MCU Expert Ranks Top 5 Marvel Deaths • Top 5 Beatdown

[@morningfaroe612]

pls the way ryan described his joy at seeing a heartbroken child be absolutely destroyed over spiderman’s death was more funny than it had a right to be

[@IsThisThePrizeIveWaitedFor]

Honestly, and I’m not a terrible person, but I’d feel the same way of a kid was being disruptive the whole movie

[@Samael767]

I am as 100% in Ryan's corner and I would have laughed when it happened.

[@Vic_the_owl92]

I mean, he was right

[@rowiel81]

I laughed wayyy too much too lool

[@leilanyx]

i was an emotional wreck and a generally nice person, but i would have been the same way. especially if it was my first viewing.

[@daxattack2862]

Every character on Shane's list he has no idea how they die, but watching the absolute joy on his face as the other two recount their deaths is the funniest shit I've ever seen 🤣🤣

[@chloelarosche9339]

“Mom and two kids in the grave. Maybe three, I don’t know I’ll have to listen to the voicemail again.” While I was screaming that he only had a son 💀

[@CrazeeAdam]

A lot of these on both Erik and Shane's list....i was like...is this not rated on impact, and like meaning? I guess not lol. And the fact Iron Man wasn't #1 on all their lists. Like I guess there's personal opinions..but idk.

[@MrMeltJr]

Shane continues to be a hipster chad on Top 5 and I'm here for it.

[@mv1420]

Erik: thoughtful analysis Ryan: these hit me emotionally Shane: i vaguely remember laughing about them 😂

[@ValentineVampyre]

shane ranks character deaths based on how glad he is that they're dead

[@calupoh9788]

I rarely relate to Shane, this video is one of those rare times lol

[@ThatsPrettyFunnyMan]

@@ValentineVampyre I dont even remember how and why Zemo's family died.

[@liviak.2901]

@@ThatsPrettyFunnyMan didn't they get killed in sokovia or something?

[@ThatsPrettyFunnyMan]

@@liviak.2901 was it shown?

[@TheATRAs14]

“What a beautiful send off, to a beautiful man” literally no one has ever said anything even remotely like this about ebony maw until now

[@BreadOmelette]

I didn't even know he had a name

[@lilleilei169]

@@BreadOmelette thats brutal😂

[@daniHellHere]

"Zemo's family" as Shane's choice killed me. Not even on screen, not even something I would consider, and rolled out by the guy who can't even remember half the deaths he chose. Yet still perfection 😆

[@kimberlywilson7929]

Shane's list was entertaining if nothing else

[@aavi.]

It's not even listed in the chapters of this video.. there's Loki, Tony Stark, and that's it😂

[@CeiliRain1]

Erik: Gory, visceral, wants to recoil at the scene of someone's demise. Ryan: Sad, impactful, wants to cry at the scene of someone's demise. Shane: Evil unfiltered chaos. Wants everyone's demise.

[@jongininikim5219]

this is the most accurate summary i've seen in the comments lol

[@Dude420Rox]

accurate af

[@jackm.7094]

Ryan’s list is the average marvel fan’s list, Erik’s is the marvel nerd’s list, and Shane’s is the psychopath list

[@johnvonraymundoguloy9632]

It's like Shane is a ghost writer for Marvel Studios for ideas for the upcoming What If episodes lmao

[@hellothere702]

@@johnvonraymundoguloy9632 honestly I need a what if zeemo won episode now

[@DancerMusicanActress]

I want to know what was going through Erik's head through the entire filming of this 🤣🤣

[@JonahStubbs]

@@hellothere702 Zemo did win

[@harleylaufeyson6136]

And here's mine being that of a Fangirl with Loki on the top

[@jonpalmer5251]

The absolute joy of Shane finding out all over again how Pietro died is pure delight. Was like second christmas for this guy

[@DapayTobias]

So we see here three different grading categories: 1. Shane: How much joy he had after watching the character's death 2. Ryan: How meaningful the death was in context 3. Eric: 💦 W E T N E S S 💦

[@pogpogpog7507]

except for ryan with the annoying kid, in which case his ranking was based solely on shane grading.

