Monster - 레드벨벳 - 아이린&슬기(Red Velvet - IRENE & SEULGI) [뮤직뱅크/Music Bank] 20200710

Monster - 레드벨벳 - 아이린&슬기(Red Velvet - IRENE & SEULGI)
KBS2 TV 뮤직뱅크｜매주 금요일 오후 5시에 방송됩니다.

[@최강레베럽]

세트장 미쳤잖아 에스엠 아슬에 돈을 더 퍼 부어라 ㅠ ㅠ

[@또림-r6n]

아슬이 뭐예여?

[@권나현-t1h]

아이린 슬기

[@Near-22]

I feel summoned...

[@Username10003]

@@Near-22 lol

[@예압-u4d]

더부어라!!!!

[@lovedal7959]

와이지빠이지만.. 이런 면에서 sm이 참 좋음.. 전형적이고 약간 유치하고 정형화된 아이돌 그 자체 같으면서도 이렇게 실험적인 음악을 해주니까 도태되지 않는 거 같음.. 예전에 비하면 한물 갔다고 하지만 그래도 와이지,에스엠이 건재한건 스스로 자기만의 스타일과 실험적인 음악을 계속 시도해서인듯

[@지야-z1i]

진짜 공감 나도 와쥐빠지만 에셈 이런 실험적인거 좋음

[@민민-v2u]

오ㅇㅇ동감..스엠이 은근 이런 실험적인거 많이하는거같아서 취향은 아니더라도 하나하나 보는재미가있음

[@korea-77]

마약 약국 회사 빠 인게 뭔자랑이라고

[@dolllltang]

와 진짜 진심 저도 약국빤데 와이지랑은 다른느낌으로 에스엠이 너무 조아요,, 항상 ㄱㅣ대됨.

[@멀랑-u1j]

엥? 에셈은 실험적인거 그 자체인데 어딜봐소 전형적이고유치?

[@snowflakes1958]

Seulrene's chemistry, talent, visuals along with Monster's choreography and stage is skyhigh. Korea's girlcrushes Seulgi and Irene dominates our hearts, girls, guys, gays alike

[@comma._]

헤메코 너무 완벽함 누가 내 취향 쏙 빼놔준 것 같음 보컬, 안무, 표정 다 너무 좋다 아슬 몬스터도 좋고 놀이도 좋음 둘이 유닛한 거 진짜 신의 한수... 둘 다 진짜 너무 멋있음

[@kokoiskoool]

걍 주접으로 하는말이 아니라 무대 세트도 그렇고 안무도 그렇고 노래도 그렇고 다 어디 전시해도 손색없는 예술 작품같아ㅠ 돈 주고 봐야할것같아서 앨범 몇장 더 삼ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅠ 코디도 디게 조음 무대할땐 좀 긴 바지 입길 바랬지만 무대랑 노래랑 조합이 넘 조음ㅠ

[@슬-c3y]

슬기 너무 에뻐......폭발적이다 진짜....무대가 작아보여요

[@욕하는오소리]

아이린이 더 이쁜데

[@지용호-x3z]

@@욕하는오소리 굳이 비교질? ㅋㅋ

[@otterlyadorbs]

@@욕하는오소리 delete your comment please. both are very pretty.

[@hasom290]

@@욕하는오소리 난 슬기 더..라고 할 줄 알았죠.. 사람 평가하지ㅏ요

[@dowjTl]

@@욕하는오소리 니 남자지

[@xyx_306]

아이린 마지막 표정이 쩐다 해서 봤더니 진짜 개쩐다...

[@요를레히후-h2m]

슬기 개멋있다 완전 천재아이돌.. 음색이 슬기없는 레벨은 상상 할 수 없을 정도 분위기 오짐

[@bisente3438]

Can we talk about Irene being more than just a Visual...

[@Purplerene]

GoddessBae hell yea say it louder sis🤩

[@ellie755]

@GoddessBae say it louder for the people in the back!

[@juliag.5114]

Reveluvs knew this already but it's nice to see the rest of the world finally realizing it too

[@chicharia5025]

to all the haters that say Irene is visual only, watch this performance and prepare to be amazed!

[@neocityzen3348]

Yassssss

[@rsgws3885]

Dear SM You have a really golden girls right there. Better not left them behind

[@mochimo93]

true that! i hope to see the rest of rv's member to shine as well, because they are equally talented as a group and as an individual. I hope SM treat the girls better in the future

[@diamonddukes6400]

@@mochimo93 I would love to see a Joy and Yeri sub unit!!!!!

[@whenyoucantchooseabias5679]

WenJoyRi need to showcase their individual talent eventually. I'd love to see this more.

