Goldenflower killing Tigerstar’s ghost is the arc we deserved
@UnstablePinetree2 ай бұрын
REAL
@ribottostudio2 ай бұрын
Firestar vs Tigerstar is what makes the narrative sense. BUT we absolutely should've seen a confrontation between Golden and Tiger.
@RUBYthedragon2 ай бұрын
@@ribottostudio if we are talking about narrative sense. They shouldn’t have invented cat hell. And ghosts that can suddenly hurt living cats. And Tigerstar’s ghost shouldn’t have been so comically evil
@lionblaze03842 ай бұрын
Literally wrote an au map script about this exact thing. Her killing him after finding out he caused what happened to swiftpaw, taking his place as shadowclans new leader instead, and then killing his ghost as goldenstar in the great battle. A bit silly but so cathartic
@StarseekertheNightwing132 ай бұрын
@@lionblaze0384THAT is a fanfic I’d read ❤❤❤
@BlueBirdFeather19962 ай бұрын
My favorite scene with Goldenflower is during the travel to the new clans and she is talking to Longtail about what everything looks like.
@albytross86812 ай бұрын
It was soooo sweet
@meghanrodriguez23932 ай бұрын
BRO MY HEART!
@chaseashley67752 ай бұрын
YES! FINALLY! I’m so upset that the authors forgot about her. She’s the parent to a protagonist to not receive a death scene and the 2nd arc would have been so much stronger if Goldenflower was involved more.
@Answeredriddle2 ай бұрын
Goldenflower, another tragic victim of the team not caring about neutral-positive family relationships period. I do hope the graphic novels emphasize their relationships more going forward. I genuinely forget Goldenflower was alive in TNP or that she is Swiftpaw’s mother. Half of the joy of Warriors is seeing what the silly little kitties are doing, there *should* be more drama and shenanigans.
@fundspending2 ай бұрын
you could say jujitsu shenanigans
@kristaberta79222 ай бұрын
Robinwing being in a polycule with Fuzzypelt, Patchpelt, and Goldenflower, only for Goldenflower to eventually leave it and settle down with Tigerclaw, is the best thing warriors has ever accidentally implied.
@amynewton7742 ай бұрын
this is a fun idea
@AzureTheEnbyCat2 ай бұрын
imo almost as great as transmasc rowanclaw
@Blaaaaazeeeeeeeeeee2 ай бұрын
It's just me who saw a search symbol appear above "goldenflower" and "polycute"
@snakewithapen54892 ай бұрын
@@Blaaaaazeeeeeeeeeee search links on youtube comments is a new thing
@fizzydizzystudios47682 ай бұрын
I want a novella or a warriors map of the four of them in a polycule now 😭
@darkninjafirefox2 ай бұрын
I always felt that, after Tawnypelt left, she stopped going to gatherings because it would have been too painful to see her daughter in a different clan
@kateb66992 ай бұрын
That's a really good headcanon, I am incorporating that into my belief system
@WooffzTheCoon2 ай бұрын
That’s a really good and yet very sad headcanon, because if she never went to gatherings after Tawny left, then she’d likely never see Tawny again :(
@darkninjafirefox2 ай бұрын
@@WooffzTheCoon they probably reconnected a bit on the journey to the lake! It would have been hard to avoid each other the entire time. At least that's what I believe
@Ahappydude4192 ай бұрын
Honestly, an ABSURDLY underrated and forgotten character is Leopardfoot. Since the girl is Tigerstar's mother and Pinestar's former mate and even so she is always kind of forgotten in the fandom, I would like a talking about her, people don't recognize how much she may have been through... If only the Erins cared about side characters...
@applesplashwarriorcats83392 ай бұрын
I've always felt so bad for Leopardfoot. Especially with the way her romance was handled. Pinestar literally admits in his novella to being attracted to her when she's an apprentice....
@Starlight_787-r9k2 ай бұрын
I agreed
@beastmaster09342 ай бұрын
@@applesplashwarriorcats8339 And if that’s not horrible enough. He’s older than both of her parents.
