MH3 Collector's Commander Game w/ MoistCr1tikal!

[@apathy112]

I don't leave comments usually but I have to say this is one of the most entertaining things watching Matt figure it out while Charlie pretends he's a seasoned player.

[@lukenorris5019]

Charlie is as seasoned as boiled chicken

[@riley8603]

Lmao no but this was so entertaining

[@TheDisturbedOne24]

That's the natural pattern of magic lol

[@MrToxicB1izzard]

I can't wait for the inevitable Post Malone episode where Charlie just fangirls the whole game.

[@piggytub1]

"your propaganda doesnt affect dinosaur energy" and then matt hitting him with the "isnt that just oil?" Is a BANGER joke and deserves so much more credit 😂

[@ashtonmunsey4647]

So funny

[@kyemonahan3977]

father has blessed us once more with more mtg

[@aLocalGuy312]

Thank you papa

[@benpline1617]

I love that Matt was so careful and organized with his board and Charlie just had random stacks of lands all pointing different directions

[@eduardorodrigues8354]

Around the 54min mark, Matt missed that his Finale let's him untap 5 lands... which with Mana Reflections is a lot of mana to play his newly drawn hand

[@indybruining]

Would have been huge.

[@taylorcrawford4387]

He also could have done that elephant a ton more and gotten rid of Charlie's Eldrazi. I think at one point he played it (after the first time he ever used it) and he didn't use the effect to destroy 3 things. So because of that Charlie got 2 damage off on him with Endbringer. And then I think if he copied it, it would have happened again right? I mean it didn't matter much since Charlie had a spell to kill him but still.

[@kingnyx1439]

@@taylorcrawford4387 the elephant does not target creatures, it states non creatures. could have gotten rid of lands but would also have given him 3 3/3 bodys

[@taylorcrawford4387]

@@kingnyx1439 Thanks, I couldn't recall if it said non creature permanent or non land.

[@zsorens4570]

I get triggered when the experienced players don't point out the extra busted things you can do with these cards, that's 14+ mana with a fresh shitload of cards he could have played, like cmon man.

[@ihusitusi]

1:25:45 "Destroy target nonbasic land" - Proceeds to destroy Ulalek

[@yargolocus4853]

about as nonbasic as you can get

[@quack929]

XDDD was just looking to see if anybody else noticed this, man thinks volatile fault is godlike land/removal

[@chrishoye55]

Just watched this moment, needed to make sure I wasnt the only one who noticed

[@Rancidtunip]

If it did not mean Moist would need to get on a plane, I would love to see Charlie on the Prof's shuffle up and play.

[@stefanpedias4511]

Would prefer command zone rather than profs show

[@milohummon8753]

Naw profs is more fun. Less fake oohs and aahs more actual conversation.

[@ohnosmoarlulcatz]

@@milohummon8753 Elder Dragon Hijinks and Commander at Home is full of that stuff.

[@Vampireinarm1]

@@stefanpedias4511 command zone is cringe af

[@growliff5998]

@@stefanpedias4511actually feral

[@euphoricbadger1227]

Just a tip for any time you create a copy of a permanent (small missplay at ~ 1:00:10): When copying a permanent, it enters as a copy of that permanent only with the characteristics printed on the card/permanent being copied (ETB and/or ''enters with' will all take effect). In such case, the aethersphere harvester myriad copies would indeed enter the battlefield and give energy, but they would only be vehicles, NOT creatures, nor would they have lifelink as both of those effects are not printed on the card. The same is true if you copy a permanent that is modified (counters, enchantment, etc); the counters are not copied, but the permanent is. Notably, you would not be able to suddenly crew these vehicles and attack with them either given attacks have already been declared. A few subtle exceptions to this copy rule are mutated permanents and copying copies: When copying a mutated permanent, you copy the 'entire' permanent ie. all printed keywords and abilities of the mutated creature which can include abilities of multiple cards so long as they are part of the same mutated creature (if there are multiple cards that make up a mutated creature, they are treated as the same game object and thus the entire object is copied). See Tawnos, the Toymaker for some fun shenanigans. If you copy a permanent that is a copy of another permanent, you copy the copied permanent as it exists on the battlefield. Ex. If 'Evil Twin' enters as a copy of a grizzly bear, it enters as a grizzly bear with its activated ability. If you then copy the Evil Twin Grizzly Bear with another copy effect, you get a copy of grizzly bear with the activated ability of Evil Twin, not just a grizzly bear. I don't have the specific rules references but if anyone would like to add them below, feel free. Cheers, and thanks for the video!

