[LIVE CLASS] 이달의 소녀(LOONA) - So What

[@TheKIRSTENShow21]

jinsoul belting during the final chorus will never get old

[@mariammemon7761]

YESSS

[@kimr.4619]

I thought I was the only one that noticed her singer her heart out at 3:30 ❤️🤣 Much respect tho, she definitely nailed those ad lips!

[@929er13]

amen. i feel blessed every time.

[@allyzaunabia4817]

Can i ask who is jinsoul there?

[@TheKIRSTENShow21]

Allyza Unabia girl at 3:00 w/ the jawline! she belts out the "yeah" at 3:30 :) she also has a solo song called singing in the rain, as do the rest of the girls. hope u stan loona!

[@quietisonline]

Vivi trying her best to not look sad lowkey breaks my heart.

[@heartsforzo]

Spectral why ? I am a New orbit sorry :(

[@adourinqly]

@@heartsforzo vivi never gets lines. honestly up till now i dont even know what the hell she sings in so what. her lines are next level non-existent. she is the only foreign member in loona so its understandable that she gets lesser lines than the rest especially since she isnt the top few in vocal ability but she gets like almost NOTHING

[@cerdipuerki1930]

@@adourinqly she's just sings "Hey"

[@yangIQ]

Which one is Vivi? New orbit.

[@kpopoholic_4623]

@@yangIQ vivi is at 1:18

[@arlethsantamaria8596]

Viví in the recording studio: “hey” BBC: okay that’s enough Orbits: but...we want more BBC:....no. ViVi and Orbits: 🥺

[@jeonjungkook-tu6sz]

me duele mucho

[@chalistdwivaneraputrizulfa5551]

Its make me cry, this vid even prove it more that vivi didn't get any linee😔😭

[@nyanyanyanyanyanya9365]

Im proud of you vivi cream

[@someone-bf9yp]

I'm sorry, which one is vivi?

[@1ostkids393]

@@someone-bf9yp 1:18 !!

[@amerchy]

i think hyunjin noticed vivi was really sad so she made her laugh by interacting w her towards the end :'(

[@user-el4zl8rh2h]

awww kind aeongie

[@aynyrda1391]

Aeong

[@oceanrxse4803]

awh what time?

[@chuucandoit5471]

Yea but she's the only one who's next to vivi tho :')

[@b1ak3]

@@oceanrxse4803 3:43

[@rafiakbar3680]

vivi: "IGHT IMMA JUST PLAY THIS INSTRUMENT"

[@AgungRizkiAS]

Imma just seat here and watch

[@王寶寶-w9i]

vivi sings the instrumental, humans could never

[@tahdenlento3607]

@@王寶寶-w9i LMAOO 😭

[@bopsongsenjoyer]

which one is vivi?

[@clarebcomposer]

@@bopsongsenjoyerShe's the one killing it on the drums 1:17

[@kualiibu1551]

One day Chuu found a little crying and asked what's wrong. The girl said " I'll never be good enough to be a great singer". Chuu smiled and told her to be more confident in herself so she decided to not give up and strive harder. That little girl is Mariah Carey.

[@izonexbae]

Chuusus i actually laughed 😂

[@Marimo974]

@@rush68 I thought it was about Vivi while reading 😂 that plot twist killed me

[@taytay7414]

loona are such sweet young ladies😻 i heard gowon did something similar with someone name m&m😌

[@lellam.4871]

LOL LOVED IT

[@khangbui3914]

rhiannon she brought up a girl from the hood who’s now a Grammy award winning Nicki Minaj

[@kpopgamer-mg5sw]

loona: im so bad vivi, with no lines: im so sad

[@andromedaellis9718]

True

[@siyeonsdoormat9826]

Orbits at BBC : I'm so mad

[@enzberns]

I shouldn’t have laughed so much

[@ra7il4728]

i feel so bad...

[@audreymaharanii6525]

bbc: im so bad vivi: im so sad orbits: im so mad

[@Lonlyrstar]

No one talk about jinsoul high note??? SHE IS AMAZING AND SO STABLE And How Vivi is trying her best not to be sad :(

[@carlask3440]

Well I think everybody talks about her A LOT, we should talk about the other members

[@haniii05]

I was like who singing the heyYYyYy and keep repeating the part to notice who singing it🤣🤣🤣

[@aliensuperstar333]

@@carlask3440 It bothers u that she is praising Jinsoul's vocal ability and not praising ur bias?

[@horchatamochi1006]

Carla SK wdym I’m scrolling through the comments and everyone is being talked about and it’s the same thing for other vids

[@sueme4310]

It's playback.

[@anthonywilliams208]

Bruh this is some SM level harmonization. No joke. Lee Sooman doesn’t play around.

[@hiru836]

Even the line distribution too ✊😔

[@raisyarenata7993]

So SM style

[@hiru836]

@@raisyarenata7993 the bridge is lmao

[@sienasyed]

@@hiru836 vivi be getting the winwin treatment

[@hiru836]

@@sienasyed yerin too

[@Dinomater_]

Kim Lip has such a pretty voice

[@celestielsigh]

She's flawless

[@kmms4720]

Queen lip is literally amazing

[@FairyAl]

her tone is so great, one of my faves in the group alongside haseul and jinsoul !

[@TheMarieflyy]

My favorite voice in Loona alongside Hyunjin and pretty sure in kpop in general, her voice is so unique and beautiful

[@OdeToAphrodite]

3rd favorite vocal color in the group (right after Jinsoul and Yves respectively) and overall 5th in K-pop and the whole world. It's just so unique.

