Mariah Carey VS So Hyang - Teens Reaction

[@ace8154]

mariah's literally a legend and inspired sohyang. both queens in their own rights.

[@robertmyers7383]

See, that's a great comment. All true So Hyang fans would agree with it. Mariah did inspire many artists including So Hyang but So Hyang has a different path. She sings to praise God and comfort and uplift people not for fame and money.

[@ace8154]

@@robertmyers7383 uhm Mariah too. she has so many gospel songs in her catalog.

[@robertmyers7383]

@@ace8154 Let me ask you something and answer me honestly. Are you a fan of Mariah only or both Mariah and So Hyang?

[@ace8154]

@@robertmyers7383 uhm why does it matter? it's so out of topic. LMAO

[@ashm7922]

@@robertmyers7383 Why would So Hyang fans do anything but agree with that statement? lol She's covered every single Mariah Carey song that exists, and regularly performs them. Ngl I thought she was a Mariah Carey cover artist before I really dug deep into her.

[@heavenlyvocals8191]

They are both legendary singers. Sohyang is not a Korean Mariah Carey but Sohyang. She has unmatched balanced chest/headvoice techniques that many singers praised for and does not need to call by any other name beside herself.

[@aribaariba8609]

She cant even hit low notes bruh And praised by many singers ? Who ?

[@heavenlyvocals8191]

@@maniacfanofnfl8475 lol it was David Foster who searched and reached Sohyang and invited her to his own concert. Oprah Winfrey was a very person who introduced her to Foster. Guess what he said? He watched her performance of "oh holy night" and "I have nothing" then said "it was the best performance ever." Not just that, she made a duet with Brian McKnight as well as Josh Groban. Again it was Josh who reached Sohyang to perform with him and was amazed and said "she voice of an angel." Michael Bolton also said, "she has reached the level of virtuoso" after watching her performance of "Lean on Me." Furthermore, Sumi Jo, a world classical coloratura soprano, even said "I learned very much from miss Sohyang and she has exceptional voice." MANY PROFESSIONALS SINGERS and MUSICIANS PRAISED her techniques and vocal ability and just because you don't feel the same would make any less of her.

[@isexchannel737]

Souyang is soprano indeed but her style of singing is lack of mixture best pro singer can make slow fast low up in between of growl husky tone whistle falsetto from light to big tone or deep for me she's not flexible in all song because of her type of voice very light and Im not prefer to a singer who always sing a high note without combination of huskiness growl etc it kind of boring but dou yang is good

[@heavenlyvocals8191]

@@maniacfanofnfl8475 LOL seems like it is you who needs to work on grammar and work on language compression skills. Ridiculously childish comments with inappropriate vocabulary choice and wrong grammar placement. There is a friendly search engine called GOOGLE my friend where you can look it up before calling someone a liar. I have a evidence to prove yet you have nothing. I have a FULL LIST of comments from many professional singers and music critics around the world who praised for Sohyang techniques yet all you do is a personal denials and opinions.

[@heavenlyvocals8191]

@@maniacfanofnfl8475 I have not made those mistakes my friend. :) Perhaps you are not reading my comment. You Pinoys needs to stop this bashing. I am from Maryland, United States and don't need your English instructions especially when you are the one who literally make mistakes. You Pinoys need to stop this bashing and educate yourself before throwing ignorant statements. By the way, you are neither a David Foster, Brian McKnight, Kirk Franklin, Oprah Winfrey, Michael Bolton nor Sumi Jo and definitely no better then them so no point of talking to you. Perhaps it is a good idea to go to your favorite Philipino singer instead of bashing here like an idiot.

[@muzikizfun]

There isn't any real comparison between these world class singers as they each have their own uniqueness. Do what I do enjoy all the great artists and appreciate their god given talents!

[@려목운]

아이디 돌려써가며 악플 싸지르는 ㅅㄲ 신고 바람 "Please report hater's fake accounts." Maniac fan of NFL = Bonita Shuya = 박민숙 = Jody Stevenson = Christina Greenwalt = Jupitorson99 = sylvia walker = Blaze Cox = Preston Franco = Kimberly Heel

[@E22-d1h]

sylvia walker is a hater who continually posts the same ludicrous comment in every Sohyang video. Please report this malicious comment so that it can be deleted.

[@obe22099]

Report for harassment, enough reports will delete comment. Even more reports will forward to a live employee for review. This is pure defamation. Also mute the person so whatever nonsense they decide to respond with will be like them speaking to a wall. Before muting, report.

[@o.i.c.uvanish9169]

@sylvia walker you mean the illusion of free speech, anything that don't fit the mainstream narrative will be silence in America.

[@whitneyandmariahremasters8597]

@sylvia walker Please stfu. Sony offered a contract to her but she rejected LOL. Delusional. So hyang's voice can be maketable as aretha even lol

[@yamilayan3873]

Mariah and Sohyang are legendary singers, Mariah is the songbird supreme queen of whistle tone and Sohyang is queen of mix voice

[@robertmyers7383]

Well put although in terms of present time you know who is the queen don't you lol.

[@ace8154]

@@robertmyers7383 gurl mariah is 50 years old. how old is sohyang? 😂✋

[@robertmyers7383]

@@ace8154 Don't get it twisted salad tosser. They are not that far apart. It is documented Mariah did not take care of her vocal cords for many years with sketchy life style.

[@robertmyers7383]

@@ace8154 Aretha and Patti Labelle was killing it in their 50's and 60's.

[@theabusivechanteuse]

@@robertmyers7383 none of them had/has vocal nodules

[@rtc7788]

Mariah Carey was the queen of the 90s. She has the record for the most Billboard #1's of any solo artist. She also writes her own songs, and produces. Mariah Carey, Whitney Houston, and Celine Dion are noted as the greatest vocalists in the industry throughout the 90s.

