Mariah Carey - Forever (from Fantasy: Live at Madison Square Garden)

"Forever" by Mariah Carey from Fantasy: Live at Madison Square Garden
Listen to Mariah Carey: MariahCarey.ln...
Subscribe to the official Mariah Carey KZbin channel: MariahCarey.ln...
Watch more Mariah Carey videos: MariahCarey.ln...
Follow Mariah Carey:
Facebook: MariahCarey.ln...
Instagram: MariahCarey.ln...
Twitter: MariahCarey.ln...
Website: MariahCarey.ln...
Spotify: MariahCarey.ln...
KZbin: MariahCarey.ln...
Lyrics:
Forever
And ever, my darling
Forever
You will always be the only one
You will always be the only one
#MariahCarey #Forever #LiveatMadisonSquareGarden

[@AmberToure]

Without discussion, THE BEST FEMALE VOICE OF ALL TIME, no one has been able to match such a glorious voice❤

[@female1x]

But mariah

[@ulradeja5380]

Any sound engineers can match it or even higher

[@AmberToure]

@@ulradeja5380 It amuses me to see how you hate Mariah, but you continue in all her videos 🤭 you are so embarrassing.

[@pv33]

@@ulradeja5380show us

[@cailempereria]

I agree!!!!

[@shytepoms5074]

Admit it, the 90s Mariah set the standard in what a singer's voice should be.

[@raylenemay2934]

so true

[@Eddy6159]

David Nick Mariah set her own standard and managed to step out of Whitney's shadow fairly early.

[@thedivasofsupreme6190]

Whitney set the Standard of SINGING Mariah set it HIGHIER.!

[@mimilamb4lifemariahthequee679]

The Serial Mariah set the standard because she writes also her songs and inspired all the New generation

[@mimilamb4lifemariahthequee679]

David Nick Mariah set the standard because she writes her songs like nobody. Whitney couldn't do a song like this and Mariah has the highest voice ever and inspired all the New generation

[@paulgalabay6338]

☑️ Lyrics ☑️ Melisma ☑️ Heavenly falsetto/head voice ☑️ Creamy/Buttery/Light Tone ☑️ Resonance Perfect representation of a perfect vocalist 💓

[@DaniloStrever]

Angel

[@recettesdechasseur]

God's given TALENT

[@bacootstream4421]

Whisper vocal

[@dazeitem]

You forgot stylistics.

[@thiagobueno8078]

you forgot belting

[@Simonmelendez1980]

I saw Mariah LIVE twice in her prime and was SHOOK by the power and quality of her voice. It was otherworldly.

[@MarKatara]

which concerts??

[@livai1915]

Lucky u...am soooo jaleaous😭😭

[@Marilyn205]

@@MarKatarate interessa?

[@VitorSantos-kp2to]

​@@Marilyn205Se não interessasse ela não estaria perguntando né..🥱🫡

[@michellel.3871]

#Perfection ! The best voice there ever was or ever will be. 💙🤍💜💖

[@giomediaworks]

For those who are wondering why Mariah waves her microphone like that, no, she is not lip-syncing. Those are her vocals live. She's doing a performing technique . See, a lot of singers make the mistake in shoving the microphone to their face when they perform. They end up sounding loud and rough. The reason Ms. Mariah here can achieve a smooth and butter-like sound from voice when sings is because she knows how to control her volume and proportion the mic from her face. With this, she is able to control her low and high notes notes, her volume, and the amount of breath noise she sings into the mic. Its vocal perfection at its best. Hence the standing ovation throughout her performance.

[@fortresssnug]

Super super super trueee!!!! She knows when and when not to distance the mic from her mouth. Sometimes, even her whispery voice is too powerful she doesnt need to put the mic too close. That's how amazing she is!!! Forever love mariah!

[@breakfastglitter]

To be fair, I think this version was edited for her DVD. BUT if you search the live unedited version of this song from MSG she sounds the same. She slays, always.

[@greatalexfromdz]

+Giovanni G she's perfect!first i thougt i was watching the lyrics video..

[@johnrovicmendoza5073]

+Linda Kamphan OMOOO Where did you find the undubbed version of Forever in MSG? I can't find it now :(

[@johnrovicmendoza5073]

PJ Greaves Yeah it was dubbed.

[@ydaphuck__youlyin6978]

I envy those who were able to witness Mariah in her prime 😭😭😭😭

[@dfabrary3932]

Me too

[@Wowitzkay]

YdaPhuck __ YouLyin? RIGHT 😭

[@IsabelArmstrong]

Me too

[@eliastefera8574]

I always bite my lips on this one!

[@floresrickjohnr.1665]

Me too I'm definitely envious right now

[@sandhyanagarajan]

The agility required to sing this song is insane. The fact that she sings this song while walking around, moving her hands, and looking at the audience is incredible! Her tone is flawless too.

[@JuliahCheree]

literally. i’ve watched this over 100x and it still blows my mind how fluid her voice sounds & how broad her range is when she sings this. unnreal

[@JuliahCheree]

*unreal

[@berrysweet2321]

Her singing can touch your soul especially this song, timeless 😊

[@dioneisantossantos6711]

Ela canta muito❤Mc

[@sandhyanagarajan]

@@JuliahCheree EXACTLY her voice is so fluid, unreal

[@francisallancastro6300]

A vocalist like Mariah only appears once in every 7 billion. Such a legend

[@toadpossum6668]

Back then society wanted her talent and she had support and favour. Today is different. But there's plenty of undiscovered talent around.

[@sylviahelena4139]

We're lucky so, now there's 8, there could be another mariah, waiting to be discovered...

