Modern Historians of Ancient India FULL CHAPTER | RS Sharma Chapter 2 | Ancient History

[@PWOnlyIASUPSC]

Download PDF From Here: www.pw.live/study/batches/samagra-book-series-batch--hinglish--902582/batch-overview 📳For Free Notes Quizzes and Tests - t.me/pw_upsc

[@anchalduhan]

Sir notes download nhi ho rhe hai

[@theundetaker.g]

​@@anchalduhanbrother same here how to download the notes

[@theundetaker.g]

Yrr ik min ni lga ga btana ma, hdd ho gyi yrr bta do

[@shaimahkhan3125]

Colonial historians viewed India as a country that lacks the feeling of nationhood and self governance. They proposed that scriptures in India had no sense of time and chronology and people were only interested in spiritualism due to which the society needs someone to govern them. The Indian society has caste system due to which it lacks harmony. The modern Indian historians rectified this generalisation by putting forward the ancient Indian history which preaches about the governance of Ashoka’s kingdom and making clear that India is well versed in self government and do not require a despotic rule. The rationalist did felt that there was a need of reform which every society needs in terms of growth and development. Certain writers such as RD Bhandarkar criticised child marriage and were in support of widow remarriage as they were ideologies from the ancient india. The modern historians such as Rajendra Lal mitra marked that the class system in Europe was similar to caste system In India.

[@mdmobrur8668]

Hey your answer appreciated by sir next video you see

[@shaimahkhan3125]

@@mdmobrur8668 Yes I saw that..Thank you

[@mdmobrur8668]

@@shaimahkhan3125 hey where you actually studying self or any coaching?

[@shaimahkhan3125]

@@mdmobrur8668 only watching these videos and studying..no coaching

[@shaimahkhan3125]

@@mdmobrur8668 only watching videos and studying… no coaching

[@mervick8ballpool549]

I was struggling for my history preparation but now I think my search is over just because of your valuable video Sir... Plzz don't break the chain sir🙏🙏

[@shishuranjan7195]

will you read rd sham or any other book too??

[@Taiyaarimantra_zz]

This should be kept parallel to the book, if you feel some key points are missing then please add in your notes

[@grvmavi]

Political history -expertise in administration. 1. D R Bhandarkar - political institutions of Ashoka. 2. Hemchandra rai chaudhary - From Mahabharat -gupta era . Criticise ashoka peace policy. Hindu revialism - R c Majumdar . Focus on south india - K A nilakanta shastri - 1. history of ancient india. 2. History of south india . Talks about supremacy of brahmana . Early indian society was peaceful. Criticism of political history - Glorification of region dynastic. Inspired nationalism. Kushan and shaka - assimilate indian culture. Kp jayaswal - republic in india. Self govt. Non political history - A l basham - From Modern view - Ancient times - dont judge. Lokayata - curiosity and pleasure. Materialistic philosophy. Dd kausambi - 1957 - an introduction to the study of indian history. The civilisation of ancient india in historical outline . Materialistic interpretation. Derived from marxion . View based on production. Contemporary history writing - Anthropological sources . Based on coins ,author, Inscription. Now has professionalism.

[@136Goodhuman]

amazing lecture sir bilkul clear ho gya chapter thanks sir

[@sonisharma29200]

Sir class ke sath sath pyq bhi krwa diya kriye

[@harshapatel7071]

Khud se bhi kuch karle bhai...

[@sanavlogs12]

Pyq mtlb

[@harshapatel7071]

Previous year question papaer

[@aspriant_wala]

😊

[@urmeesingh1905]

Thankyou sir. Sir hm sath ke sath notes bna rhe hai.

[@nutantiwary4122]

Making notes with class Best teacher of History Thanks sir

[@RameshDeshmukh-n4f]

Amazing ur mind maps are soo good I can easily understand

[@tetal5447]

Very knowledgeable instructor engaging me with interactive discussions, informative slides, and practical examples, fostering an enriching learning environment. Thank you sir 😇

[@aadyaraj5895]

Very impressive class sir But ek request hai apse, sir wo part aap btate rhna history ka jo important nii isse hm differentiate krppaye ki hme kya pdhna hai aur Kaun sa topic leave krna hai .. Thnk uh sir...

[@nilaysarkar1221]

Answer of the given question 👇👇👇 The colonialist historians generalized Indians in the following category: i. No nationhood,ii. Caste and discrimination,iii. Despatic rule and iv. Spiritualism and the next world thinking. Let's discuss the counters of Nationalist historians through the following points: i. Through the writting of RG Bhandarkar's Political history of Satavahanas he proved the that we have nationhood in ourselves. ii. Rationalist approach of Some nationalist historians compare our caste system to the European's class system, which some how managed the criticism of colonialist historians. iii. DR Bhandarkar's Work on Ashoka and Hemachandra Roy Chowdhury's Work on Mahabharata to Gupta Era showed the administrative power on Indians and the capabilities of Indians to govern themselves. iv. The Lokayata believes of Ancient India proved the "this world thinking" of Indians and showed that Indians were not only tensed about the next world but also payed attention to this world.

