Minecraft Makes Zero Sense

[@Knarfy]

Get urself a new PC and support me in the process: apexpartner.app/redirect/Knarfy Also hit da sub button and leave a comment about another illogical Minecraft feature!

[@Knarfy]

Yes this comment is from like 3 days ago 🤫 I'm on vacation at the time this video is posted so I planned ahead :3

[@jedrekfiolog5298]

Hi Knarfy🤗🙂

[@DillonerOG]

Can I have shoutout plz

[@VOID_Prince]

If you take the video to 7 minutes and 7 seconds you will see you and obsidian Among Us lol sus

[@kaylebfeary2789]

In bedrock you actually drown in lava

[@pikajade]

the reason milk removes the bad omen effect is because the illagers see you down a whole bucket of milk like a champ and realize they don't want to mess with you

[@memelord8769]

Raw milk no less

[@kitsicles111]

Straight from the source is the best kind!

[@rereplayz7275]

Exactly

[@just5fornow]

An entire cubic meter of milk, gone in less than 5 seconds.

[@IdoNotLiveInOhio]

Real

[@EcoOvergrowth]

The camels eating cactus one actually makes perfect sense. Actual camels can eat cactus by rotating the cactus while chewing, allowing them to distribute the pressure points of the cactus through their whole mouths allowing them to consume the cactus with no issue.

[@floppapal3545]

I was bouta say, very true

[@clockforsure]

stop being so smart my brain can't comprehend this can u please explain is simpler way

[@EcoOvergrowth]

​@@clockforsure It spins the cactus around in it's mouth in order to not get pricked so it can eat the cactus.

[@lasercraft32]

They also have tough skin around mouths that helps protect them from the spines when they bite them.

[@liamrapanan9434]

@@EcoOvergrowth true

[@GlorifiedToaster1]

The reason that lava and water make different things is because of the way they cooled. If the source block of lava is hotter than the edges. Obsidian is when it cools from very hot to cold very fast. And stone, just look at Hawaii or some other volcanic islands. Camels eat cacti irl, it's not that they are immune but that their mouth is specialized for eating cacti.

[@philid0r]

Yeah I was also thinking that and also 7:07 amogus

[@TheLastGuest2008]

@@philid0r AMONG US

[@VenusYoutube1]

BRUUUHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH NOOO WAYEYEYEYEY@@philid0r

[@sasakohilaki5701]

Hmmmmmmmm very interesting 🧐

[@Rednightmar3]

YES ANOTHER INTELLIGENT PERSON YAY

[@wolfyowiefae1754]

This may be a bit random but technically obsidian and stone are all made by lava, it just depends on how quickly the lava cools, so the Minecraft mechanic sorta makes sense. The thing that always confused me though is that obsidian is a type of glass. Like shatters if you hit it too hard glass…

[@Echo_the_half_glitch]

Yeah. Also, why don't we have an obsidian dagger or arrow recipe that has low durability but high damage. Maybe crafted with shards of obsidian (Gotten when an obsidian block is broken, and the blocks can be crafted with shards.)

[@pncka]

My theory is that a cubic meter of obsidian is really tough, and glass blocks are just hollow

[@Zackfish12345]

@@Echo_the_half_glitchwhat if it shattered when you use a sub diamond picks. It would take longer to get and make your high damage tools really valuable. Once you get fortune and a lava farm it would be easy, but still precious in early game

[@Mikustan39]

⁠@@Zackfish12345I actually really like that idea. I’d rather not have to get silk touch on a diamond pick and that way you could at least get something if you don’t have diamonds yet.

[@happysmilesworldandgames8755]

13:20 when theres no rendered ground below you, you can see the sun or the moon below you

[@thegatekeep]

Fun fact, in education edition, if you check the contents of redstone it has a ton of nuclear material and also a ton of other stuff that apparently isn't on our periodic table.

[@Zantheman5680]

Uhhhhhh so I should stop using a mod where I can eat ores?

