Kolkata Doctor Assaulted And Raped; Who's Shielding System, Who Betrayed Devi? | The Urban Debate

[@MastiffEggroll]

So proud to all these " BRAVE WOMEN" fighting for JUSTICE ❤. It's about time that the government needs to hear their " CRY" for help and protection for all the women.

[@doreenbalwantsingh2363]

After being torchur how come no one heard her scream..I am sure she must have yelled for help and cried out in pain...unless someone was holding her mouth shut and pinning her to the floor..I wonder if there were no one else on the floor where this crime was taken.. At night the place is very quiet.. You can hear a pin dropped...how come no one heard her.?

[@HimanshuMahajan-zn3nq]

Coz there are more than one culprits😢

[@ArijitBiswasMakeup]

1. Dr. Shahbaz Khan, 2. Dr. Subhadip Sinha Mahapatra, 3. Dr. Arsean Alam, 4. Dr. Golam Azam 5. Dr. Tanisha Yasmin.... they are real culprits Why no news about them ? Please share it across social media please.

[@srinilokugalappaththi9996]

Are these involved what a shame

[@uncletom9321]

When the prime minister of the country has close relationships with serial rapst MP like Prajwal Revanna how do u expect the women of the country to be safe? The head of state is closely associated with a man who made 3000 videos of 400 women. How is this ok?

[@choeigeechu1465]

23:27 23:34 23:45 23:46 23:46 23:47 😅 23:47 😅 23:50 23:52 23:53 23:54 24:00 24:00 24:01 24:02 24:08 q

[@r_lamack166]

If govt doesn't take actions. WE WILL

[@kathymarik1932]

My husband’s family live in Kolkata so I have been there many many times and heard of the corruption in the police force there.

[@suchetabasak6825]

Victim body was not released to her kin after postmortem. Kolkata police forced those grieving parent to cremate her body. Why so hurry for cremation? Sounds like another Hathras.

[@nataliev.149]

Cremation destroys evidence

[@ArijitBiswasMakeup]

1. Dr. Shahbaz Khan, 2. Dr. Subhadip Sinha Mahapatra, 3. Dr. Arsean Alam, 4. Dr. Golam Azam 5. Dr. Tanisha Yasmin.... they are real culprits Why no news about them ? Please share it across social media please.

[@JE-pq4wp]

​@@ArijitBiswasMakeup Shame on Drs if they are actually part in this . How horrible. How would they treat patients Is this some religious issue? Looks there's more behind the scenes

[@radhikaraj9533]

@@suchetabasak6825 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@florencedupingayvedar5427]

That's what we're talking about-for Indian women to stand bravely together and fight for their rights. I have much respect for Shreya Dhoundial for her fearless and tough questions to key persons. Salute to you Mdme Shreya.

[@TamarasBliss]

It is truly a horror crime!!! How come no one heard anything??? How come that men can do such cruelty to women, or in anyway a human being, even an animal? Lust is totally different then torture and murder, How those men could feel lust while the lady is half death by all inflicted wounds crying out in pain, knowing she is dying and a broken neck? How can men even get exited and be able to do sex? How come they are not sick till their bones to be doing these horrific acts? The minds of the rapists-killers are utterlly horrigying dangerous. Those people are still walking around. Who are those men? And how many men with such mindsets to commit such horrific crimes are walking around? How come such men even exsist? What about their upbringing, education, their households, family life where they grew up? To become such psychopaths, not having a heart and empathy and common sense and respect for women, no respect for themselves and no respect for life??? Even animals never do this to eachother!!! The poor lady suffered the most terrifying death!!! Worser then any horror movie!!! How utterly scared and lonely and in disbelief and in pain she must have felt. How is her soul now watching? How her soul can find peace? She died, another woman died, bc of lustful and murderous males. When will this stop? And will we know how those males are punished??? For example, the killer of Shakshi, what happened for his punishment? The killer of the girl in the hostel in Bangalore?? The rspists of the Brazilian lady? The killer of the Swiss lady? We never get to hear about the punishments. So men are not scared of the authorities, bc no public display of punishments are presented. Women all over the world are not save from men anywhere, anytime.