[@JakeandJoelareMagic]

The mtg curse is burning strong over here and we are here for it.

[@travis_approved]

Same!

[@heathcliffrhinocock1831]

Turn 1 bounce land + discard sure seems funny until Turn 2 is Swamp+Reanimate 😂

[@soupcansam75]

Its all fun and games until you make your discard play and get bogged.

[@devinloew7681]

I've definitely done that. It really taught me to read my cards better

[@Radbiker33357]

Oof I had this happen to me in arena, made me sick. So stupid. Thank god it wasn’t Ulamog or something busted, but it didn’t get much better after that, the value was already done.

[@breakingblackmagic7617]

remember, MANA VAULT IF TAPPED < deals u 1 damage at upkeep... Charlie... lol

[@Longridr]

All this leading up to a Post Malone, Professor, Wubby, Charlie Showdown!

[@izwe794]

Brutal to put matt on the simic deck when he's new

[@wafflehaxxx]

That precon is devastating. Tried playing it unchanged and the amount of mana the deck generates is absurd. It's just missing some strong payoffs with the mana you generate and some counterspells to protect your most important pieces. Definitely NOT a beginner deck though.

[@RM22201]

Let’s not act like simic has difficult mechanics here

[@gamerp1g]

@@RM22201 generally, you are right. But for a new player the interaction in the Tricky Terrain deck actually are .........well......tricky lol

[@aenubiis]

The amount of missed energy that would've been generated from the aetherwork is quite concerning

[@buffumjermaine7337]

You know what is even funnier is that the simic one is generally better but just a bit harder to pilot

[@horrorladchad3122]

Me not understanding anything about this game but I’m just here for Charlie and the boys: “I like your funny words, magic man!”

[@Ostrich12]

That’s how the pipeline starts

[@Matt.McCarthy]

You guys are so much fun to watch I don't get to play as much as I would like these are a good substitute keep them coming!

[@James26285]

This was a tonne of fun to listen too. I didn't even watch, just listened while you guys played while im at work and you guys make it so interesting even just on audio alone. Im excited to keep seeing these

[@coyotefire69420]

Matt missed a part of his card at 54min. He before exiling the sorcery he was able to untap 5 lands which would have netted him 10 more mana and then had 15 cards to play. I love commander though because its way more chill. When I was playing with my friends routinely we all misread cards for weeks before our other friend was like read it and changed the way my deck played lol

[@zacdredge3859]

16 mana even, several of his land tap for 2 each.

[@lordfrz9339]

Yep, TCG games with buddys and misreading cards is how it goes. Sometimes even after you figure out the correct way to play you just say whatever, keep playing it like you normally do since its funner that way, lol. Playing the PC version of TCG has taught me how to play way more then reading the cards themselves, lol. Kind wish there was a TCG that was both fun, and not so crazy with its cards effects.

[@coyotefire69420]

@@lordfrz9339 I totally agree. Standard MTG makes me go insane because its all about the meta and not even having fun (unless your fun is only sourced from winning). Good luck on finding a TCG that isnt insane lol

[@kangaboomm]

Matt is doing a great job

[@TheYoutubeUser69]

the unbeeped swearing and just general vibes of the guys makes this insanely enjoyable. good stuff guys. what a game as well

[@TheYoutubeUser69]

also the editors are fucking goated

[@jessemach5817]

Tai lung - this battle shall be legendary

[@Thaelkor]

Matt asks of we "have time" at 9:35 LOL

[@tylerphillips8262]

There's no way Charlie held onto that for that long knowing he could have won when Matt decked out the other dude 😂😂😂 that is what I call prolonging the inevitable 😂😂

[@narbra9678]

I literally said twice this week "I need a new skill check commander game" And now I have my bourbon and an evening satisfied, cheers gentlemen

[@HafusAndLegacy]

cheers mate

[@axekickstudios2886]

"You wanna shut the fuck up and leave me alone?" That shit made me cackle.