[@Suetvvlogs]

facts, they were the reigning supremes of that decade.

[@AC-ju5yu]

Let go of the past. Mariah can not come close to So Hyang for power and conveying emotion and feeling. I've never seen a reactor cry why listening to Mariah. The best she gets is an oh my on the gimmick whistle tone. So Hyang brings almost every reactor to tears. There are a lot of reactors who read that same same discription of the Korean Mariah but by the end they dismiss that with comments like Mariah has left the building. It's ok Mariah stans that someone is better. That does not diminish your favorite.

[@rtc7788]

@@AC-ju5yu lmao yeah no. So Hyang is one of the most overrated singers, no offense. She literally has an almost annoying nasally tone.. She cant phrase in her middle area with clarity, and her lower register is just amplified air. Her head voice is small and airy, and chest voice is almost non existent. Even her high belts have a pinchy, harsh, buzzy resonance that I just can't associate with a healthy vocal production. It's like there's something stuck in her throat.

[@뽀잉-j7r]

@@rtc7788 ㅎㅎ 둘다 좋은 목소리를 가지고 있어요

[@AC-ju5yu]

@Keun Seo 근후 But she far surpassed her. I don't mind Mariah it's her fans that I generally have a problem with.

[@이정현-j8n5z]

가요보다도 팝에 빠져있을때... 머라이어캐리의 고음기교는 정말 충격적이었죠. 팬이 되고나서 다른곡을 다 들어보니 감성, 컨트롤 뭐 하나 빠질게없는 세계탑보컬이었죠. 소향은 인기가 많아지기전에 CCM을 통해 알게됐는데... 진짜 천상의 소리를 듣는 느낌. 믿음이 없는사람도 믿음이 생기겠는데? 라는 생각이 들정도 였어요.

[@안심해요사람도물거든]

머라이어캐리는 어머니께서 가수셨데요 그니까 천재가 어릴때부터 트레이닝까지 받아서 괴물이 된 케이스

[@low_mind072]

20대때 소향님이 해외 진출기회가 있었어도 본인의 거절함 그때 갔다면 수많은 히트곡 남겼을 듯 합니다

[@kodavid536]

머라이어캐리, 정말 대단한 가수죠. 한국인의 정서에 맞는 슬픔? 소울? 같은 느낌을 잘 표현하는 가수.

[@김기현-t6l]

개인정

[@fareezhaiqal4392]

Both of them can't be compared because both are legends in their own games. Aaaaa I stan both!

[@fareezhaiqal4392]

@@bonitashuya9288 As a lamb I would like to say something, *we love everybody* .

[@he_solves_maths]

The comment I was searching for ✌🏻

[@villanuevajustineralphs.4646]

Yass We love everybody.

[@Arcterion_98]

소향님하고 머라이어 캐리님 소리 자체가 다 다르고 자신의 목소리의 최적화를 만든 레전드 가수라 그냥 진짜 둘 다 고유명사로서 남겨둬야 한다고 생각함다

[@dongjunlee7490]

소향이 어릴때 머라이어캐리 영향을 받긴 했지만, 완전히 다른 스타일이다. '한국의 머라이어캐리' 라는 말은 터무니 없다. 소향은 그냥 소향이다.

[@kyj11132]

맨처음에 방송탄게 스타킹인데 스타킹에 출연할때 한국의 머라이어케리로 출연했었을거에요

[@locknlock0]

우리나라가 꼭 그런거 좋아함 어디의 누구, 제2의 뭐시기

[@skim7923]

머리이어 캐리 스타일로 불러서 제2의 라는 말을 붙일수도 있지만. 그만큼 최고의 보컬리스트니까 붙일 수도 있는 거임. 김치를 한국의 피클이다라고 얘기했을 때, 김치랑 피클은 전혀 다른데요? 하는 꼴. 그게 같아서 하는 얘기가 아니잖아요

[@pc2je9lc72]

터무니 없는 소리이긴 하죠 소향 노래 즐겨 듣지만 한국의 머라이어캐리는 너무 과찬임

[@user-jk9ys3ijsj]

어딜 머라이어캐리에 갖다 비비냐

[@worthy2300]

소향같은 스케일의 보컬리스트가 한국에서 탄생한게 신기할뿐..ㅋㅋ 소향느님은 진짜 어디에 내놓아도 자랑스럽게 소개 가능. 귀하신 분

[@ewwhzre7536]

공감.

[@tolanyha9311]

All I Want For Christmas Is You 머라이어 캐리 보컬뿐만 아니라 공동 작사 작곡임

[@RICKPP-k2c]

공동이라고 하고도 뭐한게 걍 멜로디 가사 본인이 다쓴거고 악보로 옮기고 편곡하는거만 월터가 해준것.. 사실상 본인노래 본인스스로 다 쓰는 가수죠

[@pandumiharja6769]

I'm so happy to see a young generation really appreciate her. and captivated by her incredible out of this world vocal.... It's rare for a younger generation to really respect older artist like mariah...... Good job

[@rafa.subeldia]

I'm so glad Sohyang is getting more and more attention

[@rafa.subeldia]

That's his opinion. What can I say? I like her voice and what she can do with it

[@Awmsies]

@@maniacfanofnfl8475 personal taste is one thing but you're obviously vocally untrained if you think that's screaming/screeching. All of them were well supported and were extremely good belts.

