Mnet's editing is getting out of hand

[@jaeminisnt1862]

Correction: In episode 4 during the rehearsal Hui mentions that his throath condition wasn't good at the moment so the mentors advice him not to do the high note that way (to not damage his vocal chords) I made this video before watching episode 4 so i went with what i saw in episode 3 So sorry for the mistake

[@biniberryblue08]

Hui's vocals were never bad lmao I hope mnet stops using Hui for creating dramas

[@elysian4539]

It's not being bad it's being too much trying too hard

[@db2663]

They never said he's bad, he was just streching the notes too much, which changed the original sound of the song. Also he said his condition was not good, so they said he shouldn't go that high, but nevertheless, he obviously slayed.

[@kkikkodan]

​@@db2663 stfu it wasn't him stretching the notes it was yedam 😭

[@jilliasheyvw4568]

Hui is one of the best vocalist in BP999. But when a great singer improvises the note so much, sometimes it feels like it's not pleasing to hear. A professional singer is the one who can balance their improvised note in a performance.

[@rovicreel9406]

@@elysian4539 you're srsly saying this to a renown music producer in the industry? lmao pls 💀 hui can be a mentor there too let's be fr, just because the "mentors" says it's not right it automatically means that its wrong, it doesn't work that way. and all in all, hui still slayed and proved why HE IS THAT VOCALIST 🤭 winning by a landslide.

[@wana2648]

It was funny when they repeat hui part 3 times 🤣 it suddenly feel like watching indonesian drama 🤣

[@vieyrinnoa7257]

Aseli kak, ngeselin banget.. kok jadi kayak sinetron indo 🤣

[@Unununbelievable]

😂

[@sakyabena]

Ikr!!!! Wkwkwkwkwkwkwk capek jadi nontonnya kek njir ga kelar2 dia nyanyi nih

[@vieyrinnoa7257]

@@sakyabena sampe pens yg nonton ikut di sorot pun berulang kali, untung ga semua nya, kalo ga deuhh lebih dari 2 jam tuh se episode

[@leetaeyong2410]

More like Indian dramas 💀💀💀👁️👄👁️

[@SuperButcherPete]

Oh my gahd. Hui hit that note flawlessly. Who thought he'd have it in him...😑

[@taemincriminie]

I always believed he would do it As long as no one pressured him so much. The pressure got the best of him but HE CAN DO IT!!!!!😁👏🏿!!!!!

[@eleanornicholls8991]

I wouldn’t say flawlessly he still strained and pushed

[@naegabyeonhae9750]

It was strained wdym by "flawless"

[@cs.5052]

@@naegabyeonhae9750 if you saw the actual episode, his voice was in a pretty bad condition, very sore, so this was flawless considering his context atm, tyvm.

[@naegabyeonhae9750]

@@cs.5052 ik i’ve watched the whole ep, don’t get me wrong i didn’t write that comment to hate on hui. but you can’t presume that his high notes at that time we’re flawless, kudos to him tho for holding that note while he’s not in his best condition.

[@setareh5888]

After tons of evil editing on him, he deserved those good reactions. He vocal is amazing. How do people think a musical actor can sing badly?

[@eleanornicholls8991]

People can’t always be perfect and we have off days that’s why

[@moarmygene7310]

HE'S A MUSICAL ACTOR?!

[@Lunaveon]

@@moarmygene7310 Yes, he had the lead in "Sonata of a Flame" - he was practicing for it during Road to Kingdom!

[@moarmygene7310]

@@Lunaveon Omw cool!! Will go check it out🥰

[@xyzme1217]

They never said he can't sing. They said his voice matters more than the stage.

[@Ndoyy99]

The flashback in the middle of the performance got me ☠️☠️☠️

[@taemincriminie]

Ye dam was the first one I voted for. He killed that stage and took the criticism very well. That's idol material right there.

[@ashm003]

For real. He killed his parts and made the stage more enjoyable

[@FK-qc9gx]

He got done dirty being cut away during his dance break

[@ashm003]

@@FK-qc9gx i agree :(

[@elithluxe7568]

Is he the yedam from treasure who left to become a producer? Or just another guy with the same name

[@ashm003]

@@elithluxe7568 theyre different. The yedam from treasure is bang yedam. This one is lee yedam.

