WHO IS SHINee? A Member Introduction To The Princes Of KPOP

If you liked this video, please give it a thumbs up & hit the subscribe button. Also make sure to check out my previous work on my channel.
Follow me on my socials:
TikTok: @mielle22
IG: @michellefurrer22
#shawol #guide #kpop

[@milindawilson9175]

I feel I need to correct one small thing. It's important for people to know that SHINee never took time off. (They weren't inactive for a year after Jonghyun's death, they only took a couple months off to grieve and to regroup.) Two months after Jonghyun died SHINee held their SHINee World Concert 2018 -- The Best From Now On concert in Japan, and only 5 months after his death they had their official comeback with their album The Story of Light, which celebrated their 10th anniversary. And they had a full sleight of activities and promoted like normal. Even through their grief they never skipped a beat. It was important to them to be there for Shawols and to show us that they wouldn't give up or stop being SHINee as a tribute to Jonghyun and to honor him, so they purposefully made an effort to keep moving forward and not stop their activities for too long.

[@luckyone563]

Yes, I even thought the same. But efforts made for the video is good. I hope the video will be added with this detail as well soon☺ 💎💮

[@DhanbeeSuh]

@@luckyone563 I agree! I love the amount of information, a full 40 minute video for SHINee! But yes, I do hope that some detail/corrections could be fixed

[@Hope-wd7wx]

Thank you for this lovely video, Michelle Hawk! Thank you also, Milinda, you make an excellent point: they had no break to grieve properly. Also, that part about Taemin being called tone deaf is something I'm sure Shawols would like to forget. It's obvious that he was talented musically by the way he plays piano by ear, and a tone deaf person could never do that. I think it was an exaggeration made and repeated by proud Shawols who wanted to make the point that Taemin worked very hard to get to where he is today: from having no lines or only the chorus lines to training his voice to be selected as SM's first solo male artist from a group. He paved the way, as did SHINee and SHINee members, in so many ways. One last note is that, per Lee Soo-man, SuperM was not designed as a sub-unit.

[@Lizzy-du8oq]

Love the way you put it in words❤

[@IWriteEssaysSorry]

​@@Hope-wd7wx I need to find the proof, but the group actually did say that about Taemin. It wasn't made up by fans. Maybe the translation is wrong in that they didn't use the exact wording of tone deaf, but they specifically did say he couldn't carry a tune. Taemin joined SM to be a dancer. He didn't actually want to be a singer originally. Neither did Minho actually.

[@littlespoonsebastian]

i think overall this is the best guide ive seen for shinee. ive been looking for a good one to send to people but most of them are either too memey or too brief, and for some reason all of the minho sections are just really lacking and make him out to be one sided, just saying hes 'the hot one' or 'the sporty one'. youve created a really nice balance of information and entertainment while keeping it under an hour. thats probably pretty hard to do so i admire that. the jonghyun section was really nice, its good to see the section that shows him as a member and then another that shows his and shinee's legacy. thanks for making this, ill be showing it to my friends lol

[@michellehawk282]

Thanks a lot for your feedback. It means a lot to me that you've enjoyed it, since this guide took me a lot longer than my usual ones, because SHINee is a group that's very dear to me heart and i really wanted to highlight each member individually and show their strengths and personalities. So thank you very much :)

[@rainandroses__]

i see you on EVERY shinee/minho related vid- you're so real for that tho 😔✊

[@christinetirimon4232]

Some facts about shinee that weren’t in this video - shinee we’re the k-pop group that made coloured jeans trendy - shinee made video dance practise popular (with taemin iconic shirt and the iconic cloud background) to the song ‘lucifer’ and while they weren’t the first group to do it, they certainly made it a trend. - Obama thanked shinee for helping with multiculturalism (or something like that) - prior to debuting, they were originally going to debut as a rap group when producers noticed shinees talent for singing. - shinees talents for singing and dancing live are truely phenomenal, with them gaining acclaim for it - they suck at lip sinking. - jonghyun was one of taemins main trainers, which is why taemin ended up taking a lot of jonghyuns parts, because they sound similar and also because he was lacking lines in the beginnings. - Onews long note (I think it was 40secs-1min) - Minho enjoys gaming - dynamite live, Minho’s part (you’ll thank me later) - the ‘Krump’ ad - shinees song ‘lucifer’ is in the show Lucifer (episode titled k-pop) - of course ‘ring ding ding’ being the ‘forbidden SAT song’ - jonghyun wrote a lot of songs for many famous k-pop stars, his debut as a composer was IU’s ‘Gloomy clock’ where he co-wrote it and sang in (making it a duet) - key’s clown meme - SM Halloween where shinee put a lot of effort into it (kfc vs McDonald’s) haha - jonghyun debuted as a radio host in 2014, for the program ‘blue night’ which also went on to win an award. He is also a composer and wrote a book depicting his struggles with mental health - shinees colour is pearl aqua - after jonghyuns passing, a rare event happened in our night sky where the moon turned pearl aqua (not sure if it was an edit or not, don’t think it is, I’ll do more research into it) - taemin is now on military service - it’s now been 5ish years since jonghyuns passing, may he Rest In Peace. *SHINEE is still going strong to this day even with all the trials and difficulties our boys have gone through. I truely hope for their happiness and for them to be able to continue doing what they love.*