[@nameless7]

SEULGI IS SO STABLE WHILE GOING THAT HARD???? Amazing Beyonce is proud of her

[@juanmanuelmarindomiguez6906]

Lmao obviosly is pre-recorded

[@hi_jjimin_]

Haters stay pressed lol

[@juanmanuelmarindomiguez6906]

@@hi_jjimin_ who said im a hater? I love them. Just saying the truth but ok

[@hi_jjimin_]

Juan Manuel Marín did i call you hater?? I didnt point out any name tho why are you triggered?

[@fuge511]

@Ifnx -commentary nani... LOLOL

[@야간비행-m6s]

천만이네...근데 더 찍어도 할말없다...다씹어먹는 멋진 무대임.

[@madeinmoiselle]

Irene proving she's not only the original visual. Seulgi slayin' because she's the dance machine 1 2 5 to 7

[@mollybloblue7891]

so irene is not only the original visual but sulgi is only the dance machine? ok

[@dunnouchoose]

@@mollybloblue7891 I don't think they meant that. What they were trying to say is that Irene is mostly appreciated only for her beauty, but never for her talent. On the other hand, Seulgi's talent is always recognized (vocals and dancing). So I think they were cheering because Irene's talent is being recognized but without overshadowing Seulgi's talent and appreciating her greatest talent. (I don't know how many times I repeated the word "talent" but ok)

[@notwicenolifesostantwice4670]

Guys RV Vocal is not a Joke😍❤

[@sunbleachedfIies]

RV be like Real Vocal

[@mygoldenluckyyearrln]

Yeah not like Twice

[@Frandahab]

@@mygoldenluckyyearrln stop ffs true reveluv aren't toxic

[@junsjulywonpilsyonpilchany5241]

@@mygoldenluckyyearrln Please stop! Learn to be a mature fan.

[@junsjulywonpilsyonpilchany5241]

@@Frandahab That's so true.

[@Breakerzfam]

IRENE'S CHARISMA IS UNBEATABLE HERE. THEY ARE BOTH SO STABLE HERE.

[@jmp_cestmoi]

미쳤네 엔딩 근데 진짜 레전드이긴 함 곡이랑 진짜 잘 어울리는 엔딩

[@geehsanolmillo8819]

*No one does it like RED VELVET Irene & Seulgi. They snapped periodt.*

[@otakuweeb6604]

Geehsan Myles you're disgusting! You literally said “period” ew!

[@馬鹿-g7c]

Periodt sis

[@nydra8119]

@@otakuweeb6604 oh no she wrote it wrong were all going to die now I guess

[@thump535]

@@otakuweeb6604 i cant tell if you're joking

[@izzybizi2248]

@@otakuweeb6604 umm r u kay??

[@jjhaylemon714]

the fact that seulgi brought a gun in the music show is such a queen behavior

[@Lily20013]

Yeah stan queens

[@제이-c5o]

음원보다 라이브가 더 좋은 것 같음 안무하다 보니까 성대를 더 조이고 부르는 구간이 있는데 그게 진짜 개쩌는 것 같음... 아 최고다...

[@kubonmo]

둘 다 너무 예쁘다.. 헤메코 컨셉 세트장까지 완벽

[@naru6463]

the way this is only 2/5 of red velvet.... people should be afraid

[@kwinnayeon2157]

Exactly!!!

[@calli-jeonghan-ologicallis9065]

That’s the *REAL-DEAL!* They’ve been serving us too much excellency even if it’s just the 2 of them. My Bad Boy/RBB era chills comes back.

[@vkmksm5714]

Yes it is.. anyone could count on it

[@jwwsk]

Hopefully there's a subunit called WENDY&JOY&YERI.

[@marialilyquiamco6921]

@@jwwsk yeah but instead of velvet concepts,they have red

[@krplum22]

Irene’s charisma and stage presence has never been better. Queen

[@강슬기나라세우자]

그많은 컨셉을 하고도 이렇게 또 신박한 컨셉하는거보고 진짜 스엠은스엠이구나했는데 이곡 소화하는 아이린슬기도 진짜 대단하다고 느낌 그냥 몬스터 활동 안무든라이브든 그냥 다 레전드였음

[@JHJung-yb9ow]

저 레베럽인데 님 거의 모든 영상에 다 있는거 같아요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 지금 내적친분 오짐 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@b3a-edit]

The way Irene looks at the camera is so intense

[@tangodzilla92]

I die

[@-stayzen107]

I die 2

[@rodernestangelomatias542]

I die 3

[@silver_cat06]

I die 4

[@psyc_-qy3dl]

I die 5

[@천소흔]

가수들은 대단하다 어떻게 저런 춤을 추며 라이브를 저렇게 잘할까 뭐 립싱크 하는 가수들도 있겠지만은 뭐야 이거 왜 좋아요 이렇게 박혔대...ㄷㄷ

[@하마-g8o]

용감한아이들 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@u3u657]

가수들은 진짜 좋은데 스엠 일루미나티 너무 빼박이라....