[@Shukra9665]

Pelvic bone broken. Enormous semen quantity. Significant insiders must be involved.

[@Kat-zj5kd]

multiple individuals are involved and the enquiry looks not clean. WB govt shd resign over this gruesome crime.

[@JaiUtkalaMaa]

It seems some politicians are involved. There was a case like this about Sadhu Yadav of Bihar. Which was never solved.

[@subratadebnath3678]

Principal resigned and already joined to other medical college why govt is allowed this

[@hoveringcow]

Government only appointed him , vote didi

[@JjRodrigues-eq4qz]

He should not be given any job

[@TaylorLeeKnow]

It feels like, he’s one of the main culprits

[@DariaChyrmang]

Helpless Mamanta Govt.

[@None-cf5yp]

None of the bollywood celebrities too protested against this. Where are the role models who could support the protest further? Everyone just work for money!

[@hennykins3324]

Mamta banerjee is shah rukh favourite. So none will speak against rape.

[@srinilokugalappaththi9996]

Where is that drama queen kangana

[@Champ577]

Bollywood movies glamourise rape. Watch Roti Kapada aur Makkan or Vishwanath...God alone know how many rapes takes place in the movie Industry. Don't rely on useless Bollywood. Let your voice ring loud

[@DariaChyrmang]

Where is the VOY ?

[@pushpamitasarkar5242]

As a Kolkata resident, I need CBI probe ,otherwise there will be no justice.

[@itx_theanime_guy]

Top to bottom corrupt

[@kathymarik1932]

Why was she murdered. Did she know something?

[@eileenmorris2180]

This is the same case of Shushant Singh Rajput which carried on and on in the end the CBI let us all Down by not coming to any conclusion and the culprits are enjoying life. This is another repetition where the CBI, the police and the CM are all hand in glove to cover up the case to save the culprits. NO DAYS should be given they MUST act immediately.

[@radhikaraj9533]

If this was 😮her daughter this has happened . What would Mamta do

[@siddharthanvarier3342]

This guy was just a fall guy, who left his bluetooth earphones DELIBERATELY at the crime scene. There is a lot more rapists involved

[@charlesbenedictrai4252]

True

[@greaterlight]

You're so right

[@samtos236]

There are more who took part and murdered in revenge

[@rachk8255]

Cover up she was targeted there is soooo much more to this story

[@shilpigupta1369]

If the cops themselves are incapable of screening volunteers, how will they ever be able to solve the case? The person they have caught is one of their own. Maybe his bluetooth was deliberately planted to show that the culprit has been nabbed.

[@ivyimogene]

The local police might tamper with the evidence so it's best to hand over the case to CBI at once.

[@ladywhite79]

1. Why are Indian women not protected? 2. Why are Indian women lives not respected? 3. Why are Indian women denied any justice? 4. Why are Indian women not liberated? WHY?

[@florencedupingayvedar5427]

my questions too. I am hoping that all Indian women come together and fight for their rights. Appeal to the social media. Put India in the spotlight for all the world to see. Maybe then the government officials will start doing their work.

[@ZephHorner]

Why don’t hospitals in India have Cameras everywhere? Seriously this needs immediate attention, every civilised nation has this as a bare minimum 🤷‍♀️

[@hassanh4069]

Very emotional but I will also felt the same, justice for Dr Devi

[@atishkumarchatterjee455]

R G kar involved guilty principal including 3-4 guilty for gangraped and killed doubt for civic volunteer involvement

[@ZaleenaZaleena]

Love how clearly you hav delivered this news ♥️

[@ambalikachanda3933]

Hats off to “Shreya” 🫡 We need people like u! At least someone has guts to raise voice against nonsense excuses given on y to wait before handing the case over to CBI! Kisi ko koi dikkat nhi hai toh whats the problem in handover? Shouldn't the state b concerned about finding culprit and not thinking about politics right now, kisko embarrassment hogi and kisko nhi! High time, people in the state should open their eyes and see the kind of leader they r following

[@arundhatighoshal664]

Another horrific crime screaming for justice, but will the criminals be punished or shielded by higher authorities., as has become the norm with such crimes in West Bengal??

