Marshall Emberton vs. JBL Flip 5 - NOT EVEN CLOSE?

[@horacevu]

Not going to lie, I liked your video review style up until you did the sound tests. Why are you playing different songs for different speakers? Play the same songs so we the viewers can hear the sound difference for each speakers. Common sense my guy!

[@Helicobacter6]

Exactly

[@nikolaslukac]

The marshall barely had some battery . . .this was the worst comparison video i ever seen😅 And i dont know but still the marshall was the better one I dont care how loud was the jbl but the sound was much nicer from the marshall much more clear

[@JeremiahLutherPritchett]

Why do you just immediately assume people think you’re a liar? Weird way to start a sentence. Your first instinct when you hear something like that is you feel like you’re about to be lied to. That’s weird you’re weird stop being weird and stop constantly lying about everything, liar.

[@manuelbaylon9717]

Biased review.

[@Psychad3lFx6669]

Marshalls are for metal and rock it pisses me off

[@samiturunen5335]

Mashall sounded much richer and better.

[@maxmattt]

I have the Emberton and It's a fantastic speaker (sounds amazing, battery lasts ages between charges, excellent build quality) and I've never had connection issues, My only criticism is that the charging cable can come unplugged easily, it's easy to accidentally unplug it if you move it whilst charging.

[@marks7217]

There's no way...I have the Emberton and the JBL Charge 5, which is much larger than the Flip 5 and the Emberton blows the Charge 5 away. Doesn't matter what kid of music, low volume or high, it's no contest. So to hear the Flip 5 beats the Emberton here makes me wonder who paid for this video.

[@FishBeeProductions]

Unfortunately my wallet paid for this one 🤣

[@mzarar10]

That's what I was thinking too. He's too biased 🤣

[@carloscolon4295]

@@mzarar10 he used almost a low battery on the marshall,that wasn't fair.and marshall from owning boths speakers sounds better to me.

[@frhuerta74]

So you recomend the Marshall by far? Can’t make up my mind between this two. Thanks.

[@carloscolon4295]

@@frhuerta74 get the marshall,it sounds better

[@Samigabor]

Man... It is not a fair competition, because you only test on electronic music... It is well known JBL bluetooth speakers designed for electronic music and it is well known Emberton is optimized for rock music... Both speakers has great magic in their own area of the world of music. If we are looking for a balanced bluetooth speaker to listen both eletronic and rock music then we need to go for a bose soundlink II...

[@lymedog3176]

I agree with mat… first, you had the JBL to the side the mono speaker is on, so it’s gonna be louder in recording, second, you need to test them head on, from behind and off axis, third the songs need to be the same back to back to get a clear and fair assessment. I own a flip five and it in itself is a loud and decent sounding speaker, but as of what I heard, the emberton is more refined, has a more spacious sound (aka stereo type) and has a smoother clarity to the harshness of the JBL…. You almost sounded like a JBL rep giving an “unbiased” assessment.

[@johniescorpio]

True that👌☺️

[@JeremiahLutherPritchett]

Checked your channel didn’t see any of your videos doing anything you’ve mentioned.

[@lymedog3176]

User-zg1 what are you talking about… me or the you tuber?

[@blood_n_guts_murphy]

For anyone concerned with audio quality the Marshall is far better sounding. This review is bananas.

[@FishBeeProductions]

Bananas are good for you

[@blood_n_guts_murphy]

@@FishBeeProductions just had one and I agree.

[@michaeltompkinsjr.7696]

@@FishBeeProductions Yeah he should’ve said “malarkey” lol

[@JeremiahLutherPritchett]

@@FishBeeProductions Bananas 🍌 are radioactive ☢️. Fact

[@sijojose3565]

Bro sony bluethooth speaker sound is better than marshall

[@bryangarren6709]

I found this to be completely backwards. The jbl sounds small and distorts very easily. I exchanged it for the marshall and it is night and day better deeper sounds with super clear highs.

[@nanimanibog]

Maybe try charging both speakers to at least 50% (specially the marshall in this case) so you can better gauge the sound quality and loudness that both speakers can produce.

[@solidaudioTV]

How are we supposed to decide which sounds better for a given scenario when the reviewer isn't using the same song on both speakers? That's like comparing apples with oranges.

[@FishBeeProductions]

I like oranges better

[@goodlyfe83]

@@FishBeeProductions so you're bias?

[@PrinjuVaidyan]

@@FishBeeProductions haha good one

[@flaca1191]

Fr then picking softer music with barely beats for one 🥱

[@Realmasterorder]

The video is interesting and i always find the Marshall and Charge or flip to be very close in competition but i Wonder just WHY do u play different Songs on the speakers to test/compare when we should hear the same music on both to decide.