[@몰바씨눈깔아]

으엥 이거 라이브에요?

[@Unknown-xo8ri]

@@몰바씨눈깔아 네.. 이건 립싱크일수가 없는게 호흡 다 들려서 라이브 맞는 것 같습니다

[@whitey_white]

격하면 라이브 AR 까는 아이돌도 있긴한데 레벨 정도면 실력이 받춰줌

[@karmasikduyugular3927]

Find your soul mate according to your household Irene (배주현) Seulgi (강슬기) Wendy (웬디손 /손승환) Joy (박수영) Yeri (김예림)

[@user-dj8hw3rm4c]

손승완

[@Sky-vd8cp]

응아 I don’t understand but I know u sayin Wendy

[@rveluv3698]

2:10 is a proof that Irene does show facial expressions, she's more into the subtle details cus bunny leader don't wanna steal all the spotlight

[@lenaryleramos5554]

I can't forget that part. It's too powerful. I'm hypnotised.

[@agungarta1476]

Well she gained a lot of confident on this song and I loved it 😍😍😍

[@user-oi3ww2du8s]

와..이춤 추면서 흥얼거린게 벌써 1년전??

[@shahahaha.334]

I was wondering if KBS will actually edit the monster face on Irene’s part. Can’t believe they actually did! Red Velvet and KBS does not disappoint 👏🏻

[@reycellezacalimpong1125]

All music shows must comply for the first performance, that effect is really cool tho

[@jip_bonaejuseyo]

에셈은 빨간머리 잘어울리는 사람만 뽑나 빨간머리 찰떡야..

[@승-o2p]

에셈 모두 비주얼 탑이라 ㅠㅠㅠ 누가 어떤 머릴 하든 잘어울린다는게 학계의 정설

[@yunopks]

크리스탈 조이 슬기 .. 엉엉

[@yunopks]

식슼틋 아 맞당!!!

[@승-o2p]

귀염댕이 아니 정말 크리스탈 첫사랑니 빨간머리는 잊을 수가 없음 절대절대... 안녕 한번쯤은 으로 시작하는데 그 때 그 감격 잊을 수가 없어요

[@hbae5577]

귀염댕이 7월 7일 웬디두.... 아이린만 빨간 머리 해주면 소원 없습니다

[@VarshaVartikaexo-l]

No wonder why RV has haters. They just cannot handle all their beauty and talent! Their MVs are so aesthetic and the songs are simply WOW. And they all just slay all their concepts!!! More power to I&S subunit and RV together! Go Queens! You rock!!

[@jpsingh1351]

They can't believe that they can sing so perfectly

[@brendosampaioo]

Facts

[@lululun3333]

Maybe not hatter, but a JeAlOuS pEoPLe

[@luvblub]

Maybe because their faves can't give them what red velvet gives reveluvs😒🍵

[@EssenceEtienne]

It’s definitely people being jealous of their visuals or mayb not knowing how talented they are

[@이-l2o]

헐 지나가다 우연히 듣고 멜로디가 넘 좋길래 무슨 노랜지 찾고 있었는데.. 그게 이 노래였다니... 댑악

[@azalea9605]

THEIR MICS ARE ONNNNNNNN 🥰🥰🥰🥰 so shut up u antis who say they cant sing and their outfits and visuals is a killer 🥵🥵

[@miles62546]

Azalea. How can we know when idols mic's are on?

[@annapandalee4915]

@@miles62546 you can hear them breath and how different it sounds from the audio. On Irene's solo singing part the voices dont over lap and you can hear how husky her voice is.

[@vhh1992]

@@miles62546 they sing so well that you can barely notice it 🤣. Just focus on when they take a breath between sentences. You can't usually hear that in a pre-recorded video unless done on purpose. And some small mistakes in entonation and/or volume caused by dancing and singing at the same time. I'm no expert though.

[@thn.7719]

i think this should be pre-recorded, even though there is breathing sound. i am not saying they can't sing

[@thn.7719]

coz it is known that SM usually play pre-recorded for the first week promotion...

[@armyluvieexol6302]

They don't sing live : They can't sing They sing live: it's not their real vocals or it's pre recorded. BRUH you can literally hear the difference between the official audio and this performance. This stage or performance is pre recorded but they sang live during that recording. So it's obviously their live vocals and the girls slayed it despite the hard choreography. And yes kbs might have done a bit a editing but their live singing can still be understood if you don't have ear problems

[@najla2501]

Those people need to see a doctor

[@summera7144]

Pre-recorded or not, it’s stil their voice. It’s not like they used someone else’s voice. These haters lmao

[@smssavagemaknaes9340]

Pre recorded performance isnt that bad. It is clearly pre recorded, irene's part before seulrene duo dance part at the first minute wasnt that good. The vocal went on, but she stopped "singing" I mean, red velvet are well-known singers. Their vocals were acknowledged by literally everybody. No one dares to say red velvet cant sing even if they dropped a pre-recorded performance like this. So, people that might stopped by this comment, admit it... it is not live performance. Maybe they'll sing live the next stage since SM always do pre-recorded stage in the first week so...

