Kolkata Rape & Murder I "What Was Police Doing?" I Chandrachud Slams Bengal Govt I Barkha Dutt

[@dragonskinavi]

Guess who's paying for Sibal's services? The taxpayers of Bengal, who else? Such irony. What a farce!

[@sarajohn6855]

That’s really sad.

[@360mortgage]

@@dragonskinavi every dog needs representation or proscess will be more screwed as it is its a mess

[@dragonskinavi]

@@360mortgage Agree, but that was not my point.

[@dimpu603]

Bastard Kapil Sibal protecting the Principal here....How low he can stoop

[@ShanmugavadiveluS.T]

Kabil sibal might have been born to multi seeds.He appeared as a defence lawyer to Mamtha Banerjee.

[@machpower3082]

Anything for money

[@malarenganathan576]

Please avoid abuse words in public forums, please.

[@Letstalktruthfam]

Anything for money

[@raveetr8730]

All for money... ..

[@Confortably_numb]

Thank you, Hon'ble CJI. In your court orders today, we see a glimmer of hope.

[@blessing5296]

Dear Madam, I have this to ask. " Wouldn't the victim fight back? Have a look at the rapist, no visible injury or scar. I suspect a larger conspiracy.

[@manusha1349]

Are you the district surgeon? Did you examine the man accused of this crime?

[@manusha1349]

@@himanshugoyal6807 my comment was not directed at you. And your reply is DISGUSTING!

[@manusha1349]

​@himanshugoyal6807 my original comment was not directed at you! But your response tells me everything I need to know about you...educate yourself about how to behave towards women on the internet

[@manusha1349]

@@himanshugoyal6807 I don't think you understand English

[@himanshugoyal6807]

@@manusha1349 even if a group of 100 is trying to molest you, people like me make sure that you will be safe no matter the cost, without questioning that did you examine who started it first

[@ushamenon6975]

Thank u Burkha..you have moderated the debate quite well..ThankYou

[@goodcitizen3775]

What nonsense he is talking She may know the gang who raped the victim. You arrested Sanjoy just to save face and planned

[@duvvurivenkataravikumar1247]

PORNOGRAPHY & DRUGS RACKET CANNOT BE RULED OUT.

[@kutumbula]

CM sharerd a derogatory loose comment : "maye ta ke firiye dite parbo na 10 lakh taka dicchi". Which loosely translate to i can't give the life back but i can give rs 10lakhs .. Not acceptable from a state head. We will see the end of it.

[@raveetr8730]

Give 10 lakh to CM. Let her quit .

[@susmitamandal6852]

True Journalism by Barkha Dutt.❤

[@rohitsuri2856]

Elections matter...Bengal keeps voting for this Gunda government...the state is basically been driven to gutters by TMC.

[@abhisheksaha6201]

Shame West Bengal Shame. Shameful Activities by the people in the govt. Kapil Sibal see your long face in the mirror. It will tell you the Truth.

[@valeriesalway3416]

She was murdered because she knew of some illegal happenings going on in the Hospital

[@shivalithakur4067]

It's time to impose president rule in west bengal. Mamata clearly unfit to rule Bengal

[@sidvyas8549]

She has been unfit since she was voted in Hers is a “rape Raj”- rule of rapists It’s shocking when you look at the history over the last decade Absolutely horrific

[@Aquastan-de2iq]

wow - i stand in my seat and Salute dr. yogita ..and dr. sukanya !!!👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@emmyfernandes8040]

Why is Value Education stopped in schools?

[@rush666666]

Ironically the people who tried to cover the case of Doctor Abhaya were fellow doctors at RG Kar hospital. The principal was a medical doctor, if post mortem is compromised then the person doing it also a doctor.

[@emmyfernandes8040]

EQUALITY says our Constitution! Why should women be denied EQUALITY?

[@Whoknows-z5o]

A great balanced discussion, Barkha. I may have become you fan!! Please keep up the great work.

