Madison Love - Sour Candy (Writer’s Demo)

[@-l-2865]

This version suits Blackpink’s style. Would’ve been a great track for their album last year. It could’ve been a song after “Crazy over you” since they have similar tunes/whatsoever as well. Lady gaga’s version was also great. Love both versions.

[@diegomg1]

YES YES this song after COY would’ve been amazing

[@fynnhmr]

Crazy over you was the biggest disappointment last year. It had such a good prechorus but the chorus was such a letdown

[@-l-2865]

@@fynnhmr it is a song that would grow on you. Let it grow.

[@fynnhmr]

@@-l-2865 honestly i gave it so many trys but its just always the disappointment 😂

[@kunikuzushit]

@@fynnhmr I felt the same at first but after a few listens, I got really attached. it's a good song imo but everyone has their preferences

[@SelfieMasters]

this has more of the blackpink style

[@undergroundgirl74]

i think she did the demo for BP

[@danenghia]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpSniqSIiZqJaNE

[@user-uw9js4oy5c]

@Luiz Ribeiro ik but it suits bp more tho

[@blackpinkblink979]

Yeah it suit blackpink 🤓 but not that much tho

[@hellohello.123]

@@blackpinkblink979 the writer made the song for bp but gave it to lady gaga, and surprisingly Lady Gaga invited bp to sing the song too. Best Coincidence

[@gagassunflower]

this one is more "ancient" while the chromatica version is more futuristic, i think both are equally amazing and perfectly produced!

[@pietbml7397]

For me the album's version of the album is influenced by the 2010s and 80s, like a club song, fashion show, not very futuristic or new, I like it tho

[@Javiergcrespo]

"ancient"? It sounds very 2000s. ANCIENT??

[@psytch4258]

nope, this is waaaay better

[@gloomyblue227]

NOT ANCIENT SJSKJSKSKSSKKS

[@charlotteaitchison2922]

NOT ANCIENT PLS 😭😭😭

[@MissCristinaLee]

Is it just me...or does this sound like it belongs in a Monster High movie? Either way I’m living for it

[@danenghia]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpSniqSIiZqJaNE

[@vaneezailyas5201]

Yess

[@wytheli]

I can see that too , yessssh :D

[@btsshmoodlove5014]

YES

[@okay7970]

omfg yes

[@gregorio3413]

The original is amazing, but this one… LITERALLY A BOP

[@TheDavidfallon]

Um, this is the original...

[@karikhia1]

this is the og

[@Ashjustexists]

This is the original

[@sammyUknow]

Album version washed this up w ease

[@beomblast]

Guys I think they meant that this is better than the official song

[@OfficialMashArt]

The production in this version >>>

[@martinumber1]

uhhhhh noooooo

[@stargirljules]

Um no it's incomplete asf

[@ShineBright506]

yes lady gaga version is kinda sxck

[@depressedsquidward7539]

I like both.

[@rifafatima5697]

If this was the original ver people would have riot for a mv

[@danenghia]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpSniqSIiZqJaNE

[@crushonpink_]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/p3_VoKuYaNuEldU

[@blank-xs2qs]

YES😭😭😭

[@-l-2865]

Ikr. Miss lady gaga it is never too late to make sour candy an official single. ☺️☺️☺️

[@ladyhaha7548]

@@-l-2865 Maybe we'll get it after covid or after Gucci finished its production

[@rosi2794]

why doesn't this maddison makes a career for herself as a singer? her voice is sooo good

[@weavtj1097]

Yess and she’s such a good songwriter

[@Keith.Parker]

She sure is good as a singer. I'm in ❤ with her voice!!!

[@LegionIvory]

Not everyone wishes to be a recording artist. Some just enjoy the creative aspects of music.

[@ricardo6023]

I can see why Gaga took it in a basement club direction. It sounds very much like a 2020 KPop song. It sounds great but it would have sounded of the time whereas the album version sounds timeless. I hope however that Shygirl will use this instrumental.

