Manual or AMT? Which is better? | Hindi | MotorOctane

Manual or AMT? Which is a better choice for you and why? We share the details analysis on this. Which has better performance and which has better mileage? Why should you buy an AMT or why should you buy a manual? All these questions are answered for you.
Connect with us. We want to meet you: goo.gl/forms/6...
Follow us on
Subscribe us @ KZbin : bit.ly/MotorOctane
Facebook: / motoroctane
Twitter: / motoroctane
Instagram: / motoroctane
KZbin: / motoroctane
Website: motoroctane.com

[@srinathreddy6616]

My 2 cents.. If your currently driving a manual gear and have no issue in pressing clutch and changing gears manually, I advise you to continue with manual gear only even if your purchasing a new car. If you're an expert driver you will enjoy only manual gear only. Amt or Imt will definitely kill the mileage by 20%. Most of the time in city you will be in either 2nd or 3rd gear only. To advance to higher gears you have rev the engine to 2500 rpm and above. You will be burning fuel unnecessarily, that's why mileage drops. Also the clutch wear and tear will be much more in amt. Within 30k km run you will experience clutch vibrations etc.

[@abhishekramarao1512]

What I feel is, in manual, the chance for drivers to sleep is less because they should be keep on shifting the gears. In AMT the chance is a bit high. This is my personal opinion.

[@swarnakumari2910]

Tb to gaon me hi driving kijiye not in city

[@tauseefansari3023]

Bhai Sahi Kaha long rute par manual best hai

[@thazeebpatel2598]

True

[@salahd7]

Manual vehicles break down more as there are more moving parts. You end up stressing out in city traffic and also on a ton of maintenance costs.

[@Countrysideboy247]

Sa nope not really ! AMTs consist of pneumatics which are more unreliable, a manual transmissions remain rock solid ! Even if they have a lot of moving parts ! That is why many countries like Australia prefer manual moreover automatics!

[@sadikkhan-ds4vi]

good and technically explained. From last 1.5yrs I m using Dzire AMT, very good and comfortable car, excellent convenience in driving. Always go for AMT....

[@RabiulIslam-lr8xh]

Mileage kitna deta ha

[@AbhishekSingh-nq4rh]

Watch the video in 1.25X speed... It helps 😂😂🤣🤣

[@pollynaudiyal1737]

Thank you bro that really works

[@rajeshchoudhary8658]

1.5x

[@syedmolan7538]

Thanks bro👍😂

[@paritsharma314]

1.75x ;P

[@mohammadrehan5147]

Yes

[@MrRVAnand4]

In high city traffic and in narrow gallis, my car(ecosport deisel tdci 1500cc) goes smoothly in 2nd gear without any tension.

[@iDEAaNY1]

Both have their unique advantages and disadvantages.

[@shashikanttailor8700]

Sir,your views are correct 🙏

[@subrajit_das]

Waah bhai.. kuch mast line likha hai

[@babudhi]

After doing some serious research I bought Manual car. Drawbacks of AMT/AGS: 1. The first major drawback I found is that AMT/any Automatic Gear shift is linear. Means it will upshift 1, 2, 3, 4 then 5th gear. Same for downshift 5, 4, 3, 2nd gear even if you are driving in manual mode. You can not go from 5th to 3rd gear directly by pressing clutch. I found it is sometimes necessary to downshift from 5th to 3rd to overtake a fast moving vehicle on indian highway. 2. In AMT car you can not park the car in gear mode. I can't rely on handbrake to park a car on stiff incline or hill. In manual we can park the car on 1st gear to achieve braking. 3. In manual car you can disengage the gear from engine by pressing clutch. In this way you can achieve friction braking. Car will become slow or stop without braking after going some distance. In this way you can save brake pads. 3. On a bad Indian road AMT will struggle. As you can not use clutch to save brake pads. Brakes will worn much faster in AMT cars. Same for other hydraulics used in AMT clutch/gear as there will be continuous upshifting and downshifting of gears. 4. You can not push the AMT car to start in case of battery failure whereas in manual car you can do that in worst scenario. 5. Manual cars are tested and proved efficient for long time whereas AMT cars are relatively new in India. Maruti launched Celerio AMT on 2015 which was the first low budget AMT car in India. So, I didn't found any long term review after 100000 km as of now. Conclusion: If you are an expert manual car driver then I would suggest you to go for Manual car otherwise you might be disappointed.

