PARFUMS DE MARLY CARLISLE VS MANCERA RED TOBACCO

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

💥💥💥 Watch Top 10 Parfums De Marly Fragrances here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/rmfTppl8fMdsZ8U 💥💥💥

[@badrs3473]

Can you make a Top 10 Mancera Fragrances?? Thanks.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Hopefully soon yes!!!😄

[@badrs3473]

@@ThePerfumeGuy thaank youu!!!

[@elijahray9792]

Which of the three do you prefer? Sebastian

[@saxonmichaelopare4804]

Tiziana Terenzi has created their version of Carlisle called "Arrakis".Very smooth and almost 95% to PD Carlisle. Check it up

[@CoolDude-tz5co]

In the current age of reformulations, Mancera deserves great praise for producing such strong performance across their range, with red tobacco being a great example. Personally, I don't subscribe to the philosophy of constantly having to reapply weak fragrances - life is far too short for this type of nonsense. I can kinda forgive the cheapie brands like Zara, but the dearer designer brands have no excuse and I think we should collectively avoid buying overpriced watery offerings.

[@armenkaprelian]

Performance at the price of extreme synthetic smell. I prefer a balance

[@finalelement1]

💯💯💯💯

[@summerforever6736]

Agree with you about prices and all

[@imnotlarry]

red tobacco was reformulated tho.

[@shermin62]

Still its the beast@@imnotlarry

[@RohamBroccoli]

RT is the most intense perfume I have ever smelled. Startes as a chemical explosion similar to Chernobyl. Super duper uncomfortable opening. Do not think of using it in a small rooms meetings nor on car trips. It calms down a bit after half an hour/ One hour and turns into a kind of vanilla-tobacco heaven but still sharp and can cut through any kind of cold weather and keep every eskimo warm throughout the winter. Everyone is going to smell you, it's inevitable. do not spray more than 2, I would say 1 holds plenty. Spray far away from the face / nose, otherwise everything you smell for 24 hours is RT. You do NOT need 120Ml of it. I will probably pass my 120ML on to my children and they will probably pass it on to their children. Do not spray this in summer/spring. Only the coldest winter. Preferably 15 minus degrees.

[@chrisjackson8042]

Roham Rasai 😂😂😂

[@RohamBroccoli]

Chris Jackson 🤣🤣

[@vinayk9712]

😂😂

[@jokosantoso7742]

Dramatize

[@owenchukunda4186]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@justaddlight]

A very good comparison! Much prefer Carlisle myself, but RT will probably get you more attention from extraterrestrials. Because you can smell that stuff from SPACE.

[@atilaszlo8288]

😂😂😂

[@aamannadal7419]

Even the recent formula??

[@saxonmichaelopare4804]

I agree with you.For attention seekers go for RT as I own both PD and RT.

[@GlamorousBeauty1477]

@@aamannadal7419 yes rt is huge I absolutely love it, you are definitely introduced with your fragrance before you ever enter!! It's amazing the only fragrance I've ever had to be a true beast besides Black Aoud from Montale and rt is still way more projection. It smells amazing

[@Karmaisabliss215]

Lmfao. I wore that one day and I swear i killed half the ppl everywhere I went. I was out eating lunch with my daughter and she started sniffing me. Then she waved her nose and said I stink. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@charliehascall65]

I love your reviews! Best on KZbin...hands down!

[@newluhu]

Hi, sebastian, i own a full bottle of Mancera RED TOBACCO, and i absolutely adore it, i actually blind bought it, 😊😊, i'm wearing it today, it has been 10 hours and i can still smell it. It last 24 hours on my skin, its a beast, 😳😳😳. I have a sample of Carlisle. Thanks for the video.

[@sire9930]

I bought both bottles today without knowing they smell alike. Imagine how shocked I was to smell them and discover lol. I knew someone else would have noticed and did a search that brought me here. Good review

[@MrZZooh]

I love Red Tobacco. I just got it yesterday and I can't get enough of this smell. It has a shoe polish vibe as if they put a lot of piped tobacco on expensive Oxford shoes and kept scrubbing it. Smells a lot better in the air than it does on skin. This is an alpha male frag that takes balls to wear.