[@Justin_isslpng]

To those who are wishing that this should've been the one that's released then okay. But this sound won't fit in LADY GAGA'S album Chromatica if it sounds like this. And to those who said that this was written for Blackpink first, then you should blame YG for not accepting it. Just be thankful to Gaga who gave Blackpink the opportunity to release it with her.

[@maika2727]

PEEEEEERRRRRRIIIIIOOOOOOODDDDD!!!!! 💅

[@daydreamer.1997]

Yesss speaking truth and a Chen stan over here? ❤ Love it

[@-l-2865]

It isn’t YGE’s fault. The producer gave the demo to Lady Gaga first even though the writer wanted to invite Blackpink for this song.

[@maika2727]

@@-l-2865 No. Blackpink signs with Gaga's same American Record Label "Interscope Record" the writer already wrote the songs for Blackpink but they ignored it so Gaga's producer Bloodpop took it.

[@maika2727]

@@-l-2865 Blackpink & Lady Gaga are in the same American Label if they already proposed the songs to Blackpink it's more easy since Interscope holds the right for it. But YGE or Blackpink ignored the song.

[@VictorGagoArt]

1:06 This part for just one second sounds like Lana 😮

[@armywithluv55]

Omg

[@strawberrykn]

omg real

[@trangiahuy2957]

OMG SKSKSKSSKSKSKKSK

[@wtfff_fer]

Yaaaaassss

[@danenghia]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpSniqSIiZqJaNE

[@dannymvsic]

To be honest. This has better transitions between verses than the álbum versión. This versión is better intrumentally. And the final cut is good too. This has a vibe like tatu with blackpink.

[@armywithluv55]

Omg youre right, the original the transitions between verses are weird

[@markfelix3738]

t.A.T.u. ❤❤❤❤

[@Song_of_hers]

now that you said it, it def gives off tatu vibes

[@cleve736]

This version isn’t gay enough

[@roizeldiez3500]

Nice and smart of u to bring up tatu, now thinking abt it, it actually sounds like them! 😁

[@freddierenoiz]

it's like if Sour Candy was on The Fame tracklist

[@zalamazhk]

Yes! Omg

[@danenghia]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpSniqSIiZqJaNE

[@crushonpink_]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/p3_VoKuYaNuEldU

[@victorkd9926]

More like the fame monster

[@freddierenoiz]

@@victorkd9926 yeah, it kinda bounces between the fame and the fame monster

[@gagasaccomplice1089]

I like how they included the yell in the final version :))

[@TheNraveles]

This transports me to a 2004 club in the basement of some ratty building. Dark, humid af, bass blasting, too many people in one area for comfort, but everyone is having a great fucking time

[@brendav4695]

I was 3 but I got you girl

[@djiedragon]

True

[@pbj4142]

I was literally 1 but sure yeah I guess

[@vl2663]

That reminded me of Britney’s “I’m a Slave 4 U” video

[@AB-tl6se]

S-Sour Candy I'm sour candy So sweet, then I get a little angry, yeah Sour candy, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah I'm super psycho Make you crazy when I turn the lights low Sour candy, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah Ask me to be nice and then I'll do it extra mean Cause it don't really matter yeah we know we'll get the street Inside I got heart of gold but no don't tell the streets nah nah, nah, nah, If you wanna fix me then let's break up here and now If you wanna win me then let's make love for love(?) So tell me that I'm special when I walk in you say wow uh-uh, uh, uh I'm hard on the outside But if you give me time Then I could make time for your love I'm hard on the outside But if you see inside, inside, inside I'm sour candy So sweet, then I get a little angry, yeah Sour candy, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah I'm super psycho Make you crazy when I turn the lights low Sour candy, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah

[@thucanhnguyenphuong1111]

“Lets make up, not fall down”, actually

[@danenghia]

@@thucanhnguyenphuong1111 kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpSniqSIiZqJaNE

[@lilac5706]

are you sure about this line? (Cause it don't really matter yeah we know we'll get the street)

[@AB-tl6se]

@@lilac5706 oh i'm not sure at all, i just wanted to figure out the lyrics, hopefully it's accurate.

[@yazaddastur8576]

Am I the only one who heard we’ll get the “streams” ? Cause blinks are a huge fandom?