[@CataCovi]

That amazing Hui’s voice

[@adominos9221]

Huis voice are amaizing but jake give a new colour with his voice

[@xiaotangchen-lt7os]

@@adominos9221 it's Jay please

[@clarkeraven4291]

Amazing but not suitable for a 4th gen boy group 💀

[@clarkeraven4291]

@@xiaotangchen-lt7os Agree

[@xiaotangchen-lt7os]

@@clarkeraven4291 5th gen it's what mnet has said

[@pimpim6552]

Even though I like Hui, watching him 3 times and insert long flashback is too much.. I end up watching the full version without any cut instead, don't know how to call that.

[@CataCovi]

Mnet is so evil

[@daydreamsun]

Fr

[@jungshookjiminie1176]

@mr meow kzbin.info/www/bejne/eqO7hKmOj6xljs0 this is the full version🥰 and it's so much better than the edited one because you can actually enjoy the performance😭😭

[@pimpim6552]

@@jungshookjiminie1176 better for just listening as well.

[@rainflowart]

I think it’s called an uncut version

[@aaiisshaa8901]

I’ve noticed something…Mnet only puts the good reactions when it is the K groups performance meanwhile G group just gets a bland stage with little to no reactions…Reactions can be a but too much but they do hype up the audience and make it seem like the K group was better

[@solebridge5747]

I feel like compared to group G, group K just have way better stages, just in terms of the set the lighting etc. The only G group winning (which was kill this love) incorporated the dramatic lighting, but I feel it's also just home town turf bias. Personally I was annoyed how most of the bad singers from Group K somehow scored higher than the G counterparts, or Jay getting 66 included. I want group G to win just because of how they are setting group K up to be this unbeatable force, it's annoying.

[@ashm003]

​@@solebridge5747 yup. I hate the whole K vs G concept. The way it divides the contestants and creates a feeling of inferiorty for the G group members especially is so bad, not to mention that the k group seems to be favored over the g group.

[@vixxexo6855]

@@solebridge5747 I feel like the worst G contestants are worse than the worst K contestans. Like the Danger team both has bad trainees, but the G group was even worser.

[@tysedon]

What do you expect from xenophobic mnet who edited C group of gp999 as the big bad villain until the girls lost all of their confidence because of the hate comments they receive from those evil editing? In gp999, they made K trainees as angels, C trainees as evils, J trainees as ghosts

[@StanChunghaOrGoHome]

Mnet 100% is biased towards k group, they don’t even try to hide it. Korean trainees rarely ever get evil edits, yet the global ones get evil edits left and right.

[@SleuthySocks]

I feel like the way they edited K group's performance, it lost some impact because we aren't allowed to just enjoy it. The performance only version is much better

[@CataCovi]

Agree

[@XurAziX]

It's a show so they wanted to add in the reactions and everything while also showing (almost) the full performance at the same time (hence the repeating). That's why they uploaded the full version on here so we can actually enjoy it.

[@pimpim6552]

They even have the guts to evil edit Hui of overdoing the notes while Mnet themselves overdid the reaction edit.

[@ainocj173]

​@@XurAziX adding reactions are fine, but there's no need to repeat it three times, 2 times have been used a lot in the past and its enough.

[@susshimin]

I think the reason why hui's high note was intensely edited was not to doubt his vocals, but mnet wants to add some thrill since there was a big comparision on hui's improvising. Even their dress rehearsal (hours before the performance), Hui still pursued the improvised note and in the final edit, he stayed with the original key. I dont think its wrong

[@bondyaliano]

Everytime someone performs a highlighted part, they always have to quickly zoom in to the "rival" pouting or being disgusted/shocked 🙄

[@myk-popper2960]

Which we all know was taken from an unrelated scene haha

[@kairomouse]

they NEVER show Yedam, that breaks my heart because he has so much potential to debut 😭😭😭

[@Lunatic_1]

At least he got screen time in dance battle, just that make me so happy

[@woemrainsworth1371]

Meanwhile they cut lines from G group's performance just to add reactions. So unfair.

