TRUMPET VS FLUGELHORN - Which is a Better Solo Instrument??? W.A.Mozart - Alleluia

[@112BALAGE112]

It depends on the style or genre of the music. In this case the trumpet's clear and bright tone serves the classical style much better.

[@Matonizz]

Makes total sense! Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

[@Phantas1ze]

I disagree. I think the dark tone of the flugel horn sounds much better with classical music. Bright tones like the trumpet are better suited for jazz in my opinion.

[@pp_h]

@@Phantas1ze i agree with you

[@musical_lolu4811]

@@Phantas1ze it doesn't matter in the end. Associating tone or timbre quality with specific genres is an exercise in futility.

[@dave_arthur]

His trumpet tone was far from bright, it was pretty rounded and suited for the piece. I was listening to some blistering trumpet earlier today and this is tame by comparison so in this case I would vote for trumpet even though I'm super fond of the flugel and want to get one.

[@oldmanandthesea7039]

Personally I find the trumpet is more brassy and responsive, while the flugelhorn is softer and closer to French horn’s tone color. So if you want to raise the soldiers’s spirit, play the trumpet; if you want that pastoral and nostalgic feelings, play the flugelhorn.

[@waluyajaya2766]

Wise answer.

[@zijeisdezon]

Poetically put into words!

[@jerichogonzales1290]

Trumpet with a horn mouthpiece really changes the timbre at the bottom to an almost clarinet like quality. Would love to see it used on a flugelhorn.

[@ronpage8243]

Excellent reply. I'm learning both, a 1921 Conn New Wonder trumpet and an ACB "doubler " flugle. For myself, flugle sounds better but the trumpet easier to play.

[@MethodFire01]

Flugelhorn is the sound of comfort whereas trumpet is the sound of nobility.

[@Matonizz]

Nice! Well said

[@RandyStalkMusic]

Can't forget the coronet.the blade of the brass family

[@cauaikesoares259]

Flugelhorn é o som do conforto, enquanto o trompete é o som da nobreza

[@MethodFire01]

@@cauaikesoares259 nice translation

[@CameronMLeet]

Facts.

[@deendrew36]

As a fledgling euphonium player, I must say the sound of the flugelhorn appeals to me more than the brashness of the trumpet. Wonderful musician!

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Nice of you to say. I’ll try to live up to euphonium standards, haha. But sincerely, thanks. I really do appreciate it.

[@GhostRyder2008]

For this piece I'd say trumpet works better. I feel that not only is it much easier to hear as the timbre pierces through the accompaniment much better, but also the timbre of the trumpet matches more stylistically to the piece.

[@justme07111]

I Absolutely agree. This is such a stately piece and the brightness of the trumpet sounds just works better.

[@Reino.Celeste]

For this piece, picollo make more sense.

[@GhostRyder2008]

@@Reino.Celeste Yeah, I think I'd agree with that. Both I think work better than a flugelhorn though!

[@skaldstaleentertainment2969]

The articulation is impeccable

[@Matonizz]

Yep, Drew is a fantastic player :)

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Thanks. It’s a huge focus for me. My teacher spent a lot of time beating air-propelled articulation into me, haha.

[@michaeltroster9059]

It’s not a matter of which instrument is better. It depends on the music. Some works come across more suited by the more brilliant tones of the trumpet, whereas others are better suited to the more velvet tones of the flugelhorn. I play both and enjoy both. Both instruments have had and have players who have achieved fame concentrating mostly on one of the two instruments.

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

I am the ultimate jack (or maybe “hack”) of all trades, and master of none. I’d say I prefer trumpet, but I like the flugel, and to a lesser extent, the cornet.

[@waltschult1871]

My dream is to play like this guy, it foes not matter trumpet or flugelhorn. My sound preference here is the trumpet sound

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Thank you for the kind words, Walt. Lots more over at my channel.

