Make Up & Money | A Lipstick Gate Analysis

[@Personal_Chizo]

SELL THE LIPSTICK TO WHOM, JACLYN? *FUCKING AQUAMAN?!*

[@MrThebadger200]

Hermes Bouza this is the better comment

[@MaggieMaeFish]

I loved yours too tho !

[@MrThebadger200]

Maggie Mae Fish love you Maggie! You're making some A tier content rn

[@ThatOneGuy7550]

I read that in Hbomberguy's voice

[@cottoncandie761]

Next stop for dumping subpar commercial wastes into the food chain, fertilizer and animal feed.

[@lucifera1456]

She keeps saying her lipsticks are FDA approved but even the FDA clapped back and said they don’t give approval to cosmetics sooo...

To be fair she didn't say her lipsticks were FDA approved she said the ingredients in them are FDA approved ... Which also makes no sense now that I think about it LOL. That's like saying th tomatos in the tomato ketchup are FDA approved ... Goddamn every way I turn she's deceptive.

[@MsMouthy]

They give approval to ingredients not the actual cosmetic. So technically she’s right when she said made with FDA approved ingredients.

[@MsMouthy]

Rchl Swtzr anything out for mass consumption ie Ketchup, is made with FDA approved ingredients. So I like your metaphor 🤣

[@pjhogue1987]

Toni Coulson they “clapped back” 🤦‍♀️😂

[@bararobberbaron859]

Well I mean, steel and plastic are FDA approved right?

[@hollyann5717]

Damn. You exposed her more than any of the drama channels. Everyone should see this.

[@TheKatarinaGiselle]

Right?! And I’m just seeing it now, but so glad I found this vid and watched until the end. This woman deserves more followers! This video should have been the top in recommended during lipstick-gate (or whatever the hell ppl refer to it as!)

[@ellenvlachos304]

I can't believe I get to watch makeup drama and learn about tax avoidance at the same time.

[@Lafemmefutile]

Ellen Vlachos Learning everywhere- isn’t that great?

[@iciajay6891]

Its a wild ride.

[@dorcaswinter8296]

KZbin giving us the education that school did not 😂

[@brianaschino4903]

Ellen Vlachos LMFAOOOO

[@956lizz]

Lmaoooo this is great

[@ivychu3088]

.....I came for drama and am leaving knowing about tax avoidance and corruption....*takes notes*

[@jenniferr5934]

Marshmallow Princess yes learn something for a change

[@irairod5160]

...aaaaaand here we are, February 2020, and she's out with yet another product, embroiled in another production scandal, and releasing another emotionally-manipulative video directed to the people she "loves the most": her marks, I mean, her "social media family". Yuck!

[@pamelat.1710]

And she "hasn't talked to her father in years" 🙄 she's too much...

[@JustCozItsMe]

Oh this hit right in the faith of humanity. Gotta keep hope... Oh right, morbid humor is an option. So, figures lol...?

[@flipingboredcritic]

How does she even have a following and not been cancelled yet?!

[@willowarkan2263]

@@flipingboredcritic because you can't actually cancel rich people, you can make them lie low for a bit, but sooner or later, they come back and use their canceling to promote themselves, either by faux repentance or by courting the "free speech" defense crowd.

[@flipingboredcritic]

@@willowarkan2263 people are fucking idiots, they should just ignore her, she's a troll lol

[@Annalovesautumn]

Daughter of a wealthy con man becomes wealthy con woman?? Why am I not surprised even SLIGHTLY? This video is incredible.

[@pluutoop]

Wait what?! Who is her dad?

[@nelsonth]

@@pluutoop it's in the video?!

[@heather_doestruecrime]

But she has no contact with her dad?

[@jellybean3524]

Heather J Did you even watch the video? In her fathers non profit she was listed as a part of it. Her parents divorced in 2012, she most definitely had contact with her father growing up if she decided to cut off contact with him after the divorce.

[@xamyx2205]

@@jellybean3524 If you watch her wedding video, her father's there, LOL!

[@blakecooley2292]

"She's also implying that she'd rather be dead than poor" with this line you have succinctly summarized aspirational wealth in capitalism ❤️❤️

[@gimmebackmyarm]

Blake Cooley yes

[@Phor0phor]

Blake Cooley or possibly just greed.

[@livingdeaddemon2350]

Yes. I strongly believe that this is not just hyperbole. Some would LITERALLY want to be dead before being poor.

[@NoOne-is2yr]

@@livingdeaddemon2350 I mean, being poor has certainly made me want to die at times. And it'll probably kill me eventually when I get older and can't afford my medical bills, so.

[@XYZ-kb3mm]

Yeah I’d rather be dead than live under a bridge and die from a preventable disease. Is that so bad?

[@graceandglamor]

This news about her non profits needs to be viral-forget the lipsticks.

[@idrinkandiknowthings9738]

I’m back here a year later to say yes. Yes it should

[@ikeekieeki]

6 months later and yes

[@katherinealvarez9216]

Yes.

[@mj-f7135]

Yes

[@TheMeowMaestro]

Yes!

[@Levyathyn]

Give her six more years, she'll be running her own MLM company

[@aprillittle595]

....or in prison or exile.

[@guillermodebaskerville7117]

It would be called something else to avoid being called out.