[@nekop6447]

my sensitive ass started crying when i saw vivi’s face. she literally had no lines and was barely smiling. she doesn’t deserve this, since haseul wasn’t in this comeback they could’ve given vivi extra lines. heejin, lippie, yves, chuu, and jinsoul don’t need all the lines. i understand their the strongest vocalists, but we have all seen vivis potential and how great of a singer/rapper she is. her korean improved so much and she deserves more than saying “hey” once in a song. i’m really about to cry because again, she doesn’t deserve this. i hope bbc will give vivi more lines in the live stages during promotions

[@edilynew9892]

Thank god im not the only one that cried

[@nekop6447]

FeelSpecialSoty you could see in her face that she was upset, it’s really upsetting especially as a vivi stan

[@wesleylima1419]

@@nekop6447 You guys need to stop assuming things only because an idol isn't smiling. This is kinda pretentious.

[@kurami6247]

i know right :((. she wasnt smilling at all and looked so bored and out of it.

[@edilynew9892]

Yes Or No on top of the live stage where she got ZERO screen time

[@me-zk4hf]

2:36 For everyone who was looking for vivi's one second

[@bootao4682]

this makes me sad ugh she deserves more than a line :(((

[@jjjjj1339]

Im new orbit...can anyone tell me where vivi got more lines??? Well im never hear vivi with more lines Sorry for my bad english

[@salsikea]

@@jjjjj1339 she barely has any lines

[@hamstatouille]

@@jjjjj1339butterfly, star and why not

[@jingliusz]

@@jjjjj1339 butterfly, colors, whynot

[@IASSAASSAI]

All orbits are mad bc we have seen vivi rap in the meet up and her opening in fire yet this was a perfect opertunitiy to show her rap and dance skills yet she was placed as a back up dancer, I'mma just play everyday I love you even though I still play it

[@pawpawx]

YES

[@AmieMalfoy]

EXACTLY I WAS WAITING FOR VIVI TO SPIT FIRE BUT NOPE BBC PLAYED HER DIRTY

[@bees3611]

baby vivi i really love her🤧

[@loonacandoit2635]

yes they trained with Mariah Carey

[@gowon11]

they trained Mariah Carey

[@theetaurus1832]

yeahirai the delusion

[@poppypayne6271]

@@theetaurus1832 it was just a joke but ok :/

[@jungwoosolo]

@@theetaurus1832 you again? if you don't like LOONA then just leave instead of being an assh*le in all the comment section luv 😙

[@loveclouds_]

no they trained mariah carey

[@pieceof-zd]

chuu is literally the cutest human being in the world holyshit this is my first time getting 1k likes. thx guys

[@jiwoosverse5265]

No lie

[@JessicaNottingham]

Facts.

[@bencecsuka1892]

This era might seem to be serious ...but we are talking about Loona cjkxzhvfdofpdojdfobjfdjbndlkfsvfnd

[@MarkDeSade100]

At this point we may as well start calling her Chuuwu.

[@euphypie]

True

[@user-ue5px4ps1y]

와... 김립 파트 때마다 진짜 감탄만 나옴 아니 전체적으로 다들 잘하고 안정적이긴 한데 김립은 진짜 너무 안정적이고 음색 넘 고급짐 ㅠ

[@만동헌]

그러니까요

[@jentlehome08]

4:10 NOT AT CHOERRY FIXING THE CHAIRS IM GONNA GIVE HER MY WHOLE HEART BYEE

[@ddaaa6389]

ikr!! i also have that habit from school, i cant stand seeing chairs out

[@kimr.4619]

She's so pure ❤️🥺

[@perxyjavkson]

everyone is worrying that bbc put them on scary diets but in reality theyre only eating cds edit : well this didnt age well ..

[@kimr.4619]

snowy or wtv I know it’s a joke but have they ever been put on a diet? I think even some members gained a bit of weight this comeback and it’s making me really happy 😁😊 Really hope BCC won’t ever force them a diet on tho.

[@kayyem1646]

@@kimr.4619 I think Hyejoo gained some? Idk ahshshsh. It's a-okay tho, she looks really healthy. I stan healthy Hyejoo

[@themeparkreel]

KOOKIE IS MY RELIGION i dont think BBC are as strict about eating when it comes to some of the other management agencies the girls look healthy so thats great

[@jwyimpact]

Spookyboi97 oh well, BBC spent 9 million USD on food for loona 😅

[@wikuranugget40]

Gem and I I’m pretty sure that’s Yves natural body, she’s looked like that since predebut.

[@tokk1s]

Can we talk about how sad Vivi looks? She deserves more than a "hey", her voice is beautiful and she is very talented, I feel that BBC only sees her as a visual

[@longassrideskareeettt78]

SM helped in making this, SM is known for not giving proper line distributions mostly to chinese members.

[@ss_qtch]

@@longassrideskareeettt78 I mean tea but I feel like Vivi has had less lines in previous albums, she got EVER SO slightly more in the b-sides for #, I feel. Defo BBC's doing, they need to give her more lines for sure

[@longassrideskareeettt78]

@@ss_qtch she actually had pretty good lines during the butterfly era, I mean 8/9 seconds is already stable enough for me. I just don't know what happened to the other ones. I also remember one of their b sides where she actually had 10 seconds of lines I just forgot the title.

