[@Mmeeks187]

Normally I don’t really critique judges or how they handle their courtroom, and maybe this is just how she is .. BUT damn. She sounds like she’s in a constant eye roll. People’s LIVES are at stake. Not to mention the life that’s already been taken without an ounce of respect being given to him. Disgraceful.

[@SherriDowns-c2o]

This judge is terrible

[@Ashley6]

Right! I don’t think she likes her job.

[@juanacastillo7154]

There has been NO respect given to Officer John O'Keefe and his dear family. Justice ⚖️must be served. Karen admitted " I Did It " why is so hard to believe she run him over and left him to freeze in the snow. Evidence is 💯 her fault.

[@jasonfuller5603]

Every time I hear Red solo cups…. I think what kind of Mickey Mouse club house stuff we got going on here!!

[@Pr3ttyGiirlALWAYS]

Goofy’s playground , I tell yaaa ugh 🙄😒

[@donnataylor143]

@jasonfuller5603 I think of the song "Red Solo Cup" 😊by Toby Keith (RIP)....

[@tobydean7097]

Me too !!!! Toby Keith!!!! 🥤

[@nancymilliken692]

​@donnataylor143 Fun fact: Toby Keith punched my brother in law in the stomach at a house party when they were in their late teens/young adults.

[@Pr3ttyGiirlALWAYS]

@@nancymilliken692 love ittt hahaha

[@debidriscoll8108]

This is an officers home, does he not have cameras covering his property.

[@PNW_KT]

Oh… you KNOW he did! But certainly all that would be long gone before anyone could request it.

[@debidriscoll8108]

​@@PNW_KTwhat I figured. If they didn't do anything, the video would have been offered the second police got there.

[@LeannaMurphy-mx7zy]

Police officer across the street as well. Clear view of where this happened. He is the one they got the red solo cups from.

[@gigis6790]

I'm very interested in hearing what happened to all the surveillance footage. I'm not buying what we have been told so far.

[@crystalhanson1483]

@@gigis6790 DITTO :(

[@janeferguson4455]

Used ONE swab for multiple locations on the light... I have never heard of this kind of stuff.........

[@tobydean7097]

I’m not even a crime scene investigator and I know “one swab, one swipe”!!!!!

[@vanessasweeney8651]

It's unbelievable how many days they take off in this case. Ive never seen anything like it.

[@janeferguson4455]

Totally agree !

[@sharonparker8324]

The judge has other cases in between. Its been such a long trial, it cant be avoided.

[@Lexifer21]

​@@sharonparker8324apparently both the defense and prosecution asked for the trial to be delayed when there was more room in her schedule and she refused.

[@lisadavie5282]

Zero Evidence

[@sharonparker8324]

@@lisadavie5282 ZERO?

[@Tracygirl423]

“Any objections Mr. Lilly? Yes.Sustained “

[@KTD1988]

She is horrible and not even hiding it

[@juanacastillo7154]

⚖️ Justice for Officer John O'Keefe and his beautiful family ⚖️💕

[@tigerlily9536]

Absolutely 🩷 It's a shame that there are more 'likes' for posts supporting the conspiracy theory than this post. A lack of balance. Bless John's family and friends.

[@karinkoen9767]

Thank you, at least one person here thinking rationally. Not sure why it's so hard for people to stomach that little mrs perfect had way too much to drink and drove over her boyfriend. No it's this cover-up nonsense. She's not perfect, she drank too much that night like all of them. 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@nathaliedanis8725]

I could be wrong but if the rear right side tailight was busted from hitting John why was his body on the left side of the driveway on the lawn? I need a re-enactment of the hit to understand.

[@PixelKing548]

The most telling from today's trial is that Judge Bev prevented the defense from entering the chain of custody form from the MSP lab tech!

[@Lolabear00]

Of course she did after all she's Brian Alberts kids "auntie Bev".

[@jazzyvideotime]

What in the WORLD - if KR is convicted this will easily be appealed on higher courts up

[@SAMMYBAMBAM24]

There are rules..hate to bust your bubble but…defense has been a bit slimy…judge did the right thing and appeals are tough.