[@rainchase985]

it was 43 seconds! i can’t even hold my breath that long o.O

[@amandamoormann3481]

Vielen lieben Dank für die Informationen🙏🏻❤️

[@Lizzy-du8oq]

I never knew that Jonghyun was one of Taemin's vocal trainers.. Thank you for the info❤ Do you know of the others?

[@IWriteEssaysSorry]

I'm very thankful for this video! It is the most perfect introduction to Shinee. I'm so proud of it! However, the fact that Jonghyun was one of the main people who worked with Taemin is the biggest fact that I feel was really necessary in this video. Minho and Key's dynamic was shown and I wish that Taemin and Jonghyun's dynamic was shown as well (Jong being president of Taemin's fan club 😂). I believe it's important bc it shows how truly brilliant Jong is. With Taemin's hard work, Jong took Taemin from tone deaf and barely any lines, to one of the top selling solo artists from a kpop group. For Taemin to go from "tone deaf" to being able to pull off Jonghyun's parts (which are usually pretty difficult) is a true feat. I'm extremely proud of our maknae and our incredibly talented, creatively brilliant, intelligent, sensitive angel, Jonghyun. He truly did so so well!

[@Bamgeutcutiepie]

i'm so HAPPY you showed this side of Kibum as well!!! THANK YOU .. people usually only show him being funny. This truly showed ALL his charms

[@Yetti.]

Oh when you mentioned that you had a guide I thought you meant the one you created a year ago didn't realise you had a new new guide. Thanks!

[@michellehawk282]

Yeah, i wanted to make one more focused on the members and go a bit more into detail to get to know them. I hope you like it 😊

[@thannystar7077]

@@michellehawk282 I did not know about this guide because it is very recent but I saw that you recommended it to Yetti and I came to see it, the video is great

[@thannystar7077]

@seoul connection Did you see the video yetti?

[@lakshmichallapalli4363]

For me SHINee are the one's that bought colours to my life. I was soo much depressed cause I didn't had anyone to share my feelings. But one day I found them. Till now whenever I hear their songs I feel so much better. But the thing that hurts me is I found SHINee in 2019 and I was not able to attend their concert as 5. Even now also I can't go cause I am just 13 years old but I have promised my self I will stay strong and attend their concert in future. And I want all shawols to remember Jonghyun oppa for his happy moments not for the other reason ( I hope you understand the reason) . To all the shawols out there be safe,happy and keep supporting SHINee

[@Chips9741]

😋🌼Stay happy and smiling always!

[@gems1107]

How are you ?

[@analea10]

Hello, it's amazing, but I need to rectify something, you said they took some time of and a year later they came back, but they didn't take 1 year after what happened to Jonghyun, 2 months they did the show in Japan that was already sold out but it became a tribute to Him and they needed to re-record new songs without his voice for their 10th anniversary, except for one that still left his voice there, "The story of light" part 1 was released 5 months after Jonghyun's death on May 28, 2018, remember that Onew went to the military in December 2018 coming back last summer

[@nganhapham5423]

I absolutely adore how you include Key’s speech in “I live alone” with their Diamond Sky performance. It’s my favorite stage from them because it shows such a bond SHINee has. Also, what Key said must be noted down for anyone planning on support SHINee.

[@meemzzz]

Thank you for this! SHINee is simply one of a kind 💎 05.25.08 and they’re still killing it!

[@livefortomorrow221]

none of these "shinee guides" truly do justice to jonghyun's character, personality , artistry and importance in the group. everyone just throws a short segment in the end , talking about his depression and calls it a day.

[@satinsleeves]

For real it's so annoying... can't believe they did it here too.

[@kmkniu1869]

This was so well done. Really gave a well rounded background for each member. And it's up to date which is fantastic! I hope people just discovering SHINee will make their way here. Hit that like button y'all so it gets into people's mentions 💎

[@katiaichigo8778]

This is truly a complete SHINee guide, it shows everything ! I am sad ofc, and I am grateful that SHINee stayed together and that they are still here, giving us some good music, I think they honoured Jjong's life in the best way !

