朗朗的土耳其進行曲好聽太多了。改良版不耐聽,新奇感很快逝去,大量不和諧的改編只是彈者得意陶醉,我聽得燥累。能表達作者抗辯的一兩個不和諧音组是畫龍點睛(Mozart k304 part one ),令人回味贊妙。我更喜歡音色美,技巧純為更好表達情感的演奏。朗朗感情,音色,速度皆完美,設了目標。古典音樂歷久不衰基於音樂家,音樂老師,學生的努力,聽眾的喜愛和捧場。
I am very happy when i am listening lang lang 's turki march. Lang lang, beautiful performance. Vivian
@peterwilliams7335 Жыл бұрын
I very much like Lang Lang's version of this Mozart's Turkish March.
@jackc3119 Жыл бұрын
作为业余的旁观者,我投票给朗朗。两个理由:一是朗朗的演奏中旋律更加清楚,二是他更加放松和游刃有余。
@jinggu9787 Жыл бұрын
+1
@LemonloctzYT Жыл бұрын
其實兩者不可比較
@LemonloctzYT Жыл бұрын
不同版本
@jackc3119 Жыл бұрын
@@LemonloctzYT 我不是专业的,可以说下吗?听起来是一个曲子啊,长度也几乎一样
@kenchen245 Жыл бұрын
@@jackc3119 yuja所演奏的版本難度近乎不可思議,是改編自volodos改編的turkish march
@judytalk1285 ай бұрын
俩人演技都很高 但似乎朗朗的更莫扎特 听上去更舒服。
@longlichuan Жыл бұрын
朗朗表演成分有點多,但卻是每個音都很清晰,大師水準.
@pinewang506 Жыл бұрын
真知灼见
@elainemeyer5062 Жыл бұрын
Since I don’t speak the language that the comments are written in (English only), I don’t know if they were positive or negative ones, and which of the two pianists people preferred. But as a classical pianist myself for more than 1/2 century, my vote is definitely for Lang Lang’s 🎹 rendition by far, and for multiple reasons! If I thought anyone would understand me, I would explain WHY I feel this is true. *** To edit this original comment less than a week later, I thank all of you who for replied, and let me know that I was helpful with your understanding of this piece - even if only just as a music ‘lover’, and not a 🎹ist yourself. I really do appreciate it! I’m so glad that I could shed some light on its meaning, and styles of each ones playing - even with a language barrier of sorts!
@april9082 Жыл бұрын
I agree with you. There are about half of the coments preferred Lang Lang’s rendition by far. Actually, the question I asked in title is which 🎹 rendition closer to Mozart. I'm only a music lover. That'll be appreciated very much if you would like give me your professional explanation.
@sucui3285 Жыл бұрын
Yeah just tell us as I know many ppl here are multilingual
@elainemeyer5062 Жыл бұрын
@@april9082 To answer your question, and the other person (Su ?) who asked me about it, and for the same answer about 8 hours ago (under your comment)… I believe it’s the female 🎹ist who’s performance of the Turkish March is more the way in which it was intended to be played - based strictly on playing the notes. She plays them as they were initially written, and does it well imo. BUT Lang Lang’s rendition gives it more ‘flair’ and expression with his style. IF I had to guess the one that Mozart (that’s if he could hear them both) would have liked best, it would be the latter. This is bc of the way he ‘improvised’, thereby making it the ‘fun’, light piece that it was meant to be (from a technical difficulty standpoint, they were both similar). This was not written as, or intended to be, a ‘true’ classical piece - although it was placed in this musical style and genre. I’m guessing the reason why is that he was known as being strictly a classical musician and composer. When you watch and compare the two styles, she appears to be very serious and concentrating on the notes, speed, etc., but w/o clearly visible emotion. On the other hand, Lang Lang (by way of his facial expressions - at times even laughing a little - and other gestures) exemplifies that it’s a lighthearted and rather ‘amusing’ Turkish‘March - as I truly believe was the intent for it to be by Mozart. *** I’m not sure where I read it, but there was an article on the origin of music styles and their history, including this type (and possibly this piece was mentioned too) and how they began, and why. It explained how various cultures and traditions played a large part in the styles of music that represented each of many countries dating back to when the pieces were originally composed. ⭐️ The reason WHY I personally prefer Lang Lang’s versions of all his other performances in general compared with other 🎹ist’s is not only bc of his superior technical skills. It’s also this, and the manner in which he’s able to combine them with both, thereby making a piece his ‘own’ with his unique interpretations, and taking the liberty to improvise - within reason, yet not removing or deviating so much as to take away from the ‘classical’ style of whatever the piece is. (Even some ‘covers’ of songs he’s performed in concerts have been great - ie. Metallica, Sting - to name a couple!) I hope this helps answer the question you both asked me to explain? If not, please lmk and I’ll try again (lol)! 🫠
@april9082 Жыл бұрын
Thanks a lot for your detail explanation. I knew that I enjoyed Lang Lang's rendition more before. For now, I learned that why I was pleased by his 🎹rendition - that's because of the different culture and composer's original intent reflected in his musical style.@@elainemeyer5062
@elainemeyer5062 Жыл бұрын
@@april9082 Thanks April, I’m glad you found my explanation helpful! I wasn’t sure if I was able to put into the correct words what I meant, and the reasons for the difference between the two 🎹ist’s interpretation of the exact same ‘classical’ piece. * I put the word classical in quotes bc it wasn’t intended to be one when it was composed/written by Mozart. It was really a result of his ‘humor’ that was the inspiration and the end result for it! As I had already written (in a way), Lang Lang picks up on this with his interpretation, while the female pianist doesn’t quite understand, or take notice, of the original meaning/style of this particular composition, and thus plays it as a purely ‘classical’ piece bc it was composed by Mozart. * I won’t say that she doesn’t play it well technically, but my own impression is it didn’t sound nearly as interesting as Lang Lang’s. I hope this gives you both even a little bit more helpful info 🤔 !? Always enjoy helping people with music - esp. 🎹!