@sodaboi21542 ай бұрын
@@applesplashwarriorcats8339 Ewwwwww, good lord. Can warriors stop writing super creepy age gaps?? I’m aware more of it was years ago but god
@Littlefox12132 ай бұрын
@@applesplashwarriorcats8339Whoa wtf, never knew that! I also think that grandparents should be widely acknowledged in the Warriors series lol-
@fozzyspots2 ай бұрын
I love the idea that Tigerstar and Goldenflower’s “relationship” was purely a business arrangement, and I especially love the idea of Goldenflower being just as pragmatic about it. She was always shown to be just as devoted warrior as Tigerstar - the idea that she chose him to be the father of her kits, just as much as he chose her, because of the traits they had rather than any actual feelings, is fantastic, and I resent the generally held belief that she pined after him while he didn’t care. She’s never shown to do that!
@testerwulf3357Ай бұрын
This!!! I prefer the interpretation that she chose him to have a litter with purely because he was strong and a decent warrior at the time. And he did so likewise.
@MisterMistea2 ай бұрын
Bloody crazy how the ex-wife of Tigerstar and the mother to arc 2 protagonists Tawnypelt and Brambleclaw never receives any screentime. Like, hello???
@clarehidalgo2 ай бұрын
Lady spends more time on screen hanging out with her former step-son than her own kids
@caninehelicopter52002 ай бұрын
Never doubt the books' potential to do absolutely nothing
@phantomcat79902 ай бұрын
I still really think it’s a shame that Swiftpaw was listed as Bramblestar and Tawnypelt’s half-sibling. Having him specifically also be Tigerstar’s son would’ve been so good! Tigerstar is shown to at the very least feel _some_ care towards his children, so for his own child to be an unexpected casualty by the dogs could’ve been really interesting. And it could’ve also been what motivated Goldenflower to tell Bramblekit and Tawnykit who Tigerstar really was. Seeing as how Tigerstar was willing to sacrifice his own child for his ambition, she could come to the conclusion that Bramblekit and Tawnykit would not be spared from anything Tigerstar does, so she then tells them for their own safety. It also could’ve addressed Goldenflower’s perspective of Tigerstar. Because although it’s never officially addressed, Goldenflower’s unwillingness to tell her children about Tigerstar reads to me as her still hanging on to her perception of him. Despite everything he’s done, it’s hard for her to let go of her vision of the cat she fell in love with. But Swiftpaw’s death would break the illusion, forcing her to face the reality of who Tigerstar really is.
@abigailkondoudis57722 ай бұрын
So either Dustpelt and Ravenpaw were rebound kits, or Fuzzypelt, Robinwing, and Patchpelt were in a secret off screen polycule… well I know what my new favorite crackship is now.
@starstorm12672 ай бұрын
I always headcanoned that Fuzzypelt and Robinwing had an on and off relationship. They had a total of 3 litters together (though Cherrypaw and Chestnutkit are not mentioned in the series so take that with a grain of salt). Patchpelt was just kind of Robinwing’s side dude for a bit I guess
@yakketyyak64142 ай бұрын
The “alternative to what??? MORALS????” caught me so off guard I choked on my water when I read it 😭
@motorcitymangababe2 ай бұрын
3:14 I am being reminded that I had a cat who gave birth to- I shit you not- TWELVE KITTENS. (We didn't know she was pregnant when we got her just fat, it was a shock to say the least!) Miabella would have doubled a clans population with her hoard. Like, what would the clans even do with that many babies at once? I feel like there would need to be some kind of interclan intervention lol
@snakewithapen54892 ай бұрын
Thankfully that's unlikely to happen for them because the cats in the clans are usually chronically malnourished LOL
@chaseashley67752 ай бұрын
@@motorcitymangababe RIP genetic diversity
@jojobeetch2 ай бұрын
@@snakewithapen5489Except for riverclan!
@wellIhavenothingbettertodo2 ай бұрын
Was your cat alright??? Was she spayed afterward?
@motorcitymangababe2 ай бұрын
@@wellIhavenothingbettertodo it was rough on her to be sure but she was ok! Actually our dog at the time (lab chow mix) got very protective of her and the bbs, and was doing a lot of the cleanup and kitten herding in the early days- something else I can imagine the cats in these books losing their minds over lol And yes, we got her spayed! Last thing we needed was another dozen kittens!