[@honeyrose7663]

I think she's a one in a millenia. I don't think we'll see another Mariah with such a beautiful voice an technique in 1000 years. Ariana came close, she's unique with her own voice - influenced by Mariah as well but not close to Mariah. Plus Mariah had an opera singer and vocal coach as a mom

[@michaellee340]

@@toadpossum6668 get off the juice

[@camilapinheiro6272]

Thank God she has such a beautiful voice❤

[@CanoManuelGonzaga]

No one can touch this song FOREVER!

[@jimskok2102]

Nobody can reach Cano

[@Shainmeng]

Cano Manuel Gonzaga Far too high and far too hard to sing

[@jimskok2102]

Exacto! Viva Mariah! Jejjejee

[@mitty253]

Right

[@allancarey1970]

Cano Manuel Gonzaga It's right.

[@ojcarperry]

She was lucky to made her debut in the 90’s cause then people appreciate so much the power of the voice against nowadays when the voice is the last thing that a singer or people think about.

[@faldi81]

Man...if you do not have a voice killer like mariah, whitney, aretha, boys 2 men, or mostly dominated by black r n b, dont u ever wish became a singer....'90 is a hard time heheh

[@dee12yearsago88]

Only thing they think about these days are drugs and sex it's disappointing

[@joshlayes3130]

Faldi syah I agree that they are AMAZING vocalists.. but I disagree that was the only way. Madonna was arguably a bigger icon (whether we like her or not) with a pretty basic voice

[@mimilamb4lifemariahthequee679]

Madonna has a horrible voice like it or Not. Mariah outsings your flopvoicedonna.

[@eddyandroxy3830]

Lorenzo Diaz totally agree. we good we were exposed to good music

[@ETCNK]

Mariah has by far the most complex singing I've ever heard in pop music

[@evagomes1590]

And most people don't even realise it

[@ace.2065]

@@evagomes1590I love Mariah!! And Whitney!!

[@ares6953]

always imitated , never duplicated !!! The one and only Mariah Carey !

[@elisabethsianipar8934]

Yuuuppp

[@RobGuster]

🦋 Mariah Carey 🦋.

[@richmariahemancipate]

When the live version is better than the studio.. only Mariah!

[@krystiankozowski7282]

It's the same here....

[@qxyzzz]

Krystian Kozłowski No there's parts she didn't do in the studio version dahling 🌝

[@biakzuala5007]

Truth 100%

[@differentlydifferent]

This is a pre recorded live version. But yea she definitely changed the arrangement some for this performance. Amazing Vocals

[@qxyzzz]

Ron Isley Mariah can't lip perfectly, especially in her prime, it's most likely live, but people just assume it's pre-recorded since they don't have the undubbed version of this performance 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@jech_jech]

If you think "I Will Always Love You' is hard to sing, you definitely haven't heard of MC's Forever.

[@rotedem]

Definitely. This song is a vocal suicide. Too hard to sing. I cant even find covers for this song.

[@alissonoliveira7960]

+Edsam Rotedem Andit I did! It's very hard!

[@KuyaBJLaurente]

+Harry Potter I honestly have never heard anyone do a cover of this song but the writer queen herself, MARIAH CAREY.

[@rotedem]

+Salvador Laurente Jr there's someone from the Philippines apparently. Her name's Kyla. She sang this but of course not as good as the queen.

[@rotedem]

+Alisson Bryan oh God. I ought to listen a cover from a lamb. 👍🏻 i shall.

[@honestperson3042]

Mariah Carey' s voice... One in a 7 billion. Simply the greatest vocalist of all time. 👑

[@faithb.2583]

Agree

[@elieortiz3659]

💯

[@johnathantaylor5913]

The population of the earth when Mariah was born (1969) was 3.607 billion.

[@elieortiz3659]

@@johnathantaylor5913 she was born 1970

[@PopCultureCarnivore1]

She could never see Whitney Houston.

[@rafa456o]

Giant vocal masterpiece! She was doing her magic here.

[@alicesilveira9469]

Rafael Araújo s

[@fervidamidthedandelions3405]

Tyler Mills ratatouille

[@swift-rk1fx]

Tyler Mills WAHAHAHAHA STFU

[@fervidamidthedandelions3405]

Tyler Mills kzbin.info/www/bejne/mWTWc3WIral0p80

[@xlazmlx]

Tyler Mills Usually I would agree with you.. but this is dubbed. Mariah is bad at lip syncing and would never the pull the mic away from her mouth when lipping belts

[@red-xv9dz]

this woman is breathtaking and her talent will be in the history forever.

[@liorcoussin-jackobsohn7944]

wow so true!!!!

[@komangputrardelrey]

FOREVEEEEEER ------

[@goldenlamb777]

Thank you 🙏

[@goldenlamb777]

I can’t exist without her music. I’m lost otherwise. I admit. I love her so much. 🌹❤️💋💥🔥🤫😜

[@wellofcire]

that's what she was secretly careying on about...i'm sure

[@GgRdario]

The most beautiful voice in the universe, no one had or will have a better voice than her. ¡The greatest vocalist ever born!

[@otiliaiutis9049]

you mean SHE

[@camilapinheiro8353]

it was God who gave her this talent!

[@arvintemaria8466]

O iubesc pe Mariah pentru ca ea canta pentru mine.❤

[@Selinarosemarius]

I Sing like her

[@camilapinheiro6272]

@@Selinarosemarius I would like to hear you singing

[@Spilota13]

I don't want to compare Mariah to other Queens like Whitney or Celine but you have to admit that Mariah has something more in her voice and her interpretation something that comes from heaven like an angel. The performance is incredible, we forget all our worries while listening to her. Thank you Mariah to exist and to have sung this wonderful song which will remain FOREVER in my heart ❤🙏

[@shahrzadjalili5718]

Omg exactly!!I thought I was the only one noticing that😂💕

[@paulthomas281]

@Spilota13 Absolutely. Mariah Carey's voice is one in a hundred million.

