MAMAMOO - You, In My Fading Memory | 마마무 - 흐린 기억 속의 그대 [Immortal Songs 2 / 2017.01.14]

[@rosev1586]

To those antis who are saying that mamamoo can't dance, watch this because their vocals are more stable than your finances

[@hsym_mmm6976]

Rose v lol agree 100% It’s not that they can’t dance, in my opinion they just prioritize singing which is more important and creates a higher quality performance WHICH THEY ALWAYS DO

[@hwasasthiccthighs9500]

Steph _ Also remember they dance and jump around in High heels most of the time (just not in this performance.)

[@nuckesantiago]

lol, those people who keep saying that Mamamoo aint good are all pabo. they know nothing about talent. they got used to aegyo n dancing, that they forgot it's actually all about singing. Mamamoo is on the league of their own. Stan talent, stan Mamamoo

[@hwasasthiccthighs9500]

nuckelodeon - AMEN!!

[@virginiemoniquejavier2927]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA your comment is good

[@dofta7499]

The only girls who can do rock, jazz, pop, r&b and more, MAMAMOO. Stan talent, Stan Mamamoo.

[@babbyasmr2031]

Marks Wife I don't think Wonder Girls has spanned all of the above genres, like jazz, but they are talented too.

[@Gfriend_Buddy99]

Marks Wife but sadly they disbanded. they are the first group that introduced me to kpop .. if only jyp treat them better....

[@MinealotPlaysMC]

Red Velvet is pretty diverse too😂😂

[@lin-ec4nr]

dont forget Brown Eyed Girls too heheheheh Brown Eyed Girls is the adult version of MAMAMOO ^^

[@brightwinismylife3952]

there's some groups that cand do diff genres but mamamoo definitely the best in terms of vocal quality and stage presence..

[@kea8349]

A lot of non-Korean/super young fans won't really know this, quite a lot of certain moves in this dance were part of Hyun JinYoung's original moves. So overall, it was a massive tribute done super well, and the definition of an awesome trip down memory lane for a lot of the people in the audience because he was famous in the early nineties. If you look at a lot of the cuts of the audience, there are people who seem to be in their forties to even early fifties who are dancing along hard out - they would have been in their twenties to poss thirties when this song came out. I think it's so awesome that these older people who are socially expected to be 'mature' and 'reserved' let loose a little bit and went back to their youth.

[@melv5816]

KC Elle Thank you for explaining this more. It makes Mamamoo's performance even more incredible. And I'm glad they helped these people relive their youth.

[@multi2038]

Thank god I know this song from before 💖

[@패스넛소]

And MAMAMOO jived audience coming from various generations and ages with one awe-spectacular-some performance!

[@euga5653]

Thanks for this info!! Makes it even more interesting

[@bakaky0]

I'm 36 and I know the original song from Pump It Up. Oh the memories (mainly of me sucking at the game but ok)...

[@IceBear-oj2ts]

Any moonbyul fan here? Byuli slaying as always

[@Smoses_senpai]

Moonstar

[@alliancembizi4800]

Me

[@xcl9470]

(raises hand

[@Jay-ly2wo]

Moonstar and the rest of the girls ❤️

[@galzotegrashiella6223]

💖

[@IchimariKurosaki]

I need to attend one of these mamamoo live performance at least once before I die For science

[@sendmemoneythanks]

Mari Matsumoto I have to attend for hormonal purposes

[@moonsunmichaengisthegayest177]

@@sendmemoneythanks 😂😂😂😂

[@sabz_1675]

@Moonchild Bunny missed the joke

[@milflover6996]

Same For research purposes for my project

[@arrienejoyperucho6201]

sameee for my school project

[@hanadarmymoo]

For those new comer in our fandom. number one rule is Don't bring other girl groups down just to compliment Mamamoo. please, we want to remain the PEACEFULNESS of the Radish field. thank you. with all the love-Moonbyul trash😘

[@mamamoo4x4ever96]

Hannah Demellites UP!

[@mmmidle859]

Put this at the top comment!

[@48akatsuki]

This, the #1 rule in the farm of us radishes..

[@marianneomale1950]

i love how I see this post to the videos of MMM

[@3ZH_]

YES!!!

[@kathleenmaeve7009]

**This is the kind of "stage" i missed in kpop performances.** It's not just choreography it's performing and really engaging with the audience. You can see how people are so hyped up and that shows how talented MAMAMOO are. Not just with vocals but the way they perform on stage. Like they are sincerely having fun and not just because it's part of the act or choreo. ♥♥ The last time i felt this was with 2NE1.

