Mariah Carey "Hark The Herald Angels Sing" LIVE December 17, 2023 Madison Square Garden

[@alexstephens5183]

LAWWWD somebody FINALLY told Mariah we said to stop chopping them notes up and SING!!! YESSSS QUEEN!!!!🦋

[@darren2007]

Oh 😢 I loved them but respect your comment ❤

[@jaybeetv5808]

@@darren2007in general it’s unhealthy. Not directly to the voice, but it causes unhealthy vocal habits that weaken parts of the voice that can result in damage. When you staccato notes it’s an easier way to navigate through a series of notes vs a smooth legato run. Legato meaning connected in music. So because of that you’re not focusing so much on breath control to give your voice enough power to go through a whole run. Which over time will affect your breathing that is required to support the whole voice.

[@Songofalovechild]

I was there last night! She looked AMAZING & her voice sounded so healthy and her lower register and upper register are in tact! Her voice is so powerful the videos don’t even do it justice! 😍🐑🦋

[@eigen1255]

Her tone is so beautiful. I like this video, as it shows that there is playback, but Mariah IS singing. She does have to economise, because her voice does get tired more easily.

[@RJ-ek7ov]

I was there! So happy that I got to attend in NYC no less. I cried this morning from being so happy. This was in my bucket list

[@nicholastylerr]

I saw her Friday night in Baltimore. I enjoyed it all.

[@anjelocarey]

This is too beautiful 😭😭😭

[@asekun022]

Omg all the notes are connected!!! ❤❤❤

[@ohmylambily]

0:24 she definitely notice the fan squeak lmfao

[@lambilyantnyc2044]

The mic was on!!! She sounds amazing

[@jeravillarmia41]

Her voice i love it Its back Merry Christmas QUEENN MARIAHHHHHHH

[@charliexcx6784]

most gorgeous tone ever

[@justinfromthebay]

Queen of Music 👑❤️☝️

[@tonyhowze-edge8892]

She was SANGIN that night! It was magical!🥹🎄🎉

[@JovaniiArt]

I WAS HERE!!! 😍😍😍😍

[@Plutonia-o6o]

Yes Mariah❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@carlocarnaje6918]

THANK U FOR WATCHING THE FINAL NIGHT

[@ciscof1893]

😩😩😩😮‍💨😮‍💨😮‍💨‼️ Queen for a reason‼️

[@bttybwoy2]

sounded even more resonant in person 😩

[@RobertDuncanrobthevoice]

People act like she can't sing. I wonder what they have to say about this performance.

[@소원-g9f]

Her musicbox tone is amazing!! And i think it's the first time seeing her using falsetto freely during this tour. 0:33

[@ohmylambily]

too bad it's lipped for the professional recording

[@whoevr]

@@ohmylambilyprofessional recording ??

[@whoevr]

@@ohmylambilyu mean she lipped the performance or that it was dubbed? cause i definitely noticed that even the first verse wasn’t live 😭 well makes sense ig

[@issamoodissavibe]

​@@whoevrshe lipped so that she didnt need to dub it

[@sraul1699]

y'all are insufferable omfg@@ohmylambily

[@breadsteeth2562]

Wish she can recover soon. No live this time but still great performance and better lipsync skills

[@getabag_aw17]

3:14

[@L4rs]

It's obviously for the professional recording, y'all are overreacting. "Wahh people paid tickets for this", millions of people also paid tickets for taylor swifts tour and she didnt sing a note live either.

[@guscruz2]

She does sing live and plays live instruments plus a much better production

[@HuyTran-us3jm]

Show your tickets before commenting? If there fans don't speak up, what right do you have to do that?

[@lukecandidohaley5980]

You're flat out delusional. People's frustrations are valid. Mariah hasn't trained for any show or tour ever since she stopped working out during the e=mc2 era. Breath support and too much insecurities on how she looks is limiting her capabilities as a vocalist. Taylor trained like an athlete 6 months before the tour started so that her breath support would improve and hold up. She sung every note on that tour live. Period.

[@issamoodissavibe]

​@@guscruz2taylor doesnt sing live on her tour

[@guscruz2]

@@issamoodissavibe she has an acoustic set of “surprise songs”

[@WongAndrew_]

i cant believe the intro is lipped....

[@MichaelAngelo-sy5pp]

What are these comment’s? For the most part she is singing live.

[@macely]

it's taaaaaaaaime

[@SPexHoS2137]

Did she really have to lip even this the last date?

[@commentary2122]

Yeah sadly, but I guess it is probably because it will be aired or released officially somewhere later? She could dub it but these days everyone records live shows so she might have thought she would not be able to fake it.

[@SPexHoS2137]

@@commentary2122 I just really don't care. She should retire if she can't provide live vocals

[@VOM27]

@@SPexHoS2137Most artists don’t provide live vocals nowadays lmao. She’s still doing the work, and it’s a great quality performance.

[@SPexHoS2137]

@@VOM27 it's not a great quality. She's standing in one place mimicking. You just have to find good performers who actually care about the craft of live singing.

[@MCsVoice97]

"most artists" LMAO. @@VOM27

[@got2bjosh]

Her wig was too far back.

[@whoevr]

girl pls 😭 the fact there was nothing to discuss on her vocals that u had to talk about her wig lmfao

[@issamoodissavibe]

is it not her real hair with added extensions? thats what the hairstylist for this show been saying

[@got2bjosh]

@@whoevr Her vocals weren’t the issue. That wig placement, however, needed fixing.

[@RosieUribe-c2q]

I think it's her voice and emsambo that make her a professional singer that is her hair with added extensions I have some too

[@nvissynk1614]

Why did she lipped this? 😭

[@stevendesposito7204]

I would love to see this crappy generation say this to Mariah's face. Oh i forgot they leave negativity for the internet so they can make themselves feel better. I should of said bully someone because this weak generation can't say this mean stuff to someone's face

[@Lilith816]

It's not just one generation, either. It's several different generations doing it.

[@bttybwoy2]

honestly, the energy in person is always positive. everyone is cheering and no one cares enough to nit-pick which parts are pre recorded. the audience is so appreciative

[@brilo6958]

She started to lip even this one! Thats absurd!

[@royalpanther6391]

People like you need help.

[@Misterdeveraux]

No it’s called vocal fest

[@krist.t21]

you need to calm down

[@bttybwoy2]

how dare she 😱

[@rogl3W]

Shame on her ~ people paid for the tickets

[@Zarumaans]

It's TIIIMMMEEE...to lipsync 😅

[@instrumentsmrti]

it's TIIIIME to leave 45 comments on this channel alone and be obsessed

[@Zarumaans]

@@instrumentsmrti Obsessed you are indeed checking how many comments I've left 🤣🤣🤣

[@ijongoppaofficial4636]

Mariah, why you looks like robot?

[@getabag_aw17]

1:33

[@getabag_aw17]

3:30