[@jazzyvideotime]

@@SAMMYBAMBAM24I came into this trial thinking the coverup theories sounded ludicrous and insane. I watch true crime all the time, and have family members in both law enforcement and as lawyers. Never once did I believe I would even consider a coverup. Chain of custody is a common aspect of consideration to bring up in the law. That would not be the only appeal but the amount of things that could be appealed already are mind blowing.

[@juliec2999]

Omg. So the Judge is involved in this massive murder cover up and framing? 🤣🤣 I keep reading how she "sustains" more Objections on the Defense side. The Prosecution and Defense don't get an even amount of their Objections sustained 🤣. It just means the Defense Attorneys make more objectionable statements, narratives, or questions.

[@Amontillado72]

"Tell them the guy never went into the house" Matt McCabe.."Colin was not at the house when John was there" Ally McCabe "Hos long to die in the cold" Jen McCabe ..butt dial after butt dial....and one cute little hair on a car that made it miles and miles without falling down despite of a blizzard. Hos long does it take to turn a tragedy into nationwide comedy? 😂

[@gracie1598]

Very well said.

[@maanmohammad8459]

I think your house of card that was built by crocodile boy is collapsing piece by piece.

[@BryanDTCAP]

​@@maanmohammad8459delusional, the McCabes and Alberts had horrendous explanations for so many incriminating calls/texts/searches, any jury with common sense would be highly skeptical

[@gracie1598]

@@maanmohammad8459 You wish. Smoke presentations not to mention coerced and influenced do not stand up indefinitely. Just hang on. For Law enforcement to conduct themselves the way this group has is a disgrace. There is absolutely no reason to not do an investigation by the book and standard. Why? If they did the investigation properly it would have revealed results they did not want disclosed. Initially, understandably I thought she possibly could have done this until: the evasiveness, seasoned cops destroying phones after butt dialing, deliberate improper sloppy investigation , not interviewing young witnesses for 18 months( who possibly could have been a threat) would not have interviewed certain witnesses if the FBI had not got involved. Make no mistake about it corruption has run deep in that community for sometime. An accident occurred caught them off guard and their usual shuffling, manipulating and controlling exposed them because of the structure of the situation. I pray Karen Read has the intelligence to take each and everyone of them to Civil Court and bankrupts them for the emotional and financial duress they have caused; not to mention disrespect and murder if John O'Keefe.

[@Roobz2000]

💯🎯👍

[@GibbsChasity]

The responses (tone) of the judge continue to shock me. She acts irritated that she has to breathe. It makes me curious if she treats those in her personal life with the same tone of responses. I understand being “monotone” but this is beyond that. It borders on unprofessional.

[@Tracygirl423]

A few weeks ago she was “sighing “ so loudly that everyone on social media complained and now she doesn’t do it 😊

[@maanmohammad8459]

You can't use a noun after "to".

[@dianesweat6015]

Judge Aunt Bev needs a attitude adjustment Aunt Flo has been visiting her since trial began

[@dianesweat6015]

Fake**

[@GibbsChasity]

@@Tracygirl423 I remember that. I guess she forgot this is a “job” and her attitude matters.

[@thoroughbredlover3]

Just wondering how a single hair could have withstanded sticking to a tail light being towed in a blizzard

[@carlosvelasquez9922]

From his arm most likely, very small, but with a root, roots are sticky.

[@DebKuzio]

Because the hair and glass froze to the vehicle in the blizzard!!

[@michaelcalland801]

@@carlosvelasquez9922 So Karen hits John, drives her car back to John’s, then drives back to scene. Car then gets driven 20 minutes away to Mansfield to Karen’s house. Sits for 12 hours in a storm with heavy snow & high winds. Then gets towed back to Canton PD …..and they find a hair ? Doubt it…l!

[@jess85]

So it frozen right after the "accident" happened? ​@DebKuzio

[@maanmohammad8459]

Ever hit a deer?granted,there is a difference,but you get the idea.

[@Kat-nd1ln]

I love the sound of witnesses going through pictures and court official putting them into evidence

[@JazzyScat]

😂

[@ronnierhodes811]

The most biased judge I’ve ever seen!

