Manik Ratan Part 1 -- Sharmila Tagore & Soumitra Chatterjee

Kolkata Literary Meet 2014, Day Four, January 28. Iconic actors and Satyajit Ray regulars Sharmila Tagore and Soumitra Chatterjee on being mentored by the master. In conversation with Chinmoy Guha, at Victoria Memorial Hall, Kolkata. A special session by EMTA.

[@soumenbhattacharya8935]

চোখে জল এসে গেলো। হয়তো এই সুক্ষ অনুভুতি গুলোর জন্যেই আমরা বাঙালিরা আজো শেষ হয়ে যায়নি।

[@antarasinha8639]

Khub dami katha bolechhen ... Sob giyeo eta r kothao paina ... Sukkho o gobhir ... Ei chhnoya birol

[@Rupali-m7r3r]

We haven't real life without this bengali legend" SOUMITRA CHATTERJEE"

[@TheUtsavGupta]

I just watched Apur Sansar before this video..feels do surreal.

[@ashokekumardhole9354]

It is so astonishing that with so meager budget Satyajit Ray was able to get make such great films.I would appreciate Mrs.Tagore's talent as an actress specially in all her Bengali film.

[@iamahmednahian]

Get well soon from COVID-19, dear Legend Soumitra. You’re in our prayers 💚💚💚.

[@turjamondal4250]

chole gelen😑

[@turjamondal4250]

@Dipjyoti Pandey হমমম😭😭😭😭😭

[@tapasdutta284]

We are fortunate to listen to the discussion of the two respected personalities like Soumitra Chattopaadhyaay and Sharmila Tagore in homely atmosphere.

[@eniturrahman8057]

I am totally amazed that Sarmilla Tagore can speak 'Bangla' fluently. Splended.

[@sharmilabanerjee1608]

Infact Sharmila speaks hindi in a bengali connotation

[@somnathsanyal1441]

She is a Bengali

[@ayeshajahan7290]

What you have seen is that when someone smiles, nature also smiles with her!!! Yeah I have seen. I am no her time yet I think I am her age because I love Sharmila more than anyone in this world. In the next birth or if we are reborn again, I am born as her own.

[@pritambiswas8570]

Rip sir your legacy will live with us forever in our heart.....🙏

[@supriyasengupta1969]

00

[@MridulaPan-jk5ue]

X Yb 6

[@davebhaumik5455]

If any person dies. Then just writing ““RIP” is very disrespectful. I am living in USA for over 40 years. I have never seen this. Please write at least “Rest in Peace”. Writing less words will not make you a “Hip” person. Respectfully writing couple of line are decent and respect ful. Dipankar Bhaumik, Washington D.C. USA.

[@smritikonai1221]

Soumitro chaterjee is so innocent from young age and now also ...

[@Ladybug2k]

yes very true

[@shivashish2510]

Get well soon, Soumitra da.

[@krishnachakraborty860]

অপু তোমাকে প্রণাম ।

[@zainsayed5363]

Soumitra Sir such a down to earth person.

[@bittugym8282]

she is the real look alike mother

[@srvgaming5329]

ato technical prblm hoi kano....ei somosto sorno muhurto gulo ki fire asbe ar...

[@mousumimondal554]

Respect🙏🙏

[@anunitade8530]

OOOOO WELCOME WITH HEARTY TIE..... OOOOOOO JUST SPEECHLESS AWAO

[@abhisheksrivastava5014]

Appuuuu has gone forever 😭

[@krishnachakraborty860]

সৌমিত্র চ্যাটার্জ্জকে দেখেখুব ভাল লাগছে ।

[@utpaldas8227]

It's great to see

[@beckhan2144]

Colossal loss for Bengali cinema. Irreplaceable.

[@amarkantidas6210]

Really mr Guha balar daron ta ekdam moon moon Sen r moto

[@shamimzahuri1651]

Source of beauty,end of glamour,ctg

[@drrmdebnath8356]

What is the real name of 'Sharmila Tagore'- HarHarMahadev

[@PowerfullWedits]

Who are coming after death of Soumitra chattopadhyay?

[@JMTMOVIES]

I like Sharmila Khan

[@samareshshil69]

Technical glitches 😣😣😣

[@pritamandtanialifestylevlo9204]

@chinmoy Guha sir er kachey porar shujog peyechi vebe gorbo hoi

[@Galavya41]

Maybe its just me but it sounds like SharmilaJi has forgotten Bengali...She sounds like a non Bengali who is good in Bengali .