[@FishBeeProductions]

Shhh, don't point that out, LOL. I only noticed after I finished recording and couldn't find the same clips.

[@vroomvroombabu2598]

I feel like Marshall is for Gentleman where as JBL is for party bois

[@mattheturk8158]

Marshall sounds like an actual speaker. Flip being mono is too flat. It can get louder maybe and more bass heavy. Marshall is clear winner for me

[@kevindoherty2716]

Your hearing stereo from any tiny speakers I find interesting ? How when true stereo requires seperation so your hearing sound from 2 distinct points ! There is no seperation possible here unless your a bug sitting 1 inch in front of the speaker ...

[@mattheturk8158]

@@kevindoherty2716 oh cmon tiny or not you can easily differentiate a speaker that works mono compared to a stereo speaker. That’s why they say JBL charge 3 is still the best charge model of all times it has two drivers it’s stereo. First things first some instrumental components of the music you’re listening to disappears completely with mono speakers or it gets too low you can’t even recognize it but with stereo those missing nuances can clearly be heard whether I’m one metre close or 10m close to my speaker. Please

[@fredvoid5976]

marshal isnt even a sterio speaker

[@mattheturk8158]

@@fredvoid5976 Marshall is a true stereophonic speaker it has two drivers unlike Jbl charge. The last stereophonic JBL charge was charge 3. I think it’s still the best sounding charge and I used it for 3-4 years before it died on me.

[@SwetlessNoob]

@@mattheturk8158 my man doesn’t know the meaning of stareo and mono

[@aaronaustrie]

I have the Flip 5. It's a great speaker. I have it about 2 yrs now

[@FishBeeProductions]

Nice!

[@JesusGutierrez-kv1ij]

The sound quality of the Emberton is much better, richer, and in low volumes is simply pure and balanced. The JBL is the kind of speaker that prefers to give you a lot of volume with no quality, it sound mono and without magic.

[@jcmolero71]

And worse, 3 ohm speaker, just bassy presence

[@nickmegadeth6633]

He reviewed without charging the Marshall...🤣😅

[@matthewtolbert4843]

yeah, makes no sense. of course it was weaker...... it had no power

[@Wessathemessa]

Have to disagree. The Emberton has an all round better sound quality. The JBL (as all JBLs are) have boosted bass and treble and lack mid range clarity and are just designed for those who want it loud.

[@Groovial]

If you try to gain stage the volume of the clip between Marshall and JBL, meaning to increase slightly the volume when Marshall is playing but to be same level with JBL then you will see the clarity and depth on all the spectrum that Marshall gives. I chose Emberton.

[@Hypnotic_Snowman]

Marshall actually has a much more clean and smooth sound, no doubt!

[@norbertn5130]

I have the flip 5 and I am pretty happy

[@pablozz2409]

I have both of them both are amazing but i prefer JBL 👍

[@ashwadhwani]

Marshall tested their speakers on Grunge music for sure ;)

[@AntoDeejay]

Marshall soft and smooth, JBL Hard & loudness

[@aremdvnasophia]

Maybe charge the Marshall speaker first. 🤷‍♂️

[@rayrozniarek8874]

That’s funny. Every other person that tested the Flip vs the Marshall Emberton has the Marshall speaker as the better speaker. Are you sure your not a JBL fan boy ?

[@FishBeeProductions]

I might be soon enough LOL

[@carmelinapereira9978]

JBL has built a Legacy and is the top dog. Marshall sounds very thin v signature.

[@razkopchan]

The two speakers are great. But the real deal in this price and sound range is bose flex.

[@faridsaab915]

The louder speaker it is not necessary the best speaker. Sound is more related with quality not with level of sound. The sound on this type of speakers depends on the charging level.

[@bwanadave76]

AAARRRRRGGGGHHHH! Completely different tracks in a listening test??!! AYKMRN?

[@lefteris696]

Both sound nice, but should have compared same music on both speakers to give a more accurate review

[@mikga45]

Not a good review comparing a battery that needs charging to a battery that is almost full charge and playing different songs

[@raychristianpabustan8546]

Im using a Flip 3 and its still really good

[@kenny347]

Then why r u here

[@gusti99ful]

@@kenny347 its that a problem?

[@mytopicsopinions2840]

I hate to say it but the Marshall sounds cleaner and better overall

[@tomnilla9092]

The JBL Flip 5 is just a better speaker better Bass

[@mylesgreen1361]

not pretty good to play 2 different songs on 2 different speakers, they have different bass quality, u need to redo that part

[@epicboy4055]

Marshall is clear It was choice of rock stars 🤩

[@eshkakogan75]

Emberton is not worth $271 cdn. I was completely underwhelmed. It went back to Amazon. Going to try the JBL Flip 5.