[@Nellbae]

This was amusing to me. Facts are facts🤷‍♀️

[@ellen4236]

I love that Ryan is unfazed by Shane's dream but Erik is having a moment

[@onlypondintheforest]

I love Erik's reactions to Ryan and Shane's off hand morbidness. He's just shocked then laughing and hiding behind the board a bit. 🤣

[@masha8770]

"I had a dream that I was stabbed in a parking lot" - you can see that he is fighting between laughing and wanting to interject to know wtf kind of dreams Shane is having. ^^

[@Firegen1]

Erik is too pure for it. Bless his slide board

[@Firegen1]

Yes I know he said he likes wet deaths. But truly wet deaths easily become narm if badly paced.

[@JeselleObina]

He’d love unsolved true crime

[@allie_hart]

Erik is great they're all great. I just wish I gave any fcks about anything they're talking about because these guys are so funny and endearing 😊

[@Vic_the_owl92]

The way Ryan described his joy of seeing an annoying kid cry is amazing. And he's right. You shouldn't talk at the movies.

[@WickedChild97]

If you know that your kid won’t be able to shut up during a movie- ESPECIALLY if it’s a movie you know adults will be going to see- don’t fucking take them. Rent it later and have a movie night at home or something. My husband sat us in front of a gaggle of small children when we saw NWH and it almost ruined the experience for me.

[@empac8631]

I loved the “Gene Parmesan” comment from Eric. The whole story is something I can heavily relate to. I love my step child but I won’t take her to a movie theatre until she’s about five and understands the whole concept of “sit and be quiet” Kids just can’t do that and it doesn’t help that the parent in the story didn’t seem to have regard for how big Endgame would be to some people who don’t want to listen to your kid making sound effects and talking the entire movie.

[@juliánito59]

I love it so much. People kept telling me that you'll like having kids around when you get older, I'm nearly 30 now & I'm still glad I don't have to deal with kids for the most part. Because just like in Ryan's encounter, the real monsters are them.

[@Me-dt5nd]

Time stamp plzzzz

[@agirlfrommars3441]

I remember being at IMAX which is the 3D version of a movie cinema in Australia. I was in primary (elementary) school and for half the duration of a movie a kid kept kicking my seat. It got to the point where I got up fuming and in a fuming inside voice told his mother to make him stop before I made him. Think it startled her and he didn’t dare after.

[@nonastans]

Shane and Ryan just absolutely cracking up hysterically while Erik describes Visions very traumatic death is just sending me 🤣

[@MrMeltJr]

I figure that getting your head caved in and your power source torn out is a very "wet" death for a synth. Good death overall.

[@rhiannongreen2642]

The fact they brought it up 3 times but didn't mention his gf killing him or his last words being "I love you" seemed like a miss, Shane would have found it funny at least haha

[@sinebachrenleff847]

Loki's death in Infinity War traumatized me... the neck snap, oh man, that sound is still engraved in my mind. Also the fact that it happened in the first 10 minutes of the movie was shocking. I honestly believed that Loki would be along for longer and play an important part in the fight against Thanos. It was also really heartbreaking to see Thor's reaction and hearing Thanos say "No more resurrections this time". I knew he (and Marvel) meant it and the worst part is that I tried to trick my mind for THE LONGEST time that Loki wasn't dead and somehow tricked his way out of it. But deep down, I knew it was real... Wish that they had did more with his character, but still grateful for the Loki series

[@lifeisrosyy]

but he's not dead tho right? i thought loki series meant he was resurrected

[@sinebachrenleff847]

@@lifeisrosyy in the mcu timeline, he is officially dead. In the Loki series, we see the Loki from 2012 (the New York attacker, mind controlled by Thanos) take the tesseract and escape, therefore changing the timeline. So yes, the mcu Loki from Thor: Ragnarok and Infinity War is really dead. But due to the Loki series and the branching of timelines there’s another version of Loki (TVA Loki) who’s not dead. There’s multiple timelines now, so even if the original mcu Loki is dead, there’s still a lot more of Lokis out there (as we see in the Loki series)

[@marionbaggins]

Same!!! *Starting to Tear Up*

[@Trollhe1m]

+Loki is the best Marvel character of all time

[@ANightattheOpera28]

OH SAME. I really thought they were gonna bring him back, if not by the end of the movie, then in Endgame. But NOPE. And the neck snap sound is so brutal. Like that felt PERSONAL.