[@mariocardenas1833]

Hell yeah, keep these coming boys

[@kaydenchapman3094]

been waiting for more commander games

[@MCxJudge]

I got into magic because of Charlie, thanks Charlie. I am also thousands in debt, thanks Charlie.

[@Jake_Games26]

Same I’m not in debt but fuck this game is addictive

[@GothamKnight-hsw4vx526430]

Try Flesh and Blood too! Also great fun lotta mtg people drawn in

[@MCxJudge]

@@GothamKnight-hsw4vx526430 i'm poor now tho

[@KuminsU]

Love these games

[@Surefirechip]

The Eldrazi deck foreshadowed what was to come

[@JustinVanTrump]

Maskwood Nexus is in the Disa deck so you can self mill any creature and put it onto the battlefield since they would be all creature types including Lhurgoyf (and yes that also includes Grist)

[@loach5348]

Oh heck yes more addiction content

[@benjaminwoods126]

I do love the various nuanced rules that come up being explained with proper examples.

[@explodinglab]

Just a little note, for amped raptor at around minute 46, if you cannot cast the spell that it finds immediately, the spell is exiled forever instead of being able to cast whenever you wanted to

[@aymodaslacker8852]

really loving this editing with clear card description

[@IAmUser420LV]

Im so glad i live in a universe where mtg is getting so much hype from all my favorite folks.

[@lucaswalker824]

It's amazing how much Matt and Charlie improved in just 3 months

[@96Logan]

20:05 When the commander attacks, you get 2 energy so you would have had 3 and maybe not had to sacrifice the ripper token. I haven't played with that commander so idk if I am right or if y'all caught it later. Great episode so far!

[@timmycadaver8293]

Actually they messed up that entirely the token comes in tapped and attacking, therefore no attack trigger to net an energy.. this entire play was wrong lol

[@phntmthf5505]

Fun fact: Tribal/Kindred is *not* a supertype! It’s a regular card type like creature or enchantment which can have creature types.

[@newt8655]

Volatile Fault seemed busted this game!

[@solorider66]

The volatile fault should not have been able to kill Charlie's commander cause it does say non-basic land. It mattered a bit cause he could've copied the card he played and had two creatures, both with haste which Charlie probably forgot about, that could've attacked and almost, if not killed, Matt. But there was a lot of missed stuff and it's not meant to be a competitive game and just for fun :)

[@newt8655]

@@solorider66 lmao I know I was being cheeky about it

[@CasualKing21]

I think it's really fitting that Charlie is playing the Eldrazi precon, he did pull that serialized Eldrazi (I don't remember which one) lol 😂

[@knightwalker44]

I need so many more of these videos! It would also be fun to see more alternative modes that aren't so common.

[@ohnosmoarlulcatz]

There's a reason why those modes aren't that common. They're not that popular because a few archetypes tend to dominate. We're seen more green/blue combos in modern thanks to Nadu, but it's far from being the red/black dominant combo brought by Ravagan, Sheoldred, and Orcish Bowmasters.

[@HayePorritt]

i hope to catch all the misplays one day but to me this is just a clean, dope game of magic loll on a serious note great content though and lots of love to drew, matt, ryan and jesse - keep it up boys and appreciate you charlie for the grind

[@PALIGames]

Good to see Charlie enjoying Commander it really is the best casual format in magic

[@Ye_Axol]

man I would love to see these guys in Vegas this year for Magic Con 2024, it would be a hopeful dream if it didnt mean charlie would have to get on a plane

[@armondomendoza4713]

GHOST RUNS BEHIND CHARLIE AT 8:20!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@SSDriscool]

farewell top deck when on the verge of death is truly what magic is all about.

[@IjustWantedToPost]

I really appreciate the editing of your commander games. Those Game Knights dudes have nothing on you, I don't think they've ever used something as high quality as the spanish_metal_pipe.mp3.

[@Elfenlied8675309]

YEAH BABY! THIS IS WHAT I'VE BEEN WAITIN FOR!