@KIRIZATION2 ай бұрын
It's pretty obvious the Erin's never really cared for goldenflower. She's got three children, none of which she really interacts with, named after or even bear resemblance to her(even though her sons technically should). So is the plight of being forgotten by the Erin's, even if you should be a semi important character, if they don't deem you as such, good luck on being even remotely relevant.
@clarehidalgo2 ай бұрын
8:17 Nice to see Goldenflower gets along with Longtail, her former step-son
@dawnhankins95342 ай бұрын
Okay, I forgot she even made it to the new territories. I thought she stayed behind with the elders and was always annoyed with that. Ha! Makes Brambleclaw even more ridiculous for wanting a relationship with evil daddy and Hawkfrost.
@Pixelllama692 ай бұрын
0:11 Why is she so smug, I love it.
@Blossomie42 ай бұрын
I feel like it would’ve been make Swiftpaw Tigerstar’s kid with Goldenflower too in my opinion. I’ve seen a couple takes on this au and it really makes the circumstances surrounding his fate worse knowing Tigerstar was ultimately the cause. Great video, love my girl Goldie! As for recommendations, I’d love to see a talking video about Sasha, seeing as we’re already discussing Tigerstar mates XD
@inkydinkyrinkyy2 ай бұрын
I always loved Goldenflower, despite her being like, SUCH a background character. I think its just because her name was pretty
@spectacularslowpoke60182 ай бұрын
I think a good spiritual sequel to this mini talk could be one about her son Swiftpaw, like her, a lot of his popularity is based on ideas people have about him rather than what he does in the books. In the books the only significant things he does is blab about Brokentail being ThunderClan prisoner at the gathering, and then die. I’m not a Swiftpaw hater by any means at all I do like his story, but his popularity is wildly disproportionate compared to what we actually have in the books imo. I also find it interesting how people often portray him as childlike at the time of his death while he was actually a full grown man. Splashtail as of Wind is younger than him. Thunderstar was younger than him when he formed ThunderClan.
@LionSlashMeteorPowerShower2 ай бұрын
A full grown man? Maybe barley an adult in human years. He's portrayed as a young man with big goals and aspirations who knows very little on how the world around him actually works.
@spectacularslowpoke60182 ай бұрын
@@LionSlashMeteorPowerShower my point is that he is an adult, but in many fan depictions he’s portrayed like a young teen. Snowfur had a child and still managed to die 5 moons younger than Swiftpaw. Edit: 2 moons not 5, whoops.
@chaseashley67752 ай бұрын
@@spectacularslowpoke6018 according to the wiki, Snowfur was 18 moons at death and Swiftpaw was 20, so only 2 moons younger. It’s still insane and I hadn’t realized the at before.
@spectacularslowpoke60182 ай бұрын
@@chaseashley6775 my mistake, thanks for letting me know! Either way he was older than her at time of death which certainly does feel insane.
@Frostfern942 ай бұрын
Yeah I didn’t really care for him at all. The fandom loving him was a massive surprise to me. His fame is widely disproportionate to what he actually did
@kateb66992 ай бұрын
Another small scene in TNP that I liked between Brambleclaw & Goldenflower was when he was worried she was going to stay behind with all of the other elders, but she reassured him she was coming as well. Granted I might've just liked it as a kid bc the whole "leaving the elders behind" thing was HORRIFYING and I was glad at least one made it out of there XD EDIT: Apparently I imagined this scene, I can't seem to find it again. If anyone else remembers it, please let me know!
@chaseashley67752 ай бұрын
@@kateb6699 where was this? I don’t remember a single conversation between Brambleclaw and Goldenflower during Dawn
@kateb66992 ай бұрын
@@chaseashley6775 Huh, I scanned through Dawn and Starlight, but couldn't find the scene again? That's odd, I don't know if I imagined it or what.
@chaseashley67752 ай бұрын
@@kateb6699 I don’t blame you for imagining it. We needed a scene like that. It enrages me that the authors didn’t include any content of Goldenflower and Brambleclaw in Dawn; we were robbed of a reunion scene.
