MG Astor Sprint vs Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara Sigma | Which Car Is More Value For Money? | Mar 2024

[@arunw700]

MG Astor has 5 star safety ratings for the ZS platform which it is based on. This main factor should be considered as it is the main factor for increase in body weight and safety. Please consider Safety Ratings into consideration.

[@asifzbaig]

MG Astor makes more sense for a base variant if your running is low and looking for a family car. Grand Vitara's resale might be higher on the other hand after a period of 5-7 years but its initial cost is much higher, specially in states like KA where there is a higher road tax for vehicles above 10 lac mark. .

[@Krishankumar-lq4ih]

build quality of astor way better , safety rating is again superior

[@SachinPareek-u5c]

I have taken test drive of this car twice of 1.5 NA MT, first time the engine performance was very poor , then i took test drives of other cars as well , but due to value for money proposition i considered it again and second time the drive experience was good, is there a difference between the models or year of manufacturing , i mean did they tune the engine or somehting. Can someone suggest if they have driven the 2024 sprint varient and how is the performance?

[@karanbharti9366]

Astor is definitely value for money 😍

[@Amit_Kumar_Trivedi]

I am asking for a very absurd comparison! After enlisting all my requirement and desire to extract value without extreme cost of ownership. I have an inclination for diesel but petrol is more practical. I have to decide between Maruta Grand Vitara Sigma and Kia Seltos Diesel HTK(O) models. Could you compare them. Driving is about 18k per year.

[@pulkitchaudhary9632]

I was looking for this comparison today and this video popped up 😍 thanks a ton for this 👍🏻

[@dhineshrulz]

Looks little biased towards grand vitara. Size difference in boot and width should have made balanced. And weight ratio - safety rating? Astor base with better interiors, oem display and strong built will be easily VFM. Except mileage in city.

[@acescok]

Wow. really good job. nice presentation

[@RahulGaur]

Perceived value of astor with so many features is 65k. It does not look correct since the 10.1 inch screen itself will cost above 20k min. Other features like hill descent traction control are much more advanced.. its shoukd go above 1.4 lakhs.😊

[@rajendrankamalanathan7312]

I feel safe, driving an astor compared to any maruti suzuki cars. You get a premium feel inside and outside Astor which grand vitara can't offer Mileage shouldn't be a priority per say. It's my personal opinion

[@SONGOKU24-I6]

Grand vitara based on brezza platform which score 4 star rating in global ncap

[@tilakkumar9734]

@@SONGOKU24-I6 until official tested, you cannot buy on the basis of assumptions or dreams

[@SONGOKU24-I6]

brezza and ciaz score 4 star which is same platform. even Global ncap told if facelift brezza crash test again hit can score easily 5 star rating

[@classicsumit]

And what about astor 5 star saftey rating, fit and finish and plastic quality.

[@nikhilsiotia5308]

Hows resale value for astor after 5 years

[@kuNDan.1311]

MG Aster provides TATA level build quality.. so what is the perceived value of such high safety standards?

[@hiteshyagnik7285]

Astor is way better in terms of luxury, build quality and features. Performance wise also good. I always prefer Astor over grand Vitara

[@akshatkhedekar8561]

do you own one? how is maintenance and service of mg? are there any long term issues?

[@mintuali7035]

Main astor shine buy karne ka decision liya. Because safety and comfort with luxury interior..

[@jithinjosepeter6085]

👍🏻Mg is good brand maruti and tata is not that good ,iam looking to buy comet ev top end against Tiago ev

[@satyajit14306]

You have not compared the safety rating.which is vital

[@akshaypatil7451]

Astor ground clearance 205 mm and not 180, isn’t it ?

[@Bro7605]

Mg astor sprint > any other car in segment base model Big disappointment is milege But yes those who have less running astor is best for them

[@nagb4336]

When you look for sturdy and quality, you need to compromise on mileage to some extent bro. If this vehicle also wrap up with thin body sheets that maruthi uses, it also gives the comparable mileage but at the cost of safety. Our Indian mindsets always look for economy at the cost of safety , hence the reason even if many maruthi models got 1or 2 rating like Alto, wagor r , Swift etc still they are leading the market

[@sumitmishra5563]

Thank u for this type of video bro

[@narenpanwar4809]

I will prefer Astor to buy

[@freaksumfrooksum]

Drive and regret later

[@rajatbansal6716]

I will go with MG Astor any day, it has the best and better build quality then the Maruti's any car.