[@juniorjyczh]

So true. 👍

[@yesthatsserious2263]

The alpha male part is bs. Let's just say, being handsome and wearing carlisle blows people's minds

[@carasparks8500]

Is it too much cinnamon tho? That's why I haven't bought it. I'm afraid it's just a cinnamon bomb

[@javy8229]

I think all 3 are great. But hands down Carlisle is the best!

[@gabrielgallawa8205]

Totally agree with you on Red Tobacco and Carlisle. So much so that I was disappointed when my blind bought Red Tobacco arrived as I felt it would be redundant.They aren’t clones but they are either brothers or first cousins. They don’t smell identical but are totally reminiscent of each other. Other reviewers have told me they smell nothing alike because they don’t have a super similar note breakdown, particularly when it comes to the tobacco. They trust their eyes more than their nose apparently, which doesn’t seem too bright when it comes to how fragrances smell.

[@phoebetsau9635]

Very in-depth review! I am a woman but I love to wear Carlisle on myself. I tried the Red Tobacco and they’re similar but Red Tobacco is more synthetic and screechy for me. Carlisle is much more refined like you said.

[@quique7764]

Speaking of tobacco have you done a top list video of the best tobacco frags or ones w/ tobacco in them?

[@alvinjackson9685]

Just received my Parfums de Marly Herod today. Whoa! Mancera Hindu Kush is en route. Cannot wait!

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

WOOHOO!!!

[@alvinjackson9685]

@@ThePerfumeGuy I totally forgot that I ordered Amouage Fate Man. That came yesterday. Absolutely phenomenal!

[@burhanazemi-ub5ys]

I’m happy that I watched your video I bought red tobacco , I’m so satisfied , I got some many compliment 👏

[@TeyanThuny]

Bois d’oud leaves an incredible sillage, one the most charismatic fragrance I have ever smelled.

[@doctordreday22]

I was hoping for a Carlisle and Red Tobacco comparison video. And a third... Thanks Sebastian!

[@michaelbullock8011]

Great 📹 and I enjoyed it and I like pdm Carlisle and it's a 10 out of 10 and I'm going to try the other fragrances and have a blessed day

[@apartirdelos50s32]

I am a woman 👩 and I have Red T at the beginning scared me 😅 but now I ❤ it ☺️

[@therealotitis]

Carlisle is literally my favorite scent of all time! Haven't smelled Red Tobacco, but you got me curious sir!

[@jamaalgumbs6474]

Carlisles the best

[@minibus1351]

I find Carlisle not “beast mode” as others say. It seems to stay close to skin for me.

[@EauDePomdan]

stick to carlisle.. RT is a hard frag to wear, less occation to wear to

[@jeffjamjeff6669]

Own both. Bought rt over the summer and I'm waiting for it to cool down a bit to wear it. I didn't immediately think Carlisle when I sprayed it. More Cinnamon for sure. I love Carlisle and looking forward to wearing red tobacco. I own 8 pdm and only 1 mancera

[@danwilson12]

I've noticed recently after going to my local Neimans that Tiziana Terenzi Arrakis also smells similar but with a drier dustier feel to it.

[@juniorjyczh]

I put red tobacco with bently intense. This combo is bomb

[@Vger77]

I went for mancera Thank you for the comparison

[@thespikaspikaspika]

Red tobacco is a beast and I really love it 🥰

[@tonybrookes4524]

I own Red Tobacco and love it. Yes it's a bit screechy and chaotic at first, but it smooths out after half hour or so, and just keeps getting better. PDM are just too pricey, and there are never good deals on them. Will try and hunt down the third one you have. Thanks for the vid.

[@miamilivelife9583]

Honestly tony ur not really missing anything special with PDM I have carlisle and layton they are Good but definitely Overatedddddd in my OPINION and I would definitely test before buying it's not for everyone as ppl on youtube like to overhype this stuff

[@minibus1351]

The problem is, you can't buy Carlisle right now because it's just sold out everywhere and isn't stocked.

[@boardcrf2763]

Will be available soon in October at the US boutique.

[@tylero2112]

Fragrancebuy has it hurry 211 bucks for the big bottle. Super steal.

[@boardcrf2763]

@@tylero2112 It's sold out.