[@lindsey2542]

FACTS. That's part of the reason I only stan BTS and a few girl groups (mamamoo being one of them) because they're the only ones in my opinion that have this energy that are still currently active. I'm not hating on them as they're all extremely talented but take NCT as an example, I personally don't really like them because to me they're not really "performing" they're just singing and dancing the same way every time with little to no interaction/uniqueness each show. Which is valid as their choreos are extremely hard but its just not my taste.

[@jepe.14]

TRUE! and the fact that the only groups i stan are 2NE1 and MAMAMOO makes so much sense

[@Ming3484]

@@lindsey2542 i agree with you although, even though they are not performing together at the moment I also feel EXO has great stage presence. Oh. And also KARD. 🙂🙂🙂🙂 This is why Mamamoo, EXO, and KARD are my top 3.

[@pluglife7381]

That’s what we call being “Overly Produced” my friend, which most groups are. So performances like this one are a breath of fresh air in the K pop industry.

[@dangskitolentino5428]

Mamamoo set the bar so high for the girl group who wants to join in Immortal Songs...

[@newsftw]

indeed, i wonder how many decades we will need to wait before any girl group wins the entire immortal song episode (assuming the quality remains of cos). Mamamoo set the bar so high for a stannable group in my heart...which so far is only mamamoo.

[@faitharu]

they are the only girl group who won an entire episode

[@darkshad0w279]

Faith Haru davichi won

[@ShinbeKiyawara]

Davichi is a duo.

[@darkshad0w279]

1987nanang still a girl group

[@fernandotorres3963]

Who else is in a Mamamoo immortal songs marathon??

[@nixethelaxina8686]

Me 😅

[@MAGANDAAK3TCH]

Me !!!! Omg all is lovely and addicting

[@chiao1027]

Literally me! And I’m enjoying so much

[@stephaniemoreira3280]

MEE

[@biancacoelho8808]

me

[@psyrororo]

Wheein is a BEAST! the low notes, the high notes, the growls, her dance moves... she's on fire!

[@Camille-xe7jg]

Did you check her new solo watercolor ? Queen slayed again, it's so good

[@wheeinies_dimpleee1484]

@@Camille-xe7jg did you see make me happy, wheein is an iconnnn

[@Camille-xe7jg]

@@wheeinies_dimpleee1484 yes, it's so good ! The whole album is a bop !

[@aperson2730]

@@Camille-xe7jg You have good taste. It's a good EP.

[@noidreamers]

lol mamamoo fangirls are amazing xD

[@kinakino]

noidreamers ikr ! haha. i wud do the same if i were to be there. lol

[@princesskatemarcaida8267]

I'm doing the same while watching it on youtube. 😀

[@JKgaming1]

Boy crush concept killin it

[@Argonsora]

+JKgaming1 it's called girl crush, cuz they crush all our hearts

[@kainitkn7410]

Mamamoo turns from Girls Crush into Nations Crush 😏

[@miraaa14]

THE ONLY IDOL GROUP INVITED DURING KING OF KING SPECIAL THIS YEAR. TALENT TALENT TALENT

[@ym4406]

The only Idol group ever invited during king of king special

[@charliesierota3445]

is it on youtube?

[@snsdfx1]

Ying Michael seriously?! Damn my mamamoo game strong af

[@user-bh2cl7jl5w]

Charlie Sierota yes it is

[@AliahSufitaMuntasya]

I'm proud MooMoos for that!

[@tcarr7380]

Maybe I'm being too emotional but the looks on their faces after they finish got me thinking about how happy they must be. They started out as young trainees who love music and wanted to share that with the world. They got rejected from multiple companies before finally being put together under RBW and debuting as Mamamoo. Their music and skill went mostly overlooked until nearly TWO YEARS later, when people finally realized how much talent they have. I'm so proud of them as a fan who's been here since they've debuted, and I am so happy they got the recognition they deserve! We all love you girls!!

[@greenranger98]

really?? i didnt know such history of mamamoo. where can i know or watch videos about their history?? or is there a thread on twt?

[@greenranger98]

@Mel T okay i will. thanks!!

[@maryjoybersamina8700]

Wow! 😍❤

[@emma-hx5wo]

greenranger1998 also vidéo from yamachan

[@anonygent]

Just to be clear, while they may have been overlooked by the public early on, the professionals in the business recognized their talent immediately. That's why they were called "monster rookies", invited to come back on every show they appeared on, and generally had nice things said about them by every host and fellow musician they crossed paths with. I don't know of any other group that made as big a splash with other musicians as Mamamoo did.

