Michael Bolton & Mariah Carey • “We’re Not Making Love Anymore” (LIVE!) • 1990 [RITY Archive]

Reelin’ In The Years Productions has available for licensing over 30,000 hours of music footage spanning 90 years. Additionally, we have more than 8,000 hours of in-depth interviews with the 20th century’s icons of Film and Television, Politics, Comedy, Literature, Art, Science, Fashion, and Sports.
To search for footage please visit ‪our online database at reelinintheyear...​.
Note: these clips are available on KZbin for producers, directors, researchers and clearance companies for potential use in their projects. Our website on the screen is to protect the footage from being used without our consent and so industry professionals can find us to properly license the footage.

[@colo_vandeint]

Mariah Carey and Michael Bolton should release this on all music platforms.

[@7MonarC]

There was a bit of exchange between then on twitter with Michael wanting to record a duet, and mariah was like let’s do it. But nothing ever came out of that.

[@skeleton5459]

@@7MonarC what year was this?

[@rachunjaikaew818]

There's an studio version with Patti Labelle.

[@whitepaper5241]

​@@skeleton5459I believe it was in 2011. His fans asked if he'd ever do a duet with Mariah, and then he asked her about it on twitter, but i'm not sure if she ever responded to him.

[@amandopiano4291]

​@skeleton5459 1992-1994

[@VicenteBonetto]

She hadn't even released her first album here, but she was already the best singer of all time. A legend, THE STANDARD.

[@SideEyeee_]

No, Whitney is the best singer of all time.

[@speaknowethansversion]

based on what?@@SideEyeee_

[@speaknowethansversion]

this video is about mariah@@SideEyeee_

[@jonnymarv5824]

Celion💯

[@piapp9503]

😮😳best singer of all time?😳 I love her but she's the best singer of all time.

[@PaNdeM0niuM]

Mariah at 19 years old, was already a vocal PRO!

[@MacKurt]

I'd say PRO MAX

[@female1x]

@@MacKurtstill good

[@stanleysimmonsreactions9056]

That's what happens when you're born as one of the greatest vocalists of all time

[@angellv1527]

Ultra Pro Max 😂

[@NEXTGENSKYN]

Her early work with Brenda K Starr was good also. Her unreleased song " weakness of the body" proved her capabilities.

[@PaNdeM0niuM]

It's insane how much Mariah has accomplished since this performance. At 19 years old, she was already a vocal goddess Mariah's career is legendary

[@Sttephy30]

Yes, she already had developed a full-bodied voice by the age of 20, that's crazy. Most singers take DECADES to develop the voice Mariah had in this video. I just wish she kept it this rich and full FOREVER. This is her BEST voice type ever, and VERY rare to find in popular music. Every soprano in pop today sounds PAPPER THIN and NASAL (outside of Pink and Beyonce).

[@dieguitoquimera]

​@@Sttephy30Mariah had a narcissistic mother who was an opera singer and a vocal coach. Narcissistic parents see their children as their brand ambassadors, like a product of themselves, a reflection of their own ego. And that's what Mariah's mother did: she mirrored her ego onto her daughter and trained her relentlessly. This, coupled with Mariah's remarkable vocal instrument, explains why she already sounded like a mature and experienced top notch singer at the age of 19.

[@qbennett7232]

⁠@@Sttephy30 Beyonce & Pink aren’t sopranos

[@Sttephy30]

@@qbennett7232 They’re both mezzo-soprano voice types.

[@qbennett7232]

@@Sttephy30 a Mezzo soprano & a Soprano are 2 different things

[@litothemanlapid]

I cannot believe this kind of videos are just hidden away from years and years

[@lulumimi]

it’s the most insane thing to me 😭 sitting on a literal gold mine for no reason

[@PuccaP22]

Honestly though!I have always loved this song and wondered if there were ever any live recordings that went with it I'm so happy to see it now💛🦋

[@coppersulphate002]

right?