[@Starspy11279]

yes @@Zantheman5680

[@NezuNeedsTea]

@@Zantheman5680 if you're eating redstone with that mod, yes, you should, anything else and I think you'll be fine

[@Zantheman5680]

@@NezuNeedsTea so eat emeralds. Understood

[@DovahGirlie]

​@@NezuNeedsTeaOh good, I always wanted to eat five bowls of coal soup for one meal.

[@Inkyplant]

Mushroom Milk? no… Deceased Cow Milk!

[@HenryPlays923]

Why

[@Wisdomdust]

@@HenryPlays923Everything

[@bonnetmagalie3403]

😐

[@Inkyplant]

@@Wisdomdust so true, your wisdom is not a lie

[@lucy-zt2dx]

Steve uses his hand to scoop water out of the cauldron to wash the dye off the armor.

[@GuyllianVanRixtel]

The Sun Moon thing sorta works. If you go far enough past the border, you will just phase through the blocks.

[@timotheusrytter-johansen1713]

and theres the void so that is where the sun and moon go to the other side of the world

[@BoldfaceVeil370]

the earth is flat🙂🙃🙂🙃🙂🙃🙂🙃

[@ShinduBoi]

@@BoldfaceVeil370 bruh it's 2023

[@eftimij_codes]

On bedrock

[@ShinduBoi]

​@@BoldfaceVeil370I subscribed to ur channel

[@johnm9263]

i think the idea is that the leaves arent just leaves, they have "branches" which is why you get sticks when breaking them occasionally also, stone is when the lava goes ON TOP of ANY water, cobblestone is where moving lava gets cooled by water, and obsidian.... the lava source

[@RouxTheKitsune]

Somone needs to make a "desire paths" mod nammed after the actual phenomenon. And the way it would work is Each entity has a "weight multiplier" or "G" based off how heavy they are And it would be calculated on how tall and wide they are in blocks. The player is 1x2 blocks, so they weigh 2G However the iron golem is 2x4, so its weight is 8G Now every grass block has a value of how long it takes for it to change states, and lets say this value is "HP" So every grass block is 150 HP Every time a mob steps on a grass block, its HP is reduced by 1, multiplied by "G" So every step a player takes deals 2 damage to that number Meaning if a player steps on the same grass block 75 times, it will turn into a grass path ALSO every block is like "refreshed" in the morning in minecraft Every day the block regenerates +10HP So if you trampled grass, it has a chance of growing back Also you can bonemeal blocks at lowered HP to gain between 1-90 HP per bonemeal Once a Grass block becomes a path block, it once again has 150HP, however once it hits zero it becomes coarse dirt. Once it makes it there, theres no growing grass there ever again unless you replace the block with dirt. Other things that could happen is if a mob is wet while the block transitions it has a chance of turning into mud ALSO the same thing could happen to stone eccept stone wont repar, not even at in the mornings Stone also has 250 HP But once stone is walked on enough it becomes cobblestone, and cobblestone thats walked on enough becomes gravel. Also maybe the bricks variants can have 350 HP and be turned into Cracked bricks after being walked on enough AND All blocks that can deteriorate now have "petrified" versions that can be crafted with a "Petrification Table" It uses your levels to turn 2 normal blocks into petrified blocks And the list of blocks that can have this desire path effect will be limited Grass/Podzzol/Mycelum -> Grass Path - > Coarse Dirt Dirt -> Coarse Dirt Stone -> Cobblestone -> Gravel Sandstone -> Sand (Maybe something in-between) Blackstone -> Cobbled Blackstone -> (Maybe gravel, or just end it here) Deepslate -> Cobbled Deepslate -> (Maybe gravel, or just end it here) Stone Bricks -> Cracked Stone Bricks -> Cobblestone -> Gravel Netherbricks -> Cracked Nether Bricks -> (Maybe netherack, or just end it here) Soulsand -> Soulsoul

[@Dohkoh4]

4:44 this is just utah in a nutshell

[@RouxTheKitsune]

​@@Dohkoh4 I have friends from fnafland And I can agree

[@alecthe2nd]

Puts on Geology and Chemistry hat: the different blocks produced when water hits lava in different ways is analogous to how it works in the real world. When lava meets water, the crystalline structure of the stone made depends on how the water and lava interacted. Because if this, igneous rocks in a given place are made of the same general mix of materials.