[@ss_qtch]

@@longassrideskareeettt78 justice for Vivi 😭

[@piss-v4l]

3:18 vivi looks like done and bored

[@japsnmds2741]

I’m feeling she’s gonna leave loona I probably would

[@iminkjet7995]

Cuz she is AI🤖

[@aliensuperstar333]

@Chu Cha With the treatment BBC is giving her I guess she would leave, she just have 3 secs

[@imasavage3006]

At 2:32 as well

[@Coquettelectricmilk]

@@aliensuperstar333 tbh i feel really bad for her imagine quiting your modeling career and joining an idol group where you barely get any line i hate that the producers/bbc is acting as if loona has 9 members

[@KMoist]

JINSOUL YOU BETTER BELT! MIC ON

[@magalideniseboniardi3190]

i missed them so much but seeing vivi getting 0 lines makes me so so so sad she doesn't deserve this

[@IASSAASSAI]

We hyped vivi so much saying i go i go I go but we didn't want her lines to go😢😭

[@eggressive_]

She looks like not feeling it :(

[@HarvestingThings]

like, i get it because her vocals are really weak. but she legit looks so sad here :((

[@FairyAl]

@@HarvestingThings what's the correlation between Vivi not being the best singer and her not having any line in a song with rap verses and a lot of shouting ? make it more sense please

[@Kosmoluce99]

Harvest if she had weak vocals bbc wouldn’t make her the 5th member

[@MissesEntertainment]

finally got to hear jinsoul’s perfect highnote live without the autotune background music

[@celestielsigh]

Lol it's not autotuned, the studio version is literally a different voice. I wish they used Jinsouls actual vocals because she can definitely belt though not as powerfully as the studio singer

[@MissesEntertainment]

celestielsigh oh rly? welp sorry. i saw some people saying it was jinsoul’s singing but just autotuned. does make sense if it was another singer. whatever it is, they should have just used jinsoul’s singing !!! :(

[@TramNguyen-mg6zn]

@@celestielsigh it was Jinsoul's vocal in the studio version, not someone else's, pls stop spreading false information

[@SNSDVeVo2]

Tram Nguyen // literally no one knows if it’s jinsoul or not we were not in the studio with them were we

[@kylepop4371]

adrian my dad! We do know because she’s literally performed it live... it’s her voice, she’s just changed the colour of it to sound more soulful, not to mention it’s isolated in the studio version

[@Ahhrri]

kim lip is honestly one of the most talented idols

[@misomoon]

she was born to perform

[@hr_naura]

which one is kim lip?sorry

[@grace-ir2rr]

Nauraa 2:43

[@sychie3338]

where's the lieee?

[@leo-wg5rq]

vivi only sings 0.02.3 of the whole song, she literally just breathes 2 words and that's all. that's more than unfair.

[@k1msejeong925]

and they dont even show her while ""singing""

[@vxlnxtine438]

:( i feel very bad for her.

[@washingmachine2]

Me and the girls at the music class:

[@teechall4017]

girl, you got the talent

[@mayamagination]

I'm Vivi lol

[@yunaz7977]

litr same omfg 💀💀

[@vrtualangels]

im gowon 💔

[@astri1764]

I can't take hyeju seriously after hearing her voice. She's so baby. And jinsoul, you're the babiest baby

[@afnanhisyamhussin2589]

Vivi’s “Mo Ottae” is so forceful it caused a disturbance in the Orbits

[@andromedaellis9718]

Vivi should get more lines

[@user-seuliha]

2:42 김립 희진 이브 츄 진솔....... 장난없구만 계속 돌려보네 멋있어

[@아잠만-l3s]

슬슬이 최애파트임 ㅠㅠ

[@user-lr9sb3nj9t]

김립 목소리 녹는다 녹아....

[@Freethem-h8i]

소름 역시 제일 눈에 뛴다 생각했던 애들이있네

[@db4119]

ㅁㅊ..소름...내가 이 그룹 처음 봤을때 그 5명만 눈에 띄었었는데..

[@Sanas_Shy_Language]

Everyone is out here talking about how sad Vivi looks, but Yeojin looks sad too...

[@s_a_l_v_a4]

At 1:42 she looked happy

[@Sanas_Shy_Language]

salva well yeah, she has a direct shot. When she doesn’t, she just kinda looks sad...

[@yourlocaljeongyeonstan4419]

both my biases.......

[@n4ttyyy]

now yall just making shit up yeojin looked perfectly fine

[@zoepeluffo6253]

salva when they focus her she acts happy like vivi, they both look uncomfortable

[@tsmks]

If anyone from BBC is reading this, we want Vivi to sing more, she's an artist, a singer, we want to hear he singing or rapping, because she does the two very well! A foreign member came and learn your language just to be part of this group, so you better treat her well, no artist deserves to sing this little in their title songs, i can't fully enjoy this comeback because of this, i barely see Vivi on the performances on top of not hearing her sing. Get your shit together BBC.

[@valavellan]

i agree 100%, i hope k-orbits are as loud about it as we are so bbc is more likely to take notice

[@MorseCodeStutters]

AMEN to that! She put a lot on the line to join the group and has had to overcome a ton of discomfort in being in a new country, barely knowing the language, and for what? Still too little lines just like in 1/3

[@user-dc2ho7rb6t]

i hope she’s the main vocalist / center for the next comeback to make up for this lmao

[@shiloh8734]

Whine whine whine. Let her label decide what to do with her. She’s under their contract. You control nothing that happens during production. And who cares if she came from another place? That isn’t a ticket or a good enough reason to give her more lines. She doesn’t deserve anything just for learning Korean. No one forced her to go, did they? You don’t know what happens behind closed doors. Maybe they know that her Korean isn’t the best so she doesn’t get a lot of lines in fear of messing up the pronunciation. Maybe her vocals aren’t as strong as the others so they’re holding her back until then. Until we know the whole story, don’t act like she deserves any handouts. She better be grateful that she’s in the group and has the opportunity. And I doubt they would have taken lines from the stronger vocals so that means another girl would have gotten cut. Is that any better?