[@danieldonnelly3589]

I really wish Mariah appeared on the album version. No offense to Patti LaBelle, but Mariah knocks this out of the park and this probably would've been a mega hit in 1990/1991.

[@derrviel]

And there's so many more of her other performances not yet shown to the public like most of her daydream tour which were all professionally filmed. I remember Mariah said she would try to find them years ago but nothing was released. I hope we'll be able see them in our lifetime 🥲

[@Gelo.Hernandez]

My brother is looking for this video for a long time. He passed away without seeing this full video.

[@Nil929]

😢

[@VíctorLadkaneMejía]

😢

[@tyestrong5726]

Now you're watching it for him

[@crystalclarke6692]

RIP

[@crystalclarke6692]

RIP

[@johnbruno7614]

Anybody who is watching this legendary classic in 2024 is definitely a legend.

[@musiccapricorn918]

Hi good

[@musiccapricorn918]

But Britney spears is the best

[@johnbruno7614]

@@musiccapricorn918 Lol 😆

[@김혜영-h2h]

Thanks

[@ramonnavarro8631]

Somos leyenda

[@raliballen1]

Mariah may have been at her vocal peak technically in 95-96 but her vocals from debut and emotions era just had this raw soulful passion that gives me the feels still till this day.

[@transakira]

Technically speaking, her vocal prime was in 1993-1995 and then 2003. But yes, she was very soulful between 1990-1992. It really speaks of her versatility and range as a singer.

[@user-pv7pk5nh3k]

​@@transakiraIt's because she changed her style after her first album. Maybe a little bit after the 2nd album .but her first album will always be Her golden album for me.💛💛💛

[@haigiang.travel]

The rawness and husky voice come from smoking

[@jphuwae4505]

She changed her vocal placement in 1992. She started resonating her belts in her mask, so she lost that deep power chesty belt sound. Then again in 1995/1996 she started changing her head voice to sound airier and less full, she also started adopting a girlier brighter upper tone. Listen to Daydream Tour in Rotterdam/Tokyo for a few examples. In 1997 her voice deepened due to stress during her divorce 😢

[@raliballen1]

@@jphuwae4505 i think her decision to adopt the girly brighter tone led to the quick decline of her voice in 1997. Much like Britney Spears it’s clear Mariah was more comfortable singing lower in her natural tone but they had her on overload singing high notes all the time live and in studio and that takes a toll especially when it’s not her comfortable range. She’s not like Sohyang where she can sustain G5’s. Mariah is a sprinter not a marathon runner.

[@bradenmphillips]

Everyone’s talking about that whistle note but the thought of a 19/20 year old achieving that riff/all of those very specific notes that can go off key so easily at 6:00 is such an indicator of her incredible ear and musicianship so early on

[@alvyandana]

that run itself ended so many singers nowadays

[@lamaramy4477]

real. as a singer i tried this when i was like 13 n failed sooo many times lmao but now that my ear has gotten much better i can;)

[@georgemunoz7191]

6:00 No one should compare me to nobody 🤣

[@corneliuswashington-gp1we]

.....those runs are the playground of LUTHER VANDROSS....who every VOCALIST LOVES....and the two of them went on to do a remake of the song....ENDLESS LOVE....

[@ilovetati91]

This was her first major performance before ANY televised ones - you can see how raw and nervous she is and yet she still gives one of the best vocal performances I have EVER heard. The beginning of a legendary, highly influential career and Michael was spot-on in predicting her career trajectory. An unparalleled voice and it's a privilege to be able to watch the start of it. Thank you, RITY ♥

[@TruthSerum101]

That's one of the best vocal performances you've ever heard? That's interesting. How much singing have you heard?

[@ilovetati91]

@@TruthSerum101 I'm a trained vocalist. I can tell you're quite bitter, though.

[@TruthSerum101]

@@ilovetati91 Trained? Where did you study and with whom? Your teacher(s) should have exposed you to more music. You have a lot to learn.