[@rafa.subeldia]

@Maniac fan of NFL just don't bother people who like Sohyang C'mon u have a life... Why do you waste your time criticizing something you clearly don't know about? Does it make you happy? And yes... I'm not an english native speaker Avañe'ēme rojukaitéta nde añarakópeguare

[@rafa.subeldia]

@@maniacfanofnfl8475 hmmm... I guess you didn't understand me at all. I apologize. I was talking about the fact that you don't know anything about vocal technique. But if want to... You can learn with Sam Johnson's channel: kzbin.info/www/bejne/imiZlWOwd6upm6c I hope you get to appreciate Sohyang's singing skills even if you don't like her style

[@Awmsies]

@@maniacfanofnfl8475 I wouldn't be too brave criticising someone else's english when you speak the way you do. Your grammar is all over the place and the placement of your verbs and nouns are a mess. Your determinants are wrong too. You're already vocally untrained, and fronting a person that isn't. You're a whole circus.

[@mariahisthe1]

Mariah is amazing. Her tone and clarity in each register are simply amazing.

[@Noname-gp5te]

"It seems like she made this song just to sing only by herself." And i definitely agree with what the girl said! Lol

[@momoajason4603]

Calm down guys, it's not actual comparison video😂 We all know they are both phenomenal vocalists in their own league with different style. The girls are just being amazed by both singers.

[@momoajason4603]

@@bonitashuya9288 😂

[@E22-d1h]

@@momoajason4603 Bonita Shuya is one of the multiple fake accounts that continually post the same slanderous comment in Sohyang videos. * The list of the same person's multiple fake accounts Maniac fan of NFL = Bonita Shuya = 박민숙 = Jupitorson99 = sylvia walker = literate spiritual = 임종식 = Blaze Cox = Carl Goff = St. Gravel = Jody Stevenson = Christina Greenwalt = Music in LA = Preston Franco

[@momoajason4603]

@@E22-d1h Yes I know.. what a pathetic looser😂

[@luciferdraven3948]

개인적으로 머라이어캐리의 리즈시절은 전세계에서 가장 독보적인 음색과 유니크 고음 가수였다고 생각함 소향도 최고지만 굳이 비슷한 가수를 찾자면 휘트니 휴스턴 과로 생각됨

[@성우지망생담]

이기 맞지

[@ottervonkr]

갠적으로 소향은 3디바 장점을 가졌다고 생각합니다. 블랙가스펠을 다루면서 완벽하진 않지만 다루기힘든 폭넓은 장르를 다루고(랩 댄스뮤직 재즈 등등) 덧붙여 음역도높고... 소울도 충만한데 음색도 맑고 신비로울때도 종종 있죠.. 암튼 특이한 가수이긴합니다. 다만 밴딩을 조금 줄였으면 하는 바람이..

[@soso-lp4bo]

이게 정답

[@locknlock0]

먼저 전설이된게 머캐, 휴스턴이고 소향도 전설에 끼게된거지 많은 보컬코치들 가수들이 거장급이라고 말하는데 인지도와 인종차이는 있어도 실력은 정상에 섰지

[@코로롱-f8f]

@@성우지망생담 이기?

[@무케-e3b]

머라이어캐리&휘트니휴스턴이 듀엣으로 부른 when you believe 는 꼭 들어봐야함.

[@안대선-k4t]

걍 둘다 팬... 솔직히 비교이유 모르겠고 두분다 너무잘하셔서

[@wannabedavid7919]

Mariah is Mariah and Sohyang is Sohyang. I love both of them although I'm into Sohyang.

[@JamesBond-lw2qq]

@@maniacfanofnfl8475Just watch football games, OK?

[@JamesBond-lw2qq]

@@bonitashuya9288 Just manage your own business, OK?

[@rebin_cgn1231]

@@JamesBond-lw2qq dude they are both copy pasting the same shit all over her videos. If they run out of arguments, they start attacking your grammar even though its perfectly fine? Totally deluded. Oh, at this point, I think its the same person using multiple accounts, trying to bash on Sohyang

[@려목운]

@@rebin_cgn1231 That haters are same person. Maniac fan of NFL = Bonita Shuya = 박민숙 = Jody Stevenson = Christina Greenwalt = Jupitorson99 = sylvia walker = Blaze Cox = Preston Franco = Kimberly Heel That hater has almost 30 fake accounts. Sorry, my English.

[@rebin_cgn1231]

@@려목운 your English is perfectly fine, thank you for clarifiying

[@Jessica-eq2zy]

Koreans are not really exposed to whistle cause not a lot of idols sing with that style

[@KingOfThePirates101]

@@maniacfanofnfl8475 Who are those people you mention? Never heard of them before.

[@videomester99]

@@maniacfanofnfl8475 And why do you think that America is the only place on earth?

[@려목운]

아이디 돌려써가며 악플 싸지르는 ㅅㄲ 신고 바람 "Please report hater's fake accounts." Maniac fan of NFL = Bonita Shuya = 박민숙 = Jody Stevenson = Christina Greenwalt = Jupitorson99 = sylvia walker = Blaze Cox = Preston Franco = Kimberly Heel

[@stilllearning2561]

@Zeruda Hime they still vastly prefer belting out with a mixed voice, sometimes they don't even care if it's supported or not. Most of the korean singers tend to follow the same training, which imo is still lacking, when you heavily use your mixed voice, and don't care at all about head voice or agility and many other aspects

[@saghyszabi]

In Korea I think there is just two singers who use whistle notes. They are Dimash and Morissette Amon. But if someone know more please tell it for me.

[@진원-y3k]

누가 더 잘한다 누가 더 낫다 이게 뭔 의미가 있는지?? 머라이어는 이미 세계 최정상급 커리어를 보유한 3대 디바 중 한명이고 머라이어의 영향을 받아 자신의 우상이라고까지 말했던 소향 또한 말할 것도 없는 실력의 보유자인데.

[@혈액이잘생긴남자]

이게정답이네

[@knyatom2296]

미국 프리미엄

[@군쇼]

3대디바가 누구죠? 머캐?휘휴?셀디임? 그렇다면 이제부터 4대 디바라 해야되는거 아님?