[@nykihanis9825]

For jinki. No ttakbam. Haha

[@snehamusiclover1]

Replay piano instrumental feels like shinee anthem for me now I'm crying 😢 My kings I respect them so much for being shinee still After everything they have been through

[@meghpai]

Thank You for this. Love everyone’s introduction , but especially love Key’s segment. Dear Key- You May have been ranked number 5 by fans but remember it’s just their opinion- you are in the best KPOP group in terms of talent & versatility- so you are still one of the best of the best. And I for one love your vocals- it’s got a very distinct/sexy tone to it, love your sassy yet caring personality & your bold fashion sense! Ranking is never fair. And I love what you said about it being okay- loving yourself & not getting drawn into these superficial voting & ranking is the best way & you all are so amazingly talented. Stay strong. Keep fighting. And we fans will always support all of you

[@drimachuck]

I haven't cried over Jonghyun in a couple of years and this felt really cathartic.

[@luckyone563]

Literally lovely guide. Thank you so much for a beautiful edit and good briefs about them.☺💎☺❤🎵💮 I beleive you will keep making more 5HINee contents. Fighting!☺

[@nancyl6754]

Love this guide! I was just hoping you included Onew high note or spinning things and also show more how caring he is w the members. Overall best guide of SHINee

[@savaspilletta]

Thank you for your beautiful video, i love that you shows lots of different clips from already existing guides.

[@baciodolce1969]

Thanks a lot for this wonderful gift... All the best to you and our SHINee Boys «3

[@aswathixavier6830]

The best shinee guide I have seen and so beautiful Iam 100% sure that you must have worked hard to include most all the sweet and important moments and I could see the real shinee and the real side of members than a kpop artist thank you so much for this beautiful video ❤

[@michellehawk282]

Thank you 😌 I'm glad you enjoyed it, makes thehard work worth it 😊

[@hellionshark3197]

This feels like it needs a part two, given where it ends

[@battarabbit8827]

Beautifully done.

[@zytan4702]

It's so hard for me to watch videos with Shinee in them without having to tear up because of Jonghyun. I have tried to stay away from videos like this because it's too painful to watch. I miss them all being together.

[@khelenadevisukham]

This is the best guide for me. Thank you for this. I really liked the explanation. It's very clear. Among all the guides for SHINee,this is the best. Thanks a lot for this video.❤️

[@mjj1434]

@Michelle Hawk- Wonderful guide to SHINee - thank you !! I am a new fan of SHINee !! I really enjoyed it - I laughed, smiled and I cried !! So much iof this I hadn’t seen before!!

[@sarandhamotharan2898]

Thank you for the video . It's very touching .

[@jops1004]

i started listening to kpop cos of SHINee and have been a shawol since 2019 but wow, there are still lots that i don't know. thank you for this guide

[@bubblegum7504]

do something about the misinfo.

[@user-dr1ny4iz8j]

thank you for making this video

[@giselacaceres7247]

THANK YOU SO MUCH....!!!!! 5HINee FOR EVER FIVE....!!!!!!!!♡♡♡♡♡

[@snehamusiclover1]

shinee are totally in some other league I mean no matter how many new kpop artists I Start liking, I always go back to shinee! ALWAYS SHINEE ALWAYS STAYS ON TOP FOR ME this is something I didn't do intentionally It just happens,I can't help it Even their b side tracks are masterpieces Give them a microphone and thats it They will blow u away Shinee's impact is different shinee's songs-LOVE SHOULD GO ON,LOVE STILL GOES ON,REPLAY,HELLO,DYNAMITE (the oldest of the oldest) I still feel the same watching their performances and listening to their songs And they would be in some other place today but they lost jonghyun and the emotional trauma they faced was so huge and also they were enlisted in military too So that's why bts rose like this and also the madness of social media ,KZbin views etc are more important now Also bts don't follow the rules of their country like shinee did Shinee were so damn successful when they enlisted in military but they didn't behaved like a celebrity On the other hand bts keep getting out of it again and again And also everyone says bts paved the way for kpop artists which is again not true Shinee had already started selling records and concerts since 2009 in USA,EUROPE,JAPAN ETC. And what bts are doing right now in their concerts is something shinee already started since their debut They were way ahead of time. No hate to bts or anyone but couldn't help saying it Shinee faced something so huge and even after that they came back very strongly The kpop industry scenario might have changed or the criteria of everything might have changed but im proud of them for always trying to come back and always staying away from trashy race I respect them so much for being the same legendary shinee And yes i feel bad that they don't get the recognition and success they deserve but no matter what I will always be a shawol and I will always wish for their happiness and success