[@wlo2661]

you know they can pre record live audio yes

[@王小姐-b1r]

K-Luvies: ReneSeul I-Luvies: SeulRene Officially: ASeul ❤️💛

[@BLASTINGPOWDER]

아 이건 진짜 획기적이다 지금 봐도 너무 좋아 >..

[@오웨오위오]

둘이 얼굴합 오졌다 진짜

[@iseulgiiredvelvet6456]

Why most of the comment hir is fighting wether is a pre recorded or not guys dont u know rv is one of the stable group when it comes in vocal.

[@euilee3312]

literally the running joke of RV is that they eat CDs

[@rismayaputrijairina2006]

I thought we've established this matter, no need to argue that their MIC IS ON.

[@periwinkled]

yes but usually when its prerecorded the vocals of the original track isn’t in the background and thats the case here so idk

[@zacchvilla4008]

I mean like its SM entertainment. Vocal centered company.

[@leena7961]

They are using pre-recorded vocals. Nothing wrong with it, many top idols do it. SM idols especially, during the first week or two of promotions. It's done to protect their vocal chords and focus on the dance + their facial expressions. They aren't singing live in this performance, they pre-record vocals off set that are less edited and more raw than the studio version so that it doesn't sound weird. RV are AMAZING live performers, and SM has top tier vocal training, so they definitely CAN and WILL sing live later in promotions. It's just a technical choice that the company chooses for the sake of their idols' vocal health. They will definitely sing live in later performances, and you'll notice how different and less polished it sounds from these pre-recorded vocals. No hate towards RV at all, I love them a lot and they are super talented.

[@nicorobin3460]

seulgi really look good in that hair like if u agree

[@rivinatrisyiva]

can't be more agree

[@goguming2]

2:10 진짜 표정 연기 너무 잘해 ㅜㅜ

[@ringmybel]

Let's give them wins, just listen how perfect and how they nailed their vocals and dance.

[@devianty0465]

Please vote rv on choeaedol app

[@armyblinkonceaghasaerevelu4486]

Yess reveluvs let's giv our queen the wins they deserve

[@AmiAki]

You do realise it’s pre recorded. Yes even red velvet use prerecorded vocals at times

[@symonejoy6298]

They didn't win today. Does that mean they wouldn't perform next week anymore?

[@Random-rv3us]

@@AmiAki some of their performance are but not This oone

[@하똥-x2c]

아이린은 엔딩 샷에서 예쁘게나 귀엽게 보이려하지 않고 노래에 어울리는 표정을 연기해서 너무 좋음 처음 화제됐던 러시안룰렛 때도 도도한 표정이었고 파워업 때는 밝게 웃고 등등.. 노래 컨셉에 어울림 특히 몬스터 마지막에 노려보는거 진짜 개쩐다고 생각함

[@포도맛마이쮸-o4w]

니 얼굴이 더 쩐다고 생각함

[@lyrical350]

@@포도맛마이쮸-o4w ?ㅋㅋㅋ

[@Queen-ls6lg]

그런데도 듸지게 예쁘다는게 함정

[@송명희-o6w]

@@포도맛마이쮸-o4w 칭찬인가...욕인가...

[@clarasoares7898]

Tendi foi nada mermão

[@FC-ny4jm]

Do you prefer to emphasize more dance or vocals? SEULRENE: yess

[@KitKno]

Boneappletea

[@shasbdo3897]

emphasize*

[@FC-ny4jm]

@@shasbdo3897 thank you, I'll correct it. I'm not english speaker 😅

[@shasbdo3897]

@@FC-ny4jm hi, yeah sure, i'm sorry if I made u uncomfortable in any way but thank u also for taking it positively :)

[@Douyoung96]

저 때의 아이린 슬기 몬스터 뮤비 나오자마자 그냥 좀비처럼 허겁지겁 들으면서 좋아죽었던 거 생각남.. 이 때 활동하면서 아이린의 실력이 이렇게 좋았구나 라고 사람들이 알아줘서 너무 좋았음..🥹🥹 2집도요..수만할버지..

[@bwangtanie138]

People: Are you addicted to something? Me: Yes, I'm a little monster.

[@rizkyyuliana462]

Mom : Bad Boy Dad : Psycho Child : Monster

[@simkungdan1787]

cousin: rbb

[@otakuweeb6604]

Rizky yuliana how can a mom be bad boy!? Boy??? You dumb?

[@Julia-tb6le]

@@otakuweeb6604 woah, chill AHAHHAHA

[@Julia-tb6le]

@@otakuweeb6604 i dunno but the song fits 'mother' , did you listen to the song? Just because it's BAD BOY doesn't mean it has to be a boy.