[@Elneco1]

@@aprillittle595 haha rich enough to bail out or spend "exile" on a private resort or some shit. Only solution is the french one unfortunately /shrug

[@gupdoo3]

I for one would love her company where everyone is a gay man /j

[@hamburger7243]

has she done it yet?

[@popuchick]

Sooo her dad didnt want to pay taxes on that 4 million settlement and decided to go travel the world under the guise of running a christian charity. Classy.

[@snatchadams69]

Keep in mind not all auto compensation is taxable..

[@ohjalapeno]

Ana Catbutt that’s not a proven fact. I need facts. Not some chick giving her opinion for 25 minutes proves nothing. And I’m not even a Jaclyn fan.

[@Uhohlisa]

@@ohjalapeno ?? She provided a shit ton of facts dude

[@aprillittle595]

His attorneys would have taken at least 30% of that and the insurance company may well have had to pay the taxes before the payout. Anyway, Maggie's story is just a smattering of facts, by no means a complete story. I agree Jaclyn is crooked as can be. I'm pretty sure she's seriously mentally ill and incredibly narcissistic - like, clinically. But again, take this story with a grain of salt. Maybe the takeaway is "don't support JH with your dollars" and then I completely agree.

[@dumbdumber7203]

*Smart

[@PEACHFACE24]

WHOA the religious non profit is new new information. None of the drama channels ever spoke on this. NOW, I’m done with her, ugh!

[@queenkikiNC]

What Maggie conveniently forgot to mention is that Jaclyn’s brother continues to do missionary work with his family in extremely poor countries and this is most likely what Jaclyn’s non profit aids in. She dug back to freaking 1997 yet forgot to mention her brother having JUST been helping other countries- I can’t remember where and I don’t want to mispeak of the exact country but I’m sure, as we all apparently rely on, google can get you that info

[@rockabillymuffin]

@@queenkikiNC Lol. Missonaries are just neo-colonialists. I highly encourage anyone to read up on the fucked up practices of missionaries. Even Mother Theresa was a horrible person, not a hero missionary.

[@lotusthemermaid]

@@rockabillymuffin Maybe some of them, but I've personally met mostly decent people in the mission field with strong beliefs trying to spread love in other countries.

[@Nimuetootoo]

PEACHFACE24 first I’ve heard of it! I can’t believe the others haven’t seen this video and jumped all over this information! As for the comment defending her brother, who allegedly is still a missionary, we’ve ALL seen videos of hers, which included him, and I don’t see ANY difference in his type of SCAM and hers! Maybe he occasionally give something to someone, ya know, to keep up the illusion, but down deep, what we have here, are a family of snake oil salesmen!

[@Neo_Geisha]

@@rockabillymuffin Exactly. Fuck missionaries. They've done horrible things also in Africa.

[@pinkrainclouds2190]

“The safest place is where God tells you to be. This is coming from a man who was literally hit by a bus” *chokes on ramen*

[@Dragoderian]

@God Usoland There might be a correlation between the level of faith and the partial brain removal.

[@becauseimafan]

@@Dragoderian 🤣

[@Banni30]

This is insanely well shot and researched. Honestly the best video I’ve seen on the subject and I have been down the rabbit hole since the start!

[@amyvanmechelen4457]

Georgia Hagon me tooooo. Just obsessed.

[@myranaam8562]

NO it's not. lol

[@jordansadventuresSW]

Georgia Hagon I agree 100% and I’ve watched every single video on this topic😂

[@91Vault]

yeah...farmers aren't necessarily "poor" especially it's usally inherited. Me and all the farmers kids I knew all went to private schools, the families have all done really well for themselves

[@autumnhomer9786]

As a JH fan, this video was so shocking. I can’t believe she lied about everything. I really loved the,”Rags To Riches” story. Nope. All BS. 😕

[@TaylorPie94]

1. Are you seriously you a fan? 2. Can I ask you what made you attracted to her? Ya know, what about her pulled you in and made you keep coming back?

[@Crochetems]

Autumn clarke Can I ask what kept you from coming across this information earlier? Or what kept you from believing it? Anyone that’s been aware of her scandals or controversies for years has come to the conclusion that she’s untrustworthy at the very least. Did you think they were lying or “just haters” or something? I’m not trying to pick a fight I’m just really curious.

[@karliblair6982]

Eeeee I honestly haven’t heard any of this information until this point either. I watch her videos and steered clear of drama videos. But even sometimes drama videos seemed unbelievable. She seemed trustworthy to me, and relatable. Therefore I looked up to her.

[@rust44]

Rags to riches stories are 90% of the time BS

[@MrRyan-wu4jx]

I don’t get how anyone finds entertainment value in makeup instructions in general.

[@PaigeChristieUK]

You had me at non profit foundation.... wow.

[@punkorifik]

Hey It's Paige! I love when my love of breadtube and my love of drama collide!

[@queenkikiNC]

What Maggie conveniently forgot to mention is Jaclyn’s brother continues to do missionary work with his family in extremely poor countries and this is most likely what Jaclyn’s non profit aids in. She dug back to freaking 1997 yet forgot to mention her brother having JUST been helping other countries- I can’t remember where and I don’t want to mispeak of the exact country but I’m sure, as we all apparently rely on, google can get you that info 👍🏻

[@sourgreendolly7685]

Janelle AndCrew Missionary work is when you go to convert people. It uses people’s vulnerabilities to preach one’s personal beliefs. That is not a point in her favor.

