i saw someone on tt said that while listening to the unreleased version of wkof you could feel the hurt and pain but this version is filled with warmth and love and it gives comfort. it's so precious
@carating11 ай бұрын
“Where there is grief ,there was love” Happy birthday Bin-Ah, you will always be loved ❤
@Carmyot11 ай бұрын
The more correct lyrics for "when we weren't over as i held onto whatever was left you let go of me as i refused" are "You let go of me when I was struggling holding on to the end of a small thread that we're not done yet"
@Feeny-sc7ys9 ай бұрын
That’s so saddd 😭😭😭 wooziyaaaa 😭😭😭
@caratkate286010 ай бұрын
2:42 그리워요 (geuriwoyo) is a strong word. It means to miss somebody you can’t see anymore. In this song, written long ago, he goes from the traditional bogo shipeo (“I want to see you”) to this.💔 Source: some educational Korean language post.
@ohoratkkaebsong11 ай бұрын
2:37 “You, who isn’t here with me anymore” My heart 💔💔
@moonjeonleebitna1711 ай бұрын
Woozi kept his promise ❤ I wish Moonbin could listen to this released song 💔
@sairah2311 ай бұрын
The first time I heard this song it was so heartbreaking and painful but now knowing the reason behind why Woozi decided to officially release this song it made me feel comfort. Though AROHAs are questioning what will the future may bring without Binnie, even though the future without him is so sad and unsure we can always look back in the past with memories of him and he will always be there. Though his time stop in the past we can still bring his memories with us in our future. Bin-ah, you are greatly missed. A lot of people are missing you and you will never be forgotten whatever the furure will be 🌙🕊💐🌌
@vannlytayung914211 ай бұрын
Before I thought this is such an emotional song but now when I listen to this, it's even way painful when the lyrics hit different, What kind of future is this 💔😭
@ohoratkkaebsong11 ай бұрын
Such beautiful lyrics, you can’t help but tear up. Happy birthday, Moonbinnie❤
@monicas899211 ай бұрын
I was just having a Seventeen lyric video marathon when I came across this one and thought I better give it a listen since you know, it’s Woozi. Now I’m kinda speechless because I’ve been having such a rough day and the lyrics literally describe all the things I’ve been going through and thinking of. Kinda feels scary or like a cruel joke coming across this but also kinda comforting to know that someone else can relate to everything that I feel. I truly hope you’ve healed with time Woozi and I hope I can too.
@itsallagoodfun601810 ай бұрын
Hope you feeling better now! We all have ups and downs, remember to stay strong during storm, the sun will come for sure!
@Shining_purple_light_76 ай бұрын
Sending hugs to wherever you are 🫂
@imanjaleenimthara222211 ай бұрын
I can't help but tear up while listening to the song. Happy birthday Binnie. I hope you are happy up there❤
@RegineSayson-e2y11 ай бұрын
I was bawling so hard while listening into this specially when I saw the lyrics. I lost my bestfriend since I was a little kid and it's almost 2 years now and just a few months ago (last year) I stopped crying, I wont even look at her pic and would even refuse to talk about her. I was acting as if there is nothing's wrong but after listening into this I stated bawling. I suddenly broke down, anxious about how everything's would work for me if I go back home and she's not there. She's like my sister we literally grew up together, we celebrated and cried for every occasions in our lives. I miss her so much. I wish I could go back in time. I'd do everything to save her
@salehaPak3 ай бұрын
I hope you heal that's so sad and may she rest in peace ❤
@ayu_gyu2 ай бұрын
I'm sure you'll meet her again bcz fate brought you tgt & hence you'll cross paths again
@shiyana11 ай бұрын
The lyrics is sooooo painful… i wonder why woozi wrote this in the first place and why it was so special to him… 🥺
@its_kholod_vlogs11 ай бұрын
I wish i could know that too ..
@shiyana11 ай бұрын
@@its_kholod_vlogs yesyes i’m also very curious but i hope no one asks him that question 🥲🥲
@W3nGI11 ай бұрын
I heard some people said he wrote it for moonbin from astro (if u didn't know it's his birthday today.. but he's spending his birthday in heaven) I'm unsure if it is true so take it with a grain of salt
@zarachan909811 ай бұрын
@@W3nGI he wroted it long before moonbin death so the lyrics may have other meaning, he only performed it live once. But moonbin really liked it then. After he passed away, Woozi promised to release it on Bin's birthday as a gift🥺🤍
@kkuma.s_hairclips11 ай бұрын
@@W3nGI Woozi actually made this as his solo song for their Idea Cut concert back in 2018!! However Woozi said that he would never release nor perform the song again (he performed it 3 times i believe, once for the concert and twice cuz of fans' requests), but Moonbin loved the song so much that he'd ask Woozi to release it. In the end, Woozi promised after Moonbin's passing that he'd release the song even if he had to fight the company for it🥺🥺
@dreamplace100411 ай бұрын
Back then whenever i listen this song i don't have any specific person in mind but now the only person who comes in my mind after listening this song is *moonbin* 😭 I hope wherever you are now you may rest in peace 💖
@snehakumari905711 ай бұрын
The lyrics are so painful and beautiful we can't help but tear up while listening to this amazing song
@brxkenwonder11 ай бұрын
i didn't think a song would make me cry as much as this one has. Happy Birthday Binnie, I miss you lots.