[@MooseyMTB]

I’ve always admired the rich sound of the flugelhorn over the brassy sound of the trumpet but it all depends on what style of music it is.

[@gullfriend7102]

I may be biased, but I've always felt that small ensembles, especially less than ten people, always sound better with a flugelhorn than with a cornet or trumpet. The more instruments there are, the more the soprano voice should cut through the ensemble, thus necessitating the trumpet's use. Trumpets were designed to be heard from very far away.

[@mr.tiddles556]

I've never heard a sound more buttery than this fluglehorn. I love them both

[@SKBottom]

It entirely comes down to personal preference. Both sound fantastic. Given these two recordings, I would have to go with trumpet, simply because the flugelhorn at times gets a little too lost within the sound of the piano. Outstanding performance and outstanding player.

[@Matonizz]

Thank you Stephen! Appreciate the comment my friend!

[@timlinnabary8296]

I agree with Stephen. I play both of these instruments, and love the sound of the flugelhorn, but the trumpet has the punch to cut through the accompaniment.

[@Matonizz]

@@timlinnabary8296 Thank you Tim! I love flugelhorn a lot on lyrical stuff but trumpet does cut through better when clarity is needed.

[@GwenMcGill]

Totally agree on this piece.

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Fair points. I appreciate the compliment.

[@qwiklok]

I have both instruments and a French horn. This piece sounds great both ways. I think any brass instrument, horn included, would have a good effect Each has a different impact. an oboe, pipe organ, flute, piccolo trumpet all have certain qualities for different effects. The playing was gorgeous on both. Depends on my mood i guess

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Thanks, I used to be very purist about pieces being written for this or than instrument. Now, I just like to play great music, and I believe everyone should be able to do so.

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Thanks!

[@Cysubtor_8vb]

I generally always prefer the tone of a flugelhorn over trumpet. Been contemplating getting one just for kicks and to sort of be the "soprano tuba" of my brass collection 🤣

[@Matonizz]

Yes, do so! I always tell people to try and learn/play as many brass instruments as they can! Flugel is like euph of high brass :)

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

I think trumpet PLAYERS probably have had the most to do with negative sentiment toward the instrument, haha.

[@petenielsen6683]

I play the trombone - aka "bass trumpet!"

[@rafexrafexowski4754]

​@@petenielsen6683 That would be a valve trombone

[@CarlyWaarly]

@@rafexrafexowski4754 Play trumpet, cornet and flugelhorn, horses for corses, favourite for Christmas carols is the flugelhorn.

[@paulroutledge4923]

Both sound great. The sound of the flugel seems to get a bit lost sounding with the piano. Cornet would be a great compromise. This would sound great on both euphonium or baritone.

[@Matonizz]

Thank you Paul! I've recorded a euph version a while ago. It does work very well on low brass as well :)

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Fair enough. Maybe I could have mixed the flugel a little louder. It definitely comes across much more gently, especially in this register.

[@sunhong5726]

Trumpet sound is great!!! Your tone is very clean and charming!!! great player!!!

[@Matonizz]

Hi BrassFamily, hope you enjoy the interpretation of this arrangement of Mozart's Alleluia by Drew Fennell on Trumpet (F Major version) and Flugelhorn (Bb Major version). Help us out by leaving a comment down below and sharing your thoughts on which instrument and version did you like best. Sheet music available only at: www.matonizz.com/product/alleluia/ Have a great week peeps!

[@CarlyWaarly]

Just purchased a JP175S Flugelhorn, beautiful tone, impressive, will be great for Carols at Christmas and for Jazz.

[@sethprice3995]

For classical music it depends on what the piece was originally written for. Oboe, flute and violin concertos work really well on pic. Horn and cello concertos work really well on flugel. If a piece was written specifically for the modern trumpet then that is what you should probably use. I've also found that pieces written for natural trumpet can work well on pic, trumpet or flugel as the timbre of the natural trumpet is so distinct on its own.