[@ilovetati91]

@@TruthSerum101 I mean it's clear you're a poor attempt at a troll account, TruthSerum101, but this is a virtuoso performance by a woman widely accepted as one of if not the best of all-time in popular music. But why should I expect logic from someone with videos like the ones on your page

[@TruthSerum101]

@@ilovetati91 I knew about Mariah from other people in the industry before her first single dropped. I purchased it the day it was released. Were you even born in 1990? I know her voice (when she had one) like the back of my hand. She has sung and/or manufactured some incredible vocals in the studio, but she is far from one of the best vocalists of all time. She is, however, one of the most successful. She is also the greatest catfish singer I've ever witnessed. Her voice died in her late thirties, but she continues to fool millions of people. She still has a great ear (for music) and great legs. I will give her that much.

[@nicholasmccarthy7057]

That seamless transition to the whistle register OMG🔥

[@angelllxox]

MY GOD 😭 this is EVERYTHING! babyriah singing her face off right before her ascension. You can tell she was so hungry to establish herself as a singers singer here.

[@ilhamyunus7664]

For somebody 19 y.o., Mariah's power is insane!

[@leebradshaw]

Seeing how the parts were switched in the Patti LaBelle version, and how he lets Mariah take the histrionics in the last chorus key change without overwhelming her, and letting her shine; the man is a class act gentlemen. I hope he's recovering now.

[@Singing_Will]

One of her best performances ever! And to think it's the first one we have and she sounded that amazing. Michael also done an incredible job here!

[@cosm-o]

you don't know how much this means to the lambily! thank you endlessly 🤍

[@OsmanyHernandez-t1v]

Perfection is just my word to describe this duet. Bolton's and Carey's voices combined charm and accuracy. Thanks both Michael and Mariah for giving us this excellent performance.

[@Nhuhando33]

haha😢🎉 missing

[@aldwincadelina3106]

a powerful duet. Mariah is the greatest vocalist of all time. legendary. just wow!

[@steveshelley-h5k]

Yes she is good but we cannot forget Whitney H, both the best females

[@GabirouTaejin-ku4ov]

Yes she is

[@erpmo3326]

@@steveshelley-h5k who? idk her

[@MarKatara]

Wow he predicted 17 weeks.. not knowing Mariah would be at 16 weeks with another duet One Sweet Day!!

[@strangerthings88]

What??

[@alvyandana]

​@@strangerthings880:55

[@craig6363]

Well, she will prob hit 17 weeks this year with AIWFCIY.

[@rashidirahimrick3607]

Release this live performance as official version, just like I’ll Be There from MTV Unplugged, and this will be her 20 #1.

[@nh2201]

LOL please stop serving delusion.

[@cynixie8862]

Lmao 😭😭

[@daydream10.18]

​@@nh2201 doesn't matter. She's the only artist who has a live performance to go at number 1. That's a legend right there.

[@bayduvegrolode4531]

It would definitely be possible back then but not so much now I think since the style of popular music nowadays is so different. People might find ballads to be boring

[@markm5243]

⁠@@daydream10.18that isn’t true. George Michael and Elton John did it with their duet of Don’t Let the Sun Go Down on Me.

[@dextherkitbernal895]

Lets make it trending to Twitter inorder for her to acknowledge it and people around the world will see this iconic duet 😍❤️

[@PeterSchurin]

I am Peter schurin, from Moscow Russia 🇷🇺,I’m a fitness trainer currently residing in Vienna Austria 🇦🇹, I stumble upon your profile and felt compelled to reach out. If you are amenable, I would appreciate the opportunity to learn more about you. May I inquire about your place of origin?

[@legitmimifan]

Goosebumps! Seeing the video of this performance for the very first time was really really amazing and I got goosebumps all over my body. Mariah has come so far as a singer-songwriter. Now, she’s a legend who inspired great artists around the world.

[@waynehsiang]

Mariah's high notes were so insane here! Love this video.