[@Hannahgs]

I love how Ryan approached it as the most meaningful deaths to him and Shane is just like “I LOVED watching this character die they sucked” lol

[@blazinginferno15]

18:55 Shane talking about a dream where he was murdered, Ryan completely ignoring him, and Erik being like "WAIT WHAT???" is the kind of energy I live for

[@thesparks00]

I absolutely replayed Erik's surprise then laughter because that's the reaction I'm looking for everytime weird shit like this happens

[@trixannvillanueva1354]

He’s like “are we rly just gonna move pass that?”

[@chxrlies.angels]

Ryan is so used to it so seeing another person reacting to it was so hilarious

[@rileyedwards7202]

Ryan’s too used to his weird shit

[@kaceykace]

I mean haven't most people had something similar tho lol, I've been stabbed in the stomach in a dream...idk how I knew what that would feel like but my memory of it is something I've never felt before. I also had one where I died.. but I dont know how. It was just imagining what it was like to be dead and it was so terrifying that I woke up and cried a ton

[@alexmcdonald4248]

Ryan and Erik on their list: "So I picked this character at 3 because it was a really well-thought out scene that had a huge impact on myself and the mcu as a whole" Shane: "Yeah I hated this guy and it was funny how he died lmao"

[@Firegen1]

Shane staying true to his demonhood

[@CrazeeAdam]

I feel like Ryan was the most clear cut, like, clearly he's a huge fan and was rating them kind of impactfulness. Like he's the only one who has Tony Stark for Christ sakes xD

[@viewbuster1979]

Well, Erik also was going for max gore, illustrated best by his inclusion of Frank.

[@philip5513]

Shane actually respecting Ryan's list and being eager for his number 1 makes me feel like we're in the multiverse now.

[@carlwheezerofsouls3273]

w- what?? it makes you feel like you’re in an alternate universe? or like, you’re part of the marvel team?? im so fucking confused right now.

[@adoresbylaures]

It’s like Ryan respecting the professor…

[@satarupagingerkolay]

It's like Steven respecting Ricky in Too Many Spirits.

[@KaladinVegapunk]

It's super bizarre seeing Eric from new rockstars haha, that's the real crossover Definitely a bit cheesy but it has some good content Definitely not on par with Shane and Ryan haha, but it's bizarre seeing them on the same channel

[@KaladinVegapunk]

Also Eric laughing at Shane's shenanigans is great I immediately knew frank just because they reference that death a lot

[@jameselechko683]

Gotta say I would have put agent Coulson on the list, not high up granted but his death was so tragic. The shot of the bloody trading cards just slaps you in the face

[@lilycross9259]

I literally was waiting for someone to mention him the whole time

[@Wothi]

I was kinda sad no one mentioned it. It's one of the deaths in the MCU that I never forget.

[@sarah-jk7px]

Well technically he’s alive, so

[@chrissymacneil3811]

Yes! Thank you! Same.

[@karinaesquivel4447]

HE DIED??!?!?@*[÷*>÷×

[@HannahMcInroy]

Shane's Bucky slander was like a terrible slap across the face. That HURT.

[@babahu15]

god i know!

[@casualcruelty]

I wanted to throw up and cry.

[@whimsicalstray]

He's not entirely wrong. Being programmed into a remorseless killing machine, then coming to terms with all of it and reclaiming who you were (nearly a century later, too) can really make you a somber dude.

[@abook2141]

he was spitting

[@Luna_luz_11]

**starts to have flashbacks to all the things that led the MCU to be MCU because of Bucky** Note: reason why I said that is because of Bucky assassinating Howard Stark start it made Tony Stark the head of Stark industry, without Tony In charge of stark industry he wouldn’t have been taken hostage by the ten rings and becoming Iron man! I can go more into depth about this! 😅

[@mars_mayday]

I think Gamora's death would have been my number 1 simply because there was no honor in it. She didn't go looking for a fight, she didn't want to sacrifice herself. She was _being_ sacrificed against her will. We see the moment of awareness before it happens, we see her fight, we hear her yell "Dad!" in one last plea for mercy, and we see her unceremoniously flung off a cliff with her arms reaching out for purchase and only grabbing empty space. It was fucking brutal and yes, she's a hero, but she had FEAR. That was a gut-punch for me in theaters.