[@giselacaceres7247]

#SHINee

[@rainchase985]

me, a long time shawol: watches anyway

[@eleanorreal839]

So good all of them

[@sandrine39455]

Vraiment très sympa comme Guide, l'un des plus complet que j'ai vu..... juste un petit défaut, le manque "d'équilibre" ou de partialité au niveau du timing sur les 5 membres. 🙄Mais malheureusement c'est un problème récurent sur les Guides de SHINee. Mais merci pour ton travail et de nous l'avoir proposé. 👏👍

[@SeReNitY217]

what is the song playing at the background when it introduced Jonghyun?

[@universe986]

SHINee - Tell me what to do

[@paulalowery7411]

OH can he sing OPERA! Whoa.....! I'm spellbound! 1:37

[@chriscyrus8748]

i’m sorry but kibum isn’t libra he’s virgo....

[@IWriteEssaysSorry]

I said this to someone else. Key is born on the first day of libra. He acts like a libra. My husband is a virgo. Key acts nothing like a virgo so I think the dates for libra are accurate. He may technically be a virgo based on astronomy, but he acts like a libra.

[@cgpotato]

Hi. Please where was this interview at 2:07 from?

[@priyajoseph]

Oh honey they are legends not princes .. It’s their legacy that the whole world knows Kpop

[@michellehawk282]

Yes they are legends, but they actually have the nickname "Princes of Kpop".

[@yellowpandaboots3490]

What is the song at 6:40??

[@sabrinayang1724]

Forever Yours

[@martinam.5673]

I don't want to discredit the effort you put into this guide and also the time but I just have to mention that there is a bit of misinformation in your guide. Especially the part where you said the members took time off after Jjongs passing which is not true at all. I also don't get why that part of Jinki talking about losing a member was part of this!? That conversation with Minho happened long before December 18 and it feels like you just put it in for the "sad effect"! Lastly I'm really disappointed in Jjong's section. It feels like it was reduced to only tragedy and the trauma it left the other members with. Nothing about his real personality, how he could be as sassy as Key and also how hilarious he was. Nothing about his song writing or his radio show and nothing about his book either. Nothing about his relationship to the other members or his importance in the group. It was all reduced to his death and the affect it had on the others. Others might be satisfied with the guide or happy because the section of their bias was done well but I just can't say th same, I'm sorry. I would never recommend this guide to a new Shawol because Jjong's section is just to sad and doesn't do him justice and I think especially for new fans this section is extremely important.

[@Aadrianarrr]

Hyy excuse me, umm can i ask something. I am a new shawols:) umm what's Song did key sing on his intro at 5:38 and at 5:58 what is the name of that video.... Someone please answer😊

[@sabrinayang1724]

Body Rhythm by SHINee and I Wanna be by Key

[@Aadrianarrr]

@@sabrinayang1724 thank you so much! Appreciate it.

[@sabrinayang1724]

@@Aadrianarrr enjoy babywol! 💎💎💎💎💎

[@malyceascarlet9837]

Just a little correction, Key is a Virgo, not a Libra. He's born on the day of the Sign change but in Korea the 23rd September is Virgo for the huge majority of the day.

[@IWriteEssaysSorry]

He acts like a libra though so I consider him a libra. My husband is a virgo. I know virgos. Key acts nothing like a virgo.

[@malyceascarlet9837]

@@IWriteEssaysSorry I'm a virgo and he DEFINITELY has some huge aspects of it, while some huge aspects of Libras aren't there. Besides, an astral theme doesn't only depend on the sun sign so your point isn't that relevant...

[@IWriteEssaysSorry]

@@malyceascarlet9837 Well according to the zodiac, virgo ends on the 22nd and libra starts on the 23rd, therefor he is a libra. Do you know what time he was born? Unless key has specifically said he's a virgo, he's a libra.

[@IWriteEssaysSorry]

