Man vs Cobot: Stainless Steel Welding Showdown

[@ytmachx]

You're comparing apples and oranges. Mig compared to Tig . Not really the same is it?

[@austinhargett5792]

Made for a fun and informative video.. Nailed it

[@darrellolsen1204]

Really interesting and entertaining 😎👍

[@Salty_Rick420]

You can’t necessarily make a robot (ai) walk the cup or tig weld in general, mig would be the only process I can see them using them with really… I hope notat least😂

[@weldfox472]

Fun fact . 347 has same amount of chrome and less nickel than 316(19-12-3 ). 347 is basically a 18-10 or 19-9 with niobium in it for heat and rust resistance (its basically a 304-308 with niobium or nb short) , which is being used to weld on 321 material (which is 304 with titanium in it or short ti) . 321 itself has also different varients like for example 321H to name one.titanium and niobium are being used to lower the crome carbide formation. ( chrome carbides make the steel lose its chrome oxide layer , in turn makes it rust ) chrome carbides typically forms when there is too much carbon in the steel that bonds with the chrome so that leaves the iron without the chrome protecting it . The 316 or 19-12-3 variant (which is better resistant against acid and chemicals than 304 and 321 ) has about 3%molybdenum in it which makes it brittle at higher temperatures ( there is a term called 475°c embrittlement ) , therefore its only qualified to be used under 400°c max for that reason . Hope this is clear enough to be understood . Ps the welder took his sweet time to weld that , which i do not blame him for . I personally would weld it with higher amps and go much faster . Still good job

[@browskijustin3484]

SS a goat in the community 24 mins is not bad at all

[@Welddotcom]

Pretty dang fast for TIG

[@ee233]

Luv you guys lol a minute with excellent content

[@nuggy6333]

Get that exhaust on a Work Piece Positioner so that it can do one continuous weld definitely get it under 10 min, but still the coolest thing ever!

[@justinwhitaker3537]

Nice job Stan!!!

[@weldsbyzen]

Stan the man

[@Welddotcom]

Stan truly is the man! You got some mad skills yourself.

[@Okita78]

i have a cobot very similar to this one that i program at my job. it definitely works wonder for certain jobs.

[@austinhargett5792]

They use it mostly for small, repetitive parts, but hey, now they can do these too!

[@justinteal495]

​@@austinhargett5792small?!?!? Maybe this particular one, but my work has them welding up entine skidsteer frames

[@colindstark]

Now add in a positoner and both of them will be faster

[@SouthernGround]

Surprised they didn't have one.

[@moonshadowdrifting]

An etch test would help define the difference.... or not!

[@traviscollins8848]

That wasn’t really Apple to apples though. He tig’d it where the machine did mig. I would be interested to see his time running a mig op.

[@MegaSchoolman]

I know Miller makes a TIG and TIP-TIG pendant style robot, not sure about a cobot though. Would be cool to see those compete as well.

[@laiky71]

More questions than answers. Why wouldn't the human use pulsed MIG?

[@bojengels1]

That was my question. If the robot can mig it then why can’t the human?

[@austinhargett5792]

Applications for every need. Maybe they find less room for error or easier to weld with wild fit ups, not matter the joint configuration. Looks nicer etc. Those are my opinions

[@wargamingsupernoob]

I wanna know what gas the robot was running.

[@LibertyDankmeme]

i'm more worried about a robot that can use an AK-47 TBH... i hear elon is making one called optimus

[@jetfuelg4083]

Johnny cash did a song about this

[@SouthernGround]

Robots do take job's, Ask some old Cat welders before bots were introduced, ask them how the pay scale went down because of no need for skilled welders The welding line became just part's flippers.

[@mohsenmadadi5518]

Ok like ❤I love you weld❤❤❤❤❤tank you so much very good ❤❤❤❤❤

[@Welddotcom]

Glad you dug it!

[@CoopKeith1]

How do you all feel about these jobs being taken by people who have never welded or touched a machine in their lives?

[@maxscott3349]

Good for them. They have a reasonably easy jobs and probably get paid pretty well for it. I get to weld the same part 20 or so times a day for the foreseeable future for $17 an hour.

[@gmletsgetthisbread9900]

@@maxscott3349 17? have you tried any other job

[@CoopKeith1]

@maxscott3349 Honestly, that's pretty accurate on the pay they are pushing out there. It's really sad stuff.

[@morenothing4u]

The robot will win.... you just need one good welder to train the robot and clone them.

[@Welddotcom]

Stan is pretty quick but the Cobot was pretty quick as well

[@Granamire]

Another massive fail for this channel. You can’t compare a man tig welding to a robot mig welding.