McFarlane Toys CATWOMAN Batman: Knightfall DC Multiverse Action Figure Review

[@Fuzzy_Barbarian]

My favourite look for Catwoman is the slightly modified Darwyn Cooke suit (I think it was Jim Lee who slightly changed it?) that she was rocking up until like 5 years ago. It looks cool, sexy and practical, and the goggles add a lot to the look for me. There's a good reason everything used that design for so long.

[@bidhrohi12]

Todd McFarlane is a comic book artist. He started a whole comic book company. He basically started the whole artistic looking action figure that almost looked as good as statues. Why is he now tossing out this absolute trash? Marvel Select is far better in this size. NECA is a different universe. He's had enough time to develop and we can't give him a break. 6 is pretty generous for this figure.

[@collegerebel]

That's the problem with giving a person too much praise, like he got back in the 90's. People tend to get comfortable and lazy when they're not challenged. And he's probably surrounded by a bunch of "yes men", who don't challenge his decisions.

[@ew1068]

What’s bizarre is the amount of support he seems to be getting. People are going nuts over these weird looking mediocre figures. I will give him credit for some of the large characters and vehicles though.

[@Victor-mc1sz]

Comedic oversize accessories are Mcfarlane's bread and butter. From batarangs in the size of bricks to oversized canes that look like massive clubs. Once again, I really hope they lose the license because it seems like they don't give a damn about the line. Whats the point of releasing a ton of figures when a large amount of them are turds. As for your question- purple suit all the way followed by the Darwyn Cooke design.

[@collegerebel]

FINALLY, SOMEONE WHO AGREES WITH ME!🥲 Lose the license, McFarlane! And give it to Jada Toys. That company may just be the future of action figures.

[@Mattyboy-dn4oo]

I definitely agree with the critique about the figures not being able to lean forward. It’s the same problem I have with the female Marvel Legends figures. Back and side to side are good but for some reason, no range forward. So confusing

[@DabeJim]

I have a theory. Women should not move that way according to some kind-of-religious perspectiva, so toys brands do not provide the articulation as a way to self-censorship. Am I too crazy?

[@Mattyboy-dn4oo]

@@DabeJim Idk. Mcfarlane sometimes doesn't give figures with guns and Hasbro already sculpts women figures with skinny proportions. You may not be far off.

[@bigguidokc7619]

Finally, an affordable quarter scale whip for my NECA Batman Returns Catwoman!

[@daviid_ee]

I do not collect these figures anymore, but I still like to see your reviews. I feel you represent the frustration I have with this line in your videos in such a fun and sarcastic way. They've been doing this line for 3 years now and they still can fix the issues fans point out the most. They sure are aware because Todd himself pointed out that fans did not like the side eye, so they wouldn't do it anymore.

[@quintonbrooks7536]

Agreed with you on this but you think todd mcfarlane dose a better job than Marvel and neca

[@badmoonknight5009]

​@@quintonbrooks7536 no way

[@quintonbrooks7536]

@@badmoonknight5009 I mean he don't use the same mold over and over

[@badmoonknight5009]

@@quintonbrooks7536 I prefer that over this constant horrible scaling and body proportions.

[@quintonbrooks7536]

@@badmoonknight5009 true I agree but there joints gotten wacky lately hasbro

[@Daywalker1233]

The whip coiled up kind of looks like cat woman would be carrying a garden hose.

[@AnthonysCustoms]

Mhm

[@joeguido2931]

It’s called rush rush we showed pics yesterday let’s get em out tomorrow factory flaws and all. Too prolific in releases , I like dc mcfarlane but I think taking a day off wouldn’t kill them , I have this catwoman preordered and happily awaiting her but ya , she’s packin heat downstairs and could use a more pleasingly shaped body that for all its articulation can’t move all that much anyway. Mcfarlane toys has really always been a statue company and as inbox dude I wish they were all proposed w limiter movement but then I’d have mobs w pitchfork wielding nerds at my door

[@gavinsmiyh6218]

7/10 is fair rating, I like the figure but agree with all the points made.