@@malyceascarlet9837 I just copied and pasted from the first source I found, but even so, it's, pretty accurate. He's an exact mixture of both. Libra (September 23 - October 22) Libra is an air sign represented by the scales (interestingly, the only inanimate object of the zodiac), an association that reflects Libra's fixation on balance and harmony. Libra is obsessed with symmetry and strives to create equilibrium in all areas of life. These air signs are the aesthetes of the zodiac: Ruled by Venus, the planet that governs love, beauty, and money, Libras adore high art, intellectualism, and connoisseurship. Suave Libras need to surround themselves with stunning objects and create environments that reflect their exquisite tastes. Accordingly, these air signs make excellent designers, decorators, art critics, and stylists. While Libra's opposite sign, Aries, represents "me," Libra symbolizes "we." Relationships are paramount for Libras, who find balance in companionship. They love harmonious partnerships with fashionable mates, especially those who make attractive arm candy. (Libra governs the skin, and these air signs are highly motivated by physical appearance. There's no better way for a Libra to relax than with a luxurious face mask.) Libras, when they are regularly coupled, must be careful about seeking attention outside the agreed-upon boundaries of their relationship. Since they try to keep everyone happy and engaged, they may find themselves tempted to push the limits of their agreements with their partners. People-pleasing Libras must remember that the happiness of their loved ones and the health of their relationships is more important than maintaining the attention of distant admirers. Libra is a cardinal sign, which means Libras are accordingly great at launching new initiatives. However, because Libras consider multiple perspectives in all pursuits, these air signs struggle with indecision. Instead of constantly seeking outside perspectives, Libras would do well to develop (and trust) their own intuition. Their characteristic ambivalence aside, Libras can navigate virtually any social situation, effortlessly resolving conflicts by simply turning on the charm.

[@IWriteEssaysSorry]

@@malyceascarlet9837 Virgo (August 23 - September 22) Virgo is an earth sign historically represented by the goddess of wheat and agriculture, an association that speaks to Virgo’s deep-rooted presence in the material world. Virgos are logical, practical, and systematic in their approach to life. This earth sign is a perfectionist at heart and isn’t afraid to improve skills through diligent and consistent practice. Virgo rules the digestive system, which makes these earth signs especially attuned to the ingredients that make up a whole - in food and in everything else. They're hyper-aware of every detail. Virgo is governed by Mercury, the messenger planet of communication. Though Mercury also rules Gemini, these two signs are radically different: Gemini is about output and expression, whereas Virgo is about input and processing. A Virgo deals with information like a computer, transforming even the most jumbled set of information into organized, clear concepts. Though Virgos long to be meticulous in all pursuits, they must remember that constantly chasing after the ideal can be destructive when applied to self or others. Beauty exists within our imperfections and it’s important for Virgos to learn that flaws are not defects. Above all else, Virgos want to help. They are kind, gentle, and supportive friends and lovers who use their incredible intellect and resourcefulness to problem-solve. Virgo's opposite sign, Pisces, offers guidance through spirituality, but Virgos want to assist on a practical level. These earth signs are always striving to provide workable solutions and improve broken systems. Methodical, committed, and hardworking, they make excellent teachers, healers, editors, and musicians.

[@khxrizma]

i am literally bawling at Jinki talking to minho about how he'd feel if he suddenly lost one of his members...

[@BTSlove-qx8im]

Legit same when he said that I just started sobbing, he's so beautiful

[@kalpic11]

That clip was wow

[@terciopelo]

It's truly impossible to not like all members of SHINee. They're incredible artists in every way and they're all individually popular and strong as soloists, especially Jonghyun and Taemin, but never outshine one another as 5. SHINee is so special to me, thank you for making such a wonderful and well researched video 💙

[@sarjie5971]

I've always wished people, especially the new fans and reactors, know SHINee on a deeper level, off stage, because their personalities, relationship and interactions with each other are worth knowing. That's the reason why I fell in love with them even more and hope others would see this side of them as well. So thank you for creating this. Much appreciated.😊

[@MandySam13]

Once in a lifetime you get a group of people together that create a chemistry & synergy that makes history. SHINee is one of those groups. I never expected to get this emotionally invested in them the first time I heard Lucifer (the 1st SHINee song I heard). However before I knew it, I was a fan & never looked back. I love them as artists but I have great respect for them as people too. This is why they will always remain most special to me. You showcased their human side as well as their artistic achievements. Thank you for this guide & tribute to my SHINee guys.

[@unloyalshineestan9496]

You expressed EXACTLY how I feel about SHINee. This is what makes them special and different from plenty other groups. The intense synergy that gets created by the 5 unique individuals is like no other, and that humanity and realness that they show. They express their vulnerability just as much as their glory and I really appreciate that. Yay for SHINee!!!

[@cocotaem5101]

I'm barely 3 minutes in and I've already liked the vid because ONEW 🥺 Finally a good Shinee guide that shows each members good qualities and struggles PROPERLY. I hope your video gains traction among new fans. We really needed a new updated guide. Please make a more in-depth guide for each member and maybe songs too idk hahah

[@michellehawk282]

Thank you, i'm really glad you liked it. I have some other video projects i'd like to do first. I'll try to get to individual guides in the future when i'm done with the other stuff i wanna do first :)

[@cocotaem5101]

@@michellehawk282 No problem at all! Just thought I'd mention it haha your guide was awesone by the way, I was in tears by the end.