[@__arc5030]

What about the other igneous rocks in the game? Basalt is the rapid cooling of lava and already has a generator but what about tuff andesite or granite?

[@alecthe2nd]

@@__arc5030 those are metamorphic rock, if I remember correctly

[@__arc5030]

@@alecthe2nd ah ok

[@HardeepSingh-mp5oh]

That amogus at 7:07 was sneaky

[@HadenBoru]

Mogus

[@ozpinoychannel4002]

susy baka 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@t.kersten7695]

the Librarian selling enchanted books to the players could still make a bit of sense, just because you have to pay him not only in emeralds but give him an empty book too. and so the Librarian can write the magic spells into that new empty book which turns it into a new magic book ready to sell.

[@snabbedoll4531]

Maybe the emeralds have magical properties which only the Librarian has the intelligence to use.

[@Desertdustcat]

or he just uses the book on his head

[@amandastephens5776]

i believe it might have to do with the wandering trader after all he one of the only mobs that use potions other than the witch. Librarian: You got the goods. Wandering trader(comes out of invis): Yeah, a couple of enchanted books like you asked. Librarian: Good, here's payment. Wandering trader: You sure you don't want me to get you out of there. Librarian(trapped in villager farm): Nah, I'm good I'm safe here anyway.

[@PorpleBladeYT]

that makes more sense cos now ik that they scam u you on purpose

[@snabbedoll4531]

@@amandastephens5776 So that means the reason the wandering trader only sells trash, is because he gives the goods to the villagers.

[@Reggie-The-Monke]

You can drink honey, craft a honey block with 4 honey bottles, so, Steve can drink ¼ of a cubic meter block, or 1.3 of an gallon of honey...

[@Just-echo7674]

13:17 april fools update: the moon exists, and i am pretty sure the minecraft earth was visible from there

[@eluminator04]

12:07 correct me if I am wrong, but as far as I know Camels and other cacti-eating animals have a really thick saliva so they can eat it without getting hurt by their spikes but that doesn‘t make their whole body immune to them

[@thefbinevercatchme]

Yes

[@moewCalv]

Correct they said this in Minecraft Live.

[@makeandcode]

And alwso the interior of there mouth is buff af

[@dracahismail]

About the creeper disc one, the creeper disc must be stored in the creeper's body, but since the whole body turns to ashes when it dies, the disc also does. So if a skeleton shoots a creeper, it pierces the skin in that specific area, which then seperates that part from the body, allowing the disc to be obtained.

[@eshan-does]

Where did you learn that from?

[@Lukas99g]

ok but whats stopping a player from using a bow (or a pillager/piglin from using a crossbow) to get the disc then

[@Therandomduck8]

@@Lukas99gskeletons are such bad shots only they would hit right there

[@Lukas99g]

@@Therandomduck8 skeletons are NOT bad shots (i swear they have aimbot or something because they always hit me)

[@Therandomduck8]

@@Lukas99g no u bad

[@ProdigyMaster100]

12:52 So THAT’S what caves are for. Huh.

[@Foet555]

0:02 brown cow

[@Donzi_zidon]

@@Foet555 you know they exist in real life right?

[@Donzi_zidon]

They exist irl u know write

[@Foet555]

@@Donzi_zidon yea

[@Foet555]

@@Donzi_zidon but being stuck by lightning and it turning isn’t

[@Foet555]

@@Donzi_zidon 11 months ago lol

[@too_much_time]

They should add the milk bottle but make it only remove one status effect randomly and it stacks to 4 or 8

[@KrydrogensNull]

the one affect thing reminds me of farmers delight milk bottle

[@Misha_Katsuki]

@@KrydrogensNull 😂

[@AM9436.]

