LIVE - The Shia Voice Extra + | Behind the Scenes | Ep 3 | Season 2 | Q & A

The Shia Voice Extra + | Episode 2 | Season 2 | 2023
The Shia Voice has been a success hit, and many of you see the contestants, judges, and audience enjoying the show infront of them. However, what goes on behind the scenes? Why did the judges say particular controversial lines? Were they harsh or were they in the right?
Join Minhal Al-Khafaji as he goes face to face with the judges, hosts and contestants and gets an insight for the viewers at home at the behind the scenes and digs deeper into the judges' responses.
Like, follow and subscribe to Imam Hussein TV’s official KZbin channel here: / imamhuss. .
Support Imam Hussein TV: www.imamhussein3.tv/donate
Make sure you're following Imam Hussein TV for all the latest.
Facebook: / imamhusseintv3
Twitter: / imamhusseintv3
Instagram: / imamhusseintv3
KZbin: / imamhussein3tv
Website: imamhussein3.tv
Telegram: t.me/imamhusseintv3
WhatsApp: wa.me/447939917163
Watch IHTV3 using the following methods:
• Sky channel 789
• Website: imamhussein3.tv/live
• Android & iOS App: onelink.to/ihtv
• KZbin: / imamhuss. .
• Download on Smart TV's: Samsung TV, LG TV & Android TV
• Also on: Apple TV, RoKu, Amazon Fire & CTV
Imam Hussein TV 1 (Persian) : bit.ly/2zcmtCv
Imam Hussein TV 2 (Arabic) : bit.ly/2TwiXvk
Imam Hussein TV 3 (English) : bit.ly/2vfClRT
Imam Hussein TV 4 (Urdu) : bit.ly/2DvXrRH
AlZahra (Turkish): bit.ly/2ORtYnl
Morning Baraka: bit.ly/2OvrN9Z

[@mehdialjaishi7892]

Mohamed reda’s performance was truly mesmerizing

[@fatemaalasadi1739]

Mohammed Reda should have made it he wrote his own Noha and created his melody that’s what you call creativity I thought that’s what the show was about?

[@ahmedelbahja6301]

Mohammed Reda should 100% be in the final.

[@rani1835]

I’m actually in disbelief that Mohammed Redha didn’t make it to the final. Masha Allah, he’s the whole package. So disappointed. Insha Allah he’ll continue on this blessed path and be granted success in both worlds 🤲🏽

[@ibrahimkhorasani3185]

What a shame. He was way better than those who were voted to the finals.

[@schoenbrunn1]

They needed someone from the Pakistani Coummunity to motivate the Pakistani brothers/sisters for the next season. The same thing happened with Mehdi from Germany. Personally, I didn't like him so well. But he's from Afghanistan. That's just a thought from me.

[@haidermawji1928]

The 3 choices according to me, 1. Mulla Eisa or Firas al Ameeri Karbalai 2. Mohammed Reda Modaffar 3. Hussein Taft

[@rani1835]

All three were outstanding. This is such a shame.

[@HasanainElesa]

Mohammed Reda killed it absolute nonsense honestly

[@Utility12]

Mohamed Reda almodhafar really got robbed the judgmental was so not fair they did not look at his talent and what he has. He is the one who comes up with the melody’s of his qasaid especially at a young age there is no one who was born in the USA that has the courage to raise his voice and give so much of his time for khidmat aba abdullah عليه السلام

[@couger6410]

Mohammed Reda deserves to make it to the finals.

[@fatimaalmodaffer]

Mulla Mohammed Reda Al Modhafar الله يعلي شانك دنيا و آخره {وَعَسَى أَنْ تَكْرَهُوا شَيْئًا وَهُوَ خَيْرٌ لَكُمْ وَعَسَى أَنْ تُحِبُّوا شَيْئًا وَهُوَ شَرٌّ لَكُمْ وَاللَّهُ يَعْلَمُ وَأَنْتُمْ لَا تَعْلَمُونَ}

[@schoenbrunn1]

Sheikh Mullah Issa Ali is the best 🥰🤩

[@MuhibAli110]

Alamdar Moosavi is deserving of the finals. He recited beautifully on his first chance and didn't need another.

