MSV A CREATOR GENIUS AND GOD -ANOTHER ASSERTION BY MADURAI SRI GS MANI-PART III

[@ravichandranm2388]

இப்படி பட்ட அற்புதமான மனிதர்கள் வாழ்ந்த காலத்தில் நானும் வாழ்ந்தேன் என்பது தான் எனக்கு கிடைத்த மாபெரும் பாக்கியம் இறைவனுக்கு நன்றி நன்றி 🙏🙏

[@usharanivaradarajan5036]

Kodi pranams Shri G S Mani Iyya Amazing information awesome singing sir. 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@nagarajahshiremagalore226]

Madhurai G S Mani spoke very well. He is great. Thanks for uploading this video.

[@devarajdeva2094]

Sri பகவத் ஐயா அவர்கள் சத்சங்கத்தில் இவருடைய பேச்சை கேட்டு வியந்தேன். ‌மீண்டும் வாய்ப்பு கிடைத்தது. 🙏. மிக்க நன்றி ‌ ஐயா.

[@subavictoria5610]

What a friend What a colleague What an associate A staunch admirer of the great msv.speaks out his heart

[@sridhar8450]

இதே நிகழ்வு மலேசியாவில் நிகழ்ந்தால் இருக்கைகள் போதாமல் போயிருக்கும்

[@srinivasamurali2159]

Lucky to have the Great inspirational Genius 🌞🌞🌞🌞🌄🌄

[@BavaniRajan]

You have displayed such humility in praising MSV, Sir, You are great.

[@redsp3886]

you are too great Rev.

[@meenalochanisuresh2980]

What a speach. Spell bound. So enthralling. Thee great G. S. Mani sir sonna madhiri, mayangi kidakkiren. So beautiful. Thank you so much G. S. Mani sir, for bringing the creation of the songs, alive for us. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@redsp3886]

mam, you have a beautiful name

[@natchander]

True M sviswanathans greatest contribution to Tamil films music...is being forgotten now The present generation have no patience to hear M S Vs grand music.. And the media..also does not speak much about M S V Let us remember M S VISWANATHAN

[@jbphotography5850]

இசை உலகின் அவதார புருஷன் எம்எஸ்வி ஈடு இணையில்லாத இசைக்கு சொந்தக்காரன் எம்எஸ்வி வாழ்க அவரது புகழ் வையகம் உள்ள வரைக்கும்

[@vikineswarymarimuthu1840]

For us of the 70s. Fantastic

[@seshadrisampath8435]

We are all Blessed Mani Mama🙏🙏

[@Good-po6pm]

இப்படியான நல்ல நிகழ்வுக்கு தமிழர்கள் நிறையவில்லை இருக்கைகள் நிறைய வெறுமனே கிடக்கிறதே - வடிதட்டுகள் .

[@svrmoorthy]

திரையிசையின் பொற்காலம் வாழ்ந்தவர்கள் நாம் என்ற இறுமாப்பு இறுதி வரை இருக்கும்

[@anbusir]

My appavin favarait also my favorite song song

[@muthumanickamboominathan3804]

Madurai G S Mani Sir very very thanks sir En kannil Neer varuhirathu Sir

[@tamilmannanmannan5802]

Isai mahan M.S.V.🎖 KAVI MAHAN🥇

[@vaidehib6901]

கண்ணதாசனைப்போலவும்விஸ்வநாதனைப்போலவும்இனிஒருவர் பிறக்க வாய்ப்பே இல்லை.

[@saikumar-yi6wk]

We love you Sir and Your Visu. Pranaams.

[@gopalakrishnan6892]

மேதைகள் கதையை கேட்கும்போது பிரமிப்பாக உள்ளது

[@jeyakumar2667]

MSV IS ONLY ONE LEGEND

[@sathyanarayanan976]

What is Sivaji to acting so is Msv to music ....... ironical similarity is both have not bothered for getting any high recognition inspite of their natural genius.....