[@withintheshyness]

I agree, me and several friends where actually upset about it because we agreed with Gamora’s statement that “this isn’t love” because even if it’s a “father-daughter” relationship it’s an abusive relationship and it basically justified it because her abuser, the murder of her mother and her people “loved” her

[@mars_mayday]

@@withintheshyness YES. And god, it just makes me think of what poor Nebula has also had to go through with him and how Nebula had FINALLY gotten a healthy love with her sister and it being snatched from her by their abusive father. It makes it seem like you can never really escape the abuse you got out of. Anyway, all of that contributed to making it one HELL of a heartbreaking scene.

[@alexandravalerious3274]

in still dont think her sacrifice shouldve worked because thanos was her abuser and abusers dont love u !!!! thats just what they say to control you

[@magickalmason]

Her and black widows deaths were the least emotional and important to me, I did not care lol

[@mars_mayday]

@@magickalmason I did not ask lol

[@ShiroyashaVince]

That Part Where Ryan Explains His Experience at the theatre one with the kid that loved spiderman so much that part got me laughing af 💀💀😂

[@Mr_Yarn]

Seriously though. I was in stitches at that one. So damn funny. Of course now that kid is going to have that movie be an impactful memory for him. We've all had at least one movie from our childhood that impacted us greatly in terms of how we went forward with watching movies, or dealt with life, and Avengers: Infinity War will clearly be that movie for this kid.

[@JamesonWilde]

Not how you use af

[@ShiroyashaVince]

@@Mr_Yarn true true.

[@ShiroyashaVince]

@@JamesonWilde uhh sure.

[@marymik7372]

Ryan: these deaths affected me the most emotionally Erik: these deaths themselves were the most gory Shane: I wanted these characters dead, and they died!

[@adamageddonocalypse]

As someone who is consistently underwhelmed by Marvel movies, Shane just picking the funny ones and having NO emotional connection to these characters or this story whatsoever is the only relatable thing here

[@CrisSelene]

You're preaching to the choir. I'll never understand the craze for these movies, but to each their own.

[@CallmeOzymandias]

Yeah, I agree. There okay for entertainment sometimes, I guess. But otherwise pretty mediocre. That's just for me though, I'm not trying to shit on something people enjoy.

[@yds2m]

yeah like, for someone who has seen every single marvel movie, the raimi trilogy made me cry just by having random civilians be nice on a train whilst iron mans death did nothing to me whatsoever

[@potato5830]

Just wanted to thank all of y’all internet peeps for not shitting on opinions, really nice to see once in a while :)

[@oknowthisisepic8117]

I like how shane goes for the more comedic approach, ryan goes for the emotional deaths and erik is just there for the blood

[@BeGummi]

It's funny how well adapted Ryan is to Shane's weird antics when outsiders are clearly weirded out by his nonchalant statements. Ryan didn't miss a beat even after Shane revealed he dreamed of being stabbed. I guess Ryan always wanted that to happen one way or another. True friends indeed.

[@jayggernaught]

Erik is technically in the MCU by extension of his appearance in Good Morning America, meaning Watcher is in the MCU too. So we can say the Top 1 MCU death is The Professor's.

[@elmangosta9926]

Which is canonical. Like the many deaths in Infinity War.

[@lovaticextreme]

Shane’s list made me irrationally upset but also laughing my ass off

[@chloelarosche9339]

When I say I was screaming the whole time

[@Mr49erman85]

The amount of times I said "Shane, wtf?" through laughs was high

[@ahadbarakat9309]

True he really got on my nerves but i was laughing the whole time

[@christianatunni]

I'm still not over the "oatmeal" incident

[@_mothmansimp_]

Erik was not ready for Shane at all, a beautiful masterpiece

[@ravenb.3557]

I'm very upset that Natasha wasn't on any of their lists because, in my opinion, her death was very significant because she had to die for them to get the soul stone

[@deprofundis3293]

Agreed

[@genericspectator3094]

natasha's death is significant, but i think too many people think it shouldve been hawkeye to hold it in high regard

[@PineappleLiar]

I’ll be honest I remember seeing that scene and thinking to myself ‘Hawkeye and Black Widow, fighting for the title of Least Important Avenger by seeing who can die first’ which I’ll admit is a way too cynical take. .... but not a wrong one.