[@user-kw3zo3uy4s]

Yeah I agree Mohammed Redah was robbed

[@tker3313]

Mohammed Reda not making it on judges vote is pretty disappointing. The rationale provided by the judges as well as an impartial comparison of both performances make me doubt the judges were choosing on performance alone, instead of pushing a female candidate to the final. The kid deserved better

[@ibrahimkhorasani3185]

Facts. They did him dirty.

[@ali84uk]

Ignore all the negative comments, mashallah well done.

[@ZahraH.-su6cb]

Guys everyone who wants to criticize let there criticisim be contructive and respectful. After all these judges are experts and they want the best for the compatitors. So there judgement is based on performance only not anything else...

[@tahirraza1301]

What time did they announce the results

[@RyuFan1999]

What did he recite at 58:34? If anyone can tell me that would be much appreciated, it's hard to find just from those words

[@mj24410]

Really thought Abu taleb would make it😢❤

[@MohammadRaza-sd8yo]

Unfair

[@MAHDI-vz8pr]

mohammed ridha got absolutely robbed walla so unfair

[@couger6410]

Robbery on national tv

[@Wafflesssss11]

Robbery

[@ibrahimkhorasani3185]

Robbery on live Television

[@mirhussain3266]

Very unfair wildcard choice. Decision should be made on the basis of merit rather than ticking the gender representation box. Mohammed Reda, Hussain Taft and Mula Eisa were atleast 3 options that would have been better choices.

[@Maha-qf2dg]

And who told you it is gender based!?!?! Salma's performance was absolutey phenomenal. She got very high grades from the judges. Actually it would be unfair if we don't see someone like her in the finals for the amazing lectures she gives.

[@ibrahimkhorasani3185]

@@Maha-qf2dg We all know that she has zero chances to compete against the likes of Ali Zuhairi in the finals. We all know that Ali Zuhairi will most likely win the competition. So why not picking one who has actually good chances to compete against him, e.g. his pupil Reda? The wildcard choice was obviously not based on talent. Sorry to say.

[@Maha-qf2dg]

@@ibrahimkhorasani3185 It seems that you are the only one that thinks that she has zero chances to win. The judges are experts more than you and me so their decision is of course not biased. It is sister Salama's talent in lecturing that made them choose her. There were other females in previous episodes but they didn't win and I think this is a strong evidence that supports what I am saying. For Ali Zuhairi no one can say that he's not a strong contestant but to be fair you can't compare someone that does lecturing and someone that does latmiyat. Sorry to say that but it seems a lot of people are objecting on choosing Salma just because she is a girl.

[@ibrahimkhorasani3185]

@@Maha-qf2dg It seems you are biased towards her because you are a woman. Let your emotions aside. I am not a hater but a rational individual. Rationally speaking, she was not the right choice for the wildcard. I am entitled to my opinion. The judges may have their reasons but I cannot see the aspect talent in to have been taking into account in their choice. I hope for the best for Selma. Her sunni shia lecture was mehh but maybe she will prove wrong in the finals. Cheers.

[@Maha-qf2dg]

​@@ibrahimkhorasani3185 I am rational too. Whoever was in her place(male) I will have the Same opinion. If you're not convinced with her audition then that doesn't apply that she didn't do great. And inshallah she'll do grea in the final too.

[@muhammadjawadraza2825]

Narae Haidri by syed Aamar Ya Ali is very joyous for audience and when any pakistani is come on the stage and says Ya Ali madad then syed aamar is not showing any respond even then Mula nazar alqatri syed jalal why?

