Mario reacts to Rosalina Unmasked {Both parts} | Gacha Club | Game Theory

Mario, Luigi, Princess Peach, Princess Daisy, Princess Rosalina, and Bowsette (Instead of Bowser purely because of a coin toss) react to the truth behind Rosalina.
Original Videos:
Part 1:
• Game Theory: Rosalina ...
Part 2:
• Game Theory: Rosalina ...

[@Nightout88]

Anybody else ship Mario x Bowsette? Also you have to show them how the internet went berserk for Bowsette a few years ago to the point Shigeru Miyamoto released a book showing bowser as a girl lol It was called [THE ART OF SUPER MARIO ODYSSEY] If anybody is interested also can I get a pin?

[@Nightout88]

Thank you very much

[@lovelywitchoftwst8983]

Here I am

[@zenithreplays9926]

That's a ship?

[@princebowserjr.3266]

No because that's just gay because Mario is being shipped with Papa only because he have a girl version of him and and that's gay as hell

[@Nightout88]

@@zenithreplays9926 yes it is surprisingly.

[@MetalSonicMovieVersionV1]

Honestly, I was expecting Mario to be like: “you’re taking my girlfriend from me, bro?” And have like a “perfectly cut screams” moment.

[@cosi6669]

That would have been P E R F E C T

[@kjdonaghy]

Ikr lol

[@emilyschwartz4524]

No, for some reason, Peach and Mario are just friends, and aren't with each other

[@pamelasmith4230]

All I think about is "mister steal your girl"

[@Speariture]

​@@emilyschwartz4524💀💀💀

[@error_eyx]

I actually have my own theory based off this now. Rosalina is from a different timeline, maybe in that timeline Peach and Luigi are together and a reset changed it to Peach and Mario, and yes I do respect you ship. Another theory I have is that Koopa’s were aliens before Super Mario Galaxy, and the bang at the end of the game resulted in them being Earht residents, and the reason Koopa’s appear in older games because the bang not only rewrote the future but also rewrote the past in a huge way.

[@chaotix3950]

FINALLY! SOMEONE WHO MADE THEM REACT TO ALL THE PARTS INSTEAD OF MAKING THEM ONLY REACT TO THE FIRST PART

[@djmac8537]

Mario having multiple lives from the Galaxy being reset does bring up some questions: What happens in the alternate cycles? Does the Galaxy get sick and tired of Mario dying after loosing hundreds of thousands of lives? What happens when Mario runs out of lives? Are his multiple lives like Izanagi? As in, are the 1-Up mushrooms like a somewhat less powerful version of the Galaxy being recreated?

[@Speariture]

Mario is the only confirmed Mario character to come back after death and reject hell and heaven

[@enderborn6860]

Mario is an Uchiha XD

[@azarifire510]

daisy: if it's really so rare to have blue eyes, then why does everyone in this room have them? mario and luigi oc's: **have black eyes** ._.

[@the_gremlin1]

Had Black then blue part one had black eyes part two blue eyes

[@kjdonaghy]

Why tho

[@I_haveur_family_in_my_basement]

Well there is a 7b people on earth so 7m people having blue eyes is rare

[@Speariture]

💀💀💀

[@izzysmith105]

2:24 totally missed the chance for Mario to say "It's-a me!"

[@emilyschwartz4524]

Is anyone going to talk about the fact that Peach and Mario are just friends? THEY'RE CANON LOVERS

[@PAULOPGR]

Yeah, but in this case, is a AU.

[@rossymariposa6003]

Yes bowsette. Rosalina is princess peach and Luigi's 100 year old daughter.

[@lovelywitchoftwst8983]

Well congrats Luigi you got peach 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@jarondooley8691]

Yay Luigi's finally not the second fiddle he's finally player one

[@The-Bisexual-Queen-Kitty]

now mario go get daisy cause you have lost peach

[@user-kx1dh2dp7i]

Luigi is a millionaire

[@The-Bisexual-Queen-Kitty]

@@user-kx1dh2dp7i ya

[@luismiguel4041]

If that theory is correct Rosalina can also come from a universe where Mario does not exist or he died if we apply what I know about the multiverse in fiction none of the universes is the same it can be a parallel one or one where the roles of Mario and Luigi are reversed or Mario use green and luigi red everything is possible per me support of the first theory where maario peach is not memorized but luigi and peach. it's like gwen said to peter in the spiderverse she's not your mj i know, the same thing happens with universes where she and peter hang out or where she hangs out with thousands and is just peter's friend