[@진원-y3k]

@@군쇼 맘대로하세여

[@knyatom2296]

@@군쇼 그냥 보컬로는 원탑임

[@Ashley-nr4vh]

Sohyang had me physically waving and holding and rocking myself 😂❤️😭 That’s how you know it’s good. Literally got goosebumps. The amount of control she has!!!! Wow. Whitney would’ve been proud.

[@Kw-nm6dl]

What?? How come they dont know about So Hyang?? Me as Foreigner feel surprised enough for knowing So Hyang formerly by her performance at "immortal song" TV Show as she was sing a Korean's song called Arirang and it's such a beautiful song TBH

[@hkjay908]

Since they're young

[@tcarlo159]

SoHyang is Queen of emotional delivery and Mariah is Queen of whistle. I love them both

[@before711]

She was born in 1978

[@tcarlo159]

@@mie1744 Nope. SoHyang doesn't try any of those. She is a very original vocalist.

[@LadyASolveg]

@@tcarlo159 I honestly can't speak on her career, but this clip literally has her singing a song Whitney Houston is known for. I didn't really care for her version tbh. I can't recall Mariah ever singing someone elses song unless it was a tribute.

[@professionalappreciator]

@@LadyASolveg if you honestly can't speak on her career, then just don't. It's simple.

[@LadyASolveg]

@@professionalappreciator did you understand that my response is to a person claiming that this artist, doing a cover song, only does original work? Context is everything. I never commented on her career, just pointing out that this is not her original song. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that. Btw it also is NOT Whitney Houston's song. It still belongs to Dolly Parton and WH made it popular when she sang it for the movie.

[@smfmnoneya9134]

That is why Christmas songs are one of the last reasons that Americans know Mariah Carey. She is known as one of the greatest singers of all time no matter what she sings. So Hyang is just AMAZING...she gave me goosebumps.

[@slaveofthering]

소향도 돌고래 합니다. 스타킹 무대에서 몇번 보여줬는데, 돌고래 소리 낼 노래가 이모션 밖에 없어서 걍 이모션 노래 할때만 하는듯해요.

[@UFC_Shavkat_Rakhmonov]

VITAS - dedication

[@Luckyhappily0504]

하긴 하는데 머라이어가 하는 휘슬이랑은 좀 다른 느낌일거에용

[@hkang486]

이모션의 초고음은 휘슬이고, 소향님께서 이모션을 부를 때 사용하신 것은 두성입니다. 그 공연 자체도 4옥타브 솔을 4옥타브 파#으로 플랫되게 내셨으며, 원곡은 최고음이 5옥타브 미인데 그것도 생략하셨고요. 소향님 말로는 자신의 최고음이 5옥타브 미 정도 될 거라고 하시긴 했는데, 정작 노래로 불러서 영상으로 남은 기록은 두성 4옥타브 라 정도라서 휘슬을 정말 내실 수 있는지는 모르겠네요. 대신 머라이어 캐리는 두성 음역이 은근 낮고 불안정한 편이라, 3옥타브 시 정도의 음도 가성이나 두성이 아닌 휘슬로 처리하기도 합니다. 개인적으로 소향님의 두성은 워낙 소리가 풍부하고 아름다워서 휘슬 자체가 굳이 필요할까라는 생각도 드네요.

[@vladimirpereira2009]

Both are vocal beasts.

[@musiclistener6457]

You're strictly fair~!!

[@segambutorang]

Both r great in their own way... no comparison needed here

[@muggsmitghty6398]

Don't make this kind of meaningless comparisons. They both are one of the greatest vocalists with different style and Sohyang is such a stan of Mariah..

[@hunterchampion5433]

Agreed. When you're as good as they are, you have to just respect them individually. They're two different beings. No one should be compared to Mariah on an artistic level because she does it all, building music from the ground up. But in terms of singing, don't compare artists. If you like the way they sing a song, leave it at that. People seem to forget you can like multiple things at once.

[@MelanieTrine10]

비교에 의미없어...둘다 진짜 지구의 보물이심...

[@staywmiii]

머라이어캐리 전성기때 보컬은 진심 내스타일

[@luffykingofpirates9539]

i literally choked when mariah carey hit that high note

[@ismaelm.mbaangue9147]

Mariah carey is a living LEGEND👑❤

[@j.a3616]

돌고래 소리 보다도 그 듣기좋은 진성고음이 난 더 대단해보임. 톤도 좋고 성량 자체가 넘사...

[@윤진희-l5y]

저음과 드라마틱한 기교에서 정말 뻑가죠

[@TheSeeking2know]

Thank you for the video. Sohyang loves Mariah Carey but Sohyang took inspiration from other top singers like Whitney for the power belts and faster runs too. In my view, Mariah's vocal strengths were a strong low and middle range, strong change in dynamics, clarity in the higher range, creative live runs, and her mostly unmatched whistle tone. Sohyang's are her dynamic contrast between breathy, soft tone, and power in he chest register, clear head voice, strong resonant mixed-voice belting to a high pitch, and fluidity in moving between registers within an extended note, run, or phrase.

[@liamcuerquis9631]

Thank you for your dynamic description! I wish more of these comments were like these instead of just bashing one or the other

[@TheSeeking2know]

@@liamcuerquis9631 🙏

[@liamcuerquis9631]

@sylvia walker okay Karen

[@liamcuerquis9631]

@sylvia walker she's not seeking fame anyways lol

[@E22-d1h]

sylvia walker is one of the multiple fake accounts continually slandering Sohyang. Please report this malicious comment so that it can be deleted.

[@김경욱-d9r]

솔직히 지금은 목이 상했지만 90년도 전성기 머라이어는 누가와도 못이겨요 그냥 취향이 있는거죠

[@타타-c2u]

소향이랑 나이차 얼마안남..