[@Karla-wb3id]

If Sour Candy was on The Album this version would fit perfectly, but it's on Chromatica where original version fits much better

[@trajerarusseldavel.5713]

Since bp wasn't labeled as featured artists on this song, they can put it in their own album and made a new version for them.....

[@TheBoomerang32]

@@trajerarusseldavel.5713 they have zero writing credits on the song though so technically speaking it doesn’t belong to them. They just sang it.

[@sungjin-woo4979]

@@TheBoomerang32 but Teddy, BlackPink's main producer, is also part of the producer list on the final version

[@kerol5905]

I really like this version 😮 Even more of the "end product" they went for in the end. The demo IS REALLY GOOD!

[@mercedeszfenyo8941]

*This woman is super talented...*

[@Drebe73]

Explains why Gaga sounds like she’s a guest on the track.

[@LegionIvory]

I believe it was Gaga's idea to make it that way. After the song was given to her instead of Blackpink, she asked for them to be on the record anyway, and gave their original verses to them.

[@oompz3060]

she sucked this era plsss served nothing

[@tsu8229]

@@oompz3060 shut

[@redloriyellowlori]

@@oompz3060 she's getting ready to retire leave her old knees alone!

[@BritneyHIAM]

@@oompz3060 Gaga hasn't served since 2013

[@TShay92]

Demo's are always fire 🔥

[@valeisfine]

We were robbed this is amazing omg

[@bernardocarvalho3399]

1:20 I went crazy here holy shiiiiit

[@crushonpink_]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/p3_VoKuYaNuEldU

[@mayo5365]

Wow, this woman should be a popular singer. Is she, guys? Amazing

[@carlstalker9670]

The drop made me cry omfg

[@crushonpink_]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/p3_VoKuYaNuEldU

[@TheNraveles]

THIS IS SO EARLY 2000’s DARK CLUB MSUIC AHHHH

[@ricardo6023]

Not really it sounds like a 2020 KPop song I can see why Gaga changed it to a basement track. It’s a good song for sure but it could’ve been lost in time 🤔

[@ricardo6023]

@Luiz Ribeiro the final is meant to be a basement club song. This definitely does not sound like an early 2000s club song this is definitely a 2020 KPop song. Early 2000s club music was more hip hop r&b influenced. I can see what you mean about the demo sounding like an Ashley Tisdale song but that was more late 2000s.

[@TheNraveles]

@@ricardo6023 listen to early 2000’s darker cub music.this is exactly what it sounds like

[@ricardo6023]

@@TheNraveles that’s such a broad statement, you’re going to have to give us names and song titles. Clubs play a variety of different music, I’m just saying that this sounds closer to the 2020s than early 2000s. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with that.

[@Raphael-2]

@@ricardo6023 But a lot of recent songs are inspired by early 2000s music. This demo totally sounds like something that could have been released in the early 2000s. It sounds much more early 2000s than 2020 k-pop. Honestly when i discovered more early 2000s music I was surprised at how much modern it was and close to nowadays music. Basically a lot of nowadays music (the good music) is recycling older music, and you think this is new but it's not.

[@Jooyaa503]

So basically from what I’ve heard this song was originally planned by Madison Love to be BLACKPINKs song but instead it became Lady Gaga’s song and they turned into what to we know now as Sour Candy by Lady Gaga, featuring BLACKPINK.

[@trajerarusseldavel.5713]

Blackpink wasn't labeled as featured artists there and bloodpop brought sour candy to Gaga cause they're Management didn't accept it and Gaga decided to put BP there...

[@bluedthaddeustimbang6145]

this would’ve fit artpop or the fame or kill this love really well but the final makes sense being in chromatica

[@matheusfulco4051]

this instrumental is so good, more original than the sample in the oficial version.