[@Lolabear00]

Ya she should've recused herself considering Brian Alberts kids call her auntie Bev!!! The corruption goes all the way up the chain here.

[@SAMMYBAMBAM24]

@@Lolabear00small town and you think people don’t know each other. Shame that you think a judge would not do her job and be corrupt..sad…she’s done nothing wrong. She’s doing her job.

[@yogabee2222]

​@@SAMMYBAMBAM24 she should not be on the case because of her personal relationship.

[@corky_cork]

Absolutely biased, bored, incompetent, and only works 21/2 days a week.

[@Peter_From_Lowell]

Most bias judge since the Trump trial.

[@donriddler4204]

I wouldn't trust them to investigate anyone's death.

[@MeadTheValkyrie]

If judge Vader makes a single comment about the DEFENSE taking up too much time, I will have to write a letter!!! She cuts them off in the middle of questioning but allows the prosecution to finish their questioning every time!

[@corky_cork]

I do not understand why this trial is taking so long. Most weeks average 2 1/2 days of trial time and enough sidebars for 10 trials.

[@3P44CT]

It's an odd trial because the witnesses for the prosecution are the culprits - so they have witnesses rights that the judge needs to uphold. That's also the explanation for the comments about her conduct, she has to enforce the witnesses rights. The defense is acting more as the prosecution. It's all backwards and will be huge national trial when Karen is acquitted and then this trial flips into a trial for the Alberts and McCabes (because they haven't been on trial even though it feels like that...but they are witnesses in this MA. Vs. Karen Read). Hard to type but hope that helps.

[@LeannaMurphy-mx7zy]

They are hoping to lose some jurors and have a mistrial. No air conditioning. It’s going to drag into July. Then they will find a reason not to have another trial. Morrissey will retire and they will try and sweep this whole clown show of a trial under the rug.

[@alsan623]

and... this judge has allowed the prosecution to waste a ridiculous amt of time with ongoing redundant irrelevant questions --- like whether ir not the def's blood alcohol level was taken from serum vs. whole blood. Seriously??? The prosecuting atty had no clue what he was talking about. Judge should have reined that in.

[@maanmohammad8459]

​@@3P44CT Thanx for the laugh...

[@maanmohammad8459]

​@@LeannaMurphy-mx7zy We will see.

[@Valerie_Dawn]

This judge is sooo biased! She asked the prosecutor if he had any objections when he had NOT objected and then she sustains the prompted objections??? WTAF?

[@janeferguson4455]

I absolutely cannot believe how rude and bigoted people are being about this last witness.

[@kate47ish]

Waiting for Jackson to say, “Is this a MAGIC hair??”

[@Elizabeth.C.Holmes]

Anyone else watching this trial and basing guilt or innocence strictly on facts and evidence presented and NOT on the gossip of the peanut gallery?

[@PNW_KT]

Same. I didn’t see much before the case either. Just basing it on my evidence presented here in court.

[@suesingleton4927]

ME!!

[@suesingleton4927]

Well just heard another day off!! Not back til Wednesday.

[@PNW_KT]

@@suesingleton4927 and no court on Friday.

[@juanacastillo7154]

💯 so far ..I Did It ...GUILTY ⚖️

[@truecrime98]

How does she not know who she gave the evidence to? Isn’t their supposed to be a chain of custody

[@lyndigibson7699]

How does a hair stay on a car thru a blizzard,, was it tapped or super glued?

[@joannt2298]

Or placed

[@KTD1988]

And if she hit him with her car, she would hit his body. Yet the autopsy showed no injuries below the neck, except the scratch and bite marks on his arm. Why didn’t he have any injuries to his torso, his legs , etc. How did his shoe come off yet there were no lower body injuries?

[@TMxo]

Get it together Bev… you’re growing tired and it is rude as heck… Justice for John O’Keefe 🇺🇸 🌹 💙

[@my2cents581]

Bev needs to retire!

[@MeadTheValkyrie]

Is it the typical job of a court reporter to take care of evidence as well as record everything? I don’t think I have ever seen anything like it.

[@wls1020]

One thing ive noticed in this trial is how much the CW objects (often) compared to how much the defense objects (very rarely) which tells me one side doesn't want the jury to hear everything there is to hear

[@mathninjamrsgriffith]

Why would she ask if there was an objection when he didn’t object?