[@juliea2864]

I really like the sound of the Flugelhorn. It's very soothing.

[@RW-ob4en]

Gorgeous clean sound on both, characteristic of each. Great phrasing & articulation too

[@ericssonnyeleti]

Both sound great but I think the flugelhorn carries the day due to the fact that it isn't as noisy and shallow as the trumpet. I believe a solo instrument shouldn't really be cutting out all the time, flying high above, because the accompaniment(s) has to be heard too, to add more meaning to a piece of music /composition /arrangement.

[@Matonizz]

Very nice! Thanks Ericsson!

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

“Noisy and shallow!” Hey! Just kidding. It’s a fair point you make. It has its place. Being honest, I like playing flugel and cornet, but I like the trumpet best.

[@ericssonnyeleti]

@@TheMusicofDrewFennell I feel you! 😊👌🏾

[@RealJstJazz]

Tbh I like flugelhorn more and It’s basically a euphonium had a child with a piccolo Bb trumpet, met in the middle and had this.

[@mystephen3821]

I love the sound of flugelhorn , sounds so awesome 😎,

[@TheMrAshley2010]

Some comments are about 'personal preference', which I don't disagree with. But I question 'whose' preference? In other words, the context of the performance is what I would be basing the choice of instrument on. Is it a church prelude in a big building, but for the 'conservative' congregation? If so, then flugelhorn. Is it incidental 'pre-ceremony' music for a college graduation in a multi purpose/concert hall? If so, then trumpet. High school recital with multiple performers? Flugelhorn. College recital, you're the only performer? Trumpet. And so on.

[@Matonizz]

Well said! Thanks for commenting Scott, couldn't said better myself!

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Good point. Easy to be trying to fit square pegs in round holes.

[@EngPheniks]

Trumpet - good for solo pieces of upbeat music Flugelhorn - good for solo pieces of soft music Cornet - good for ensemble

[@Matonizz]

Agree!

[@andrerosa1234]

So beautiful sound! Bravo

[@Matonizz]

Thank you Andre!

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Thank you, Andre!

[@judsonbaker4628]

I have always favored the Flug love the rich warm sound they have.

[@qwiklok]

ACtually when I think about it, the Canadian Brass have taken Bach's pipe organ masterpiece and made it work for brass. And some great piano pieces are used by violin and even brass as well. And all of it sounds great. Of course some pieces are made for brass fanfare and it would sound crappy on a recorder or flute so the instrument must be suitable. But overall, I love the work. Well done. Great playing. the heart and soul was in the playing and that makes all the difference in the world. Dave.

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Simply put, I think music is music and musicianship is musicianship. When music meets musicianship, good things can happen. My ethic is based on the idea that, with so much great music, no one should feel excluded from playing it.

[@qwiklok]

@@TheMusicofDrewFennell Well stated. I'm onboard with my frenxh horn. Lets see, Rachmaninoff 3??? for 10 horns. ??? hmmmm

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

@@qwiklok, prooooobably not, haha. Right now, we're focused on smaller pieces which can be performed with a small number of players...this is to serve our audience who are asking for it (they want to play duets and trios with friends), and also to make life a bit easier for us. Producing this volume of work is really pushing the limits of what we can do, and every player you adds extra cost, time, and challenges. Thanks again for your comments!

[@matthewbrindle]

As a trumpet player most of the time I am bias about the trumpet. But the flugelhorn's tone is just a whole other level! Amazing job on that piece!

[@Matonizz]

Thank you!

[@mr88cet]

I think it would be a more-interesting comparison if the two versions were in the same key. I know some people question the usefulness of the medium-high to high registers on the flügelhorn. I personally think they still work just great, even though they’re not quite as rich as the lower register.

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

I agree. I only chose to do the lower key to show the arrangement is playable in two keys, so people have a choice. Definitely like the mid to high register on flugel.