💙🤍❤ Bonjour de la France! merci pour cette magnifique marche turque 💙🤍❤
@許燦堂-h9j2 ай бұрын
王羽佳難怪是年青人!不守規範!像極了在古典樂曲中加上rock!爵士!超好聽!
@kennethpao13556 ай бұрын
Wow ! Thank you for sharing these two pianists playing the same piece of music side by side so that we can "compare" with our ears ! I must say that I'm not a musician but I thought that I heard two differences - Lan Lan's fingers on the piano keys are "lighter" almost "velvety" and I thought that Lan lan's playing showed the overall melody "sounding better". Just my non-musical ears 2 cents. Comments ?
Whenever he plays this, I can't help but think that he is the reincarnation of Mozart.
@richardvolpe76644 ай бұрын
To mochila: Oh, please! You really think Mozart would've plowed his way through this march in such a vulgar, cheap fashion? From all accounts, he indeed meant to 'please' his audiences, but in a dignified, professional way. Here, on the other hand, we have Lang Lang who's determined, no matter what, to wow, to "slay" his viewers. Go ahead and be titilated by his prankish delivery, but try to keep in mind that this madcap tempo is in opposition to what the composer indicated in the score. One more thing: The constant (and boy, do I mean constant!) smiling is something that so many find [choke] endearing, and others find uniquely revolting. Just because this piano player has established himself as one of the happiest people on earth, must he show it for every minute he's sitting on the piano bench? All right, Lang fans - - I'll wait for the usual hate-mail to come my way, but try to be as gentle as you can, okay?
Even though one can’t compare the 2 versions of the same piece, but hands down to Yuja because her ability to modify the piece to such high degree of difficulties and complexity. Of course she can play the classical version equal to or better than Langlang, all I hear here is a race car driver and I was never a fan of him anyways! He has talent, so are a lot of other distinguished concert pianist!
@elainemeyer5062 Жыл бұрын
It’s amusing in a sense that I have the opposite opinion about the two of them. I prefer Lang Lang’s version to Yuja’s by far! Not only with this one, but in general when I hear them both playing the same classical 🎹 pieces. I can feel much more ‘emotion’ in his, and that I don’t in her. To me, she sounds rather ‘dull’, and although she’s talented technically, she doesn’t come across as being able to make this sound like the ‘fun’ piece that Mozart wrote, and intended it to be. But you’re right about not ‘comparing’ (to a degree) musicians, as each person has their own opinion and preferences. But this is mine!
@nathan834810 ай бұрын
@@elainemeyer5062I agree with you, although I am a fan of Yujia, however for this piece I prefer Langlang more than Yujia as I could felt more joy in it.
@lzhou989 ай бұрын
I am a big fan of Yuja. I think the two pieces are not comparable as Yuja is not playing the original version. I play piano and I like Yuja’s version better.
@mikechan2021 Жыл бұрын
王羽佳我聽到很有壓逼感,朗朗我聽到很開心舒服
@sina6457 Жыл бұрын
Absolutely amazing! I loved them both. In the first piece, SHE is playing some music, whereas, in the second one, the MUSIC is playing him.
@SuperFerrariX Жыл бұрын
your ears hears when the girl is playing and when lang lang plays your whole body and sole are listening. This is the best way I can explain their play. Of course I love them both!!!
@deepunicorn7953 Жыл бұрын
虽然没法对比,更喜欢朗朗的演奏
@brunyate Жыл бұрын
I have long admired Yuja Wang's performance of the Arcady Volodos rhapsody on Mozart's Turkish Rondo (pretty much a recomposition of the piece) and disliked Lang Lang's mugging while playing. And when listening again to Wang just now, I assumed she could not be topped. But lo and behold, Lang's playing of the Mozart exactly as he wrote it (except for the liberty of a very slight ritard towards the end) was utterly brilliant, and what I had previously called "mugging" was simply his youthful delight in Mozart's genius and humor. So his is the performance I treasure in this comparison-although I would still travel farther to attend an actual concert by Wang.