[@sridevigowravaram8642]

even a hospital is not safe.

[@RasidaBarkatNathani]

Take Action just don’t talk We Need Action we need justice

[@TamarasBliss]

Even to be hospitalized as a patient being female is a risk!!!

[@rajeshaggarwal777]

There are other Rapists involved so where are they now hiding and are they being hidden by Indian Authorities?!!... He is not the only one who raped her, catch the other Rapists as well Please... RESPECT YOUR WOMEN INDIA.. 🇮🇳 RESPECT MY SISTERS INDIA 🇮🇳 ONE LOVE, Rajesh Semrete Selassie Aggarwal FRSA 🙏💚💛❤️🙏

[@khookeekeng]

Why is rape so rampant in India 😢

[@lakshmig2061]

In US too especially NY

[@sharonjoseph-k4l]

​@@lakshmig2061: I think NY should be called the R**e capital of USA isn't it ? 🤔 Not sure why they gave Delhi that name ?

[@Champ577]

​@lakshmig2061 yeah console yourself with that piece of info and do nothing. D

[@greaterlight]

​@@lakshmig2061keep consoling yourself you delusional being

[@ZaleenaZaleena]

I don’t understand wtf the doc was saying ! And why he resigned so quickly .

[@ppuspapusparaj]

Worst rulers

[@hasumatichandra6387]

No security No cvt camera Noone heard her shouting Noone there to help Blood are on their hands Karma n enablers are n will be punished One one is spared All these politicians hv lost their soul all bshit cheap talks

[@Mtelsa]

If medical superintendent has any ethics he should not work till the case is solved

[@mamtat7206]

Justice Now

[@saenchai5071]

If this tyrannical regime is dissolved in the fast track, all crimes can be stopped for sure !!

[@subratachakraborty7405]

Sandip Ghost re appoint and how? All documents destroy before handover to cbi!

[@marinamarina6337]

Yes must go for higher level enquiry...don only depends on to Kolkata police....

[@subratadebnath3678]

Yes immediately it should be on cbi

[@asmitadak6336]

yes students were involved

[@Pam_Dasgupta]

CBI should handle any capital case automatically.

[@Martin-kn6id]

Thanks Noel.

[@itx_theanime_guy]

He is main culprit he is knows everything about this 😢😢😢😢

[@Shukra9665]

Yes, other insiders are involved. He knows.

[@ArijitBiswasMakeup]

1. Dr. Shahbaz Khan, 2. Dr. Subhadip Sinha Mahapatra, 3. Dr. Arsean Alam, 4. Dr. Golam Azam 5. Dr. Tanisha Yasmin.... they are real culprits Why no news about them ? Please share it across social media please.

[@lathamogan2661]

Investigate these doctors. Why are they being protected.

[@Mtelsa]

Well said Dr Vikram why wait for more days KP not capable just handover to CBI. KP should be educated on how to attend such a case. PM or President should just use their power and hand the case to CBI.

[@lathamogan2661]

If Sanjey was a crook, so who is protecting him. If he has access to the entire hospital, the hospital authorities did nothing about him. This is ridiculous

[@jonswap9097]

Looks like he has links with the police. This may explain the cover-up!

[@abilashananthula6966]

Idiotic state government should realise their offenses and restore the justice.

[@samtos236]

CBI must be free from political cage

[@1mikon]

Many times they are not.

[@Vicky_5513]

Prevention is better than cure always irrespective of state wise discrepancy.