THIS VERSION IS A MASTERPIECE!!! OMG 🔥🛐

[@ayo7208]

Does no one else love her own voice it fits herself wayyy more then blackpink or lady gaga like comon i love the demo wayyyy more

[@bristydas5048]

I like this one more. Actually I love both. But if sour candy sung by Madison love and blackpink on this tune and if the lyrics are also in English , I think it may be sound more sexy. But no problem I love lady gaga and bp version too. Blackpink in your area 🖤💓🖤💓🖤💓🖤 😘

[@andrewhudson88]

I always sing the English translations out loud and it just feels so satisfying to hear them properly and know I’m not just butchering it (especially that “inside gotta heart of gold moment)!

[@badmanicpower]

This sounds like if it was just BlackPink singing it and it wasn’t a Chromatica song

[@Alina-jb3jk]

Becouse the song was meant for bp dut yg declined

[@monohopead5553]

This is pure sass.. I mean imagine choreography they would have performed on it 🔥🔥

[@bhawanipadhi9345]

Yess!!!

[@a.fragnant.flower]

Both are amazing but this one is superb too

[@FAMEIV]

this is a little better in my opinion, but i'm glad they went with the album version because the sound they went with is more timeless and has more replay quality

[@Keith.Parker]

I'm loving Madison Love!!!!!!

[@Lou-bj9tk]

It's so fun to see how this is really a bp style song, while the chromatica ver sounds so lady gaga-esque. The writers did an amazing job adapting it to Lady Gaga ! Love both versions, but I have a slight preference for the chromatica one, maybe cause it's the more well-produced one and the first ver I heard...I'm sure that if the demo ver had been released on a bp album first I would have been hooked as well.

[@alessiorappa2081]

OMG this so better than the final version! What a pity!

[@tanton2531]

quero essa versão no spotify

[@danenghia]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpSniqSIiZqJaNE

[@jisoosbabiee]

@@danenghia shut it

[@mzko6174]

The production on this is so good!!

[@davidhay7657]

K but can we get a Mashup with this kinda drop because I LIVE

[@danenghia]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpSniqSIiZqJaNE

[@crushonpink_]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/p3_VoKuYaNuEldU

[@rickross80]

@@danenghia Thanks

[@jvictor001]

This version is so much better and the voice is so sweet,it really fits the song.

[@sinefromabovebabylon3577]

This was just a pitch for black pink.. I kinda like the girls intro in this more than the album version I THINK. But no gaga 100% made it better in the final.. this has a clean western finish which makes it pleasing to listen too. My issues with black pink after I discoverered last year is... they’re sound is very late. Like their sound is very much dubstep instrumentals with vocals on top. It’s so hard to connect emotionally to them. I like their sad and more slower songs better. But yeah the final version is better... I love love love gagas classic part.. but I wish with this intro from the demo they would include it in the final...

[@danenghia]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpSniqSIiZqJaNE

[@crushonpink_]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/p3_VoKuYaNuEldU

[@toffeetoby3585]

It's because kpop is really different from western sounds, YG songs is the closest to western sound but still have a perfect mix or kpop

[@sinefromabovebabylon3577]

@@toffeetoby3585 but kpop is western sound though?

[@Babyitseu]

Kpop is not western sound, it is westernized, but not western tho

[@tohida8642]

Indian Vibe, feeling home !

[@jemescobar]

RELEASE IT!! I'M BEGGING YOU, OH MY GOD LISAA

[@quynhanhdao8473]

so catchy!!!!

[@crushonpink_]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/p3_VoKuYaNuEldU

[@SylvesterArnab]

Love this version.

[@adrian_hook]

The drums from the final version with the rest of the instrumentation from this version would be perfection 🥴

[@IAMASELENATOR92]

That intro/instrumental is so good

[@chielytavry9656]

It should have reached million right by now

[@chielytavry9656]

She changed it so much... We have our choices to live upon now😂😂. Both are incomparable

[@scottiliciousmcfabulous]

Both versions are so unique. 😱

[@JuanIshidaGaray]

Necesito que Gaga y las Pinks graben esta versión y nos den un MV :'(

[@aerolbacle8108]

This version is fireeee

[@itsbrenoalodeh]

Sour candy is my favorite track from chormatica but THIS, is a masterpiece from another planet, i never thought i need this

[@sserabulous]

This is so good that I wanna hear the original song produced like this

[@aellusion9658]

This could've been a bop if this was the original 😭😭❤️

[@ellaangelatv7577]

This sound so goooddd

[@brettmcneil]

Okay so she wrote the entire song wow. Icon!!!