[@TRISTAN-gi9fn]

came from the jype collaboration stage & this is just incomparable! MAMAMOO is actually the only group that comes near 2ne1 when it comes to performing but people are afraid to admit that.❤️

[@multistan8969]

IFKR 🥰 thanks for recognising their talent

[@PuthyStuntin]

not that mamamoo and 2ne1 are on the same level but for real they hit home 😭💙💙 an oldtimer blackjack here 🏳️🏳️🏳️

[@cxry404]

indeed

[@camicamiflorian8952]

Exactoo!!! Gracias por tu comentario!! ^^

[@buddies6389]

why did you even bring it up lmfao

[@janineganapin6124]

this is not a show. this is mamamoo's concert.

[@bubbletea3456]

This is immortal songs 2 show.

[@tiaoli8866]

@@bubbletea3456 You didn't get what they said, did you?

[@bubbletea3456]

@@tiaoli8866 now I begin to doubt. What do you mean? By the way Sunny side up is my favorite song.

[@tiaoli8866]

@@bubbletea3456 They said that the way that MAMAMOO performs makes it looks like it's actually an concert, and only only a show. SSU is my favorite song too lol.

[@meng2296]

@@tiaoli8866 mamamoo mini concert? Hehe looks like

[@siratasuriyaket8070]

Mamamoo said that they had only 2 day for practicing and creating the choreography cuz of year-end shows .. lets not say talent, but super talent

[@Hwasasthroneismyface]

Lets say gifted

[@ChrisBrengel]

Yaaaaassss!

[@vadjulawakaru]

yassss.

[@GaaraFan01]

WOW that's insane, most talented girl group ever!!!

[@honeybeemoo]

Let's say MAMAMOO😌😎❤️❤️❤️❤️ Honestly, I'm considering using Mamamoo as an adjective to describe someone or something as really cool, talented, beautiful and overall amazing🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@fooolsun4917]

I love how every time they perform on Immortal Song the crowd just gets more passionate, like, they made Immortal Song stage, their stage, now it's like a small Mamamoo concert!

[@qwheein4125]

And that people, is what you call talent.

[@ChrisBrengel]

One of the high points in the entire history of Kpop, IMHO

[@minadia7855]

CLaire Qwheein Honestly to me they're the most talented group in kpop and I've been into kpop since '08.

[@rushda9830]

@@minadia7855 wow thank you for appreaciating them. It's hard to even find people saying this when they got into kpop in 2016-2017 and you're there since '08. Hope more people could be like you and don't sleep on them.

[@minadia7855]

BTS MAMAMOO and BTOB are legends I found out about them in 2016, and I was honestly disappointed because I wish I knew them earlier. I feel like being an international kpop fan, it's harder to find out about Mamamoo because they're not as hyped and promoted as other groups like twice, BP, RV etc, especially a couple of years ago. I'm glad they're getting more appreciated now because ugh they soo deserve it but they still deserve MORE. My two favorite groups now are BTS and Mamamoo and talent wise, Mamamoo should be on the same level of fame as bts imo but people are still sleeping on them 😩

[@homesickalien6194]

mamamoo= talent Facts

[@bangtansbae3985]

Multiple attack by unmatched vocals, badass rap, stunning visuals and mind numbing talent

[@k-musictrash356]

👌

[@siniongleong1530]

Using Mamamoo as studying music is possibly the worst choice ever because you'll just end up watch every video and smiling at it like an idiot

[@honeybeemoo]

Tell me about it😅

[@gantengindonesia2448]

I feel u sist, i feel u

[@regianegermano9910]

Kkkkk😄😄😄 verdade pura😜

[@mounemuii]

I play this video 10 times a day for a religious experience

[@karidunne3541]

ddongbyullie amen

[@s2pdchzcat]

ddongbyullie same fam. same. you're not alone 😂

[@igot7problemsbutyougotnojams]

ddongbyullie Instead of telling people "You need Jesus" I say "You need MAMAMOO" 🙏

[@layadaya]

ddongbyullie S A M E

[@ssangi]

ddongbyullie Mamen

[@yxni.x]

All those people in the crowd became MooMoos that day.

[@mooodleoodle]

Yeni Rodriguez Best comment. xD

[@beansprout7891]

Pin this goddamn comment.

[@dianarodriguez8764]

im not saying that theyre the best girl group out there but thats exactly what im saying

[@nabitharihi]

before gogobebe they already had this to prove that they can sing so well with a hard choreography and more complex notes

[@roxylipz2672]

Just Divas.

[@somebody3509]

Now we have HIP

[@aimeeong8285]

And now we have Dingga and Aya !

[@wununez5800]

@@aimeeong8285 and now we have where are we now

[@aimeeong8285]

@@wununez5800 yes heheh but the OP said it is about Hard Cheoro heheheh WAWN is only vocals.