[@user-dc2ho7rb6t]

Silo Green even if they aren’t as strong, she doesn’t deserve .3 seconds of lines. look at literally any idol who isn’t in the vocal line. sure they get less lines, but my god. give her more than one word AT LEAST. we’re asking for the BARE MINIMUM. this is her JOB. where screen time and lines are more important than anything. she isn’t getting recognition therefore she’s getting lowkey scammed out of her hard work put into being an idol. if you sit back and accept that “she isn’t a good vocalist so she doesn’t deserve lines” then bbc won’t give her lines.

[@kaedeharakazuha3643]

2:43 THE BEST PART!!!

[@Kelly_nct_exo]

YEEEEES

[@justinianoy5888]

Yesss

[@l66cid]

jinsoul is insane. versatile voice, other worldly visuals, funny as hell, perfect body, and has the most adorable personality. i can’t believe i’m gonna have to settle for less and NOT marry her

[@jl-fw7jf]

she's also smart af. like legit. she placed in multiple top math rankings while in school/college

[@jadoreyou3979]

jinsoul's high note in this >>>> studio version i think they used some voice filter thing in the studio version bc that sounds nothing like her. here u can tell it definitely sounds like her

[@user-nd5lg2rj2j]

it sounds like charli taft again, which would make sense bc she works with sm as well

[@va54samsung5]

nah ure hearing taeyeon's "backing" they justcouldnt mix it better with jinsoul's dub

[@jl-fw7jf]

@@va54samsung5 twitter.com/orrery_nim/status/1226454170091151360 Here's Jinsoul confirming in the live chat that it's her in the studio. Will that be enough in shutting y'all up or will you continue in your clownery?

[@stephenbravante2692]

as much as i'm sad with miss vivi only getting almost zero lines SHE KILLED THAT 'MWO EOTTAE' PART A SASSY QUEEN INDEED

[@wiqqqp]

3:11 이부분 츄 갈라지는 듯한 목소리 미친거같다 ㅠㅠ 세상 상코미하게 생겼는데 넘 파워풀하잖아 ㅠㅠㅠ!!

[@solbi134]

ㅇㅈ 와 소름이다..

[@이시간에-e4r]

이거 다 후보정임 ㅋㅋ 현장에서 못들어줄뻔했음

[@이름-s2b]

@@이시간에-e4r 그걸 어케 알아요?

[@성이름-q2x7t]

@두부다현 자기 최애프사달고 이러고 싶을까? ㅉㅉ

[@user-cx7cm9nb4n]

1:14 ...?

[@nj2929]

라이브 개잘한다 진짜 음원보다 이게 더 좋음..미친듯

[@zooted6761]

I feel so bad for ViVi, she’s sitting there all sad because she only has 3 seconds of lines. I bet she justs wants to get up and leave 🙁

[@pixcea]

it wouldve been nice if she had 3 seconds of lines, her lines all together are literally 1 second + one line she shares with hyunjin

[@stephwishesyouwerehere]

Yeah and I love Chuu but why did she take Vivi's "Hey" ;-; 1:07

[@zooted6761]

Wish You Were Here right!!

[@zooted6761]

秋山歩美さん right and then the 1 second of lines was her saying “hey”

[@stephwishesyouwerehere]

@@zooted6761 yeah ;_; maybe I should blame the camera person instead for not showing Vivi because you could hear Vivi and Chuu say the line

[@WENderland_]

"I'm so bad". Chuu: look how cute I am. . BBC Stop being an idiot and give ViVi lines.

[@luminousmiu]

#JusticeForViVi

[@aphoetic]

@@lovelykirby exactly my thoughts. Thank you for saying it out loud.

[@venusyang8711]

꧁m꧂ ok but hyunjin has a very soft voice, but she still got lines and slayed in this cb. Chuu is always smiling and cute and yet shes front line in dances and lines. I honestly doubt the robot thing, we havent seen anything referencing her robot thing in a long time as far as i know. i get that it might have smthn to do with lore but if bbc consistently does this, whats vivi gonna do when loona eventually disbands? Idols get attention by screentime, and vivi gets none.

[@StarShade0]

Venus Yang You also have to consider that Hyunjin has a lot more stamina. She’s more stable on stage than Vivi, which allows her to sing parts in a stronger tone without running out of breath (all the while dancing on stage). Unfortunately, Vivi isn’t as capable of that, which is why she doesn’t have a prominent role in the song.

[@Marimo974]

@@lovelykirby What you said about the producers might be true, I haven't thought about that. But the other part is less probable xD didn't they throw away the loonaverse when Jaden left? Loona will have tons of comeback, maybe, but we don't know if Vivi will still be in the group ;-; I think about Linlin from cherry bullet (who reminds me of Vivi a lot) or JinE of Ohmygirl, there are multiple reasons to leave a group and it can happen anytime, looking at Haseul, I dearly hope she will get better and comeback.