[@fnb8171]

취항차이라매;; 그리고 휘트니 어디감?

[@Mdc80188]

​@@타타-c2u 8,9살 정도 차이 나는데요......

[@hunterchampion5433]

Queens. Mariah is my all time favorite because she makes music from scratch, a true artist. But I love a strong asian talent who's a beast in her own right vocally like Sohyang. Her ability to emote is compatible to Mariah and the great Whitney and Celine. That's my era of music so that's all I know to reference.

[@hunterchampion5433]

@@robertmyers7383 You sound like a huge fan with huge bias. You haven't seen "all" the videos to be able to compare. I've grown up with Mariah since the start of her career. Like who you like but don't be ridiculous. It's unbecoming.

[@hunterchampion5433]

@@robertmyers7383 I can say that. Because it's true. One of us is embellishing just to prove an unnecessary point. It's embarrassing to be as old as you are and to claim that no one has ever cried while Mariah sang. If you want a quick fact check, watch her Jimmy Fallon performance where she does a private performance for some fans and you can see tears excreting from that pore in the corner of human eyes. Maybe you're losing your memory at your age and have seen it and just forgot since you also claimed to have seen ALL the videos. So many claims.. so many lies...

[@pjh-w4w]

소향 원래부터 대중가수가 아닌 ccm가수고 본인이 노래욕심이 크게 없어서 음반을 안내는게 너무 안타까움 진짜 신이내린 재능

[@gush_04]

본인만의 신념이 있으셔서 그럼ㅠ 소향님 말대로는 인기가 너무 많아지면 그게 칼이 되서 자신한테 되돌아올 거라는 하나님의 말씀을 듣고 본인이 사리는 거라고 직접 밝혔음

[@레오나르도디카프-i2w]

신념없어도 본인이욕심내도 머라이어나 휘트니처럼 될거라고보냐? 이런게 오히려 더 소향 욕먹이는 짓임

[@pjh-w4w]

@@레오나르도디카프-i2w 아무도 이말보고 욕 안하는데 왜 혼자 발작함..? 웃기네ㅋㅋ

[@gush_04]

@@레오나르도디카프-i2w 그 머라이어 캐리랑 휘트니 휴스턴의 소속사인 소니 뮤직에서의 계약 제안도 본인의 음악적 신념과 안맞아서 거절했는데 대체 뭔 말이 더 필요함? 적어도 소향이 CCM가수가 아닌 일반 대중가수로 데뷔하고 소니 뮤직까지 들갔으면 머라이어나 휘트니까지는 아니어도 지금보다 훨씬 더 높은 위상에다가 히트곡도 많이 나왔을거임

[@gush_04]

@@레오나르도디카프-i2w 마이클 잭슨 보컬 트레이너인 세스 릭스조차도 “미국의 벽을 넘을 수 있는 유일한 동양 가수” 라고 극찬했는데 억까하는 수듄이ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅠ

[@qwermnbv12]

혹여나 머라이어 캐리보다 노래를 잘한다 한들 머라이어 캐리는 대중음악의 르네상스 90년대를 지배한 팝의 여왕 혹여나 마이클 잭슨보다 춤을 잘 춘다 한들 마이클 잭슨은 전세계를 열광시킨 기네스북 13개 보유 팝의 황제 그들의 아우라는 미쳤음

[@samkim7874]

모든 노래를 직접 만든 머라이어 캐리는 마잭이나 비틀즈와 비견 될 아티스트로 봐야 합니다.

[@danielnoh3349]

10대 때 소향 ccm앨범 테이프 늘어지게 들었는데.. 언제 들어도 소향은 좋습니다~

[@YC-bk1sn]

소향님 진짜 힘이 대단하심. 성대컨트롤도 미쳤음. 걍 쵝오

[@Lill2895]

Mariah is a whole legend, but the other singer has the greatest rendition of "I Have Nothing" by Mariah's billboard rival and fellow queen, Whitney Houston. Like she really killed those notes.

[@kuroneko7022]

Are you crazy? You think she sang that song better than Whitney? You Americans are so out of your minds about these Korean pop singers! NOBODY sang that song like Whitney! Don’t insult my Black people by comparing a Korean to Whitney. All they do is appropriate Black music but really don’t like us and if you’re Black, shame on you!!😡

[@최혁용]

@@kuroneko7022 What does it have to do with black people? You're just a singer who sings, and you're the one who demeanes black people.

[@robertmyers7383]

@@kuroneko7022 Obviously you don't know what you're talking about. Your just rambling. Your Whitney ruined and tarnished her reputation the last 15 years of her life by doing the worst things in humanity and her voice and you praise her like she is God still. She couldn't sing anymore at all. She ruined her voice with all the drugs and partying. It's very well documented. There will always be more talented singers come after others, just like the way Whitney did to her own idols like Aretha Franklin, Ella Fitzgerald and Patti Labelle. Do some research before you talk your nonsense. You sound dumb. You also sound like a racist. You think people from other countries can't sing as good as American singers. So Hyang can run circles around any American singer at this present time. She is highly respected by many music industry people, vocal coaches, music critics and top singers from many countries that wants to work with her. She is devout Christian who does ministry work for God so she does not seek fame and money like your Whitney did which ruined her career and life.

[@goo2405]

학창시절에 머라이어캐리빠였는데..ㅎㅎㅎ 뮤직비디오 테이프로 모으고..ㅎㅎㅎ 앨범사고 그랬던..하 올만에 이모션들으니 기분이 좋네요~ 그래도 1일1소향하고있습니다 ㅎㅎ

[@eyelandgal]

They're both so legendary, I got goosebumps all throughout the video

[@madey.moiselle]

I love mariah..the way she sings the high pitch note ..the whistle is her specialty..

