SO MANY COMPARISONS! Plus More // ABH ICED OUT // Brow Freeze

[@ilenochka74]

The highlight looks pretty on you, but I'm not convinced that it's universally flattering.

[@annealbaugh919]

Agree Mel looks stunning in everything , but not sure it would work on me uggg

[@ShannonP1307]

Hey gorgeous lady!!! I absolutely love your hair like this, you're making me want bangs again lol! The colour of your hair is so so pretty!!!

[@melthompson2856]

Thank you so much 😍😍😍

[@lindapassos]

I still regret daily not getting the Amrezy one 💔😭😭😭

[@renthehag]

I have the Amrezy highlighter and theBalm’s dupe and honestly, theBalm’s Mary Lou-Manizer is such a close match that you can’t really tell the difference, especially if you spray a touch of setting spray on your face before you apply it. I almost regret getting the Amrezy one bc there is NO way that I’m gonna use it up in a whole year 😂

[@teresabrewer903]

ME TOOOOOO🥺😕😔

[@ma-ma-mamary3946]

Same

[@lindapassos]

@@renthehag that's great to know cause I have the TheBalm one ☺️ Thank you 😄

[@toggomusic]

MAC Extra Dimension Skinfinish in the shade Whisper of Gilt is basically the same as ABH, a light gold shade with the same gel powder formula! It's very nice and smooth on the skin.

[@LorraineParis1]

Oh my gosh, I’m dating myself but I just realized Mel you remind me of Demi Moore when she played in movie Ghost with Patrick Swayse with your bangs and dark hair!!

[@monicayang6414]

This eye look is EVERYTHING! I love how simple and fresh it look.

[@TheEAndrik]

The color reminds me of the white shade in the abh Jackie aina palette

[@gabbysoto04]

I am so happy that ABH took some time to come out with exiting new stuff. They were releasing a lot of palettes 🎨 and were getting a little overwhelming and nit so great quality. They needed yo wait and come out with a 🥊 punch

[@kaylynnhuddleston5533]

SILL WATCHING YOU MEL !!!! I WONT STOP !!!

[@skysbeauty3369]

I LOVE YOUR HAIR LIKE THIS! THE DARK HAIR IS SO STUNNING ON YOU NAKED YOUR EYES POP SO MUCH! BEAUTIFUL AS ALWAYS

[@melthompson2856]

Thank you so much 💋🥰💕

[@krystaleverett5197]

I know! So chic!!

[@HeatherTerry84]

I agree! The dark hair on her is absolutely gorgeous!

[@LMDinNC]

Just wanted to take a moment to say I appreciate how many videos you have been producing! Getting ready with you always lifts my mood.

[@melthompson2856]

Thank you! I appreciate you so much for being here to watch them ❤️❤️❤️

[@EricaConger]

Your hair is just perfection! I’m getting my hair done today and I may just have to tell her... give me “the Mel”. 💕 Just sat down with my coffee and I’m so happy to have you starting off my day. Have a wonderful weekend, beautiful Mel!🥰

[@karacop4093]

You are stunning and such a gem. I just discovered your channel and have been binge watching since. Just love everything about you ❤️

[@melthompson2856]

Thank you for such kind words! It really lifts my mood 🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@chelleyrenee]

It’s so funny how the benefit keeps your brows up all day but for me it isn’t strong enough. I love the Anastasia clear brow gel the most, or just using soap.

[@faceface9996]

Same

[@shellyflowers3787]

Same benefit doesn’t work at all for me. I use the Patrick ta one but want to try the abh one.

[@mrsfox4274]

None work that great for me 😔

[@lauries2757]

I just got the ABH brow gel. I’ve used it twice and I already love it 😍

[@nellieloves]

The Pat Mcgrath fine gold looks really similar. Thank your daughter for the lovely swatches, missed seeing her beautiful face this time!

[@Strawberryfearsforever]

I feel like I actually would’ve loved an unique Smokey cool toned eyeshadow palette with this collection. As long as it wasn’t followed by 50-11 more.

[@kellycann50]

I love your videos! You are so honest and I just absolutely love how you put your videos together. You’re my #1💋💕

[@constancemurphy6230]

How do you do it? No matter how you wear your hair or wigs, or any color you look spectacular. I love love love this look with the bangs.