[@sowhat5399]

MAMAMOO are those artists that every generation enjoys their performance Elders middle aged adults teenagers they satisfy all of them!! This is why MAMAMOO is a Legendary Artists genre

[@moonsunmichaengisthegayest177]

Totally agree !!

[@lotionbottlehead]

5:35 backup singers just be there like "damn....what are we here for?"

[@catmoo6887]

watch mamamoo slay the stage......... and that's a close 'seat' tho :(

[@latenightcashews]

lotionbottlehead haha

[@GINAVIBU]

JAJAJAJAJA

[@iamalma1402]

Lololololol😂😂

[@AbsoluteYana_Official]

my thoughts exactly

[@kinakino]

i only stan people with talent and Mamamoo has it all.

[@fightfannerd2078]

ikr

[@juhixian]

kinafairy lee Mamamoo has it ALL

[@drii4002]

MAMAMOO HAS IT ALL.

[@moonstarisminedontouchme3679]

kinafairy lee MAMAMOO HAS IT ALL

[@melv5816]

OUR QUEENS HAVE IT ALL! 😄

[@namaohoa8674]

The only girl group nowadays that could live up to 2NE1. They're definition of performers. Not some pretty looking dolls dancing up in stage

[@casualsuede]

Nam Nguyen I agree, I was hoping that Blackpink group could be that group. they have the talent but they are so lifeless personality wise. mamamoo has 2NE1's personality, along with better singing talent. while 2ne1 is my guilty pleasure, I feel they have been surpassed.

[@Reyofsunshines]

Nam Nguyen I have seen so many girl idol groups but what 2ne1 and MMM can do on stage, nobody can beat that! I hope MMM carries their legacy and become as huge as them! They deserve it!

[@Nico.Robin7]

Agreed!!

[@lisanglir1683]

Agree..

[@siskomerda]

NO!Surpassed?!!! N-E-V-E-R Mamamoo is their 2nd generation but the door that 2NE1 opened for them today would not be possible.Like with GG or Big Bang and Wonder Girls.Those are the groups that marked ˇ90. and today and will always remain as the wall of that time.You can consider this 2017. as a new era but there is a diference when an old group try to live on old glory and old group that will always have it.Its like EXO can rule this decade but whenever BB is back,BB will slay.That big of fandoms and netizens heart only BB,GG and 2NE1 had.From age 3-85

[@adobongoatmeal4527]

As much as i love the jype collab stage, nothing can top this performance as they were moving/dancing actively plus LIVE SINGING!! Also hyping up the crowd which speaks greatly of their stage expertise- if that's a thing lol. I just love mamamoo so much!

[@woozihae]

brooo nothing tops this till this day

[@buddies6389]

why are you comparing them to begin with

[@chetnaprajapati8972]

It's live whereas jyp Collab was prerecorded way before the actual program and have no audiance

[@BSMutebi-uk3hi]

@@buddies6389 Bc they sang the same song? They're not even bashing jype. They're just saying they like this better.

[@forer1906]

Honestly I can't believe they aren't considered the best kpop girl group, cause they deserve it and I'll never shut up about it

[@thevoiceofthefuture2]

the only girl group worth stanning in kpop rn. fight me

[@karidunne3541]

Allison Dunning Dang I was expecting angry people here but this comment has close to 50 likes I guess people know what's good

[@thevoiceofthefuture2]

Popcorn Goddess exactly

[@IndianaJonas96]

Allison Dunning okay: not true

[@melv5816]

VIBuddy Actually, they are as they have it ALL. Vocals, rap, harmony, stage presence and great personalities, songwriters, lyric writers, composers, and dance (tho they don't use it very often).

[@IndianaJonas96]

Mel V Yeah im aware that they're excellent, doesnt make them the ONLY girl group worth stanning. Thats a horrible thing to say.

[@wheepupisbombyo7134]

does no one realise that wheein was singing high parts for the whole 6 minutes?

[@3rationalfans]

I think both her and Solar were singing high parts.

[@abaysj]

Especially 4:44

[@namithapremjith1714]

This perf the sound tracks is so so loud.. mamamoo is trying to sound louder than that while singing.. so ppl didn't notice well.. Solar's could be heard but Wheein's wasn't coz her vocal tone is a bit airy..

[@mightyobserver12]

I love her my biaS

[@anshizhi]

@@abaysj that part!!! Omggg Wheein the backbone of mamamoo sooo versatile! 💗

[@alyanfs7500]

i need "sleep in the car" performance with this outfit!