@lMlNY0URWALL2 ай бұрын
Something I want to mention it’s such a small unimportant scene but in the new graphic novel what I think is Goldenflower actually disagrees with tigerstar on something it’s such a small thing but I love her so much
@mirthfulmagician3172 ай бұрын
I would love a video on Purdy! He's so silly! His life is literally a massive joke, but in the best way possible ❤
@colinwoods5263Ай бұрын
@mirthfulmagician I agree! Purdy is so adorable ❤️
@EaseeCheesee2 ай бұрын
I would love to see a talking video on Darkstripe. Hes a stinky little man and I've always thought he's interesting, his only job is to be a lackey but he's been retconned into being Graystripes brother and thats neat.
@namikkou2 ай бұрын
i like saying Darkstripe is gay and homophobic. I don't make the rules he just is
@Spottedstorm272 ай бұрын
Finally! My girl! My favorite queen! The form that's literally my mom is she was in the books! I know she was forgotten by the authors, but I'll never forget. I wrote her a death scene where she's talking to and comforting Brambleclaw as he's doubting himself after the events of arc 2. It only made me love her more!
@katiedouble2 ай бұрын
Please do Feathertail next-it would be interesting to see your take on her sacrifice, position as a half-clan cat, the book a shadow in riverclan, and her relationship with her brother and Crowpaw/feather
@DiddlesDankovsky2 ай бұрын
Straight up went "Yayyy!!" out loud when I saw the title, i LOVE goldenflower. Thanks moonkitti!!
@hollyklemmer89022 ай бұрын
It would be nice to see a talking video about Willowshine. I always thought she wasn’t talked about much often, especially after what happened to her in The Broken Code, which saddens me. I feel like she was forgotten too quickly when we got to know her for so long throughout the various arcs.
@angryequestrian75532 ай бұрын
Sunfall/star may be an interesting cat to talk about. I’m loving this series!
@kaisunami2 ай бұрын
Yes!! He deserves to be talked about! He’s my favorite background character
@hawktalon78902 ай бұрын
I always thought Goldenflower's name was so beautiful. Really wish the Erins expanded upon her relationship with Feathertail and Stormfur.
@namikkou2 ай бұрын
Ok this may be a controversial take, but I wanna see a video on Tigerheart, or well, Tigerstar II He's probably the leader with the most personality currently, and is actually INTERESTING. I feel in a way he's a successor to both the previous Tigerstar and Firestar's legacies. He took over RiverClan and has done some bad things, but he has strong morals and sticks to them. He was the only leader to directly oppose the Impostor and not just go along with everything. He offered sanctuary to all those exiled and told his clanmates to treat them like their own. I think it's also interesting how ShadowClan overall has become more accepting of outside cats (maybe due to the influence of the time with the Guardian cats?) While other clans seem to get less accepting. He's also one of the few toms in the series to be shown to be ACTIVELY involved with his kits lives! He's actually there for them! He's also interesting in the way that it seems like he values his family more than his clan, which you don't see much of in warriors, especially a character whose a leader Idk, he's unironically one of my favorite characters and I love him.
@kaisunami2 ай бұрын
Same! I love Tigerheartstar, he deserves more love.. I’m actually surprised he’s not that popular in the community.
@asterrovenator2 ай бұрын
i've always had a soft spot for goldenflower!!
@doginabog30322 ай бұрын
Moonkitti please implore us with a modern day shadowclan mini taking, the masses cry for it
@tanookitty2 ай бұрын
3:18 i for one would love a video about your tangent on modern shadowclan! 🙏
@TinyBabyAlienDancingOnTo-kc6mj2 ай бұрын
Honestly a big pet peeve I have with the books is the family tree, after becoming apprentices no one interacts with there parents as their parents. Just as another clan mate
@gfox3142 ай бұрын
3rd Video of asking: Can you do a talking on Spiderleg. His relationship with Daisy is interesting and his age at the end of OoTS was retconned. His sharp personality would be cool to hear about.
@Quilladraws2 ай бұрын
A Goldenflower video I’m so happy 😭
@WarriorCats4ever5602 ай бұрын
She is actually underrated, I’d love a novella on her tbh but sadly they don’t write those anymore :(
@Greenkitten452 ай бұрын
Goldenflower: *exhausted taking care of four kittens* My sibling's cat: YOU'RE WEAK!!!! *Aggressively nurtures seven kittens at once*
@GarbageCannot2 ай бұрын
Goldenflower my beloved !!! It’s a real shame she was so underutilized.