[@mcsinger7719]

This is Incredible. Listen to her power..Look at her glamorous Beauty... Dang she is beautiful.... And she calls this her BAD side.. She is F'ing Beautiful

[@briannab4037]

You can barely see her left side here dude

[@VicenteBonetto]

Greatest vocalist of all time.

[@TrisTan-wo7tf]

Mariah is giving me the "vision of love" grammy performance vibe/spirit here. The gay hands. The turn away from camera/shy away look. The hair. The dress. She's really packaged in the beginning of her career.

[@franss7554]

The gay hands 😭

[@oskarm646]

Gay hands 😂😂😂

[@sacihuszar3718]

I liked it before I started watching. 😁😍 And I had tears immediately in my eyes. 😪Also because it's so wonderful, and because two fantastic artists singing in perfect harmony. 🤩 Everyone is talking about WOW, Mariah. Absolutely true, but let's not forget how fantastic and HUMBLE Bolton is! He could have let her voice out, as he did several times, but at the high point he intentionally held himself back, letting MC SHINE. He knew it was her moment! 😇 I adore them both! Dear Michael, GET WELL SOON, you are a wonderful human being, and the world needs you! ❤🙏🙏🙏

[@PeterSchurin]

I am Peter schurin, from Moscow Russia 🇷🇺,I’m a fitness trainer currently residing in Vienna Austria 🇦🇹, I stumble upon your profile and felt compelled to reach out. If you are amenable, I would appreciate the opportunity to learn more about you. May I inquire about your place of origin?

[@begrnuriar]

Bolton here was at the peak of his career. And here Mariah was only 19 new comer, already on the stage with a superstar. Mariah was born to be a legend.

[@briannab4037]

She was 20

[@LambXDaydreams]

@@briannab4037this was sixteen days before she turned 20

[@briannab4037]

@@LambXDaydreams If you believe she was born in 1970, sure

[@tylermills4812]

@@briannab4037 19/20/21, doesn't matter, point is she was a young newcomer. I swear, y'all fans argue over the pettiest nonsense lmao.

[@michaelt.2308]

​@@briannab4037doesn't matter what you believe anyway, we'll still say 19

[@raliballen1]

Omg thank you. We’ve been blessed! I hope “I dont wanna cry” is also uploaded someday.

[@mariahwhitneycelinejanetmadona]

Please upload I don’t wanna cry

[@jesserobsob663]

Mariah performed 'i don't wanna cry' here??!!!

[@marcomarquesmaia]

It's so good to be alive to see this incredible live performance. Thank you @Rellinintheyears66 We know there is more Mariah live performances from 1991 Narm!

[@PaNdeM0niuM]

Mariah still looks the same! Timeless beauty That face no flaw

[@jerseytomato100]

you need glasses, she looks totally different.

[@Hoo_huu]

No

[@Wavecattt]

Not really..

[@imagydmusic1129]

@@jerseytomato100exactly

[@magdamagda5799]

She is much older, she is not the same. We change with time. IT is called ageing. Still beautiful and talented.

[@sunsetdays]

Wow...two of the greatest voices ever! What a performance! What a treasure!

[@TrungPham-lq3em]

Omgg soo very early in her career. But u see, her technique, whistle very stunning, her musicality when duet with male singer. Talentttt

[@Antonio-vw8pp]

To whomever is in charge of this channel, I'm truly sorry for the fan who re-uploaded your video without giving you credit and removing the watermark. We were in the comments making sure that everyone gave you credit for uploading these performances and unfortunately one didn't listen. Please do reconsider and give us fans just one more chance. I can assure you it won't happen again. If not, I understand that as well, and thank you for listening. We appreciate everything else you've given us. The combative minority don't represent all of us, I assure you. Thank you, your channel is a treasure to all music fans.

[@becalamb3728]

Here she had no idea that she would become the greatest songwriter and singer of all time

[@mb3391]

19 #1's and 250 million records later ....