[@priscellia1639]

This is a really beautiful guide. It shows their character and humane side.

[@HelloHi-ui1sf]

Wow an updated guide! This is nice:) What I like: Onew praising other members, a good leader Key's story being true to himself Minho not only a rapper but a vocalist as well Taemin's duality, fun & close moments with the hyungs Jonghyun talent showcase and his bubbly attitude that will not be forgotten

[@michellehawk282]

Thanks a lot, i'm glad you enjoyed it 🥰

[@hiddlespearean]

Yes. Fresh new things more suited to the new sides of them in 2021

[@chocolatecheese4729]

I recently learned that vincero means I will win. I used to listen to that opera song sung by Onew many times a day when I was treated for depression. Yes, I can say that Onew's voice saved my life

[@satinsleeves]

I feel like you did Jonghyun a disservice here. He got only a few minutes compared to the rest and half his time was "showing off" trauma from the other members. I didn't like it. You didn't even mention Blue Night, the book he got published, how he could be as savage as Kibum, how Jonghyun and Minho had the original "Tom and Jerry" dynamic, how much he wrote, how he created his own albums, his artistry, how close to and supportive of Taemin he was... none of it. Why?

[@nathaliachiaradia6212]

Thank you for your lovely guide, Michelle! As a locket, I rarely feel satisfied with the way people use to describe Key as only sassiness, but the way you did was so good to see. Definitely a video I will share with my friends that want to get to know shinee better. Thank you for your hard work for our 5hinee

[@michellehawk282]

Your welcome and thanks a lot. I really appreciate that 😊

[@bubblegum7504]

why did you make jonghyun's segment so short skipped so many things about him and made it tragic. and did you have to put a whole segment about members talking about thier grief

[@bubblegum7504]

putting all that vulnerable moments of them..at least put a warning

[@IWriteEssaysSorry]

I agree with putting a warning for those that can't handle it. I sent this to a friend and told her not to watch the last 3:40 of it bc she's a highly sensitive person. However, I'm glad she included it in this video, especially key talking about it being OK to miss him. I thought it was well done. Maybe include a few more positive things about Jonghyun's personality to balance it out.

[@pepsigolda]

the only group which i don't have an ultimate bias as i love them all equally ❤️ also, member for eternity ❤️😭 btw if not mistaken, taemin was not given part at the time because of his puberty's voice change

[@Lara-om7lj]

This guide has a lot of misinformation and you reduced jonghyun to his passing + focused too much on grief and dec 18 which tells me you clearly don't care much about shinee members nor jonghyun and you just want clout through this. you aren't even a shawol and I'm really disappointed that many are praising this guide when it is disrespectful to jonghyun and reducing him to his passing and reducing him to a tragedy

[@satinsleeves]

I feel the same way. This is not a great guide at all.

[@IWriteEssaysSorry]

How about some constructive criticism instead of attacks and you deciding who/how someone else is that you don't even know? This whole comment was immature. Plenty of people have said this but were still respectful about it. 🤦🏽‍♀️

[@Rose.to.Spring]

my only issue with this guide is that jonghyun’s part was shorter than the others there was a lot of things you could’ve added to the guide and you actually didn’t have to make this with a sad/heartbreaking way.

[@DhanbeeSuh]

I agree. I love this guide, but I feel like it focused too much on the sad aspect of it. The section of Jonghyun's talents/personality felt much less significant compared to the mental health, etc. addressed (though it's great to bring up! Just maybe not as much of it). Although I'm sure the creator meant no harm, I feel like if a new shawol were to see this, I wouldn't want them to think of Jonghyun in a sad light- too many do so already. For constructive feedback, I think it would've been great if perhaps, Jonghyun's SNL moments, his kazoo, hell- even his book! That sorta thing was prioritized over his death, and maybe treated him more like the other members. I also agree that this didn't have to be heartbreaking, nor end on a sad note. I would've loved to see some more emphasis on their discography, etc. P.S. Creator, if you do see this, please don't take it too personally, but these are just some things that I wanted to say!

[@Rose.to.Spring]

@@DhanbeeSuh he had his own radio show for several years he motivated a lot of artist to write and work of their own songs and music he wrote a lot of shinee songs since young age. his personality is a lot more than the shared on this video ! he is as savage as kibum he is as sweet as onew he is sexy and “swag” too hehe! and he has a lot of things more tbh

[@DhanbeeSuh]

@@Rose.to.Spring Oh yeah, of course! I meant in case a new shawol watched, I’m already a shawol lolol

[@Rose.to.Spring]

@@DhanbeeSuh i can already see you’re an old shaowl by your pfp lol hehe what i meant is , the things i mentioned would be more helpful and more important to mention in a guide like this one instead of what was shown

[@DhanbeeSuh]

@@Rose.to.Spring Yes yes! I apologize for misunderstanding, but you’re absolutely correct !

