Migration & the Manto Family I JS Bank Presents Jugnu Ka Des Season 1 Episode 8

Migration & the Manto Family I JS Bank Presents Jugnu Ka Des Season 1 Episode 8
Jugnu Mohsin speaks to the late prolific artist Shahid Jalal and Suraya Begum about their beloved relative Saadat Hassan Manto and memories of the 1947 partition of India and Pakistan!
This program was recorded five days before the unfortunate passing of Shahid Jalal (1948-2020).
#JugnuKaDes #WatchNa #Manto
Song: Raga Kirwani-Alaap, Jor, and Vilambit Grat
Artist: Shailendra Mishra and Soumitra Lahiri
Subscribe to WatchNa for the best in entertainment!

[@abdulchoudhry9372]

Jugnoo, you are a great lady. You are serving the nation by reminding the past. May Allah bless you best of health.

[@Karmazov]

I am from East Punjab. I am a fan of Jugnu Mohsin. She is well-educated and highly sophisticated, yet she is also very grounded in old Punjabi culture. Her ability to talk in Punjabi, Urdu, and English simultaneously during conversations is remarkable.

[@vinodsingh4971]

Ma’am you conduct this program in an exceptional manner and your kindness and warmth shine through. I guess it’s not a coincidence that linkages to India and shared Hindu Muslim traditions are a part of almost all the episodes. It’s a pleasure. You and your husband are truly an amazing couple. Stay blessed

[@javaidsdar]

acch likha aap ne.

[@naumankabir9842]

Gradually I've become addicted to this very interesting program. Jugnu Mohsin Sahiba is marvelous with her articulate English and theth punjabi.

[@sandcroft2924]

I am loving your interview series thanks for bringing these hidden gems to light. RIP Shahid Jalal .

[@shubhraUtube]

Yes I agree and I read that earlier Jinnah was member of Congress and a simultaneously he became member of Muslim League. He never wanted Muslim state. And he was against partition.. but many other Hindu leaders at that time were interested because of their high ambitions to get Political positions and pressurised to do partition. Sad story it was. I can't find any cultural difference in India and Pakistan we share same history, tastes, foods and rituals. In literature we had been reading stories of Manto. Manto jitne aapke hain utne hi hamare bhi hain. It's also correct many Kashmiris used to migrate to Punjab. Carpet making came with them. Jugnuji I liked your description and presentation. It has always been very nostalgic.

[@raimohsinraza]

I wish to live in this great subcontinent as one unit. Free to go from the great Himalaya to the Kanyakumari Beach.

[@shubhraUtube]

@@raimohsinraza really I also wish that again all these three countries become one again. Then there will be no fights.

[@rari_driver]

Not really. Colonial british raj was quite an artificial state and so would've been its successor mega state. We have to remember that different nations lived under kingdoms in South Asia even before the british raj. I know people like to romanticize a "subcontinent" state but its just that i.e. romanticization not reality. As far culture is concenerned there are many differences but you have to look at them with glasses of reality not nostalgia. While punjabis in pk may share links with sikhs in india they don't with rest of the india.

[@rari_driver]

@@raimohsinraza maybe you speak for punjabis but not for rest of the ethnicities in pakistan.

[@javaidsdar]

and same dna as well. aap bohot khubsurat likha.

[@irfantoysworld3919]

I am addicte of monto Sab frm south India

[@asharmirza]

ALLAH pak shahid jalal sahab ki maghfirat farmaien..Aameen Superb episode

[@zaheermahmood6287]

ماشاء اللہ، زبردست پروگرام ہے، نہ صرف تاریخ سے آگاہی ہوتی ہے، بلکہ گمنام اور فراموش کرده لوگوں کو دوبارہ متعارف کروایا جا رہا ہے، keep it up Mhotarma Jugnoo.

[@sharifaroy5213]

Jug nu ji, your programme is very interesting as well as informative. I really enjoy watching it. I am from Mumbai, but love Pakistan and do wish I can visit it someday. Just a small request, when you speak in Punjabi, please give a translation. I miss a lot of important information. All the best with a lot of more such programmes.

[@saniak5466]

We enjoy her punjabi , reminds me of my Nani and nana ji who migrated from gujrawala during partition

[@sharifaroy5213]

Sania K Saniaji, it sounds lovely. But goes over my head. Anyway, I still like the show.