[@louselman]

The hair, the makeup, absolute perfection 😍😍😍

[@yolandabarrera7532]

Mel you look so pretty! Just like Demi Moore in the movie Ghost! And yep I wanna be in the giveaway :) [e-mail] and the closest I think is the shadow from Pat McGrath mothership V ... however I think one form Dior Backstage palette would be closer

[@melthompson2856]

Thank you!!!! ❤️❤️❤️

[@bobbiobanion7706]

She does, I was wondering who she reminded me of.

[@user-tm6ij6gx7r]

Omg yes Demi Moore in ghost holy shit she does! How beautiful Mel girl!!! ♥️♥️♥️

[@Tiffany24117]

@@melthompson2856 Hi Mel I was looking for reviews about careprost & this person has your face in their video & i was thinking maybe they are trying to scam so was wondering if u know about your face being in this video. Here's the link kzbin.info/www/bejne/m5ulc3iAgcl5sLs

[@MalenaAlison]

I’m so glad you reviewed the brow freeze! I am in love with the benefit brow setter because of your recommendation! Thanks for saving me the $23 from buying the ABH one 🙂

[@celestecelestial90]

You got a lot of highlighters! That hairstyle suits you well. You look lovely! I ordered this highlighter and it’s on the way, but I’m not sure if I want to keep it.

[@ladycarizza47]

I’m totally getting Demi Moore vibes right now. Seriously you look stunning no matter what you wear or do 😍 thanks for the review, I do not think this will flatter me though, I’m an NW40 and have a very warm, golden skin tone so I’m nervous this will look too light

[@oliviah1561]

I’m so glad you compared double gleam, I have it already and was wondering how similar they’d be! Added it to my cart 😊

[@EstelleDiary]

Couldn't wait for your review on this !!! Thank you so much Mel

[@sharone7479]

Hi Mel, You always look stunning. I am loving the bang look on you. They still give you that edgy look you always have, just a little softer. I wear bangs too, but mine don’t look as good as yours. Also, loving the eye look. I tried using my Benefit brow gel, like you, before going in with a pencil or powder and I couldn’t get the products to adhere. You’re like a magic genie with make-up! 😀😀😀

[@mallorys4524]

The elf retro paradise highlighter is surprisingly close to the new highlighter!

[@julieaversa4657]

I was surprised at how dark it really is.

[@cherylmaclean4349]

I was so privileged to be in a Zoom meet with THE Anastasia on Saturday morning that was organized by my daughter’s law professor as a women’s empowerment meet that she organizes every month. She goes to school in Malibu so professors have so many connections. The entire time I just kept thinking, Oh my God, this is Anastasia!!” Plus, I love the Brow Wiz. I have terrible brows that face down.

[@annemunoz4407]

I just got my Kitten and Beauty last night. I love them. I definitely want smooches now too. The formula is so nice, and the colors are everything.

[@WVUGRL24]

Not sure if you have Becca’s Vanilla Quartz highlight, but that’s the one I thought of besides Albatross once I finally saw it swatched. And as you were swatching, I started to wonder also about the lighter highlight in the other Dior quad - the one with that peachy shade you love. Too bad I missed your poll asking for comparisons!!

[@lesliedupre4357]

Your hair looks fantastic!! Love it!!💕

[@brennankubica7534]

I haven't been this obsessed with a makeup launch in a while - the packaging the icy aesthetic

[@ashleyfutey5480]

I bought the brow freeze a couple days ago and haven’t opened it yet because I wanted to use up my beloved brow setter..... looks like I’m making a return 🙈 love your videos!

[@ingainge3146]

I love how honest you are😍

[@stacyechelberger]

When I saw this highlighter, I was super excited. I thought, “finally an icy white highlighter for my crazy pale/cool self.” I lusted after Amrezy but I knew it would be super dark for me. But, it still looks like this one is not for me too. We want Amrezy for the ghosts!

[@johannahoneyman697]

I 100% agree with you about the Benefit brow gel - it’s the BEST 🖤

[@shaunnashandro]

Love your hair!! It looks like it has a deep purple sheen in my TV screen and it’s gorgeous!!! 🥰

[@nadiadncr]

Looking so gorgeous Mel I love your hair styled like that. Great review and video 💕 I have dry skin so I’m not interested in the highlighter I’ve been loving the YSL all over powder based on your recommendation 😘

[@JustBec2122]

It’s funny how formula can make a difference on what you can wear even when the shades are similar. Champagne pop and Amrezy looked so similar next to each other but I feel like Champagne Pop is too dark on me but I can wear the Amrezy and it’s one of my faves!