[@linosdori]

Fr the favouritism mnet has is clear

[@jeyserii3102]

I keep watching their stage again and again same goes with the backdoor stage of K group

[@userpluto]

it just hurts seeing hui proving himself all over again :(

[@rubyjomao-as8527]

Never tired of watching this team especially sung hanbin😍

[@mackerelgod]

mnet really milking audience interest by Hui being in that show because from beginning, the edited preview made as if Hui performing will be so bad and make fans malding. but it is not, Hui on the stage is so good and not as bad as the edited preview

[@mcqelle]

Hui had a bad throat that day and the mentors didn't want him to make his throat any worse, that's why Hui changed to the original version last minute.

[@jungshookjiminie1176]

This is my favourite performance so far but I was sooo frustrated with the editing when I watched the episode🥲😂 like you don't have to throw hui's highnote three times into my face to let me know he's a great vocalist😭😭

[@sunoollify7388]

i honestly prefer jay's high note over hui's

[@shara5985]

Same, I hope a Jay is able to debut. I think he actually has a better voice than most of the boys on the show. Including Hui.

[@xrrgr]

same i think the point of the video what just that the editing trying to make hui look like he was in danger was kinda ridiculous

[@xrrgr]

@@shara5985 i like his vocal color more, but in terms of technique hui is definitely still better

[@shara5985]

@naomi obi but see, Jay doesn't have a lot of technical training. Once he gets it, he's gonna blow everyone out of the water.

[@Chloe-ct7vz]

yea fr i repeat his part a lot, he really carry his team

[@noladasjajaja4573]

why don’t they just debut hanbin already, he’s just so perfect 😭😭😭😭😭

[@Merlina2004]

He is gonna debut for sure no one is gonna take his place He has the most huge fanbase

[@anushkanegi304]

EXACTTLYY

[@Wahwahhhh]

Now I think that mnet has already planned who they are going to debut..

[@chivo7367]

I think thats the truth. Its hard to find concept and songs for a group that newborn for just a few months after the show so of course mnet's already had their line up that fit in their concept and songs and they will edit and give their bias more screentime to make sure they will debut. If it doesnt work? Thats fine they will rig the votes.

[@oohhyunee6908]

Mnet has always planned the lineup even before the show aired. I feel like we are just watching idol drama series directed by Mnet lol

[@shara5985]

It's going to be mainly Koreans. Even though Seok Mathew is not nationally korean, he is ethnically. Which is why they give him so much screen time. It sucks

[@hockeyblues46]

@@shara5985 So Matthew is pure Korean and he just born and raised in Canada?

[@shara5985]

@@hockeyblues46 Yep, pure Korean. Nationally Canadian.

[@shriyamakeupvanity9166]

Seriously this performance had me on the edge of my seat like i just want to enjoy the performance 😭😭and plus Viki keeps showing ads in between performances

[@ni-kiminajenhypen9577]

mnet rlly need an editing tut from us

[@icegongju8027]

mnet literally repeat jeonghyeon's rap 3 times, make a whole flashback before hui's high note n repeated it again for 3 times, n use hanbin's intro since ep 2 but we are getting this stage at the end of ep 4 this is soooo foullll

[@sanjitkumarghosh4572]

This is like Indian daily soap ,replaying a moment thousand times and showing everyone's reaction to expand the screentime.

[@thitsar2376]

Hui is a talented boy and also hard working. His voice is amazing 🤩. Please vote for Hui 🙏. He is one of the boys who should debut.🥺

[@thv_jkk4718]

this is Hui's beautiful voice, I'm so proud of him,but why people act like it's not he's vocal.

[@dorsaftrabelsi1416]

At some point it seriously felt like watching a bollywood drama and it was an unpleasant experience

[@mcy6826]

I feel so bad for Hui...hes one of the best voices and singers and now...hes doing all this

[@tehelea]

their editing is truly something else

[@yunomiadiam9190]

Hui slayed even with his throat not in it's best condition! I love how he added his kind of style tho🧡

[@cinderrela7268]

Respect to the editors. They save us time and effort for replaying videos and searching for any other videos with audience’ reactions to the perfomance😊

[@onepiecefan1459]

He did amazing 😭

[@ashm003]

Ye dam impressed me. I wish he got more praise. Sung Hanbin and Hui did really well of course, but i didnt expect Ye dam to be so charismatic and to have so much personality in his dancing.