[@WEYABAGO]

I tried to fall asleep listening to this but I got to the part where Drew was rhythmically flicking the cards for a few minutes straight and it woke me up lol welp I don’t play magic or DnD but I’ve watched every episode on this channel you guys are great! ❤

[@WEYABAGO]

I really hope the campaign picks up momentum again, I need more 💪

[@demo3645]

Matt's first card being Simic Growth Chamber was crazy cause i was sleeving a deck watching this video and Simic Growth Chamber was the next card i had lol

[@shikarymtg]

please take it out :D

[@wafflehaxxx]

@@shikarymtg Why would he take out one of the best lands in the deck?

[@CrapsGoodxD]

At 1:04:55 I thought charlie was allozed to exile at insant speed upon the bug entering battlefield, so that the landfall can't happen since playing lands is sorcery speed right and cannot be added to the stack? Correct me if I'm wrong im pretty new to magic, but I have a feeling they explained it wrong?

[@zangvids]

amazing episode. do you guys sell your playmats? do you have a merch page? if so, i can't find it for the life of me

[@polylingua]

With scute swarm you can use this equation, 2 * 2 ^ n - 1 (where n is the amount of scute swarms on the battlefield when playing a land), to count the correct tokens if you have 6 or more lands.

[@ghlutton7971]

Keep up the commander games!

[@orvar7035]

Charlesmtg content is such a down to earth begginer vibe with the most expensive versions of everything. Perfectly balanced

[@jojo123792]

Matt destroying charlie's commander with a land is just hilarious

[@eugenebrooks4035]

I didnt understand any of this but I did enjoy watching you all play . Very entertaining .

[@DigitalD20]

Didn't know Ulalek was a nonbasic land. Neat.

[@FxNimm_]

Nice. Also when the sphere of oblivion went off Ryan's arcane signet was suppose go into the graveyard.

[@pendotxl822]

seeing that land untap trigger at 53;55 ignored kinda hurt . esp since it was like 15 mana

[@ZacharyGalloway]

Long time sealed Pokémon vintage and modern collector but I bought my first Magic product yesterday being the Eldrazi commander. Now I’ve got a few collectors booster boxes on the way to rip and see if I get hooked or end up putting it all in a bulk box and moving on with my life.

[@WildcardGamez]

1:25:45 He definitely did not just remove an eldrazi that could've won charlie the game with nonbasic land removal.... Didn't even let charlie ramp afterwards like he should've...

[@rosskred1160]

that was a crazy play haha, imagine if a land was that good

[@Dumplestiltzken]

Yeah how'd that go unmissed 😅

[@ColumnBlack]

New decks, new players, it happens. Plenty of mistakes were made along the way. Maybe they should get a guy to just watch over the rules since the guys that know the rules are busy playing and sorting their deck.

[@Sercotani]

​@@ColumnBlackyeah, other MTG channels have actual off-screen judges that oversees the games. It's not just to prevent misplays, it also slowly teaches the players about specific interactions. It can be really fun to learn those, *and* makes you a better player overall.

[@lordfrz9339]

@@Sercotani I d rather see people playing the way I would with the bros.

[@kubabab]

You can't play cards off Amped Raptor at any time. It's like Chandra, Torch of Defiance's +1; you have to cast it as part of the ability's resolution otherwise you don't get to cast it

[@legacyxv7132]

Matt *uses something that only destroys lands to destroy a commander* Charlie *Doesn't read card* Me *Holding my head in agony*

[@Jake_Games26]

Charlie got me into mtg with his card opening videos now I have 2 commander decks and am thinking about a third one. This addiction grabs you hard and fast. So far I’ve only made outlaws of thunder junction decks.

[@The.Nasty.]

Why even resist? He’s just gonna slap your hiney with that new Eldrazi 😂

[@nethernuisance4540]

This is so fun thank you for letting us watch the games

[@xfire5727]

28:06 Shouldn't Charlie get two experience counters here from the boardwipe Final Act? Even as a commander being put in the command zone, it still has to hit the graveyard before it can be moved, right? And Azlask should give an experience each for itself and Ulalek. Counter removal wasn't chosen, and energy was kept. Not that +1/+1 mattered when being blocked by 13 13 13s

[@JimNoBoDie]

Are they not losing life from commander damage?

[@joules1092]

for Ulalek dont you need 5 wastes not just any 5 colorless to cast him?