[@theleftisttimemachine8196]

My favorite look for Catwoman is probably this one or as she was drawn by Darwin Cooke! And as far as a better figure of this version of Catwoman, I'd recommend the DC Essentials Knightfall Catwoman. It was obviously lacking in accessories as the whole line was, but it's a far better looking figure. Though, like this one, the head sculpt left a little to be desired

[@AnthonysCustoms]

I reviewed that one

[@retroboyone3577]

The wip is not actually long at all but the handle is oversized! The length is also perfect for wrapping it around enemies from a distance just like she does ! You wouldn't want to bring a short whip to a gun fight 😅😊. I'm just appalled by the heat she's packing and her makeup 😢

[@elimooremusic]

Not as good as I'd hoped, not as bad as I feared

[@jscimmortal]

A Catwoman that can teabag her villains or Batman if he’s feeling frisky.

[@rafaelvolpiteixeira7315]

The whip looks like is from a 1/6 figure 😂

[@gwenb.4179]

It looks like she's wearing an adult diaper. They destroyed the character.

[@ludwigvanbubthoven5692]

I see so much potential with this line, but it perpetually manages to fall short. It definitely needs some variety. Can't say much for Legends anymore, but it pulls from every corner of the Marvel Universe.

[@richardmardis2492]

Always so brutally honest- you put their feets to the fire, and save us our money. We’ll done, yet again 👍

[@piggyv4972]

Darwyn Cooke Catwoman is my favourite version.

[@romandodero3847]

I love the Darwin Cooke design, modern and minimalist

[@CyborgSodaCollects]

Definitely!

[@sirgnavic]

I had to take a McFarlane figure apart once, and I think I know why their figures can't really lean forward. The chest and abdominal pieces of the torso are connected by a double-ball ("dumbbell") joint. Looking at the side view, you would think that you would design this connection so that the dumbbell joint is vertical and is centered horizontally in the chest piece, but if you did that, it would collide with the space needed for the two shoulder joints. So in the chest piece, they move the socket for the dumbbell joint forward in front of the space needed for the two shoulder joints. Now the dumbbell joint is angled forward instead of being vertical. You'll have to draw a picture of the side view to properly visualize it, but the consequence of this design is the the chest piece immediately collides with the abdominal piece if you try to lean the chest forward, but there is plenty of space for the chest to lean backward.

[@AnthonysCustoms]

Yeah. That's what they do that doesn't work for sure but it can easily just not be done that way lol

[@zannusx]

Oh good a right trigger finger hand. I was worried they wouldn't give us one.

[@damagedgynoid257]

the ab crunch of mcfarlane figures and mcfarlane shares the same thing, they can't move forward to be better

[@ryboticlong5419]

This is my favorite version of Catwoman, most likely due to Jim Balent's art that was very appealing to a teenage boy in the 90s. I think I'll try to track down the DC collectibles version, though. It's definitely more accurate to the comics.

[@imnotsickler]

McFarlane has shown they can do rubber overlays that work well on top of articulation, I don't understand why they don't do this for the women. Just make the diaper and lower torso one rubber overlay, and then a chest piece as the cut. It would look a ton better.

[@graefx]

The hair bugs me too because it looks tacted on. I see the head and the mask completely separately from the hair that it looks like a wig arbitrarily stapled on. Harsh criticism aside I do like this figure and the look so she's probably going to be my main catwoman in lieu of another option. Unless I finally kitbash the ML shriek and a Jae Lee head but then there's scale issues. Lord that batman is a big lad. This might be the first figure I actually take a scalpel to, that diaper is egregious but seems easily fixable. And if the pegs are long enough, slicing straight through on the boot top will be an easy mod too. Also I've seen people spin around the ab sections on McFarlanes for better crunch. That might work for her

[@imp2247]

"That's a man, baby!"

[@jangbuttheresnobricks1256]

I like the Hush Catwoman look most personally. I wish that was the release alongside Hush Batman but oh well.

[@AnthonysCustoms]

That would've been good

[@graefx]

Separate comment for the operations of McFarlane. I genuinely think that Marvel Legends have gotten so expensive and cheap looking, that people see uniquely sculpted bigger figures with equivalent or more paint they just grab it. They're selling fairly well from what I can tell so iteration and improvement isnt as demanded. But I deeply want to know what the crunch issue is especially that they can make them lean back so far. Just 180 the insides right?