[@jaisinghpunia3078]

Very interesting keep it continue.

[@KM-vn9mj]

Jugnu Mam, If you know my mother’s grandfather ( dada), Haji Munshi Nizamuddin, his name and picture in top 100 Kashmiri families. He was the founder of Anjuman e himayat e Islam. Two of his son in laws were Ministers, I remember one name Malik khuda Bukhsh Bucha. My mom tells me that he he used to work as Accountant General for Rani of Bhopal. He was a very influential person in India but did not claim much when he migrated to Pakistan. He managed all accounts of Pakistan movement. Please do let me know if you know our family. Infact, my mom said that her dada ‘s picture is still in Islamia College Lahore.

[@nazlone]

I wish the whole interview was in Punjabi.... Jugnu has a charming way about.

[@341sunnyjudge]

Agree

[@nothing-vh4nw]

Nuzhat Manto graduated from F.C. College Lahore with us in 1965/66. I was Science Student while She was in Arts subjects. Latter in Jan 1966 I joined Packages till 1978 in Paper Mill. I am still associated with Packages for Business. Honorable SBA is my Mentor and SHA very kind for business with Packages. Another relation with this family ,which I have never exploited, is that Mr Mehdi Shah Sb was real mammon of my mother-in-law ( Mrs Asif Bashir of Sialkot) and SHA is married to Mamaa Taji Shah's daughter (grand daughter of Mehdi Shah Sb). Syed Amjad Ali

[@1saffron]

Wow! Thanks for sharing!

[@ifthikarifthikar6737]

Nice information and so loveable comment thanks sir

[@amitsethi1786]

Nice video love from Delhi 🌹💐...

[@Mirzabeigistocool]

I’m thanking you dear it’s take me toh my childhood when I’m living in monhi road near bhati gate student of cathedral high school church road backside off Lahore museum wow still feels the same when I’m watching any of your videos 💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕😘😘😘😘😘😘😘

[@AhmadRaza-fp2he]

Salute to Mantoo family for their great achievements in Sub-continent. Kashmiris feel proud of them.

[@nothing-vh4nw]

I heard about Sad demise of Mr Shahid Jalal---2 days back via Facebook. Innalillah wa Inna elayhe Rageoon!

[@saminaahmad4679]

جگنو آپ کے پروگرام بہت بہت اچھے ھوتے ھیں بہترین پروگرام ھیں کچھ دیر کے لیے ھم پہلے وقتوں میں چلے جاتے ہیں جو کہ خوبصورت ترین وقت تھا ویسے بھی آپ مھجے بہت پسند ھیں

[@spicemela8156]

I love your way of interviewing 👍great jugnu mam

[@exploretheglobe686]

Madam i am mesmerised by your eloquence. Great work

[@mauroofsultan6887]

Golden. Times. Gone

[@ayeshasharif4476]

Very nice show I'm big fan of jugnu

[@KM-vn9mj]

My mom also told me that her father was a very handsome man, he was approached by Pari chehra , who was Dilip Kumar wife’s Saira bano mother . But my mothers grandfather stopped him from joining movies stating kanjar kahlawao gay hamain.

[@uniquecookingwithaasma8456]

JUGGNO ANTY I like ur style....great personality..

[@sabakiran2265]

Kamal ka interview tha Jugnu Mem i really wanna met u . Am impressed by ur prsnlty .. lovely human

[@akhlaqkhan949]

Refugee camp was in malerkotla only muslim princely state in E punjab

[@Academia545]

The Anchor Jugnu Mohsin is doing very well.Being a student of Geography , History and political Science ,I personally appreciate this channel. One thing I would like to suggest is ,as this is watched nationally and globally by urdu lovers,so urdu may not be tuned in to punjabi. Punjabi is not understood by all.

[@Peerzadasajid]

Jugnu Sabina you are superb.This program is superb. God has blessed you with superb qualities of head and heart.I am lucky to live in your age.

[@rehanaqamar7989]

Mashaallah what a show simply beautiful.

[@fauziayaqoob4260]

Jugnu you are doing great work

[@mrbilal4151]

Bhut khushi hoi app kay mamoo ka interview

[@muhammadsalimakhtarnatldir3974]

Splendid. Thanks

[@HassanAli-pr4ze]

Strong stories

[@hifzafaisal8534]

Love to see that we have people to be proud off!!!!!!!!!