[@tylero2112]

@@boardcrf2763 damn not even 24 hours

[@jamalmohamed7773]

Carlisle is in a league of its own…

[@marcelopagnussattkura6474]

You can buy 3 or 5 Red Tobacco for the Carlisle price.It's the same Cedrat Boise x Aventus Dilema. Mancera is offering the best value,price and performance combo.

[@Keliiyamashita]

Truth!

[@cactu5jack]

Cedrat Boise is not Aventus..

[@Annqt19]

I love Carlisle and house Of De Marly. I heard of mancera haven't bought from them yet

[@OksanaItkes]

Great video as always :) Personally not a fan of these two (haven't tried the 3rd one) but I know a lot of people are so its nice to have a comparison

[@jawwadafridi2194]

I have old batch probably 2015 and 2019 batch carlisle and mancera red tobacco.. There are a few things common in newer carlisle and red tobacco.. Newer carlisle version is slightly rough if compared to 2015 ( but no way near the roughness of red tobacco still) 2015 one is monsterous in projection but really smooth and my favorite of the two Carlisles ..

[@UnknownChap]

No need for a notification today 😍 I never found them that similar but also that perris monte carlo has been on my radar for a while now , they have so many gems 🍀

[@100zz100]

I'm wearing red tobacco today absolute beast 💪

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Agree!!

[@edavidmartinez]

Amazing review. I own both Carlisle and Red Tobacco and I find Carlisle to be more appealing whereas Red Tobacco is way more piercing and polarizing. I know this video is about 4 months old already and many comments have gone by but I wonder if you have already done a side to side comparison of MFK BR540 EDP, Mancera Instant Crush and Parfums de Marly Kalan. I believe that would be an amazing video showing comparison between the three

[@cactu5jack]

Dude Instant Crush should not be mentioned with BR540. They are NOTHING alike

[@hadnick1]

I got some BR540 samples on the way so I haven’t smelled them yet but Kalan and instant crush were nothing alike for me. Instant crush was great smooth and sweet while kalan was spicey and not appealing at all.

[@rickytomatoes]

Some video suggestions: fragrances for harvest season, Halloween, Elections, Thanksgiving.

[@03500]

Thank you Sebastian 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@lalchimiste9717]

Both great

[@cherokeeramirez2911]

I love Red Tabaco de Mancera 😋💪💯

[@ericdickerson9080]

Carlisle vs triumph of Bacchus? Which do you like more.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

I don't recalled smelling the latter?

[@reasonableselectivefragran5047]

All the descriptions are spot on. I prefer Carlisle 'cause it is more rounded and done with great care with absolutely fine performance. Even Bois d'Oud is also a very nice fragrance. Thanks for the review Sir 👍 👍 👍

[@brunopaolucci6594]

Yes!!these are the toes of videos I am looking for Sebastian! Comparisons with other similar scents. 👍

[@jakesimms9915]

Red Tobacco and Odyon Scorpion Intense are my strongest beast mode fragrances. Layer the two and you will FLEX on ANY other fragrance that anyone around is wearing.

[@antonio72966]

Well said Sebastian I couldn't agree any more

[@moneyparhar]

Mancera red tabbaco I got yesterday. I don't know what people talking about opening too harsh. It's not harsh to my nose. It's smells good. Picked up thierry mugler pure havane from marcary for $120 95 percent full bottle. It's smells good but more intense than Mancera. Mancera red tabbaco is $88 from gift express

[@odeansamuels1727]

I love Red Tobacco ...... and wear it year round sooooooooo.... I won't be buying Carlisle since they share similar vibe...ill now switch my focus to oajan instead. Great comparison as per usual. Looking forward to more of your amazing content.👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾

[@Animejook]

Is there a designer edp that’s beast mode like these? Any recommendations?

[@elijahray9792]

Which one do you prefer out of the 3?

[@aftekharkhan1094]

Red Tobacco is noooooiiiiicceee! Carlisle is really nice also but Mancera out the 2 is my preference. Both blended really well and huge sillage definitely a must in the fall and winter.

[@danspanos]

I own Red Tobacco, and Carlisle. Carlisle is definitely my favorite!