[@female1x]

⁠no has mariah voice she one in 10 billion her voice is god like vocals

[@kaiwoods6260]

Only be and ever be one MC. We are So lucky

[@sunshinelove3668]

Exactly! Mariah Carey! 🔥👑❤️

[@asekun022]

Mariah's Voice is absolute perfection! Crazy range!!

[@allenluy]

Beyond perfection 😍👌

[@ErnieMarquez]

Norielle Serrano i agree with you

[@greisanette2307]

Norielle Serrano Totally agree!

[@thepapyrusxrol]

Norielle Serrano This song is untouchable XD

[@federicoraggio252]

Tyler Mills So? NO ONE IN THE WORLD could ever dream to replicate this even in the studio

[@fjesbright7942]

with this song alone, she destroy all your fav catalogs and career... so please RESPECT this woman as a singer, vocalist, songwriter, producer and LEGEND !

[@ADazzledDazzle]

FjeS Bright tea was SERVED

[@user-jk3ho7uo1s]

Preach

[@catherinevaz6139]

For real though...

[@veevids2679]

Yeahh Dahlinnnn

[@danielx4731]

savage！！！

[@bsusak09]

She will forever be the best singer/songwriter in history. Doesn’t matter what her voice sounds like now. You sell that many albums, travel that much, get used by record labels and give birth then try singing. She’s the ultimate, forever.

[@honestperson3042]

PERIOD

[@DaniloStrever]

PREACH!!

[@alifishakayob3633]

SINGING WITH NODULESSSSS! Don't forget this part of her instrument that could be both a huge blessing and a factor to the detriment of her voice.

[@cristinavega5729]

One of the most difficult songs in history, performed by ¡The best female voice in history! ❤ You will be eternal Mariah carey.

[@Brend.0]

The "mic swinging" is a clever way to get dynamics right singing live. Controls volume, like a knob. And the hand waving? That is a mind trick she (and other singers) use to "aim" for melisma on pitch, kind of a form of mathmatics . Basically there is a lot going on in her and any good singers mind when they sing. The voice is truly an instrument that takes practice and skill, something many modern day singers have forgotten.

[@codywalsh2075]

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Mariahs hand movements are just as legendary as her voice Heheh 😝😊

[@jsbg7323]

well said.

[@Melanie1502]

It's an art we don't see artist do anymore. Mariah's technique is what really sets her apart from other legendary singers.

[@abdulrahimankakkoothil1817]

+Madison g

[@mariahisthe1]

+Madison so true.

[@Matthew9.__]

After this performance, i don't know why there are other singers, except for Mariah, Whitney and Celine.

[@eliastefera8574]

That's what I always say, thank you!

[@butterflyszn2342]

stop ignoring talent. Aretha Franklin, Patti Labelle, Barbra Streisand, Donna Summers and many others deserves recognition for their talent.

[@toma7409]

+Kingpablo so freaking true, recognize and appreciate all of the people that have paved the way but I think he was referring to the kind of newer generation that influenced the mid 80s to present pop and r&b culture. But you're so right

[@reuvinvids]

+Thomas Allen I still think that some modern singers like Sia or Hayley williams deserve some respect.

[@toma7409]

+Reuben Vinnie most definitely. i do respect them. Sia is a real musician and songwriter. i would never take that away from her.

[@roujinheath]

One of the hardest song to sing.. Those riffs and runs,the adlibs and the high pitch notes are insane..and the malisma is captivating,. pure talent.

[@jfrnz1703]

the only singer in the business with such beautiful face that matches her vocals.

[@SleazzyM]

Children bashing MC singing live on stage, but their favorites could never have the vocal capability of this woman gracing the stage. AFTER 20+ years of performing LIVE. Don't judge people, pay resects, while this legend is still living. Do you see Mariah dancing around on stage with an act? Or in any ridic outfit to keep the audience entertained? No. Millions paid to come hear her VOICE, a talent, oops, no shade to your favorites today. But let that soak into mind. Could they ever????

[@izell6316]

Yes.

[@KemalTrinanda]

ikr😂😂👑👑

[@THXx1138]

+MIMI CAREY +MIMI CAREY - Even though this particular video's audio is the studio recorded version of the song - I still totally appreciate Mariah's talent :) wonder what she sounded like live here - more than likely flawless as usual :)

[@markgabay2940]

indeed...

[@meggutierrez2114]

+MIMI CAREY Really agreeee with that. Mariah is a living legend.

[@nat0106951]

why am I starting to appreciate singers like mariah now.. is this part of really growing up... as a 31 year old 😅... just realized how good she is and how hard it is to sing like that. the breathing alone.. is a killer.. and those mic techniques and phenomenal vocal. a metal head here 😅

[@tactileMD]

Me too! 31 year old guy here and just now learning to appreciate Mariah Carey's voice. Got to have all her 90's albums for sure. Her voice is like butter!

[@meng057]

Nate She’s 25 here tho

[@tactileMD]

JE TH We mean that we are 31 and only now starting to appreciate Mariah’s vocal techniques (at any age) 🤗

[@meng057]

tactileMD I know i said shes 25 here at that young age shes has that incredible voice😇

[@rt7535]

Nate....i hear ya. I was only into heavy metal music back in the 90s, I didn't really know about Mariah. But now I appreciate her music, she had an awesome voice. I think it comes with getting older and more mature....haha.

[@EvelynMoretti]

One of the best vocal performances of all time. In the greatest voice that has ever lived.

[@Angelina-lf1rh]

Performances like this are what separate Mariah from other singers. The greatest of all time, no one will ever match this.

[@Y3C0868]

Mariah sounds amazing here. I can't even believe she's singing live. I think her problem today is that she is her own competition. We expect her to be just as good as she was.

[@CassieJazz96]

werquin perez My thoughts exactly.

[@SleazzyM]

+werquin perez She shared her voice & gift w us for 20+ years. With the vocal strength like she graced us w on this performance, ofc it will not be in the same shape. Be thankful.