[@avleenluthra]

i know.... its very disrespectful. she gave up her life for the stone knowing she'd give up on having time with yelena.

[@burningrumm]

i would have liked to see nat too since she was my favorite character, but unfortunately natasha doesn’t resonate with a lot of people because of the somersaults they did with her in aou and the fact that she wasn’t given her own movie until after she died.

[@rahul.srinivas]

Ever since the Pixar beatdown, I guess Shane deliberately curates his list just to rile up Ryan😂

[@cassie2561]

This is extremely possible

[@SetFireGirl]

Oh the deliberate way he riles up Ryan has been going on for MUCH longer than that ...

[@Whateverworksman93]

Erik looking around like "are we not going to address what Shane just said" at 18:57 really got me

[@corvidae2741]

I love Shane's energy in this one. Very casual and irreverent.

[@AC-pm3mc]

Idk I felt very disturbed by his choices lol 😂

[@kathleenburns7085]

My favorite part of this whole video is when Shane casually mentioned having a dream about being stabbed and Eric did a double take like he didn’t know whether to laugh or be horrified and Ryan just kept talking like nothing happened

[@alli1222]

I love how they all ranked them differently. Erik ranked his through thoughtful analysis, Ryan ranked them based on what hit him emotionally, and then there’s Shane who ranked his based on what he remembers made him laugh

[@steventhefan]

The reveal of “Zemo’s Family” was one of the funniest things I’ve seen in a long time

[@kat_impossible]

All of Ryan's picks were the emotional and meaningful ones, whereas Shane was just like "which death was the most fun and satisfying for me" haha love it!

[@claska333]

Eric is literally me laughing after Shane just drops “I had a dream once where I got stabbed in a parking garage.”

[@danielamaro4554]

What's funny is he called it a dream and not a nightmare 🤔

[@idontevenknow628]

19:00 I love how Ryan gave no reaction to Shane telling about his dream. Dude really went ”i once had a dream I was stabbed to death” and Ryan goes on with his thing.

[@rukhsaryazmin7144]

Eric: Analytical and thorough Ryan: These made me cry but also I got revenge on a child Shane: confused video for 'funniest MCU deaths'

[@kuraisaurus]

I was not expecting a Watcher/New Rockstars crossover, but I'll take it 😅

[@reene_the_mess]

Me neither and i love it!!!

[@NitroGummyBear]

For real! I love Eric

[@helenejapa]

Me neither, but I am here for it.

[@ervinandreicabrera]

They gotta bring erik to puppet history

[@thejennadiaries]

Shane’s “oh I forgot he died” absolutely killed me 🤣🤣

[@notthis.mp3]

seeing Erik Voss react in real time to the sheer chaos of ryan and Shane is immensely joyful to me

[@theflutefreak]

Ryan: how emotionally impactful it was Erik: how gruesome it was Shane: how much I disliked them as a person

[@EpilepticLobster]

My favourite death was black widow's, the whole sequence of her and hawkeye doing acrobatics while tryna save the other and kill themselves was so hilarious to me

[@kodomoshawn6729]

18:53 Shane: "I guess I'd rather have my neck snapped than some other ways, I had a dream I was stabbed in a parking lot." Erik, quietly concerned and unsure what to do with that information: "what?" Ryan: proceeds to ignore that and go right into making fun of Shane's head.

[@hannahmorgan644]

The way that each of them picked completely different routes on how the deaths ended up on their lists just makes this so much better

[@yanniesays]

I like Shane's list. When watching action movies, I always think about the deaths of minor characters, the collateral damages, the civilians--the "insignificant" deaths. It might not be Shane's point, but those deaths, for me, should impact the main characters.

[@harmonytyndall1747]

I feel like Shane's list is the list of wives who aren't into the MCU but get stuck watching everything about it lolol

[@MeredithHagan]

DISCLAIMER: RYAN IS NOT A MONSTER I’m so with Ryan with his story. This is hilarious.