[@takengpabin7626]

Best channel for auto. Underrated

[@ars411]

I really like the astor, but worried about the long term survivor of the Brand.. presently owning Chevrolet.

[@jithinjosepeter6085]

Chevy is an emotion 👍🏻 maruti is local 😂 mg is stylish

[@ars411]

@@jithinjosepeter6085 I own a ciaz 2015 diesel too. I have coined a name for it . Maruti Nazuki. Rest you can guess.

[@birdie8085]

A comprehensive comparison.

[@JayrajBrahma]

Features dekhar Maine Astor ko hi choice kiya hai lekin fuel ⛽ consumption ko bahut jaada lagra ha hai.

[@vbv454]

Definitely Grand Vitara is Top in Class. It would have been good if you could have explained the body Metal Gauge. Steel Body Efficiency

[@lessonplans9674]

Didn't mention ncap rating

[@gauravsisodiya2163]

Cutting-edge technology, modern design, and a potentially more exciting driving experience might make the Astor better pick.

[@RIPKing77771]

Ground clearance of astor is 205 mm 2024 model

[@kamaldeepsingh3356]

Will go for grand vitara any day coz it gets a incredible resale value even after 5 years you can sell it just 2-3 lakhs below the purchase price

[@nikhilsiotia5308]

What will the Astor resale cost after 5 years be

[@amir26ansari]

who will buy a car of 13 lac in 11 lac after 5 years

[@abhishekagrawal7998]

Yeah u are right but after 5 year the cost of car will also increase by 2-3 lakhs ​@@amir26ansari

[@prashantkhot5667]

Road presence, brand trust, service network, hybrid technology, mileage, resale value these are the deciding factors. Build quality is also not so bad. Its good. Resale value of NonMaruti vehicles in India is very bad. Grand Vitara is better.

[@prasadmuppana8354]

You Miss 8/pernet intrest atlist 25000 and car insurance every year rs1000

[@roshansinghkshetrimayum2002]

In my opinion Astor is more valuable should consider built quality premiumness feel good factor

[@Amit_Kumar_Trivedi]

Anyday, GV is better than Astor. Low cost of ownership, better service network, good features and comfortable.

[@ghanshyampawar99]

1st comment for V3Cars ❤🎉

[@Indian-r6i]

😂😂😂😂Maruti sponsored video, how a 5***** rated Astor car value with luxury interior perceived value is less than tin factory😂😂😂 MG is laughing at doglapan😂

[@nagb4336]

MG Astor ka quality bahathareen hai. They just can't be comparable with models like grand vitara or breeza .

[@sameeraggarwal8689]

MG Astor ka base model hi sabse best hai log kuch bhi bole but mileage bhi achi hai car me!

[@umairhusain4056]

You didn't take astor's premium interiors and superior build quality into consideration

[@vrnr1]

Most important thing in an SUV is ground clearance…180 in Astor is almost like a sedan!!!!

[@santhoshn8108]

2024 model has 205 mm ground clearance...Don't comment without knowing

[@apurvadixit2923]

Safty is very important

[@guptasaransh0303]

Maruti se kitna payment mila

[@vbv454]

Ultimately Chinese Brand MG is the matter of Fact…

[@shubhamxtreme6886]

Jsw Steel buy 35% share in mg India bto

[@coolperson6143]

I have heard 2 bad things about Astor, that its performance is very bad especially in hills and petrol efficiency milege is very less, however i am not a maruti fan because of its cheap quality metal and durability

[@vijaysandapoor5365]

Mg astor

[@ManandMachhine]

Winner was decided before 45 secs vitara 😅

[@33chandu]

Astor is very slow at pickup

[@Abhiiiiiii726]

2nd comment ❤

[@digvijaykhade9844]

Astor in the comment section but Grand Vitara on roads…there is a reason Astor not even in top 20 in monthly sales…Indian buyers are smart enough to decide while buying whereas highly intellectual people will try to degrade Maruti Suzuki cars in comment section as usual

[@yashoza3005]

How can push button start and power folding ORVM cost 51k 😂😂😂. Totally biased

[@the_dented_NPC]

Yep, I agree

[@khemchandsure7553]

51K is not just for these two features, they did mention all the features in table format. watch video again.

[@kingofmonsters7452]

GV comes with Traction control 4:47

[@kingofmonsters7452]

You forgot Additional Battery with Smart Hybrid technology regen

[@asifzbaig]

@@kingofmonsters7452 That's covered in Fuel Cost comparison. .

[@gopalvirtual]

Gru