[@Y3C0868]

I love MC, but I hate when ppl keep saying all this. Haven't Aretha and Patti done the same... Celine too? Mariah is not that old!!

[@SleazzyM]

werquin perez But we're talking about just Mariah here, not those other queens.

[@ilyjc91fe5]

+werquin perez They don't have vocal nodes like mariah does

[@nelsonsailo4019]

This song is so damn hard to sing. Technicality and emotional delivery must be 100%. From soft to powerful belts to melismas to projection to stamina to key change is required. She made it seem so easy. Mariah is Mariah 👑👑👑

[@ambercyezii1880]

Mariah is untouchable, attempting to sing her song is suicide 😂

[@andreaboys]

This song is beautiful even is not a top but for me is so hard to sing this song like Mariah ..is wonderful

[@emelinesuarez5520]

Correct

[@ernesthemingay5397]

It sounds SO DIFFICULT to me and she made it seem effortless 😍

[@rt7535]

nelson sailo .....true. Such an awesome voice.

[@lesthermarquezblanco8343]

Still watching in 2024 anyone?

[@bryanstarke2931]

That run towards the end is unlike anything I've ever heard in my life. And she's so GD beautiful. Am I dreaming? 😍

[@sarahm5936]

I'll bow down Beyonce, but Mariah makes my knees go weak and has me floored by her talent.

[@soaringangel5316]

+Leave Now no they aren't they fall under the same category and Beyoncé said Mariah is the reason why she started singing so...

[@jefftorres409]

This song is done nobody can sing this song ever again..

[@cruzlane9448]

Mariahs talent is totally internal which means it can't be manufactured, Beyonces talent is external which means everyone can copy it

[@harajuku.dennis]

@@cruzlane9448 No. Beyoncé is in fact one of the best vocalist. You might not like her or think that her tone sounds boring and bland but girl her technique is almost as great as mariahs, her versatility in music is unmatched, she has more than 4 octave range. She can sing circles around artists like Ariana, Adele, Sia and even Lady Gaga. In addition to that she's been singing sing 1993 and her voice still sounds very great. And there is a reason why she's called the greatest performer alive. Not a single artist in the whole damn music industry can deliver a Coachella performance like Beyoncé did and if you watch her documentary "homecoming" you know damn well that you can't deny that. Now stop uplifting Mariah and dragging Bey. They are good friends and even Mariah said that Beyoncé is a gorgeous vocalist. I seriously hate fandoms. Mariah and Beyoncé are my queens but lambs can't stop to drag people like Beyoncé, Whitney or Celiné down.

[@harajuku.dennis]

@@cruzlane9448 kzbin.info/www/bejne/n4OZiGSmgNOEns0 Hate her or love her but the woman is talented unlike many people. She combined vocals and dancing and made it a thing in the 00s. I mean look at other female performers. Can Janet Jackson sing? No. Can Britney Spears sing? No. Can Jennifer Hoepez sing? No. Beyoncé is outstanding no matter what you say.

[@odangoatama98]

This could easily pass as a studio recording. The vocals are freaking perfect.

[@schaferatsprynet]

+Al'ykc Pryor It's an exact duplicate of the studio recording. It was lip synced or dubbed here.

[@hectorbello161]

+Lenny Schafer Are you deaf? THis is VERY different from the studio. Dubbed maybe, lipped NEVER.

[@nokie3256]

+Lenny Schafer they maybe play the studio version over the live version to make a so call "lip-sync" feel in most part of the song, i think

[@soaringangel5316]

It's dubbed vevo usually dubs performances like these for some reason but at this time Mariah would never lip sync

[@nokie3256]

+John Loreno it is kind of strange of her 'playing' with the mic, it sometimes far away from her but sometime close to her.....

[@timothyjeromewilliams8589]

A beautifully tragic love ballad..I remember..most people will always recollect such an absorbing piece of stellar music and vocals...

[@Izabelle835]

Yes! While i love tons of Mariah songs, Forever will always be number 1 for me. Melt Away would be second best.

[@raykkenmnc1555]

That transition makes my heart melt away, and when she sustain that C#5("forevaaaaaaaaaaa") , i was carried to heaven, and that A5 in head voice...!! Guys, just goosebumps 😭❤️❤️❤️

[@mariahisthe1]

Yes!

[@JustFiddler]

😇😇😇

[@mhanne02]

Number of times Mariah switched her mic left and right: 29

[@kellysmith8845]

Observant

[@michaelie8735]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@melmel7011]

boredom is real😂😂😂😂

[@panganayniprecy592]

Peanut Brittle actually, it's 30 times

[@bettykhuboni8758]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂❤❤

[@8VD80Y]

You people will never give Mariah the credit & respect she deserves. Mariah is a music Icon. Who else produces, writes, and sings like her?? NOBODY! She is in a category of her own. #queenofmusic

[@DanteRiccelli1]

I honestly believe she is the BEST artist in the business. Bc SHE decided to put forth the effort to be her own and other people's producer and writer and learn to keep singing better and sing runs like nothing. She is the hardest working artist who doesn't get half that credit. She gets credit for her success not the work she did to get the success.. Smh 😤😒

[@CassieJazz96]

Danté Riccelli Same here, she's my favorite artist of all time.

[@DanteRiccelli1]

CassieJazz96 I can't fathom the thought of what the world would be without her. Half the artists from 00's to 10's wouldn't be on the radio is Mariah was never discovered.

[@CassieJazz96]

Danté Riccelli Yup, ha influence lol

[@federicoraggio252]

Law This makes me so sad... that it's impossible that another singer like Mariah will ever exist

[@bmack2244]

Feel bad for people who didn’t grow up in the early 90s not hearing her hits on the radio.

[@truthseeker9290]

Thanks for the sympathy 🫂.