@caratkate286010 ай бұрын
I waited a month to hear this. I was just getting through the days, adulthood. Sometimes I watched the tour. Woozi is extremely talented, a musical genius (음악의 천재). In addition, he’s thoughtful, caring, and more. Though I never knew much about Binnie, all can I say is losing them in that sense was devastating, but now it’s up to us that we remember them in a positive light.
@every_onewoo_moment11 ай бұрын
노래 속 담긴 이야기를 알고 들으니 유독 더 가사와 멜로디가 멤돌던 곡
@tteo_creating_my_own_story8 ай бұрын
Who hurt uri Woozi🤧 The lyrics! I have no words to express the beauty of them. Woozi's voice is so beautiful, I got goosebumps. He is just amazing. Truly a musical genius❤ Baksu👏🏻👏🏻
@DnyaptiChavan8 ай бұрын
2:10 from this part I really cry hardly . I had no words to show gratitude to woozi he is really mind reader
@user-tp6dq5lg6pАй бұрын
This should be an ost ❤❤❤ m here after woozi nominated for the lyrics of this song in asian award 2024...this man is genius ❤❤❤ N today woozi got the best lyricist award for this ..so so happy ❤
@utopiaeverglow19311 ай бұрын
No wonder that binnie loved this song so much this song holds so much power to it with these lyrics
@lauraemiliabarraza411411 ай бұрын
Happy birthday Moobin❤❤❤ sin dudas tuviste amigos ,hermanos de fierro que te amaron y te aman , hermosa letra Woozy tu voz tan linda y dulce transmites esa tristeza y dulzura ❤❤❤
@itspribanerjee11 ай бұрын
This is really an amazing song! 🥺😭
@arwitazahraputri307911 ай бұрын
이 노래가 너무 좋다 ㅠㅠㅠ 소중한
@Mrrrr_Thomasss11 ай бұрын
He kept his promise🥹😭💗
@05kbs7011 ай бұрын
Happy bday moonbin❤
@강지연-g5x10 ай бұрын
우지야 약속 지켜줘서 고마워 그리고 이 곡 들을때마다 울었어 힘들어하지 말고 화이팅!
@Sky-write_s6 ай бұрын
Thank you, Woozi, for releasing this song. I think all of us needed it in different ways. I'm glad the promise to Moonbin was kept and this song was released. I listen to this song whenever I want to reminisce him or when I seek comfort, this is a strong and comforting song. I hope I'll get to hear it live someday, though it might make me bawl my eyes out.
@neomulonely_lucas11 ай бұрын
Happy birthday moonbin🎉 I miss you ❤
@bulbul271211 ай бұрын
Is it just me or the lyrics does feel different from original like its sounding more painful and sadder than before
@dreamplace100411 ай бұрын
No it's really more painful and sadder now
@auduesther437911 ай бұрын
I can totally relate to the song cause I lost someone dear to me 😪😔
@dreamplace100411 ай бұрын
@@auduesther4379 i sorry for your lost 🙏🏼 i hope this song will make you feel better 💖
@auduesther437911 ай бұрын
@@dreamplace1004 thanks
@dreamplace100411 ай бұрын
@@auduesther4379 mention not Stay strong 💖
@Seventeen17-r1l4 ай бұрын
회사와 싸우더라도 곡을 내겠던 약속을 지켜준 우지야 고마워
@lovesvt0526mg11 ай бұрын
지훈아 약속 지켜줘서 고마워
@kimphair73111 ай бұрын
Amazing song. Pure emotion and love. Wow❤. Thank you for releasing it again
@냥디-e4j11 ай бұрын
오랜만에 영상 올려줘서 감사합니다❤ 그리웠어요!!
@princess.girl.10114 күн бұрын
Shatteringly beautiful. 🤍
@sunshineam11 ай бұрын
happy birthday moonbin !