[@punkorifik]

@@sourgreendolly7685 Agreed! It's a tool of western imperialism and neo-colonialism that occurs simultaneously to the economic exploitation of developing nations and their people.

[@phoenixgirl70]

Paige you should really cover all this in a video. No other channel has besides this. She grew up wealthy, her parents divorced in 2012, her mom would have gotten a good chunk of money especially from the sale of that hog farm, and she says her mom is involved in everything she does, this obliterates her food stamp bullshit her opening up a ministry...there’s a lot here and it’d get so many more educated and open up her stans eyes. Not all but a lot. I think of all of these people she’s sold garbage to and especially the younger ones saving babysitting money for that Vault garbage, now this. People are having trouble getting their money back. I think Jaclyn’s hoping they’ll just give up. The other channels mostly are afraid to dig too deep. You’re not. Your Peter Monn video was amazing.

[@KatBlaque]

So I've decided to stan forever.

[@MaggieMaeFish]

*bows* I am not worthy

[@CanuckMonkey13]

I'm old and don't understand what this means so I'm going to assume it's a reference to Sebastian Stan, and you are an actor who is going to take roles where you start as a villain then become a hero. Good for you!

[@ThatWeirdFinn]

@@CanuckMonkey13 "Eminem-Inspired Use of ‘Stan’ Added to Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary Title of rapper’s 2000 hit song with Dido has become shorthand to describe obsessive fans"

[@CanuckMonkey13]

TIL! Thanks @@ThatWeirdFinn!

[@haleymist09]

@@CanuckMonkey13 i think I'll replace your definition in my head. It has more nuance 😁

[@Annalovesautumn]

The phrase "retire my mom" is hilarious to me. Put her out to pasture, get a fresh mom?

[@aoutsky]

Her new full time job is defending Jaclyn on insta.

[@KLKosi123]

Lmao "Get a fresh mom"

[@heathersaylor3379]

This is gold. Pure gold!!!

[@missyhennessy]

Annalise Snoddon 😂😂 best comment

[@corhydron111]

This was not called execution. It was called retirement.

[@katyenglish1]

And you didn't even talk about her brand Jaclyn Hill Cosmetics, which became Jaclyn Cosmetics after her divorce.... Yet her lipsticks had JH logo on them. Old? Coincidence? 🤔🤫

[@Whatrabbitseat]

Damn. That's some tea

[@missalic3ria810]

Holy shit. Besides this being some HOT tea, this is also very educational. Talking about beauty industry drama AND educating people about the exploitative nature of capitalism is such a winning move. I love this video so much!

[@velvetvascular8085]

I think some of her statements are ridiculous. capitalism is the entire reason she can post this video and speak freely and people can boycott jaclyn's products. Please don't take this as educational on capitalism. We can all agree exploitation is bad, and corruption is bad, but capitalism as a whole system, is not bad. It's very very good.

[@blackanimecat2]

@@velvetvascular8085 capitalism requires exploitation at the lowest level

[@cottagegardener3725]

Isn’t this video and KZbin a byproduct of capitalism too.

[@blackanimecat2]

@@cottagegardener3725 yeah youtube is a company and platform that exlpoits the free labor and information of millions of people and holds no responsibility for harm done on or by their platform. This video is good. I like maggie. That dosnt mean capitalism isnt bad just because we can make good things despite being forced to participate in it to live(and those good things being exploided for profit by the wealthy). Capitalism requires exploitation and requires escalation of that exploitation for the top percent to make maximum profit.

[@audrey-lynnisabel6024]

velvetvascular agreed! 👍🏽

[@1986Commando]

I had no idea about the non profit she set up. She makes me sick 🤮🤮🤮 Everyone needs to see this!

[@queenkikiNC]

What Maggie conveniently forgot to mention is that Jaclyn’s brother continues to do missionary work with his family in extremely poor countries and this is most likely what Jaclyn’s non profit aids in. She dug back to freaking 1997 yet forgot to mention her brother having JUST been helping other countries- I can’t remember where and I don’t want to mispeak of the exact country but I’m sure, as we all apparently rely on, google can get you that info

[@carasnow8441]

Janelle AndCrew that's BS, if Jaclyn's non profit weren't a tax haven then she would be boosting about all the good work she has done on behalf of her charity

[@1986Commando]

@@queenkikiNC If they weren't doing any kind of missionary work their non-profit can be dissolved. It would make their tax evasion too obvious. It's good if he's actually helping people, but this doesn't prove they aren't filtering their money through the non profit.

[@beshiiisimasi1991]

Janelle AndCrew yeah he lives in Cambodia with his wife it’s on instagram, explains her weird family dynamics

[@gix2lee]

Great, non beauty channel perspective on this debacle. It’s only going to get worse for Jaclyn. I hope the drama channels watch your video.

[@andreathesexy1]

Drama channels are also (some) perpetuating capitalistic greed!