[@andromedaellis9718]

When vivi said 뭐 어때 I felt that 2:36

[@ultimateweedsmoker4144]

Justice for Vivi 😭😭

[@옙-i7g]

다들 미모 무슨 일이야 정말 난 언니들 보면 수명이 증가하는 기분이야 이달소 사랑해 난 옹알이도 이달소로 시작했다 ㅇ... 이...... ㅇ...ㅣ 이달소 사랑해

[@pakiraju786]

I usually don’t complain about line distributions, because not everyone is meant to be a vocalist but when the THREE title tracks, one barely has any lines, there is a problem

[@rainshipley9802]

the thing is her role is a vocalist yet she gets thrown "hey" mo ottea" (sorry I can't spell it right) "because I'm special" and I can't even remember what line she had for butterfly. literally orbits flip their crap when she gets center time in a bside and just repeats "i go" the whole time

[@rashmipatel1205]

Olivia Shipley “hey!” “eottae seo so what!” “nan teukbyeolhanikka” “idaero” “fly like a butterfly” like wtf is that and in hi high haseul didn’t EVEN REACH 1 SECOND LIKE BLOCKBERRY WHAT IN THE NAME OF MICHELLE OBAMA ONE “eottokae” IS NOT ENOUGH ESPECIALLY FOR A MAIN VOCALIST. VIVI AND YEOJIN ALSO GET LIKE 2 SECONDS AT THE MAX AND I WILL NEVER FORGET HOW HASEUL OMLY GOT 0.7 LINES IN HI HIGH

[@penguinhammer420]

Loona doesn't actually have any set positions aside from leader and maknae. If BBC's claim of no fixed positions was true, the same girls wouldn't be in the spotlight every comeback.

[@rafellino9137]

@@penguinhammer420 fact✨✨

[@karinano1stan]

@@rainshipley9802 'Hey!' 'mweo eottae' and a 'Take that, So What?!' which was a shared line bbc is so disgusting it's sad

[@slay3965]

vivi already has no lines and then they didnt show her during her little "hey" they showed yeojin during hers but why not vivi? EDIT: i will NOT stand for this vivi slander under my comment, if you have something negative to say, just leave.

[@winniemeeniemineymoe]

the first hey is from vivi, the last is from yeojin:(

[@nekop6447]

Colin Williams vivi didn’t even get to sing her first “hey!” cause chuu sang it

[@Marimo974]

@@nekop6447 Vivi sang it but they simply kept filming Chuu ;-;

[@NatWarrior1]

It's cause Chuu kept singing it 😭

[@haveueverfeltcosmoinsideyo1006]

The first Hey is from ViVi the second from Yeo Jin and the last one from Olivia Hye

[@sue4805]

3:16 replay button for jinsouls high note, you're welcome

[@Bapthard]

1:47 Can We Just Talk About Jinsoulie's face ? Like LMAO SHE POPPED LIKE THAT ON MY SCREEN I BLBLBLBLBL

[@kimr.4619]

JINGOLAS BEING JINGOLAS 🤣❤️

[@Random1nations]

I thought she was gonna punch a hole on the tambourine LOL

[@giginsomnia]

3:12 CHUU'S VOICE I'M- HDKSMNDBJSHSBS THAT WAS SO CUTE

[@nakoringtheproudorbit6412]

Dolphin

[@jungwoosolo]

chuuriah carey ❤

[@은지-d6g]

헐 찐라이브?????? 너무너무 잘하는데 ㅠㅠ 이달소 신곡 너무너무 좋으니까 꼭 1위 했으면 좋겠다 ㅠㅠ 코로나 조심하고 건강하게 활동했으면 🥰😁✊💕

[@AdilKhan-uq2nm]

Jinsoul's vocals are NO joke. She's usually a rapper, and hitting those notes despite it not being your greatest strength is just AMAZING!! *Jinsoul world domination*

[@Denis-up9gh]

Oh damn the song is so good but i feel bad for vivi, she literally left her modelling carreer in china to persue her dream of becoming a kpop idol, moved to south korea, trained for an entire year, was added to the group, and she barely gets lines. She had literally a couple of seconds and in this video she looks quiet compared to the others and i hope she’s ok 🦌💗

[@Shadowboost]

She just needs Haseul there.

[@nyomancantikapelangi7729]

@@Shadowboost where is haseul?

[@Shadowboost]

@@nyomancantikapelangi7729 she's taking a break for her anxiety that was diagnosed recently

[@user-dq2fi8uy4v]

김립목소리 너무 맑음... 너무 예쁨..ㅜㅜ

[@catalinareveco4486]

I'm not a fan, but I became obsessed with Butterfly last year, and still could notice the "tiny girl" (Vivi) didn't get any lines in this comeback...

[@brooke5957]

Catalina Reveco in butterfly vivi actually got a bit more than yeojin. it was hard to tell but the line distribution for butterfly was actually okay with vivi getting ~ 8.5 seconds. of course she deserves a lot better , and this comeback was especially disappointing how little time she got to shine. but i’m still trying to believe that bbc will give her her era , like hyunjin got hers this time around !!

[@Frankie-tf6xo]

Catalina Reveco the tiny girl is actually Yeojin 😁

[@catalinareveco4486]

@@Frankie-tf6xo I didn't said the tiniest, it's just how I used to refer to Vivi before knowing the names

[@reinventlove1866]

Kim Lip's vocals are so pretty. I'd never shut up if I sounded like that.

[@swishbish4525]

Same honestly. I like her vocal colour the best

[@nihi6817]

yes her voice sounds so sweet

[@hvezdicky]

im so sad for vivi, shes just sitting here :(

[@hvezdicky]

@@AggressiveAegyo youre right, its just kinda sad i think shes more talented than just for 'sit and watch' but ive got your point, still the song is bop!! all girls in loona are so talented and im happy for them

[@horizonkyun7203]

LordDesAbsterdens thats really not true. there are plenty of groups with way more members that have decent line distribution

[@cokolada6039]

Wait who is vivi? I still don't know who is who..