[@honestperson3042]

She has the most beautiful and angelic voice I' ve ever heard, It' s magic, unreal, heavenly. And this song is almost impossible to sing. Forever the unbeatable Vocal Queen 👑

[@alanr.oliveira957]

The world's best, there is no comparison.

[@42woofy]

you said it... the best singer and no compare...

[@wahn10]

No one even comes close. And no one could ever sing this song other than Mariah. #incomparable

[@theslaytoendyourfaves]

@Imani Alexander everyone in this world is flawed but there's something in Mariah's voice that blesses our souls. Her songs are prayers!

[@imtheboy2200]

Hi sweetie 😍😍😘🤗

[@mimilamb4lifemariahthequee679]

@Imani Alexander Mariah destroys Slutney she has resonance,Melisma,agility That Slutney doesn't.

[@jericmalicse3449]

No one can compare Mariah's voice. This is one of her hardest song to sing, that no one or somebody can sing like what she did in live on in studio version. This is the only proof that Mariah is on top of the other artist from her prime until now. She's kicking every artist until now.

[@timehealscompany9813]

So hardcore...

[@misshaiku_k2857]

If you love Mariah, check out PH's Morissette Amon, you might have missed someone in your yard...

[@honestperson3042]

@@misshaiku_k2857 If we can listen to Mariah, what's the point of listening to an inferior karaoke singer. And anyway no one has ever sung this song with the same, low notes, transitions especially in the chorus, runs, resonance, perfect pitch and so on

[@CrystalMurphyMusic28]

Agreed! Fav. song & Forever my Idol!! I'm also a singer songwriter and I cover songs by Mariah, Whitney, Kelly, Toni, Celine, Beyonce, Leona, Alicia, Adele, Ariana, etc. Just posted a live performance at a festival. Would love some feedback. Thanks. (Forever Cover) kzbin.info/www/bejne/e4fSamegZ9OYgrs 💖💖💖🦋🦋🦋 Crystal

[@roywilliam6080]

She cant sing like this anymore now

[@paulthomas281]

People don't realise how impossible it is to sing this song. It is suprahuman. You can hear these dynamics and acrobatics in people who have been trained for 25 years and more in Indian classical singing and vocal art. Mariah Carey is simply the greatest.

[@RDanetu]

Is she human?????

[@krystleroa2481]

At all shes fkin everything

[@bulustyle9825]

😂😂😂

[@stephaniebuggs1762]

Can’t be

[@jordanlemichael]

Pre recorded I think sadly

[@RDanetu]

Pre recorded but still its her voice tho

[@memadelrey5099]

You Mariah, you will forever be the most talented woman ever 😘👸🙏

[@qxyzzz]

Sophie Adam Jealous much you don't have her talent? LOL dumb asf

[@PeteRoyJackson]

And who can compare, other than maybe Whitney?

[@andersonsouza2613]

You Love

[@lololol1278]

@@PeteRoyJackson Lara Fabian? SoHyang?

[@lololol1278]

@@PeteRoyJackson Meh, Mariah is still better

[@SleazzyM]

There is something about the way she sings this song....I just cannot explain it, you would never find a LIVE performance w this much passion in a song today......sad but this is the truth, I have hope for music though.....good music.....Thank you Mariah for sharing your gift with us.....

[@theilliad4298]

+MIMI CAREY its too insane and effortless ...

[@marianospears3626]

+MIMI CAREY i love you

[@SleazzyM]

Mariano Minaj I love you too.

[@johnhill4973]

+Caprice Summers Yea,you've said it right.They never make such good music any more! Pity current lot of the so called singers/musicians!

[@osmandemir3167]

+Caprice Summers 7y0

[@AaronDalgliesh]

She was blessed with a voice that no one can ever have. A unique talent.

[@mycenth22]

the placement is what really separates Mariah from a lot of other vocalists. belting like that can get overwhelming to listen to but as an amazing vocalist Mariah knows how to place and support that the sound... A lot of people just holler...

[@rexonbagares7879]

One of her hardest songs to sing..nobody could sing this song like her..no one..she's incomparable..👍👍✌

[@andresizarra2312]

only when i saw you can top it.

[@user-jk3ho7uo1s]

She wrote her songs like that. Hard to duplicate

[@a-bd1216]

the lungs on her...like girl what did you just do amazing ! hard work

[@Daydream30583]

@@a-bd1216 Had yeah this is a classic example of power belting above sound resonance no wonder people were going crazy at her live performances

[@antonioallen1763]

And still is super luscious too!!

[@MrKindgirl]

I like when she sings the "never be ashamed, call my name!" so clean, so buttery, and emotional, these adjectives can only come together when mariah sings

[@LadyVoldemort]

Frodo's Mascara Frodo's Mascara? LoL. 💜

[@lavernieejoc7981]

[@anabelenopia6841]

Ohhh really nice song I love it.....

[@honestperson3042]

AND AGILE !!

[@davidwharehinga2679]

MARIAH CAREY WILL FOREVER BE THE QUEEN OF THE STAGE FRONT !!! ...

[@diygamer1396]

This is mariah carey in her prime❤❤

[@mariahisthe1]

Unbelievable. Her vocal control, tone and range are simply amazing. Best vocal I've ever heard of hers or any artist.

[@user-ut7ig7zu7k]

She's clearly the superior vocalist, no one can reach her level of perfection

[@mariahisthe1]

@@user-ut7ig7zu7k agreed. She's amazing.

[@joseph9531]

She wrote this song.

[@mariahisthe1]

@@joseph9531 yes!

[@BrunoArrudaEng]

Her voice is so connected. How the hell she just enunciates after that enormous C# at 2:52 is beyond me.

[@lovesongs8810]

I swear when this woman passes and is no longer with us, I will lock my self in my room, with 5 boxes of tissues, and watch this video over and over just sobbing at how beautiful her and her vocals are.