[@the_l0cal_astro_lad]

and mario, you..... are...... NOT THE FATHER

[@JuanGarcia-dz4ei]

Real luigi: why fake luigi fake luigi: theres not enough room for the two of us

[@No_where_to_be_seen]

FINNALY SOMEONE PUT BOTH OF THE VIDS TOGETHER LIKE SEROISLY IM GETTING SO ANNOYED THAT PEOPLE WONT PUT BOTH OF THEM TOGETHER AND THEN SOME SAY THEY WILL MAKE A PART TO AND THEY NEVER DO. THANK U FOR NOT BEING LAZY LIKE OTHERS ARE !

[@Remake_Builder]

16:39 mario and Luigi: changes eye color 17:48 no pupils

[@MarioEXECreepypasta]

Dark Mario: 😡 Devil Mario: 😒

[@kidsrestoule8170]

I'm happy because it's the first one with both parts you made my day😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻😻

[@mistomanastrafe]

Glad to hear it. I noticed that no one seemed to have done it yet, so I figured I would.

[@loganshaw4527]

@@mistomanastrafe well it was a different Mario galaxy so stand to reason Luigi could have been the older brother or the only brother and being the one to save peach all those times.

[@devinpacheco4522]

​@mistomanastrafe why can't they here matpat call mario a psychopath?

[@orangespiderlily]

Have they reacted to Luigi being Rosalina's dad instead of Mario?

[@CryptJoker2438]

Thank you I’ve been waiting for a complete reaction to these specific game theory episodes Edit if you ever inspired to do another game theory reaction might I suggest these four 1.the bo bomb episode 2.the blue shell episode 3.the other Mario kart episode? 4. The bullet bill episode

[@mistomanastrafe]

Hey, no problem. Bowser’s broken home is next, then afterward I’ll do a reaction to non-game theory stuff. I’ll have to refresh my memory for those four, since I haven’t seen them in a while. But maybe in the future I will. I have some plans for both reactions and stories that I want to at least start first. As well as for other fandoms. I have some undertale stuff planned, and one other fandom. Though, I have yet to figure out how I want to introduce it.

[@jjohnson2445]

@@mistomanastrafe aw baby peach and baby daisy and baby rosalina are so cute

[@crazythemisterious1174]

My Father: Brown hair, blue eyes, left handed My Mother: Dark brown hair, green-brownish eyes, left handed My Brother:Dirty blond hair, blue eyes, right handed Me: Dirty blond hair with a smal tint of red, hazel eyes, right handed ✨Genetics✨🤣

[@FridayNightStreamz]

The theory about multiverses also applies to Undertale, there are a lot of different dialogues, plus the au’s

[@PAULOPGR]

It's true.

[@sunnyokumura8841]

That's my boy!! I'm proud of you Luigi ^^ love you video bruh

[@stinkergard]

ROSALINA IS WEARING HER MOTHER'S DRESS

[@JuanGarcia-dz4ei]

Peach died in a different timeline

[@_axxika_3715]

Luigi really said: I stole your woman lol

[@dinnerjacket419]

Mathew Patrick is so funny

[@queenxenit9127]

matpat can make me think im a crayon lol

[@kjdonaghy]

3:29 I’m thinking of MatPat going on a date with Rosalina in her biker outfit

[@fhfrhwg7729]

Mario must be mad inside.

[@Wiisportseires10234]

me and daisy is today a long time ago

[@literalthrowaway6051]

Imagine how much odessy fucks this theory up

[@mistomanastrafe]

Haven’t played Odyssey yet

[@Randomized_author]

Matpat reminds of that scene from the office

[@mistomanastrafe]

I’ve never watched the office, so I don’t know what scene you’re talking about.

[@Dr._Vita]

Me, left with more questions than answers: BUT WHAT ABOUT OUR FAVORITE LOUD PRINCESS FROM SALSALAND

[@calvinjohnson2985]

26:51 Starlow: Is it any wonder why Luigi always looks after the home front? Also, does that have anything to do with me?

[@Invictusfish]

So is Mario still a psycho in this universe or was the crazy one Mario’s grandpa? MatPat brings both old and new games into the theory saying that he’s nuts.

[@mistomanastrafe]

Mario isn’t a psycho in this universe. The grandfather thing was an Idea I had at the time of making this video, but I’m not sure I will incorporate grandpa jumpman in the series vary much, if at all. He’ll likely be a character mentioned rarely through the series.

