Maison Margiela Replica FROM THE GARDEN Review + Tomato Leaves Fragrances 🍅🍅🍅

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

🪵🪵🪵 Please watch Top Niche Woody Scents Video here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aafKdJechseieKM 🪵🪵🪵

[@financeYH]

Bought Maison Margiela From the Garden a couple of months ago because it reminded me of Sisley's Eau de Campagne which I have had since 2005, wow.. for almost 20 years :) I LOVE Diptyque's L'Ombre Dans and prefer L'Ombre Dans L'eau to MM. Probably, because I prefer that very nice back currant leaf note to tomato leaf note.. Also, the geranium note and green patchuli from MM From the Garden, L'Ombre Dans and Sisley's Eau de Champagne makes me think of the greenest patchuli ever - Patricia de Nicolai's Patchuli Intense. Patricia Nicolai is the keeper of french tradition in perfumery and what classy perfumes she makes. Great video, Sebastian.

[@JayWalia]

When I think tomato leaf I think Hermes Un Jardin Sur Le Nil!

[@RobbnCO]

I think Brioni Eau de Parfum Essentiel

[@docm5314]

I always think of a spa when I smell geranium 🥰 so relaxing.

[@gourmandyandy]

I bought 30ml it’s sooooooo good ❤ Apparently Olivier did 10% and 90% his son Sébastien

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Dang it!! Okay well father and son is fine! :)

[@lala_bee]

Got the travel spray bc it wasn't in stores and was intrigued. I like it and have been saving it for warmer days. It is light, but considering the notes, it works for me. I added Prada's Infusion de Gingembre and that definitely added some depth to it. So happy that you reviewed this and similar fragrances.

[@rebeccainthemiddle]

How exciting, I love the idea of tomato leaf in fragrance! Thanks for the reminder about the Sisley one, too :) definitely inspired to track these down.

[@johnregan4673]

I love the tomato leaf note. Eau de Campagne is my favourite, but Chef's Table by MiN New York is a close second. Super realistic tomato leaf with basil and sage. Nobody talks about it, but it's fantastic

[@Pinerocks]

I got great projection and longevity from my sample. I will be buying a full bottle.

[@ginnievestal9774]

I was looking for tomato leaf fragrances a year or two ago in spring when I had the smell of the actual leaves on my hands. I can’t help but be joyful when I smell the leaves. The closest thing at the time I could find was Moss by Commodity. It is powerful and a punch in the face. No tomato leaf accord listed but it does trick my mind to believe it is there.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Oh I can see this, it's quite green. I love Moss btw too. Moss and Petigrain to the max! :)

[@saaacredwaaater4730]

I love green scents so this is very appealing to me. I have tried Italian Leather Memo Paris but nothing else. Must try. Thanks Sebastian for the great review.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

You are so welcome!

[@CathyVaughn-ph3lr]

Sorry but the price point for the replica fragrances is too much for me because they do not last at all.

[@Ltlmscrl]

In my experience the Dossier versions perform better than the originals.

[@raucusretread]

Interesting note. I don't love it, and I don't hate it. Im simply trying to learn it. I do like the Memo, however. Great Topic! Thanks! Cheers!🎉🎉🎉😊

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

thank you for stopping by! :)

[@OceanluvOC]

I have From the Garden and I’m really enjoying it to wear at work as well as for my daytime scent! Price is high for not being eau de Parfum but oh well, I still enjoy it 🤷🏼‍♀️

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Great. But yes pricey for EDT! :(

[@mikebrengartner5484]

I have a sample of Joop! All about Adam (I think that's the name?) that also has a lot of tomato leaf. I love the tomato leaf scent - can't wait to try this!

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

I discussed the What About Adam in this Vintage Haul video: kzbin.info/www/bejne/bIeTgGyngp5gors

[@sore.neculai87]

Exactly yesterday I was looking for perfumes with tomato leaves and black currant leaves .

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

WOOHOO. Thank you for stopping by! :)

[@ems_h.eartnotes]

Found at Dusk by Miller Harris is way better in my opinion

[@hey.noah.]