I actually remember there was a mod (don't ask me for the name or where to find it, I sadly can't remember) that made it that when you rode an animal or walked over a path often enough and long enough it would turn the grass into grass paths

[@JoeTheGreat]

what was the name of it? :)

[@coldroc_]

what was the name of it? :)

[@056weom]

its called automatic path

[@ToonedMinecraft]

Sounds like something Immersive Weathering might have but I am not sure

[@ImSonith]

Repeaters are like voltage transformers where it requires a voltage to increase or decrease the power level.

[@livvyplays5558]

I can explain the cauldron. Basically a water bottle takes more since you fill it with water. When dying leather, it uses less since it’s only absorbing a tiny bit to be colored.

[@geraldballinger6428]

from all that milk, steve must have near unbreakable bones

[@gl1tchcat]

I love how Knarfy has his own Knarfy verse with his second channel 😂

[@CraftyMasterman]

I'm a geologist

[@billybonkers244]

Yes Yes you are

[@IvanBedfordKlimentiev]

"applause"

[@rederowyxdd5405]

Ok

[@labby_brawlstars]

congratulations! here is your achievement “how the hell do you power dust”

[@JoshThePotato]

@@CraftyMasterman dope! :)

[@Hipposgrumm]

At least the lava one makes sense on bedrock. Air bubbles appear when swimming in lava on bedrock.

[@alfie8Studios]

You sir have commented what I was gonna comment, good job 👍

[@ajjms4715]

I think the librarian villagers just write their enchanted books themselves with their lecterns, using the enchanting table language

[@kingofpigi]

10:40 book villager writes book for emeralds

[@Turtle-gb1nf]

‏‪6:59‬‏ The obsidian looks like among us

[@The-fg2mq]

I think he meant to do that lol

[@ItsK5YT]

Knarfy is gonna turn into Game Theory

[@spades952]

yea lol i watch that

[@spades952]

@Averagejjbaenjoyer-ly9xx yea🤣🤣🤣

[@rosemarydavis6536]

Like I must keep 69

[@HyperNightGalaxy]

2:48 - 3:35 It actually makes sense for milk to go in a bucket, because it’s common in real life. The thing that makes no sense however, is that Steve drinks those 1.5 litres of milk in a shorter period of time than I can drink 15 times less milk.

[@Stray0]

Petition to have a death message "Player died in lava while also drowning"

[@Villager_Nerd]

"it should only be obsidian"... rip cobblestone generators

[@JustMoss821]

For the villagers not getting stuff, there is a chance you can see wandering traders walking thru villages and talking to the villagers

[@empplayz]

Knarfy trying to get a creeper killed, by skeletons, was just incredible, Great job Also gotta love knarfy 2

[@realfreshmint]

Fr

[@Cherry-edits.]

You can feed a wolf bones but you can’t feed a dog bones yet it still tilts it’s head

[@nevaansbooks2078]

10:34 What if all of the villages were originally branches of a giant villager mafia that robbed travelers and hoarded wealth, but eventually the mafia was forgotten and they were left with giant stocks of supplies that they carry around in their infinite pockets? This just seems to add more questions.

[@OkayIW]

11:09 they do turn into witches when struck with lightning 🤔

[@HarmonyMoonbeam024]

12:11 Actually, the Minecraft world is not in fact infinite. A Minecraft KZbinr by the name of Squiddo tested this I think last year, and found there is a point in Minecraft where the world can no longer generate. I forgot how many blocks you have to go out to find the end of a Minecraft world, but it is A LOT and will make your computer lag like crazy

[@kijanka0_0]

OMG I LOVE SQUIDDOOO once i got to her video with a fanart :D

[@wardengamer374]

AntVenom also tested this in modern Minecraft. Soon the chunks stop generating and the player gets stuck forever.

[@ThyLord-kv5bf]

It's not infinite in practise, but in the lore and stuff like that, it is. This isn't all in practise.

[@HarmonyMoonbeam024]

@@kijanka0_0 Which one was it! I’d love to go find it

[@takiallahjamai]

but, but theres a border

[@MiloMoiloLointzo]

Can we all wish luck to the villager at 5:33

[@HoB_PN]

7:05 Bro created Among Us

[@BrantonFasola]

11:03 for some reason the position of the lecture makes my brain give up.