[@thynguyen6769]

that's right hahaha

[@lioness2728]

Lol. Now that you bring this up, I agree completely

[@homesickalien6194]

omg i said the same thing in my brain lmao

[@nameme7801]

It was a crime that they didn't win this episode. One of the best performances on immortal songs

[@radishmoomoo2471]

I always thought they’d of won this one. Which performances did they win for?

[@vfb_143]

@@radishmoomoo2471 they won 3x with backwoods,wonderful confession and the dance in rhytm..

[@radishmoomoo2471]

@@vfb_143 cool, thanks

[@afifahnuraini9301]

5:35 the backing singers were standing there like, "why are we even here?" lol

[@honeybeemoo]

I didn't even notice them😅

[@jennawes6026]

Even the backing vocal singers

[@amyfang1405]

LOL

[@moo5289]

Well, they had a good place to watch the performance from.

[@elfridah]

You can tell they weren't there to compete 😂 they were there to have fun!! I'm glad they enjoyed themselves a little because there was a lot of pressure placed on them competing with legends.

[@MissMelody26392]

They are the legends tho

[@luckyradjapono1331]

Who are they compete with?

[@chiao1027]

Lucky Radja Pono maybe other contestants?

[@arlandeetagaytayan4154]

@@luckyradjapono1331 senior singers and bands that are veterans in Korean music I think

[@woozihae]

How the hell was Solar, wheein and hwasa hitting those high notes like they didn't just jump around and danced like their rent was due? the hell😭

[@123marcusmooney]

Solar- one of K-pop’s best female vocalist Wheein- one of K-pop’s best female vocalists and dancer Hwasa- one of K-pops most charismatic performers Moonbyul- one of K-pop’s best female rapper and one of the most credited songwriters in kpop Their talent is astounding

[@radishmoomoo2471]

Just watched the jyp version of this and while it’s good it just doesn’t even come to this.

[@aasthaj31]

Those who say that Mamamoo has easy choreography and that is why they could sing well live, should watch this. Like literally! They're doing such power pact cardio moves for the whole 5 minutes and were screaming, singing and hyping the crowd by shouting over their lungs while also enjoying the performance. They were not well synced but also very much stable and had power pact high notes and vocals. Still their performance was not only energetic but so perfect and makes you want to dance along them. That is the power of Mamamoo! If anyone still thinks that they have easy choreo, they should think twice if their favs could perform close to this energy while hitting those crazy high notes and still enjoying the performance.

[@bastetowl3258]

they can also perform for almost 4 whole hours at their concerts. their endurance is crazy

[@aasthaj31]

@@bastetowl3258 It's really crazy and the quality of the performances are never compromised. I also love how they prefer more interacting with fans than just completing the performances and the choreographies.

[@allthethinks]

Lol even if they stand and not dance theyre not gonna be better lol. mamamoo are singers thats why. Most idols doesnt have to sing as well as them and thats alright as long as theres a studio and dancing aint easy either. theyre trained to be so sync. Mamamoo can do both if they want to. They can prioritize singing and nail it, dancing and nail it, both and nail it. Natural born performers, all rounder talents, genuine ladies.

[@aasthaj31]

@@allthethinks Exactly! Everyone in the industry acknowledges mamamoo for their talent. Yet some people still try to prove their point, by pulling mamamoo down.

[@dustofyth4433]

I'M IN TEARS, THIS IS SO AMAZING I'M GOING TO STAN MAMAMOO SO HARD

[@iSell1nsurance]

Ie Yiol welcome to the Radish club

[@iSell1nsurance]

Yea I am well aware. It’s a late welcome party. 🤷🏻‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️

[@AnnaS-sl7sf]

No one hypes a crowd like Mamamoo. They are born performers

[@djvillan]

They learned from the best, 2NE1. Hwasa and Wheein are huge Blackjacks (2NE1 fandom).

[@rominaamador5360]

You can see how the audience enjoyed this performance and this was at least 6 or 7 years ago. I want to experience that hype. Mamamoo is the only group that awoke my love for K-Pop. They will always be the one I’d choose. ❤️❤️

[@owl9704a]

Again, I hope they never take these down. These babies are simmply the best girl group ever. And at my age I have seen a lot of them. And Wheein is spectacular. She can harmonise with any of the girls anytime. I have even seen her do it with our Monbyul. But when hwe and Hawasa sing together, there is simply magic!

[@aruaru6836]

i’ve been watching this video for four years now and i only now realized it’s because it has everything i could ever want from MMM in one performance: a stage where every member is having a blast, exciting choreo, honouring music culture, meaningful audience engagement, wheesa harmonies, moonsun moments, and above all, outstanding vocals. when i first watched this video to now, all four of them have grown so much and have developed even stronger techniques - it’s almost unimaginable how much greater they’ll become in the future. will follow them until the end!