My faves is definitely Diptyque's l'ombre dans l'eau, Sisley Eau d'Campagne and Annick Goutal's Folavril that is sadly discontinued.

[@debrajane7622]

I’ll have to check out Italian Leather, because I do really enjoy Iris Malikhan (never would have known they were similar)! Thanks for the video, Sebastian! ❤

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

You're welcome. Thank you for stopping by!! :)

[@laurakateschnitzer42]

Love a tomato leaf note!

[@tabathahussey]

🍅 🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅🍅 the feeling and mood tomato leaf scents evoke is pure summertime joy. I try and smell all and any I can. I hadn’t put Galbanam and Tomato leaf together but I see it! Aube Pashmina by Pierre Guillaume is/ was(?) a lovely one.

[@Ltlmscrl]

I love the green and vegetal, as well as grassy notes but I’m reserved about wearing them in public.

[@K0koma]

Have you gotten your nose on Piper & Perro Vines? Notes: Grapefruit Rind, Tomato Leaf, Green Fig, Water Lily, Hyacinth, Moss

[@rena7123]

So interesting - I like tomato and tomato leaves, but I never got this scentnote in un Jardin sur le nile (which I regularly repurchase for many years now). Sadly, so far I had no opportunity to smell the new MM. I love Iris malikhan since I received a sample with my yearly Christmas perfume purchase. Absolutely on my wishlist since then. The Vaniteese from Dita v.T. reminds me a bit of Iris malikhan. Recently I wore a lot of Hunq the Gardener (airy minty to my untrained nose 😅). Thx for the great overview ✨🍅 now I'm even more curious to try the new Margiela.

[@justaddlight]

The video I was waiting for! 🍅🌿 Thank you Sebastian! Really wish What About Adam would make a comeback, but I'll have to try Dandelion Fig and L'ima. 💚 Planting season is finally upon us here up north.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

YES thank you for stopping by! :)

[@lynnleglaire4819]

All sound great. My favorite is Stil Green Spell from Eris Parfumes. Eis de Campaigne is Veit too light wearing for me…I go through a bottle a summer.

[@carlosmunoz2192]

Valentino uomo acqua has a lovely tomato leaf note.

[@JT-rx1eo]

I've got a 10ml decant of Memo Italian Leather that Im test wearing, and so far Im not totally enamored with the tomato leaf and leather combo. Maybe Ill learn to like it more as I wear it. Ive test worn MMM Replica From the Garden and like it enough to put it on my full bottle to-buy list. Ive had a bottle of Le Jardin Sur Le Nil for a long time now and have learned to love it. It has tomato to my nose. Not sure if its more the leaf or fruit itself. Coincidentally, with my Memo Italian Leather decant I received a sample of Iris Malikhan. Sprayed Iris Malikhan on paper and didn't get a comparison to Italian Leather, just another makeupy powdery iris. But haven't worn it yet.

[@melp8175]

Sounds interesting . I will test this first . The Sephora reviews are bad.

[@tatyanazlotnikov-goncharov5570]

I got it from sephora 15 ml, I liked it only for 15-30 minutes ( it was exactly that tomato leaves note) after drying down, it smells like a very cheap air freshener on me. I own Diptyque L'Ombre dans L'Eau and I am in love with this parfume frome first notes to the dry down

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Oh bummer! :(

[@michaelbullock8011]

Great video and I enjoyed it and I'm going to try these fragrances and have a blessed day

[@alimaalikhan]

For what you get, I’ve always found MM fragrances overpriced and that’s at the old prices. For EDTs,THEIR EDTs anyway, are not worth the price.

[@boogiedaddy3434]

I honestly don't know if I have smelled many tomato leaf fragrances. I'm picky about green notes and don't like them if they turn too sharp or bitter. I'll have to try a few of these to see if they work out for me.

[@chrisls912]

I find tomato leaves to smell almost exactly like the plant lantana’s flowers. It grows in hot dry climates, it’s sold as an annual here in Colorado. Anyone else?

[@carolinesutton5231]

Great video!! I really like Summer Vine by Foras. Not sure it is available outside of the UK, though

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

OOH must check!! :)

[@sondesix_]

I really like this one. Tried it when I was visiting Singapore earlier this month and I think it is quite unique, fresh, and pleasant. Would love to get a bottle of it someday. But yeah, the performance is underwhelming.