[@totiyanachannel1317]

Exactly 💯😊 but alot of people here are confused cause sohyang was screaming with high note but dey don't know music is not all about high note., Mariah Carey as a very unique styles a very outstanding voice that makes her so special she's a legend a queen 👑 and that's on period 💯😊

[@madey.moiselle]

@@totiyanachannel1317 your right...but if you ask me about this video who is more better...Mariah carey wins....sohyang is also good..but the way she sings.. it's more like screaming..it irritates me..for some people she's like a legend..i respect that..but sorry to say..i don't like her way of singing..

[@divineartofmusic1]

Mariah and sohyang are the biggest voices today

[@weslove6018]

My two favorites are "SO HYANG" and "DIMASH" DIMASH singing "UNFORGETTABLE DAY GAKKU CONCERT" he sings a "D 8" note. It is so high it's not on a piano.

[@모니카-k7n]

Sohyang. She released her new album in August 2020. Please love our title song, 'Stay'

[@Gisaround]

She didn't release any album, that was just a single 😅

[@SuperHyunJun]

머라이어캐리는 그냥 신! 소향은 비할 수는 없는 미안 소향님! 그런데 인간계에서 높음

[@galaxyuniverse5769]

Both amazing woman❤️

[@E22-d1h]

sylvia walker is one of the multiple fake accounts continually slandering Sohyang. Please report this malicious comment so that it can be deleted. sylvia walker는 소향님을 지속적으로 음해하는 다중 가짜 계정입니다. 이 악플이 삭제될 수 있도록 신고해 주시기 바랍니다.

[@sage6805]

@sylvia walker you’re nothing. No one. No one will remember you and will do nothing significant.

[@SquidProQuo80]

Mariah Carey and SoHyang Kim are the two very best vocalists on earth... Korea should be very proud of this humble yet insanely talented diva.

[@sinnanda1818]

머라이어캐리는 휘슬로 돌고래랑 장난치는 영상도 있죠.

[@hyoungphilyang2609]

소향도 충분히 가능하고 옛 영상 찾아보시면 휘슬가지고 장난치는 장면도 있습니다

[@sinnanda1818]

@@hyoungphilyang2609 한국에 제가 아는 분만 열명은 됩니다. 소향을 낮추는게 아니라 저정도로 컨트롤하는 사람은 못봤단 얘기

[@hyoungphilyang2609]

@@sinnanda1818 무슨 말씀인지 이해했습니다. 머라이어가 휘슬을 잘하긴 하더군요

[@hkang486]

@@hyoungphilyang2609 소향님은 휘슬이 아니라 두성입니다.

[@유통키-i7v]

5옥이상의 휘슬은 소향이 못하죠

[@홍준일-p7n]

초중딩 급식시절에 머라이어 캐리 개좋아했는데 Love Take Time 개띵곡ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@starfish8205]

소향님이 부르신 곡 중에 '눈을 감아' (ost) 도 들어보셨으면 좋겠어요 ㅎㅎㅎ

[@hughw2377]

Thanks for introducing Koreans to The Legendary Songbird Supreme Mariah Carey🕊🐬🦋💜

[@ramonpadilha9987]

They only know her Christmas album. But That's a start.

[@stilllearning2561]

@@ramonpadilha9987 what are you talking about. Mariah has been in the industry for 30 years, ask koreans about vision of love, we belong together, hero, and open arms. This is a living legend not an average vocalist.

[@ramonpadilha9987]

@@stilllearning2561 I'm talking about the new generation.

[@stilllearning2561]

@@ramonpadilha9987 though I'm part of the newer generation, i have to say that most of them are heavily uneducated when it comes to music

[@burjer8921]

Mariah Carey and SoHyang are the Queen and the Empress of singing

[@adrianbrown8899]

Mariah Carey period… she inspire ur fav and show them the way on how to SING… Mariah tone alone is unmatched

[@totiyanachannel1317]

Exactly 💯 😊 sohyang get inspiration from Mariah Carey is very obvious but she can never be compare to her cause Mariah Carey is different just like no one can compare to Micheal Jackson, Whitney Houston, Adele, Celine Dion, Ariana grande voices are so unique and powerful 💯😊

[@i-mq7xjawuonv7wf6h]

머라이어 캐리 진심으로 내려치는 댓글들 한숨나온다 솔직히 둘이 비교불가임 그 가수 팬들이 왜 점점 우물안 개구리가 되어가는지 지들만 모름

[@fruityfudge]

Mariah is a legendary artist, and Sohyang is a legendary vocalist. They are untouchable in their own ways. And I dare say SoHyang is undeniable all time greatest vocalist. Literally no one can sing like her. It's not just about her monstrous vocal range. Just see at least one single performance of her endless legendary renditions, anyone will immediately know.

[@kuroneko7022]

🤣🤣🤣😂😂

[@totiyanachannel1317]

Lmao your comment is so funny., Don't even dare is better for you to jump cause obviously., Mariah Carey is a legend while sohyang is a vocalist that's on period...dey are both good but sohyang can never sing like Mariah Carey not to talk of Whitney Houston, Celine Dion, Adele and Ariana grande.,.. sohyang is one of the best cause her voice is good too but she's not greatest 🙄

[@이태리때타울]

어서오세요 ᆢ 소향월드는 처음이지? 🤗💕

[@April_la4988]

6:02 that’s Illegal. Wow impressive ❤️😳❤️

[@justme1553]

I love both MC and Sohyang!

[@이준희-k1u5y]

5월 소향님 콘서트 VIP석으로 예매 해 놨네요ㅋㅋㅋ 옛날에 뮤지컬하신거 보고 거의 8년? 만에 실제로 뵙게 될것 같아요ㅠㅠ

[@muhammadredzuanbinjalil3795]

Both are my favourite !!!