[@ilsanboi3963]

cazZo this is vivi 🥺❤️ 1:18

[@cokolada6039]

@@ilsanboi3963 aww she is so precious🥺

[@goon576]

Imagine watching everyone singing and you have to awkwardly sit there doing nothing the entire time. 😔#givevivimorelines

[@luciejohnson4081]

Homegirl was just chilling tapping on those bangos🥺

[@idkbruh1250]

@@luciejohnson4081 🥺🥺🥺🥺

[@ValeLQ]

She was singing too (?

[@luminousmiu]

@@ValeLQ No.

[@goon576]

Valentina Landeros not really she looks left out

[@thefastones]

Choerry is that kind of classmate: that when there is a school fire, she still checks if her classmates left the room clean and that every chair and table are line up

[@renren7187]

2:50 is no one gonna talk how yves sounds like her voice in the real mv

[@Raeignmcnair]

ate the cd

[@misviamethystlinzy8484]

Yes, mami Yves❣️

[@lunasssss]

and at 2:10

[@johnronaldbuena2252]

teh bat moko inunfriend

[@iwanttobetiktokfamous4217]

Confirmed, they eat cds.

[@ovoojaverandtheywereroomma6409]

They eat the album period't

[@cocazade7703]

fOR BREAKFAST

[@lalola5cc]

It's pre-recorded 😭

[@iwanttobetiktokfamous4217]

Lara Colobo they still eat cds idc idc

[@js-tl1ip]

Lara Colobo no it’s not 😭

[@rxbs6465]

ViVi sweetie I’m so sorry. I hope that she’ll get more lines in the next combeback. She has a sweet and beautiful voice, she’s amazing... and she doesn’t deserve this treatment for sure

[@188Cmon]

전세계의 인류애 상실을 막기위해선 이브언니 거지존 중단발이 대책이다 .평생하세요 영원히 하세요 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ언니 신ㅣ이약ㄱ! ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@yujutrashy1552]

1:07 Chuu isn’t actually actually saying Hey, ViVi is but they continue to film Chuu. ViVi looks so sad :(

[@andromedaellis9718]

😭

[@finger_me_hard_daddy]

😭

[@staychaerin1346]

😭

[@modelstatus3456]

😭

[@mama_penguin567]

😭

[@yeribffie4844]

they sound SO much like the studio version they’re such amazing vocalists omg

[@EditsbyM]

that's because there's clearly a lot of post-processing being done here.

[@mimasroom]

@@EditsbyM it's mainly just canceling the noise around them which is why you barely hear the bg noise and instrument but they're still well trained and they've proven it over and over again

[@nightinez969]

@@EditsbyM no

[@ZSunder]

@@mimasroom somy their voices were pre-recorded, you can see Heejin not moving her lips at 1:14 and 3:49

[@Bubbleee]

@@ZSunder Anna ou

[@감자탕-d7y]

이정도 라이브면 걸그룹중에 탑아닌가

[@Hong_nabok]

1:03 짧은 한소절인데도 목소리에 에너지? 느껴져서 너무좋네요 놀람,,

[@vepm]

Jinsoul goes jinsoul minaj to jinsoul carey...

[@pjtauti4858]

Ohmygod..... I love you for this🤣🤣

[@eyadane]

my heart rlly breaks for vivi. bbc really hyped her up during the pre-comeback promotions like in the not today cover and the teasers but when it's finally comeback time she only gets like barely 2 lines and barely enough screentime. i can't believe they've been doing her so dirty since the start of time. vivi deserves better. she's just as talented as the rest of our girls and she shouldn't be shoved in the back.

[@스왈로-q8w]

라이브 개잘해ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 깜짝놀라씀... 그리고 김립 음색 진짜 미쳤다

[@PhC1234]

립싱크에요... 저도 속았음 03:49 희진 파트인데 안함

[@김도연-w5o]

이걸 라이브로 하네?ㅋㅋㅋ 대박신기하다 처음 음원듣고 힘들줄알았는데

[@yves4428]

i'm so sad for vivi, yeojin, and gowon. look at them being all sad and bored while the other members are literally singing their hearts out :( they don't deserve this kind of treatment bbc, fix this. i know that they aren't the best vocalists or rappers of the group, thus they receive less lines, but we all know what they are capable of and that they are more capable than what we are seeing here, especially vivi. vivi literally went from singing a whole song in korean for more than 3 minutes to having 3 seconds of lines, yet all of you say that it's because she isn't very good in speaking korean. she literally has a whole korean song that she sang herself :( yeojin and gowon also, they are such good and decent vocalists and rappers yet they're treated as if they're going to ruin the whole song if they sing more than 5 seconds :( look at yeojin 1:25 3:14 3:26 3:34 look at vivi 1:17 1:29 3:18 3:38 look at gowon 1:06 1:09 3:41

[@hyunjinssoul2354]

The chanting lines could've easily be given to Yeojin and Vivi. I can even see Gowon rap Chuu's line. My god I would literally get a job in BBC if it means giving lines to Vivi, Yeojin and Gowon😩

[@jessicacroft7183]

@@hyunjinssoul2354 PLEASE FR THO why make a group of 12 members if u cant treat them farelyyy

[@agorahills.]

3:18 Vivi hit hard. :(

[@milkeyway7105]

3:00 yes yes you can kill me jinsoul

[@Gunes-ve-Han-SoHee]

milkey way she killed me already

[@marian3079]

Did anyone notice how Hyunjin let Vivi sing that part alone? At 3:42

[@seulgiplssteponme2617]

aweeeee 🥺🥺🥺🥺

[@juli3836]

she noticed vivi was sad :(

[@Niziu.Delilah]

she looked so much happier! OMGG

[@Unknownlyunknown]

Awwwww im crying!!. Ty HYUJINIEE

[@bluhbluhbluh3542]

Kind Aeong 🥺 My tiny Hyunvi heart

[@emmaontoast]

Chuu took Vivi’s “hey!” because was so short...