[@AnthonysCustoms]

It's very peculiar

[@graefx]

@@mellome83 I realized I had a superman here I could fool with and I'm not going to admit how long it took me to realize the issue was the upper part not the abs 🙃 this is asinine.

[@CyborgSodaCollects]

The crazy thing is...they wouldn't need to change really anything. Just the existing design of the ball joint.

[@TheMattTrakker]

Your critique on the hair is absolutely correct, but personally I like when these figures have the overdone highlights in their hair, it makes it so you can actually see it when it's on a shelf. I doubt that's why mcfarlane did it this way in this case, that'd be way too much planning.

[@nellielfan4940]

Purple Jim balent Catwoman. I have all the knight fall Catwoman figures and comics.

[@ChiefPeep]

Ain’t too bad. Still is better than 80% of Marvel Legends these days. They actually paint the figure

[@TrueBlueMajikDewd]

My favorite Catwoman comic design is Guardian of Gotham

[@jasonmckillip5936]

Catwoman hung like a duraflame log.

[@FriedSpicyChicken26]

Don't know why they didn't just referenced She-Spawn's diaper. That sculpt is perfect imo.

[@JerryGattz]

This figure just passes, and I will get since it's my favorite look for Catwoman... so that answers the question of the day. After seeing your photoshop, I hope they change up the articulation cuts in the near future because that is the biggest problem with some of these figures. Otherwise, I like them, it's still worlds better than anything we got in the 90's, but they can that much more better.

[@ghulamshaikh1124]

In a weird way I almost feel I'd rather have Hasbro, uh do the Hasbro thing with DC IPs. While I'll give it that McFarlane has a vision for the DC line, it comes with severe compromises actually adapting them in figure form because it seems what he wants is to bring characters in one very specific instance to life without ever considering engineering. I wouldn't be too thrilled about Hasbro lazily reusing the same molds over and over again for all my Batmans and Supermans, but hey, at least they'd scale well with other figures.

[@collegerebel]

Of course he doesn't consider engineering. He's been saying it for years that he hates articulation because it breaks up the sculpt. I wouldn't be surprised if he's the one actually holding the line back from being what people want. Think about it, he's at least green lighting every figure before going into production, meaning he has the last word on what goes and what doesn't. And hey, maybe I'm wrong, but its just a thought. Anyway, I agree with you on Hasbro doing their thing with DC. At least there'd be consistency. People defend McF Multiverse because there's little re-use, which is fine, but the thing is that before the 2010's superheroes were pretty much all drawn the same. They were just athletic bodies, colored in to look like they were wearing clothes, with very little in the way of detailing like stitching and only the occasional fabric wrinkles and creases. Looking at it like that, Hasbro's laziness is pretty justified in my eyes. Plus, we'd have the Avengers and Justice League in scale with each other.😁

[@LochNessHamster]

I actually love the current(?) Rebirth design. I always think of Catwoman as wearing an all black leather suit with a mask. In my mind I guess it's just a rough amalgamation of her Animated Series and Batman Returns looks. She had some costume similar to that in the 90s, but her Rebirth design really captures her as she exists in my mind. I hope McFarlane does that one next.

[@Scurwesyn]

So what you're saying is that McFarlane gave us Hush Batwoman and Knightfall Catman? 💀

[@CyborgSodaCollects]

The platinum label variant is going for stoopid money right now 😄

[@GeorgeNadaYT]

Yeah. When was it even released! I had been waiting on that one. Next thing I know it's no longer sold.

[@CyborgSodaCollects]

​@@GeorgeNadaYT people are ordering three at a time just to get the variants ha ha 😂

[@chaisrocha9853]

My fav Catwoman is the grey one from the animated series

[@metalneanderthal]

You know, a lot of these figures look fine to me until you do your photoshop comparison then I’m like “Ok! Now I see what he’s talking about!” Thank you for doing that!