[@KrisTheNinth]

I'm actually obsessed with Shane's #1 (and Erik's #4) pick because it really made me wonder how many fridged mothers and wives get treated as disposable with almost no reverence or respect in their deaths. There are obviously exceptions like Natasha and Gamora, but I'm interested in why these picks were mostly male characters in big impactful scenes. Though, not all their picks were for plot or emotional impact reasons (the commitment to everyone choosing some hilarious picks was amazing). I guess it could just be statistically more likely because the genre is still so male-dominated, but it'd be interesting to do analysis on...

[@deprofundis3293]

Interesting point. I want to also add that it was strange to me that neither Gamora nor Natasha were mentioned here. It's not a serious analysis, though, so I totally get that. But I guess I felt like both of their deaths were just....I don't know...barely recognized at all in the film. Especially disturbing were the abusive undertones with Thanos and the implication that he DID love Gamora. Sorry, but you don't kill someone if you truly love them. That depiction really bothered me.

[@PineappleLiar]

So as far as female character deaths in the MCU there are two major variants: unimportant offscreen and plot contrivance cul de sac. Trying to write out why with all the particulars though just makes me realize more that I hate they made a while planet whose sole purpose was to kill off important female characters, and have their deaths contribute to the progression of the plot in the most shallow way possible. Sure, you can say ‘well Natasha made the decision to sacrifice herself over Hawkeye’ but maybe…. Just a thought…. The heroes do what Thanos refuses to consider and decide that no one has to die. Or just anything besides the almost comical fight to see who could take a long fall with a short stop first. It’s not a character decision it’s a fucking toll booth that says ‘pay 1 major character in order to pass’.

[@blairreyes1542]

Ryan resisting telling the kid the reason spiderman died was because the kid was talking in the movie is some next level restraint.

[@daesgatling1345]

Right? Cause I'd have done it just to spite the shit parents

[@AJ-fd2ph]

I think Natasha's death would definitely be on my list, probably 2nd or 3rd. The emotion, the finality of her story and her arc, the fight with Hawkeye, it was heartbreaking and amazing and it still makes me cry

[@baka9466]

I just love Shane's joy at their deaths. I also respect that he didn't actually care about the manner of deaths but rather how they made him feel :)

[@laurenragle5228]

Shane's love of Zemo is precious and so expected. 😂 Poor Erik with his deep logic and understanding. I had completely forgotten about Frank!

[@sydneybooth260]

Coming back after Ryan had an actual cameo in a marvel movie with his wife 😮❤

[@StopMotionDryptosaurus]

I said, “Is that Ryan Bergara?” in the theater when he showed up.

[@sierracascade00]

Once again Shane’s list giving off the most chaotic energy

[@sarajerde8280]

Shane always has the weirdest justifications for honestly pretty much anything he says. if it's off the wall, you know there's gonna be a good reason behind it. It's something I look forward to

[@Guy-zf5of]

Because I have butterflies in my freezer

[@naneesther1540]

Ryan in Shanes show: learns a whole script for Professors death Shane in Ryan show ranking deaths: this is my number two... wait how did he die?

[@ProPhile]

Ryan is definitely a workaholic trying to give off slacker vibes…

[@sierra4766]

Not only did he learn the whole script he played that shit for 4 seasons and Shane's like I just did this in the parking lot before I came in😂😂😂

[@billiep1603]

As a marvel stan this is hilarious. Shane essentially being a Zemo stan is the best

[@nocte8807]

I really like this dude. Would love to see him again on the show in the future. Maybe best super heros of all time 👀

[@verse1167]

Ryan’s list is the most perfect list of a list that ever listed

[@malcolmmcleary2678]

I usually side with Shane, but his list was bullshit. Ryan's all the way!

[@madisoncombs5725]

The fact that Agent Colson's death wasn't on one of their lists hurts me in ways I didn't know could hurt

[@happyviruslulu]

But he didn't die right?

[@Chicoshy]

@@happyviruslulu watch avengers

[@rochchan4145]

@@happyviruslulu yes but also no

[@vickyy3531]

@@Chicoshy have you watch agents of shields?

[@Shalovesgod]

I cried the first few times I watched The Avengers because of Phil’s death

[@ClaireKat77]

I’m so happy to see Yondu get mentioned, I cried so hard at his death.