[@goodcitizen3775]

Basically you are a very honest journalism. COVID or Bilkis or Tilottoma you are relentlessly working in favour of the real victim Regards. Thanks

[@relelata]

Sad to see political parties politisizing such a horrible issue. They are not working for people but for themselves. Have a thought for the girl, what she must have gone thru & her family. What was Sandeep Ghosh's motive in hurting this doctor so hideously?

[@sarahsheila38]

Sanjay gosh should be sacked n arrested.

[@SnehaDatta-qt4ke]

Barkha kudos to you!! For great coverage.

[@samin096]

Even my mom who is a gynaecologist and trained more then 50 years back had night shifts. During my training I did night shifts. However in my time or my Mom’s there was never a 36 hour shift. The longest was 16 hr

[@mountain85]

This was a much needed discussion. Feminism - fights for equal rights of women. Its not a propoganda against good men. But yes definitely a threat for bad men like those rapists! Doctors- the Hospital Management should be elected competent and strong individuals that can protect the doctors. And give them BARE MINIMUM FACILITIES Like a secure toilet and a resting room. If a doctor has made a mistake the Hospital Management should be in charge and take the family to court with valid points. Lastly WOMEN AS A WORKFORCE - we are stronger than before and we will keep studying and rising. So men who are regressive will be left behind. Men can stay home so that women can work safely at night ! #claimthenight

[@SKSK-n8f]

MEDICAL FRATERNITY SHOULD NOT ATTEND MR. KAPIL SIBAL AND FAMILY IN INDIA AND ABROAD. ALL SHOULD DENY MEDICAL SERVICE.

[@puresoul9233]

Kudos to those young drs who spoke really well . Yes as a part of medical fraternity we need protection.

[@ShanmugavadiveluS.T]

With out registering FIR how the autopsy was done ? What is the motive behind the gruesome murder ? We are not ready to hear Mamtha's story here.

[@MRR20899_]

I don’t understand why the lawyers are crowding near the judge

[@ushamenon6975]

Yogita...u r spot on...and have highlighted the defence lawyer's atittude.we need a forensic specialist to give his or her opinion

[@360mortgage]

This all boils down to police reforms . Police failed from begining to end . From intial entry of this guy in the hospital . There is posh act not implemented.

[@ushamenon6975]

Those who work in the airlines, media , police and others do have to be protected when they work late hours at night.

[@judelobo6972]

What is the center doing for protection of the wormen n girls in this country the same crime again

[@adityabhattacharyya600]

Nothing. Just playing State vs Center politics

[@mamtat7206]

We are with the Medical Staff. We Want Justice Now 👍

[@MaryL-hb8gq]

Advocate sibal sir ur a senior wonderful lawyer please see the horror that happened to a 31 yrs Dr. We want justice don't support. Tmc be justice this should not happen any where in this worldur a seniour. I. Hope ull inderstand lawyer sibal sir

[@puresoul9233]

Look at his audacity of the Tmc man to tell open lies on camera . Shame on u and ur disgraced leader. Don’t forgive this lady leader , do not vote for her . Goondaraj should stop 🛑

[@VibingwithSeher]

Absolutely

[@siddharthanvarier3342]

This incident occurred in a City which takes ENORMOUS PRIDE in being the SAFEST CITY, in terms of women safety and female empowerment.The CBI has been directed to submit its preliminary REPORT on Thursday next Barkha jee, LET'S NOT RAISE A STORM IN A.TEA-CUP. Let us wait until the CBI submits it's Report.Even the Supreme Court Lordships are anxiously waiting for this MUCH -AWAITED REPORT and initiating the deliberations of the STF Committee

[@siddharthanvarier3342]

Barkha Jee, I robustly believe that TOLERANCE and INTOLERANCE are co- existential in today's power seeking world. One cannot exist without the other. This is relevant in the present dastardly incident in which a psychopathic hedonist committed a heinous crime on a lonely, alone, woman doctor intern. While the real MOTIVES are yet to be unearthed, and are in the hands of a competent team of professional investigators,who ,I am sure, will get to the bottom of this heinous felony. Striking Doctors should realise that they should EXERCISE the same amount of PATIENCE, than they exercise on their INVALUABLE and SERVING PATIENTS

[@s.k.s9529]

Kapil Sibal Should declared as A liablity of India.....