[@mr88cet]

@@TheMusicofDrewFennell, either way though, thanks for the comparison! Thinking back to my comment, maybe, instead of the “usefulness” of the higher registers, perhaps “appeal” would be a better word. The lower register is soooo deliciously resonant, that the middle and upper registers sometimes “take second fiddle,” so to speak, in some people’s minds. That, even though, objectively in themselves, (with a little work) they sound fine! Much of Sergei Nakariakov’s first album was down in the baritone-horn range! I wish I had more time to play my Courtois… Retire in 5 years!

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

@@mr88cet, totally agree. The thing I ALWAYS struggle with on flugel, especially playing with River City Brass Band, is playing really loud and often fairly high, I tend to start puckering my embouchure into the deep mouthpiece. It takes real effort to avoid it. Deep mouthpieces can be a trap.

[@mr88cet]

@@TheMusicofDrewFennell, perhaps its kinda analogous with the bass clarinet: The lower register is so rich, and emblematic of the instrument, and the higher registers more challenging to make “sing,” that some people lose faith in them.

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

@@mr88cet, I’d say that’s a great analogy. It can be warm and sweet, but can easily become throaty and unattractive really quickly. Of course that’s mostly a low register issue. Can’t overflow…

[@doctormorbius6430]

Which instrument is better for solos? Well, which one do great soloists play? Flugelhorn: Chuck Mangione Trumpet: Miles Davis, Louis Armstrong, Dizzy Gillespie, Winton Marsalis, Al Hirt, Harry James, Bix Beiderbecke, Rafael Mendez, Don Ellis . . .

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Definitely depends on the piece. Use the right tool for the job.

[@peterharrison5833]

Actually, Bix Beiderbecke played the cornet---and so did Louis in his younger years....

[@ktang001]

Beautifully played! I would say that a better comparison of the two instruments would be to have both instruments play the same piece in the same key.

[@IkanGelamaKuning]

on flugelhorn, it feels so good.

[@TRUMPETSIZZLE]

Good demo

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

You should hear me on a kazoo! In all seriousness, thanks, Sizzle.

[@ChilesailorDR]

Gave me just a little feel that maybe the flugelhornist was rushing...just my take on it. But love the lower key arrangements that are FOR flugelhorn! Love it!

[@RafaelSantos-om4my]

Executaram essa linda música antes da série round 6, ficar famosa. vocês estão de parabéns, trompetista muito bem afinado, rápido, simplesmente perfeito, uma ótima execução.

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Thanks, Rafael!

[@meh11235]

phenomenal playing my friend

[@Matonizz]

Thank you!

[@ItsAngel.X]

Saludos desde Colombia

[@henkvandenhurk3370]

Werkelijk heel mooi!!!!!!

[@TucsonDude]

Question: Is the score for the flugel lower because it's harder to play in the upper register?

[@thomasrice4078]

Well, euphonium was the obvious answer of course. But each horn has its' own flavor and the music will determine which horn best fits the mood the composer wanted to create.

[@kennethtalbott2233]

the trumpet on this piece hands down. you have a lovely clean crisp sound. sounded lovely. horses for courses as the flugel wasn't suited to this particular piece in my opinion. nice flugel though.

[@jessehamilton9758]

This a silly question. The two instruments are used for very different reasons. They capture very different feels.

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Fair point…. I think… in a way, the question is, can one instrument, full of soulfulness and warmth, capture “JOY” as meaningfully as an instrument that is synonymous with over the top brashness? I think it’s “JOY” either way. My two cents…

[@kevinAuguillard]

Very nice, but you can't compare the two horns and then play the song in separate keys. Flugelhorn in the upper register, like the higher key with the trumpet. That would sound heavenly.

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

That is a fair point. These were recorded at separate times…illustrating that the arrangement is playable in multiple keys. Maybe down the road, I’ll make a point to record each key on more than one instrument!

[@gabi101180]

Me gustó más con trompeta. El sonido del fliscorno es un espectáculo. Súper meloso.