[@AneequaAarifaHaque]

Very good teacher 👏

[@rishikayadav6469]

Colonial historians are those who argued that Colonial rule was right in India. They argued that Indian do not have proper time chronology, they like Despotic rule, believes in Spiritualism and thinks about the next world i.e. after death world, Caste & discrimination and also argued that there is no nationalism as well as no self governance. Though which was then rectified by Modern Historians that they are not fully right as taking an illustration that self government or talking about political history under Ashoka's rule there was well established self government which was even told by D.R. Bhandarkar in his book named- "Political Institution of India". Similarly, many modern historians argued such as Rajendra Lal Mitra in his book talked about Indo Aryans, Vedic texts related to rationalistic approach.

[@deepakdubey7887]

1:08:25 D.D Kaushambi

[@chgsbhu]

Right right sun sun kr pkk gye bhai😮

[@roufahmaddar8516]

Sir Aise he flowcharts aur points mein likhayee.... Because It is concisely being written in notes..... And getting revised easily.... Your teaching style is so good sir......

[@siddharthkumar6453]

You are an amazing teacher. I am liking the Speed, methods of teching and timeline wow. 😊

[@ThunderingClouds]

Sir is amazing but wht abt R.S. Sharma whom Supreme Court scolded left and right during Ram Janmbhoomi case presenting fake History to the Court by Sunni Waqf board quoting R.S Sharma and marked it jst an opinion..how can we reading someone opinion as a History in such prestigious exam like UPSC?? R.S Sharma is irrelevant in current time as Rationality and Scientific Temperament increasing in our Country

[@siddharthkumar6453]

@@ThunderingClouds You can become a very good advocate

[@Pragati_Gautam_vlogs]

Simply amazing classes

[@LazyAspirant-ke6ch]

Lecture done+made notes Awesome teaching sir

[@simrankumariburman6678]

Wow what an explanation, u r an amazing teacher .❤

[@mohinisharma8660]

Best teacher for history 😊

[@anishasingh1044]

My favorite teacher for my favorite subject. 🙇‍♀️❤️🧿

[@aalamalham8737]

Sir aapne to history kha rkhi hai, Aaap to aise padha rhe hain jaise ki apne hi history bnayi hai🤩. Really I am enjoying to read history and its easy to remember also.

[@Aditi_Kishore]

Sir you the best History I ever came across. And as a GURU you don’t need to worry that students will feel bad if you take reference of any religion… etc. Aap humare guru hai and koi fark nhi padta hum kis religion se hai, humein kabhi bura nhi lgega, aap toh humein itna kuch seekha rahe hai. students be it from any religion will always respect you and aap itna acha kaam kr rhe h hum sab ko padha kar, aapko itna sorry bolne ki need nhi hai Sir. Thank you for teaching us🙏🏻

[@sonisharma29200]

Sir hm apke sath notes bnate hai and uske revision krne mai help ho jati hai

[@NidhiBanga-n1q]

Bombay Asiatic society was set up in 1804 AD..

[@Aditya-Saroj]

Thanks sir I watched thrice time this lecture.

[@rohinisharma2626]

Method of teaching is awesome

[@PadhleSoc.science]

Such a great explanation ❤ Thank you sir!

[@BabitaPra-kq5pr]

Sir please her ek chapter ka test bhi conduct kariya aise to sab bhul jayenge please sir for the strong the topic please conduct the test😭😭😭😭🥺🥺🥺🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏❣️😢😢😢😢😢😢

[@Curious_radhika]

Thank you sir .. Lecture Smjha Aya but PYQs bhi add kr dijiye session me....

[@arpitayadav943]

Great mentor lots of thanks bottom of my heart

[@sskkhan7063]

Mein aj se satrt ki hu hope ki me continue kroaw pura ancient history lets seee😊

[@sehanlomagh5354]

Sir your explanation is so good

[@GudduKushwaha-cj2qu]

Class 7 girl mujhe bhi samajh aa gaya sir thankyou good explaination☺☺

[@VSV_Productions]

Happy Guru Purnima Sirji🙏🌷🌷🌷🌷🌸🌸🌸🌸🌸🌸

[@Factshub_hindi]

Chapter 2 done ✅

[@rohittomar590]

Habdmade notes bana rahe hai sir..... Or sir aaj 2nd class thi ancient history ke par abhi se hi confidence aane laga hai.... 😅😅

[@gyaaniguys6183]

Your mindmapes is okk no need to short notes❤

[@kesharrajoriya210]