[@ایڈاتوں]

بہت ہی اچھا پروگرام ہے جن لوگوں کے سراغ میں آپ پروگرام کر رہی ہیں لاہور کے یہ لوگ کہاں گم ہو گیے ہیں کاش یہ لوگ واپس اپنے اپنے مال کے فلیٹس میں یا بلڈنگز دوبارہ رہائیش پذیر ہوجائیں

[@nasreensheikh6403]

So beautiful

[@manasir5620]

very intresting informative historic rememberance programme

[@HS-gt1qf]

Loved her Punjabi - towards the end

[@baijitechnical5127]

Wow.. Well I recently started to watch your interviews n must I say that am mesmerised.. Awesome

[@burhanalisajjad2048]

Remarkable Work Jugnu Apa !! Taking on your own family legacy (SyedMaratibAli Family) as well as of other dignatories!

[@carpe._diem]

Love the show Jugnu g one of the most intellectual women of Pakistan.. I want to see this kind of intellectual people more they present a very different picture of Pakistan and Pakistani culture and take somewhere else and tell how rich our culture is.... Oops sorry *was

[@zulqarnin5362]

Your interviews are very informative especially I learn a lot of Unique English words thanks Jugnu Ji

[@saniatayyab7557]

It is very interesting and eye opening interview about saadat Hassan manto. Students like me get alot of important facts about our history. Keep it madam jugnu .

[@aslamhayat2276]

jugnu bas cha kar you have done a lot

[@amulyamishra5745]

Manto jaisa koi nahi hoga shayad aage bhi

[@saniak5466]

Thank you for the interview

[@bilalkamyana8944]

گل بات ہور وی سوہنی تے نگہی لگدی جے کدی پنجابی وچ ہوندی ،،،میرا صلاح اے کہ کجھ پروگرام پنجابی وچ کیتے جاون تاکہ اسی اوس ویلے دی پنجابی دا ورتارہ تے لہجے جان سکیے

[@shahbazzahid2302]

Baji tusi great ho..

[@pp-xg8ub]

Jugno Mohsin you are very very intelligent lady proud of you

[@hshakeem]

Wonderful.

[@debashreemishra895]

Kattar hindu..wow madamji. Spreading much love. Btw see now, we kattar hindus made many muslims superstars🙏

[@rari_driver]

they also burned their widows so ...

[@341sunnyjudge]

I love your Punjabi Jugnu jee

[@babaranwar5462]

Very beautiful paintings

[@Ahsannn]

Begum sahiba is such a cute and lovely lady 😍😍😍😍😍♥️♥️♥️

[@sairamalik1572]

I love the way Jugnu relates her self with people speaking punjabi & come down to their level, absolutely awesome, Jugnu thank you for producing such a informative programme, our new generation need to know what traumatic time people went through during partition, some thing different than just singing national anthem/songs. Great job👌🥰💕

[@ibrahimzeb4146]

Sorry Punjabi is not a level down she changes communication tools whenever is needed

[@princebabar4772]

Excellent

[@ayeshaiqbal4927]

Very interesting!!!

[@tahirbaig3453]

Is there any interview of Nawaz Shareef's family in your serials? Any body know

[@rubinatariq9692]

Jugno i like your personality way of talking and dresses

[@sardarbootasingh2708]

Jugnu has a class. I was posted in Kashmir thus understand this family pretty well and also understand Kashmir Valley and her people. Saadat Hasan Manto was the greatest; that is most creative of this clan. What is the origin of Manto? He was from the Kashmiri Central Asian Aryan ethnicity background of Kashmiri Hindus whose ancestor had converted to Semitic-Islam a great religion like any other. There is a foreign agenda to mix Punjab with Kashmir or vice-versa for the future agenda of some foreigners and we know who they are! I am a proud Jat-Sikh and also proud Punjabi and might mention Punjabis are distinct from Kashmiris and vice-versa. None is superior both are great but do not mix them as this is absolute rubbish. A Punjabi can not understand Kashmiri and vice-versa and also little similarity in looks, food, culture, etc. The Indian subcontinent is a diverse one yet colorful and will stay that way. In his letter to Pandit Nehru Manto wrote he felt proud being a Kashmiri and Kashmiris are a beautiful nation. In my opinion so is Punjab and other regions of our subcontinent. This is genuine Kashmir for you people living in Pakistan: kzbin.info/www/bejne/m5_IpWOdgZllq5I