[@tomaslorenzovillegas9546]

Uno de los puntos fuertes de la industria audiovisual de Corea es la edición. Ellos son especialistas en contar una historia. El tiempo no es lineal en los programas Coreanos. Dividen el presente en varias partes y te la muestra poco a poco. Es un estilo nacional que ha funcionado muy bien

[@yugayruslan7390]

This Hui moment reminds me the Mamma Mia performance of Produce 48, because the main vocal there had similar situation as him.

[@alisonbae-tv4gq]

K group vs G group concept is so damn frustrating they should just have done it like gp999. I expected to see teamwork between K and G trainees. Honestly how does Mnet manage to f up every season

[@thitiphonelarnorphet5936]

Please make more of these videos XD. I love this vid ❤. I'd love u to make similar vids for some other performances in boys planet as well.

[@che1seyvi01et]

i can imagine it drives people crazy i personally love it because I wanna watch it again and again and again it's too good😭😭

[@eupsychics8167]

i hate how this is so accurate

[@cinnamonroll96]

But also yes, the editing is so freaking hilarious, it’s as if you watch some trash tv reality show and the reactions they showed of hui when g group was singing love me right and jay had his parts…the editing made it look like hui is in some trash tv reality and is seeing/reacting to a clip of some contestant talking shit about him. It’s so funny 😂😂 also the dance battle(?)/wrestling clip/trailer where one dude is throwing his shirt, and Haruto is like ayayayaya so freaking gold. Then Ricky’s catchphrase, this dude can’t be real 😂😂 I wish I was young, rich, tall and handsome 😅 And uff, generally sometimes when they sing (I know they are trainees, and I’m also a bit over-exaggerating) especially when they sing seventeen songs (maybe they are particularly difficult which also makes me appreciate my boys even more) it sounds like I just turned on the tv and watched the auditions for DSDS (for all my German fellows you know what I mean why I say that). 😂😂

[@jays3202]

For seventeen song , i also thought the traniees did that much good same with hot sauce ones , may be bcz those 2 songs didn't get good traniees both is k and g groups

[@denises3283]

There is 100% favoritism toward the K-group in my opinion, which is sad because there's so many good trainees in G-group :(

[@hockeyblues46]

Not surprised at all because of what Mnet did to C-group in GP999.

[@lenal6868]

At first, I couldn't see what everyone was talking about......now, I did. Mnet for some reason has chosen to whittle down certain videos in favor of others. If you look at the number of views for each video, the video (stage without edit at 3:10 minutes) only had 381,789 views. But the longer video (stage with edit--4:30 minutes has 612,296 views). I hope that this lengthening of the video was to give a longer view of each group member.

[@ramyeonz8447]

I’m just glad I’m not the only one who gets low key irritated by 5 reactions being edited in over a 3 second part cause I swear it be pushing me off my rocker sometimes 💀.

[@da_weird_hooman]

Why is everyone acting like this was done for the first time?.... This has happened from pd101 onwards. They have always done this. Why do you think they purposefully delayed k group exo performance when G group's performance was shown in the previous episode. This was not the first time and won't be the last time. But i do enjoy watching the reactions though.

[@MsJackieJack]

Lmao i felt weird about the amount of reaction shots by this point too, glad i wasnt the only one!

[@gourichandran6510]

Even I always feel the same. Mnet doesn't allow me to finish seeing the performance!😒🙈😪

[@yoselinlizbethparedespuma772]

Muy talentoso Hui 🥰

[@AzelTV]

He was on bad condition then mnet used that

[@mirovio]

They are doing the overly centered editing on Hui just like what they did to Heeseung in ILAND. People literally knew they are talented and skilled without those unnecessary editing. I think this one is just more overdone. Instead of making them look good, it has an opposite effect which makes the other people sick of seeing the individual do great and starts to find fault on them. It happens a lot with popular ones.

