mina called this 5th gen girl group member

[@yesyesyoo]

Natty have a long long journey, from Sixteen to idol school, solo career and here she is, being a member of an amazing group

[@kaotao1005]

Yesss I hope kiss of life really get more recognition

[@ClakyNotReversed]

​@@kaotao1005sorry for the long comment btw 😢 and sorry if I made English mistakes, it's my 4th language

[@jkyle1018]

Sixteen had the most stacked line up in Survival Show history.

[@deadringer2349]

No doubt!

[@theninearemine8499]

True, 15 of the 16 ladies debuted.

[@beob1601]

not only debut but also famous or superb famous​@@theninearemine8499

[@yesyesyoo]

@@theninearemine8499 correct *14, Minyoung and Eunsuh 🥲 I hear somewhere that Minyoung continue her study with her passion in music and Eunsuh idk there's no information about her, the last time she's participated with Jiwon and Natty in idol school

[@FrostyPlayzYT]

​@@yesyesyoo pretty sure minyoung had a digital single

[@Yourfavmulti-stan]

Aww I love that Mina still checks up on her 😭♥️

[@TheVallex]

Right? If that doesn’t show her true personality, i don’t what is

[@Yourfavmulti-stan]

@@TheVallex you're sentence doesn't make any sense

[@TheVallex]

@@Yourfavmulti-stan my mistake, i made a typo. Wrote Id instead of if, but i still think it was pretty readable 😂

[@PhoenyxEvhos]

I hope that one day all of the 16 members can meet again a lil reunion

[@FrostyPlayzYT]

@@thelyachronicles jiwon is literally in this video 😭minyoun]g tho,,, idk tbh

[@three-leggeddog4705]

@@FrostyPlayzYT Ik, I miss Minyoung alot. JYP lost another gem

[@Sanas_Shy_Language]

If any survival show needs a reunion, it's Sixteen. I mean, so many have debuted now. Obviously the members of Twice, Somi, Jiwon, Natty, Chaeryeong, and Chaeyeon have all debuted, like, I'd love to see them all together and just talking again. All of them have such unique journeys and experiences now since it's been 8 years since Sixteen ended.

[@MomoT-T]

mina and momo are so cute

[@ragadalnuaimi]

I need a sixteen reunion.

[@samrandom84]

Louder

[@VFRyan800]

Mina is the perfect example of, struggle, survive, thrive.

[@cloudydayofficial]

My precious Jiwon TT Dont cry. I remember watching both survival shows, I became a flover and kissy as well as a once

[@nabong5968]

Me too

[@wanishuk6489]

do you know where Jiwon are rn?

[@cloudydayofficial]

@@wanishuk6489 She debuted as a member of the girl group Fromis_9. This is the survival show that formed the group. I highly recommend giving their music a listen, its so good!

[@nakulmandhotra]

@@wanishuk6489 Jiwon is a member of girl group Fromis_9

[@WaffleBerry516]

​@@wanishuk6489 fromis_9

[@GleeChan]

I was wondering when we'd see TWICE and KIOF interactions. It seems they are doing it on a more personal level since we learned that Mina contacted Natty privately. Perhaps they don't want to rain on her parade and let her have her moment?

[@videokmk]

It's easier for groups to interact through the music shows if they release comebacks around the same time.

[@Bobsky143]

Nayeon and Julie will have a collab soon

[@Swi2thMummbles]

Imagine. 90% of jyp trainees become successful regardless of whether they stay or not at jyp.

[@onzons7604]

IU !

