me too! I was a hard fan of L'Oreal double extension mascara especially the white and red one! just like u said, i have not encounter any other mascara which able to do such a good job in extension + won't smudge + easy to remove! I m very skeptical on mascara coz im ave oily eye lids, i tried quite alot of brands before untill i met this. it is a long time products, i just hope L'Oreal won't discontinue this.