[@afia7710]

1:04 hui was straining a lot in the rehearsal and his voice was not in good condition, that’s why he said it’s much better. I personally preferred Jay’s ver better but they were both nice 🫶🏾

[@purpurr707]

Lol the editing couldn't be more different from Peak Time where you can actually complete the performances as it should be xD then they sometimes highlight the parts they skipped at the commentary at the end of the performance. JTBC is way more genuine in promoting the contestants. And there's like no elimination until the finals.

[@Mbbniya]

Hui slaying with his vocals effortlessly

[@ririenko]

Why is mnet even doing this k versus global. Kinda unfair. Watch almost all global get eliminated since only one global team got the voting benefits.

[@jaeminisnt1862]

Ik I hate the whole K group vs G group thing it makes no sense I hope they drop it after this elimination

[@sarashekh8636]

Kim Gyuvin 🥺 they have give him a very short part, Didn't even show him much on camera

[@rizkymln97]

Because gyuvin himself is not really confidence in his skill, please watch the full episode. It is still a good thing he didn't do any mistake.

[@sarashekh8636]

@@rizkymln97 🥺i watched already 2 time it's oky I think he will his best next stage

[@wabisabi7755]

This is why I always prefer to watch the MV versions. The reactions break the momentum. 😂

[@parkhae-il9211]

seriously WTF, hui is already talented with his vocals. no doubt about his high notes, that one mentor has some issues. when i hear Hui do his high notes it comes from his heart, nothing more. Good thing i don't watch these survival shows, i watch the highlights coz it's such a waste of time

[@Kpopseoulbox]

Mnet should give other trainees a chance to screen time their self more why they always showing Hui lmao he already debuted and has a enough frame !

[@anhlinhtran3883]

if they like K trainees and show the audience a lot of good about them and make G trainees weak or something, then why don't they ban/disallow foreigners from joining kpop instead of miserable Low ability or bad editing about them? I feel bad for both G & K group :((((((

[@anhlinhtran3883]

If I wrote something wrong ,I'm sorry

[@ughgowonsscalpandcrunchyvo4926]

that’s why I watch the official performance, I’m still traumatized by Sakura’s audition during P48

[@rizkymln97]

Hui got sore throat at that time-_ this is why the coaches put more attention for him-_

[@mugne28]

Love the song choice 🙌🫶

[@karlafernanda529]

Okay, to be honest, I like it when they show many reactions to the parts I liked the most lol

[@Raphael-2]

Same! It's really satisfying to me. I think most people think that way.

[@arjayyoung5357]

thats how a tv show works if you want a full stage then watch it on music programs..

[@nakoringtheproudorbit6412]

Mnet took inspiration from Indian serials

[@suhadinieperera8027]

Hui>>>>

[@lovepentagon8646]

I don't mind hearing Hui's godly vocals so many times💜

[@meld5542]

Hui doesn't need to be in a group anymore, he is perfect to do solo. He's been in different kpop group, it's time for him to step up and do his own thing. He can shine on his own.

[@gavisbarbie]

Mnet really editing like those Indian drama meme edits fr

[@theonewhorandomlypopsupeve1995]

Sungmin? Am I seeing a fellow Sungmin Stan 👀

[@gyuniverse0_1]

Me too, Sungmin is my one pick :D

[@Watermelon523]

Tbh they should just use this show to get their name out then drop it or smth. If they're not korean, winning this show and debuting is a curse rlly. They'll just live in the company's favoritism. Just look at kep1er

[@JolieGirl2002]

I think I'm the only one who likes the repeating stuff like yeah maybe I need to see that shit cause they ATE??!?!?!?

[@jaeminisnt1862]

well you got a point haha

[@Raphael-2]

No I love it too! It's so satisfying. I only hate it when it's a bad moment. But when it's a good moment especially for a contestant that were rooting for, it's so nice and satisfying! I'm sure most people like that too.

[@snehalbarde4880]

No the fact that I couldn't even see their performance on hitv and searched for like entire 2 hrs and couldn't find it anywhere in the 3rd ep,

[@lubnamahmood2251]

That's why there is full version ✌️✌️..