[@Superr143]

this is so amazing. well, I'm a moomoo but I don't really fancy watching them perform for immortal song since I don't recognize any of the songs they sang, but this one, just wow. they really deserve that standing ovation.

[@aethersslut6267]

glazeddd it performing at immortal songs is one of the reasons why they're so popular up to this day and i love the songs they covered everytime so please watch them (i know you did tho) 😂

[@Superr143]

XJ YoonMinKookie haha I do watch them! but not all of their immortal songs performance. but this one is too much. I just can't take it. it's too good that I had to leave a comment or two

[@vadjulawakaru]

imagine immortal song invited them in many episode from were they debut in 2015 up to 2017.this girls every time they on stage they give the surprising perfomance to the audience.

[@_previously]

Ugh ;-; I love Mamamoo but I feel like their performances from Immortal Song are better than some of their music show and award show performances. But I swear, imagine this performance for one of the gayo festivals when they do segments for throw back songs. They'd slay the fuck out of the audience and the idols watching and convert them all to Moo Moos.

[@KaryluzPalacioVega]

Its true but also, they aren't given much time to work with in the award shows, just recently they did a performance in the mma that can be considered a Inmortal songs level performance, but that was because they were given more time.

[@tauratic]

I prefer the lit performances over the slow ones when they come on immortal song. every time they come out with performances like these they get more cheers than the previous time.

[@newsftw]

because they are soooo charming and charismatic when they perform! :) You need lit perfs to show that!

[@StudyLiveCanada]

Too good. Can’t compete with Mamamoo. They can do everything and anything on stage. They probably don’t know this but in future Immortal Songs, other groups will be singing their songs because they themselves will become Immortals! Bless them!

[@nuevaeinstein3148]

No matter what you cannot hate mamamoo

[@WellDressedGypsy]

Not saying that the person that won wasn't good, but Mamamoo had a much better performance. And how much work they put into it, I was surprised since the whole audience seemed super into it.

[@TheAlmane]

WellDressedGypsy who won?

[@malo5833]

Yeah, who won?

[@iRaven23]

Tei with Back in Those Days song

[@mielqtt]

Yep... I really enjoyed Tei’s performance too but in my opinion Mamamoo really owned the stage in their performance.... both were good though, and I bet Mamamoo lost by only a few points seeing how the audience enjoyed the performance

[@Athenal0ve]

​@@mielqtt​ Tei (who sounds like Korea's Josh Groban) was shocked that he won against Mamamoo... but he made it all the way to the end and beat ALL the others, so that's not something to sneeze at. But yeah, I was also shocked that Mamamoo lost when clearly they brought the house down!

[@nurcinar6405]

Wheein sounded amazing especially the part where she growls

[@shradhapurohit0765]

I'm super jealous of that audience

[@huazhang7654]

I am still obsessed with this song...🥹

[@ermack91]

I'm into kpop just for the last year, I seen a lot of groups and as a musician and leader of a metal/grunge band I can appreciate the talents of the boys and girls, but HOLY FUCK! Mamamoo is on another level what the fuck? that was outstanding !

[@fae91]

I'm sure you've discovered them by now, but i'm certain you'd like Dreamcatcher as well. Very different to Mamamoo, but also amazing. They're the only groups in kpop that really interest me.

[@eyesonmooos3689]

Mamamoo is the upgraded version of K-idol. theyre just too good that theyve set their own standard.

[@ANNABELLEPOP]

tHEIR BEST IMMORTAL SONGS YET I AM NOT JUST SHOOK I AM SHAKEN

[@Celebretix]

go watch passion flower

[@ANNABELLEPOP]

Oh, I've seen Passion Flower (I've seen them all tbh). This still wins it for me

[@Celebretix]

oouuh the real fangirb

[@wtvig1234]

Delilah >>>

[@cranberry1311]

BACKWOODS was the best for me!!! :D

[@rein5230]

They set my statndard so freaking high that i think I won't able to stan any gg anymore.... But it doesn't matter cuz they're the best! Mamamoo Jjang!