[@Diva2themax]

It's too dark for me too. CP has a peachy undertone Amrezy is more of a neutral golden champagne. Love it.

[@theresah6126]

Omg! I can't wait to see these comparisons! I ordered this! 😁🤗😍

[@veraz1888]

fenty moon metal, artist couture gold digger, give me glow halo are similar shades as well but in diffrent textures…i believe kvd used to have one anniversary version that is similar shade wise. I'm a huge lover of these white gold highlight😍

[@ginanord9327]

I LOVE your eye looks with the Juicy palette! I just purchased it, I would LOVE a video with 3 looks I could copy. You're a master with choosing and blending colors, please help a gal out!

[@ShayMcArdle-101]

That highlight looks gorgeous on you ✨ I haven’t tried these yet I wish it was the same formula as Amerezy 🥺 I’m upset 😭 that you don’t think 🤔 it’ll work on fair skin but I didn’t think 💭 Amerezy would work for me but does if used lightly... I used to LOVE double gleam too‼️😩those were the days💯‼️

[@jamaica72001]

Thank you for testing the brow gel. None of them hold mine including the Benefit.. which I will say is the most effective of all of them. But I'm still looking for my holy grail! so it was great that you tested this. I appreciate it! :)

[@kittycloud6693]

Loved the swatch fest. I thought the highlighter was gonna be more white and frosty. I was curious how it compares to the ofra ones

[@irinawoods]

Pat's Fine Gold is the closest dupe in my opinion. And I'd still try the brow gel even you didn't like it. I like more "messy" brow styling rather than neatly groomed, I guess this product should work perfect for that.

[@annagtz80]

I don’t have the ABH iced out highlighter but looking at the shade it looks very similar to Becca Vanilla Quartz.

[@katietomblin6823]

Yes! I was looking to see if anyone mentioned this one. I definitely think nars albatross and Becca vanilla quartz are going to be very similar.

[@FloatingSpark]

It's so hard to tell without seeing them in person, but I guess the Pat McGrath gold from the trio palette looks closest? I am pretty excited about this launch too, Amrezy is one of my true loves as well 💖 Insta: FloatingSpark

[@prettyinspireddecor6787]

No, it is not just you who is excited. Looking forward to this video!

[@MyNewObsession2017]

I love the comparison! Enter me!! I think Marshmallow was pretty close! I also thought the PML highlight was pretty close.

[@TheKaseyfelker01]

You are spoiling us with so many uploads ❤️

[@lorrainemallory6951]

How do you think it compares to kaleidos solar surfer? The white to gold/yellow kinda reminds me of it...

[@FreudianOne]

Do you think the Iced Out is really close to MAC Vanilla pigment? Probably not as pink now that I think about it...more green. Either way, I like it more than my Amrezy.

[@chrissymoss514]

Well I've had my Amrezy a lot longer than 9 months and it's perfectly fine ..... so I ain't throwing it out 😉! I had to check what was on your eyes (because I love the eye look) and I'm so happy to see it was the Tartelette Juicy palette. I watched Tara's review of it today and so, because of you and Tara, I've just orded it. 💗🌸💗🌸💗

[@melthompson2856]

Heck no! I’m not gonna throw mine out either LOL I’ll just scrape off the top a little bit and plus, I have a back up LOL

[@michadawn234]

Love the hair!!!! The marshmallow one from ABH

[@valerievalois6263]

Good morning Miss Mel, you already know how beautiful I think you look, I told you yesterday😜 I do have a question unrelated to this video. I have been playing non stop with the tarte juicy palette since you recommended it and I love it and you were so right to call it the Aspyn Ovard extended, but I do miss Santorini Sands like crazy. Is there any single eyeshadow in MAC, Sydney Grace or Makeup Forever that could almost dupe it? Hell, at this point I would buy an entire palette just for a dupe of Santorini Sands! If anyone at Sydney Grace is reading this, please oh please do one 🙏

[@melthompson2856]