[@saniatayyab7557]

اور اللّٰہ تعالیٰ شاہد صاحب کی مغفرت فرمائے۔ امین

[@ManshaQazi]

خدا وہ روز بد دشمن کو بھی نہ دکھلائے قفس کے سامنے جلتا تھا اشیاں اپنا

[@KOOPISLANDBLUES1]

Eminent artist Shahid Jalal passed away on Tuesday, surrounded by his loved ones. He was 72.

[@sandcroft2924]

😮😮

[@mrbilal4151]

Khush reho

[@Sskaushik878]

..manto enjoyed much success in Bombay!he was part of a close cirlce of the Bombay talkies!!hobnobbing with the elite of Bombay film industry... including star Ashok Kumar!!what happened to him after he migrated everyone knows ...I cannot count the no.of muslim artist who chose india..and became successful ..their work looked upto and loved by Indians till today...his friend shyam kept sending him money orders much after he had left !!Manto mde a mistake by migrating...

[@Sskaushik878]

@@Goku-zc8tp no I'm not these are facts...he was given an ice factory as compensation on arrival in Pakistan...in partnership that is!!with almost no income....he suffered badly...why his relative didn't give a clear yes /no when asked whether Manto wanted to return?he can clearly be seen stammering on being asked about it!!! his friend ismat chugtai stayed in india and was very successful!!and here they r discussing 'kattar hindu'....was hindu kattar?did hindu asked for a seperate state for muslims becoz they r 'different'...did hindu ordered direct action day ,which killed millions of hindu on streets of bengal? People responsible for partition must rot in hell ,they have blood of millions on their hands...innocent suffered..looted ,raped and displaced...and they wanted Pakistan to be democratic and secular ..lol...look what if is now

[@amitprabhu2069]

Jugnu ji.. With due respect 14 Aug is not Pakistan's Independence day but formation day. There was no Pakistan before 15 Aug 1947 and no Pakistan under British rule. It was India that was ruled by various dynasties including the British. You can ckearly find this if yoh go through the Indian Independence Act 1947.

[@shaukatsaleem3597]

Jugnu madam Ap na Saadat manto shb ka bra bhaio ka ni pocha.Apko in sa pta krna chaia tha saadat shb ke all family ka.

[@sanjeevchadha4467]

Interesting interview. But they portray Hindus in bad light. Hindus of Pakistan who migrated to India leave behind rich heritage.

[@qureshi701]

Kashmiris brought glory and culture in Punjab long before independence, without the contribution of Kashmiris Punjab would have been nothing but just an agricultural culture.

[@saminahayat9826]

Ayesha jalal ne Quaid-eAzam k buht against likha ha...iski writing egr Pakistan mn common ho jai tu sirf nafrat hi phaile gi....Ayesha jalal k naam k baad interview se dil hi uth gia.

[@humairamalik8893]

Yay tou koee khon kee ultee karnaey walo Kay biwi/bacho say pochaey Kay woh kitna azeem Insaan haiN......#manto

[@farahdeba1017]

AP to slam b nei krti

[@dipakdasgupta2527]

It was a very interesting show. You talked quite elaborately about Sadat Hussain Manto. But you were quite silent about his grand daughter Ayesha Jalal's husband Sugats Bose , Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose's grand son professor of history in Harvard USA. Shall be highly obliged if you could put some light on this side. As regards partition it is a fact MA Jinnah wantef to make an Islamic state and all his statement that in Pakistan state and religion will not have any relation and everybody is free to practice his religion is all false . Jinnah snd only Jinnah is responsible for the devastation of Partition. You can get the true story from the book JINNAH , success and failure by Dr Istiaq Ahmed published from Penguin India.

[@rari_driver]

Nothing wrong with partitioning a colonial state. It was already "partitioned" before the anglos conquered it and amalgamated into a kingdom. For example my grandfather lived in separate Sindh under a Sindhi kingdom called talpurs. About 80-90 years before 1947 they were conquered by the British and merged with British India. Ever since then we were hoping to be again be free from the colonial state and we got the chance in 47. We don't need a permission from say a marathi, bihari, mallus etc to do this you know.