[@Hazord_]

6:50 that’s literaly how different rocks are made in real life

[@Hazord_]

10:44 the librarians get the book from their head

[@Hazord_]

12.04 camels have freely mouthes irl and that’s how they eat cactus. (They literaly eat cactus irl)

[@nnyctoo]

4:24 * angry fish sounds * (undretal referenc)

[@Foran98]

13:48 Breathing is overrated

[@Ciaoi2349]

Agreed

[@MM-JAW]

How to break minecraft: Set a world edit position anywhere, go thousands of blocks away, go up 100 blocks, set position 2, //set anyblock (Water will probably crash instantly)

[@warriorsabe1792]

About the stone thing: different rocks can be made of the same stuff, for example, the only difference between andesite and diorite is how quickly it was cooled from lava Also, things with mushrooms growing out might not be dead, they may be like those parasitic fungi that take over ant brains and control them to do their bidding like zombies with mushrooms growing out of their head - so those mooshrooms might actually be having a pretty awful time

[@gimok2k5]

And at 5:40 we see that Knarfy doesn't understand the gravity of the situation.

[@emeraldbaby3191]

Ba-dun-tss

[@silly_willyYT]

idea: put minecraft into a brewing stand and drink it. actually nevermind, make it lingering and stand in it and see what happens

[@marshaenderheart]

He sorta did that one

[@silly_willyYT]

ok i got a new one

[@marshaenderheart]

@@silly_willyYT interesting, nice one

[@Kuartle]

3:30 *happy Dani noises*

[@hilesterhi1168]

No, villagers get their books from fishermen... The fishermen throw them at speeds faster than light these books with extreme accuracy by knowing their exact position using x-ray! Imma right boys??

[@RTW_Vex]

To break Minecraft, place 5 million tnt than a repeating command block that spawns withers and another command block that when the wither spawns, it spawns enter dragons

[@SparkyAndZippy]

Thank you so much Knarfy for inspiring me and other creators. Without you i wouldn't be making videos! Thank you brother!!!

[@inrusane_n]

fun fact: you can actually drown in lava in bedrock

[@GabrielGohier]

??? I play on bedrock and i didint knew that

[@East_GermanyBFFC57]

this video is amazing keep it up Knarfy❤

[@RoxImagineOfficial]

Actually... Camels Have A Special Digestive System To Eat Thorny Plants.

[@cairo-araya]

he thought he was slick with that amogus at 7:06

[@AdrielLoboz]

make "Knarfy think's you're a geologist" into a copypasta

[@MusicalCookie923]

When you think about it, moos grooms are just cows from The Last Of Us

[@brightfaith12]

The Minecraft world isn't infinite - past the world border, it just ENDS.

[@makeandcode]

12:00 camels have a mouth that is super durable that cant be harmed my cactus to it does make sense

[@ritreewilson4579]

Being able to breathe in lava is Java exclusive. On Bedrock, you cannot breathe in lava.

[@Nakaishaweigert]

10:28 maybe it's the wandering traders. Maybe they are not traders but collectors giving out scraps. Also sup knarfy

[@superNova5837]

10:09 weird stuff I’ve seen with water and lava In some seeds you’ll just have flowing water but no water source Lava from ruined portals that spawn underwater (how and why did it end up underwater) not turning to obsidian Also when you load new chunks the lava starts flowing like a player just placed a source How can a bucket hold lava but can’t survive in lava HOW IS STEVE ABLE TO CARRY AA BUCKET OF LAVA ANYWAYS?!? How does drip stone somehow able to make infinite lava Why are infinite water sources possible

[@itzfloppaplayz]

7:07 IDK I THINK AMOGUS ATE THE LOGIC?

[@justbella_gc]

Its also hilarious to me how if you punch a villager they'll get annoyed but if you lock them in a 1×1 without food, water, or a bed for the rest of their lives they're totally chill with you

[@CertifiedCoffeeAddict]

The sun plowing through the ground explains the random caves all around

[@appliedbss]

7:07 Is that an AMOGUS?