[@bandanarajbongshi8668]

Rubbish! He has better brains than you😂

[@NinaNarayan]

When its an Opposition State ..the SC is full of scathing comments but when equally heinous crines are committed in Bjp ruled states...there is no suo moto taking up the matter and even if the matter comes up its always a nice balancing act and sermons with actions near none. While WB deserves the sternness in SC orders, the same action should be there for Bjp ruled states as well. Renember Brij Bhushan matter . Female wrestlers being beaten by police for protesting their molestor. We want real fairness from our SC ...we the public are pretty discerning that way...

[@bandanarajbongshi8668]

Agree

[@bandanarajbongshi8668]

Cover up after crime is done more often than not. Its good that Supreme Court has stepped in. We are living today in a democracy where basic human rights are denied more and more. Not just only in West Bengal.

[@mithunkartha]

Never surprised when Sibbal appears in such cases.

[@Algorhyme]

Its shameful so many thousands of people were involved and the target was a helpless girl...this just shows to what level the govt.can stoop against ordinary people when the need arises

[@user-ip1wd3kw5m]

All stupid comments, if women don't do night shifts who will look after the patients on night shifts, as most are women nurses, everyone is beating round the bush and making a mockery of the case, the guy representing TMC is only defending CM, no comment on what actually happened,why was the post mortem done in the same hospital,why was the body cremated,by whose orders, they should be in this topic and give answers,shame on the government to whishwash the whole issue, need CM on TV to explain

[@ushamenon6975]

Whenever the sanctity of a crime scene is violated... the violators need to punished .

[@change962]

Sanjay Hegde seems to be government lawyer

[@vanithareddy9879]

Due to organised crime. Justice please 🙏 Thank you Barkha Dutt. We have to conquer. Mamata should be removed. So much of crime and injuria. She is still not in prison. Please justice system 🙏 😢

[@IndiraSen-v6g]

This is a movement…… not a protest or strike. Barsha please call this a movement. A tsunami of a movement Regards

[@antonovverkhoyansk9170]

West Bengal government must pay at least Rs 1 crore as compensation to Dr Abhaya’s parents for this crime.

[@marutsshah1]

The doctor's should not call off their protests. In fact these protests should happen across the country. All the people working in the IT industry and the press also should also join in as they're equally vulnerable

[@antonyphilip5991]

I still feel CM Mumta must face the judges as she is the Health Minister and also theCM and the buck must stop with her. She authorised the transfer.

[@ushamenon6975]

Barkha u r spot on...introspection is required by Mamta Banerji

[@hemikovsky]

What about Manipur and other states?? In such a short lifespan you have all forgotten all rapes and murders in UP, Deaths and accidents in Gujarat! hain. Kya nautanki!! Why was President rule not imposed in Manipur, just because you had a BJP CM there? For Gujarat, and UP Modi has no rules.

[@Onlyabhi9]

..U can do it Barkha dutt..u can enlighten the people

[@siddharthanvarier3342]

It is a Renaissance of Women Empowerment

[@raveetr8730]

Today sibal defending wb government totally exposed his duplicity. This incident is eye opener to all in the power. It is good tht doctors took it seriously n to the streets. Shame on the people who still treat women as sex object. Shame.

[@sai6275]

Only Barkha is fighting this from beginning with sense 🙌🙌🙌 govt really like to control women just like that their work times & provide some protector, but not the Men to stop them from roaming around… why can’t they do that????

[@ushamenon6975]

What do they mean by unnatural death...is it not very vague when there were obvious signs of assault both physical and sexual?

[@exxtraagyaanofficial10m36]

Stupidity at it's best. Victim should get govt. Lawyer. But instead accused are getting it. If proven guilty will culprits pay back the taxpayers money?

[@rohanprashanth1982]

No need to treat Doctors or even women as Gods and Goddess, we should learn to just treat them as human beings.

[@vivekdubey4363]

Atleast now ppl ( including feminists) will agree that women may not be safe under Women in office. Good governance will protect the citizens not Irresponsible women ( or men) in office.