[@AnthonysCustoms]

Happy to help

[@danielwesley5051]

6:14 That’s what she said

[@jakeZ79]

Did you use an exacto knife to trim the waist and torso down ?

[@AnthonysCustoms]

No. I reviewed them academy as they come. You could though for sure

[@BonesEye42]

What do you think of covering the whole torso with the diaper material? Or at least up and under the chest articulation. Maybe tighten it up. Arkham CatWoman is nice, but favorite drawn is Long Halloween, I love Tim Sales style.

[@AnthonysCustoms]

Wouldn't be good for torso articulation

[@heinzaut]

if you want the perfect knightfall catwoman get the DC Direct Knightfall Series 1 Catwoman.

[@AnthonysCustoms]

Pretty sure that's the one i reviewed

[@bee-beargaming]

This review was hilarious

[@kunonabi]

I don't like any comic design for Cat Woman. Purple one is probably my least favorite though.

[@Paragon132]

Great video as always Anthony. Odd question, I noticed you don't review mythic legions anymore- why is that?

[@AnthonysCustoms]

I never collected them. Just borrowed some from a friend. But i don't review indie figures since I'm working on my own line. Could be a perceived conflict of interest.

[@Paragon132]

@@AnthonysCustoms ahh, understandable. Thank you for the response!

[@El___Barto]

Houston: we have another catwomen...

[@RIME387]

Darwin's has removed so many heads from other figures, his collection must be gigantic at this point.

[@joelbalbowski7195]

Watching the articulation parts of ur videos. Oh my I can not wait for ur 'Street fighter 2' from jada toys review.

[@aaronmauer7225]

I have pretty much stopped collecting DC figures except for a few random ones that I can fudge in with my dcuc collection

[@JONNYSORENSEN_AU]

They sure do like ugly cuts in those figures that mess up the sculpt. Might as well have zero articulation (they dont stand, they dont do any human natural pose) and not look like trash. I liked stuff mcf did 20 years ago better than the dcu miscarriages they crank out.

[@waldensmith6384]

God I love that they all get new sculpts. But the hips and torsos need work. They all need to lean forward, and the all need to be able to kick forwards 90 degrees and do the splits. If they could make those 2 changes across the board I think the articulation would be pretty good. At least range of motion wise.

[@mikepowers9486]

I bought 3 McFarlane figures. Threw them all away. I will never buy one again. For many reasons.

[@collegerebel]

👍🏻👍🏻

[@carsons3511]

6:15 TWSS

[@coreymasoy7034]

I think it's cool ❗ my opinion 😎 and also great video 🔥💯👍

[@troubledturtle2332]

Greg Capullo version of Catwoman

[@jeeziss8563]

Moose knuckle mountain catwoman needs to go to the wax salon BAD.

[@dwrek6013]

I used a Dremel to bevel a line for a Lovely camel toe. When u actually get the figure in hand. Then judge it.

[@DPCHM0D]

Thats what I hate the most of Mcfarlane figures. They look like super articulated figures, but most of those artiiculations are useless.

[@GeorgeNadaYT]

Why is it that they can't make the figure crunch forward!😡 don't these designers and engineers play with the figures🤨

[@AnthonysCustoms]

Probably not.

[@GeezyCE]

Hasbro would've needed a Haslab for that whip

[@ItzXLnotEXCEL]

Lovely I love this

[@karascrow]

They need to redo this figure and put the torso articulation directly under the breasts, so that it looks more natural. And they should get rid of the diaper and just have the butt cheeks attached to the legs that some other higher end figures have done in the past.

[@whitezombified]

I have only bought mk11 spawn and the new classic alternate skin figure as well as the classic doom marine from McFarlane , and they're the only figures I will own because they're actually decent compared to 99% of trash they prefer to put out 🤣

[@teppest111]

Her face looks like Demi Moore from the 1990's after someone give her the wrong coffee.

[@nir24adler]

Catman 😅

[@braydenpage1808]

Are you going to review the NECA Ultimate Warrior Predator?

[@AnthonysCustoms]

I might... If i didn't yet.