[@Euphoniumplayer12]

Is it fine if I post this on ticktock and tag y'all because I love it and I'm a flugelhorn and trumpet player myself

[@Matonizz]

Sure

[@glgaws]

Well done!

[@Matonizz]

Thank you!

[@da11king]

Awesome sound! Exquisite tone 🎺✨️🎶👌🏾I believe you are using mics to get that reverb sound effect. Am i right?

[@Eloweh]

I prefer flugelhorn but I also like the darker sound it makes, kind of bias since I play euphonium haha

[@bluehorn50]

i like both!

[@ronaldocalefeberemni3066]

Belíssimo 👏👏👏👏

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Grazie, Ronaldo! 🙏

[@ChironAce]

For this piece, trumpet is more appropriate; the bright tone color gives it a regal quality.

[@PiotrBarcz]

I really like flugelhorns, they're so much smoother than trumpets most of the time with a lot more depth, my kinda sound!

[@nomnomnommy2955]

To me the trumpet is sharper , and the flugelhorn is warmer, Woolier and more rounded. I Personally would choose flugelhorn if I had to choose one

[@Valkyry5]

Very Nice *

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Thanks, Valkryry.

[@antniopereirasobrinho3599]

Excelente.

[@diz7595]

What is the highest note that can be played on a flugelhorn?

[@paulgrimm6850]

I bought two trumpets . I wish now one was a flugelhorn . I love the mellow sound.

[@TucsonDude]

I have a Bach Strad and King Flugel. I like the latter a wee bit more.

[@jonplopp6643]

Well....I like them both.

[@AddieRey7]

I love how the recording is so smooth and perfect like what do you use to record?? 🤔

[@uning1912]

... Flügelhorn ... ! Gut gespielt.

[@davidbarbero6212]

"which is a better solo instrument". It depends on the type of music you are playing. Some music is very lyrical and the flugel horn is well suited for this, other music might need a brilliant sound and the trumpet is obviously the better choice.

[@Matonizz]

Agreed, seems like a sentiment most people share :) Thanks for feedback!

[@jasonzurlo1543]

It would be nice to hear a version that was a bit more dry. The reverb/delay at times make releases ambiguous.

[@JohnA000]

Why not include the cornet. It all depends who is playing it. I don't think it's something you can really compare. Which is a better fruit, apples or oranges.

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Maybe I’ll record a version for cornet someday. Next Tuesday, on my channel, I’m coming out with yet another version of this piece, for brass quintet…so it’ll be a little while. Lots of other things to record!

[@Lesnik2akk]

Молодец!Великолепное исполнение!

[@hedwards4599]

I love the trumpet to eternity but the flugelhorn sounds more regal and if it could speak words it would be more commanding. It's the boss but I'm glad they were both invented.

[@arcangelocurazi2473]

2:23

[@germ1770]

this is the battle of the century

[@goldskynl8041]

Ive played booth trumpet and and flugelhorn and i prefer to play flugelhorn its just more beautiful in My opinion

[@Phoenixspin]

TRUMPET for extroverts; FLUGELHORN for introverts.

[@Peter-ii4xq]

There is no worse or better. Only diiferences in character. Strange question. Excellent player by the way.

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

I’ll take that. Thanks, Peter.

[@Oh_I_Will]

Beatles “Dear Prudence” uses the F….wonder how it e would sound with a T instead? Probably wouldn’t even be noticed as it’s buried in the mix

[@kakaliac]

I like the flugelhorn best on this piece

[@twodollarboy06]

My opinion I like the Flugelhorn Version better it gives off that Mozart feel like your watching a show about Mozart.

[@smoothoscillator1]

What’s a better solo instrument? It doesn’t matter when you can play like that.

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Thank you, Smooth. (And please tell me your handle is meant to be sung like the Sade song! I sang "Smooth Oscillator" immediately.)