[@nafisalubaba6271]

But she still good in english watch her miraccle shows videos!

[@anitadatta1303]

জীবনের জন্য অনন্য সুযোগ !

[@rahulspeaking]

uni rabindrabharatir ex VC na?

[@tathagatac1992]

Ha prof chinmoy guha

[@x55551man]

Sumitra Sir er golar awaz eto modhur vaba jay na

[@lajmeazfar5436]

Absolute pathetic anchor 😏 Truly unmatched with these legends. Miss u Sir... ❤️

[@azizhasan138]

Started in English then went on the 'Banglish' of Sharmila Tagore that was disappointing! Sharmila having affinity with Rabindranath speaks good Bangla but very often opt for that mixed language. Why? Is there any complex? Soumitra Chatterjee is not well comfortable in English and rationally he didn't try to do that in this meet. Sharmila therefore at least for etiquette sake should have chosen unmixed Bangla.

[@anilkashyap5321]

Sharmila Di disappointing

[@ayushmanbhattacharjee]

Soumitra Chatterjee is very well acquainted with English. His roots are too deep into the Bengali culture.

[@apratimnanda1202]

@@ayushmanbhattacharjee right.

[@augustuscaeser10b78]

This is offensive...the kind of stupid the back crew and director of the event was...the mics are never set up right

[@jyotsnabegam6472]

😥😥🙏🙏🙏

[@suvodip100]

The anchoring is absolutely pathetic......eto bhalo ekta conversation e erokom anchor ke bosano uchit noe.....

[@tathagatac1992]

suvodip chatterjee uni chinmoy guha akjon eminent professor

[@suvodip100]

Yes I am aware of that.....but that does not mean just because you are an eminent professor you will also be a good anchor......all the time he is looking at his notes for asking questions.....he can't say a word without looking at it......this is worst.....

[@tathagatac1992]

kolkata sohore r ke ache bolun??jara chiln sbai swarge r amdr moto mukro rai achi

[@asifiyananoshin8380]

Love u . Please give me visa.

[@rudrachakraborty2276]

কেমন প্রফেসার যে কুরোসাওয়াকে কুঁরোসাওয়া বলে ।

[@manamitalukder]

That anchor's accent was such a turn off

[@soumojitguhamajumder3143]

He spent a lot of time in France and he has got an equivalent of a knighthood from France. He's an eminent professor.

[@manamitalukder]

@@soumojitguhamajumder3143 doesn't mean he needs to have a French accent when talking in Bengali. Every language needs it's essence sir. I am not demeaning his capabilities or stature in anyway but when you are speaking a language it should be proper especially when you are hosting an event..

[@soumojitguhamajumder3143]

@@manamitalukder .. He has very good command over vocabulary,and accent is secondary to me as long as I can understand. Secondly , he's spent a long time in France , I'm sure you could cut him some slack.

[@manamitalukder]

@@soumojitguhamajumder3143 and I think you could cut slack to people having their opinions. I never said he was bad. I just didn't find it good and he could not grasp my attention. Cheers

[@soumojitguhamajumder3143]

@@manamitalukder That's your opinion, however, I just gave mine. For me the accent didn't matter at all. Cheers !! All I was saying- His accent was a result of his time in France for a number of years.

[@Moumita1Dutta]

Uff Sharmila Tagore, her saree and her shawl..and her tissue and sweat on upper lip...do these Bollywoodies always have to be so annoying. Look at Soumitro Chatterjee shaheb...no air, no arrogance...class by himself.🙏🙏

[@saswatabandyopadhyay3169]

Bodhisattva babu bhadra hawbar cheshta karun

[@bandookbaaz-lite8900]

WHO IS HEAR AFTER SOUMITRA CHATTERJEE DEATH

[@apontutul]

Grow up

[@bittugym8282]

sharmila mother on great for good

[@hrikmondal5803]

Who is this Anchor??😥

[@priyankarde2874]

Hrik Mondal He is eminent Professor and translator, writer and a famous figure in the World of Literature,three times Knighthood winner from the Government of France and Sahitya Academy Award winner Prof.Chinmoy Guha.

[@hirakjyotichakraborty428]

khub baje anchoring

[@priyankarde2874]

Hirakjyoti Chakraborty nije kore dekhun toh.You would be peeing.