[@santiagogamez90]

7:07 Knarfy made an amongus.

[@ralimaeli9333]

Camels in cacti actually make sense because they have incredibly thick lips designed for eating spiny plants like cacti Fun fact about camels: that's how they get water

[@MysteriousNight_Macoroni]

😅 ok

[@OreoRobDog]

sneeky knarfy sneaking an among us at 7:07

[@Thatsmidg3]

7:08 Ik bro did not just make an obsidian amogus 🗿

[@TheLittleBean1705]

12:00 Camels actually do eat cacti. It’s not their first choice but they are incredibly adapted to the harsh deserts they live in so often cacti along with other dried, often thorny vegetation are the only things on the menu. They have strong cone shaped growths that look like a whole bunch of fleshy spikes in their mouth which are called "Papillae" and their main use are to protect the Camel's mouth from getting pricked and poked from the cacti they eat.

[@VGCCCCC]

1:40 I thought redstone used to break when you walk on it but it got removed

[@Nomedapro]

What if in an April Fools update every logic would get realistic?

[@Tivali572]

7:08 amogus ඞ ඞ ඞ

[@AdrianAAAHHH-oy7zl]

8:25--9:25 knarfy discovers electricity is confusing

[@barberdrake]

5:34 that villaget bouta start a whole adventurer arc

[@hassanqayyum8847]

knarfy if you always get obsidian from water and lava anarchy and all the lava casts would go terribly

[@MysteriousNight_Macoroni]

5:57 Knarfy:"Gravity, more like... uh nose... NOT-vity" Me:"Gravity, more like cavity!"

[@xxflamingburritoxx7648]

I say the world is a sphere or a cube and that’s why we have a border and maybe the void is a way to block us from getting to the other side

[@dragonlord4898]

Promotion Skip Button: 1:32 KZbin does this for me anyway

[@Seimei0]

7:07 AMONGUS???

[@hoodwatchurr4081]

all of knarfy's videos like this give me so many ideas for mods to make

[@IpadLicker]

i like the fact that Knarfy unintentionally made an among us at 7:07

[@GT-20]

bro, irl camels' skin is not protected from cactus but their mouths are so that they can eat cactus, what do you think camels eat, pizza?

[@Micah-does-stuff]

How does a Redstone block power regular Redstone? They’re both just Redstone.

[@burritochimcken5842]

The Among Us at 7:07 in the obi???? Great vid also :)

[@thewolfstu]

6:34 water onto Lava Source makes obsidian, Lava onto water source makes stone, Lava and water flowing into each other in other cases makes cobble... for the most part, I think lava landing on flowing water still miiiight make stone, but I believe it'll just make cobble where they collide.

[@Deviled2248_]

Bro really forgot about water breathing potions XD

[@quicktime_griddle]

11:56 that's actually realistic, irl they do eat it albeit it may cause them a bit of pain.

[@littlewolfyzapling8810]

I love the idea that milking cows with a bottle is a more logical explanation than a bucket LMAO

[@zaywineland6294]

11:55 it actually make sense because camels actually eat cacti the can do it cause thir mouth just look up camel mouth

[@Iliadic]

5:57 Gravity? I hardly know thee.

[@Sosima_Barbosa]

7:45 did yall see that left handed skeleton here?

[@MasonWilliams-qq9qi]

I didn't see that also here before a minute

[@SillyPerrin]

12:19 No, a Minecraft world isn’t infinite. In fact, it is only 60M blocks wide. Players cannot go past that point. Chunks still generate but you could reach the edge of the world, as it stops generating chunks at some point.

[@networkofneurons]

no the stripelands let it go on to be (2³²)•2 blocks wide

[@nojdo331]

Something feels a little sus... (7:07)

[@winkystinky]

Did anyone notice the sussy among us when he was doing the obsidian bit?

[@Pakistanplayz]

Villagers are witches in disguise