@sesbaniaio23955 ай бұрын
I'm crying so hard right now. I just ended a relationship with someone that I really loved so dearly. I regretted bcs I let go the only chance I had to tell him that I am really thankful for everything & I was really happy with him in the past 5 years. Now I wanted to hug him once again, to properly say goodbye. I love him so so so much. but things just aren't meant to be for us :")
@iz39611 ай бұрын
Happy birthday Moonbin and thank you Woozi for keeping your promise❤️
@Bitterishere7 ай бұрын
I want to hate you so much for leaving us but I can't for you is just an angel who deserves so much better... and I failed to give you the things you deserve... This song breaks my heart knowing how woozi rarely gets emotional and only expresses his feelings through songs, the lyrics are very painful... it hurts so bad please I love you MoonBin ❤
@rubynayak58769 ай бұрын
Woozi and me is similar who left our inner child to become that we never thought.
@Memsy711 ай бұрын
Hey! You’re back!
@보민박-c4c11 ай бұрын
지훈이는 약속을 지켰어......ㅜㅜ
@mary602211 ай бұрын
You're back 😊 Thank you for the video
@Myboos012611 ай бұрын
우리 미래가 이랬다면 오히려 내가 오빠를 더 사랑하고 봐줄수 있었을까? 우리의 미래가 어긋나기도 전에 내가 알아차릴수는 있었을까? 오빠 기다리는게 힘들다 오빠 더 바라보고 오빠 생각하는게 뭐가 어렵다고 안해줬을까? 내가 언제나 오빠 사랑하고 그리워하는 거 알지? 오빠도 우리 아로하 잊지말고 계속 찾아줘 많이 보고싶어 사랑해
@camilleg14311 ай бұрын
Beautiful song
@Myboos012611 ай бұрын
빈오빠 내가 아니 아로하가 많이 기다려 나 오빠 기사 떴을 때 너무 믿기지 않았어 일부러 모른 척하려했어 근데 이제는 어쩔수가 없더라 오빠 내가 너무 미안해 이제야 알아줘서 내가 이제야 이말 해서 위로 못해줘서 오빠가 아로하만 남겨둔게 밉기도 했는데 너무 그리워 아니 보고싶어 어떤 미래를 바라고 살았는지 알아 내가 오빠몫 전부 다 대신 살게 아프지말고 건강하고 행복해 나보다도 더 잘 살아야해 사랑해 생일축하하고 오빠때문에 이젠 나도 안울게 그니까 오빠도 그래야해 사랑했고 사랑할게 사랑해 2024.01.26. 오빠를 그리워하는 아로하가
@elyssacalisura7940Ай бұрын
happy birthday, woozi. thank you for ur music.
@maysarahutub11 ай бұрын
Jihoon-aah time flies.. yet sure when you heard this song ur memory prob flied back to it moment. Despite of ur promise to urselve n also ti Binaah, Im so thrilled that u hv vvv big heart to release this precious piece of ur memory treasure❤
@puyye.8 ай бұрын
They think they can drop one of the most mind blowing video out of a sudden, how are we gonna live noww 😱😱
@KrishaMaeGanlag11 ай бұрын
Why am i crying right now I'II forever miss u MOONBIN❤🥺
@MarcJonPierreMagbanua-o7d10 ай бұрын
When your dealing with something and this song of woozie made me realize that I am still hurting 😢
@zarachan90987 ай бұрын
This song literally sounds and feels like grief...it's so painful
@FodorMaria-h7l7 ай бұрын
Amazingh❤❤
@Lia-ip2mu7 ай бұрын
This song made me cry cuz it reminded me of our binnie (every sad kpop songs/pop songs remind me of binnie) so i started crying😭😭😭😭😭😭
@XinhuiLim-zq1wk11 ай бұрын
sobbing because this is somehow sadder than the original version
@Beomiesoulmate11 ай бұрын
Happy birthday bin 😔 u will be remembered forever
@Bil8895 ай бұрын
padahal dulu kalo mau dengerin lagu ini dengerinnya lewat clip video yang unggah carat di ytb, tapi sekarang Woozi realise lagu ini buat Moonbin🤍
@FodorMaria-h7l11 ай бұрын
Thank you.whozi❤❤❤❤❤
@sleeepyhollow_11 ай бұрын
Hi, can you please translate scoups "me" and "God of music"? I only trust your translations😅
@KrystalSnow_1711 ай бұрын
Wait too
@fysontheboard11 ай бұрын
She already uploaded ‘Me’. Lets hear that song~
@blkpopnovellover8 ай бұрын
Binnie-ah I hate you for leaving us but at the same time I miss you so bad.... I MISS YOU BINNIE
@kpop-with-24-7-BANGLADESHI-boy8 ай бұрын
This song make me cry as an carat & aroha
@ilasuraya394911 ай бұрын
Happy Birthday MoonBin 🌙🌙🌙
@Thank-you81811 ай бұрын
Happy birthday Moonbin🩶
@JaneJustJam21911 ай бұрын
my umbrella from rain of sadness.