[@subratadebnath3678]

Treatment should be stopped like elective then people will come to know people will also protests

[@francisdantis205]

What happened was wrong and the culprits should be brought to law ... but punishing patients who had no hand in all this, is how much justifiable? And the people who reach government hospitals are mostly the lower middle class who can't afford to go to PVT hospitals..

[@hurishchummun1179]

The worst things am hearing in my life 😮

[@malpalmer3269]

Kolkata Government are woeful

[@Vicky_5513]

Dilutional tactics by the looks of it by our CM

[@juliusserrao6630]

Who is responsible for letting the principals forgo their crimes?

[@subratadebnath3678]

Don't allow time to kp proof will be compromised

[@annienizami1326]

Now all politicians will use this in their favour.bloody nonsense.

[@Karen-zh7hx]

I know its not my business, but i have been following this horrific crime and have felt that thisis a crime coming from the higher low lifes, along with the criminal that should have been put done. We have crimes like this here in the usa and a lot are not reported or are covered up. Stay strong, safe, fight your sisters around the world are with you.

[@hurishchummun1179]

It’s not only the ladies doctors but also the ladies patients 😢

[@nishantgaurav9612]

Please don’t make it political

[@annienizami1326]

I am from pakistan and a woman and women here are so shocked at why these grursome acts take place so frequently and so easily!!@

[@Issayanah]

The way they see women in India is just shameful.. Why did they force the family or persuade the family to cremate the body on the contrary enforcement, you would think that they want to preserve evidence. I hope those lady doctor stay safe and shake up on each other often because obviously police won’t keep them safe.

[@marioparreno9375]

No cctv cameras?unbelievable

[@RamsookSoodeen]

Corruption by police and city

[@frozansherzai6440]

How it’s possible that’s a hospital and there no security cameras 😢 such a horrible situation happened to her, there was no one to hear her 😢

[@rohinisuri6]

That all the doctors all over are protesting tells us its happening in every hospital.

[@nirmalarajput6373]

It's surprising when this horrible thing happens with Dr no body heard her screaming. It's shocking..they are evil..kitani tarhaphi hogi.kiya kisi ne nahi suna hoga very sad

[@sm1256]

Where are these people, when "Sandeshkali" has happened? When neighbors house is burning Hindus think I am safe, They know the pain when their house burn. But its too late to do anything.

[@taramattiemanieram6222]

How many times did this happen in his in charge of the hospital,

[@siddharthanvarier3342]

Seems to create MAJOR. DIVERSION from the Bangladesh imbroglio

[@emmanueljohn3881]

All these sexual offences in India take place because of Indian cinemas which promote sexual offences.

[@prithisadanand3182]

Please install hidden cctvs in strategic places in all institutions and roads too

[@bdrakmrju7635]

There is no honorable CM or honorable government unless they honor the citizens rights and feelings safety and everything under

[@viladias348]

Ask him what if it was his sister, his wife or his mother what he would do ask him that

[@tomjones9082]

So when not being a scam caller, this is what they get up to.

[@rachk8255]

How did this one guy do so much damage to this poor girl and on camera walks out with no blood on himself makes no sense- is he being framed

[@johnjoseph1573]

Honourable Chief minister and her Dishonourable administration 🤔

[@bdrakmrju7635]

This is not an honorable CM, I am a citizen and I have a full right to say it in this democracy...please go and research what republic country is

[@19payal]

Should not give time. More evidence will be wiped out

[@maini51]

Who made the roster for her to be on duty that day? That person was surely in the loop, question that person. Who vandalised her car? What have the goons of 14th August revealed? Next to be tampered with will be Roy, he needs to be isolated.

[@diogo1988100]

Sandip Gosh is an actor that has no remorse who first stated the victim committed suicide.

[@Vicky_5513]

शर्म आनी चाहिए न्यायालय को पूरे भारत वर्ष की।

[@sonumahanta1531]

Removed or transferred?