[@MrBates1]

She ate him up 😭😭 Loved it

[@QueenSlayriah]

This was March 1990 before her debut album came out in june.

[@PeterSchurin]

I am Peter schurin, from Moscow Russia 🇷🇺,I’m a fitness trainer currently residing in Vienna Austria 🇦🇹, I stumble upon your profile and felt compelled to reach out. If you are amenable, I would appreciate the opportunity to learn more about you. May I inquire about your place of origin?

[@LalaMontenegro1]

Michael sorta gave a glipse of Mariah's future as she went on holding the most comulative weeks at #1 on the BB Hot 100 charts at 93 weeks, and has a song that went #1 for 16 weeks.

[@sapphirelatina]

her first performance after getting signed to Sony Columbia 👀 Thank you

[@David-vq6qg]

This was before she got signed

[@jolennon8629]

No??? She's literally introduced by Michael as "the newest member of Columbia Records' family". Not to mention Vision of Love was released 2 months after this performance. And Columbia screened a video showcase of her earlier that night (as Bolton also said). You can find it on youtube as "MARIAH-CAREY-RARE-EPK-Vision of Love" by Kenny King.

[@mariafreitas2855]

I just want to say that Michael Bolton is incomparable. I believe that talent like him is only born once every century and fans and admirers of true talent are privileged to enjoy this phenomenon who owns the most powerful voice in the artistic universe.👋👋👋👋👋

[@PeterSchurin]

I am Peter schurin, from Moscow Russia 🇷🇺,I’m a fitness trainer currently residing in Vienna Austria 🇦🇹, I stumble upon your profile and felt compelled to reach out. If you are amenable, I would appreciate the opportunity to learn more about you. May I inquire about your place of origin?

[@ZanaB_50]

Man, If y'all don't APPRECIATE this video! The beginning of an amazing singer's amazing career.

[@Rialmyvs]

Wow. I never thought I’d see this clip. If this version of Michael and Mariah was officially released, this would’ve been a Billboard #1 hit. I think that this should’ve been in Mariah’s debut album. Thank you for giving this never before seen footage ❤ a lamb’s treat

[@dinka05]

It's such a shame that Mariah hid the left side of her face with her hair. She looked fantastic! She is beautiful in any way. We love her "bad" side. ❤️ And vocals were on fire! I almost cried while listening to them. Wonderful! ❤️

[@sunsetdays]

Well...to be fair...it was a thing of her record label team and then she get traumatized about it...

[@dinka05]

@@sunsetdays True...

[@DoyouthinkofmeR]

No one could do it like Mariah

[@bealambwouldya]

😭I cry at those runs at the end. Omg I just love her so much. Lemme watch this again & again. 🥹

[@PeterSchurin]

I am Peter schurin, from Moscow Russia 🇷🇺,I’m a fitness trainer currently residing in Vienna Austria 🇦🇹, I stumble upon your profile and felt compelled to reach out. If you are amenable, I would appreciate the opportunity to learn more about you. May I inquire about your place of origin?

[@soulovelee_2433]

Thank you sooooooooo much for uploading this! Even with Michael's introduction which I've never heard before. 😮 Her voice sounded more mature and voluminous back then than now with older age, she sounded so womanly at only 19 yrs old. Her voice control was insane her tone was beautiful

[@lulumimi]

their voices are absolutely beautiful together it makes me cry 🥹

[@chopardriah7992]

NO WAY OMFG THIS IS INCREDIBLE

[@PeterSchurin]

I am Peter schurin, from Moscow Russia 🇷🇺,I’m a fitness trainer currently residing in Vienna Austria 🇦🇹, I stumble upon your profile and felt compelled to reach out. If you are amenable, I would appreciate the opportunity to learn more about you. May I inquire about your place of origin?