[@teenslayer]

i love your username lol. i concur

[@johnlemuelm.santiago6036]

Idols are trained to dance and sing so those who said that mamamoo can't dance are blind as hell and are the one who can't dance

[@quinneuchida3591]

My girl Wheein dancing so hard, she loses her hoops

[@cxstxyxs]

honestly I would absolutely love for korea to vote mamamoo as the next NGG. they're easily the most talented girl group out there right now and recently they've been on the rise - I can't wait for their 2017 comebacks ! absolute talent

[@lovedrunkenergy]

unfortunately, talent isn't only what makes a group in korea :( they'll prob need to release an even catchier song before they get general public recognition

[@miraaa14]

libeika DH mate, koreans love mamamoo. Like LOVE mamamoo, the thing is, they're still a little bit underrated for inter fans since they come from small company :( I believe this year will be a total bless for them 😁

[@adelam564]

Lmao you have no idea what you're talking about. When Korea Institute of Corporate Reputation ranked the most marketable celeberties in Korea; Mamamoo was 4th in March and they were the highest rank out of all K-pop idols or K-Pop idol groups. When KICR released the December list; MMM was 2nd, only behind TWICE. They are definetely recognizable but they aren't that big internationally.

[@lovedrunkenergy]

but they seem to be doing well with international fans?? ofc you can't compare with the crazed fangirls of boy groups but for a girl group and from a small company theyre doing really well imo! also considering they only debuted in 2014. usually groups gain traction in their third year so i wouldn't be too worried about their popularity taking off yet

[@effbuds]

Agree! :)

[@crxzedhumxn]

i just came here from watching the Ateez stages and goddamn Mamamoo blows my mind with their vocal stability and their engagement with the audience. I would love to watch Ateez and Mamamoo go up against each other (not in a rival way but I just love both of their performance styles)

[@himawarinara3855]

And I thought I couldn't fall more for Mamamoo, gosh I was so wrong THIS PERFORMANCE IS SO FREAKING GOOD

[@catmoo6887]

well everyone won't (or can't) stop falling for mamamoo XD

[@latenightcashews]

Himawari Nara everytime i watch another performance i feel this way

[@rcapracp3867]

Holy fuck dude those dueling vocal leads are you kidding me???

[@sorandom7210]

this is what KPOP should be... it should be like this!! #MAMAMOO is beyond idol, because idol can't afford to perform this........ i couldnt keep my mouth closed, this is so jaw-dropping performance... the only reason KPOP stans do not stan mamamoo is they haven't watch this.

[@greenranger98]

agreed

[@daniellxnder]

Mamamoo: casually mixes in their own song and still making older peeps cheer for them Their stage presence and energy are truly out of this world

[@murynay]

their vocals are no joke even from the beginning already

[@angelikab.4599]

That guy claping like crazy looked like proud father

[@sebastyann123]

5:35 when mamamoo comes to the stage and doesn't need the background singers to do their harmonies lmao

[@johnlemuelm.santiago6036]

When they are a new comer but already singing old songs and making it there own song a revival

[@jyungholic]

They are the true meaning of performers They know how to get the audience to hype and enjoy ^^ so proud of these beautiful and talented (and dorky) girls :))

[@BellaJones1999]

THEIR VOICES AND THEIR CHARISMA AND THEIR ENERGY GIVE MY EYES AND MY EARS ORGASM I CANNOT

[@meglee6889]

just want to say reading through these comments that im super proud bc we mmm fans are overall pretty mature in the way we handle discussions and debates, we respect others opinions and don't cause trouble for mmm. Sure, we may be aggressively defensive over things but we're not breaking havoc in the kpop fandom and i hope we continue to be this composed and respectful. Thanks guys!

[@srushti3680]

Not a single soul is disappointed. EVERY ONE IS ENJOYING THE PERFORMANCE.. THAT'S THE TRUE IDENTITY AND TRUE HONOUR FOR A "TRUE ARTIST" . HAPPY FOR MAMAMOO THEY GET THE LOVE THEY DESERVED...

[@melcute0393]

Who are still watching it after 3years? Definitely ME.

[@marhwasa5139]

6 minutes full of fun , talent , love , energy, excitement , beauty , and life .. only mamamoo can do this

[@magdalenamashudi3624]

THIS PERFORMANCE IS NO JOKE LADIES AND GENTLEMEN!!!! MY CAPS LOCK MODE IS GONNA BE ON IN THIS COMMENT SECTION. THIS PERFORMANCE SLAY ME PERFECTLY. PERFECTION: THEIR VOICES, THEIR CHOREOGRAPHY, THEIR STAGE CONCEPT, THEIR FASHION (I REALLY LOVE THIS THEME, THEIR STYLIST SUCCESS ALL THE TIME), THEIR GIMMICK, AND ALL THE PACKAGE! PLEASE GUYS SPREAD TO THE WORLD ABOUT THEM. THE WORLD KINDA NEEDS TO KNOW THIS MAGICAL MUSIC! MAMAMOO DESERVED BIGGER APPRECIATION AND ATTENTION!