[@danspanos]

@Gabriela Antes Kuhn Me too!

[@Marco-ol6ms]

Somebody said mancera smells like a cat piss !! Which is weird . Did u get that ? I’m afraid to buy red tobacco

[@Welcome0002]

@@Marco-ol6ms No, it doesn’t smell like cat urine, but you have to wait at least 30 minutes for RT to shine.

[@willbuesseler8739]

Maybe they might think that if they dont like oud.

[@danspanos]

@@Marco-ol6ms I agree with Welcome Welcome. No, it doesn’t... not even in the slightest!

[@emiliosman820]

Would love to see you do some Arabian oud and Boadicea. Enjoy your channel. Also hoping you do a review on your recent pick up of Oud Essential from Guerlain.

[@MP-ej9pw]

I will try those 2 against a third: Carolina Herrera Mystery Tobacco a 2016 Quentin Bisch creation. Great video!

[@onlyu2high]

I really really like both of them tbh, cant really pick one

[@jonniewaniak4494]

They have a New York boutique as well

[@clarencewilliams9432]

An awesome review. Keep doing your reviews this way. Very good speaker.

[@robertlauch9854]

Love both House and i have Red Tobacco. I love it it is so good smelling.

[@sakkamoto]

Did you find any similarities with Tom Ford Noir Extreme?

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Now that you write this there might be some but I haven't compared it but I can see it. Will have to test them side by side! :)

[@sakkamoto]

Smelling Great Fragrance Reviews I remember trying at Sephora and instantly reminded me of Carlisle

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Will have to check for sure!! It’s probably the Cardamom!!

[@bradpeterson5299]

I have both Carlisle and Red tobacco and I’ve never noticed a similarity

[@xxbluecrystalxx]

I totally agree! Carlisle is way better and different

[@Joseph-jy5lz]

Carlisle was my favourite but I am finding it difficult to get hold of at the moment

[@firemedic5170]

MaxAroma has a restock with 8 left at the moment. 15% off of $200+ code at the top of their homepage. Hope that helps 😎

[@ericnelson4651]

Had samples of both, I can see similarities, but 100% different for me... RT smells like shisha hookah Tobacco to me. Carlisle smells like sweet medicinal syrupy goodness... I wore 4 sprays of RT to my college graduation last December to assault the noses of the deans of the schools 🤷‍♂️😁

[@owenchukunda4186]

Can I wear it to school? Should I spray on skin or cloth?

[@Photojanne]

After I bought Rt I cant see a reason to also buy Carlisle. The difference aren´t that big that I need both. My favorite tobacco scent i s Herrod.

[@Soldier4life-H5]

Try pure havane

[@MartynoKing]

RT all the way! Just two little red tobacco sprays all over my body when I get out of the shower in the morning and I feel incredible for the whole day... 😋🤩 I don't think Carlisle smells the same, for me it's a fragrance where I find almost no tobacco but a lot of fruit...

[@leonordstrom7610]

I have yet to try Red Tobacco, but i get major similarities with Carlisle and my recently acquired bottle of Side Effect from Initio, not redundant but close enough, i wouldn't say that i get the similarity with Bois D'Oud though, i think that Rouge Saray by Atelier Des Ors also kind of had that dna mixed with some of that Oajan/Ambre Narguille vibe!

[@Schatje79]

I ended up selling off Layton and Herod so I have to default to Red Tobacco for the time being. I much prefer Mancera as a house overall but I still want to be fair and give Carlisle a sniff.

[@TeyanThuny]

Tiziana Arrakis smells like cinnamon too

[@GlamorousBeauty1477]

I love the red tobacco its perfect and so rare to find a true beast mode but I found it in this. Parfums are extremely hard to last on me but this does. I'm wanting to try more Mancera but I'm scared they will not be as beast mode. If anyone knows other frgrances from Montale or Mancera that is as beast mode as Black Aoud and The best Red Tobacco please let me know. I've been looking at intense cafe, instant crush, and Aoud Exclusif.

