Discussion: Innistrad remastered vs masterpiece era vs LOTR Special ed. Dollars and sense 1. Today, Innistrad remastered cards tanked and probably won’t rebound for any real money anytime soon because everyone ripped cases of product chasing Edgar and found they have too many poster cards in every box with 3 to 5 different printings of all the chase cards. 2. First ever chase cards in history. Masterpiece era, BFZ, aether, kaladesh, amonkhet, Hour of devastation cards. Most of these cards in all of these sets aren’t high value cards. Not because there aren’t good playable cards on these sets it’s just everyone heavily ripped packs chasing the masterpieces. 1, that caused all cards to run to the bottom as the market was flooded and became bulk. And there was about 30-50 absolutely beautiful masterpiece chase cards that were about 1 pulled per entire case of draft booster. Yes know it was possible to pull one in a bundle but was super rare. And for 15 years Sol ring masterpiece was the most expensive sol ring out of any would ring printed. Which is almost printed as much as evolving wilds. So if you need a sol ring for your deck you can get one for $0.25 all day long. But if you want The One golden child sol ring masterpiece you’re going to drop a paycheck, minimum. And you could open 20 cases of Kaladesh and pull 20 masterpieces and still not pull a sol ring. $$$$$$$$ ps I still think this particular card is way underpriced. but we don’t know how many truly got printed and there is no serial numbers. 3. Recent history collector era. LOTR special ed. This product had 10-15 serialized poster art with poster foils and non foils of the same version. Average price of these cards is around $150. And the collector boxes are $1300+. These boxes were a limited run, with serialized cards in them. Yes they banned one ring in modern and caused the price to go down from the $2000 high per box. And most of the serialized cards are very expensive, $1000’s of dollars per serialized card. And most of these cards are ehh, not bad, playable, good cards. Right 4. Edgar Markov? The value of Edgar has raced to the bottom because not there are 500-1000 different copies for sale online, not including what game stores have on the shelf and not counting how many are in play boosters that haven’t even been opened. So the showcase foil alternate art version is probably the best casual, affordable, playable, in deck card available to buy. And will most likely stay affordable. The question…..why is a serialized Edgar Markov, 1 of 500, Teir one CEDH commander not priced to The One Ring Serialized price?? Or higher?? This is a holy grail card!! There are not any non serialized posters foil or non foil in the set for Edgar like the one ring or Tom bombadill or Sauron. How many EDH players have or want to build an Edgar deck, casual or competitive. Now, how many cases, just on KZbin alone, how many cases upon cases of $300 collector boxes have been opened with zero serialized rainbow foiled poster Edgar’s??? So you open $8000 worth of collector boxes and you have NO serialized Edgar?? And it’s selling for $3000 on eBay??? That is INSANE!!!!! Your thoughts