I have been looking and looking but I haven’t found one. I’ll keep looking though. 😍

[@valerievalois6263]

@@melthompson2856 Get Sydney Grace to do one 🤩

[@elvilopez7910]

Hi Mel, yeah the brow freeze didn't wow me. I have better luck with the Benefit 24 hour setter. The highlighter was okay, at first I was not too happy about the slight greenish under tone but like you said, it's okay but not my favorite. I have soo many highlighters that if I wanted to I could go 2 months without grabbing the same one (yes, I have too many, but recently gave some away so I feel slightly better lol 😆 😅) I need the pandemic to end so I can go back to work in the office and use my makeup. Also, I don't use clear gloss and would never pay 20+ for one. My daughter loves the ELF 3 dollar clear gloss and I always stock her up during a Ulta sale lol 😆

[@BeautyBeeBilly]

I doubt you'll see this, but the KKW Beauty Glitz & Glam palette has a shade in it that swatches nearly identical to the highlight. It's called Moonlight Glow. Just wanted to tell you. Also, love your content. I watch every night when I can't sleep. 🥰

[@sarahroot3650]

Are you going to be reviewing the mini Love palette? I always like to hear what you think!!

[@TheJalebe73]

Ooof! Now I want that milk iced highlighter....beautiful texture.

[@melthompson2856]

Yes! Those are definitely underrated 😍

[@starshine311]

Same!

[@lacondesalatina]

How are you? I haven't really been there for you and I need to apologize for not doing my share on supporting your channel lately. I pray that others have been making up for it. You're a sweetheart and you need to be told more often. Even my 7 yr old granddaughter and 4 yr old grandson think you're great. Hugs from Florida, Latina 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜 and Julio

[@os5634]

Gorgeous as always but definitely loving your whole look today!

[@karenp3278]

Can we just talk about how adorable your hair looks today!😍

[@mariannam3100]

The most exciting thing about this was the clear gloss!! Been on the hunt for one because elfs is so cheap and sticky. Torn between this abh one or fenty hmmmm

[@evapolichroni5129]

You are stunning🥰. I wish Amrezy was available again😭

[@mzmerryweather]

I am such a sucker for highlighters...yet with a green/yellow undertone I have to be careful as I have blue/pink skin undertones. Sigh. Well, as I say, if it doesn't work on my face the eyes will definitely benefit. Thank you for the comparisons Mel ;)

[@kenybarbie3131]

thank you Mel for testing this ABH brow gel because benefit test on animals! ABH not!!! and for us who buy only cruelty free it would be a great option❤️

[@tiffanykaicedo4305]

Could you do a video on your favorite highlighter formulas?

[@angielott83]

It seems most similar to the other ABH shade from the glow kit lol! I wonder how close Iced Out is to Becca LE “Pearl flashes gold”..... I have it, I’ll have to give it a swatch! 😍

[@GlitzyFritzy]

On to the next LOL seriously I only watched to support ya I don't care about that highlighter BUT dang my brow freeze isn't here yet and now I'm wondering! I mean I already had a concern because it doesn't have the applicator and that's really a part of why I love Benefit. I guess we shall see LOL Love you!

[@ra.j7210]

Thanks for comparing the highlight with patmcgrath bronze seduction mel. Love you for listening xx

[@justinejustice_league1857]

This new ABH highlighter is a spot on dupe for a shade in Pat Mcgraths sublime skin highlighter pallete, the middle shade. If you have that pallete you dont need this one. This will work on deep skins and is a transformative highlighter ❤

[@melthompson2856]

They are super similar but the PM has more shift and is far smoother . Also, a bit more Opaque. (You can really see it in the swatches at the end) I do think this will be so gorgeous on richer complexions 😍

[@justinejustice_league1857]

@@melthompson2856 i do agree with the textures, Pats is otherworldly smoother. And the ABH highlighter has definitely a "dryer" feel to it, something to note. They are so close in how they translate on the skin. And the rose gold highligher by Dior was my next close comparison as well but it is lighter. ❤ good video! Thanks mel. I got this wanting to get the Amerzy feel i missed out on but nope! Not the same😭😭😭

[@melthompson2856]

@@justinejustice_league1857 mother pat is queen 😍 and wish ABH would bring back the amrezy 😭 this highlight would have been so good in that texture as well. That would have been amazing 🙌🏻 I appreciate you watching!!! I hope you have an amazing day ❤️❤️❤️

[@lialongtime1156]

I knew I could rely on you for a good review on the abh freeze. I have the same issue, my brow hair must be like yours. Try the got 2 be glued hair gel. Sooo cheap with soooo much more product. I squeezed some into my old benefit gel container. Just as good if not better.