[@Lucy23133]

😅 haters come here and say she is not the greatest vocalist of all time when she is in fact she is the only singer to be titled the SONGBIRD SUPREME by Guinness word records and grammy and others. She has the best range and technique hands down. Clearly live and she has an unmatchable music catalogue! If they come here and attack opinions and say she is not singing live or hate on her then I don’t get why you hit this video 🤷🏻‍♂️ some people are really mental 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@Vishalx01]

I wonder if we can get this trending on Twitter or something , see if Mariah acknowledges it.

[@desuu33]

The way he said it would’ve been number 1 for 17 weeks like it was a random number, but it would beat by 1 week her record which was 16 weeks few years later.

[@dinka05]

He knew what he was talking about. 😏

[@tmmusic724]

@@dinka05 here come the conspiracy theorists

[@desuu33]

​@@tmmusic724 idk what you're talking about, I just thought it was funny.

[@dinka05]

Yesss, finally! Thank you so much for this treasure! ❤️

[@hughw2377]

5:56 the descending run! MARIAH DIDN'T COME TO PLAY!😱😍😭👏

[@GabirouTaejin-ku4ov]

She knew every exposition out she had to prove

[@debutriah]

we need i don’t wanna cry and vanishing narm convention footage 😭

[@jacobplaylists]

Nah you’ll have to wait another 34 yrs

[@debutriah]

@@jacobplaylists well they released the love takes time narm convention footage 3 weeks ago and now this already so you never know

[@CesarJoel94]

​@@jacobplaylistslmao 🤣 yeah they can release it when we're all dead

[@junebingbing5162]

TRULY, 2 of the best voices we ever have.

[@drewm.2790]

OMG I USED TO PRAY FOR TIMES LIKE THESE

[@michellea9183]

This video needs to be on every platform! I didn't even know it existed! An incredible duet of pure power and intensity. Audiences all over the world need to see this video! To have 2 magnificently talented singers such as Michael and Mariah singing together! Sorry Michael, this would surely hit #1 for more than 17 weeks!! Voices like both Michael and Mariah's only come once in a lifetime!! So grateful to see this and save it. Michael, recuperate and come back to us. You are so missed. I can't wait to hear your beautiful voice again!! Aways my support, much love always, Michelle 🎤❤️

[@Oemg35]

Weve been waiting for this video first we had the snippet with the whistle then a lamb released the full version on Christmas a few years back and finally we have this

[@PaNdeM0niuM]

Wow! Mariah was a Superstar from day 1

[@Alma-nu5bt]

For two giants in the industry this is pretty laid back and chill and relaxed.

[@MIXANDMTCH]

PLEASE POST I DON'T WANNA CRY FROM MARIAH'S 1991 SET 🙏

[@xanderanthony1401]

YES PLSSSSS

[@JuniorDumont21]

YEEEES. AND ALSO VANISHING ❤

[@HallOfMimi]

THEY LIKED OMG

[@TravelwithTP35]

@@JuniorDumont21+1 pls my fav song

[@javierosorio3882]

Please

[@maise0821]

Two of the most powerful voices ever👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

[@Anndkfjrosldm123]

The best duet, not just vocally but it stirs up the heart with emotions ❤🥹

[@RodrigoOliveira-pg8rs]

This is pure perfection ❤

[@dannyfrias7829]

The power of her voice ❤….thank you 🎉

[@PatrickShanahan-xo1dq]

I c mariah sing live in london she was outstanding😊

[@benzmusiczone]

This performance is absolutely DIVINE. Thank you for posting!

[@3333falcon]

Consider yourself very privileged if you saw that performance live. We won't witness talent like this again until we are in heaven. This is God given talent!

[@oliviar0x]

I’ve been waiting for this!!! 🙏🏻

[@jestonuarycarbonilla1774]

I didn't expect that whistle tones of Mariah, Im just WOW 🤯 such an amazing voice and her voice literally no one can't replace it.

[@Blue_Eyed_Baby_Bear]

Every once in awhile, an amazing vocalist and songwriter comes along, Mariah and Michael are two of them!❤️

[@Modernaire]

Wow. What unity of talent. Really hope Michael is doing well and will continue to regain his health.