[@sarahjones4831]

i love how the audience are people who genuinely love music and are not all kpop fan moomoos yet they all enjoy mamamoos performance to the best

[@lurker619]

Moonbyul doesn't look out of place even when she barely had any lines and I think that's really awesome. The four of them really belongs together.

[@ernestdavis3237]

After watching so many of these "imortal" songs this morning ( woke up early from a bad dream) i now see Moonbyuls importance. Shes like a cute little puppy standing there almost shy n smiling sweetly..next minute shes rapping like a pitbull terrier and gets the crowd GOING !

[@snzmn]

Pitbull terrier😂😂🤣🤣🤣

[@KB42moomoo]

three years later... i can't believe how far they've come since this performance! i thought they couldnt get better, but i was wrong!

[@shymoon3750]

All Mamamoo's members are Divas but Whasa is Diva' Queen. LOVE MAMAMOO SO MUCH!! 💞

[@juhixian]

Shymoon HWASA*

[@shymoon3750]

Juhi Xian Babria Oh, thanx. I didn't even notice I wrote it wrong.

[@crazynfreaky99]

Actually Whasa and Hwasa are both accepted romanizations of her name... but they use Hwasa in their music videos n stuff

[@Andy42402]

yeahh Hwasa is the Queen

[@gimcadiente1648]

i thought Whasa was wheein and hwasa.. lol

[@dani1075]

And that, ladies and gentlemen, is how you deliver a performance.

[@humanstellar]

They are THE idol group of this generation

[@andreaflorenza7906]

4:42 Wheein's switch to head voice was crazy.

[@kainitkn7410]

Sometimes I felt if they are debut from YG, now they will be even more shines, but after that, I feel glad that they are not from big company, that's why we are having now day MAMAMOO, is because from small company also, everyone was appreciated their talents and everything they achieved seriously they deserved it. Tks to RAINBOW very much for producing these girls 💕

[@natasya0618]

Noo, they will be locked up in dungeon!!!!!😣

[@naomiapaza4671]

If they were from YG, probably they will only have 9 songs as blackpink. I think that they are free at that small company.

[@cryinghoe8295]

@@akiraaa6767 true

[@yuki48121]

@@naomiapaza4671 Yeah..Also, they won't have freedom in YG..It's true that RBW sucks at promoting but at least Mamamoo has freedom..Like how Moonbyul makes her own rap, and them composing their own songs..They even turn some into song when they were just dissing each other like in 1cm Taller Than You..Also sometimes RBW sometimes follow Moomoo's advice like turning radish into lightstick, using Moomoo's costume design during You're the Best Era and many more..

[@roxylipz2672]

If they are in big 3, they won't have creative artistic freedom.

[@Ren-no5wc]

Are we not going to talk about 2:17 with Hwasa and Byulie, I mean that's hot tho ;)

[@wheeinqueen]

Is there a doubt about MAMAMOO is the best South Korean female group? 😘

[@gag0oo880]

wheein's growl will always get me

[@loandep2000]

Another way to say the word “talent” is “MAMAMOO”

[@malibu_rum]

This is undoubtedly a legendary stage in Mamamoo's Immortal Songs repertoire but five years later I'm still upset that they were robbed of the trophy that day (at the King of Kings special).... they deserved to win smh

[@SapiaNt0mata]

they weren't robbed. the vote comes from the audience and the audience is not biased. look how the audience enjoyed this performance.

[@yongsunsworld6519]

they only practiced this one day due to their busy schedule. THEY MASTERED IT!

[@armella.h]

And then some dump people doubt them??? I mean how can you doubt them after watching this or any other of their immortal songs?? Damn the power of this girls. I cannot see any other group reaching their level, I don't care about views or charts. This is what a legendary group should be like. Respect to mamamoo!!

[@SapiaNt0mata]

it's not doubt. it's hate that comes from jealousy cause Mamamoo are better than the group they stan, so in order to lift up their group they bring down Mamamoo.

[@stanwitch6947]

Mamamoo, Spica. Possibly also 2ne1. That's it. No one else is allowed in this tier. *in kpop*

[@bastetowl3258]

brown eyed girls also have really good vocals and stage presence though

[@outresru7751]

those who Stan mamamoo have good music taste

[@jassy7309]

doing MAMAMOO Immortal Songs Marathon again rn.

[@heartlee138]

bring back mamamoo in immortal song... please kbs..

[@SunnyRose196]

Came to watch this after I saw clips of skz (+other jype artists?) perform it

[@call-me-a-dreamer7339]

same hahaha

[@clydeeborrel3280]

Mamamoo has that charisma and stage presence that people of all ages can’t resist. I just can’t believe how talented they are

[@Belabibliophile]

2023 still they're really talented and best among the best

[@liquack]

Sii