[@iamthemouse4483]

​@@mistomanastrafeSo you're saying he's... Grand Dad?

[@donovinkenney9079]

Hey can you please have them react to bowser, broken home game theory episode

[@mistomanastrafe]

Yeah. I’ve actually already started work on that one. Lol

[@donovinkenney9079]

@@mistomanastrafe omg thank you so much I’ve been waiting for someone to make a reaction to that for so long and since it’s you who is doing it I know that it will be of high quality with real emotions thank you so much 🎉❤❤

[@Maybeyes917]

That would mean Mario’s Rosalina‘s uncle

[@dinnerjacket419]

Mario before the second theory, nice after, HOLY CREPE

[@enderborn6860]

0:44 MARIO XD oh you actually made him speak like that oh god i love it

[@BestKeptSecreization]

Peach and Rosalina are like the same age and like not dead

[@Multifandom.Moon.Edits.]

Broooo Luigi's scream😭💀😳🤣

[@raffi2936]

Its been confirmed that Luigi and Daisy are together Also the creator of the Mario Franchise Cut the Connections Between Rosalina and Peach completely, in other words Peach and Rosalina arent related in any way. Its also weird that sources state that Peach is together with Mario and in an official Game a Statue of Daisy and Luigi is seen but the weirdest fact is that Mario is 38 years old, Luigi is 37 years old and both Peach and Daisy are 16.

[@mistomanastrafe]

This video isn’t following canon.

[@raffi2936]

@@mistomanastrafe OK i was just confused. Thank you.

[@mistomanastrafe]

@@raffi2936 No problem.

[@empressofcreativity]

Wait Mario and Luigi are pedophiles?!?!?

[@raffi2936]

@@empressofcreativity if we go by that, yes they are.

[@n.b.1809]

Matt Pat you ####ing genius

[@moko...]

Hey!! can they react to mario is a sociopath theory? i bet it would shock all of them and they were able to take this theory and bowser's broken home!! plz? yes it may take a along time...but at the very least...maybe?

[@fatalwaffle1715]

Awesome video!

[@RedDragonForce2]

@16:40 Grandfather?? I mean… you should check out his Mario timeline video next. Because it’s not “grandfather” that Matpat concludes your relationship.

[@mistomanastrafe]

I realize that, but I have a bit of an AU going on, so not everything is going to align with matpat’s theories. There’s another major factor of the AU that I’ll have in future videos.

[@RedDragonForce2]

@@mistomanastrafe no problem! You do you! This was a great video and reaction. Though that psychopath bit getting lost is for the best.

[@mistomanastrafe]

@@RedDragonForce2 Thank you. And yeah, it is, I think. I’m not really a fan of the mario psychopath theory, but I can definitely see why he would have the theory.

[@RedDragonForce2]

@@mistomanastrafe a lot of it comes from the graphical limitations the first four generations of games had. That and the 80s games had a much lower standard of censorship and sensitivity. Now it’s the opposite. Some things are way to sensitive when growing up in the 90s and 00s weren’t a problem.

[@error_eyx]

Is this why you ship Luigi and Peach instead of the normal game franchise?

[@chrisdhabalt2280]

Hey can you make a video about princess peach being coiled by kaa from Disney's jungle book?

[@Seannaworldlovergachacoral]

I like this Au so much you gain a subscriber

[@Pbrothers07892]

If that's the case shouldn't that mean that Mario is Rosalinas uncle?

[@enderborn6860]

by family logic and all that yes "Itsa me Mario" "uncle Mario?" thats a assassin´s creed 2 reference

[@luigi7248]

😈

[@assiabathily3278]

Mario: I can’t imagine being with peach Also mario: literally fighting over her with bowser In super Mario odessy (idk how to spell it)

[@mistomanastrafe]

Well, I haven’t played odyssey. And I’m also creating an AU, so there’s that too.

[@marcellusrobinson9155]

You know the video said that since Mario has blue eyes he could be Rosalina's father but then you decide to give him and Luigi brown eyes😂😂😂

[@mistomanastrafe]

The reference picture I used to create them didn’t show their eye color, so I just made them black.