[@manusha1349]

There is a lot of international focus on this case, I have seen posts on Sky News in Britain. Strength to the women of India in your fight for Justice for Moumita! ❤

[@Antariksha]

Even if its temporary, restrict the men! Stupidity! Enough with the term this should not be politicised. What are political parties for? Oppositions need to question and take up issues. Thats the whole point of politics and accountability.

[@lavanyanaidu1205]

The rape laws has to be intsefied.

[@hassobhatia2885]

The recent events show how Indian society and polity is rotten to the core..long live vishvaguru..

[@Scramblersj]

Truth will not come out EVER.

[@ashishprabhat1]

Kabil Sibbal is so disrespectful to CJI

[@vanithareddy9879]

WOMEN SHOULD FEEL SAFE TO WALK IN FREELY. POLICE SECURITY SHOULD BE ON THE INCREASE. PROTECTION IS NEEDED. ALSO CCTV SHOULD BE INSTALLED IN HIGH RISK PLACES. CULTURE AND ATTIUDE. MORE EDUCATION. JUSTICE BE DONE . ..PLEASE 😢

[@ushamenon6975]

The spokes person for Bengal has awoken up from slumber

[@NatashaSingh-xz3qs]

Sick of all the political parties, politicians of this country.

[@Public-dc5rl]

What police did at godhra vandalism is replicated in Kolkata under the ruling government

[@Kat-zj5kd]

We need a clear report on forensic analysis of DNA samples to know how many culprits are involved and who all. Rather than going deep into one roy and principal. Because the scientific analysis has not yet been presented. West Bengal govt shd be dismissed over this gruesome crime and their archaic handling of it. If any officials, ministers or even judicial members are found to be involved in a deliberate cover up they shd be tried and sent to jail for obstruction of justice.

[@HarshwardhanShahani]

Shameless TMC defending this tragedy. The rot is set so deep and so high, I am waiting to see how Mamata Banu will sweep this under the carpet.

[@amulyalabschandigarh1009]

The offender is under the umbrella of police and is paid a salary by them /Govt. Is no police verification done before employment? From media I gather he lived in the police lines!

[@arpitasam5018]

Why isn’t Kolkata getting president’s rule?

[@antonovverkhoyansk9170]

There are women getting raped and murdered daily in Bengal (and in India). A woman gets raped every 51 minutes in India. The police also commit many rapes and murders. This is normal in India. Now tell me, do you really want to have Presidents rule?

[@mniranjan9509]

Shame on our criminal justice system, where is punishment???......... the crux of the issue is, who the hell committed crime, who are the culprits, whether the criminals identified, what was the role of college principal, what exactly happened on the day of crime, whether Sanjay roy misleading the whole case?????? It's two weeks now, nothing concrete is ascertained, CBI enquiry appears to be totally BJP's third rared politics just to keep the fire against state govt.... Arguments in supreme court, the way the case presented, the way it was opposed clearly demonstrates the justice system is totally insensitive and dead.... .. We all failed the victim and her family in a most shameless way.... Supreme court totally disappointed the entire nation and utterly failed in its duty as usual....... 😎

[@machpower3082]

Don't lose the focus on the main incident,and the people in power hell bent on protecting all the perpetrators of this crime , We need to know who are those culprits CJI is the only hope Because CBI we know what they did in SSR case Nobody till date doesn't know who killed SSR

[@DevTrivedi-tb3tm]

Wonder where was this Barkha and CJ when there were and are rape cases every day in Manipur in the last two years??? If they have little humanity and are sincere towards their profession, they would make both Modi (personally) and BJP govtS in center and in Manipur, asam and other NECstates.

[@jenniferlyngdoh6053]

Isn't it the courts who freed the Bilkis Banu racists in the first place? Isn't it the courts who allowed the Dehra chief to go home and celebrate a marriage of some sort? Justice Chandrachud should introspect the court's role through the many many rape cases where its been allowing culprits to enjoy vests freedoms. The whole judicial system is a sham.