[@pierowosgien4774]

why would you compare two speakers when one has a low battery? this can't meant to be serious

[@bernard5260]

I'm a bass lover and I have quite a lot of bass headphones and speakers. I had a JBL speaker, it played nice but not as perfect as I wanted. In this video Marshall plays very decently and luxuriously soft, I'll go with it.

[@bernard5260]

Update: Bro, the 360 audio is hands down better than the JBL. I love cooking yes cooking and I'm a man. Having the sound play the same everywhere I go is next level. Other speakers in this range lack this awesome feature 👏. And I don't seem reviewers talking much about it but it's just better to have it. When you're out with friends you can put it in the middle and you can still hear the same sounds coming from different directions. I love it

[@christophermatthews9246]

I don't know man,... Seems like you compared the two with un even volume, or maybe its because of the low battery in the emberton,....the emberton is a pretty loud speaker, sure not as loud as the jbl, but not by a big difference.....

[@nidamanurivinod1047]

Recently bought marshall and before it I had jbl 5 marshall souds awesome classic and rich jbl 5 loud not rich to the perfection. Marshall kept it. Only issue with the video as you don't charge it full sir.

[@sclancy79]

I own both and this is a terrible review. Testing on a low battery? Really dude? Anyways... JBL is louder and has better bass. Marshall has WAY better sound quality. It's not even close. Both speakers are good, just depends on the main purpose you are using them for. JBL is a mono speaker with awesome bass radiators that's great for outdoor use. Marshall is a stereo speaker that doesn't get as loud but has MUCH better sound quality. Marshall is better utilized for indoor use and those who truly care about fidelity.

[@FishBeeProductions]

Yeah, terrible LOL

[@JAFFER3657]

5:14 - 5:40 what is the music being played during that duration?

[@FishBeeProductions]

don't remember the name but its in the youtube audio library

[@tomtan6612]

Oh my god, the sound of bees at the opening made me jump with headphones💩

[@SulakshanJamwal]

Somebody please please tell me which one is best of best of them as i am spending my half month salary please in each i want a good detailed reply

[@anyariv]

Is this fake? How is this possible?

[@zingzing8915]

All the commentor here cnt afford any speaker but still have the gut to choose which is better 😆😆

[@jjy365959]

I compare marshall emberton ii vs jbl charge 3, marshall had better sound. jbl is more focus on bass but marshall is focused on treble and voice but I found marshall bass is better.

[@carlt9265]

Jbl all sound muddy and suck at high volume everyone i have tried been the same

[@fredvoid5976]

Though Im still going for the flip 5 cuz Of the bass and Its design... But Dudeee, even if I never heard of marshal emberton, The SOUND Is sooo gorgeous and the clarity,much better than Huawei soundjoy That My friend has

[@StoreByThebox]

One song on both mate , nice one

[@ginoalfonsoragaschipana2723]

Dear regret against telling you but we are comparing two products that are in two different spheres. The mere fact that you compare the JBL with the Marshall indicates that you do not know what is inside each product. JBL creates products with good value for money but you should not compare it to a Marshall whose build and audio quality is far above it indicates that you are doing your job poorly. Lima Perú.

[@SciFly7]

Totally disagree. Comparison reviews should be done based on what products compete in similar categories and what peoples' options might be when looking for a particular type of product, not brand names or how companies market themselves. Some budget speakers can have much better sound signatures than supposed big name brands which would be great to know before spending a ton on a high end speaker only to find a cheaper and better sounding option.

[@kylestewart8354]

Why didn't you charge the Marshall? Do you not think low battery effects speaker output? Lol. Anyway. I own both. JBL are great speakers for teenagers. But if you truly like music the Marshall is By far better listening experience. So much cleaner sound.

[@nicoletambasco9210]

Have to let them fully die before charging them so I like when they come low already

[@jonasf6930]

Not a fair comparison when playing two different songs. Why did you do that? Does not make any sense, unless the purpose of this video is to disadvantage one brand from another.

[@HussainMohammadMobin]

Playing this on my Flip 6

[@tallice20]

Is it me or is the Marshall more Silent as the JBL ? ... the JBL has more Bass and a Louder Sound, Sorry but the JBL Sounds better for me 🤷

[@oni493]

I like Marshall sound too good

[@stevegonson4234]

You need to charge the battery of emberton first before you test. Your comparison is not fair, its seem you are the fan of JBL

[@soeunbunheng1146]

Huawei sounds joy?????

[@gpipeline]

Let's compare by testing one speaker when the battery is real low 🤦‍♂️

[@zahriatan1946]

Well I just don't like the JBL sound signature. It''s a matter of taste I know but they sound rather artificial.

[@sollyharr]

You totally screwed up the sound test...try charging them properly too...better get some more lotion on those fingertips.....fail..