[@lakeerieislander]

Absolutely breathtaking! Hearing Mariah sing "Forever" always stops me in my tracks. That soaring voice. The presence of her on-stage delivery in this video. Her voice is perfect. Perhaps, other-worldly. And when I hear this song it, is as if we are hearing an angel sing among the clouds of the heavens - if that should exist out there, somewhere. Now, I was in college in the early 90s when Mariah's first album dropped. And everybody loved it! I can remember being in the dormitory with friends and listening to her first CD. My roommates and I were like "Who is this person? This amazing artist?" For me, this song is the culmination of all her experience. The absolute peak. Brings a tear to my eye, because with these lyrics, I ponder the passing of time, the loss of loved ones, and the profound sadness that things will always change and you can't hold on and live in the past. Nevertheless, with these lyrics, is that holding onto that idea of "forever love." Remarkable. Thank you for this gift to the world, Mariah. Your songs have made the world a better place and enriched our lives as we make our way thru our everyday lives.

[@kriximae2817]

One of the hardest Mariah songs to sing! :)

[@mdmnvv]

All of them :)))

[@sandraquezada6987]

yo la canto porque soy soprano si es algo complicada..pero linda..

[@CassieJazz96]

Gary D And Emotions......................................chile

[@LadyVoldemort]

Belle Caroro Personally, I think this is the hardest one in breath control...everytime I tried to sing it my mouth would be filled with saliva, LoL. This is her most beautiful and my most favorite song of her, too. "Emotions" and many others because there's too much high notes and I don't have whistle range. And "My All" because of the crazily wide range...I can't reach her lowest part in the end, and I'm an alto for crying out loud. 😂

[@izurrahman4559]

all of MC's songs are hard to sing by others...amazing singer...legendary

[@sheepsheep5751]

Mariah at her best is just unreachable and unparalleled.

[@honestperson3042]

True

[@DaniloStrever]

Period. #1 vocalist in history

[@Izabelle835]

What most people dont realize is the power of her breathing technique in this song. 2:29-2:42 is only 1 breath! 🤯

[@ronieljaderosello60]

No one is a better singer. 🫶🏻

[@absolutelyscaramouche]

period

[@mdmnvv]

No-one can sing this song. If anyone can touch those high notes, it's still not great because it's Mariah's vocal.

[@mauyagsamanudingi.7414]

yes, really truth mariah is the best International Queen Of music industry🤗😉😘😍 and I'm a fan of mc i love her so much, ☺️ I Have a request for you, u can check out the mariah carey of the phillipines a young man who can Sing it like mariah , U search in here in KZbin KENNY CANEDO Forever she ruins and nailed it the song, and more song of mariah ☺️☺️☺️

[@pipitojosen765]

Yaasss.....

[@mauyagsamanudingi.7414]

what can u say😁 about him, he did the song of mariah and he's sounds like mariah also😉😊 he's also known as mariah Kenny of the philippines😁😅 .. I lOve u So much (MC)🤩😍😘 Forever and ever idol☺️

[@carolllop]

Katerina velarde...

[@Saulestrellav]

are not as high duh

[@MrIkmalAhjusshi]

I envy to those who lived during this era.

[@oceanusun]

I lived during that era.. I was like 9 years old and it was magical times.. Mariah was on the radio every time my dad took me to the school .. : D

[@gabrielmohi1186]

Ikmal Ahjussi it was amazing living through the 90s

[@hijadedios4235]

Gabriel Mohi What makes the 90s so amazing ???

[@gabrielmohi1186]

Hija DeDios .... 1st of all what made the 90s amaze ballz . ... My Mum was alive well and healthy... Mariah was introduced ... music was actually music none of this made in china bullshit (well not in my country ) ... so much positives i had in the 90s had a blast ... its 2018 and MC is still relevant .... Oct 2nd im off to her concert again ...

[@richardlara5466]

This album was released when i was back in second year highschool. Damn even the guys were jamming on her song fantasy and most of us students have a cd of this on our discman.!!!

[@GheloMatic]

This is probably one on the hardest songs that is almost impossible to sing. Mariah's voice is not human

[@mikeurias770]

90s Mariah set the basis for her style. Afterward, she built on it. She just got better and ridiculously accurate with her note choice and tone. Butterfly album is THE benchmark. NO ONE CAN REPEAT OR BETTER THAT. It's all sweet candy. I've got a cavity from it.

[@lutherfrost5176]

God knows how many times I've listened to this song

[@user-ut7ig7zu7k]

I'm so obsessed with it yet it gets me everytime 😭

[@seeeLAH1]

forever and melt away on repeat 24/7 for awhile now

[@liorcoussin-jackobsohn7944]

the same lolll

[@kirstiekettledas9635]

24/7

[@bacootstream4421]

Fuck love it

[@Matthew9.__]

In order to be even considered to compare with Mariah Carey... you need to check the things in this list first. 1. Strong Chest Voice! Able to sing low and belt notes flawlessly without straining. I've heard a lot of singers who covered MC's songs, when it comes to upper belt, they are very weak at it and use falsetto/head voice to reach the notes instead. Some just strained the heck out of their voice, that's why they said "vocal suicide". Some could even do whistle notes but couldn't do justice to the upper belts. 2. Have a soft, full, dark, and melodic tone and able to have a clear diction. In order to fit with MC songs' mood, the tone need to be similar. Bright, light, sharp tone won't fit the mood, though bright tone tends to have much clearer diction. That's why practice.....! Produce those sounds and consonants clear. 3. Have at least 4-octave range! Able to sing low, mid, belt, high. And all the notes in between, no skipping any note! MC'S range is 5.4. And able to do a lot of stuff with that vocal range. If you have a 5-octave range with weak and untrained, then don't even count. 4. Able to write their own songs with meaningful/creative lyrics. Also superior to your own voice, meaning other singers when cover your songs feel pressure as the songs are built for your voice, fit your tone and range. We rarely hear singers cover MC songs, because they require tons of vocal acrobats! 5. Able to do vocal acrobats, like hit low, belt, high, whistle notes, shift register smoothly, sing in different register, run, riff, melisma, phrase, etc. All the things Taylor Swift can't do. xD 6. Stage presence, show emotion when sing, captivate audiences. Switch original keys to different keys when live, do a live version of the studio version and dont have to be exactly the same every notes. Mix it up! 7. Versatile, able to have fun with different music genres, dance and have fun, also a performer. 8. Able to act, direct, produce, his/her music video, be creative, artwork. 9. On high-maintenance of vocal because you know your voice is precious. 10. Be fabulous, be a diva/divo and shady as f**k because you know you're good! haha xD There, 10 things to be considered the next music legendary. If anybody is able to do it, let me know xD haha.