[@PuneetAcademyOfScience]

Good review

[@vgopal8701]

Thank you so much❤❤

[@neotrinity99]

Read your 2nd point again

[@elyassarmast]

Thanks for your very valuable information regarding manual vs AMT system in 4 wheeler

[@kpbhagwan]

Manual is more engaging, feels connected with the car. It gives more control over the vehicle. There are skills and techniques required to use the car at its best ability. Id not depend on a computer chip to decide whats best for me or car.

[@andromgalaxy7507]

Do Manual transmission really give more mileage than auto

[@avash2009]

@@andromgalaxy7507 actually usually it never happens in high end cars mustang etc. But for some reason Auto does give less mileage than manual in cara like creta , seltos , harrier etc . I think This can be mostly due to with the kind of auto transmission being used in lower end cars .

[@andromgalaxy7507]

@@avash2009 what's your view on Mahindra xuv 700 mileage?

[@oxplegendff2820]

@@ItsHarshAtreya no 13 kmpl

[@suryansh7589]

@@andromgalaxy7507 petrol max 10 in city and 12-13 in highway Diesel max 12 in city and 15-17 in highway

[@shivendusharma3592]

I understand your point. What about Performance of DCT cars like AUDI etc.

[@deepakatray21]

For hill area only Nexon amt comes with hill assist prevent rolling back in hill. In bs6 nexon diesel is only option in mini suv segment.

[@halfdreamldn9128]

Manual se tarning kiya or AMT chla rha hu pr mza to manual me hi aata h

[@DSDS11788]

Bhai Amt me manual bhi to h you can still drive manually...ab ye mat kahna ki clutch dabane me maja aata h.

[@FindMeInsanity]

@@DSDS11788 clutch dabane me maja aata hai bro :) driving isnt fun without a clutch.

[@jaysinhabagal9134]

lol

[@DSDS11788]

@@FindMeInsanity - pls try then Nexon AMT in sport mode then come back with ur experience

[@MrApurvbajpai]

Bilkul sahi..maza manual mein hi hai driving ka👍👍👍

[@bananybaruah4777]

One cannot negotiate an automatic transmission car in flooded roads as it's not possible to keep high engine r.p.m and low speed, using half clutch and accelerator, to prevent water entering the exhaust pipe

[@iqbal-oh5qx]

I think automatic is more efficient because nowadays we have better gear box and better engine tuning.

[@timelessdriver2335]

Im my opinion both are good and fun. Both can be equally fun but it all depends on what car it is. A auto 2020 challenger should possibly be equally as fun as a manual challenger. Just my opinion

[@pankajmanik7789]

I had seen your AMT reviews in past also and bought All new Swift 2018 last year 😃 very helpful 😀

[@amannadlakha8321]

So wat u obsorve.....Amt or manual

[@pankajmanik7789]

@@amannadlakha8321 Amt .... It's good choice as you need not worry while travelling in crowded city !

[@swarnakumari2910]

I drive amt but don't know it's manual function.

[@Ranjitshedge]

@@pankajmanik7789 does average /mileage , maintenance cost affects lot

[@pankajmanik7789]

@@Ranjitshedge not much .... U get decent average.... Also maintenance cost is not that high

[@vishalsrivastava1731]

Very very nicely explained, but at the end of day, when going for first car, mainly focussed on city driving with 10 % to 20 % on highways i.e. long driving, pls give you final and kind opinion on Manual or AMT.

[@waqasmustafakhan5832]

Bhai bohat alla behtareen concept clear kra you have got the sound technical knowledge love from Pakistan

[@shashankrawat4437]

I wanted to buy AMT as my first car, but now have manual, because at price of AMT variant I got one segment above car (base model). After few week of learning and months of driving Manual just feels natural to me. I mostly drive in low to moderate traffic not in rush hours so Manual is fun to drive, but yes in heavy traffic you get exausted/frustrated fast.

[@satya4uall]

I have a AMT now which I had to forcibly buy due to heavy B2B traffic in my city..I'm a manual drive liking person BTW...The best way to use is Auto mode in traffic and once hit a free road shift to manual for thrill and fun..there is marginal difference in mileage

[@harshit7747]

Automatic gives more milage or manual ?