[@ikerina]

There was a looooooooong era when real vocalists dominated radio/chart. That era won't coming back I guess.

[@jacobplaylists]

I’m crying I’m literally crying

[@Lisa-heartsings]

Why have I not heard this song before? I love both these artists. Such a pretty song!

[@charmmhie]

omggg im seated for the slayage of mother & bolton 💅🏻

[@PeterSchurin]

I am Peter schurin, from Moscow Russia 🇷🇺,I’m a fitness trainer currently residing in Vienna Austria 🇦🇹, I stumble upon your profile and felt compelled to reach out. If you are amenable, I would appreciate the opportunity to learn more about you. May I inquire about your place of origin?

[@dhayes6147]

I just love this Mariah. She puts my heart at peace. She makes me so happy within myself and happy by myself just by her singing. thats all I desire from her.

[@mariahwhitneycelinejanetmadona]

Thanks for this!! Can we please have the video of Mariah performing “I Don’t Wanna Cry” at thise event. Please!!!

[@PeterSchurin]

I am Peter schurin, from Moscow Russia 🇷🇺,I’m a fitness trainer currently residing in Vienna Austria 🇦🇹, I stumble upon your profile and felt compelled to reach out. If you are amenable, I would appreciate the opportunity to learn more about you. May I inquire about your place of origin?

[@muhammadfadlybasalamah8148]

goosebumps ❤

[@iamjessieduarte]

We lambs always have some “new” material to feed us 😍❤❤❤

[@AL-rq3im]

5:30 that was otherworldly..she SANG

[@rudolphmcneill515]

YESSSSS!! Michael Bolton is so absolutely talented and gorgeous. ❤❤❤🎉🎉😢😢😢

[@rolandbishop7401]

One of the greatest vocalists of our generation ❤ 👸

[@cherrylla]

omgomgomgomg😭😭😭A Dream come true. You don’t know how much I love this version😭

[@daydream10.18]

THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS! OMG, YOU HAVE NO IDEA HOW HAPPY I AM! 😭❤️ I AM SO GRATEFUL!

[@JonQuerequincia]

I’m so happy this has seen the light of day!

[@jerichosorronda7832]

OMG LIVE FOOTAGE FINALLY RELEASED!!🥹

[@romanjaskowiak8288]

Thank you amazing singers

[@danielrushjr.5788]

Omg this is incredible! Please post Vanishing from NARM! and Someday & I Don't Wanna Cry from the debut showcase. Love your channel!

[@corycooldangerous]

IDWC first

[@lavender3413]

Please reconsider your comment about not posting anymore videos of Mariah Carey. Not every fan put your video through AI Software. A majority of us just want unseen performances. I looked forward to more posts of Mariah, especially other performances from Narm. Please reconsider. 🖤

[@miguelangel7006]

😢What a beautiful memories.....Lord knows how greatful Im for grow with artist like them😊🙏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@HallOfMimi]

OH WE WILL BE WATCHING THIS ❤

[@christinepadua593]

Beautiful vocals on both their parts!

[@ashrafcosain3486]

Two legends 🎙️🦋😍😭

[@brendanansamba2964]

Wow, how come I've never seen this before. Beautiful.

[@sarahlind24]

It hasn’t been available until now

[@luv_b2808]

This clip reminds me why I'm a lamb. Love u my Queen

[@daisyadah4549]

Always Mariah Carey ❤Forever Mariah ❤😊🎉Still listening to both 2024.Bravo!!! 🖐

[@PeterSchurin]

I am Peter schurin, from Moscow Russia 🇷🇺,I’m a fitness trainer currently residing in Vienna Austria 🇦🇹, I stumble upon your profile and felt compelled to reach out. If you are amenable, I would appreciate the opportunity to learn more about you. May I inquire about your place of origin?

[@solarambala]

6:53 she was like K, bye! 😂

[@blackbeauty5717]

Two legends. I love them both