[@justmissjamey]

Drama channels have already been joking about the games side of KZbin will be making jacklyn videos soon too

[@alextacy21]

I’m wondering if this was something tea spill and here for the tea we’re going to talk about in their collab Jaclyn hill series but obviously Jaclyn hill used her mental health as a reason for them to stop the series

[@kham9578]

gix2lee most of the drama channels have become so biased , unless it’s James Charles

[@ankylosaruswrecks3189]

I can't believe how amazingly touched I was by this. It was hard-hitting journalism, lessons on capitalism, socialism and tax shelters, sensitive to low income people and mental illness and just overall great. And I love your eyeshadow.

[@evieechan498]

I'm sorry, but Jaclyn's family were MILLIONARES when she was 7 YEARS OLD because of that pay out. And if what Jaclyn says is true about not speaking to her dad for 10 years, then she was still well off financially when she was a 19 year old ADULT. And you can tell she comes from money because of how she spends it. I'm the same age as Jaclyn and come from a working class background. We didn't have a lot, but we got by. There was food, shelter and warmth. I'm only just experiencing having more disposable income after gaining a job in my degree field (I'm a graphic artist) and I still consider a $200 handbag to be too expensive. Her spending habits are so telling.

[@apracticalwitchtarot]

I love what you said about spending habits. I agree they can be very telling about someone’s background. Scarcity mindsets etc

[@evieechan498]

@@apracticalwitchtarot Yeah exactly!! If she had been as disadvantaged as working class people are (and she wasn't if the thing about hog farms are true) she'd have a scarcity complex, like you said. It's not something you just get over. My partner has to beg me to spend on myself because although I want things (who doesn't) I'm still in the mindset of it being a luxury I can't afford, even if I can actually afford it now.

[@kkurajam]

A 200 handbag is ludicrous

[@brib6046]

@@evieechan498 I also know a lot of people who would rather starve to just afford that $200 handbag, and have done so. There are a lot of people who pay and try to keep up with the Jones’s when they definitely don’t have the means to.

[@mndlessdrwer]

Exactly. Even when I started getting some disposable income, I would hesitate to buy a $70 bottle of fancy whiskey. And that's not even considered a particularly expensive whiskey. You don't get from food stamps to a ridiculous closet of designer clothes, shoes, handbags, and jewelry without a history of wealth.

[@aoutsky]

I number of times she says 'I love you and I miss you', seems manipulative. It's like a boyfriend who keeps making his way back into your life after you left him for treating you like shit. She says just enough to gain her fans' trust back. She has used her father's accident more than a couple of times to garner sympathy. Little did we know. There are 2 sides to every story.

[@rediscoverme]

I’ve been a JH fan since she worked at MAC and have never heard of most of this stuff. Wow. So gross. Thank you for bringing attention.

[@reneeleese]

liza gonzalez how is that possible? That you’ve been her fan this long and didn’t know about any of this.... didn’t you see her apology videos? I’m just curious.... it seems impossible to me

[@Scrapegoat]

Professor R. Chaos What do the apology videos have to do with her shitty family though?

[@rediscoverme]

Professor R. Chaos i saw the apology videos but I didn’t know about her past family stuff. Like about her dad’s finances, etc.

[@reneeleese]

liza gonzalez oh ok I didn’t know that’s what you were referring to.... I was thinking the scandals

[@Tia-Marie]

I don't wear makeup and somehow I've spent a week watching youtube drama blow up over Jaclyn's lipstick like Brexit.

[@sadrabbit53]

Haha same

[@jeyyran]

gotta get my monthly dose of make-up industry dragging to remind myself to never start wearing make-up

[@juanchavez1176]

The way you came at her as someone who grew up in a farming community hit me hard. I felt that. My day was a dairy farm employee and his boss was doing fine. It came at the price of underpaid farm workers but that’s the human cost of capitalism.

[@ashleyb7139]

Regarding the Morphe Vault palettes...I got the purple one as a gift. It had smears on the mirror, so I didnt even touch it, I exchanged it. Then I looked at the box...There was a sticker slapped over the ingredient portion w the "old" formula on the box. They absolutely didnt do anything w those.

[@weiiiden]

Ashley Stryker not saying you’re wrong but they could just be re-using the boxes to you eliminate unnecessary waste. i doubt they did anything to change the palettes though bc a lot of ppl posted tutorials with both

[@lishan4657]

Leyden Torres well, yes, call yourself whatever you want :)

[@zuzanaxyz8866]

A breath of fresh air in a sea of brainwashed ignorance. Subscribed.

[@vibhab191]

*It's one of those rare episodes where KZbin recommendation really worked for me. Gonna subscribe and stick around for sure*

[@laurenkelly9811]

Same here!!

[@bsmeenakshi]

Same same😌

[@likewow3804]

Your impersonation of Jaclyn was insane. Literally HER. Thank you for the brilliant research 🙌

[@RykerJones28]

I wasn't watching it the first time but listening while working and I thought at first it was Jaclyn!

[@jones4106]

This topic is back in the zeitgeist thanks to Jaclyn sending her millions of cult members after a small youtuber for making a video where all she did was read Jaclyn's father's own website page. This seems like the perfect time to link this video to everyone who is soooooo~ concerned about Jaclyn's father's "private" life and how it shouldn't have any bearing on how we view Jaclyn. :)

[@ozorkon]

Tea? TEA?!? This is scorching lava 😳

[@PabloEmanuel96]

ozorkon hahahahahaha True tho

[@princessjello]

Straight up guillotine tho

[@marionsousagraca2031]

*IKR*

[@XRXaholic]

I love connecting with you guys... particularly through the medium of bacteria on my lipstick.