[@bribb9]

@@onzons7604 IU was never a JYP trainee but was rejected during the auditions. JYP said himself that he wanted to fire the person who rejected her hahah

[@Emporiox-xs9bq]

Natty ended up being at the right agency and group in my opinion, ngl JYP isn't producing many gg pops lately, but all kof songs are bangers

[@fndjufri]

My favourite group in Sixteen - SoMiNatty. Let's have a reunion!!! 🤣🤣🤣

[@natureguy0_1ca41]

JYP should make time for all the girls to get together more often when their schedules allow, I hope they all stay in contact with each other, this was such a wholesome and wonderful visit I often think that Twice would be the perfect group to take on training a new young group

[@g.yosh21]

I thought natty is a soloist like somi

[@marfur9]

There is a soloist called natty, but that is someone else

[@Sergote12]

@@marfur9i thought it was the same natty? I thought she soloed before joining kiss of life?

[@marfur9]

​@@Sergote12 never mind double checked, she just looks so different in her solo i thought it was someone else when i saw it recently

[@g.yosh21]

@@Sergote12 yeah i thought it was same natty so its a different person ??

[@marfur9]

@@g.yosh21 sorry, it was my mistake, no its the same person. But she looks like 3 different people from sixteen - teddy bear - KoL But she looks most different in the teddy bear era 😅

[@smvtttt]

Was that Jiwon from fromis_9 as well? They were all so young in those clips.

[@Park.Yoseob]

Well, she's doing great and grown-up now in fromis_9. Also, you should stan fromis_9 imo

[@eritoasuka]

Yeah, Jiwon and Natty was in SIXTEEN, the clip of them together again was in Idol School which is the survival show that created Fromis_9!

[@serigalaberbuludomba]

Thats her baby

[@Riizeis7burnsm]

I've always hoped we would get interaction like this with jiwon and chae sister.

[@chururira6510]

I want to see a sixteen reunion and a pd48 finale reuinion. or maybe just izone is fine too 😭 I MISS THEM ALL SMMM

[@ClakyNotReversed]

Awwww I can see they cared about each other a lot. Natty was probably one of the youngest trainees in JYPE at the time, and I can see Momo and the other members of Twice (and other trainees too) treating her well, taking care of her as the maknae there, etc... This video is really sweet, Natty was really sweet and her tears at the end 😢 Momo was so sweet too, I could see how much she is proud of her and how much she missed her. I always say this, JYPE idols are really amazing people! I know for a fact that JYPE prefers to have a trainee that is worse in skill than another, but has a heart of gold and a beautiful personality. Because you can teach the skills to be an idol, but you can't teach being a good person

[@chl3171]

❤❤❤

[@konradhenkel7284]

This is very cool 😎

[@CaffeineVirus]

If Jiwon stay at JYP after 16, she maybe keep training in Stray Kid show snd maybe debut in Itzy, will be main vocal. So sad.

[@unknownbliss3342]

It took her 2 generation to debut🥹

[@JaniaJosiah-n9w]

Wow that plastic surgeon did a good job

[@princegirish1991]

0:05 is that natty from 16 She looks different

[@Yourfavmulti-stan]

No its Natty 💀

[@oncextokki]

Yh it's natty from sixteen

[@yesyesyoo]

Because of make up maybe and puberty. Back in sixteen she's still 13 y.o

[@SakaiSteven]

Yes, same Natty People go thru puberty so it is normal that face change

[@eliseallard7994]

@keepitsecret-dl1pr finally someone who dares to speak the truth!

[@insanofrags]

bro, just today i realize natty is from sixteen, omg

[@oofedget]

NOW I REALLY WANT TO SEE EUNSUH AND MINYOUNG TO DEBUT, ISTG MINYOUNG WAS SUPPOSED TO DEBUT IN 6MIX BUT YUH TWICE FORMED AND SHE LOST😭

[@Janred05]

8.62k subs keep it up btw new subscriber here 😁

[@hyohyo418]

Pls I need those clips

[@sweeteste]

I SCREAAAAAMED

[@ainelina]

❤

[@thichzuize]

Where to see this

[@ViewportPlaythrough]

dont get me wrong, i did clicked on the video for mina and specially for natty but, MEGAN!!! so loud sheesh! 🤣🤣😂🤣 now i wonder who among momo or jiwon would have the loudest laugh 🤣

[@onceyuju4743]

Ah yes.. from 3rd Gen time, then Park Jiwon have debut in fromis_9 at 4th Gen.. and then Natty at 5th Gen, but what group she debut in??