[@sharonramlogan8057]

Who found her and why wasnt a second autopsy done

[@putusaiputra]

Ex Principal could be renting out Dead Body of rape victim for sex ? . Also I feel they were selling live body’s ( Induced into Coma State ) . Not dead body’s alone ? People who were induced into a coma state they were alive but look dead . Body sold for organ parts . could be possible that they were renting out her Dead body for Sex - when they did not give the parents the Body it’s very possible that they were renting out her Dead body for Sex they were doing many sick things . This is possible and that’s why they were selling Dead body’s so renting is also possible -Many sick things are possible .

[@ranjinimillon]

The hospital is responsible for this incident. It happened while she was on duty

[@DanielDavid-w3m]

And the government in doing nothing abut he its and big shame on their leaders of India

[@williamkisku444]

WB deserves PRESIDENTS RULE

[@Vicky_5513]

😢

[@debubhaumik]

It is Rai

[@uncletom9321]

When the prime minister of the country has close relationships with serial rapst MP like Prajwal Revanna how do u expect the women of the country to be safe? The head of state is closely associated with a man who made 3000 videos of 400 women. How is this ok?

[@jewelspearls3752]

The Entire Police Force in Any Country should have to go for personality evaluation every year A Psychologist should be assigned to each category These people are dangerous especially if they are police officers or seniors but are psychopaths or NASCISIT They have weapons and uniform to be above the law Like the murder of Sushant Singh not only police uniforms worn by impersonators police vehicles and even equipment was used to kill him ...but the report by police at crime scene , Sushant committed SUICIDE Following his death many actors and actress and even bloggers were found hanging or missing However the CHIEF OF POLICE was tracked by the public by media till he had to go into hiding and became a fugitive Though the Police Force had their own media supporters What does this tell the entire Government ..That there could be many useless police chiefs or heads of departments who are exactly like " Fugitive Police Chief of Mumbai Kolkatta is far away but that does not mean it has a Citizens Police Force By the details of this case The Police Chief must be questioned on how and why people get into the voluntary police service Are they allowed the privileges given to police officers If Not WHY IS SANJAY roaming the streets after committing years of violence against woman especially his wives and he so bravely KILLED A DOCTOR ON DUTY went home to sleep Sickening and totally disgusting inhumane beast of a man SANJAY IS A MAD MAN MENTALLY DERANGED but a POLICE VOLUNTEER THAT TELLS THE WORLD OF THE POLICE FORCE OF INDIA JUST LIKE SUSHANTS MURDER WITH CAPITAL EVIDENCE , on the people the woman who set him up and even conversations before his death THE CBI still cannot crack the case !!! The Doctors and professional women must create their own organisation to fight and challenge all abuse against women. Draw your strength from "PEOPLE POWER " that's what Mahatma Ghandiji set as an example for Indians to fight the then super powerful BRITISH LEADERSHIP IN INDIA There will be no justice for the murdered Doctor Even if they sued the hospital for millions and the police force for employing a psychopath whatever money can never being her back to life This Psycho Sanjay may have raped many others , reports squashed we never know otherwise he would not have been so cool to go home and sleep as if it was just another mission accomplished kzbin.info/www/bejne/nXiun3proaimlbMfeature=shared 2*kzbin.info/www/bejne/nXiun3proaimlbMfeature=shared 3* kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z4Gci4iCe8Sbq8kfeature=shared

[@siddharthanvarier3342]

This guy is just a FALL GUY who left his blue tooth earphone at the crime scene There is more to this case than meets the eye and a lot of skeletons would fall from their closets by the time the CBI finally,closes this case.

[@esther41693]

Where. Mukesh Ambani and richest teams..... against this.... Where all famous people now?

[@debubhaumik]

Who is the news anchor trying to protect?

[@KtsKalyani-z7p]

We demand justice for Dr betia rip

[@1mikon]

Why was he given a job ?

[@Sandy-ed7ve]

What's the use of asking the TMC person?

[@SarasSingh-y2l]

Put pressure on Sanjay roy cause he knows all the truth i believe he is scared