[@danani2711]

emma this is so sad.

[@bickbalsy]

I think Vivi is just too sweet and doesn't have any 'bad' in her, so she's unable to sing this song.

[@emmaontoast]

ballsy No, the reason she has no lines isn’t because of the lore. BBC have always given her the scraps and I’m sick of it.

[@spongebobsquirtpants]

ballsy pretty sure the only reason why she didn’t get many lines is because this song was produced with someone from sm, sm is known to give their foreigners less lines, and since vivi is from hong kong, she automatically got less lines in this title track sadly :(

[@jammm2113]

j i feel like it’s the case. BBC did give a relatively fair line distribution for Butterfly, why would they suddenly retract themselves from a good point when all we’ve done was praising them for it ?

[@victoriacruz6853]

3:16 OMG JINSOUL IS PERFECT

[@user-gw7bp3zx6m]

뮤비에서 그렇게 멋진게 김립언니구나...근데 희진은 왜 랩도 잘함?? 톤 제일 찰짐 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅅㅂ 근데 이브언니 사랑해..ㅠㅠㅠ 진솔 톤 이번 곡이랑 넘 잘어울림 카랑카랑??

[@yeout_cookie4484]

*Jinsoul said she's the main vocal and im here for it.*

[@seokjinsbuns7684]

We all know how talented Vivi is so this is a bit disappointing how she has no lines :(

[@louisarose7748]

She might not have the strongest voice but her vocal tone is gorgeous. Just listen to "where you at" she deserves so much more

[@hafu5599]

is vivi the third girl who's sitting in the middle??

[@louisarose7748]

@@hafu5599 Vivi is at 1:18

[@ArtisticMusicRebel]

2:44 to 3:00 their voices are incredible. Loona said no to lip syncing

[@annellej]

They actually lip syncing in this video

[@ArtisticMusicRebel]

@@annellej I don’t believe that, they’re all really good singers 💕

[@karolinacater6295]

I swear if I see one more idiot looking for excuses... Vivi didn't come all the way to Korea and faced hard times (learning the language and so on) just to be treated like this. No one is blaming the girls btw. I love all the members *but obviously Vivi deserves more* she's not just a pretty face she's actually talented. How can she shine with 0.00001 seconds of lines? I though now when Haseul is recovering Vivi might get to shine this time because with teasers they kinda Vivi-baited us. Lots of us thought this is Vivi era where she will be able to shine. Again, I love all the girls but Vivi deserves more and I hope BBC will notice that as well. I wonder what's Vivi's true feelings about this shitty line distrubution. Sure in a group with 12 members you can't get fair lines. But what she gets is just... crazy... she gets so little lines like they think she can't sing. When she actually can.

[@hoahaukathy]

OMG SAY IT LOUDER TO BBC

[@Queenaisofpop]

It wouldn’t have changed anything if Haseul wasn’t in the comeback anyway since girlie doesn’t get lines either

[@someasiankid6323]

YESS and she got some lines in the other songs of the cb

[@user-nd5lg2rj2j]

Naïs R. haseul does get lines but ok

[@owo9173]

Yes, BBC debuted her as a solist (like all the other), bc she CAN be a soloist. They told us every girl has the ABILITY to be a soloist. So why Vivi doesn't get lines??!!! I mean, if you will give her no lines and no way to shine, WHY did you debuted her? I love Vivi, but this is just ruining her carrier, when Loona disbants who will remember Vivi if this stills happens, just Vivi stans, I can see in a future some "orbits" saying she's just for filling. This is so unfare for her and the ones that love her.

[@김일개-l6b]

와 완전 씨디 삼켯네.............. 라이브 오ㅑ케 잘해요 사랑해 ,,,.,,,.,,,,,,,,,

[@ifancyyou913]

Vivi looked so bored. She was playing with the drums all the time

[@Chamotmot]

She has no lines :(

[@szalogist]

2:37 😔😔

[@siyeonsdoormat9826]

Bruh what else is she supposed to do other than playing them bongo, girly was given almost no lines😔 BBC better get their shit together and give Vivi more lines in the next comeback

[@juli3836]

she had nothing else to do but play with the drums :(

[@juli3836]

she had nothing else to do but play with the drums :(

[@wave2me]

일 년이나 됐네 다시 봐도 진짜 라이브 잘한다

[@user-Wz61mg2pb]

무대위에서 표정만 봤지 자세히 보는건 처음인데 김립이라는사람 그 여유있는 표정 개멋있다....

[@mato6058]

no one: jinsoul when she sings: >:(

[@raymondvargas6133]

Things I notice in this vid: -Kim Lip has a beautiful tone -Heejin, Chuu and Yves singing perfectly their hard pre chorus part -Hyunjin and Choerrt improving her vocals -The girls trying to act cute with a baddie song -LOONA CAN SING AND HARMONIZE PERFECTLY

[@feliciaa1087]

They didn't sing it perfectly though. Chuu was straining a bit. Heejin sang more softly and with less power than in the studio version, she might've done that to not be so loud though, but she wasn't straining. Yves was straining a bit on the highest part but not much, also not as much power as the studio version but more than Heejin. I personally think Heejin did it the best here

[@raymondvargas6133]

Felicia A Chuu has more high parts than the other, that’s why she strain a little

[@zhasyane]

Jinsoul's highnote....