[@tanyaconley7375]

To cue him to object.

[@tobydean7097]

Criminal?!!!!! 😮

[@KTD1988]

@@tanyaconley7375yep !!

[@KTD1988]

@@tanyaconley7375exactly why

[@barbaraoneill7384]

These people are out of court more than they are in court. Must be nice to go on vacation every day and come to court when you feel like it.

[@janeferguson4455]

it must be nerve wracking for Karen Read !

[@tobydean7097]

Its happy hour somewhere?!!!! 😂😂😂🍺🍸🥃🍷🍷🍷

[@cyndilagasse991]

according to early hearings the state couldn't locate the clothes to turn over to defense, the whole shirt should have gone to the lab

[@hotpinkthread]

The clothing would have been in custody of the hospital, in a belongings bag. It would not have been evidentiary from the outset, because he was taken in an ambulance to the ER for trying to resuscitate.

[@cyndilagasse991]

@@hotpinkthread it should have but it wasn't - no one could account for it for weeks

[@hotpinkthread]

@@cyndilagasse991 is this part of testimony? Because I do not recall hearing that said at trial

[@cyndilagasse991]

@@hotpinkthread it was brought up at an early hearing

[@hotpinkthread]

@@cyndilagasse991 So, unless the jury was present for the early hearing, then no, it is not part of the trial. There is a lot that goes on in pre-trial that never makes it to the jurors ears. I am trying to view this whole proceeding as a juror would. 💕

[@TXBULL195]

I think the Defense should start using the Lally like statements to get things in. IE : "what if any name is on the bottom of that form"

[@musicvarietyclips]

It does not make sense that the taillight pieces would be found where JOs body was found. If she supposedly hit him at a high rate of speed he would have flown quite a distance and landed there or even if he was dragged, the taillight pieces would/should be at the point of impact not where he ended up 🤨

[@jules6460]

The taillights were found at the 2nd search after Karens car had already been impounded, which there is missing footage of…of course! I believe the taillights were placed there after the fact! There are way too many inconsistencies with prosecutions key witnesses and I’m not sure if you are from Massachusetts, but if not, the Albert family grew up in Canton and holds a lot of power there. Brian being a Boston police officer previously and another brother being a Canton police officer. The brother Chris is a board member and Even Jen McCabe has known the Alberts since she has been six years old. They go back! However, John O’Keefe is originally from Braintree and only moved to Canton in 2016 I believe. Also, just found out brother Chris Albert, board member killed someone when he was younger, I believe it was an alcohol related accident. I love how the defense attorneys are proving such corruption, and it is quite obvious the judge favors the prosecution.

[@bethmccrae2714]

Most of the taillight pieces and John O'Keefe's sneaker were found at the point of impact, north of John's body. And some of the taillight pieces would have moved with John's body

[@shannon6609]

Maybe I missed it.. if Karen hit him in the road and he went flying... how did all the pieces end up in the lawn and not the roadway

[@shannon6609]

@Thomas-vu5ge then shouldn't there have been tire tracks in the snow

[@barbaramay1866]

Lolol. No one said he went flying.

[@81suze]

@@shannon6609new snow was falling constantly

[@mighty0974]

Where did you hear that she hit him in the road?

[@shannon6609]

Well she either hit him in the road, which wouldn't make sense that there was tail light pieces on the lawn... or she hit him in the lawn and no one leaving saw the tire marks from the lawn to the street. Either way...

[@Winter307]

The injuries don't match the prosecution's theory of what happened. There would be blood on the vehicle and more damage from hitting and dragging a grown man. This should have never gone to trial.

[@jodifocht5680]

No one said she drug him. My friend had a car back into them. Two broken legs where he was pinned. If there wouldn't have been witness they would have gotten away with it. Not a scratch on the car

[@evahanson7681]

​@@jodifocht5680 cool story. John had no trauma to his lower body. But he did have a massive head wound. And there was almost no blood in the snow. Which, as we all know, is ridiculous.

[@Winter307]

@@jodifocht5680 Then how do you explain the cut marks on his arm? They alluded to that happening when he was drug by the car. He also had blood all over from head wound but no blood on the taillight.