[@a.n.8972]

brother they really didn't let me enjoy this great stage like this editing decreased the value of this performance in my eyes because i was just annoyed the whole time. and the flashback before the highnote?? girl we saw the whole thing we knew he was struggling, i know i have bad memory but like we saw it two minutes before this-

[@rayliur]

Ok I'm glad I wasn't the only one who noticed this. I'm like can we just watch their performance like normal people?....

[@KayaaaaDe]

I am expecting the reactions of janitors too next time.

[@jaeminisnt1862]

Hahahahah

[@as-rz]

your edit is hilarious tho XD

[@_SoUL2204]

JAAAAAAAAY ಥ⁠‿⁠ಥ

[@vuduc5553]

Jay is the best.

[@JiroBytes]

I mean that is why there are full performances and one that has a reaction on it incase what ever performance you wanna watch... What's the point of comparing the two clips?

[@achuuz]

Tell me we aren't acting like the highnotes hui did in the rehearsal were good. Like he's a great singer but he sounded like he's screaming in pain. Which makes sense because my vocal chords hurt from listening to them. I was at the edge of my seat crossing my fingers that he was going to just do the regular highnote like everyone advised him to do and thank god he did

[@myk-popper2960]

Notes like that usually he can do easily without straining but he was apparently not in a good condition

[@elaineuwu3699]

Prob done on purpose for mnet drama/viewers. Don't forget Somi faked a fight for views lol (but it's hilarious). Hui is a smart man. This got him screen time obv (no hate).

[@piliredondo2661]

But Hui’s voice did sound a bit hoarse during evaluations, and for the last rehearsal. He focused a lot on his dancing, since he believes that’s his weakness. Plus, he’s the leader of the team. His condition wasn’t the best. He made the right decision.

[@enhaworld]

they weren’t but he did state that he wasn’t in good condition, those notes are usually no problem for him. im glad he did what was best for himself and he did amazing.

[@windyday6850]

He's literally the best vocal on the show, sit the down.

[@SkzCompilations]

I watched episode 5 yesterday, I cried so much-!😭 Even if I did'nt vote for Krystian I am still happy that he did'nt get eliminated. He got so much evil editing, I feel really bad for him and the others who has been getting it.

[@missato8214]

Vote for the slay guys !! 😔😔😔 1:10

[@missato8214]

And also look at those vocals !!😔 1:26

[@xiumin6823]

Well, that is why Mnet is providing FULL stage without reactions. I enjoy seeing some reactions though so I'm not really complaining

[@zhisu2665]

I don't care how the audience is reactingggggggggggg

[@hoseokismyhope3351]

Wow i dont watch boys planet but these kids are really good. Great performance

[@ekwaiedoktong1384]

Gg should’ve win for me

[@JSN_1997]

but it's memeable atleast

[@jaeminisnt1862]

True

[@roremaco]

i want to say this for those who are unaware so mnet actually posts a youtube video including the reactions and a youtube video of just the stage so you can see the uninterrupted performance. but i agree the show is kinda annoying cuz it keeps repeating parts after reactions.

[@noladasjajaja4573]

i’m pretty sure that if it wasn’t bc of mnet’s stupid editing no one would have ever doubted on hui’s vocal skills

[@jiffyviv5341]

and the fact that they put on the screen that you can watch the full performance on youtube and one would expect to actually be the full un-interupted performance but, NOPE, instead it was just the exact same thing from the episode...

[@lazes2109]

I honestly like the retakes I wanna see everyone’s reaction AND the actual choreography. If you just wanna enjoy the performance uninterrupted there’s a different video up for that lol

[@itslonelysaram6722]

it wasn't even because Hui was singing badly, it was just he was trying to hit different notes.

[@QuokkaCola143]

Basically this was Exactly what I was going through my head while watching it. 🤣🤣🤣

[@anialit4373]

Tbh at first I thought that those dramatic cuts like with previous clips were just shown in hui stage ( yk drama, more views, just mnet things) but then I saw other stage group... I think they started with new editing style lol... This getting out of control

[@splendore.ngrandeur3599]

There was no evil editing on this one