[@braydenpage1808]

@@AnthonysCustoms i definitely recommend it. He has so many awesome accessories and he's just a nice NECA Predator

[@LaserPants]

Tumblr account! LOOOOOL!

[@thorgotem]

Like can we get Jada toys or someone to pick up the D C. License and give us 6 inch figs? Enough with Mcdiaperlane!

[@DanB.0]

👍

[@doctorgiovanni853]

I bloody love Anthony’s honesty and critiquing. Companies should take heed yet they do not bother. The same problems persist still. Oh well…. Enjoyed the video, mate - I will share it with my colleagues. 🤘👍 Take care, Giovanni Marino, M.D.

[@AnthonysCustoms]

Thanks a lot, doc.

[@hannahsaphire7643]

I lol’d when you asked if she was dead. I also think her hair looks insane. Why is she so ugly? Thank you for the wonderful review ❤

[@Normonaut]

Bulgewoman

[@collegerebel]

2:29 "She looks upset to be an action figure." Of course she is, she's a McFarlane toy.

[@NightWatch0997]

@1:36, not incompetence, but more leaning toward arrogance and ignorant 😂. I mean, look at the person who owns the company, he is those.

[@AnthonysCustoms]

But he's good at style and aesthetic. These aren't even that.

[@GratefulPrimate]

I HATE the McFarlane "diaper" look on all the female characters. It's very unappealing ; thankfully, DC made better versions previously

[@El_capitanazo]

Maybe Todd like female with diugh , this is the femboy versión of cat woman

[@sadmel2705]

Deflated cake = pass

[@MistyDusker]

I think the issue with her face is she has RBF. As for McFarlane Toys in general, their figures usually look so awkward and unnatural to me. The bodies look like random pieces snapped together. Maybe it's because I watch your channel but their designs set off my Spidey Sense.

[@aaronmauer7225]

The diaper looks terrible to me on this figure

[@Al-dx1mb]

I hate to say it, but I'd rather have the Marvel Legends style hips with hard plastic and semi-exposed joints than these huge, rubber granny-panties. McFarlane is the worst offender, but even some NECA figures (Universal Mummy) have terrible diaper pieces.

[@AnthonysCustoms]

the thing is they can just be trimmed down and work just fine.

[@Al-dx1mb]

@@AnthonysCustoms I agree that trimming helps around the waistline (i own this figure and I've trimmed it down). But I think trimming rubber from around the top of her thighs would make her johnson look even bigger.

[@Al-dx1mb]

@@AnthonysCustoms My bad, this Catwoman wasn't a great example. But a figure like the McFarlane 3 Jokers Clown or the NECA Mummy look more diapery because the hips and crotch get too wide and fat. I'm all for rubber diaper figures so long as the designers don't screw up the proportions.

[@FREKKI]

Because of the shape of her hair it looks like she doesn’t have a neck. Looks even worse in the promo pics.

[@hollywoodbound912]

I honestly love your honestly❤❤❤ #ihopeyourlisteningtodd

[@BlakeGildaphish76]

Why on earth did you give them your money? That figure is terrible. As a life-long Catwoman fan, i am offended.

[@AnthonysCustoms]

It's my job to review figures

[@BlakeGildaphish76]

@@AnthonysCustoms i want to be clear. i understand that this is your job. i’m not offended by your review. i enjoyed the review. The actual figure is what offended me.

[@dwrek6013]

Way too much bitc&ing in the comments for one figure. If it is so bad . Why did pre orders sell out.

[@AnthonysCustoms]

How do pre-orders indicate quality in any way? That's like saying a movie with a big opening weekend must be good. That's not how it works

[@dwrek6013]

@@AnthonysCustoms Your video acknowledges pros and cons . I said in the comment section. Great vid

[@AnthonysCustoms]

I didn't mention my video. I was responding to your comment about pre-orders.

[@sik7476]

It's nice to see that Todd made a catwoman figure for the "trans" community. 😁 Sik

[@MikeyDLooffy]

They really made this Catwoman transgender.

[@ralphyfirebird4662]

It is incompetence. I don't get how some of the folks that work in these companies continue to botch these things. It's unacceptable at this day in age. 😩👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