Max Mueller and other western scholars made certain generalizations about the nature of ancient Indian history and society. • They- - The ancient Indians lacked a sense of history, especially of the factor of time and chronology. -The Indians were accustomed to despotic rule. -The natives were engrossed in the problems of spiritualism or of the next world and least bothered about the problems of this world. - The caste system was most vicious form of social discrimination Indians had neither experienced the feeling of nationhood nor any kind of Self govt. Vincent Arthur smith gave primacy to political history,his approach was imperialist, emphasized the role of foreigners in ancient India India was presented as a land of despotism which did not experience political unity until establishment of British rule. The modern Indian historians rectified this generations by reconstruct ancient Indian history of India in such a manner as to make case for social reform and for self-government. They adopted mainly three approaches (1) Rationalist approach(2) political history (3) Hindu revivalism Historians and scholars like rajendra lal mitra compare our caste system to the European's class system, writers such as R.G Bhandarkar criticised child marriage and caste system and were in favour of widow remarriage as they were ideologies from the ancient india,also through the political history of satavahanas he proved that we have nationhood in ourselves,the writings of D.R Bhandarkar about the political institution of Ashoka proved that we have a strong administrative system and Indians have capabilities to govern themselves. Pandurang vaman kane wrote-history of 'Dharmashastra'and studied of social processes in ancient india, Rc Majumdar focused on History and culture of Indian people,Kp jayaswal wrote several articles to show that the republics existed in ancient times and enjoyed a measure of self-government. The Lokayata believes of Ancient India proved the "this world thinking" of Indians and showed that Indians were not only tensed about the next world but also payed attention to this world. As we move towards Non-political history A.L. Basham and D.D. Kosambi were two of the most influential historians of ancient India A.L. Basham was one of the first historians to use archaeological and literary evidence to reconstruct the political and social structures of ancient Indian society. D.D. Kosambi was an Indian historian who made significant contributions to the study of ancient Indian Society, particularly in the areas of economic history and the history of science and technology. His work on the economic history of ancient India, in particular, has been highly influential in the field. Both Basham and Kosambi played a major role in shaping the way that historians today understand ancient Indian history.

[@magicdrawingacademy]

👍

[@sanwariya_ss]

Great series❤

[@appurvigarg4648]

Complete with handmade notes.. No backlog till now❤

[@Averagetotopper951]

Can you please share your notes with me

[@appurvigarg4648]

@@Averagetotopper951 sure.. But how?

[@akarshverma14]

​@@appurvigarg4648T EL E G RAM se

[@shubham__vicky]

@@akarshverma14 mujhe bhi please @shubham389

[@deeptiwari4603]

Can you share your geography notes

[@neerajkadyan1501]

Thanku sir 🙏

[@AspirantRajib]

Thank you for the series....

[@togo12]

Hr baat me right right.....interrupt krta hai... lecture pe focus krne me

[@sunehabhau4336]

Amazing❤

[@takenCupcake]

Aaj jo Class krayi he uske Pyq next video me krvaiye Sir taaki tb tk hum learn krle

[@abbasiikram1455]

Thank you sir

[@vikasvishwakarma4865]

Kindly add pyq mcq at the end of respective chapter it will give better clarity about how to read chapters

[@patrickjameswarner]

49.00 mahabharata is started in 3200 -3300 BC

[@nandinisingh5058]

yessssss this is so good 👍

[@niteshsrivastava2004]

From where have you read mediaeval history?

[@satparkash5270]

Great sir

[@arpantyagi1127]

Nice session

[@urdupoetrylover5915]

Colonial historian percieved that Indian are used to the despotic rule further they thought that Indians are very much inclined towards the spiritualism However on the other hand indian historians answered them that the Indian are not used to the despotic rule they gave the example s of some great rulers such as ashoka and samunder Gupta they also highlighted that in ancient india the widow remarriage were allowed and chaild marriage and female infanticide were prohibited during ancient india However some indian scholars are overplayed the beauty of ancient india

[@anjalitrivedi1232]

Thankyou sir from Titan 2.0

[@Neha0713]

overall the classes are moving smooth, please continue with the same pace and method of teaching, i'am reffering handmade notes only. also please mention the MCQ series along with the answers of it in the next video. beside sir can you please add the ebook link of R.S.Sharma which you are referring to. i was not able to find this chapter in the R.S.Sharma I own and refer . it will be crucial . thankyou .

[@EducationalDesire]

THIS IS NEW BOOK OF ANCIENT INDIA CLASS 12 OK DEAR DONT WORRY I HAVE SEARCHED alot old ncert of rs sharma is sufficient comprise of 27 chapted beside this just read that book and just make notes of ur oown with sirs video ok if any added chapters which sir is dicussing

[@truptihadiya]

Thank u so much sir🙏

[@simranbajwa8407]

How do nationalists negate the view of colonialists? Answer : 1)Nationalist historians like Rajendra Lal Mitra had opposed the colonial view by saying that the caste system is the same as the class system in Europe. He also said that Ancient Indians were non-vegetarians too. 2) R.G Bhandarkar who said that widow remarriage was prevalent during the ancient times in India unlike what colonialists said. 3) D.R Bhandarkar who opposed colonialists by writing about the Ashoka empire. 4) K.P Jayaswal who negated the colonialists views by claiming that there were republics in India which were gana/sangh, so Indians also have experience of self rule.