[@sanjudurai5499]

Sir I'm melted

[@ravichandraankrishnan1355]

Sir Don't miss Madurai Mani Pl any one person interview YOU tube channel

[@ravichandraankrishnan1355]

Sir Kafi with Jai Laxman sir pl interview with Mani regard MSV

[@narayanaswamyhariharan3177]

Very honest man and talented

[@chandrasekarb2216]

Why is he not touching on the contribution of V K Ramamoorthy ? VKR was the one behind orchestration, arrangement and the chords. They add so much value to the songs

[@sreekkanthraghunathan6812]

Yes the contribution of VKR is forgotten by many. Had the duo continued Tamil cinema music world & fans would have gained more memorable songs

[@lotus4867]

Mani Sir is sticking to the topic - Msv . He is very fair in his expression/experience. Heart felt thanks to this great musician, he is so humble & full of respect for Msv sir . This speech should go into the archives.

[@ilangos2015]

Veeru unfair to omit TKR

[@ilangos2015]

Unfair for one person to claim all the credit. TKR was an unsung hero.

[@balubalu9450]

Very good satisfaction

[@soulcurry_in]

How does one become a member of this wonderful association? Please let me know.

[@mmfamellisaimannarfansasso231]

@soulcurry_in please contact WA 9600953535 or writte to [e-mail]

[@redsp3886]

why dislikes ji? he is telling from heart

[@hariramkumar94]

Don't interrupt him while he's going with flow... It's continuing in every video. People you know content be quite. Respect the person who's giving speech

[@isaistuffarvind]

saami🙏😂

[@prasanthps2165]

God =music=msv

[@suraensuraen773]

சுகமான அனுபவம்...

[@PremKumar-nk3db]

❤❤❤

[@Good-po6pm]

GOLDEN TALK

[@devadarshini7076]

Yes

[@jemimavasantha3746]

என்ன ஒரு விளக்க உரையாட ல்

[@sivaramakrishnang]

🎉👏

[@sivakumarramanathan3975]

இசை இமயம்.இருந்தவரை அவரை கவுரவிக்கவில்லை.மணிஅய்யர் இசைஞானி ஐயா வாலி போன்றோர் அவருடைய பெருமையை ச் சொல்லும்போது ஆனந்த கண்ணீர் வருகிறது.வாழ்க மெல்லிசை மன்னர் புகழ்.

[@karthiklakshmi]

Mani mama - Soundscaping or sound design is also an art and an integral part of music... creating music only with melody or composing with one or no instrument while amazing, does not have to be the central piece in music. At its core, how is melody not a form of sound-scaping or engineering? Where did the harmonium come from? Have you considered that it was cutting edge technology the day after it was invented? Can you pitch bend on a harmonium like a veena or violin? By using your own standards of musical purity, I would contend that you shouldn’t use the harmonium as it cannot properly render gamakas and sliding scales. Should we call blasphemy then on the harmonium sullying the holy waters of this high art form? (We shouldn’t). Also, since you seem so reviled by sound “producers”, perhaps you should try performing concerts or cutting an album in the future without the sound engineering mixing or mastering artists. To the modern wars, sound producers/artists have the ability to transport you to another world. Sounds exactly the same as what melody producers are trying to do. Your generation did stunning work creating melodic compositions based on raagas. But the world is more connected and there are other frameworks to produce music. Be it Kuthu, Gaana or Jazz. Accepting, learning and enjoying those works including “sound production” as musical art shows an evolved mind, in my view. I can’t help but think of an imaginary old iyer mama (not old in age), back in the day, yelling at his son for participating in the forbidden sensual dirty business called movies and producing “music” for the same. And that too, producing music with a harmonium! Lol. While I say all that, you are still a superb artist in my mind and deserve much respect to you for your contributions to music. “Sound producers” are musical artists too and deserve the same respect as Indian classical melody creators.

[@Sundar...]