[@philliplipple1799]

The venue where this is played could be a factor. Big space -trumpet; Intimate space - flugel

[@Matonizz]

Agree!

[@wsmart994]

Wow

[@Matonizz]

Yep, Drew can play :)

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Hopefully, that’s not, “Wow, that’s horrible!,” haha. I’ll take it as a compliment. Thanks!

[@wsmart994]

@@TheMusicofDrewFennell i see how that was a cliffhanger. Ha ha. On a personal note my 5th grade son is learning by watching you play awesome and relaxed. He was approaching the horn like an intense online team video game battle. Tense- !!! thanks so much for sharing all the good work all of you do. Wow- awesome stuff.

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

@@wsmart994, that’s great! My daughter is in 5th grade also. Happily for me, she’s a carbon copy of me, with straighter teeth (at that age anyway). It really should be “easy.” Keep working on that! I can’t say I’m always relaxed, but it is something I endeavor to do. Best of luck!

[@LucaYSUI]

F l o o g u l l

[@milafrommanila6181]

These two instrument are almost the same sound, for me, I can’t hardly recognize each sounds. Though, they’re superb instruments.

[@waxmax001]

And now add a rotary trumpet to the comparison 😁

[@michaelshelley1289]

trumpet....so much more majestic....but i love the flugelhorn too just not the right music for it

[@trainliker100]

There is no one general answer. It depends on the piece. It can depend on one or the other might blend with or complement others in an ensemble. And then there is what the composer might have intended. The venue could even make a difference. (Are you playing jazz in a tiny coffee house or on a stage in front of 1500 people.) For THIS piece, I would absolutely vote for the trumpet. It is a "bright" piece, and the piano accompaniment is also "bright" sounding. The darker more mellow flugelhorn sound gets a little lost against the brighter piano and, to me, is not a good match for this piece.

[@gulapula]

kinda sounds like a combination of a french horn and trumpet

[@jameskalbfell1507]

Which of your kids do you love most?

[@improvisedlines5498]

why 2 different keys?

[@Matonizz]

Allows for all instrument selection and most range comfort upon performers preference :)

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

It really does sit nicely on each horn in BOTH keys. Just demo-ing the arrangement on different keys.

[@mikestang679]

It's a tie.......awesome horns...

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Thank you, mike!

[@jeffreyyoung4104]

Indoors, trumpet, outdoors, a flugelhorn!

[@zealouszucchini2043]

I never thought i would see a floating head and arms play the trumpet

[@JanMarkerink-z8i]

In the trumpetversion its like handel.

[@Matonizz]

I can see that :)

[@ashleythorpe7933]

1:58 Blüh' in Glänze dieses Glückes....

[@nebelamoebe1047]

I play the cornet so i can't really tell the diffrence anyways

[@angelmendez6638]

Fluegelhorn is better sound with rotary valves

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

I’d love to try one someday. I played a rotary C trumpet when I performed Bruckner’s 4th with the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra (a truly unforgettable experience), and I loved it!!! It felt like an extension of me.

[@xltek1]

It’s easier for me to play the trumpet in the high register, my wife likes me to play my flugelhorn because it’s easier on her ears. Go figure! Same key, different purposes.

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

Haha, the joys of trumpet playing and marriage.

[@xltek1]

@@TheMusicofDrewFennell if I sounded like you it might not be such a problem🤔😀

[@TheMusicofDrewFennell]

@@xltek1, thanks, but...it still is, haha!!!

[@felixmarques]

I think all that reverb doesn't help any of these instruments shine properly, especially the piano, which nearly always sounds better dry.

[@alexandercalder2143]

mellow is good but brassy is great

[@shakaama]

well I was looking for an example of flugelhorn playing lil nas. this is ... slightly divorced from that sound.

[@KleberebelK18]

"Different horses for different courses".

[@paulgrimm6850]

I prefer the flugelhorn .

[@furniture5223]

When the music Feels So Good, its gotta be a Flugelhorn.