[@satya4uall]

@@harshit7747 Its almost the same as AMT is makeshift manual transmission with auto actuator, hence its a marginal difference. Im getting 14 in city..highway should be 18 or so.

[@nripshoree543]

Hi Satya! I hope you are in good health. Does the lag that you get while driving amt in auto persist when you change the mode to manual gear shift?

[@satya4uall]

@@nripshoree543 well you cannot compare a manual tiptronic gearshift Vs the standard manual shift. There will be an un-noticable lag .

[@jayentjenny3752]

Hi rachit could you tell me please i going to buy new car first time in my life also I am not able to properly drive car so which car should I buy please answer me? Automatic or manual

[@vineetmishra4706]

That was very thorough,, loved your take on the topic in a really concise way.. Thanks..

[@mayapatil1785]

Thank u sir me bahut confuse thi amt or manual me ab dicision fix huva AMT hi Lu safe rahega

[@guddupatel5722]

Amt bahot achha rahta h driving ke liye

[@ayushsharma8395]

Bahut achha samjaya sir aapne thank a lot.. 👍👍👍

[@hemantrix]

Hi Guys, I'm going to buy my first car soon and will me mainly driving in city. So which one should I go with AmT or Manual!?

[@saiganesh4783]

Thank you brother mere sara doubts clear ho gaya Thank you so much

[@HarshIndia19]

Which one should I choose for Tata Nexon??? And Why???

[@vikramsingh-yf8ih]

Don't know why, but i love shifting gears at bikes but not in cars 😁😅

[@UPLStudios]

Bhai fortuner kon si lu manual ya automatic

[@deepshudhiman011]

Pro Uses Manual 😈🔥🔥🔥

[@BicepsboyMac]

Pro uses Gear cycle 😅😂

[@jayraheja8314]

Because they are garib

[@srinathreddy6616]

I still feel manual is the best unless you have leg or knee pain while pressing clutch. Also point to be noted is the drive quality and experience is very very bad in amt. At times you will feel if you're driving the car or you're being driven by car?

[@Kirannarkar16]

Sir., I'm your big fan... Sir aap car types pe video bano. Eg. Sedan, MUV , Micro . 8 different car types ...

[@kj__95]

I want to buy S- presso which version should i opt Vxi + manual or amt My budget is max 5.2 or 5 .3 lacs

[@adheshn7507]

Nice one Rachit, Doston vo car he kya Jo bina gear shift ke bina chalaye, so Manuel makes you feel you are really driving a car 😉, varna tho vaise bhi life boring hai..

[@SushilKumar-sl9sr]

X

[@hellzonehz1416]

Depends on user choice

[@ROHITJADHAV-dz9ii]

Sir aap se yek request hai.... Ki aap 5 speed and 6 speed transmission pe video banaye..... Konsa better hai?, kya advantages & disadvantage hai? Aur aaj kal car lete samay 5speed /6speed dono option hote hai konsa lena sahi hai..... Plz reply and do video on this topic

[@madhavapaim]

Thank You. Made understanding the difference easier!

[@joyngamkhumlo6019]

Yes you are right.

[@bhupendersinghlucky5649]

Scooter and bike is better example. good...

[@FoodIsLove420]

If you are buying your first car go for manual. Take this as an example, you know to drive AMT and your car stopped working, suddenly you need a car for an emergency situation. In this moment you have to rely on your neighbor car which is manual. So in this situation you must know to drive manual. In a country like India, you will find more manual cars than amt. So learn manual first than Amt and you will be able to drive all cars.

[@Tiwaricarcure]

Nice video

[@krishithanair7644]

Thank you

[@Rajatjaisinghani]

Hill pe Jane k liye ya fort pe rasta thoda height pe hota hai uske liye kya best hai manual ya AMT

[@rameshbajracharya6612]

nicely explained and to the point! you have pretty nice voice to such works

[@sudharshanthirunarayanan465]

U get a better driving experience in manual transmission oly

[@aashanaskar1765]

But why expensive cars have amt

[@superkamiguru7985]

@@aashanaskar1765 Because they're more geared towards comfort in city conditions...I personally prefer manual because it is more engaging.