[@SoHyangisMyQueen28]

I LOVE THESE QUEENS!!! BUT ONE IS MY ULTIMATE QUEEN!!!

[@dhk6663]

머라이어캐리는 귀를 녹여주고 소향은 마음을 녹여준다

[@보리-w9s]

머라이어 캐리도 소향님도 둘다 너무 잘하시는 분인데 왜 굳이 대결을해요? 둘다 너무 잘행~~~♡

[@MrHappy6989]

1000번째 댓글은 제가 씁니다~~ 소향님 사랑합니다💜

[@latishacampbell5764]

"Dolphin" is whistle tone. That is what Mariah Carey is known for. Both are amazing talents.

[@지블리-f1f]

가창력도 가창력이지만 작곡,작사,프로듀싱...가수,아티스트로서는 정말 레전드로 남는 머라이어캐리이죠

[@princehyup1585]

맞아요..! 사람들은 고음이나 휘슬에만 집중하는데, 보컬/랩 콜라보 곡을 처음으로 대중화시킨 것도 머라이어였던 만큼, 음악적으로 미친 영향력은 가늠하기 힘들 정도죠...

[@princehyup1585]

@sylvia walker umm... I never said you are malicious.. I just praised mariah, because I'm a huge mariah's fan..!

[@donutrandys5543]

@sylvia walker troll

[@estella1282]

춤빼고 모든걸 다 잘하는 아티스트...

[@sarahhchan]

Both excellent, and very different singer

[@marloupoldadaeg963]

Dont compare them, just Love them both

[@TV-hi6mz]

이게말이나 되나 소향 자신곡 없음 지금도 커버송 머라이 휘트니에 정말 고난이도 노래는 안부르고 쉬운거만 부름 물론 프로들 사이에서 쉬운곡은 아니지만 소향팬들은 머라이 휘트니곡 소화한다고 찬양함 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@TV-hi6mz]

무엇보다 음악에 중저음영역에 머라이나 휘트니에 멜라리즘 즉 입차감 있는 중저음 보이스도 없고 그냥 깨끗한 목소리 ccm노래에 표본임ㅋㅋ

[@yuri83190]

미국빌보드 1위곡 한곡도 없을뿐더러 멜론 1주 1위곡도 없는분이 소향임

[@b1tchycvnt]

Wow you guys chose a really interesting variety of songs from MC ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@colossusrageblack]

To me it seems Sohyang is more of the Whitney Houston of Korea. Doesn't really have the style and pitch of Mariah Carey, but does have the power vocals of Houston.

[@whenisdinner2137]

There are hundreds of people that can do play Whitney Houston impression perfectly. I have yet to see a singular person that can do a Mariah Carey impression perfectly

[@samueldarko3500]

@@whenisdinner2137 lol which planet are you living in. after all the Mariah impressions over youtube?? try and research it'll help you

[@껌꾸끼까]

간만에 좋은 영상 감사합니다

[@oneouts627]

애들도 보고 놀라네. 어릴때 머라이어 캐리 이름 생각 안날땐 돌고래 소리 내는 가수라고 하면 다 알아 들었었음. 😆

[@ewwhzre7536]

솔직히 머라이캐리 노래를 즐긴 듣긴 했어도 그땐 잘 몰랐고 소향님을 알고나서 머라이캐리를 더 잘 알게 되었다? 둘 다 시대의 멋진 가수임에 틀림없다. 소향님 목소리는 나이가 들어감에 따라 더 풍부해지는 느낌. 목관리를 너무 잘하시고 계시는듯..

[@수한무-l5d]

소향은 나 높은 음 잘 내지? 쩔지 ? 이러는거 너무 티남 모든 노래가 다 거기서 거기처럼 악씀 . 너무 듣기 부담스러운 고음 몇번 들으면 질림 머라이어 캐리는 듣기 너무 편함 음색이 넘사벽임 자주 들어도 부담스럽지 않음 내가 한국인이어도 머라이어 캐리 소향 비교는 무리다

[@whenisdinner2137]

So Hyang feels like the sky is the limit. Mariah Carey feels like the expansion of the universe still hasn't caught up to her limit.

[@행복소문만복래]

학생들~ 머라이어 캐리 명곡들 정주행 한번 해봐요. 신세계가 열려요~

[@highest1724]

나같은 감정이 메마른 사람도 들으면서 눈물이 날정도면 legend맞지ㅎㅎ Sohyang is a legendary artist and the top tier singer as of now.

[@김해연-q5h]

머라이어 캐리는 세계 음악사적으로 큰 족적을 남긴 레전드 가수고, 소향은 세계 정상급 "보컬리스트"임. 아예 다른 길을 간 아티스트들이고 보컬 스타일도 한쪽은 휘슬, 다른 한쪽은 진가성 영역 마스터라 스타일 자체가 달라서 비교가 무의미해.. 되도않는 막귀로 한쪽 후려치지 좀 말고요 다들..; 하는 음악의 성격부터 한참 다른데 뭔 소리들을 하는거냐. 둘 다 못즐기면 니들 손해지ㅋㅋ

[@려목운]

아이디 돌려써가며 악플 싸지르는 ㅅㄲ 신고 바람 "Please report hater's fake accounts." Maniac fan of NFL = Bonita Shuya = 박민숙 = Jody Stevenson = Christina Greenwalt = Jupitorson99 = sylvia walker = Blaze Cox = Preston Franco = Kimberly Heel

[@E22-d1h]

sylvia walker is one of the multiple fake accounts continually slandering Sohyang. Please report this malicious comment so that it can be deleted. sylvia walker는 소향님을 지속적으로 음해하는 다중 가짜 계정입니다. 이 악플이 삭제될 수 있도록 신고해 주시기 바랍니다.