[@irfanhuq5918]

If you want to read about Jinah then read by Volpeet or by Jaswant Singh available in India. Jinnah was secular from head to toe

[@dipakdasgupta2527]

@@irfanhuq5918 Jinnah's secularism was all drama. After 1940.he became communal head to toe. He wanted an Islamic nation that's why he created Pakistan. He encouraged direct action plan for great Calcutta killing of 16th August of 1946 to demand seperate muslim country. After the division when there was massive pogrom in west Punjab and to retaliate it India started the same operation in east Punjab then he realised by the load of refugee Pakistan will collapse. To avoid that he gave that speech in Pakistan everybody is free to practice his own religion and state is independent of religion. He gave that speech also to give a message to congress in India that Hindus are safe in Pakistan so don't drive out muslims from India. So his entire speech was drama. Because of his double standard doing PhD or MPhil on Jinnah was not allowed in Pakistan. To know about Jinnah you don't have to read a book by a foreigner. You will get true information from a book written by a muslim of Pakistan, Dr. Istiaq Ahmed, published by Penguin , India. This book will be available in Pakistan from September 2020.

[@irfanhuq5918]

@@dipakdasgupta2527 It is obvious you are manufacturing your own facts and writing your own history . you can own interpretation but you cannot on the facts. What is so great about the killing of Calcutta and what is solittle about killing of Noakhali.and what about the killing and riots s that happen in Bihar where Nehru Patel everyone attended after the massacar and Jinah's speech was an 11th August 1947 addressing the constituent assembly ,4 it before the independence. And what is wrong by reading a book by a foreigner and what about jaswant Singh your foreign minister who wrote 700 pages on Jinah The problem is that your mind is impregnated with hate the same as Modi, the person with fascist ideology who was member of RSS which followed Gustapo in uniform and behaviour. All the advances that India had made all these years were because of the 60 years of Congress. You had Manmohan Singh The economist and many other leaders. you are silent about the killing in Gujrat which was by the chief minister at that time the present day Modi. read some books and improve your understanding of the history. But if you are reading only to reinforce the Hatred that you have in your heart then it is hard to discuss anything with you , also how did you get a hold of a book on Jinnah by a Pakistani which is not available in Pakistan yet that is little surprising to me and I would like to know the answer.

[@irfanhuq5918]

By the way the granddaughter of Netaji(his brothers) Sarmila Bose(an indian writer), has written a book dead reckoning about creation of Bangladesh and what happened there you should read it but it would be hard for you to Digest.

[@saltwithlemon2507]

Very nice let’s support each other on youtube channels 💕

[@muhammedawan4414]

Really Jinnah was a stooge of British empire

[@sabihasajjad6244]

Saw and listened a woman interviewing , well she set certain standards ,yes according to her intelligence 😝. Let’s see Butto ---- a womanizer, habitual liquor consumer ,split the country in TWO ==== A SB

[@sabihasajjad6244]

And General Zia , a man who prayed five Nawaz, plus Tahajad regularly , a very pious man ,never touched liquor ,brought a decent look to woman ,an Islamic couture in country ,He even refused a dinner party while his visit to USA ,saying have some important things to attend , Naturally they suspicious and set their cameras ,saw the man praying whole night ,😢 ====. Listen how the woman is addressing him in her interview 🧐🧐🧐. Yes she has a right ,having her own piece of BRAIN , Wonder how she herself will be JUDGED by the All MIGHTY on the day of judgement 😜

[@ashrafsubhan8891]

Not many interested in this family.

[@mushtaqqureshi2437]

Can you speak Urdu Madam.

[@KhalidJYusuf]

انگریزی نہ بولو تو آپ کا حسن بڑھ جاتا ھے

[@ppp7236]

Jugnu bibi it seems that you are against partition. You live in past. Allah shukar we have our country. Don't be shy of being Muslim.

[@abcmdeffghil]

you are right. these have nothing to do with Muslim issues just their businesses.

[@HS-gt1qf]

@@abcmdeffghil you can’t deny the price of partition was high - millions of people died especially Punjabis

[@tahiriqbalkhan4002]

انگریزوں کی باقیات اور حال کی اشرافیہ 😅😢