[@Sanas_Shy_Language]

Natty debuted in a group called Kiss Of Life.

[@twicedemita2151]

wait were all in 5th gen now?

[@MrAresxy07]

Honest opinion as much as a i love kpop the reality of kpop companies are like concentration camps

[@erebusdark4614]

5세대가 아니라 4세대임. 트와이스가 3세대고 지금 나오는 애들이 4세대

[@poltergeistducs2948]

careful natty you will be the next victim of mina getting caught on 4k

[@nandithar9457]

🤣🤣

[@TWC-kl5ls]

Weirdo

[@noobmaster2940]

Mina saw Natty really grew up 😏

[@chobitASHL3Y]

not really related, but japanese members have got to be some of the most attractive in the business. mina and kazuha(le sserafim) are, like, unbelievably good-looking lol they're both absolutely stunning.

[@markrayanvaldez4136]

She outgrew everyone, even Jihyo's 👀. 😆😆😆

[@alexialovestwice]

???

[@serigalaberbuludomba]

Okay creep

[@markrayanvaldez4136]

@@alexialovestwice you know it 😘

[@alexialovestwice]

@@markrayanvaldez4136 that’s a weird think to comment on

[@markrayanvaldez4136]

@@alexialovestwice really?

[@theninearemine8499]

What the heck is this nonsense of (5th) gen? You guys make up a new gen every 2 years. 😂 ●1st gen - 1992-2005 (13 years) ●2nd gen - 2006-2015 (9 years) ●3rd gen - 2015-2017 ?????? ●4th gen - 2017-2019 ?????? ●5th gen - 2019-2021 ??????

[@Eluthien]

1st gen is just a generalisation so it's not an "actuall" thing (like WW1 was not WW1 until WW2 happened).2nd Gen was 2005-2011, 3rd Gen started in 2012 and ended in 2017. 4th Gen started in 2018 and ended in mid 2023. Late 2023 and onwards groups are considered 5th Gen. It's almost 5 year/gen.

[@theninearemine8499]

@Eluthien 😅 Sorry, that's not the way it works. What you guys are looking at are the phases of a single generation. Let me explain... by your logic. Wonder Girls 2nd, MISS-A (2 years later) 3rd, TWICE 4th, ITZY (2 years later) 5th, NiziU 6th, NMIXX 7th, VCHA 8th. I hope you can see what I mean. ●SNSD (2007) is (1st phase) of 2nd. F(x) (2009) was (2nd phase).

[@ernestogastelum9123]

@@theninearemine8499 groups like Le Sserafim and Newjeans who started in 2022 are 4th generation

[@Eluthien]

@@theninearemine8499 I have a problem following both your logic and in general what you are talking about. By my logic both Wonder Girls and Miss A were 2nd Gen. TWICE 3rd . ITZY , NiziU , NMIXX 4th. Same SNSD and f(x) are 2nd , RV 3rd etc etc. Gens are not something that is based on personal opinions. They are decided by the industry and Korean media/public. Categorizing groups by the same company in order of debut in "phases" is just weird and helps in nothing other than confusing both you and anyone that is trying to have a conversation with you especially when you are being incoherent. That's all from me. If you still don't get it then we just agree to disagree and all is well. 👍

[@hafizzain6911]

@@theninearemine8499 that actually how things work. For example 2ne1 is 2nd gen, Blackpink is 3rd gen & Babymonster is 5th gen. Theres no 4th gen YG girl group. It’s called gen (generation) not phase and you have to deal with it. Wonder Girls is 2nd gen, Twice is 3rd gen, Itzy & Nmixx is 4th gen