[@cgiraffs]

Props to Shane, i never expected Zemo's Family to place anywhere on the lists.

[@absinthespoons]

I love how everyone treated this prompt as a completely different assignment. Erik seemed to treat it like Dead Meat Kill Count's Golden Chainsaw Award, Ryan seemed to treat it as the most emotionally affecting deaths (tbh I assumed this was the prompt), and Shane treated it like... deaths that he was the most glad about, or tickled by. All of which I respect tremendously, except Ryan's because I do not find the MCU to be emotionally affecting, ever. Also as someone who hasn't watched a Marvel property since Winter Soldier (and not many before that either), it's a mark of how much I love the boys that I watched this despite the inevitable frequency of me going "who the fuck is that".

[@winchesterdean]

I love how popular you guys are on tumblr and shane still is brave enough to say he hates bucky

[@mj7087]

Haha on the flip side he made the small but mighty Zemo-heads very happy

[@kanemoss4235]

I’m surprised Black Widow didn’t make anyone’s list. When she was Vormir with Hawkeye was one of the most badass deaths scenes there are

[@a.m.5541]

it was because hers was so poorly done there was no sense of finality. It seemed like she was coming back towards the end

[@SweetNothing937]

Also the fighting took away from the emotional impact it should’ve had

[@gracehowell.]

"Nothing brings friends closer together than MURDER." As an Agatha Christie fan, especially of the Marple and Poirot stories, can confirm that close friendships are formed when someone is murdered. You kinda expect the opposite.

[@Red_Ghost85]

I’m surprised that nobody listed Gamora. Her death had so many emotional effects on the other members of the Guardians, and even Thanos himself. Also, I almost listed Pietro on my list as well, but only because I live the comic character of Quicksilver so much and it was so disappointing to see him killed off without getting anywhere close to his comic book self.

[@kkrypt0nite]

not only gamora but natasha and the ancient one too

[@rowni]

I never expected these three to collab but i am so darn happy. New rockstars and Buzzfeed bois are literally some of my most watched creators in the recent years

[@gabrielaestrada1631]

I love Shanes take on the mcu, he just listed the funniest deaths and didnt remember half of the movies "Oh yeah tony Stark, I forgot he died" was so good 😂

[@Railuki]

See, I think Vision's death is one of the best. I don't mean when his body dies. I mean in Wandavision when he "dies" to Wanda. I know that isn't death in the sense of life leaving his body. But he had the embodiment of Vision's soul, even if it was made from Wanda's magic. Wanda letting go of that, plus 2 kids, that's huge and impactful and shows that you can't let your grief hurt other people too.

[@rachelhansen2417]

Fully agree. That one makes my top 5 for sure.

[@infinity-ville]

Erik’s like “are we not gonna touch on Shane’s bizarre dream?”

[@SetFireGirl]

Support group for Erik and Ricky the bartender from Too Many Spirits for having to put up with these chaotic assholes

[@FranVianzon]

It's so weird seeing Erik outside of the blue dungeon. Finally getting the recognition he deserves

[@Austin3859]

Dude it’s so weird seeing Erik on a channel other than new rockstars and with Ryan and Shane at that! It’s so fucking weird

[@singinsanity]

I was hesitant until I saw who they chose as their MCU expert & I was very relieved to see Mr Voss! The mashup I never knew I needed.

[@emilyraggett1581]

I knew as soon as I saw that still of Ryan and Shane laughing with ‘vision’ on the board that it was gonna be MCU deaths 🤣🤣🤣

[@emilyraggett1581]

My Shaniac heart is kinda broken by Shane saying he doesn’t like Bucky though 😂😭

[@emilyraggett1581]

But actually his love for Zemo has restored it 🤣

[@everythingdibs344]

@@emilyraggett1581 I kinda agree with him. Bucky is a sad character but he borders the line between boring and serious a lot.

[@ErieMaxwell]

@@emilyraggett1581 Honestly, I kind of agree with him, at least considering they weren't including shows. I think Bucky has a ton of potential and I love him in the comics, but the movies don't really DO anything with him personality-wise, at least not yet. Maybe they will in the next stage of films though!