@sambird79462 ай бұрын
Tigerstar and Goldenflower always put off a one night stand vibe (although they were more involved than that). Goldenflower and Patchpelt…. could be a similar situation? And Robinwing and co is defo a poly throuple situation with Robinwing and Patchpelt having a courtly love situation. The shape this love triangle makes is - - . . which is morse code for “mi”. MI is short for Michigan. The Erins are covertly trying to hint that the books actually take place within the city of Detroit in the United States, and that is why the setting sometimes doesn’t match up with what you’d expect from England. Trust
@chaseashley67752 ай бұрын
@@sambird7946 can’t have shit in Detroit. That’s why Goldenflower gets no screen time.
@Frostfern942 ай бұрын
😂😂😂
@UbyVictor2 ай бұрын
I CLICKED AS FAST AS POSSIBLE Yaaaay Goldenflower!! Edit: I'm so used to seeing fanart of Goldenflower being fluffy, it's a bit strange to see her slim and short-haired lol (not in a bad way tho)
@kyuafriendy2 ай бұрын
I’d love to see a possible lilyheart or cherryfall mini-talking! Both of them are decently relevant in avos and the current arc and I’ve always enjoyed them.
@daydreamer89412 ай бұрын
I feel like Goldenflower is the biggest what if for Warrior Cats fandom alongside Snowfur who had huge must kill energy but that part of her character is kind of forgotten so she's just Whitestorm's mom
@daydreamer89412 ай бұрын
I felt bad for Goldenflower because her ex mate's actions unintentionally lead to the death of her son Swiftpaw.
@LaffyTaffywithaDoggo2 ай бұрын
I like Goldenflower.
@biscuitbcat2 ай бұрын
Palebird mini talking? Shes an interesting character for only really being minor character in one book
@stromcrashtheicewing63532 ай бұрын
Instantly YES! I LOVE GOLDENFLOWER! JUSTICE FOR GOLDENFLOWER
@SpooksTheFox2 ай бұрын
WE NEED BEETLEWHISKER!!!!! He is really forgotten and was killed in the dark forest when trying to leave
@OctoAri2 ай бұрын
I am reading A Vision of Shadows and I am emotionally devastated. I nominate the sassy grandmother of ThunderClan - Sandstorm as part of my therapy.
@Harmonikitty22 ай бұрын
I love the way you draw, and also agree on this video. ❤ I love how you explain these things without thinking too much 😂
@Null0702 ай бұрын
It took me so long to realize that moonkitti posts every saturday lmao
@P1viLivi2 ай бұрын
Wait ..she does??
@6.astr02 ай бұрын
I like the name goldenflower so that’s the only reason I remembered her.
@Witchcraftmoon2 ай бұрын
I would love to see a video on Midnight or rock as there's a lot of mystery around them or a video on onewhisker (Edit) or a video on the cats trying to break th ice at the moonpool
@Tw1zteR.2 ай бұрын
I REALLY LIKE THE IMPLICATION THAT CLOUDTAIL LISTDNS TO ALT ROCK AT 8:37
@mmmm-lg2mj2 ай бұрын
Once again I'm asking for a mini talk on Leopardfoot (tigerstar's mom)
@juliawertz52822 ай бұрын
I saw the thumbnail and my first thought was "it's Mom!" And then I saw the video description. Moon understands. Goldenflower is fun because she is definitively three things: (1) a cool lady, (2) a good mom, and (3) jaded with a chip on her shoulder that she never talks about, and that's...basically all we know about her inner world. She's a background character who does almost nothing but is a good, strong person who has been through so much stress, and therefore has loads of potential for headcanons.
@I_am_in_your_walls32 ай бұрын
Have we talked about Needletail yet? I think her character is really interesting, and her life was definitely a rollercoaster 😂❤
@halcyonbuzz2 ай бұрын
as much as i hate the robinwing-related family tree retcons (making brindleface and frostfur not just related but LITTERMATES has got to be in the top 10 worst decisions the erins have ever made) they are undeniably very funny, especially when you consider that fuzzypelt was patchpelt's mentor.