[@codykamrath7337]

Yellow hair is so aggressive but such a nerd at the same time, these are definitely conflicting story arcs and makes him interesting to watch play

[@11epicnoob]

Thought putting Mortivore into hand was a misplay I thought Disa was out at the time of the Grisly Salvage

[@GaninIsMyName]

Don't worry! They turn on the mics at 2:23. So don't leave like I almost did.

[@Sercotani]

honestly I almost did lmao, they really should have a disclaimer up.

[@frasert8779]

Everyone makes mistakes and misses stuff, it’s inevitable and ultimately doesn’t matter. But I can’t believe nobody caught the Volatile fault destroying Charlie’s commander 😂

[@opossum9813]

Yeah 40 min and there has been 8 something missed energy and Ryan should have lost 9 life but edh is all for fun but it’s just funny to notice

[@MyNameIsNyx]

as the wu tang clan foretold protect your deck! word

[@SlusheeDucky]

Matt not realizing his moonscape sage would allow him to pick up his locus land that gains life for every locus with the everything counters to gain 5+ life a turn bugged me

[@tolkienshadelore4937]

At the end wouldn't Charlie have been able to sacrifice an Eldrazi Scion to stop tap the frog before attacking instead of using the other Eldrazi to tap?

[@zurreal8087]

The card you find off of amped raptor must be cast immediately or not at all.

[@Tired.]

Charlie playing mtg has to be the best thing I’ve ever seen I use to play and this makes me want to again

[@MrWader76]

I would watch this channel even more if this is the only type of content that you did. Love ❤

[@jacksongriffith3359]

Would you guys consider doing an episode on Emperor or 2 headed giant?

[@bananabeam5602]

What app is being used to track the lifetotals?

[@ryanwilhite]

Please do something about the bell that's constantly going off in the background

[@ulisesno.8071]

Matt wearing a omega speed master like a king

[@johanjansson6367]

31:33 That Ulamog's Crsuher attacks each combat, even the turn it gets played. Counts as haste, as it has to attack!

[@BoppoTheClown8]

untrue.

[@akaniichan]

The Energy precon is sick. Cant wait to combine it with science.

[@johnhungerman5057]

when will you guys do a fan episode?

[@Mativicus]

Love how Matt the newest play ended up with arguably the most complex / need to know game knowledge deck.

[@dorkdarketh5285]

When he kept attacking with razorfield ripper and not adding the one extra energy was sooo annoying haha 😂

[@BrianSmith-dq5iv]

Rules Check: I don't think Razorfield Ripper gets its triggered ability (i.e. energy and +X/+X) if it comes in attacking as a token, right?🤔 (Nvm, they caught it, lol)

[@anthonybrainwood8015]

Yes, Yes, YES, F*** YES!

[@BobbyAlejandro21]

YESSS KEEP POSTING THESE!!!

[@Casual_BackPacking]

CHARLIESLAND PILE LOOKS LIKE A KID RUNNING UP AND DOWN STAIRS HOLDING SCISSORS

[@sadboisoup]

wouldnt propaganda affect the attacking raptor since the text says each creature attacking?

[@GreenLama]

There were so many mistakes in this game, which is understandable since charlie and matt are relatively new to the game (especially matt) and i noticed them mostly on their turns, but the biggest one imo is that mirage mirror doesn't have summoning sickness, so he could have swung with everything and (probably) won (couldn't be bothered to actually do the math since charlie could stop one from attacking). Still a very fun game though! I'm excited to see more and see the mistakes become less and less frequent as they gain more experience. It's always a good time to see people learn a game you enjoy yourself.

[@Jerfo42Gaming]

This is incorrect, mirage mirror does have summoning sickness, here's the ruling on gatherer: If Mirage Mirror becomes a creature the same turn it enters the battlefield, you can't attack with it or use any of its Tap abilities (if it gains any) unless it has haste.

[@Vipertooth007]

@@Jerfo42Gaming I love when people randomly 'correct' people when they're wrong lol. Yeah everything has summoning sickness the turn they come in because you can animate lands/enchantments/artifacts even planeswalkers can swing with that one sword.

[@elizanoelle313]

@@Jerfo42Gaminghey lol

[@fallenangelyt1590]

What kind of sleeves are those Drew has? @Skill Check

[@beamerboi_420]

why does the energy in this video feel so tense? do they not get along?