[@jodifocht5680]

@Winter307 scratch marks were from her she was mad about him screwing around on her.

[@jodifocht5680]

@Winter307 and he got cut when his head hit the ground. Hence blood under snow

[@melissa74066]

This first witness is dancing around the questions.

[@miche289]

The only thing illegal here is the judges bangs

[@dianesweat6015]

😂😂😂

[@Lee-le2kp]

She looks hideous

[@beegee5460]

I myself think they need fewer cops in this town and more hairdressers!! There are a lot of crimes of the hair variety going on!!

[@campsbaysa]

Why doesn’t the judge tell Lally to stop saying sort of. Sort of means whatever he is asking or describing means it’s not accurate. If he said was Mr O’Keefe sort of dead, or was it Sort Of cold… !!!! - he needs get a better grip of how to professionally ask a question or make a statement.

[@Mear1881]

The constant “sort of” drives me insane. He needs to be precise.

[@anadeandrade5368]

That’s considered leading and that’s a total violation of here civil rights! It’s crazy

[@jacquelinefriedhof242]

Maddening

[@hotpinkthread]

@@anadeandrade5368and yet her lawyers are not objecting to anything.

[@anadeandrade5368]

I really think they don’t care because the FBI is all over this case and I’m starting to really believe that the judge is also involved in this conspiracy 🤐

[@scottwoodruff1761]

They are the Boston Red Sox, NOT the Red Cups!😂😂

[@debbiehopper1667]

This is the noisiest courtroom I've ever watched. Someone is constantly shuffling papers and opening and closing a binder! So distracting!!

[@junkandthangs]

All while the judge can’t hear a thing

[@JazzyScat]

And creaking chairs or something

[@jennifermelendez9502]

And all the coughing too

[@hotpinkthread]

@@junkandthangsyep, maybe the judge needs a hearing aide. 😂

[@cyndilagasse991]

@@JazzyScat judge's chair

[@juliem.3526]

The cuts on his arms do not look indicative of being hit by the vehicle.

[@peacelovemusic3400]

Wait, one hair and all those pieces of glass remained on the car through all of that driving and towing? Gtfoh

[@lyndigibson7699]

As soon as red solo cups were brought up case should of been thrown out...

[@KTD1988]

And they claimed they came from the neighbors house. But the Alberts were the ones having a party and drinking.

[@Michbeachlover]

So much for the belt missing and the sneaker. They are both there.

[@bethmccrae2714]

Mark bederow started that lie

[@musictomyears6920]

It was a hat, and they didn’t find it.

[@KTD1988]

@@musictomyears6920very suspicious the hat was never found

[@musictomyears6920]

@@KTD1988 It came out during testimony that the hat was found under a big pile of snow.

[@hotpinkthread]

It is kinda scary to think that University of New Haven is one of the largest college forensic programs in the US. Between this specialist, and the one in the Murdaugh case, they may want to re-evaluate their teaching methods before graduating anyone else from their masters program!

[@Lee-BrooklynsFinest]

At this rate this trial will take a whole year....

[@lynnmendoza2254]

It seems that the judge is quite bored with the entire situation and definitely not a fair judge!! She’s not allowing testimony in that should be heard by the jury!!

[@dianesweat6015]

She's a real hum dinger, with hot flashes

[@mjn55128]

Regarding your last statement, what testimony are you referring to, and what are your qualifications to make this accusation?

[@maanmohammad8459]

She is biased because she allowed a third party culprit by the defence,which is rarely permitted in courts.I assume she gave the defence that chance bowing to the pressure of a mob.Judges shouldn't yield to mobs because it would encourage other criminals to hair their day not on hours,but in the streets.

[@maanmohammad8459]

​@@mjn55128 No qualification is required to be a part of Karen's cult.

[@janeferguson4455]

I think it is her personality

[@debidriscoll8108]

It is very fishy that the officers got rid of their phones.

[@crystalhanson1483]

When is the Cell Phones evidence. . .what was on John O'Keefe's TEXT & PHONE CALLS. . .3 days BEFORE? ?