[@marcellusrobinson9155]

Oh okay

[@marcellusrobinson9155]

But come on you must have watched the video and the video has it told you time and time again that Mario and Luigi have blue eyes

[@mistomanastrafe]

@@marcellusrobinson9155 I didn’t really think it was that big of a deal. Didn’t really think about it that much

[@kristenfreeman7591]

So Rosalina is the daughter of Luigi and peach? Does this mean Mario and dasiy could have a kid

[@mistomanastrafe]

Could they? Yes. Are they going to? I haven’t decided. Not sure I’m even going to ship Mario and Daisy. Right now, the only confirmed ship for this channel is Peach and Luigi. I haven’t decided about anyone else yet.

[@firegamerx5650]

mario the music box the history

[@umbraanimo7767]

Ever have the moment where you know what’s happening and are already flinching? Had that when the “sleeping under the tree” part played

[@SodaTacticooler]

I'd love to see how Lady Ozenta looks. (I'm imagining her with glittery rainbow hair.)

[@fumikagetokoyami5040]

Cool, I'm part of the %10 of people that are ambidextrous, but had both parents right handed.

[@anantonyproduction]

matpat so many facts

[@christinariggins3481]

I don't know but I've always felt like just because the theory might have been true for that universe this universe could be different maybe luigi ends up with someone else I mean no two cycles are ever the same one small change could change more things then actually expected

[@kjdonaghy]

According to this logic, Mario is gonna be daisies’s husband

[@GianPatrickCRubio]

It's sad that Mario is not with peach

[@altinselmani9690]

Make them react to Mario is a Merderous

[@REEEEEKING_HAVOC]

His theory makes sense to the point my brain is rebuilding its self from it...

[@user-ce9sv7bs7i]

I've seen the actual videos before I saw this

[@Tsuyuri193]

Gould they react Luigi Mansion cutscenes

[@dekutoshi2769]

I love the part where he's all I'm starlord *pew*pew*pew*pew*

[@loganwoolard4203]

That character in white before just before the vid looked a lot like the miss king boo

[@mistomanastrafe]

You mean Boosette? I guess I can kinda see it.

[@James_Semaj_Hatsuki]

I honestly expected Daisy to get really *really* mad at Peach for taking her man (since the game franchise ships them a lot as well) and possibly either A. Have a perfectly cut screams moment like another comment said B. Daisy getting normally mad at Peach and stops being friends with her Or C. Get so mad to the point of starting a war with Peach all over Luigi

[@katelynnmorgan3395]

I loved this. Keep up the good work creator ❤️ 💙 💜 💖 💗 💘 🎂 🥮 🍥 🥞 🧁 🍰 🌼 🌸 🌻 🌹 🏵 Can I give all of your characters a kiss on the cheek and a hug. Pls pick me I've never been picked before!

[@mistomanastrafe]

Pick you? I’m not really doing anything with the mario characters that would require picking anyone right now.

[@jjohnson2445]

Aw baby peach is so cute

[@jetrhoads9072]

can you make them react to reasons luigi is not an idoit or make luigi is actully cappy theory or luigis darkest scertet

[@boyfriendlol4271]

Mario explains in " ITALIAN"

[@Ireallydunnolol]

He is an Italian plumber

[@boyfriendlol4271]

I know I just find I funny that mario and luigi are Italian and speak like that

[@-McNahida-]

is i weird that i just assumed that the story she tells was about her?

[@redacted451]

Make them react to Mario's dark secret pls?

[@unicorn1z1loverismehroblox62]

I'm not a fan over the eyebrows but other then that it's amazing

[@lesbian-fictionalserialkiller]

Family reunion

[@lukebowen7367]

can you please have them react to the Mario is a sociopath theory. I get how you would dislike your O.C. can tell them that it is only an au. just one other person has done it and I would absolutely love to see it come from you. please voice your opinion

[@lukebowen7367]

or you could make it as the theory being on Marios grandfather

[@stinkergard]

Mario had a telescope in that game

[@glichtrap6769]

Can you do five nights at warios 's

[@mistomanastrafe]

I might eventually, but there’s a lot of other things I want to do first.

[@LeoEmber]

Now react to the Mario timeline video from game theory to explain what happened to Mario after Luigi and peach got married

[@calvinjohnson2985]

Yeah, Mario characters. These Mario games kinda have more clues than you think.

[@dakotadelossantos170]

That's kind of funny because I was blue eyes.

[@imnonsense5109]

Why isn’t Mario’s Eyes blue not Real Mario of course Edit Never mind Mario’s Eyes changed in the second half

[@Its-a-Hammer_Time]

He made a mistake Mario's first ever save was princess Daisy next princess Daisy could have become Princess peach that means Luigi married daisy...