[@likewow3804]

XRXaholic haha 😂

[@punkorifik]

Amazing! I've fallen down the Jaclyn Hill rabbit hole already, but I'm loving the leftist spin you gave it. I also didn't know about her Christian charitable non-profit, which makes this all that much more interesting...

[@Hales462]

Who’s here after jaclyns second launch?😂🙄

[@deedeemc587]

Oh HI!

[@jessicaornelas64]

Me hi

[@cinemaocd1752]

Yeah, I mean Raw Beauty Kristi seems to have uncancelled her, even though she was one of the one's doing the research on the defective lipsticks.

[@purpleenchilada]

Ha ha me!!!!!!

[@efolinsky]

@@cinemaocd1752 Kristi and kathleenlights used suspiciously similar key terms in their videos....

[@Raw774]

“...and retire my mom.” I immediately thought of blade runner and Deckard ‘retiring’ replicants.

[@Crochetems]

Raw 😂

[@phastinemoon]

Between this and the comments above comparing the statement to retiring a handbag or something, I have a feeling this sentiment was intentional on her part

[@Apemopo]

like getting fuckin crushed by Star Platinum in JoJo's. "Retired!"

[@SolaGratia.]

I haven't uploaded in a while. I'm thinking of making a new calligraphy video writing "Jaclyn Hill Lipsticks". Then throwing fur, cotton fibers, metal and plastic all over it, and writing in block text below, "ALL INGREDIENTS FDA APPROVED."

[@deltasaves]

Please do this. Please.

[@HotMessNessMUA]

Yes do it

[@noelsantacruz5282]

The possibility of this is enough for me to subscribe to your channel.

[@miso8090]

Noel Santacruz SAME!

[@GitShiddy]

Gay RoboCop wouldn't sell/wear/tolerate moldy lipstick and they're a corporately owned re-animated corpse.

[@wildflowers100]

Wow- the Christian Nonprofit. I can’t say I’m surprised. Why anyone continues to buy her wares is beyond me. 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@lazerbeam134]

True capitalist life stories are never rags to riches, they are always riches to more riches.

[@rebeccasmith4814]

lazerbeam134 unless you’re John Rockefeller. :) he is the only person I can think of who was truly impoverished before becoming one of the wealthiest people on earth. A few actors in the 50’s/60’s as well, back when you could actually become famous without having famous parents first 🙄

[@angelbarajas9180]

70% of rich people grew up in non wealthy families.

[@cjboyo]

@@angelbarajas9180 yeah… if you define upper-middle-class as “not wealthy”

[@AC8X]

My grandfather was a rags to riches story, but he sold his company BEFORE losing millions to Madoff's ponzi scheme, and now he's in his 80s and still has to work for a living.

[@crittermoded]

Sometimes they're rags to riches, but it's not because they worked the hardest and truly pulled themselves up by their bootstraps, it's because they won the lottery with odds worse than Vegas

[@anastasiagirl1342]

Maggie predicting the Roe v. Wade reversal three years ago. Proves that she truly is a gem attempting to warn us of many dooms.

[@PeterFrikadelle]

Yes! I was just about to type the same thing haha

[@heather_doestruecrime]

I have NEVER heard her talk about or promote this non profit "christian spiritual charity" that she literally OWNS ... has anyone?

[@mj-yo7vt]

Heather J that's because she doesn't need to: it's money laundering scheme. She puts her money there as "donations " to avoid paying taxes

[@kinkineki]

If she promotes it she'll draw attention to it and presumably people will start asking for actually things she's done with this charity money. Its a much better strategy to keep it on the down low as you can just use it to receive "charitable donations" and legally evade tax

[@apriljk6557]

Because it's merely a tax shelter.

[@Venessa101]

Exactly, what the others have said.

[@lspbeautea4791]

Never. Not once.

[@JosieGoyangi]

I've discovered some of the coolest KZbinrs through this scandal. So, I guess that's the light at the end of the tunnel? 😂

[@jacquelineess1141]

*scandal

[@JosieGoyangi]

@@jacquelineess1141 lol how did I miss that? Thanks.

[@jacquelineess1141]

@@JosieGoyangi What a classy response, kudos!! A proper lady!

[@queenkamie1743]

Same

[@ermfine2]

How does this woman Jaclyn Hill still have a career???? #greedy

[@LatinaVixen91]

Vapid fan girls/boys

[@heidiaguilar1257]

Master manipulator narcissist.

[@tiffanylastinger3925]

14 year olds ...look at rawkristee

[@CS-yr5jr]

I can tell you straight up, that if you are shopping at Woodfield mall, you probably aren’t on food stamps. Lol I didn’t realize she was from my neck of the woods.

[@Theyungcity23]

There's all kinds of cheap crap you can get from Woodfield mall. It has the same stores that almost every Simon Property group mall has all over the country so it's not like it's got exclusive super expensive stuff.

[@CS-yr5jr]

Theyungcity23 I’m talking about the kind of people. I’m not talking about what you can buy. But thanks for letting me know that malls have the same things 😉

[@Theyungcity23]

@@CS-yr5jr what do you mean by the kind of people? If they serve all price ranges then they will attract people from all financial groups. I mentioned the stores and the items because those are concrete things that you can judge a mall on. But because they are basically a franchise at this point that goes out the window.