[@hagojibi]

그런데, 가수랑 보컬리스트 차이가 도대체 뭔지...??

[@보보-g9g]

@@hagojibi 가수 자신의 노래로 사람들에 인정을 받음 소향 좋은곡을 자신만의 스타일로 잘부름 명예의 영역이라고 봄 보컬리스트>가수>싱어송라이터

[@hagojibi]

@@보보-g9g 보컬(Vocal)은 음악의 성악 및 노래를 부르는 역할 또는 이 일을 하는 가수 또는 성악가를 가리키는 음악 용어이다. 노래를 부르다 라는 말도 된다. 이 용어는 주로 ‘록 밴드의 보컬’등과 같이 대중음악(또는 실용음악)에서 사용되는 경우가 많다. 노래를 부르는 사람, 즉 ‘보컬리스트’를 줄여서 보컬이라고도 한다. ‘보컬(vocal)’이라는 말은 ‘가창(singing)’이라는 말과 함께 팝 음악 뿐만 아니라 클래식 음악계에서도 사용된다. 차이는 ‘보컬(vocal)’은 ‘목소리’, ‘가창(singing)’은 노래라는 개념으로 ‘보컬 코드(vocal cord)’는 ‘성대’라는 뜻이 된다. 보컬리스트 vocalist 팝 그룹과 함께 노래를 부르는 가수. 무슨 영어와 한글의 격의 차이인가? 보컬리스트와 가수의 차이가...?? 게다가 '보컬리스트>가수>싱어송라이터' 이건 또 어디서 나온 기준인지요? 여태 살면서 처음 듣는 말이네, 둘 다......;; 😩

[@chong921]

머라이어케리의 곡을 볼 땐 귀신 본듯 놀라더니 소향님이 부른 노래를 들을 땐 그냥 황홀경에 빠지네 두분 모두 각자의 개성을 가진 최고의 가수이지 비교 대상은 아닌 것 같아요

[@차성완CU아빠]

소향은 정말 한국을 대표할 디바 중 하나 임. 머라이어는 인류를 대표함

[@maxbountymastermind2947]

Black queens legends inspire the world love to see other culture singing Whitney Houston . ❤️❤️😊🙏🏿

[@박상현-y6w5f]

머라이어는 노래이전에 벌써 여자로써 매력있지않냐? 그 다음에 머라이어노래지 나는 진짜 사랑을 한다사랑을 흑인+백인의 묘한 색감 그리고 그녀만의 감수성.90 년대 그녀모습은 청순하면서 진실성을 노래에서도 느낄 수있었다

[@raquelfigueroa5539]

Mariah and Whitney Huston are my favorite American singers, love. Love. Love their music !!!!!

[@justdoit-o8t]

Sohyang = Mother Nature

[@jamesyi8692]

yes. if mother nature had a voice.

[@kimdavid9389]

소향은 유일한 한국 아니, 아시아 출신으로, 휘트니, 머라이어캐리등과 함께 6명 정도 밖에 안되는 세계 보컬 레벨 최고 등급인 s레벨이라고 평가받고 있고 취향 차이는 있겠으나 보컬의 모든 부분에 있어서 현존하는 가수들 중 최고라고, 우리나라 보다 해외 전문가들이 입에 침이 마르도록 칭찬하는 가수죠. 그러니 제발 소향을 고음 잘하는 가수라고 소개하지 마세요. 고음도 잘하는 가수입니다. 동의 하지 못하는 분은 소향 비긴어게인 misty 들어보고 오세요. 그럼 알게 될 겁니다.

[@JamesBond-lw2qq]

@@bonitashuya9288 Have you ever been to Hollywood? Education is a progressive discovery of your own ignorance.

[@JamesBond-lw2qq]

@@maniacfanofnfl8475 You can be proud of knowing of David Foster or Josh Groban.

[@려목운]

아이디 돌려써가며 악플 싸지르는 ㅅㄲ 신고 바람 "Please report hater's fake accounts." Maniac fan of NFL = Bonita Shuya = 박민숙 = Jody Stevenson = Christina Greenwalt = Jupitorson99 = sylvia walker = Blaze Cox = Preston Franco = Kimberly Heel

[@려목운]

@@bonitashuya9288 Show me your all accounts. Cheer Up!!! E D ot P no E~ ^ ^

[@E22-d1h]

Bonita Shuya is one of the multiple fake accounts continually slandering Sohyang. Please report this malicious comment so that it can be deleted. Bonita Shuya는 소향님을 지속적으로 음해하는 다중 가짜 계정입니다. 이 악플이 삭제될 수 있도록 신고해 주시기 바랍니다.

[@WlfnWlfn]

어린 학생들의 평이 배려와 깊이가 있고 세련되어 듣는 입장에서 대견하네요~

[@actiongamen]

머라이어 캐리의 하이노트는 'whistle voice'라고 하죠. 성대를 닫아버리고 복식호흡으로 공기를 밀어내면서 공명점은 머리 끝으로 하는 두성

[@alonzoclarkston1781]

Mariah and sohyang are both gifted vocalist 💯each are the best at singing for their respective era BUT ain’t nobody touching prime Mariah tbh💜

[@YangKwangSeok]

리액션과 본인들의 생각을 조리있고 예쁘게 잘 보여줬네요. 칭찬합니다 애기들 ㅎ

[@regularwhitneyfanhatingonm5050]

i don't know why people still call Regine Velasquez as "The best asian singer", since she can't sing at all, just yells. SoHyang is WAAAAAY better, supports everything

[@HK_K]

소향😍😍💕

[@ltm5590]

Mariah and Sohyang are my favorites❤

[@bk-sl1en]

이제는 머라이어캐리를 모르는 시대가 오는구나…세월참..