[@jenneymurphy5751]

I put Albatross next to ABH and they are close but ABH is way more glittery.

[@jamanewman3157]

So I bought the brow freeze the day it launched on Sephora it's okay but I won't be using it much because it takes time and that's something I don't have when doing my makeup usually LOL I don't know if I didn't use enough but it left a white residue after a while so maybe I blended too much while it was dry or didn't use enough I don't know but yesterday I use the clear brow gel which I don't usually use and I actually like that a little bit more LOL so I'll just have to keep playing with brow freeze to see what works for me.... Didn't get the highlighter because I have the sugar glow kit and there is a shade that looks almost identical to that so I didn't think I needed it.. Plus i have amrezy highlight!! I just don't like how yellow the new one looked... 💗💋💗

[@pattiboudreaux8720]

Again I LOVE you with bangs!

[@sambricker2234]

I’m loving this hair style on you! I wish I had the guts to cut my hair like this. I usually keep it short but have never gone this short. Maybe one day lol.

[@CTcatfur]

Love the bangs girlie!

[@melthompson2856]

Thank you 💋💋💋

[@faceface9996]

Omg the hair is perfect!

[@kellynicole3672]

Thanks for being honest about this highlighter I was thinking about buying it I really thought since the Amerezy highlighter was such a success that Anastasia would use a similar formula and color? Oh well I’ll stick with my Amerezy and cookie highlighter! 🙏💗

[@wildeliseortiz4734]

Lunar beauty is pretty spot on!! I might grab that one instead 🤔

[@wildeliseortiz4734]

I got confused. I think Pat McGrath is!

[@AndreaM1127]

Mel Thompson, you will be missed 😢😢 R.I.P. 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@beatrixpo1956]

I Suspect? That after the top and ridgey parts blend away the formula will be a bit more Gelee.. maybe? I rubbed my finger down quite a bit on a corner and it did get creamier

[@simplypearlbeauty]

hi mel, i appreciate the amrezy highlighter more than this iced out one. thanks for letting us know your honest opinion about the brow product. i guess i’ll be skipping on that one. TFS!

[@louisewarren6472]

I love benefits brow gel also !!so easy!!

[@melthompson2856]

🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻

[@mrsfox4274]

Love your hair Mel!

[@lmc5890]

I wish they would just use the tone and formula from Amrezy because I still regret not giving in and getting it. Love Moonstone but I love the the wet look so much.

[@robinswan5831]

Still lovin the hair down! So cute!

[@KD-df9wo]

I love 24hr Benefit. Thank you for telling not to bother with the freeze.

[@loridoyle3068]

I know its been out for awhile but I would love to see a dedicated video like this on Danessa M. Highlight pallets, loose highlights and HL Balm.

[@beckybertish7841]

I love icy highlighters but I don't need more. I also have been known to buy highlighters that don't do anything for me.

[@sarlizglam8015]

Reminds me a lil bit of the abh moonchild palette ugh....the shade lucky clover. Had to look up the shade name 😆

[@thebeauteatalk]

Mel ur hair is suuuuper cute 😍

[@morgankrueger808]

I immediately thought of ‘Helia’ from ABH Aurora Glow Kit

[@lyndahollins2881]

I much prefer the Champaign highlights IF I wear a highlight. I never really buy highlighter, but have a few and never seem to go for them.

[@catherinemorrison1909]

Pink Honey is the only thing that tames my brows x

[@sickandpretty]

Thank you for the honest review, as always! Looking stunning (as always lol!) 🖤

[@meagenb4968]

I think highlights are pretty but subtle is for me.... and with dry, aging skin...don't use it, really. So much fun to see the swatches. Stay safe and well.

[@lifeunfiltered4822]

How do you get your hair to lay flat like that? Mine wants to stick up everywhere, and when I try to lay it down, I just look like a boy.

[@jadehanson1989]

I immediately thought of Nars Albatross as well when I saw this one.