[@funeka691]

I love to eat salad. But I don't want to smell like it.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

LOL!

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

I love the tomato leaf accord. The Replica is the only one I don’t like at all. It’s too fleeting.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

It's light for sure!! :)

[@syrpentina]

I enjoy Un Jardin Sur Le Nil by Hermes. Its more green and garden-like but there is a tomato note💕

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Oh yes I do get tomato like qualities in there! :)

[@zackwilson8283]

It’s nice but 10 ml would last me a while.

[@SmellsAddicted]

Black currant? Aventus! Just kidding 😂

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

LOL

[@demimiforrest1349]

I’m a big fan of green scents! I love Italian Leather which I don’t really get any leather at all. Yes! To me, it absolutely reminds me of Iris Malikhan! I love them both but I think Iris Malikhan is a bit better but less tomato leafy. I just tried From The Garden last weekend in Sephora and it smelled freaking amazing. I was tempted to buy it but I wanted to wait until their Rouge sale. It became very faint 2-3 hours mark so now I’m not sure. I think this summer I will stick with my longest lasting green magic - Synthetic Jungle❤

[@NorthMountain]

Lovely note, Miller Harris used it a lot. Sisley is gorgeous too!

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

YES

[@nicolenonya5874]

jo malone should bring back Wild Strawberry and Parsley - tomato leaf in there.

[@FayeCNL]

I can't even cope with how amazing tomato leaf scents are

[@JT-rx1eo]

😂

[@zankfrappe5145]

I got a Campbell's soup vibe from the replica. 😬

[@randyharpel619]

Shuhrah by Rasasi has a very strong tomato leaf note.

[@heykerryann]

I picked it up this week and I love it. Im a Carolina Herrera 212, Issey miyake and recently Vilhelm Parfumerie purple fig for reference

[@sergeidani8272]

in 2017-2018 year Maison Margiela for each bottle of perfume 100 ml. I paid 55 dollars. why is it now 3 times more expensive? Perhaps this brand was bought by a large conglomerate and is now making money

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

You must have gotten a discount cause I have never seen Margiela Replica for $55 anywhere! :)

[@sergeidani8272]

@@ThePerfumeGuy Large perfume stores can offer good discounts from time to time, but even without a discount on a regular day they cost $80-90 per bottle

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

WOW you got some deals on those. I wish I did! :)

[@kharrell8356]

I've had a tomato fragrance for the home not for personal use.

[@Betmas2]

Idk. Replica might be EDT but the ones I wear last on me all day

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

It's so interesting. Everyone has complained about the longevity of the MM fragrances and here you come and say it lasts all day. Which is good. :)

[@viggenone]

Interesting I don't have in my olfactive memory the smell of Tomato leaves and I don't have any fragrance from the list 😬I need to go to the market to remind me of their smell also try some samples. Thanks for the video Sebastian!!!

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Thanks for sharing!!

[@Shanikaish1]

What do you think is a good scent to layer with l'ombre dans l'eau to freshen it up. I find it to be too overwhelmingly wet and mossy green has a vintage, old smell to it, sorta sticks on the skin and feels suffocating. Even with the ETD a little goes a long way.

[@stevend2730]

Lol was just smelling From the Garden and looking into these yesterday. Great timing!

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Perfect!

[@kircur]

I can’t believe the perfect capture of tomato vine that L’Ombre dans L’Eau is could possibly be beat. It is so accurate and transcendent. Love it so much!

Replica's tomato leave is much more realistic.

[@jennyyang2257]

You have to try Eris Greenspell!! That’s the most beautiful green/tomatoes leaf fragrance I’ve ever smelled.

[@alecgutteridge4606]

I absolutely love tomato leaf fragrances! I would be curious to hear what you think about another tomato leaf/vine fragrance: CB 103 Memory of Kindness as there aren't many reviews for that brand's offerings. Thank you for everything you do!