[@bandanarajbongshi8668]

The judiciary must also introspect. Politically motivated judgments are common. But Justice Chandrapur is doing a great job🎉

[@silvanofernandes9648]

Madam Barka why don't you invite Madam M.Moitra on your channel for interview I would love to see her how she spoke earlier in your channel when she won ..what fire what confidence Oh and when she spoke in the Parliament with such honesty and integrity Love her to be on your channel to speak her mind and heart on the gruesome murder/rape of the young aspiring doctor and the respectable efficient Ghosh after whom jobs just run.

[@ushamenon6975]

Recruiting police shud be stringent... too. In many cases police are the perpetrators...so what does the public do

[@hassobhatia2885]

CJI is doing the duties that the PM Modi should be doing, but unfortunately he’s always AWOL whenever tragedy hits the country..he’s only good time pm…

[@lohithmjajee]

You should clearly state whose side was Sanjay Hegde, so that viewers know

[@ajkichurants2185]

I feel so sorry for whatever the young doctor is saying. I stand srtrongly with his statement.

[@rc2k22]

Kapil Sibbal will always stand on the wrong side of the History. He is trying to prove the CJI wrong.

[@philomenamenezes6916]

very ironic why was the principal transferred asap all evidence wiped out police not attending. the culprit is not the cuplrit the culprit is out free i pray justice will prevail

[@hassobhatia2885]

Mr Jaisalmeer should not display the picture of MMta in the background

[@vanithareddy9879]

MAMATA IS A PERSON OF NOTE. JUSTICE PLEASE 🙏 😢

[@Anand-ku4fy]

What if the gang which came in and vandalized the emergency ward had really came to destroy the emergency ward itself

[@ad-br4kr]

Adv. Hegde taking the side of justice very unlikely of him.

[@ajkichurants2185]

Advocates like Hegde have always stood by justice. Perhaps, it was your bias towards a party that didn't see this through.

[@sarajohn6855]

TMC… how did you exactly stand by the victim’s family? By transferring the scoundrel Principal ? By not letting the parents to see their dead daughter for hours? By informing their daughter committed suicide? So didi said it’s a mistake. So who’s taking the responsibility for the Principal’s transfer? If she is calling it a mistake then what sort of government is she running? If things are happening under her nose and she is unaware…then what did you do afterwards? Why did Didi protest on the streets herself making ridiculous demands after mishandling this from the get go? Meanwhile her Police started intimidating other protesters. Looks like she has no clue. She need to step down.

[@anukapoor4082]

Mamta offered Parents 100,000 Rs to shut their mouth and keep quite. Going to parents house doesn't help. Mamta wiped out the evidences

[@sarajohn6855]

Dr Jaiswal ..! So if a man is raped or sodomized would you ask men to stay home at night ???

[@sukanya6513]

Can this lady be given justice as the torture was as a woman and not make it a mouthpiece for voicing grudges of the medical fraternity. First provide justice to this woman for the crime committed against her. She was ridiculed and put down because being a woman she asked for her place. GIVE HER JUSTICE FIRST. LET JUSTICE BE TO THE TORTURED FIRST.

[@ShanmugavadiveluS.T]

Supreme court condemned West Bengal government.(Mamtha government).Her government is to be dissolved at once. Mamta is zero in administration. Simply barking against other political parties.

[@NiravJoshi]

Never thought will see this day - Sanjay Hegde talking sense

[@RIJU9285]

Please understand TMC has all but destroyed the very fabric of Bengali society. We understand there is an equally fascist and opportunist regime at the center but the ordinary citizen still has to take to the streets. Hope Mr. Sibal realizes who he is fighting against.

[@sarahsheila38]

Why didn't anyone go in search of this doctor when she was not seen for so long?

[@saichaitanyan]

I'm a man. Restrict men

[@padmalochanbehera1745]

Why CM of WB is not seen in the streets now a days... Why no padayatra... Can Barkha datt checks it up from AS.....Remembering her of nandigram days... Is it due to self- introspection or loss of political mortality to be with general people of WB.... Jai Hind

[@stanydsa4720]

Kapil Sibal is Rogue lawyer.

[@VibingwithSeher]

Mamta has messed up big time. Tmc still defending her