@Poppet5792 ай бұрын
I would love a featherwhisker talking video I feel he is kinda overlooked as a medicine cat but I love his character
@GRASSFUR_WCUEАй бұрын
Honestly, I'd like to see a super Edition about Goldenflower. How she felt when Lionheart died, When Swiftpaw died, When her much younger sibling Snowkit died. When Tawnypaw left, When Tigerclaw got exiled... Yiu get the gist.
@chickennuggetpaw2 ай бұрын
THE TAWNY SCRAWNY LION REFERENCE OMG I LOVED THAT BOOK 😭😭😭❤❤
@KaeserLooty2 ай бұрын
I remember through in tigerclaw's fury Tigerclaw checking out if Goldenflower and their kits were safe, so it is canon he cares for her, just not romantically
@Kerfluff2 ай бұрын
A video about foxpaw and icepaw would be so fun!! (I just like them more than your average side character)
@krumelsuppe88372 ай бұрын
Can you do a talking video about Feathertail? I feel like people only view her as "crowfeathers first crush" but I think there's so much more to it, esp in her comic
@starringsnips2 ай бұрын
I got really attached to Goldenflower when I read Bluestar’s Prophecy, and I’m sad that she was forgotten. I love her personality🥰
@KaeserLooty2 ай бұрын
Now I want whole drama story between Fuzzypelt, Robinwing, Patchpelt and Goldenflower
@kateb66992 ай бұрын
5:10 There are a few weird repeating/inconsistent scenes in the first series (and possibly the others, though I don't remember very well). Another I remember is the reveal that Brokenstar is Yellowfang's son - she confesses it to Fireheart (I think) in Fire & Ice, but then later when he spies on Yellowfang poisoning him it's treated like a reveal again? When Yellowfang dies it seems like it's implied she hadn't personally told Fireheart the truth even though she had. It's also possible that those scenes were written with the thought process that some kids might've picked up the book without reading earlier ones in the series, hence the repetitiveness (trying to catch newer readers up)
@yulelog222 ай бұрын
A NEW MINI-TALK WITHIN THE WEEK?! lets go boys
@ancalagonaidoni74252 ай бұрын
If only Firestar had named Brambleclaw "Brambleflower" instead.
@kaisunami2 ай бұрын
I love Goldenflower
@ilovewillowrosenberg2 ай бұрын
Forgot to comment this the day this came out, but Goldenflower video on my birthday?? Yippee! (Doesn't work as well now that it's no longer my birthday but the sentiment is still there)
@TheChaosGoddess10242 ай бұрын
I love how you drew Bramblekit, he’s shaped like a brick
@sketchyscr1bbles2 ай бұрын
I would absolutely love a Goldenflower super or novella
@AshKunz2 ай бұрын
Mini talking idea! Midnight the badger from the second prophecy
@rorytelling2 ай бұрын
I always misremember Goldenflower staying behind in the old forest with the Elders
@liv.slays542 ай бұрын
YES FINALLY OMG OMG JUMPING IN JOY AHHHH CANT WAIT TO WATCH IVE BEEN BEGGING
@saturnbubblez2 ай бұрын
EVERYONE SHUT UP MOONKITTI POSTED AT THE PERFECT TIME AGAIN! I was legit JUST rewatching all your talking videos for the tenth time!!!
@kanadescupnoodless2 ай бұрын
hi moonkitti i always put ur talking vids on before i sleep, it rlly helps me for some reason!! just about now i’m getting tired so perfect timing :p been a fan for years, keep it up !! :3 love ur content sm
@liaspring72 ай бұрын
Goldenflower my beloved
@Mi2uk1_M0ssАй бұрын
I love kahoot and your edit is so amazing!
@pumpkinskittles82252 ай бұрын
Woah everytime i see your videos they are from like 2 years ago, its awesome to be early for once
@lmorgan58722 ай бұрын
I would really like to see a talking on russetfur. I always forget she was such a minor character. She was always one on my favorites. I also think one on mousewhisker would be cool, just so I can have a full collection of his riverclan thing.