[@joseluisrodriguezritte2734]

I have Vale tino Uomo Acqua… veeery good and fresh tomato scent… (among mandarin, iris and leather…)

[@carashobby]

I have a travel spray and really enjoy it. I would definitely consider a full bottle when I see on the discount sites. $165 is way too much for what this is.

[@jacybonnot3548]

In Vetiver Ecarlate the list of ingredients looks really great, but from what I know it is laced with ambroxan..

[@freddykruger8229]

The 2 tomato leaf fragrances that I have and love are: Memo Paris - Italian Leather and Rasasi- Shuhrah Pour Homme.

[@audreyhou1342]

To me, this smells very similar to Byredo's Pulp, which i owned.

[@Zzzooooppp]

LOVE vetiver Ecarlate

[@heatherw5632]

Love tomato leaf - quite evocative of my own childhood when we picked tomatoes and canned them. Replica is my favorite because it does go green but perfumey still.

I would like you to do a video on best grapefruits/pomelos in fragrances.

[@oodoo79]

From the Garden has been around since last year when I got it. Love it ! I have another Tomato by Quentin Bisch for O Boticário

[@veronicaixta6597]

I really enjoy the tomato/ tomato leaf fragrance. It also reminds me of my mom’s garden and I’m actually growing tomatoes right now! I agree with you in regards to the lightness of the fragrance. Great video!

[@mohammadyounis7852]

Nice

[@weltbuerger23]

Where is un jardin sur le nil?

[@amnetaa.a8064]

14:03 exactly I’m agree with you Italian leather really smells like to me like Iris malikhan

[@keenan13jpn]

Un Jardin Sur Le Nil by Hermes

[@moondust013]

🌹

[@jasvirsandhu1158]

Hey Sebastian 👋🏻 Jazz Club and By the Fire Place are my favorites like all of Folks ☺️ I like the smell of Tomato plants but don’t like Tomatoes a lot

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

LOL yeah you have to like tomatos or tomato leaves smell to enjoy this one. It's an acquired taste for sure! :)

[@alimaalikhan]

I smell Sur le Nil, and love it, but I smell no tomato.

[@angelsshare.]

Thanks for the reviews. Hard pass on anything tomato-scented, especially tomato leaves.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

I understand

[@SmellsAddicted]

You grew up in a garden? We're you a Cabbage Patch Kid? 😂

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

LOL

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Definitely not a cabbage patch or garbage pail kid! ;)

[@SmellsAddicted]

😂👍

[@brookef2368]

I also have the scent memory of my grandpa's tomato patch & spending time there with him. I don't want to wear it but I want to buy one for the memory just to sniff. Great video.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Awesome!! I love those kinds of scent memories! :)

Orchidivy is nauseatingly sweet. Yuck, it has very little to do with tomato leaves.

[@SmellsAddicted]

I love Memo Paris Italian Leather 😍😋

[@jennybrodrig]

Wonder if smell similar to dkny New York?

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

I can't remember the DKNY NY. I would love to find it but long gone now I think.

[@jts4248]

Wow this would be interesting

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

It certainly is.

[@ilseschiborr6727]

🍅❣️

[@nubnub75]

Looking great as always!

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Thank you! Cheers!

[@funeka691]

Yeah, not sure about this one.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Yeah I think I remember you mentioning you don't like green notes. This is uber green.

[@pamelabrown8467]

Thanks for sharing 🥰

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

You're welcome, thank you for stopping by! :)

[@adamasharisugiono6298]

I think you forgot Rasasi shuhrah

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Don't own it!

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

I'm going to write it down and order it next time I buy some stuff. Does it smell like anything else?

[@freddykruger8229]

​@@ThePerfumeGuyit is heavy tomato leaf to me and then the rose hits. I don't know if it smells like any other fragrance.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

I'm going to have to get it then. Thank you both for the comments!!

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Actually I just ordered it. Let's see how good it is??

[@roxysimmons]

Sorry, but NOTHING beats DKNY Women (the original version).

[@mikeczyz]

Criminal to not include Eris Parfums Green Spell

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Nothing is ever criminal! Especially when it comes to not listing certain fragrances! LOL!

[@mikeczyz]

@@ThePerfumeGuy :)