[@Awakenig.Anjali]

Thanks I was confused you gave me much clearity

[@tanyanheva7059]

Pahar ya mountain ilaka ke liye kya lena chahiye ?

[@deepakatray21]

For hill area only Nexon amt comes with hill assist prevent rolling back.

[@ashokrao6284]

Hamare paas AMT Celerio Two years se hai koi bhi pareshani Abhi tak nahi hui.On the contrary most suitable for heavy traffic.

[@rameshsaklani4235]

What about hill area

[@DrAnujgoswami]

Bhai aspire facelift petrol top ya amaze petrol top ya Honda wrv petrol edge sabhi ka price aas-pass hai kon si better package hogi safety and quality best honi chahiye

[@veereshgr]

When u get tired, u get sleep, if ur energetic feel fresh u won't sleep. Better u be fresh when u drive. If u feel sleepy then take break. Amt and cvt will fetch good resale.

[@Bts_forever235]

Sir u r the best ever I have seen a guide like u

[@nagoluraghavendrareddy7967]

When you drive on slope, there is a concept called ' half clutch'. Will AMT box can accelerate immediately when you remove foot on brake. And again if I have stop on middle of slope, can it pick-up to move forward ? Please suggest

[@indermali7571]

Sir car manual Lenachaiya ki Amt. celorio car choice kiya pls reply

[@ssvlogs4171]

I dwell in Sikkim and my drive is 99% hills which include city and highways. May I know how is the performance of amt in hills? Specially in the traffic condition in the hills. Will I have any problem in starting the car uphill in bumper to bumper traffic?

[@ssvlogs4171]

Plz make a video on it

[@thisisrahul8237]

bro..out of every video about cars..video put by you are most reliable

[@ferozkhan9777]

Manual is the best you feel you are driving

[@abishekraj9751]

Obvious

[@9175330784]

amt car safe hai khas kar new driver bar bar gear change karne ki jarvat nii

[@amarasegaonkar1607]

Impressed with your knowledge....👍👌

[@bigbrotherhyd]

Google it.. All does the same make out few points, tell no knowledge person he think you are knowledgeable person... 😀😀

[@chandrakantborase9075]

Good information

[@amarasegaonkar1607]

Love 😍 your style and speech how you explain.....👍👌👌

[@aminul0760]

Mera drive city me hai but traffic nhi hai to kon sa lu

[@sona6196]

Sir which is better for village and bad roads manual or automatic ??

[@tejpratapsingh2085]

Alearner should go for a manual or AMT car please advise.

[@AshishKumarDelhi]

Manual only

[@JKshivam417]

Motoroctane 👍 Shifting gears - comment

[@manojchelani5657]

Rachit Bhai mere pass Harrier xz manual Hey kya isko Automatic Torque converter mein convert krwa skte Hey.kya Tata co. Khud krke Degi or isme kitna kharcha ayega.pkease jaroor batayein

[@karansinhkatija9946]

Mujhe clutch chodni mai dikat hoti iska koi ilge batvo please sir

[@AnytowNDeitY]

Kya manual car to automatic car bna sakte hai kya ? Agar bna sakte hai to kitna cost padega manual car ko automatic car mein convert karne k liye

[@squeidgame6240]

Santro amt magna iya WAGONR vxi ags achchha hoga for long life (15years) k lie in Kolkata city me Kavi kavi sal me 4 bar 250 mp karke tour hoga Iya alto behtar?

[@ksc6569]

octane ji apake video bahut achhe hai please teach practical driving I understand you are busy but we also hope that you will teach us all the tools/tricks from a to z let the vedio big or in different parts thanks

[@bjaxom601]

Hill area or gaon ke raste me konsi gear box car lena chahie????

[@nitzmadre9950]

Sir mai nagpur Maharashtra se hu Mujhe mere state me used Tata nano xta (automatic transmission ) kitne price tk Leni chahiye

[@kapiltrivedi9615]

City drive ..use 2 wheeler..metro..public vehicle...car avoid

[@rajiblochanpanda5170]

Sir I want a car but confusion who is best diseal or petrol

[@nitondas204]

Which transmission all time best for Honda Amaze ? Manual or Automatic (CVT).