[@sinefromabovebabylon3577]

No lol not gagas part

[@AB-tl6se]

yes she did it she also wrote gaga's chorus only part she didn't write is "i might be messed up..."

[@sinefromabovebabylon3577]

@@AB-tl6se ok so not gagas verse then?

[@novad1stribution116]

just in info this was intended to be offered to BP but the producer of Chromatica Sent this unfinished demo to gaga first so gaga took it and add little more verse and mixes of beats and offered BP to join aswell

[@novad1stribution116]

@@sinefromabovebabylon3577 read my comment 😊

[@carlstalker9670]

I want this released to the public

[@alien_fugitive]

It just was lol

[@MyTam1981]

This is cute but album version is superior wbk

[@pablolinares2801]

Even better than the album version

[@notilator]

should’ve kept this production on the official version, its more fresh

[@lvlykonig]

madison love called us untalented in a nearly two minutes video😭

[@Rezyon]

This version is so much more exciting

[@BenJMartin95]

The whole “hard on the outside” section is so, so good

[@adri7476]

OMG this is so good wtf

[@Asepa99]

I love the og version obvi, but I totally see this on a bp album

[@broken-zv5pt]

When my indian blink heart heard it have indian vibes i came to listen

[@lovelypeachy6493]

I thought it was arabic

[@broken-zv5pt]

Ya but many indian music have this kind of vibe

[@user-ig3kq8gn9y]

The singer sound similar to Blackpink. This version sound so suit with BP.

[@excalibur3164]

That basssssssss!!!!

[@EduardoClavel]

Me encanta el ritmo 😍😍❤️

[@mela9601]

I need a full version 👁️👄👁️

[@rxtrograde5136]

this version gives me chills omfg

[@crisleyvonitalia7138]

I love this

[@teodonisdavidjustimianogon6522]

El instrumental es demasiado WOW

[@danenghia]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpSniqSIiZqJaNE

[@aiquinn]

This is 100% better than the released version. This demo doesn't sound as rushed and unfinished lol

[@ruth3431]

If Gaga's sounded this good I'd still be listening to it. I feel like I could listen to this more.

[@luiznogueira7105]

somebody do a mashup now!

[@элина-е4д]

Omg this sounds so good, I feel like I'm in heaven 👌🏼🧚👼💃

[@alma9727]

i'm obsessed😳

[@NachoBlueYT]

THIS IS SO GOOD OMG WHY DID THEY SCRAP IT

[@ryanfaure3120]

They did not?

[@NachoBlueYT]

@@ryanfaure3120 That's the Demo...

[@ryanfaure3120]

@@NachoBlueYT well yeah they didn't scrap the song

[@NachoBlueYT]

@@ryanfaure3120 I'm talking about the demo

[@jisoosbabiee]

@@NachoBlueYT i think they scrapped this because the vibe is completely different from chromatica, so it wouldn't have worked on it

[@yogurt2924]

I like this more than the album version tbh

[@itsmefotisb4247]

LOVE THIS omg

[@xuxu337]

i love this version

[@xhstan]

This is so much better omg

[@carlstalker9670]

We still listening to this, cause I can not get enough

[@samuelphillipe3135]

I NEED A EXTENDED VERSION FR!

[@cartoonstoons-q1r]

Oh my God this is beautiful

[@sserabulous]

This is more interesting than the original edm production

[@rickeymehra5329]

It's can be an all original sour candy blackpink version...... Just too good🙈🙊

[@lee_yumii]

This is lit🔥🔥

[@lunarlino]

I like this one more. It wouldn’t have worked on Chromatica though-

[@cassinirose]

why is this way better than the released version

[@kittenstamales6219]

THIS SOUNDS GREAT

[@carlstalker9670]

YALL I CAN NOT STOP LISTENING

[@drewpalacio3815]

ME ENCANTA 🔥😍

[@kienggharold]

Omg this is too cool!