@Karthik Lakshmi While your argument is logically valid against Mani Iyer's regret of lack of "classicism" in present-day music, I don't think the "sound directors" of today make the same impact on the soul of the audience as the "music directors" of the past did. There is nice line in a song from Anbe Sivam: "saaraayam bodhai tharum, thaaippaalum bodhai tharum, rendaiyum piriththariya buddhi illai." While their superficial effects are similar, one is life-destroying while the other is life-enhancing. That's exactly how sound production differs from music creation. Guess he had something along these lines in mind when he made that remark.

[@Lushendira]

❤️

[@seshachary5580]

THANK YOU REGARDS.

[@rambirthday8068]

MSV கூடவே பயணம் பண்ணிய தாங்கள் பெரும் பாக்யசாலிதான்!! ஆனால் அதைத் தாங்கள், நினைவு பிறழாமல் நாங்கள் கேட்க தருகிறீர்களே!! நாங்கள்"மிகப் பெரும் பாக்யசாலி" என்பதை தங்களால் மறுக்க முடியுமோ?!!

[@rambirthday8068]

உண்மைதானே??

[@dhanabalbalan1319]

மகான், அதை உடன்னிருக்கும் மாமேதை புகழ்ந்து பேசும் போது, அதை கேட்க எவ்வளவு ஆனந்தமாக உள்ளது, இது பதிவுகள் கண்டிப்பாக வரலாற்றில் பதிவு செய்யவது அவசியம், அப்போது தான் இதன் தன்மை, மெல்லிசை மன்னரின் அபாரம்மான ஆற்றல் உலகிற்கு தெரியும், புரியும், அறியும். காலத்தால் அழிக்க முடியாத பாடல்கள் ஏன் இன்று வரை நீங்காது இடம் பெற்றுள்ளது என தெரியும், இம்மாதிரியான பதிவுகள் மிகவும் அவசியம். அல்லது கண்டிப்பாக செய்ய வேண்டிய காலத்தின் கட்டாயம், இல்லை என்றால் அது பெரும் வரலாற்று பிழையாக ஆகிவிடும், எனவே இம்மாதிரி பதிவுகள் வரலாற்று பொக்கிஷங்கள்

[@mannarkural7466]

மிக்க நன்றி. எங்கள் பணி தொடர உங்கள் ஆதரவு தொடர வேண்டுகிறேன்

[@ilangos2015]

All the songs mentioned in this talk were composed with T.K. Ramamurthy but his contribution is totally ignored. Unfair.

[@krisnarasi2505]

Ilango S I thought the same.

[@NICENICE-oe1ct]

Tkr is music conductor not tune maker. So only he failed when he came out from MSV. Only 17 films he done alone. Only few songs popular.

[@venkatr2446]

He was not involved in tune making.

[@ilangos2015]

@@NICENICE-oe1ct may be . But songs of duo MSV & TKR are much more greater and pleasing than solo songs of MSV.

[@69rkannan]

Poor audio...

[@chandra4u306]

😮😮😮😅 0:32

[@swaminathans3706]

Shri Madurai GS Mani is a genius. He wasted his time with MSV

[@mmfamellisaimannarfansasso231]

But Mr GS Mani feels the best time in his career was the time with MSV

[@ytadltspv]

ippadi manikkanakkaaga paesubavargal vayadhil miga periyavargal stage la oru chair la amarnthae paesalaamae

[@mmfamellisaimannarfansasso231]

offered but he declined

[@ytadltspv]

@@mmfamellisaimannarfansasso231 white plastic chair koodaadhu. Sofa, settee, pol furniture try seyyungal aduththa murai

[@sreekkanthraghunathan6812]

@@ytadltspv good suggestion friend. Elders should be respected

[@NICENICE-oe1ct]

Tkr is only conductor. All tunes from Msv only. So only Tkr could not get success while he done seperately.

[@springjanani]

Puthiya paravai director was Dada Mirasi. Not Bhim Singh .

[@SubramaniSR5612]

No Rajagopalan. Mani sir was referring as Bhimsingh for another song Yaar andha nilavu from movie Shanthi directed by Bhimsingh. I hope you will agree with me. Thank you.

[@jemimavasantha3746]

என்ன ஒரு விளக்க உரையாட ல்