[@AliHaider-nv8qp]

Cvt

[@namitsingh5528]

I am Planning to go with petrol amt varient but a bit worried about the mileage. Should i consider going with manual only ? Amt is comfortable and easy to drive in city but mileage i am concerned.

[@renukabhandi9363]

Very smartly explained...thank u😀

[@kiranpalsingh9191]

सर आपके द्वारा दी गयी जानकारी बहुत बढ़िया है AMT कारों के बारे में, बस एक चीज और समझ दीजिये की सब लोग कहते है और आप भी कहते की AMT ,iMT, CVT कोई भी कार अगर city एरिया में daily use के लिए चलाए तो बढ़िया है, city में 20, या 30 km के प्रयोग के लिए ही केवल AMT CVT, अगर बंदे को सप्ताह में एक बार या दो बार 200 या 250 km तक एक ही ट्रिप मे चलानी हो तो AMT cars usefull नही होगी क्या,, बहुत से video में सब expert एहि बात कहते है कि city area, city use के लिए,,, सर अगर मात्र city use के 20 से 40 km के लिए AMT कार चलेगी तो सिंगल ट्रिप में 150, या 200 ,250 km नही जा पाएगी क्या, फिर तो बंदा city के 25 ,30 km के लिए स्कूटर लेले, कृपया सुझाव दीजियेगा

[@IslamicMission]

Great video Pasand ayi video❤️

[@hamzadadi1092]

Please Gear box AMT good ???

[@ankitgiri6874]

Manual vs AMT, which has more torque? Thanks in advance. :)

[@indrajitnaik5150]

Thank U

[@powerchanal2875]

Monthly 3 time journey wich car is good manaval or AMT

[@aryayk]

Which one is better in hills?

[@abdurrabkakar564]

thanks sir you solved my problem

[@HowTo-yr2yx]

Does Amt gearbox fail in any circumstances?. How to use it in hills and in overtaking?

[@drnilamberpatel6957]

Torque converter k bare me full details batane ki kripa karen....actually i am waiting for Tata Harrier which will mated with this gear box...

[@bhartichandrakar7196]

Main Jeep compas s 4 by 4 Dena soch Raha Hun mere ko mujhe automatic Lena chahie ya manual main automatic ke aur pahli bar ja raha hun aur main jyadatar gaon per TRAI karta hun tum mere ko

[@ishanhande92]

Best explained

[@SunilVerma-nj8nz]

Thank you sir - I know for parking ke samay piche karte samay chadhhai bhi hai qur dhire bhi chalna hai Isliye Accelator bhi dena aur dhire bhi chalna hai Kya AMT me sambhav hai

[@nasirshaikh402]

Thank you so much sir jiiii . very very nice .God bless you .

[@mudassirahmed6199]

Kwid AMT or celerio AMT ...which is good..I want to buy...

[@VISHVANATHSINHSOLANKI]

Thank you brother Rachit. I was looking this kind of video since many many days in Hindi ..!! I really wants to know that what is the difference between AMT vs Manual and from some people I have heard that "Automatic gadi kafi kam average deti hai Manual se " kya ye sahi he bhai Rachit ??

[@motoroctane]

Normal problem kam hai, AMT behtar hai

[@gustaspvimadalal7131]

Any car with Automatedanual Transmission-AMT when parked on steep declined road and if we have to take reverse, there is no control on acceleration and sudden acceleration can bang the car. Incase of Manual we can still control the acceleration with clutch by slowly releasing it. This safety advantage is not in case of cars with AMT?

[@gustaspvimadalal7131]

....its automated manual transmission in query

[@vedsharma10]

Nice explanations

[@baljindersingh-mp5zj]

Sir plz make video on 3.5 to 4.5 lakh car. Which is better. Manual and automatic. In this segment. Plz make

[@maheshparab3282]

Thanks rajat for ur good advice

[@satyahotrasingh733]

Dehat ur market donon me chalna hai. Amt le ya cvt. Ki mainual.

[@bhuwalsahu8195]

बहुत ही शानदार

[@sudhirpatil6636]

I am going for my 1st car..which I am planning for upto 3lakh..should I go for Manual or transmission?

[@tauqeerfarooqui9801]

top speed mei diffrence ata hai manual aur amt mei?