[@giselacaceres7247]

THEY ARE KINGS...!!!!!!!!!!!!! KINGS KINGS KINGS KINGS KINGS KINGS...

[@myatinyshawol2845]

This is a very good guide..i really appreciate your effort to doing this guide..its bring back all the memories for our lovely SHINee...

[@Joonggrami]

Something i've seen some others mention but not enough, jonghyun's part of this guide was relatively shorter compared to the others and was mainly sad. the other's was pretty detailed especially taemin's. there is so much about him and his talents that weren't highlighted at all and i honestly feel like a much better job could've been done on jonghyun's part.

[@Lena-zn4re]

I think for surface level stuff, there are popular guides out there who do a great job of it. But I think I’m terms of showing newer fans what their personalities and dynamics within the group are, this guide does a far better job explaining. Not only does it highlight all their achievements and talents, but it also explains a lot of the hard work and obstacles each one of them had to go through in order to become as successful and respected as they are now.

[@michellehawk282]

Thank you so much for the positive Feedback. It really means a lot to me because this Guide took me way longer than any other Guide i ever did. This one took a lot of effort so i genuinely appreciate the nice feedback 😊

[@hiddlespearean]

Thank you for your effort. It is an amazingly detailed and compassionate guide.

[@michellehawk282]

You're welcome. I'm glad you enjoyed it 😌

[@tionnenoble7193]

29:54 I screameddd Gosh. I stan such an amazing and talented group. I love SHINee😭😭 uwu

[@xxgurlxx07]

Thank you for making this beautiful guide. I love it!!

[@SusanB101]

Thank you for this beautiful showcase of SHINee the musicians, the artists, the family... even as an established Shawol, I’m still learning and the more I do, the more I love them.

[@KhayRei]

when I saw Onew act in DOTS again...I realised he really good at acting^^ that part really made me cried a lot... excited for his upcoming musical~ and really THANK YOU for making this video..ITS AWESOME^^ THE ONE and ONLY PRINCES OF KPOP SHINee!

[@joammi8753]

amazing! thank you!

[@nykinabilah167]

Why did u use past tense for jjong? I'm so disappointed

[@luiicious]

This guide highlights a lot of aspects of SHINee as a group and individuals. Thank you for making this. This will help people who just knew them recently to understand them more. Thank u. They really taught us to not forgetting about Jjong. Forever shinee is 5, it's just one of them has become an angel and rest peacefully. SHINee's dinamic is so great that it's quite hard to like only one of them. When u get to know them, u literally like every single one of them bcs they are very different in many aspects, it makes u curious about each of them so in the end it's hard to choose ur bias lol imo, SHINee is a very unique group. They never failed to amaze me every single time, even when they go solo they keep surprising me with new things. They are truly amazing. Their energy, their vibes, their hardwork, even seniors give them thumbs up for always giving their all in everything. It's unquestionable that younger idols look up to them. Miss u guys, stay healthy ♡ Waiting for ur amazing activities onew key minho ♡ Taemniii fighting, comeback safe from ur duty and be healthy always ♡ Jonghyun, u'll always be missed be loved and remembered. Rest in love warm and peace ♡

[@TaeminnieLee]

This guide is old now :( there are updated ones. I personally like the one by Michelle Hawk although it has a few small misinformations. It's a bit long though. There's also a fanmade documentary about Taemin as an artist that's very interesting that delves into his artistic mind.

[@loveitftw]

Btw, the Japanese singer that wrote *Rainy Blue* released an album in june this year. The bro can still sing.. very much so. 😐

[@pixiyzduss2877]

this is the best SHINee guide for me, thank you for this beautiful video! i hope this guide get more recognition for those people who want to stan SHINee

[@michellehawk282]

Thank you so much 😊

[@wandawolfe4675]

Jonghyun is sorely missed! It’s beyond my comprehension.

[@keanusoriano8953]

.millions of your FANS missed you,Sir Jong Hyun.rest in peace, we love you

[@sabinacini9357]

Thank you for this beautiful guide. It helps me to discover deeper this extraordinary group of artists. I followed them since few months, but they became my ultimate so faster

[@chloesylloe9877]

Onew sining opera: instant goosebump ♥ thanks a lot for the video!