[@mariahcareygreece]

Noone can do these. can I make these into a video?

[@Norma-Arte-y-Ventas]

AGREE unfortunately Ariana fans don't think the same, they disrespect Mariah using her 2014-2016 performances as argument to say she can't sing.

[@mariahcareygreece]

Norma Di Pardo And many of her performances during this period are amazing.

[@Norma-Arte-y-Ventas]

Fated_Child I think you're just boring quite frankly you need to find something else better to do than arguing. Anyway both singers won't see our comments 😄

[@justcutiecats2733]

I agree with the most, but why you should bring Taylor Swift, she's not a vocalist and most singers today can't do what Mariah did in her prime. If you want to make a comparison, please do better next.

[@harrietnalubwama9345]

the original voice i will never stop listening to

[@musicalkavya]

Wow people who were able to witness Mariah in her prime are so lucky!

[@LXPhotographie]

This song literally takes my breath away, the way she goes from whisper to belt to whisper to head note and back again is just breathtaking. God, I need a tank of oxygen now lol

[@theilliad4298]

+LX Cooper how is she doing it?

[@christopherdavis5593]

+chauncy primm timing, diaphragm control with perfect placement and musicality. What's really amazing is the vocal stamina. Most vocalist would be utterly exhausted by this arrangement but Mariah does it with virtual ease.

[@AccordingtoZorn]

+Christopher Davis Extremely true.

[@imtheboy2200]

Hi sweetie 😍😍😘🤗

[@ariicarey7295]

Her voice is so golden during the Daydream era. She could not be matched.

[@honestperson3042]

For real !!

[@shaunsebastian532]

The best vocalist of all times ❤

[@salvatorecorrado423]

Mariah Carey is literally the 8th wonder of the world. Tell me I'm lying!!!

[@aphiskk.384]

Those days of love are gone Our time is through Still I burn on and on All of my life Only for you From now Until forever And ever my darling Forever You will always be the only one You will always be the only one As long as I shall live I'll hold you dear And I will reminisce Of our love all through the years From now Until forever And ever my darling Forever You will always be the only one You will always be the only one If you should ever need me Unfailingly, I will return to your arms And unburden your heart And if you should remember That we belong together Never be ashamed Call my name Tell me I'm the one you treasure Forever And ever, my darling Forever You will always be the only one You will always be the only one You will always be the only one Forever You will always be the only one Forever You will always be the only one Forever You will always be the only one Forever You will always be the only one Forever You will always be the only one

[@TheKlaudializ]

Thank you

[@nikobila4216]

Thank you! 😊

[@juicycarton25d51]

That voice was sent to us from God. Nobody can sing like that. She has emotion, breath control, range, and she flips from chest to falsetto to whistle like she was born with a piano in her throat. Whitney Houston had a powerful voice and it was hard to ignore but she had a range like anybody else it was just when whit sang it the song was better. But almost every song written by Mariah is impossible for anybody to sing without changing it.

[@christianumali4856]

You comment just covered almost everything.brilliant.😀 couldn't agree with you more. BEST TECHNICAL SINGER TO EVER HIT THE MICROPHONE.😀

[@mariahfan999]

I'm an atheist 100% but mariah's voice is the only reason I would ever believe in God. There's plenty of amazing singers out there but Mariah is just out of this world.

[@jimskok2102]

That is just a gift from God

[@chillen2000]

mariahfan999 i agree her voice is soo unique just riffs and runs and the melismas she does with her songs and on top of that she is such a great song writer and has soo many underrated songs.. Such a shame...

[@selenathequeen9147]

I only can sing GTFO from Mariah. Or "Obssessed "

[@paulrob08]

Pure talent and class that will never be bettered in our times

[@paulrob08]

Also I love the ending and how she used to end her songs with notes like that!1 just beautiful!

[@abbyatun6478]

This is the era that earpiece is never yet excisting …it proves how powerful mariah carey’s ears when becomes to live performance especially on her ballad sonds

[@jengildz9104]

Mariah, I grew up with you, and I just wanna say thank you so much for all these beautiful songs...I love singing them. U r so special!

[@noyuchan]

Don't confuse. Mariah carey actually didn't sing this song in her 1995 madison square garden concert. This video is filmed in studio: it is taken after the show. If you don't believe, let's just search and find her undubbed video on youtube!

[@DucTran-yu7rj]

노유찬 sorry, but is it relevant to her comment? She just shows her love with Mariah.

[@joshuavidad6025]

노유찬 Yeah. Is this relevant? Your provings looks like you're a hater. :) How dumb you are.

[@gabriraph]

Actually this was filmed on MSG, after the audience had gone

[@kevinjohnson4877]

노유찬 people like you get on top of my nerves. Can we enjoy a video without the trolls? Take sometime to actually appreciate the lyrics, music, and vocals before u comment

[@qxyzzz]

It still scares me knowing she has a really light voice, but has resonance to destroy entire buildings. 🧎🏻‍♂️

[@touka7317]

right. her voice may not be naturally as powerful as other singers' , but her resonance definitely takes out that power and loudness in her belts

[@shegolily]

Nicely worded.