[@sajjadhusain4146]

The artificiality of Sharmila Tagore is nauseating. Annoying woman, with minimal acting ability, a ridiculously odd voice and accent. Soumitra is an absolute legend!

[@roysmith5711]

Cinema dekhecho ektao soumitro r Sharmila Tagore er?

[@sajjadhusain4146]

I don’t communicate in Bangla using English text. That said, yes, I have seen a few films casting them both in lead roles. Your point being? 🙄

[@roysmith5711]

@@sajjadhusain4146 In Aranyer Din Ratri, she pretty much plays herself. So, if you find her annoying, you must have found the character to be annoying as well. I think she's a good enough actress, her voice is odd and that's pretty much used extensively by Mr. Ray as an asset. And I didn't understand what you artificiality you found. You can't even write in Bengali, she's talking pretty fluently.

[@sajjadhusain4146]

Roy Smith ...Look, opinions on film actors and their talents, or lack thereof, will vary widely. I feel the least bit obliged to debate at length our clearly divergent views on Sharmila Tagore. All I’ll say is I don’t particularly like her at all. She isn’t an outright mediocrity as an actress. But her voice, mannerisms, what she brings to her roles etc...don’t impress me much and often grate on my nerves. In public appearances and interviews, Sharmila always strikes me as rather too stiff, self-conscious and affected in the manner she talks and behaves. In that, though, she is far from alone in the Indian film industry at large. But my comment about Sharmila obviously pinched a nerve in you somewhere. Get over it! Lastly, your parting comment smacks of imbecility. And a presumptuousness that is mildly amusing. I made clear that I don’t trade thoughts or post in comments sections in Bangla using English text. How does that remotely suggest I don’t know how to ‘write in Bangla’? If anything, it just shows that I have better education, standards and tastes than the likes of you plebs who aspire to nothing higher than juvenile antics and cheap shots. You have to do a lot better than that,

[@SaptarshiDasgupta]

i completely agree.... end to end artifical

[@manikroy2332]

Manik +nomi

[@manikroy2332]

Manik +nomi

[@zkingdom2]

@@manikroy2332 nomi noob..bulma

[@rakhimukerji7937]

Sharmila should tell herson not to l use.Tai.mur as the name for her grand son 😢

[@sankhashekharbiswas5635]

Sharmila Tagore marred the meet. Her shallow knowledge and boastful manners, just disgusting. 😈😈

[@anindyabhattacharya4878]

The anchor is a let down.

[@bodhisattvabhattacharyya3259]

2or boi udbodhon,, ar 2ui boi 6re udbodhon kwrte parli na,,6ii pulu,,kwbe manush hwbi??

[@visionworld005]

Shame on you. Such an uncultured person.

[@rudrachakraborty2276]

কি রামছাগল রে বাবা...... উচ্চারণটা কুরোসাওয়া, কুঁরোসাওয়া নয় ।

[@priyankarde2874]

Rudra Banerjee আপনি উচ্চারণ পারেন।আর এই সব কি ভাষা।একজন কিংবদন্তি লেখকের নামে এইসব কি ভাষা?

[@bodiulalamripon3026]

আপনার কাছ থেকে উচ্চারণ শিখতে হবে !!!

[@abhijitc251083]

Kon gadhar dol era. Ingreji kopchachhe edike ato joghonno arrangement? Chhi chhi...sound check ta porjonto koreni. Chhi

[@namratasarkar5707]

Darun interview... But the interviewer is pathetic

[@sukumarsikder7479]

নেই

[@hiranmaygolder3769]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@mirabhattacharyya707]

Huge loss for Bengali cinema

[@bulletbullet2558]

Satyajit jodi na thakto soumitra ke keou chintona baler actor

[@supra1977]

Anchor ta ke ? Ki bhasha e kotha bolchhe ? er upor Rituporno Ghosh er onek probhab dekhchhi. Kinda worthless.

[@priyankarde2874]

Supratik Dutta Google Chinmoy Guha, you will get in touch.Because crooked publics you won't understand the idea of conversational analysis.

[@piumondal8131]

He is one of d eminent professors of CU who was awarded many tyms frm France Govt. Apnader joggyota o nei onar sathe kotha bolar.

[@rikraunaak2507]

With all due respect, and reverence to his eminence, I am assertive that, when I say this, I speak for many people- there is certainly something off about his Bengali pronunciation. The level of sophistication that he brings into his conversation is extraordinary, but his Bengali idiolect could certainly be better off without the "english" accentuations.