[@chriscyrus8748]

thank u so much for this guide you showed different sides of the boys and i’m really thankful and happy to see that

[@kmkniu1869]

I believe this story of Taemin being labeled "tone deaf" has been debunked as a myth (afterall, why would an agency sign someone to an idol group if they couldn't sing). Instead, SM waited for his voice to change before giving him heavy vocal parts so his vocal cords wouldn't be damaged (this is what Taemin has been saying in interviews). He was very young at debut after all.

[@satinsleeves]

It's not a myth, Taemin said himself people would call him tone deaf. Also agencies will sign idols on for rapping and dancing in place of singing, there's lot of idols out there that can't sing....

[@IWriteEssaysSorry]

Key and taemin both joined SM on the strength of their dancing. Taemin didn't even want to be a singer. He wanted to be a dancer. Minho was approached by an SM agent bc of his looks alone. The entire group was originally supposed to be a rap group bc they weren't strong singers. These entertainment companies have straight up said looks is the priority, talent can be trained.

[@Br-Ash]

There will always be 5 members......

[@marianakuksoberanis2437]

Thank u!!!! I think that is beautiful! Jonhyungni the person who make me feel a lot of emotion! Onew, Key, Minho and Taemin! They are a stronger human being. 5hinee 4ever!!!! ✨✨✨✨✨&✨

[@snehamusiclover1]

It's my pleasure to support these wonderful artists They are so precious to me And I will always support them And thanks a lot for supporting them till today They are actually the finest and best out there, they are beyond kpop or any tag And as human beings too they are the most amazing idols and their bond is too solid with each other Still they are not acknowledged as much they deserve which really makes me feel bad I wish they would get the acknowledgement and recognition they deserve I'm not saying this coz I'm their admirer,I'm an admirer coz they are legendary in and out

[@juliennees]

thank you for this video :) it felt like it was really in depth, and as a new shawol i appreciate your work in putting this together, in my opinion this is a really good guide !!

[@bread4754]

i miss jonghyun he died he will always be part of shinee

[@Riee1209]

Even shinee not your idol but shinee is idol of yr idol’s

[@thExoticAries]

Shout out to you for getting such high quality clips for this video! It's become so common to get already low quality clips when people create these SHINee videos, so I appreciate you taking time to source high quality/close to original quality clips.

[@Relaxingasmr-zw6nf]

This makes me love 5hinee even more!! Thank you for your hardwork. I hope 5hinee and we shawols always stay together!!

[@nevesevn]

Where is the clip from 35:15 from?

[@lucyordonez651]

Gracias por esta guía hermosa, ellos son más que kpop, ellos son su propia creación , su propia interpretación de lo que es el arte , la calidad, la belleza y la autenticidad todos y cada uno de los 5 miembros de nuestro amado SHINee 🙏💎⚘

[@BTSlove-qx8im]

One of the best SHINee guides I have ever seen, thank you x

[@gautambakshi2063]

29:56 the way Taemin says SHINee's back with that soft smile on his face just hits deeply when you realize how long it had been since he'd said it and just how much he missed saying it.

[@Yijisuu]

“If one of our members would suddenly be gone, my whole world would collapse” that hurt

[@louxd9465]

It's my first guide to SHINEE I new a bit about them and their chemistry I just wanted to say 'that was an amazing guide, the best I've ever seen for any group I've ever watched a guide for. Thank u for taking the time and effort to show and introduece me to them' 🙏🏼🙏🏼🖤👑🖤🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@kmkniu1869]

Jonghyun was my bias and I miss him so much. There isn't another voice like his in KPOP. His high, sustained note in "Stranger" still makes me hold my breath and my soul leave my body. It's a religious experience, go watch a live performance of it here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/gF7GgoZ8mpl9d5I 💎

[@icecreameveryday]

Rewatching every now and then because why not? My day isn't complete without watching a #SHINee 💎✨ video or even another #CHOIMINHO 🔥 related clips 🥰 #MINHO #JONGHYUN #ONEW #KEY #TAEMIN #5HINee forever! Again, thank you so much for your efforts in making this beautiful guide 👏

[@roselifpolis]

Muito obrigada!!! Esperando por um novo SHINee is back em 2023!! 💎💎💎💎💎

[@nancymcgee4776]

Thank u Michelle! That was very well put together, alot of hard work girl. I sure learned a few new things! 🙂

[@Aya-bb9nr]

Waaww This video is amazing . SHINee💚💎

[@vi_noona6113]

A very touching vid. Thank you for your hardwork. SHINee has to be known worldwide. They are extremely great.

[@lisac5579]

Wonderful video! Thank you for all your hard work gathering individual information. Kudos and appreciation!!