@elainemeyer5062 Жыл бұрын
I’ve previously written a comment on this video, but just saw yours. I was glad to see that someone else is writing them in English too, but mainly bc of your change in thoughts on Lang Lang. He played this ‘March’ as it was intended to be by Mozart - a light, fun, and ‘humerus’ piece. However, I would travel anywhere to see LL (vs Yuja Wang) perform at a live concert as opposed to you! Musicians, just like everything else, is a matter of personal taste - this is just my own. 😉
@brunyate Жыл бұрын
@@elainemeyer5062 Yes, I read your original comment, which is what inspired mine. If I went to hear LL, I would need to keep my eyes closed; while he may not intend them that way, his gestures and facial expressions look awfully like showboating. YW is absolutely his equal as a virtuoso (?virtuosa?), but I have always felt her to be a totally dedicated musician. Thanks for responding!
@elainemeyer5062 Жыл бұрын
@@brunyate 😊 I understand what you meant about some of his facial expressions, and bc of it wanting to keep your eyes closed if you saw LL live. I don’t intend for this to change your mind, BUT personally, I think it’s just his own way of expressing himself, being able to ‘feel’, and to become ‘one’ with the piece he’s playing. (I don’t know if you’re familiar with Lola A., or ever watched a video of her play the 🎹, but I’d have to do exactly the same myself, while the majority of men would feel completely different and ogle her due to her physical presentation. She plays with stiletto shoes 👠 , very tight dresses, and has extremely long legs 🦵! * I used Lola as an example, however I don’t feel that she is talented enough to even listen, let alone see, her play. There are many who have the opposite opinion of her than I do.)
@brunyate Жыл бұрын
@@elainemeyer5062 I am of course a man (though an elderly one), and can't deny that YW's personal appearance is a factor! But I'm also a professional musician. I was actually amazed to find that LL played the Turkish Rondo absolutely straight (though about half as fast again as I can); from what he does with, say, Liszt, I would have assumed he would ham it up. I have actually been at one of his concerts, years ago when he was hardly well known. I was impressed then, and am impressed again now. But too many intervening videos made me change my opinion in between. But I will listen with closed eyes in the future, and perhaps my good impression can remain. Let's leave it at that, shall we?
@elainemeyer5062 Жыл бұрын
@@brunyate Absolutely 👍 ! BTW, I too was a classical pianist - and organist (since I was 5 and I’m now almost 70), and have a tendency to be extremely ‘picky’ about pianists and even other musicians as well. I like to see their hands and fingers up close when I watch them play - either in person or on a video. I guess it’s the same for you being a professional, and maybe we each look at a performance in a different way and like or dislike it for our own reasons. Happy listening!
As a piano learner, I would prefer Lang Lang's performance. Firstly, In the techical aspect, Yu Jia stands out. She could still keep the melody clean and precise when quickly processing a lot of apregios. However, in terms of musicality, Lang Lang clearly wins. His performance is full of various dynamics but at the same time, keeping the melody smooth. However, although Yu Jia's performance shows a high level of skill complexity, she lacks control on the tempo and the atmosphere of the piece. Finally, in terms of completion, Lang Lang is definitely better. Yu Jia failed to keep the piece as a whole and has only succeeded on showing off her so-called splendid skills
@elainemeyer5062 Жыл бұрын
👍I already wrote more than one comment about this video and my preference for LL’s overall treatment of it. What you explained is how I feel when comparing the two versions, and why. Both of them having studied with the same person, the main difference is in how they each ‘interpret’ and play so differently as far as their ‘expressiveness’ and emotion (or lack there of!) * I’m not referring to the technical aspects or level of difficulty - she’s very good in this respect, but…
@chloeadams8703 Жыл бұрын
There is nothing wrong with her tempo.
@elainemeyer5062 Жыл бұрын
LOL 😂 ‘Splendid skills’ as in her technical ones with the 🎹, OR her LEGS 🦵?! I’m a woman so I’m not a good judge of that, or care to be!
@朱肇亮-f9x10 ай бұрын
論評⇒分析貼切了然!
@spacejackson1612 Жыл бұрын
我想大家都很明白,今天其實不是王羽佳 VS 朗朗,而是王羽佳 VS 莫札特。 再高超的技巧,在音樂神童面前還是得俯首稱臣。套一句Salieri 的話 “Displace one note and there would be diminishment. Displace one phrase and the structure would fall” 這場是莫札特贏了。但雖敗猶榮
Yuja is an extraordinary musician and lang lang is an excellent performers. Sorry to say there is big differences between the 2. I have heard yuja playing volodes version of Turkish March in person, it was even more impressive.
Hell what a great piano play battle....unfortunateley I can't understand all the comments here under this video BUT Yuja Wang you did an awesome job and show I like your slower play 🙂