[@qxyzzz]

touka Pretty much 🤓😼

[@tmp3725]

Same. Same.

[@just_cade]

Her voice is still very strong though, just not as strong as some others. But she more than makes up for it with her resonance and tone, not to mention her agility and precision.

[@mattymariah]

This sounds almost identical to the recorded version with only a few slight different vocal choices. Mariah is honestly unbelievable. This is going to be my wedding song. Transcendental. ✨

[@thedivasofsupreme6190]

No one can do, what she already did, same to whitney, they show us, how beautiful music is..

[@CassieJazz96]

Prince Raeven Couldn't have said it better myself, beautiful sentiment.

[@thedivasofsupreme6190]

CassieJazz96 thank you. well it's a fact.. :)

[@NicolasSantos-bj5wr]

This voice is unreal. A truly gift from God

[@jorgeeduardotellez3660]

What a beautiful voice 😻! I don’t know if it’s infatuation, but I think Mariah has the complete package, talented, gorgeous, funny, intelligent, etc.

[@clalhmingmawiiofficial4709]

Mariah is not comparable... To me she is the greatest singer of all time... what a great talent she had. May God bless her voice more and more🙏🙏

[@shaniaenaje8373]

i envy those who have watched her at this concert damn it

[@valedavila5336]

yessss me too :( :( i would have done anything just.to be there

[@Ter-el]

Seriously no one understands

[@jorgegarcia3635]

Shania Enaje Amen! I wasn't even born yet lol 💓

[@KuyaBJLaurente]

If only I were in that concert, I would be crying throughout the entire concert because of extreme disbelief that I'm actually hearing the voices of angels in heaven. Also, frustration because I can't find my wig. LOL

[@Christina_Bodmer]

I was at this concert! We drove from MD to NY and I was only 12! She didn’t perform this, but this must have been rehearsal or after everyone left. I was requesting her to sing this and “Underneath the Stars” all night. Her voice was live and flawless all night and she’s is not lipping this. It’s definitely live, but they edited scenes of the audience to make it look like it was during her concert!

[@dominicpsroyal]

“That We Belong Together” I love Mimi unknowingly foreshadowed one of her biggest hits in the future.

[@gilmarsantos4023]

such an underrated gem. this performance is flawless, the trasitions are so damn heavenly

[@jallibee]

I love the way she adjust the mic coz that's how powerful her voice is.

[@paisteplayer1040]

Regardless to what damage she did to her voice , what she gave the world cannot be matched , dismissed, and will never be forgotten, Mariah will "FOREVER" be the greatest of all time.

[@mariahisthe1]

So true.

[@erixtian]

Who’s here still listening to this precious masterpiece🙋🏻‍♂️

[@luisfernandodiaz9924]

Me! all time😍🔥

[@louiehernandez6667]

xtian_odinson it’s March 2020, still watching this video while covid is attacking the world

[@louiehernandez6667]

xtian_odinson it’s March 2020, still watching this video while covid is attacking the world

[@louiehernandez6667]

xtian_odinson it’s March 2020, still watching this video while covid is attacking the world

[@mimilamb4lifemariahthequee679]

You are the Queen Mariah ❤️👸🏼🎵🎼🎶🎤

[@exposedreport]

What a classic look for her!

[@TheXanderVan]

THIS IS WHAT SINGING TRULY MEANING .. not just wooo wooo huu .. wok wok wok .. and other just catchy tunes that get boring for two or three months ..

[@niks9296]

well said you are so right

[@cho.s.en1]

TheXanderVan nahhh. forever is my song okkk and i hope on playing during y wedding. its funny cuzz i was born in 2001 and this came out in God knows when.....i love the video and m.c i just actually liked tht she does tht with hee foot everytime she sings this song

[@SuperDannyBoy95]

sheedy blu Why must kids always address their age? Like can't you just say you're playing this at your wedding which you're still very young to be even thinking about? Seriously do you think you need a standing ovation for being under 20 and liking this song? lol um no bye.

[@qxyzzz]

SuperDannyBoy95 Still too young to think about? That's the dumbest shit I've ever heard LmAo, there's nothing wrong with youthful people thinking about their futures, and no one's asking for a standing ovation dickwad, they're simply giving their nice opinion of Mariah's song, don't be such a grumpy bitch and kill the mood

[@andrea0105]

Multi-talented, gorgeous, angelic voice. She's PERFECT.

[@chocolatemorechocolate8963]

This is my favorite Mariah Carey song of all time.

[@grisa435]

I don't think it will be like this again, your voice is superb, Michael Jackson, you are legends, bravo, Meriah Carey, Greetings from Moldova.

[@markybayona7426]

How long are we going to be in quarantine? Mariah Carey: Forever!!! Yes Mariah Carey is a queen of quarantine

[@iaralima5595]

Amor eterno por essa diva, direto do Brasil

[@jayb.6705]

This comment is amazing

[@amelitapardo763]

Hayst! Here in the Philippines S2 E01 of Covid - 19

[@markybayona7426]

@@amelitapardo763 i'm a filipino too. Stay safe kabayan

[@rudihut7799]

Lol

[@Knidhy]

The most difficult song to sing in the history of music!!!

[@Knidhy]

@@Zehom04 The songs you've mentioned have easily been mimicked. But this one song noone have been able to mimic so far. The songs you've mentioned are all of high notes. This song is all about getting the low register correct. Low registers are more difficult.

[@retrodico4357]

Butterly/emotions is way more difficult🦋🦋💫😌

[@SONGbyrdRYzing]

*Lead the Way steps into the chat*

[@mikeycroker3480]

All in your mind?

[@King-iv6px]

SONGbyrdRYzing lead the way is so gosh darn HARD LOL