[@cyndilagasse991]

and did it the day before the preservation letters arrived

[@dianesweat6015]

You didn't say. What else does crooked people trying to hide things do

[@janeferguson4455]

a lot of lawyers etc on youtube channels seem to be questioning whether Proctor will be on the stand.... evid. he has conflicting story from testimony in federal grand jury vs. Camden ..... uh oh !

[@Ideszamarch]

Someone tell the prosecution that that it’s important not to bore jury. Try to keep them awake !

[@tobydean7097]

Take pictures of your entire vehicle before the police tow it to the station?!!!!! 😮

[@my2cents581]

Take a video so you can’t be accused of photoshopping the pics!

[@teresacox8517]

Nice that the search lead cop didnt need to refer to his reports, he knew his times!

[@Lexifer21]

He was solid!

[@PhillyDove]

Only testing one solo cup= Yikes. This strikes me as another instance where another witness is taking the Canton PD''s word on what is happening and tailoring their testing to that narrative. To me, this is the worst fact for the prosecution so far, There could be Albert, Mcabe, Higgins DNA in those other cups, or only JO DNA in that cup. We will never know. After hearing that my doubt went way up.

[@crystalhanson1483]

The Witness. . .MELTED the snow/blood from a cup, took a swab. . .NO RESULTS? DUH

[@geejames5283]

It’s not a matter of guilt or innocence, the one with the best lawyer always wins. “The dream team”

[@ruthx3346]

The forensic evidence is paramount.

[@kahmyiahlinzy363]

Never heard “um” used so much

[@claudiaramos4273]

After the 20th I stopped watching. Sorry can’t do it! The “umm” is driving me nuts, can’t get past it and actually pay attention to what she is saying.

[@KTD1988]

She is obviously extremely nervous

[@thebrittanykoala]

Love the people who say the tail light couldnt have broken from John but could be broken by someone removing it. So what is it? Is it fragile or not lmao

[@MeadTheValkyrie]

Unless John was on his knees when she (allegedly) backed into him, his soft tissue at a very low rate of speed, would not have caused scratching, denting, and broken glass. She would have had to backed into him at a higher rate of speed than what she could have done. If she hit him at the area of the brake light, he could have easily moved out of the way. Did she wait until he was behind her car then slowly back into him? However, how much force is required to remove the light cover, is a different matter. If it is done carelessly or by someone who doesn’t know how to do it, it COULD break it. It’s not that hard to reconcile the two things.

[@aes1492]

Karen Read is so incredibly uncomfortable to watch. Constantly twisting in her chair, whispering to her attorneys, smirking, duckfacing, and narrowing her eyes. She seems to have no emotional connection to the tragedy of whatever happened to John O'Keefe. Let alone whether she actually killed him herself when blackout drunk 😢

[@TimParker-Chambers]

Agreed. I think she's innocent, and being frames by the McAlberts, but that aside, she does not present as someone innocent or likeable in any way: If the McAlberts' testimonies weren't so blatantly sketchy, the jury would likely convict her based on her demeanour 🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️

[@cyndilagasse991]

its been 3 1/2 years, I'm sure she is done grieving and more focused on her life now

[@WhoopsADaisy]

Her father has the same "duckface" expression. It's genetics.

[@MrGrumpyGills]

What exactly would you want her to do?

[@mandyohlin6886]

She sure don't look concerned about ANYTHING. no reaction to others whom are still sad about the death. Sitting stone faced would be a better look to the jury than what she does. It looks bad on her no matter what.

[@truecrime98]

Omg they planted a drinking the straw too omg! You could tell that she felt awkward even saying that!! How does a drinking straw get scraped from his clothes after his clothes were cut off and then missing for two months 😂

[@tanyaconley7375]

Proctor probably eats in his car and throws his trash in floor…landing on the clothes he carried around.

[@NikkiTrixieLee]

@@tanyaconley7375haha, bet! 💯

[@marionboucher3155]

that judge is the most biased ever ,and i have watched dozens of trials

[@SAMMYBAMBAM24]

She isn’t biased. The defense is breaking rule after rule. She’s actually let them get away with too much.