[@Julia-tb6le]

@@otakuweeb6604 it can just be edited to psycho.

[@abrilchavez7504]

if you liked this song please vote for them on idolchamp and mcountdown :c we're raking #3 (the gap is not that big) on everything and we need more votes to get at least one win pls guys :c they worked hard, irene even went to the hospital bc of herback lets give them all of our support

[@rivinatrisyiva]

how to vote?

[@levantrunglevantrung9901]

Rivina Trisyiva Ayudianie Download Idolchamp and vote

[@devbell4]

@@rivinatrisyiva please help for the voting!! at least we have to get first win for aseul :((( you can check the vote tutorial on twitter, just search key word like "idol champ monster or mcountdown vote" ♡♡♡ if you don't have twitter acc you can search on ur web without login :*

[@nisrinanajlahuwaida3178]

@@devbell4 Thank you for the information. It helps a lot. I will vote asap

[@jesanfaith3567]

Howwww?

[@shubhra8028]

Did anyone notice that Irenes lipstick was pink but when they started dancing it turned red.

[@alegriatabi9966]

Yes when she was seating it was pink

[@cyndixx]

Yeah because it was pre recorded they changed her makeup

[@vilgenea1594]

i'm a blink and after this I think I will stan red velvet

[@luviesxo]

thank you blink

[@tengbanga4007]

who said that irene was a bad singer? Irene:Hold My Rap position Bashers

[@박종우-m5w]

진짜 모르는 사람 많은데 아이린 춤 겁나잘춤ㅠㅠㅠ 슬기가 진짜 잘춰서 모르는사람 많은데 아이린도 겁나잘춤ㅠㅠㅠ

[@ba9792]

춤선이 되게 매력적이라 항상 아이린한테 눈이 가요 ...

[@최은서-o9i]

ㄱㄴㄲ 써사업 같은 노래에서는 아이린이 더 부각됨

[@김지훈-u3l8o]

춤은 솔직히 잘안출려고하더라 ㅋㅋ 얼굴은 진짜이쁘다

[@쟈밍-c8m]

김지훈 근데 잘추는편임ㅇㅇ

[@망개지민-o8i]

저두 슬기만 잘 추는줄 알았는데 이거 몬스터 보고 아이린도 잘 추는구나 했어요ㅋㅋ

[@0321inuuni]

와 나 사실 연기 들어간다길래 걱정 했는데(게임회사는 클립으로 봤는데 그냥 생활연기니까) 마지막 아이린 표정 보고 나도 모르게 와 연기하면 끝내주겠다 생각함....ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ표정 미쳤다.,.. 요며칠 아이돌학교나 프듀 영상 봤는데 너무 과하게 끼부리는 연생들 보다가 걸그룹 탑 센터 표정 보니까 갑자기 마음의 평화가 찾아옴....

[@notigers_nolife]

기획력은 물론 퍼포머 수준 도랐다고 생각,, 스엠 역사에 길이 남을 프로젝트가 될거고 시간 지날 수록 더더욱 재평가 받을 것이 분명함!

[@user-sb8gw6iw7l]

재평가 받아버림!!

[@lifeisreal0000]

성지순례 왔습니다

[@예은-q4w3w]

아 진짜 최고다 너무 예쁘고 진짜 노래 또 오지게 잘 뽑았고 역시 스엠

[@user-dx5kv9dv1r]

봐도봐도 오진다,,,하루에 한번은 봐줘야해 중독이야...

[@pikaapikaa5437]

Overdose

[@상여자-y4n]

@@pikaapikaa5437 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ중독 오벌도스엿지!!!! ㅋㅋㅋ

[@이따두시거기서만날래]

@@pikaapikaa5437 이 댓글 보니깐 다들 한동학 오버도스 뜻이 중독인줄 알았던거 생각난다ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@김도연-j6f8s]

집나간 우리 한국인들 모입시다

[@윈터-x9t]

안녕하세요

[@준며들다대봉둥]

여기에 있습니다

[@무지개떡-g7t]

여기에 있슴다!!!!!🖐🏻🖐🏻

[@웽-p8u]

강슬기 지켜 강슬기 지켜

[@민서이-f9n]

ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@user-hh5eskkdjssk]

ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@Jisuunara]

진짜 우리 슬기언니는 건들지마라 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@user-ty4fj7jg5f]

슬기 웬디 둘이 유닛 내주면 좋겠다

[@oo-xz8tl]

우리 슬기언니 지켜라ㅜㅜㅜ

[@성이름-k2c1f]

노래 계속 들음 놀이랑 몬스터 개좋음 ㄹㅇ...

[@reveluv6424]

ATTENTION ❗️❗️❗️ Let’s watch this performance in this channel not the performance from KBS WORLD They’ll give us points, LETS MAKE THEM WIN!