[@FishBeeProductions]

True lol

[@edcipriani8873]

You seem to be confusing how loud a speaker gets with good sound quality. This is the unfortunate reality is that many people who compare, review, and use Bluetooth speakers these days mistake and confuse loudness, or overcompensating in the bass range for good sound quality. Do yourself a favor, go watch several of Oluv's reviews on Bluetooth speakers here on KZbin, as well as go read some professional reviews from CNET, Digital Trends, PCMag, and a few others. You might learn a few things. Gotta love your feedback: The Button the Emberton feels weird, it took dry skin off your finger, and you need to use lotion. If you're going to be reviewing electronics and devices, be prepared to be hands-on and handling devices, and not go into the drama queen zone.

[@rishabhs391]

U gotta use the same music for both of them... I am more confused with my decision than i was 😭

[@johnnydepo]

This video brought to you by JBL. Marshall blows JBL out of the water.

[@FishBeeProductions]

LOL

[@Torturro100]

not good when you change speakers and start music over - should switch WHILE playing

[@orangeluck5309]

Jbl flip is the champion of all speaker💪💪💥💥🔥🔥🔥

[@ngektor666]

Бляяяя, кто хоть ставит разную музыку для сравнения?) Откуда вы такие берётесь?!

[@jhoanalvarado968]

Parece que las pruebas de audio fueron modificadas

[@quantztrader]

It is clear that based on comments, this channel doesn't do a fair comparison.

[@jericlee1509]

flip wins

[@doymiranda3929]

M. Emberton👌👍

[@Akash-tq1ui]

JBL is winner!!

[@NimaSering-ke1mj]

Ofc marshall....bro .

[@borkata1]

Jbl for the win I have 1 speaker of jbl the charge 3 its also waterproof

[@srikanthvadla6255]

Jbl winner 🏆🎉🏆

[@Grass754]

I have big speker of marchell

[@mutalibabdullah7587]

Which one is good for Bollywood music

[@MilatovichFamily]

Marshall.

[@travisbanner7893]

Mending pake jbl kawe aja bang... Enak dangdutan juga bisa.. Murah lebih asekk goyangnya

[@bldycrash1420]

Marshall sounds soft in ears

[@techtricks983]

If you see video in 144 p you feel real build quality.

[@Flaan883]

speed 1.25x takes you into heaven

[@FishBeeProductions]

Relax, no need to rush through life LOL

[@johnsonthadz]

Biased Comparison, marshall is good

[@hpmc7426]

Seems like everyone but the host feels a tremendous bias here. Very hard to not give it away when you it THAT obvious. I wouldn’t have paid you if I were JBL.

[@FishBeeProductions]

i agree, JBL, if you're watching this, please send me your stuff for review.

[@johnbyington6414]

Marshall is a better speaker, and yes you need some lotion.

[@chickencorgi5827]

MARSHALL NUMBER 1

[@omarelnahal7394]

Right away you can tell there is a biased narrative in this video.

[@FishBeeProductions]

True

[@bw8827]

This guy is clearly tone deaf. The Emberton is a far more musical speaker than the JBL. Either that or he was getting a bung from JBL. He's also a dope for not playing the same tunes on each speaker for a true comparative result. 2 out of 10 buddy, try again.

[@FishBeeProductions]

Glad I could help!

[@PalashGupta]

Useless Review , not same songs, battery issue n whatevera , the reviewer himself not sure of anything ..

[@FishBeeProductions]

true

[@love_death]

The reason i'm watching this video is, The emberton sound is distorting at full volume. I'm not expecting that from a premium brand at all.... If you are a person who loves listening to loud music or hugh bass sometimes please go for JBL, it has almost no distortion.

[@pranabmahanta888]

Your voice is so much robotic 😮

[@FishBeeProductions]

lol yeah sometimes

[@KuyaMan]

i saw a video about fake marshall. it seems your marshall is fake. by the time you power ON the marshall, the authentic marshall should have no sound but yours has. so your marshall is fake

[@FishBeeProductions]

really? i'll have to look that up because i have another marshall speaker and it also has the same startup sound

[@charloujrg.imalay8471]

This is bias sound test..

[@meinungsfreier6]

LOL! You use different Tracks to just what? To Show Music Production is different…come on!

[@mrwhiteinca]

Oh my God I can totally hear the difference.... LOL of course I can't because I'm listening on a s***** tablet like everybody else

[@mechanickiwi4116]

Looks like you got a fake emberton, bad luck

[@tutuan7252]

Jbl

[@detaraisha6314]

4:30

[@putraamir3589]

Using flip 5🙋🙋

[@gibson69sg]

Terrible sound comparison playing lame drab music through the Marshall, why not be fair & play the same music through both speakers?

[@FishBeeProductions]

Yeah I couldn't find that audio clip, of course this video became popular so everyone lets me know LOL