[@marionboucher3155]

@@SAMMYBAMBAM24 are you for real and part of that wonderful family or the judge.or you are blind and deaf

[@PhillyDove]

@@SAMMYBAMBAM24 Just repeating this over and over doesn't make it true.

[@malu21usa]

@@marionboucher3155100% plus some! 😂

[@SAMMYBAMBAM24]

@@PhillyDove and you attacking a judge and saying she’s biased doesn’t make it true either? What else ya got? She’s guilty..

[@elmariesteyn5106]

Seems to me that this case is going on for a next 5 months or so? Whats it going to cost???

[@riggstribluemerle949]

This trial is like the US team trials for Olympic Sighing 😮‍💨

[@scottwoodruff1761]

Corruption in the red solo cups!😂😂

[@margaretconnery7422]

That Judge gets on my nerves. Jack hammer Jackson was brilliant.

[@dianesweat6015]

Love that nickname. You know it takes a jackhammer to break up the concrete that the prosecution tries to lay down for a foundation

[@dianesweat6015]

Love that name Jack Hammer Jaxon, and he will break through all this bogus testimony on the prosecution side. And Aunt Bev should like him because he's loud like a jackhammer she doesn't have to tell him to speak up lol

[@kevinbernard9791]

The judge is so annoyed because karen is winning and her friends. THE ALBERT'S/McCABES are going to be investigated 😅 worst judge I've ever watched 😮

[@cyndilagasse991]

if his injury was on the back of his head and he was lying in the snow on his back after she hit him, how did the front of the shirt get all bloody

[@bethmccrae2714]

Either when he was first struck by the vehicle, or when he may have tried to get up, or when CPR eas done, or when he was moved to the hospital

[@nicolearmata1818]

@@bethmccrae2714or when he was beat up in the house… you forgot that option

[@margy1884]

Where is all the blood? He lost 3 liters of blood… where did it go? Commonwealth says she hit him he landed in the yard did nt move …. Where is the blood on the snow in his hood from the cut on the back of his head? I believe he was injured somewhere else. Also they have her backing up 60’ feet in the snow in the dark and drunk … 60 feet and he wouldn’t see or hear her coming he just stood there and let her hit him.

[@sepharaSwift]

@@margy1884keep in mind both these individuals had a high alcohol content. However I too do not believe there is enough evidence that she did it. Like you said where is the blood? Why isn’t he bruised on his torso? If she hit him at 12am when there was a light dusting of snow, why was he laying on such a thick layer of snow? The snow would be on top of him not below him. Making him not visible when Karen et al found him in the morning.

[@KTD1988]

@@margy1884and she hit him with her car but only his head and arm were injured? No injuries to his torso, legs , anything below the neck ? I agree with you. He was attacked in the basement and placed there

[@TimParker-Chambers]

5:27:36 The point which is being stumbled toward - like someone playing 'Pin the tail on the Donkey' - is that an apparent hair which she was *able to remove with tweezers,* would not have remained adhered to the car during its transport *through a blizzard!!!* It could have been deposited by whoever towed the car or anyone else who came into contact with the car at the PD... 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️ It needs to be declared inadmissible as evidence 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@maanmohammad8459]

Imagine.They probably had about 30 to 50 cops each one was tasked with planting or corrupting some evidence.Actually one of them went to the same bar the second day to get the straw and the same glass that John was carrying because the original one was left in the basement.

[@smadd11]

They said she backed into him…which even further makes this a bunch of hogwash. Unbelievable

[@janeferguson4455]

From what I have learned, the tail light on that car is made of some material that will Not break up into a bunch of pieces.

[@tobydean7097]

This is true!!!!! I backed into a brick wall and all it did was make a little scratch on my taillight!!!! 😊😊😊

[@tabitharay3076]

Red solo cups gets me every time I hear it! It's like it could be satire.

[@louise2257]

Did John have any pieces of glass in his arm or stuck anywhere in his skin?

[@michaelcalland801]

Nope

[@ginafabiani5629]

No the cops were not able to get to his body lol 😩

[@kurtrichards6899]

Witness sits and smirks and lawyer can't comment? C'mon Aunti Bev, your bias is showing again.