[@jokosantoso7742]

Nishane ani

[@GlamorousBeauty1477]

@@jokosantoso7742 thank you love

[@jokosantoso7742]

@@GlamorousBeauty1477 your welcome

[@jamaalgumbs6474]

I love cafe intense kinda smells like tom ford black orchid with coffee in the base

[@GlamorousBeauty1477]

@@jamaalgumbs6474 thank you babe. How does it compare to the longevity and silage. I love monster beast silage lol

[@armentutundjian6800]

Great review Seb love red tobacco amazing long lasting bold sent for the winter.

[@celia5132]

I've also seen people comparing Carlisle to Atelier Des Ors Rouge Saray. It would be great if you could kindly share your thought. Thanks in advance! 😀

[@philipkelsey840]

I would absolutely agree with this however Sebastien disagreed with me. I think his nose was having an off day!

[@celia5132]

@@philipkelsey840 I guess everyone's nose is different😁 I did see that other people think they are alike in some other platforms. Thank you for sharing your opinion!

[@billyocean9236]

Carlisle has been impossible for me to find in the USA for the past few months

[@hudsond110]

Nieman has it.

[@thatduke1534]

Fragrancex has it in stock now, I just purchased a bottle

[@fatdave4582]

I agree with Chuck… if I’m gonna blind buy a Niche fragrances I look for your opinion on it… the only time I was let down was on mancera BLACK oud but that’s just cause it smells just like black prestigium; so not your fault though lol

[@carasparks8500]

The dry down on black prestigium goes Ina very different direction

[@brandonphoenix1096]

Wouldn’t Red Tobacco vs Herod have made more sense being tobacco? 🧐

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

No because they don’t smell similar so why would you compare them? Just because they are both tobacco Fragrances I guess you can compare them but they’re so different.

[@brandonphoenix1096]

Smelling Great Fragrance Reviews ok I’ll take ur word then! 🤝 I had just never heard anyone say these 2 smelled similar but understood.

[@qnunyuh8417]

after a long wait to get my nose on Carlisle it was nice and the only complaint I had was is smells like an average lattafa or rasasi ,something that has already been done a while ago and i couldn't figure out what all the talk was about

[@boardcrf2763]

There is similarities but like what sebastian said, it's less than 60% similarities. Carlisle definitely sweater, slightly moist tobacco and heavy in vanilla. But Red tobacco is less sweet, more synthetic, heavy dry tobacco and more patchouli than vanilla.

[@RakanDiab]

Also a lotttt similar is mystery tobacco by Carolina Herrera

[@rayhanes1347]

Been wanting to add Mancera Red T to my Mancera collection but all the reviews keep tallikg me out of it except Ross at TLTG. Navitus Parfum Virtus seems better

[@rustneversleeps7094]

They are very very different to me. The similarity ends with the obvious sweet tobacco accord. To me the Mancera is a screechy synthetic red hots candy with a clashing tobacco accord. Carlisle is a completely different wearing experience. Much smoother and refined, And very different note profiles. ...the whole gender thing is absolutely absurd too. Feminine/Masculine is about personal scent memory, not a wand waved over the fragrance in a marketing meeting. just my opinion having owned full bottles of both (no longer have the Mancera ;)

[@Yjn75]

Red Tobacco has just been nerfed bigtime! I hope you make a feature on this. It sucks.

[@alexluke84]

The beastly of the beast perfumes...I see that title 😁😁😁 a video that was a joy to watch 😎

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@TheByzmal]

Does red tobacco smell like shurah?

[@imnotlarry]

not at all

[@michannamurphy6816]

I’d love to try the Mancera fragrance. I know it has major silliage and is probably pretty masculine but I’d love to get my nose on it.

[@dldjacobs]

Ha! I love Red Tobacco and get lots of compliments when I wear it and I’m a woman! Go for it!

[@rzone1286]

How does Initio Side Effect compare to Carlisle?

[@willbuesseler8739]

Not even close to the same but side effect is WAY better

[@extraordinary_scents6806]

I very much prefer Carlisle

[@elvirsahinovic7200]

Can you please compare perfume vintage with a creed

[@theblues4101]

I really like red tobacco : D....great video

[@franksalas5507]

I've read some reviews that red tobacco has a bug spray opening lol

[@nickzee1637]

I love the opening, but it is bracing.