[@CS-yr5jr]

Theyungcity23 ok 👌 maybe stop spending so much time on google to find out who owns what malls and what price points and people they cater to? I just commented about a spoiled little girl who says she’s poor enough to be on food stamps but held her lipstick that she bought at MAC and blah blah blah, but she said she’s poor. Maybe you should donate money to Jacklyn if you feel like she had a bad life. 🤔

[@Theyungcity23]

@@CS-yr5jr I'm just trying to understand how your comment makes sense

[@jenniferh9612]

My fight or flight was triggered when you showed Ben Shapiro 🤢🤮

[@mediocre_violist]

Jennifer H Same. Every time I see his face I feel like dropping into a fight stance. I'm prepared to put all of my fourth-grade karate class knowledge to use! 😆

[@TaylorPie94]

I was trying to watch some old performances on SNL and got to Sia. Guess who introduced her? Trump. I. SCREAMED. I screamed from my gut. PURE horror.

[@mediocre_violist]

Taylor Taylor oh God, I’m so sorry. You were bamboozled by the human Cheeto.

[@elKinesis]

I immediately heard in my head, "Just one small problem: sell their houses to who, Ben? Fucking Aquaman?!"

[@elKinesis]

Oh, nevermind. There's my beautiful boy.

[@jessyjulie5506]

Oh man, u really destroyed her. I didn't know jaclyn was THIS bad!

[@tourmalineivy]

Your Jaclyn impressions were brilliant 😂👍 I always found this woman to be fake and shady AF, and cannot understand her stans who blindly defend everything she does

[@stretchopotomus2385]

ikr!

[@elisinwonderland1306]

Her stans make me wanna throw up

[@miso8090]

“She’s a Christian!” “Well...Yes, CALL yourself whatever you want” 😂😂😂

[@rileycoyote8275]

@true feminist free thinker provocateur You can be as much of a free thinker as you think you are. It doesn't change the fact that you're Christianphobic. Would you have the same amount of disgust if she were an American Muslim?

[@emilejetzer7657]

@@rileycoyote8275 yes.

[@darkthorpocomicknight7891]

I wonder if she made an ISLAMIC foundation if the cough white cough lawmakers would turn a blind eye? HMMMM ...

[@sv32099]

"She's a Christian!" Alexander Anderson: "Call yourself whatever you want you crazy protestant bastard!"

[@eliottrodriguez7425]

Oh my God! Maggie. I thought your video was relevant before! But after watching JH comeback video " Where I've been" You nailed the truth of this drama SO! WELL your video should go viral ( whatever that means). Fantastic job! 👏 bravo

[@YunierViada]

I came for the foreseen pettiness, I stayed for the social commentary and eye opening information ❤️🙌

[@avpapp]

Jaclyn is the Monsanto of the beauty industry.

[@lordhagfishii9192]

avpapp omg yes 😂

[@heidiaguilar1257]

Good one.

[@colombianita2005]

avpapp omg 😂 😂 that is statement is sooo right!

[@calamityjane4259]

Maggie you’re voice!!! You have such an AMAZING voice for radio, voiceovers etc. Loved the video, also LOVED your voice!

[@Mallory-Malkovich]

One of the greatest illusions of American culture is that Christianity and capitalism are compatible ideologies, and merging the two has made both of them worse.

[@Amazatastic]

Jesus was a commie you can't change my mind

[@bandiafhiaigh2008]

"Christianity and capitalism are incompatible ideologies" may be the needlepoint I make for some of my relatives as Christmas presents.

[@princesstamika]

@SuperNoone89 and how all that was added later to accomplish political motives.

[@SSelkie3]

@@Amazatastic literally true

[@andree824]

Osiris Malkovich - Wow! I love this comment. So true : )

[@FranNyan]

I know this is an old video, but I gotta say, running a small business has really shown me how batshit tax law is. The amount of crap I can deduct from my taxes is mind blowing. The easiest way to avoid having to pay taxes if you're in that awful "poor enough that you have to pinch pennies but not poor enough that you're exempt from income tax because the feds don't realize that rent is a thing you have to pay" bracket is just start a small business as your side hustle. Totally legal! Totally insane...

[@martuquiconcu]

Here because of Abby Williamson's recommendation and I'm so glad she talked about your channel! Subscribed 👌👌

[@stephanied6711]

Same

[@Erinselysion]

God, I already had 0 respect for her but all that background info you revealed about her is so insidious, it's disgusting. I really hope more people see this video. I'm glad to see a lot of people denouncing her, but I feel like more people need to realize she can't be trusted and ASAP.

[@sheliadavid9933]

Hopefully,more people actually take the time to watch her video( I got the suggestion from a Peter Monn comment...suggesting they do a review), thats basically how Antphrodites views grew( by Peters Shout Out!).These smaller channels need room to grow!! I found Maggie's video so informing,and well put together... Bravo👏👏👏👏

[@ermfine2]

OMG!!!! The dad was a preacher!!! Figures. She has that hawking, preacher way about her. #hypercapitalist

[@katharinaschutz8026]

she both sounds and looks obnoxious. girl, invest more money into better PR teams and less into fillers.

[@Shmaples]

It's true...she has ruined her face.