[@adriannerouleau533]

They really need to invest in some better microphones 🎤

[@JK-jj9ko]

How did the tail lights appear on top of the snow if john was hit by a car before it snowed ? Shouldnt the tail lights be under the snow if the tail light broke exactly at the same time john was hit by a car ? According to the female who is johns closest friend, she said when she saw him on the ground she didnt know it was him as his face was fully covered with snow and she had to wipe away alot of snow of his face and then realised it was john. So the snow just avoided covering all the tail light peices and decided just to cover johns body and face instead?

[@maanmohammad8459]

Did you see it on top of the snow,or did you read it somewhere and believe it to be true?

[@Monarch533]

He said they raked them up from under the snow and took pictures afterward

[@CarolCaines]

OMG the swabs of EVERYTHING were performed so shoddy. This forensic expert has never swabbed an accident vehicle previously and only swabbed one red solo cup. Unbelievable 🤦‍♀️

[@lucyElaine5656]

The Judge is opening the door for appeal issues. Wow!! She shouldn't been the judge in this cases. What a shame.

[@maanmohammad8459]

What is life without hope

[@Amontillado72]

yes, Bev helps the defense a great deal by displaying her preferences so clearly and by being so biased...so Bev..keep on. Thanks

[@margy1884]

I wonder how much this trial cost the Commonwealth?

[@hotpinkthread]

How so, exactly?

[@maanmohammad8459]

@@hotpinkthread Do you think somebody who writes"shouldn't been"is qualified to write an opinion about law matters?

[@PickledPepperz]

Someone get Aunty Beverage a hearing aid

[@justmyopinion7636]

Why couldn’t the forensics lady agree that the hair was inverted? She couldn’t agree that the hair was flipped in different directions? It’s obvious to the naked eye.

[@janeferguson4455]

sloppy work and sloppy info by lab ! This whole thing is just unbelievable !

[@meekosss]

Finally got thru with the Daybell trial. So did this girl do it? Do we have a lot of evidence?

[@joannt2298]

You’re gonna have to catch up like everyone else bud

[@nikilietsch3451]

I appreciate the lab ladies but all of their work doesn’t carry much weight if the “ evidence “ was not properly collected or maintained before it got to thier offices . The police were way too sloppy !

[@my2cents581]

It wasn’t “sloppy” it was Criminal!

[@dianesweat6015]

I have why doesn't judge Bev put two microphones on people stands instead of one or clean out her ears

[@loriduffecy9205]

Don't tell me one strand of hair is going to stay on a car for a 60 mile trip in a snow ❄️ 🌨️ blizzard.... unbelievable 😯

[@foobarrel9046]

*The Defense Theory of Case as per Closing Argument:* Chlöe's was severely hungover after being administered 8 Jameson & Ginger by practical joker Brian Higgins during the 29th of January. When the Irish sauce-mechanic John O'Keefe late that night stumbled blind drunk into the Albert household and promptly face-planted into her feeding bowl, she took this personally, flew into a rage and savagely tore into him with fang and claw. When she grew weary, Brian Albert stepped in with an aluminium baseball bat to finish the job and evade the lawsuit. His wife looked on impassively as blood spattered up her kitchen walls, before helping her spouse drag the quivering bag of smashed hamburger to the lawn. Finally they all sat down at the table and, betwixt swigs of Irish potcheen, plotted out a Venn Diagramm of how to frame my client, the fragrant Karen Read, for this murder.

[@HerbKillin]

Defense only has to show reasonable doubt not prove anything with all the mcalberts lies its over

[@mighty0974]

I waited a week for this?!?!?!

[@crystalhanson1483]

? ! ? ! ? ! ? I "thought" the lawyers would have gotten THEIR act(s) to--gether! By NOW!

[@KTD1988]

Looking at the photos of this man’s clothes he was killed in was incredibly sad.😢. Someone knows THE truth of exactly what happened. It’s sad that there is so much lying and coverup.

[@JazzyScat]

So his cap was never found?

[@KickRocks-me7hh]

Look suspiciously like dog and bite marks on that clothing.

[@serena9543]

This does not look like there were 40 pieces of tail light?

[@TimParker-Chambers]

5:39:39 Two items cross-contaminating each other... 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️