[@_hkwd_802]

You should notice that when VIVI singing “HEY” the camera is not focusing on her...

[@Marimo974]

@@_hkwd_802 No it's normal since she's kind of insivible due to her poor lines 🤷‍♀️ her "hey" was so short that we didn't even got the time to see her!

[@user-ew5wf4tb2b]

내가 들을수 있다는거에 평생 제일 감사한 듯

[@tdo6871]

라이브가 맞나...? 너무 잘해서 아닌 것 같네 힘 빼고 불러도 고음이 되는 것인가 진솔이 라이브 잘한다 풀뱅 검정 머리 잘 어울림😎👍

[@celinebeanie]

LOONA EAT CDS

[@숭-h1o]

립 목소리 너무 예쁜 거 아니야 .....??

[@nyodager6916]

i'm not a fan of them, but there were two girls that looked to bored bc they didn't sing anything, so unfair and sad for them

[@assa7425]

nyodager x I think you were talking about Vivi, go won or yeojin. Because none of them got enough lines. Especially Vivi. So I think you mean Vivi and go won or yeojin D: it’s unfair for bbc to do that. What is going on over there??

[@kimslotion2486]

nyodager x you are talking about the girl that just says a exclamation and one line?

[@johaseul4538]

@@assa7425 yeojin got time to shine, idk why ppl are making fuss about her lines. she got a lot of screentime during the first chorus on the mv and got much more lines than vivi and gowon.

[@yunaz7977]

ana luiza yeojin has had history of not getting lines; she was excluded from her subunit and gets no screen time. gowon gets more than yeojin.

[@stanitzylol]

Vivi Gowon Yeojin Are treated so bad. That y they said I'M SO BAD at the intro

[@user-dt3nx5es9w]

츄는진짜 노래도잘하고 얼굴도이쁘고 끼도넘치네

[@candee1558]

yeojin is literally the cutest human being in the world

[@mesha4823]

and people were trying to say that one adlib wasnt jinsoul...giving credit to a white woman. y’all better stop playing with loona’s vocals.

[@houstonscott4362]

Mesha exactly! Loona have shown that they have top notch vocal capabilities EASILY. In fact, they’re one of the best in the generation.

[@jadoreyou3979]

@X1 Hangyul yeah thats what i was thinking...

[@theetaurus1832]

Houston Scott you’re saying it like the Asian community don’t be stealing from others, especially the black communities 😩😩😩😩😩😩😩😩

[@houstonscott4362]

Rebelbear57 what does this have to do with my comment? People were saying that the note JinSoul sang wasn’t her. She proved it was. I’M SAYING that Loona has capable vocalists easily and some of the best of their generation. They’re a top notch group. Has nothing to do with black or white people. 😑

[@farishmzn]

@@theetaurus1832 totally not the right comment section for this

[@얍얍이다]

사전녹음 같긴한데 그래도 엄청 잘부르고 반주 작게 깔린게 음색 더 잘 드러나서 좋다ㅠ 김립이랑 진솔 음색이 더 돋보이네 희진이랑 츄도 되게 탄탄하게 잘부름

[@honeymadeinkorea]

저거 생라이브 맞습니다.

[@shiela_kat]

JINSOUL SLAYING HER HIGH NOTE 😭😍

[@nandytogbf2369]

Vivi: ok my part is coming, i gotta be prepared to shout "Hey!" Chuu: *korean korean* hey! Vivi: H- ok, i'll just keep playing whatever instrument i have with me until my mwo eottae line 😒

[@richardmatthew7901]

korean korean

[@luminousmiu]

When exactly is that???

[@luminousmiu]

@Béatrice Bordeleau oh gosh thanks

[@WenderllyAraujoS]

I'm pretty sure chuu doesn't shout hey, it's just they didn't caught vivi on camera doing it

[@queenie4859]

Why camera never focused on Jinsoul's high note at 3:30

[@haniii05]

Yea i work so hard to notice who singing the part and its Jinsoul unnie...🤣🤣🤣

[@grazi3749]

I think it's because she's not singing ...

[@juliennengabisdak4038]

@@grazi3749 She's singing. Someone filtered this and she's actually the only one singing live in this. (The vocals are pre-recorded, even though it's called Live Class.)

[@JangggouJin]

이달소 보컬 되는 멤버들 진짜 많은데ㅠㅠ 라이브가 너무 적음 이거 말고 라이브가 별로 없음 라디오도 그렇고ㅠㅠ 담 노래는 라이브 가능하고 보컬적인 부분 많이 보여줄 수 있는 곡이었음 좋겠다

[@진-n8s]

이거 진짜로 부르고있는거에요?

[@JangggouJin]

@@진-n8s 저도 AR깔고 립싱크 한줄 알았는데 메이킹 영상 보니까 라이브 하더라구요 ㄷㄷ

[@진-n8s]

@@JangggouJin 라이브였어요…?? 와.. 무ㅓㅈㅎ

[@슈크림-o1r]

@@JangggouJin 메이킹이혹시 어디있나요? 찾아봤는데없어서 무례하지만 링크달아주실수있으신가요?

[@이주희-d8v]

내가 보려고 만든 진솔🥰 0:57 1:46 2:17 2:58 3:16

[@영영-w9p]

달소 어쩜 라이브도 일케 잘하냐... 립이 씨디 삼켰나ㅠㅠ

[@김윤정-n6n]

김립 음색 최고야 너무 좋다 진짜ㅜㅜㅜㅜ

[@ufuu]

츄 이브는 원래 잘하는거 알았는데 김립님 뭐랄까 와이지 느낌 음색임 너무 좋다 ㅜ