[@Allie-om7ut]

Is this enough for upsc please tell

[@_Aspiring..]

Sir is it compulsory to enroll for the course to download the pdf?

[@Krishna-i6u]

World best history teacher god bless you forever sirji pls continue rakhiydga series thank you so much sirji for ur such great effort.

[@rts8639]

2:46 the colonial view says that ancient India has 1) poor in time and chonology 2) despotic rule 3) talks about spiritual world 4) evil cast system 5 ) no self government Nationalist view 1) the political structure in ashoka' s time 2) cast system and religion in mauryan time 3) . .. 😅

[@abhishekdixit43]

Thankyou so much sir. Pdf me hi likh liya sir.

[@vikkiiasofficial4240]

Very nice sir❤❤❤❤

[@viney-pg9bc]

I am referring to powerpoint sir

[@annuprajapati015]

Thankuuuu sir.....

[@Kanishka-ib3tu]

43:27

[@akshaymeghe9265]

It will be explained in a very simple way sir, you should do MCQ along with that lesson💖😇🙏

[@m.k1978]

Apne pdf download Kiya h kya g qki mujhe pdf mil hi n rahi hai

[@yKumar-ic4hh]

​@@m.k1978 app sa download hoga

[@SyedMusaib2330]

Nice

[@flyingsuccess5822]

Apke sath hi sir notes bna rha hu thoda late start hua is vjh se apne 10 chaoters mere 2 hi hue h But notes sath me bn rha hu but answers ko apne words me likh nhi pa rha hu

[@upsc_devens]

Despotisms abhi bhi hai indian people alwalays want this type rule

[@kafeelurrehman25625]

❤ Abhishek sir is my favourite one ever🎉 sirr plzz mediaeval history ko bhi start kariye plzz sir❤

[@shashankshukla493]

Thank you sir

[@UpscCse-k8s]

Excellent 👌 sir Sharma ji ki kitab superb explanation kar rahe hai 👌

[@mosharibkhan8508]

Sir class dekhne k baad book read karna jaruri hai kya

[@AnushkauttkarshShukla-rw2ni]

Dont break the chain sir ji🙏

[@dineshkumaryadav7879]

Super teacher

[@sumitrajsinha128]

Sir likh kar padhao , bahut acha padhate ho

[@studentunfiltered2024]

sir ,aap jo homework k liye questions dete hai usse next day discuss bhi kiya karein

[@tezauniquefacts2031]

❤ sir bahot achha padha rhe hai , map bana ke sath padhane ka aap ka style se notes making connecting hota ja rha hai , mai notes bana rha hu , aur bahot achhe se samajh aa rha hai

[@Dev.maharathi]

Plus plus ,,,,,,now now. Ye toh chap gay mind mai😊

[@prempatel3497]

thnx sir

[@SwekshaOjha]

Sir jo apne bola non political history wla topic wo h jo political s hatkr h.. Toh ky yeh nationalist approach k andr ayaga...y fir isko non nationalist and non political approach khu

[@utkarsh_7070]

Sir aap mast padhate ho

[@adityaprasad4716]

All good sir thanks for giving this and all supportive lectures🎉🎉❤

[@mohinisharma8660]

Sir pdf hi follow karenge

[@Aina9902]

Excellent sir

[@sayyadabegum6905]

Sir best teaching for history chapters thank you sir 😊

[@raginigaud9343]

Sir aap right bar bar bol rahe jo bahut chubh raha..

[@noxioussahil3621]

Plus plus

[@purnachandraswain9937]

I like very much

[@tabreztabrez9129]

Excellent teacher of history

[@mohinisharma8660]

Thankyou sir ...pls pyq bhi krwa dijiye topic wise

[@Er.innovate]

sir mcq bhi krwa diye onlly 10 per day

[@Jaat315-mx6td]

Sir polity optional ki class ka kya time hai please btaye

[@sejalsingh7730]

Thankyou so much for the wonderful explanation and every topic is crystal clear sir. Most of the students are following pdf as a study material sir so thanku so much for your great effort.

[@nikitasingh2699]

6:00

[@PUBG-PLAYER.-]

Sir please..also.....solve some MCQ realted all chapters.....🙏😊

[@keshavmishra8698]

Sir medival history v Kara de sir

[@VaishnaviBaranwal-pl6qb]

Sir aap bohot acha padhate h❤😊