[@Laura-mi3nv]

@@Shmaples Entirely too many people are ruining their face with fillers. You should need psychiatric approval for fillers.

[@nelsonth]

Uhh... Shouldn't she be investing in better products instead? That would generate more good PR...

[@adenineful]

Nelson Thangjam Absolutely! But a good PR team would have told her to IMMEDIATELY recall the products and test them to figure out what was going on, so it would have been the best course of action for consumers as well

[@CourtayMichele]

RIGHT?! I’m always wondering every time I see pictures of her like how is no one commenting on how god awful her ballooned face looks?! She ruined herself!

[@ellerywinslow6120]

"This according to a guy who was literally hit by a truck." Laughed out loud. Great video.

[@ttlovepie101]

And don't forget the money they're avoiding tax on was earned through the exploitation of workers here and abroad.

[@AngLSTM]

Just when I think I've seen enough Jaclyn analysis, this was great. One minor note, the ridiculousness of the company emails (mainly regarding the issues) being signed "Stay Bougie" surely deserved a mention purely for its ridiculousness.

[@JH-kw8zy]

She really dragged all of rich America 😂 this was informative, insightful, and exhausting. Subscribed😭

[@heythisisizzy]

That warning about not starting in the beauty community is so true. Last Christmas my bestfriend wanted Jeffree Star's Blood Sugar palette and i was like "what from who?". 5 minutes of googling and it was too late.

[@skylar_kada]

1920- They’ll have flying cars in the future! 2019- LiPsTiCk GaTe 👄

[@familyguy237whip]

Skylie lmfaoooo

[@hereforit2]

Jacklyn is one of the worst actors i've seen. Especially the part in the beginning where she says how much she misses talking to her fans. How do people fall for that?? Ps: You're hilarious and so well-researched. ❤️

[@szacharyf]

This was more in depth than any drama channel video I’ve watched! 😂

[@jellybean3524]

Kaminoneh Bhoot you sound bitter, want a snickers?

[@keksitse]

This video is so needed in KZbin community, talking capitalism in the way people can understand and using the right terms about it. I hope you will make similar videos in the future!

[@jaynedavis3388]

I started at Safya Nigaard, was bumped to SimplyNailogical, then on to RawBeautyKristi & now I’m obsessed with this lipstick scandal... HELP ME?!

[@chilicircus26]

As a person who grew up in a religious home, preacher does not equal broke. Even if the preacher is not an evangelist, and only pastors a church with 100-200 people.The small church thing applied to a close family member of mine. My mom was a housekeeper, my dad a factory worker and this family member with the small church made more money than both my parents put together. I was shocked at that because the people at that church didn't look like they had money, they looked like normal hillbillies

[@blueshoes915]

What’s this!!?! An honest person, using facts to back up claims, what a new novel concept! Thanks for the video. She clearly doesn’t care about anyone but herself. I can’t believe she still has followers! It makes me so sad how some people manipulative masses of people at all costs for personal gain. Thanks for being smart! 😁

[@dtllmpn]

Two weeks later, "Hey guys! It's me, Jaclyn, and I was thinking back to when I had food stamps, and then I looked at this pallet of lipstick, and I had RRRIIIICCCCHHHH idea! Introducing the nature's promise line of lipstick, made with micro-organic elements."

[@lesliethiel428]

That was effing brilliant! And SPOT on. Jaclyn is from a family of grifters....she doesn't fall too far from the tree. Just my 2 cents...that I've earned honestly.....heh.

[@mythicalmelodies276]

As a person who is gradually becoming more leftist I really appreciate this video. You did a really great job on presenting the information and the impressions were excellent. I think a lot about "artificial scarcity". I AM NOW SUBSCRIBED.

[@otakucouture]

I LOVE this anti-Capitalist makeup drama analysis thank you make more of this

[@otakucouture]

@Michael VR I implore you to shut the fuck up as my family's country was ruined by a CIA supported fascist regime that killed many people ignorant American.

[@Annie261.]

Nitrus What are you doing here?

[@robertstan298]

@Michael VR Get bent, boot licker.

[@robertstan298]

@@Annie261. "here" LMAO You know you're on the Internet, right?

[@erinrose9774]

I'll tell you what, speaking as someone who has been on welfare, I was not going to Mecca for my make up. I couldn't even afford to look directly at the store.

[@Serena_Eve]

I am so obsessed with you and this video.... I have also recently been strangely addicted by beauty KZbinrs and have been bingeing the gossip channels with a weird, detached fascination. Your video absolutely hits the sweet spot of what I’ve been wanting to see about this topic - something more in-depth than Twitter receipts that calls out the warped and dirty machinations and manipulations. Please please please make more videos in this vein, I haven’t yet found anyone else coming from this angle in such a fantastic and informed way. I never ever even comment on videos but I just had to throw in my plea for you to continue these type of videos 🙏🏻 OH and what I also wanted to say....JH has not yet recalled the products, they’re only offering full refunds to everyone. I’ve been following this closely and there’s still a lot of anger and frustration about the lack of a recall, with some people even theorizing that accepting the recall releases them from liability and could potentially impact people’s ability to join in a class-action lawsuit, if it ever comes to that. People also think that a recall has not been issued because that would mean that the company is admitting fault in some way, when they’re still steadfastly insisting that their products are completely safe and FDA compliant. Just throwing that in....while there has been intense backlash that has been a catalyst for many of the things that JH and her company have done, a recall has not yet been the result of any of it. And the longer they go without issuing one, the more disgusted people get, day by day. The FDA has been flooded with complaints and demands for them to step in to force one, and their BBB page reflects the hundreds of organized complaints that have poured in. I feel like if a recall was issued a lot of people might be placated, but that has yet to happen because they just keep doubling down on the “safety” of those nasty lipsticks.