[@izzybizi2248]

up

[@izzybizi2248]

up

[@izzybizi2248]

up

[@izzybizi2248]

up

[@blezzyrose8824]

Vote on IDOL CHAMP AND MWAVE too!

[@claudia-sd4ce]

No one can compare to Irene... She's stunning 😍

[@lenaryleramos5554]

Irene is like Red Velvet, always has something different to show.

[@Jsmith12345]

Bae Rene Irene personality is the inspiration behind red velvet as a whole. She has a red and a velvet side and she is weird, spontaneous, playful, and creative as a person. That is why she is face and center of the group, she is the muse.

[@이예슬-m4l]

난 사건과 상관옶이 얼음공주 타이틀 가지고 있던 애가 이런 컨셉 완벽하게 소화하는거 보고 좀 멋있다고 생각했엇음ㅜ 무대는 언제봐도 좋다

[@hezelia]

Sigh, SM might not be the better company when it comes to the management of their artists’ welfare (mental etc) but like they do produce a lot of outstanding groups with amazing songs. Idk how to feel about that. But I will support red velvet like I did for girls generation forever.

[@Bellaaa133]

Their live vocal omg! How to be this good while doing a very intense choreography!

[@fchjacksone2248]

Actually it's called Live AR

[@hepburnposts1675]

@@fchjacksone2248 what is that

[@pinkgangsta6157]

@@fchjacksone2248 their real voice still louder than AR

[@makogerald7014]

@@fchjacksone2248 that is live but supported by backtrack

[@makogerald7014]

@@fchjacksone2248 i suggest you watch their all MR removed from YHY sketchbook (almost perfect but some of them strain), and real full performance YHY (become perfect) and there is literally video they singing without Backtrack in festival uni, see by yourself how they sing.

[@sebaaqlo]

Im the only one who thinks this should have been released on October for Halloween??

[@hellobye7697]

They needed to keep Red Velvets name alive as they can’t release anything as a group due to Wendy.

[@Shadowboost]

Red velvet does concepts on their terms, not on mere mortals' holidays

[@aphelionyms]

Every year is Halloween for Red Velvet, what do you mean?

[@ihavenoideabutsure]

Seulrene said halloween is now in july so i can only 🤐 and str3am

[@wahidunsiji5511]

@@Shadowboost agreed. They previously released RBB during Christmas and Umpah Umpah near Halloween... 😂 😂

[@londonbylynden]

어우 둘이 퍼포먼스 너무 멋있네 어우

[@yellowbear1318]

I am so happy for Irene. Everyone's finally seeing she's more than just a visual.

[@kj5379]

Yes 🥺

[@autumn_summer_4316]

yes...im so happy too. She sings well and has such a nice voice. I always enjoy her voice in the b-side tracks of RV.

[@tinecaerbear3580]

❤️❤️❤️

[@notsobright7257]

Shes super talented ♡

[@amya.3174]

Irene looks like 99% of other idols, there is no visual here. So average.

[@헬로우-x8u]

2:26 아 진짜 심장 떨어지는줄 알았네

[@eleannasully3606]

성지순례 왔습니다

[@unifam7086]

It is 2:27

[@징징-s9q]

연말무대 몬스터는 이미지가 쎄서 어렵다면 놀이라도 둘이 같이 하는거 보고싶다....하....곡이 아까워 묵혀두기엔...........하

[@aijeuwonmnda4152]

kbs: so you two should record first- sr: queens don't lipsync *excuse us*

[@memegodsonseungwan329]

This comment is underrated FORREAL

[@Jose-k8t7t]

but,, it's actually pre-record tho

[@onikukamisama3063]

@@Jose-k8t7t yeah they have pre recorded audio but they are singing as well, their live voices is louder than the audio.

[@bruh-ok5ks]

@@Jose-k8t7t you can tell that's live vocals tho because it's loder than pre-recorded backing track...

[@joejoejoe0817]

I think they were not singing live in this stage tho

[@LObita2030]

I don't understand how can to be people that dislike this. They're amazing and this performance is a masterpiece!

[@cozkeyisinnct]

what?!!! imma fight. lol. maybe it not their taste. or they have no taste at all. shrugs.

[@nahidaamalia7494]

Haters gonna hate 😒

[@kaylaadeliapanerusan]

Irene has an elegant and fabulous charisma while Seulgi have an baddas and swag charisma. Seulgi and Irene is look like an queen for different kingdom

[@Usmavie4030]

Irene is so freaking gorgeous but seulgi took me away , she so charming and one of the most beautiful girls i've ever seen

[@tccandler]

The absolute definition of "cool".

[@ryanbrown1607]

TC Candler why do I see you in every video I watch

[@tccandler]

@@ryanbrown1607 Because we have the same taste?

[@anniecortez7071]

Yes, Seulrene domination...