[@franksalas5507]

@@nickzee1637 I have so many tobacco fragrances, VIRTUS. Naxos, 1821 SWEET TOBACCO, carlisle, just to name a few. Lol.

[@wordlife1997]

@@franksalas5507 how is that sweet tobacco?

[@franksalas5507]

@@wordlife1997 to my nose like 90% like Naxos ! Lol. I'm actually selling my bottle on meccari lol

[@CoolDude-tz5co]

An added bonus, no doubt!

[@yahyaraz4617]

Looking forward to a cold 32° day with wind gust making it feel like it's in the teens and me scented with Red Tobacco #BeastMode

[@dldjacobs]

@yahya raz ha ha ha! No waiting for me! I waiting for even a moment in the 50s and I was spraying the stuff with abandon!🤣

[@sarahbrodish7616]

Hi Sebastian, off today’s topic... how many fragrances can I bring back from France? I can’t find a straight answer. You seems to bring lots of them back with you. How do you pack them in your luggage? Thank you in advance.

[@sarahbrodish7616]

I going to visit the Dior Boutique over there and see if they have Vetiver, Mitzah, Santal Noire and smell Eau noire. The online French Dior does have Eau Noire, Granville, Cuir ..., Santal Noire available.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

I sneak in as much as I can but be careful because I also travel with others and they claim fragrances for me and I also have a pass!! 😄

[@sarahbrodish7616]

Thank you for responding! What is the pass you are speaking of? Is that a fragrance pass? Can I/how do I get one?

[@joshmarauder]

Do arabian oud bussma

[@throwthejavelin368]

I had huge expectations buying Carlisle because I love Layton and Herod. Smelled Carlisle and to me this smells very very bad!

[@willbuesseler8739]

Same man, it just smells sour sweet to me. Not good

[@Danmandingo]

*Would LOVE to see a VS between PDM Layton, and Hugo Boss Bottled Intense.*

[@CultivateAwareness]

They smell nothing alike...

[@Ryan-ph7nk]

I think Initio Blessed Baraka is more similar to Carlisle.

[@Chaumurkie]

Awesome video and scary good timing! Earlier today I was about to pick up Carlisle, but then figured I should dig up my Red Tobacco sample first one final time :) The jury's still out on this one...

[@dantone6738]

I own both RT and Carlisle...RT smells more approachable...great for a cool Fall daytime wearing. Carlisle is immaculate and night time PLUS wearing when I smoke cigars at the local cigar lounge. Both have their place and are AWESOME!!!!!

[@Filip3alex]

Since red tobacco is a mancera it goes without saying that Pierre Montale is the perfumer

[@stecorbett1]

Both are bangers, Carlise is better but i still love Rt

[@shabmtn1668]

Also watch all reviews on youtube becz u r one of best reviewed ✌️

[@Audrius267]

Is anyone got problem with Carlisle longevity?

[@shabmtn1668]

Plz tell me one of best beast long trail and long sillage perfium for summer and winter plz must replay bro💖

[@1manairband]

What was your favorite again from the three?

[@KidWithThePen21]

I can't find Carlisle anywhere

[@AKS3629]

Sold out everywhere online and even at Parfum De Marly Boutique in NY. They are getting new shipment this week.

[@KidWithThePen21]

@@AKS3629 I have been dying to try it!

[@AKS3629]

@@KidWithThePen21 I think maxaroma sells samples in atomizer of it on their website.

[@npovse25]

Hey Seb love your videos. I watch all your Montale videos because its my new cologne im looking at for myself. I just have a quick question.. whats the best Montale version of Comme des Garcons Wonderwood Eau De Parfum?

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Maybe try Wood & Spices from Montale? I don't have experience with the CDG Wonderwood to give you correct suggestions though. I'll need to buy a bottle to test it and see. :)

[@npovse25]

@@ThePerfumeGuy Ill take a look at the wood & spice. Do you think there is anything that smells more i guess like a pine tree? Or just super wood smelling?

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

You want pine tree? Try Russian Leather by Memo Paris you should also try some of Bottega Veneta's men's fragrances! Try this: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mYq6lpqBfreJg6M and also Imaginary Authors Cape Heartache.

[@npovse25]

@@ThePerfumeGuy you're awesome thank you so much! Look forward to more videos :)