@seoksoon11 ай бұрын
happy birthday moonbin
@bekahchu410211 ай бұрын
I'm late to this couldn't handle listening to it near the date but happy late birthday Moonbin 🌙❤🖤
@Sarina_5432o8 ай бұрын
And here I am going back. 😭 I don't wanna read everything in the comments, I feel like my heart is going to explode. I'm not the type of person to cry on something so all of my feelings are stucked in my heart that it hurts more than crying. 😭😭
@paulinavillacres247111 ай бұрын
Gracias Woozy 💔
@ilariacostantini896111 ай бұрын
Semplicemente bellissima canzone straordinaria da brividi che meravigliosa sensazione e che emozione, bellissima voce dolcissimo i miei complimenti straordinario musicista e compositore straordinario sei una bella persona dentro e fuori complimenti ti meriti tantissimo e io te lo auguro con tutto il cuore ti abbraccio forte forte baci baci e grazie per regalarci tutte queste belle emozioni ciao woozi ciao ciao ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Sei spettacolare ❤❤❤❤❤
@ilariacostantini896111 ай бұрын
Grazie per avermi risposto gentilissimo e cordiale grazie di cuore per la tua gentilezza un'abbraccio grande grande ciaooooo baci baci
@blblssy11 ай бұрын
bagong carat lang ako, mas lalo tuloy akong naa-attach sa svt 😭
@pingping________piiiiiiiin196411 ай бұрын
Crying...rest in peace dear Moonbin😢😢
@Clowdywoo2 ай бұрын
Seventeen comeback, can you comeback too for update videos seventeen lyrics again? Miss you so much🥺💗
@wonderingheights11 ай бұрын
Happy birthday, Moonbin 🌙 🐺
@seung0811 ай бұрын
Happy birthday Bin
@cloudycupz_555026 күн бұрын
Though, the song means something different, I interpret it as one of the problems I'm contemplating, not knowing what my future has in store and fearing that I won't be happy with the path I'm taking.
@b.99411 ай бұрын
Thank you for the video❤ Happy birthday to Binnie, we love you. Btw are you planning to make a lyrics video for Scoups solo "Me". Since it's been awhile I was wondering why haven't you uploaded it yet😅
@iamichh11 ай бұрын
IM CRYING
@yooniepie500511 ай бұрын
binnie, happy birthday ❤️
@therealrosa69111 ай бұрын
Happy birthday Bonnie we all miss you rest easy our binnie😭😭😭😭
@apseyo2 ай бұрын
Don't worry, He's already in the future😊
@kyleangelinemejillano3159 ай бұрын
Still crying in april😭😭😭😭
@brendasayre632111 ай бұрын
I could not stop crying when I heard this song! I was curious as to the story behind the lyrics, so I was looking at other posts, and @micahrinoatestor1598 had the best explanation. The members once said that Woozi wrote this song when he was afraid/worried for Seventeen's future. Since they are a self composing/producing group, he was afraid if Seventeen flopped he would be stuck in the past maybe blaming himself? She said he cried about it in One Fine Day and in the Soop. I also read that he has only performed the song three times and vowed never to release it because it was personal to him, but Moonbin loved it so much that he wanted Woozi to release it. So after Moonbin left us, Woozi released it for him. Whatever the real reason for this song, it is a true testament oftheir love and friendship for Moonbin that this was released! I hope that Moonbin is smiling down and happy that it finally happened. Happy heavenly birthday Moonbin. You are missed by many!
@melissabee57089 ай бұрын
8> beautiful
@Bia_shingibangibungbungbangi11 ай бұрын
😭😭😭
@faridaabdelazeem72608 ай бұрын
I'm here in his death anniversary..binnie u will always be remembered
@EmilianaMassombeАй бұрын
😢Lua🌒 Astroaniana ✡️✨🤍🕊️ senti saudades 😢😭😭
@kyuxyzz10 ай бұрын
He was under 22 years old when he wrote this!? 🤯🤯
@Nero-cf2mi10 ай бұрын
Moonbin in proud of you woozy. Us arohas have always got your back
@CallMeCathCath11 ай бұрын
It's soooooo painful.. every single word.. 😢
@shattermirror11 ай бұрын
Fuck, I'm crying.
@txt_annie11 ай бұрын
It hits more when you know that this song is for moonbin.
@annakononen98152 күн бұрын
😍😍😍😍😍
@FodorMaria-h7l11 ай бұрын
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
@FodorMaria-h7l11 ай бұрын
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
@kwontitan11 ай бұрын
Sorry in advance, but why don't you make fighting, god of music lyrics?