[@johnmharlonlacson3071]

@@tccandler i like your taste! XD

[@coily.hijabii3142]

@@tccandler why was irene ranked so low on the 100 most beautiful faces?

[@gamsungsalaxys2227]

ㅈㄴ 멋있다..

[@굠-k3v]

레드벨벳 완전체 컴백 보고 시퍼~

[@mellmao5087]

not that i was looking for a bad thing to say... there was literally NONE

[@동현-d1v]

비판 이랑 비난,인신공격 구분을 못하는 사람들이 많은거 같아서 아쉽다 정확한 정보만 봐야하는 상황에서 억지로 우기고 짜집기 하면서 이때다 싶어가지고 욕하는거보면 진짜 무섭네 ㅋㅋㅋ;

[@gotaku2]

레드벨벳 노래 좀 듣고 싶은데 언제 컴백할까 싶네 올해 재계약 시즌이라던데

[@user-kn1sr1si2j]

예리조이 피셜 곧!!한답니다

[@수-m1b]

야호무!!

[@gotaku2]

오 굳

[@Djsjfjejdksksk]

정규3집 안무 녹음 다 끝났다고 해요!

[@창백한푸른점하나]

연습 개빡세게 하나봐요 웬디 보면 온몸에 성한곳이 없음ㅠㅜㅠ

[@clscxd2522]

who is doing it like rv? NO ONE

[@arthurmrl]

@Elitist A**hole no mention of live vocals in the comment? Still no one is doing it like RV, period

[@anggyadr]

@Elitist A**hole can you stop? I always see you giving bad comments here

[@user-rl3zx5sz9o]

@Elitist A**hole man stay pressed, no ones doing it like rv period

[@TP-zm6bo]

a lot of groups actually lmao

[@yeppiyj]

@Elitist A**hole but can you sing like them?

[@adhimasgilang482]

Irene the charisma is outta the world she's captivating

[@khanttiks1420]

Love that there's no back track here and just pure RAW vocals. RED VELVET ROCKS, STAN THEM

[@revinavalensia6480]

We need Aseul comeback 💖💛

[@예담-x4p]

아슬 2집 보고싶다

[@user-ql5yd7lg3h]

즈그들도 비판 비난 하나 구분 못하고 악플로 갑질하면서 누가 누구한테 뭐라함?ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 악플 다는 놈들은 돌 던질 자격도 없다

[@바라바라밥바라]

ㄹㅇ 악플다는 사람들이 더 못났음 잘못한거나ㅠ욕하지

[@3412-x8d]

@채연 영웅 심리에 취해서 아이린 욕하면서 자기가 되게 선한 사람인 것처럼 행세하는거 진짜 꼴보기싫더라고요...갑질한 사람이면 당연히 인신공격을 견뎌야하는 것처럼.

[@tellytellyk7329]

비판이 아니라 비난받아야 할 짓해서 비난하는 건데 비판비난 구분하라는 댓이 제일 웃긴 듯

[@차이-x9o]

@@tellytellyk7329 니 댓글 쓴 것만 봐도 답 나옴 ㅋㅋ 비난을 재미로 하는거지 비난은 어떤 의도든 하지 말아야 하는 건데 대가리가 딸려서 모르죠? 지가 하는 짓이 그렇게 까는 아이린이랑 똑같은 걸 모름 ㄹㅇㅋㅋ

[@아름다운이야기-z1e]

@@tellytellyk7329 ???

[@OneofaKynd27]

YES SEULRENE MY QUEENS

[@kiaraisidro7105]

Can't wait for your dance cover/parody of Monster. Lots of love!!

[@lynnk.1741]

I'm ready for a "parody" (It's too good to be a parody)

[@chexmix7043]

Ky27 OMG. I WATCH ALL OF YOUR VIDEOS. BUT YES!!! SEULRENEEEEE

[@구글계정-r1c]

ㅁㅊ 찐이다

[@hoori.]

Fancy seeing you here

[@faithfultoyou]

This is the Main Dancer and Main Rapper of Red Velvet. They sound so stable and good with live vocal performance. They really lack nothing.

[@xcxjjku]

Facts.

[@tokiibun]

this isn't live ..

[@Pamelalrene]

@@tokiibun Yes it is. You can especially hear it in Irene's voice. That is not the same as the recorded version. You can also hear her breathing and popping her consonants into the mic.

[@putragabe8654]

@@tokiibun stupid comments

[@SGEC2010Y1EC]

Pamela Irene As in whether it’s live singing. I can’t say for sure now whether it’s live singing or not, have to compare with other performances. It is very common for artists to record “live vocals” in a studio and play it as a backtrack instead of using the version we listen to on streaming platforms. The best way to judge whether it’s live singing is through comparison of performances of the song from the same time period.

[@wingxxxg-01w8]

무대 진짜 개레전드

[@이시우-o8z]

아무리 내려도 한국인을 찾을수 없었다...