[@abbrakadabraalakazam]

omg girl "That's coming from a guy that was hit by a truck." your commentary and research are on point.

[@tiffanyyyyyyt]

Me finding your channel is the best thing that came out of this whole Jaclyn Hill lipstick-gate debacle.

[@ellemathews9840]

So that's how she was able to afford a $100,000 a month house in LA ..

[@pixelatedddd]

3 years later and this is still my fave video. Motel Makeover is a close second. Maggie you’re brilliant!

[@hannahbanana570]

Yep! Same

[@asmrtpop2676]

The FDA does not approve cosmetics it merely regulates them.

[@skatergurljubulee]

Just subscribed! Came here fir the JC roast but found someone who does video essays on films, my other love! Need to support more women in the film industry! ❤❤

[@davo4174]

Great work. This gave a totally fresh perspective on Jaclyn Hill. Bravo

[@patrickmcnally7901]

I came to this channel for Zach Snyder critique, and I’ve found myself watching about the beauty KZbin industry and tax avoidance, I love it. I can’t wait for the deep dive that is definitely incoming!

[@hemptressco]

Why aren’t more people talking about this!!!!!

[@peanutbutterjam9501]

Nailogical did a gread job, it seems that the products are good and the website didn't crash, and they stuck to deadlines.

[@coudgeb]

This was so well put together. I hope this goes viral. You definitely deserve it. I'm so sick of KZbinrs like this. They are making me rethink the platform. Why do we have to have products & merch constantly shoved down our throats. Especially how our kids are being suckered. Thank you, hopefully this will be a real eye opener for ppl!!! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@iheartjackieyes]

as someone who doesnt wear makeup, has had very little interest in makeup, cares very little about what is happening in the makeup, your warnings about getting sucked into the drama are true and i am subscribed to several makeup and tea channels because of it

[@nymeria941]

Ok so I'm new to your channel, got here via Ash Hardell, this is my first video. The SECOND you described the beauty community on KZbin at the beginning of the video I GUFFAWED. Amazing video, and I'm happy to be here as a new subscriber.

[@karolt.8881]

She came with highlighters this time. People never gonna learn.

[@SolaGratia.]

Maclyn Mill and Bim Barbashian! 😂 😂 😂

[@thejollywriter]

I just realized my favorite youtube essayists are like colleagues (Maggie, Lindsay, Dan, Hbomb) and that made me happy because it feels like I found the one good corner of YT

[@Amazatastic]

Its called lefttube or breadtube !

[@robertolie6798]

For those commenting "she didn't recall the lipsticks" Maggie's aware of the mistake(probably small error in the script or reading and it was too late to re-record/edit), as shown on 21:29 bottom right saying in asterisk *refunded, not recalled

[@jordenb5906]

ARE WE GONNA FORGET ABOUT THE EYESHADOW PALETTE SHE HAD WITH BECCA THAT LITERALLY GOT RECALLED??

[@Cocolagaffe18]

Thank you !!! I was wondering why no one mentioned this lol

[@Whatrabbitseat]

What happened

[@melissalykins8895]

No one ever mentions this anymore when they talk about all the mishaps with her releases. I still have my palette from that launch.

[@melissalykins8895]

b s If I remember correctly, when JH came out with Champagne Pop with Becca Cosmetics -originally it was just the highlight itself. Then they decided to extend the line to a liquid version, a face palette (which included Champagne Pop’s “baby sister” Presco), and an eyeshadow palette. I believe the eyeshadow palette was thrown in at the last minute as a money grab. As people started receiving their products, they realized that there were inconsistencies in the eyeshadow palettes performance. And upon further investigation, they found that only the eyeshadow palette said “Made in China” on the back of the package. When everything else from Becca, including the rest of the Champagne Pop products, has always been made in the USA. The eyeshadow palette was nothing like Becca’s normal palettes and people noticed immediately. The quality was much worse as far as the packaging and quality of the shadows. For example, the face palette is heavy, very good quality, and the eyeshadow palette was very light weight, completely different material - very cheap made, and there were so many inconsistencies with the performance of the eyeshadows that they had to actually recall the palette. I have the face palette which I did love, and I kept the eyeshadow palette instead of returning it. I never did really use it to know if mine was a bad one or not, they claimed some people’s shadows worked well, when most others didn’t. And also, I didn’t know this but at a Burke’s outlet store, my sister found a Champagne Pop stick, and loose powder. So Becca actually continues the Champagne Pop like without Jaclyn after all that.

[@jackimoon8284]

Melissa Lykins that shit is piping

[@hippopajamas]

Even though it has been literal months since this was published, I keep coming back to it. This by no means exclusive to JH, and sometimes I need another reminder/wake up call when I feel like I am being sucked into the black hole of youtube.

[@lovelyMaria210]

Jaclyn's loyal followers are something else. 🤦‍♀️