@mmwatchasay7392 ай бұрын
Would love to see a talking video about feathertail. Her graphic novel gave her a lot more character and I think she could have had a lot going for her had she been fleshed out more
@JaeYim-w3s2 ай бұрын
GOLDENFLOWER FINALLY THANK YOU
@mangle184232 ай бұрын
PLEASE TALK ABOUT LEOPARDFOOT
@SugarSwirl2 ай бұрын
Day 2 of asking Moonkitti for a Dovewing talking video 🙏 I feel like Dovewing is a bit more popular than she used to be but the fandom is still pretty split on her
@kmerj74232 ай бұрын
I think it would be really nice if you talked about Sparkpelt. (If you haven’t already, if I missed it I’m sorry). One of her kits is the new protagonist, I think it would be cool to see all she’s done specifically before her protagonist child
@KZFathom2 ай бұрын
hi! i was wondering if you could talk about sandgorse. i feel like people only ever bring him up in pair with paledove -- who was unfairly treated by the fandom for being a mother character and having postpartum -- as a sort of example as to how "tallpaw's parents weren't really that bad." i think that paledove was not a perfect mother and a complicated character (and honestly is more indicative of how divided windclan is at the time, because the po3 don't really have a problem with being weaned/watched over by ferncloud/brambleclaw/any other adult cat while still calling squirrelflight mom), but sandgorse imo was far worse. he repeatedly blamed his son for problems unrelated to him, and was either completely emotionally illiterate or just ignored the fact that his son wanted to do something different from tunneling. i've honeslty never really understood the angle that sandgorse was "just looking for tallpaw to continue the family tradition" because regardless of his intentions, he was treating tallpaw badly. him talking tallpaw up being seen as being "a good parent" puts a bad taste in my mouth because you can simultaneously hold your child in high esteem and mistreat them because you never listen to them.
@splotchbearwcue2 ай бұрын
Love your videos! Can you make a talking video on leopardstar or littlecloud please? I think you’ll have a lot of interesting things to talk about with them!
@annabellesgamingadventures52432 ай бұрын
We need a Goldenflower Novella or super edition. A novella would be better though, just a nice short story better expressing her emotions
@latentradiance16502 ай бұрын
ngl i forgot goldenflower wasnt one of the older cats who stayed behind in the forest during TNP. feels like she might as well have been w the amount of attention she gets in the narrative in that arc
@Hero-lt2ir2 ай бұрын
Team forgot about such an important character I wonder why queens are ALWAYS forgotten in warriors
@ophelia52402 ай бұрын
Day one of asking your next talking to be about Brightheart. She's my favorite, and i wholeheartedly believe she should've been chosen as Deputy instead of Brambleclaw.
@cricketflightstar2 ай бұрын
Two talking videos in a row? Yippee!
@strikermystic2 ай бұрын
Guys wake up, Moonkitti just posted another underrated video !! Honestly people don't talk much about Goldenflower sadly, so I'm glad you're doing a video about it ^^
@armadillo-artsАй бұрын
3:15 don’t be shy, moon. drop the tangent on modern shadowclan
@FumblingFrogs2 ай бұрын
I hate seeing the authors saying stuff like "Sasha was Tigerstar's one true love" like okay but in the graphic novel with them, Tigerstar's last words to Sasha while he was alive was "you're nothing" and that's so gross that the authors woukd call that "love". I personally headcanon that Tigerstar and Sasha were a fling.
@testerwulf3357Ай бұрын
I do think he had a thing for her at the beginning, but in the end it wasn’t that serious and he left her easily (probably because she refused to join his clan, when she wouldn’t he stopped caring about her snd she truly did become nothing to him..nothing more than a fleeting moment of passion)
@cosmicchocolatepaste2 ай бұрын
I love goldenflower she has been one of my favorite cats for a long time I am also very disappointed she doesn't get a lot of development and time even though she was the mate of a very prominent bad guy and is generally the cause for most of the plot to happen in arc 1 and 2 because the second arc follows her kits
@Noname18455Ай бұрын
Hi I was wondering if u could talk about Spiderleg ,I think his relationship with Daisy and the reason he neglected his kits needs to be talked about