[@이시우-o8z]

엥 나 맞나? ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ당황쓰

[@Autumn.Sun.Eclipse]

Ice Princess....that cold glare. Irene + Seulgi = class and perfection.

[@user-ev2ci3kn6q]

되게 라이브티 많이난다 음악 깔고가는거 아예 없이 부르는거같네 아 됐고 결론은 언니들 사랑한다고요

[@즐거우세요-u3i]

기존 녹음된 라이브본을 깔아 놓은거임 라이브 아님, 실제로 무대에서 라이브반 에이알 반이라해도 송출된 이무대에는 라이브 안들림 결과적으로 라이브인지 아닌지 알 수 없음 예상컨데, 춤이 격렬해서 라이브는 아니라는 추측을 해봄 ~> 2세대 걸그룹(소시/원걸/카라/투에니원) 때의 오리지널 라이브가 너무나도 그리움. 시청자와 관객 그리고 아티스트들 모두가 시원스럽게 오로지 보이스로만 소통된 그때가 그리움... 어쩌다 가요 무대 보컬방식이 이렇게 변화된 것인지 솔직히 답답함 그 이유가 세대가 흐르면서 춤추며 라이브를 잘 할 수 있는 인재가 없는 것인지 음악방송 송출 환경이 바뀐 것인지는 모르는 일...

[@꿈이네-y9p]

라이브 티가 난다는 건 좀 오바인 것 같은뎅.. 저 춤 추면 허벌나게 힘들어벌임.. 여성 기준 체력으로 노래 부르고 저 춤까지 추면 헉헉소리 종내 들릴듯

[@한서희-l7b]

라이브는 라이브인데 보정 들어간 라이브일듯

[@쟈밍-c8m]

펭하 그럼 그때무대 보러가여기 았지말구

[@쟈밍-c8m]

펭하 보컬방식바뀌는건 어쩔수없는거지 그때 방식으로 부르면 또 계속 같은방식으로 부른다고 난리치는 사람도있을거니까 요즘은 그게 너무 심하긴하지만 근데 요즘 아이돌이 전부 춤추며 라이브를 못하진 않음 몇몇은 잘함 대중들은 그냥 못하는애들만 골라서 까기바쁘니까 잘하는 애들이 묻힌거지 애초에 레벨은 라이브 잘하기로 유명한 그룹중하난데 얘네무대에 이런 댓이 달리는게참...ㅋㅋ ar깔아달라고 레벨이 부탁한것도아니고

[@HappyMatt12345]

This is probably the best subunit Red Velvet could have possibly had.

[@wintergarden6079]

내가 에스엠 좋아하는이유: 가수로서 기본기는 다 잡혀있음

[@조영지-o1b]

um...인성이..

[@user-skdkqodkwodkdoeoej]

별로 .... 노래 춤 못하는데 슬기만 잘함 트와이스는 욕먹어도 퍼포먼스를 오지게잘하잖아 블랙핑크는 라이브 잘하고

[@얄루-w8s]

인간으로서의 기본기는 없는듯 ㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎ

[@닉네임미정-g2u]

인성은 빠짐

[@미마미-o9j]

근데 가수로서 기본기 안잡혀있는 소속사도 있나요?ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ삼대는 웬만하면 다 잡혀있는데

[@궁금하다궁금해-g9g]

진짜 레벨 팬이지만 이노래 너무 아까움;

[@밤바라밤바라밤비비리]

역시 스엠 라이브가 더 깔끔하고 좋네

[@ghostfullsun]

개이쁘다 주현언니랑 슬기언니...

[@성이름-b5o3l]

걍 다 정신과 가봐야 할 것 같음 사람 한 명 미워하는 데에 그렇게 자기 시간과 정성을 쏟아낼 가치가 있는 거임? 이런 헛짓거리 하는 데에 시간 쓰지 말고 다른 데에 시간 쓰세요..

[@호그와트4학년학생]

맞는 말

[@김재이-i3x]

ㅇㅈ이요

[@hey-dy1dv]

아이린부터...

[@맥메이]

안무존멋

[@hny-o2c]

노래 솔직히 개좋음

[@악어는브라자를입는다]

지금 남이라서 공감을 못하는거지 내 가족이 갑질을 당했다? 진짜 눈돌아간다 때리고싶을듯 ㄹㅇ

[@정은이-s1k]

주겨버리고싶을거같은데

[@오소리-l3d]

그 기분 아는사람은 절대 쉴드못침

[@서랍속에비툽]

ㅇㅈ 쉴드치는 사람들 내 가족이라고 대입해보셈 상상만으로도 화가 치밀어 오름 이건 절대 쉴드불가임..

[@cant_run]

@@sooamekycat2113 어차피 실력 없어서 그닥..

[@delight_486]

@@user_eakj55 예를 들면? 쟤보단 아닌 것 같아서