[@impatientjones1617]

So glad this season is in person, there's a ridiculous magic that happens when Shane and Ryan are in the same room

[@rainbowgeek3284]

Ryan’s story about the kid seeing Peter die was so hilarious

[@DaniMol]

One of the most incredible acting moments in the entire MCU is right after Spiderman dies and Tony Stark looks away, distraught, unable to process what just happened, and he begins to wipe his hands clean of Peter's ashes and then looks down in horror at what he's done. What a brutal, tiny moment that shows how Tony's brain hasn't processed what is going on and then everything hits him at once. What a mindfuck, and what an outstanding performance by Robert Downey Jr.

[@lillydav10]

This is like an MCU event! Three of my favourite KZbinrs coming together 😃

[@aandyy4791]

Ryan’s story about the lil kid in the theatre had me in tears. 😭😂 It’s both so sad and so funny. And hey, my first thought when they were talking about why didn’t the parent(s) tell their kid to be quiet? I’d be willing to bet that kid has probably been obsessed with Spider-man for a while now, and he’s probably just as loud and excited about it at home. That parent might’ve been sitting back laughing about their kid’s reaction as much as Ryan was. 😂😂

[@ihaveaquestion3962]

"Tony Stark...oh I forgot he died" THE DISRESPECT. I got mad at myself for cackling at that lmfao

[@ipshitakanungo3025]

Ryan laughing as the kid's crying over spider man's death is the best image I had on my mind lately

[@Helloitsame123]

Shane's list was impeccable, absolutely perfect

[@izzybella9196]

I find it really funny how at 19:00 when Shane is talking about being stabbed in a dream and Erik is just in complete shock and confusion while Ryan is just continuing on like normal lol

[@camilaviana1196]

I love that most of this episode is Erik discovering how chaotic Ryan and Shane are😂😂

[@firequeen9018]

I really became endeared to vision in wandavision. We get to know so much more about his character, his goofiness, and his compassion. Love him a ton now, hope Wanda can get him back

[@andreabrooks3337]

I'm super surprised that Erik didn't have that flagsmasher Nico who got violently merced by John Walker on his list cause that was a hella wet death! That being said, Erik is a joy and I really hope he comes back in some following projects.

[@mztatin955]

That death was definitely on my list. I don't think there's a death that was motivated by pure hatred in the MCU till that one and to see the blood on the shield..... brutal. My mouth was open in shock when I saw that. Spiderman in no way home seemed like he was about that life but thankfully he was talked down.

[@sebastian4792]

Love new rockstar, this is the collab I never thought I needed !

[@KL-qp6yo]

Shane's chaotic energy brings me such joy.

[@nerdygal6133]

Ryan’s story about that kid in the theatre should not have been as funny as it was. I feel really terrible for laughing. 🤣

[@DieFluchendeHexe]

Would love to watch Ryan and Shane play the Hunt a Killer game. Seems really interesting. I laughed way too hard at the child watching Spider Man story. Had tears rolling down my face.

[@turner15]

Yeah

[@soll_sor]

Yesssss

[@amandalee1639]

after seeing the photo of "vision" it was either going to be marvel or ranking the 5 senses (which would be interesting)

[@user-rf2iu3wo9u]

Omg I wish they would make them rank the five senses that’s such a funny idea

[@perishonimpact]

ERIK VOSS!! I used to watch all of his breakdowns of GoT episodes! I love this collaboration!!

[@RaVi-bh7vm]

Happy to see Voss, Ryan, and Shane together. My three favorite people in yt. This is a NWH level of crossover HAHAHAH

[@sparkfadingspark]

Shane remains as chaotic as ever with his list 😂😂😂 As someone who loves the MCU and enjoys Eric and New Rockstars, I literally couldn't have asked for a more perfect return to Top 5 Beatdown

[@nadismolina]

seeing ryan laugh at a 7 year old crying just saved 2022

[@justhanginout420]

a new season of top five beatdown is exactly what i need to get through the winter

[@sofirvalle]

i read somewhere that peter parker felt the entire 'dusting' bc of his spidey-sense, so he felt the pain and that's why he was telling tony he didn't wanna go, while the rest of the people who got snapped just left '´peacefully' and I'm not the same since then idk if it actually makes sense, but is still a sad concept

[@sophianotsofia]

Everyone's saying Shane's list is chaotic, but it makes a lot of sense and I agree