[@ibrahimkhorasani3185]

Because ya ali madad was invented by the ghulaat to lead muslims to shirk and iftiraa

[@user-wl9ci8wl8z]

كنت اتوقع ان يكون تشجيع الشباب الذين نشأوا في بلاد الغرب من الموسسات الاسلامية ولم اكن اتوقع ان تكون هناك عنصرية لبعض الاشخاص بسبب المصالح الشخصية والفئوية على حساب الكفائة وحسن الاداء ما شاهدناه على عدم صعود المبدع الرادود خادم الحسين محمد رضا المظفر شيء مخزي لهذه الموسسات واصبحنا نضع ملايين الاستفهامات على من يديرها وكيف تدار ومن المستفيد منها وعلى حساب منّ؟؟؟؟

[@ZahraH.-su6cb]

لم يكن هناك عنصرية أو فئوية فتقييم الحكام كان حصرا من خلال الأداء و الجميع تقريبا في هذه الحلقة كان ادائه جيدا و لكن يبقى هناك من هو أفضل من الأخر لو بقليل .

[@R-ty4mo]

Hate to say it but when the majority of viewers are from the indo-pak community they will vote for their fellow countrymen regardless of talent( same as last year). No clue how redha mudhafar didn’t make it as a wild card at least…

[@angelofdeath7739]

I dislike hindi/urdu latmiya/noha they all sound the same

[@relax_asmrnoises]

wallah bro i m from pak but i literally voted for one contestant from pakistan only i swear, and yes for the last semi final i voted for Alamdaar because his recitation was phenomenal. i know you may disagree but wallah other than that i voted for hussain taft and abu talib. for me they were shining stars. i swear i always vote for talent disregarding bias

[@ibrahimkhorasani3185]

@@angelofdeath7739 to me urdu nohas sounds like songs from bollywood movies (no offense)

[@ibrahimkhorasani3185]

They did my man reda dirty

[@ZahraH.-su6cb]

​@@angelofdeath7739 its natural cause you don't know the language. isn't that right?

[@husseinyassine6214]

Mohammed Reda robbed

[@Utility12]

I can’t believe these men who claim themselves as the doing khidma for Allah swt going out there and expecting a women to stand in front of thousands and maybe millions of people who are also men and expect her to give a lecture and put herself out there. Where is the شرف of these who claim themselves as Shia men who are serving a Shia community; the household of the prophet peace be upon them didn’t allow the men to see the shadows of the women of their holy household. Imagine these men here who are serving in the name of ahlulbayt are allowing a women to stand in front of thousands of men speaking and giving a lecture

[@tinalang34]

What about Hazrate Fatima and Zainab binte Ali in Shaam in the court of Yazid?

[@Utility12]

@@tinalang34 don’t start comparing between these two different situations when sayeda Zainab peace be upon her went in the court of yazid may Allah curse him she had a message to deliver. She peace upon her was carrying the message of her beloved brother and took over after his martyr.

[@Maha-qf2dg]

I just want to understand what is the problem!!! She wears proper hijab and she gives a proper amazing lecture. She's not singing or doing unappropriate things. But it is your minds that are sick. You are not able to differentiate between halal and haram. Just give me the name of one marjaa that says this is haram. And I am sure that you'll not be able to do it.

[@sarasaske]

Shame you call yourselves Shia and servants of the Ahlulbait or Ammar thinks he is so knowing but all of you haven't understood Islam even remotely. How can you talk well putting a woman in front of millions of men, don't you know what the Ahlulbait as said about the woman, how she should be, what were the women of the Ahlulbait as like? You even present her by choosing her, besides that her aqida is rubbish and she didn't even understand the teachings of Ahlulbait as.

[@piratekingzoro7386]

So what happens when she’s in the street ? Don’t people see her too? She was wearing proper abaya so stop acting holier than thou

[@ZahraH.-su6cb]

First, its sayed ammar,(please show some respect dear). Second, what she was doing is not even haram non of the marajaa (scholars )prohibit a female from giving lectures when she is wearing a proper hijab. Ahlulbait teach us to be modest but at the same time to voice our opinion and that is exactly what Salma did .