[@itsmetime2517]

SINCE WHEN DOES BOWSER HAVE A WIFE HE DOESNT EVEN HAVE PARENTS

[@neonemerald37]

Now dose that mean Mario and daisy weill be together now

[@ewertonpimenta2577]

hi

[@krissy_o_gi904]

I do not believe Rosalina to be Mario and Peach’s daughter, even with evidence it is a real blind shot in the dark, I mean she may have blonde hair but her blonde hair is so much lighter than both Peach’s and Mario’s. Peach should be extremely old if she is her mother, hasn’t Rosalina existed for a very long time? It is just too unbelievable for me but that’s why it’s just a theory ^^

[@kjdonaghy]

You can believe what you can believe

[@mistomanastrafe]

This is discussed in the theory itself. Rosalina is from a previous cycle of the galaxy, that’s partially why Peach appears so young relative to her. It’s basically like a parallel timeline, except they take place one after the other instead of all at once. Besides, the version of peach from the cycle Rosalina is born in is dead according to this theory. I personally find the theory believable, which is why it’s canon to the AU. But there’s nothing wrong with disagreeing with the theory. I hope you can still enjoy the other videos dispite that fact.

[@Speariture]

Rosalina being a goddess most likely reseted the timeline and decided to look out for her Mother and Father while also being by their side

[@CreekSong.warriors]

Can u make them react to Mario is mental

[@twillacatron7596]

Aka Mario Charatcters react to someone real abusing them(even though there not real)

[@user-iu6gz2rj6u]

Luigi is her father!

[@kellenvivier2291]

Mind blown 🤯🤯🤯

[@Wiisportseires10234]

It Mario and daisy are now together

[@stinkergard]

Super mario galaxy 2? Hello?

[@aryarobinson1909]

Welp Luigi broke up with daisy

[@mistomanastrafe]

They were never together in the first place in this au.

[@Mr_Inspiration]

As much as MatPat put it, I have some evidence of my own to point out that Mario is the father. Fact in point, what are the Toads doing in the same picture? They're not related to any of the characters except for Peach by more like guardians than blood family. Another point being, Mario & Luigi are brothers so of course Mario & Luigi have similar features to each other. The blue eyes, the dominant hand thing, the hair. Mario & Luigi just so happens to have the similar features because of their genes. And the green hat? Why would Luigi give his favorite hat to the younger sibling if Rosalina is his first born? Wouldn't it make much more sense for the oldest get the father's personal possession before the youngest is even thought of being a thing by the parent? I know there's the constant reboots of the universe changing everything ever so slightly, but suddenly making Mario just vanish into a different love life & leaving Luigi to have a family with Peach seems more like a huge jump than a small step. And no romantic relationship? Why else would Peach promise cake & a special gift that soon comes in handy as he uses it to save her if they won't an item? But, with that in hand, that does lead things to point to someone else being the *mother*. In the drawing of the mother, you see a lot of features that just so happens to look like Peach, but one major thing to point out is the hair color. It's not blonde like Peach's. It's orange. Now who else do we know who has similar features to Peach & has orange hair? Hmm? 🌼

[@mikina4636]

So that i write on paper with left hand and write on board with right hand is more rarer then only left? Idk xd

[@dia_brando3345]

I feel concerned about why bowser in this video is an girl-

[@mistomanastrafe]

Bowsette. It’s a mario community thing, I didn’t come up with it.

[@xcosmicchaos2740]

I would have put in Mario murdering Luigi

[@PAULOPGR]

But why, if Mario was the first choice for the entire two parts, while Luigi was only in the last few minutes of part 2?🤷🏽‍♀️

[@balex55lp]

i have blue eyes xD

[@ghosthunter7733]

Mario got dasiy we good

[@loganwoolard4203]

Hold up my brain hurts if Luigi and peach are the mother and father of Rosalina then...WHY DOES MARIO SAVE PEACH WHY DOESNT LUIGI DO THAT??!!!!!!

[@gaming_sus]

Ladies and Gentlemen i think My brain just committed suicide

[@champger1234]

Is to through the whole thing off

[@PAULOPGR]

Relax, the assumption is that they would be her parents of a previously cycle, basically 2000 cycles behind. And as Rosalina says at the end of Super Mario Galaxy, the cycle in that universe restars every 100 years, but never repeats itself in the same way. That is, every reset, everything stays, but it still changes.

[@rielyc5639]

Why did you make Mario's bag red and White?????